The Giants are trying to be smart with Andrew Thomas, Malik Nabers, and Darius Slayton, but every cautious update raises the same problem: this roster may only work if the key pieces are actually available. Joe Schoen’s multi-year extension adds another layer, because now the Giants are betting that better coaching and better health can finally make his roster look different.

Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.

The Big Question: Are the Giants being smart with injury management, or are they already exposing a September problem? The answer is probably both: it is only May, but Andrew Thomas, Malik Nabers, and the offensive line are too important to ignore when the updates start piling up.

Drew and Rob opened the show with the Joe Schoen extension after the Giants announced a multi-year deal for their general manager. Drew questioned the timing and the message after several rough years, player relationship concerns, and the Dexter Lawrence fallout, while Rob pushed back on how much of Schoen’s evaluation has to be tied to the coaching staff he had in place before John Harbaugh arrived. The debate came down to whether this season finally separates Schoen’s roster decisions from Brian Daboll’s coaching issues, or whether the Giants just rewarded a front office that still has not won enough.

The main injury conversation centered on Andrew Thomas. John Harbaugh said the Giants are working Thomas back and managing his reps, while Thomas said the goal is being ready for September. Drew’s concern was not that a veteran is being managed in OTAs; it is that Thomas has an injury history and the entire offensive line changes if he is not right. Rob pushed the “it is May” side of the argument, but both agreed that Marcus Mbow getting left tackle reps matters because the Giants need a real answer if Thomas misses time again.

Malik Nabers became the next big concern after Harbaugh described his ACL recovery as a tough, grinding process and said the Giants will be ready whether he is back right away or not. Drew and Rob debated the mental side of a first major injury, how much training camp or preseason work Nabers should get, and why rushing him back would be a bad gamble even if everyone wants him ready for Week 1. Darius Slayton’s sports hernia surgery, Jalin Hyatt leaving practice early, Roy Robertson-Harris leaving early, and several veterans sitting out added to the larger question of whether the Giants are simply being cautious or already dealing with a real availability issue.

The episode also touched on Andrew Thomas’ comments about Dexter Lawrence moving on, Ar’Darius Washington getting slot work with Dru Phillips out, Harbaugh calling OTAs a “fast rehearsal,” the rookies needing to “hit the gas,” and John Mara being spotted at practice. The tone of the show stayed right where Giants fans are right now: hopeful because the coaching staff feels more serious, but not ready to trust anything until the wins and health actually show up.

Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show