What are the most underrated Taylor Swift songs in her entire discography?

In this episode of 13: A Taylor Swift Fan Podcast, Ana and Nick dive album-by-album to pick the most overlooked song from every Taylor Swift era — from debut through The Life of a Showgirl. Using a mix of Spotify streaming data, Swiftie intuition, and personal favorites, they debate which songs deserve way more love from fans and the general public.

Along the way, they discuss the beautiful gems like Stay Beautiful, The Best Day, Haunted, Holy Ground, This Love, Dancing With Our Hands Tied, I Think He Knows, Peace, Cowboy Like Me, Question…?, Dear Reader, and more. Some picks come from pure vibes, while others are backed by hard streaming numbers — and a few results are honestly shocking.

They also explore:

Why some Taylor Swift tracks become fan favorites years later
Songs that Swifties love but the casual listener may have missed
The storytelling brilliance behind underrated tracks like Peace and Cowboy Like Me
Whether streaming numbers actually reflect what fans truly love
And why The Tortured Poets Department might have more hidden gems than any album yet

Plus: thoughts on potential Debut (Taylor’s Version) timing, why reputation ages like fine wine, and the surprisingly stacked lineup of Taylor’s track twos.

Whether you’re a longtime Swiftie or just exploring Taylor Swift’s catalog, this episode will definitely send you back to the playlists to rediscover some incredible songs you may have overlooked.

So pause the episode, make your own list, and let us know:

What’s the most underrated Taylor Swift song on each album?

Stay Connected with 13: A Taylor Swift Fan Podcast

Join the conversation in our exclusive Lobster Lounge: station.page/13

Contact the Podcast

Voicemail: (689) 214-1313

Email: the13podcast@gmail.com

Instagram: @the13podcast

TikTok: @the13podcast

Twitter/X: @the13TSpodcast

YouTube: 13: A Taylor Swift Fan Podcast

Follow the Hosts