Juju Chang (2:48)

But based on what investigators say Sarah's aunt told police, when Sarah stopped by the house, she found something of value among all that storage. Her aunt told police Sarah was looking through a box of photos of her mother, who had passed away when Sarah was just 15. And she discovered something else in the box. Cash. A lot of cash. According to what her aunt told police, Sarah counted $10,000, but believed there might have been twice as much. There's a lot we're never going to know about this money, like where it all came from or why it was left in a random box in a house used for storage.

Detective Nick Catalona (3:39)

My grandmother used to keep money in the freezer. Anytime she needed any money, she wouldn't go to the bank. She would go in her freezer and get money out of there. So people do things differently. Why she had a little stash of money, who knows?

Juju Chang (3:55)

But answering what Sarah did with this hidden treasure and whether it had anything to do with her disappearance, that is where investigators hungry for a breakthrough in the case of turn their attention. From ABC Audio and 20 20, I'm Juju Chang, and this is bridge of lies. Episode three, box of money. In the days after Sarah's disappearance, Investigators were working with two main theories. The that Sarah had died by suicide or that she had run away to Canada. Police were still exploring both theories, but investigators, including detective Brian weisbrot, Were becoming more and more skeptical that Sarah had jumped off that bridge.

Detective Brian Weisbrot (4:53)

Sarah's family and her close friends, they described her as being her happy, go, lucky self, that she was in good spirits, that she had goals and she had plans and that she had things that she wanted to accomplish in life.

Juju Chang (5:04)

Alex napoliello covered the case for NJ.com and said he got a lot of tips from the community, Saying that Sarah, who was known for her quirky sense of humor and her artistic talent, Just wouldn't end her life.

Detective Nick Catalona (5:19)

I've covered, you know, cases where people

Depop Advertiser (5:22)

jump off bridges in new Jersey.

Detective Nick Catalona (5:24)

However, I had never experienced people coming

Depop Advertiser (5:29)

forward to me saying, this is not

Detective Nick Catalona (5:32)

the Sarah that we know. Someone who would do this, People emailing me, calling me, telling me this is impossible. There's no way she jumped from a bridge.

Juju Chang (5:44)

None of the searches for Sarah along the shark river turned up anything. Not a scarf, not a wallet, not a purse or backpack. Investigators didn't pick up any fingerprints from her car and. And they didn't find anything inside the car Besides some artwork that Disney memorabilia and a small key. Detective Nick catalona also searched the stern's main house in neptune city A few days after police first went through it in the middle of the night looking for Sarah. Catalona needed to Be certain Sarah was not somewhere on the property.

Detective Nick Catalona (6:22)

There was a lot of areas where somebody could have either fallen and got injured and incapacitated or could have been hidden. People tend to kill themselves in the strangest of places. So I searched all the cars on the property, all the buildings, sheds, things like that, the pool area, all the bushes, and there was nothing. The garbage went through the garbage. There was nothing of any interest whatsoever.

Juju Chang (6:55)

Detective Catalona noticed that all of Sarah's belongings seemed to still be in the house.

Detective Nick Catalona (7:02)

All of her clothing, her. You know, like she was very into her art. All that stuff was still there. I just found it odd. Then Belmore Police Department ultimately had her passport. If she's moving to Canada, you would think that she would need that, her Social Security card, things of that nature. So that didn't make sense to me that she was running away.

Juju Chang (7:25)

Why would she run off to Canada without her car, her clothes, her art, and most importantly, her passport and id? To authorities, the theory that she ran away to Canada seemed to make less and less sense. Investigators decided to look into Sarah's bank records. Maybe there was something in her financial history that could explain her disappearance. Detective Catalona said Sarah's records at JPMorgan Chase didn't reveal anything odd. No big purchases or withdrawals in the days leading up to her disappearance. No erratic behavior at all.

Detective Nick Catalona (8:09)

Up until the day she went missing. There was regular activity on her debit card, but then pretty much stopped the day that she went missing and hasn't been any activity since.

Juju Chang (8:23)

But Sarah also had an account at a local branch, Kearney bank in Bradley Beach. Reporter Jessica Easthope said Sarah had good relationships at the bank.

Reporter Jessica Easthope (8:35)

The manager, Raymond Blochess, was a family friend. The bank staff knew her, and. And she had known Raymond since she was born. And so the bank was somewhere she was often found. She would even stop by when she wasn't interacting with her account at all, just to say hi.

Juju Chang (8:55)

As investigators searched for information that could break open this mystery, they received a tip. On the day of Sarah's disappearance, she went to the bank. Investigators learned that in September 2016, just months before she disappeared, Sarah opened a new account at Kearney Bank, a safety deposit box account. According to investigators, a review of her bank records showed she accessed the box three times. Once in September, once in November, and once in December. On the last day she was seen, they got search warrants for her safety deposit box and for surveillance footage from the last time she went to the bank. And that's when they went to the bank to search Sarah's box. The bank kept the safety deposit boxes in a big, shiny metal cabinet. Detective Catalona was there to execute the search warrant.

Detective Nick Catalona (9:58)

The bank has. It's like a two keyed system. So the bank maintains the key and the customer has a key. And the box could only be opened with both keys.

Juju Chang (10:08)

That small gold key that had been found in Sarah's car had the number 35 on it. And it was the matching key for the safety deposit box.

Detective Nick Catalona (10:21)

They inserted their key, I inserted the key that we recovered from Sarah's car, and it unlocked the box.

Juju Chang (10:28)

The long, beige metal box was pulled from the cabinet and set down on a table. Detective Catalona opened it.

Detective Nick Catalona (10:39)

My first thought was, wow, this is a lot of money.

Juju Chang (10:42)

This money wasn't in organized stacks of crisp, clean bills like you see in the movies when someone pulls out a lot of cash.

Detective Nick Catalona (10:51)

This is old, old currency. And it was in a very bad condition. It was, you know, brittle. Some of it was falling apart. Most of them were stuck together. They had a lot of holes in them. These are the old style, smaller portraits. Current currency has the larger portraits on them. It's like when you go to the store and they hand you an old bill. You're like, wow, that's, you know, I haven't seen this in a while. So it's just. It was old, it not widely circulated at all.

Juju Chang (11:19)

Police believe this was the money Sarah found in the Avon by the Sea house, tucked away in a box of photos. And there was far more than $10,000 of it. Double that, actually.

Detective Nick Catalona (11:34)

$25,250 in twenties, fifties, and hundreds.

Juju Chang (11:39)

Catalona noticed that the money was split into a few rough piles.

Detective Nick Catalona (11:45)

There was a yellow mesh bag that had some money in it. And the money seems to have been separated by amounts with index cards. Some of the index cards had the amount of money that was in it. Some of them didn't.

Juju Chang (12:01)

They sent the money away to their evidence vault. They didn't know whether Sarah had taken money out on her last trip to the bank or put money in. All they knew was that she made this trip just before 3pm on the day of her disappearance. In the surveillance footage from the bank, you can see Sarah is wearing a puffer jacket and glasses. Her hair's in a messy bun. She's dressed for a casual day with a friend, getting lunch, running some errands. As she leaves the bank, she waves and says goodbye to the bank manager, who's a close family friend. She's smiling and you can see her dimples. Even in the grainy footage, the she doesn't look stressed or tense. She looks like someone who's seen some friendly faces and made another ordinary stop at a bank she's been coming to for years. But this trip was not ordinary. This surveillance footage is the last clear recording showing Sarah's face before she vanished into the night. Sarah turns around, walks through French double doors in the lobby and leaves. Another camera shows her exiting through glass doors into the parking lot. She was a 19 year old walking, seemingly carefree, out of a bank where she had over $25,000 in cash hidden away.

Detective Brian Weisbrot (13:38)

The first thing that went through my mind is that Sarah did not run away because if she was going to leave, she certainly would have taken her money with her.

Juju Chang (13:47)

Based on police interviews, it seems that not many people knew about Sarah's safety deposit box. Her dad, Michael, says he didn't. According to investigators, he told police he didn't even know Sarah had found money in the Avon by the Sea house in the first place. Sarah's aunt, her dad's sister, did know about the money. So did some of her friends, based on what investigators say they told them. Friends like her neighbor Carly and her friend Liam. Detective Brian Weisbrot said finding out about Sarah's trip to Carney bank marked a big turn in the investigation.

Detective Brian Weisbrot (14:32)

Especially when we took into account that Liam had failed to tell us that he had gone to the bank with Sarah.

Juju Chang (14:38)

Liam McAtasney Liam had told police about going to Taco Bell and playing video games with Sarah. Investigators knew from the time stamped bank surveillance video that Sarah had gone to the bank right after Taco Bell when she would have still been with Liam. Did Liam know more than he was letting on? Was Sarah's friend going all the way back to first grade hiding something? This show is sponsored by Quince. A thoughtfully built wardrobe is all about pieces that mix well and last. That's where Quince shines. Premium fabrics, thought thoughtful design and everyday essentials. Their pieces are effortless and dependable even as the seasons change from the short sleeve Mongolian cashmere polos to the linen pants and shorts. Their pieces are designed to stay crisp and comfortable season after season. And Quince works directly with top factories so you're not paying for any markup or middlemen or fancy retail stores. It's all just quality clothes no matter where you are. Whether it's already warm enough that it feels like summer or it's still a bit chilly and damp like like it is here in New York. Quince has the pieces you'll need for the perfect spring wardrobe right now, go to quince.com bridgeoflies for free shipping and 365 day returns. That's a full year to build your wardrobe and love it and you will now available in Canada too. Don't keep settling for clothes that don't last, go to Q-U-I-N-C-E.com BridgeOfLies for free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com BridgeOfLies 2020 is partnering with Vibes

Vybz Headphones Advertiser (16:28)

open ear wireless headphones. That's Vybz. If you listen to a lot of True Crime, you probably like to listen with a good pair of headphones. But it can be tricky to find a pair that provides great sound quality that's not too immersive because when you're out with a podcast during a late night dog walk or a pre dawn run, you don't necessarily want noise cancellation that blocks out the sounds around you. That's why you want to get yourself a pair of Vibes, your perfect companion in audio. They're designed for maximum comfort with ultra lightweight earbuds that just sit outside the ear canal and they offer crystal clear audio no matter what you're listening to. Whether it's your favorite song or a sound rich True crime podcast, it'll come across loud and clear and silky smooth. The battery lasts up to 10 hours per charge and they come in a range of sleek, modern colors and styles. So what are you waiting for? Order now and you'll be listening to better sound with better headphones before you know it. For a limited time, our listeners can get more than 60% off a pair of Vibes wireless headphones. Just go to ABCsecretsavings.com 2020Again, that's ABCsecretsavings.com2020 abcsecretsavings.com 2020Your little one grew three inches overnight.

Depop Advertiser (17:38)

Adorable. Also expensive. Sell their pint sized pieces on Depop and list them in minutes with no selling fees because somewhere a dad refuses to pay full price for the clothes his kids will outgrow tomorrow and he's ready to buy your son's entire wardrobe right now. Consider your future growth bird budget secured and start selling on Depop where taste recognizes taste. Payment processing fees and boosting fees still apply. See website for details.

Juju Chang (18:09)

By December 6, 2016, police officers had spoken with Liam McAtasney multiple times. Now he was being brought in for a more formal interview at the police station.

Detective Ryan (18:22)

The detective from the county's gonna come in and talk to you. You haven't met him yet.

Juju Chang (18:27)

So at this point, Detective Brian Weisbrot had just joined the investigation. Weisbrot has a very calm, matter of fact demeanor.

Detective Brian Weisbrot (18:37)

I wanted to be able to introduce myself to him and also speak to him directly. In an effort to find Sarah, Liam

Juju Chang (18:43)

and the officer sit in plastic chairs at a long rectangular table. The camera is pointed down right at Liam. He's wearing a blue plaid shirt and has his arms crossed on the table. He's leaning forward in his chair. He's looking down at the table rather than up at the officers or at the camera. And you can see the wavy blonde hair on the top of his head. The officers are sitting across from him.

Detective Ryan (19:11)

Yeah. I'm Ryan. I'm a detective with the prosecutor's office. Nice to meet you.

Juju Chang (19:16)

Investigators are curious as to why Liam hasn't mentioned the bank, but they don't ask him about it right away. They go through a long list of other questions. First, like what he's studying at the local community college.

Detective Ryan (19:32)

Psychology. I want to pursue some kind of career in law enforcement.

Juju Chang (19:37)

How long he's known Sarah, first grade, and how close they are, I would

Detective Ryan (19:42)

say we're pretty close friends. I'm a lifeguard in Bradley Beach. She was a bad checker, so I saw her pretty much every day over the summer.

Juju Chang (19:50)

Weisbrot asks Liam to go over the day of Sarah's disappearance one more time. Liam says he slept in till noon. Then between one and two, he met up with Sarah and helped her move bins to her neighbor's house. After that, he says, they went to Taco Bell together and brought food back to Sarah's house, where they played video games until Liam left for his job as a waiter at Brennan's Steakhouse. That was it. Again, no mention of visiting the bank. Weisbrot wants to know if Sara asked Liam to help keep any secrets.

Detective Ryan (20:30)

Did you make any promises to her? No, definitely not. You wouldn't tell anybody anything? No.

Juju Chang (20:39)

Liam pauses for a while and then, without prompting, leads investigators back to a familiar theory that Sarah was in emotional distress and ran away to start a new life with her YouTube friends in Canada.

Detective Ryan (20:54)

I had spoken about going to Canada with her over the past few weeks, but that was just kind of her emotional support, I guess. I didn't think she would actually go through with it. I thought this whole Canada thing was just trying to escape the situation she was in, I guess, with her dad.

Juju Chang (21:20)

Detective Weisbrot urges Liam to think carefully. Did Sarah say something that suggested she might be in Canada.

Detective Ryan (21:30)

If she told you something, if she told you that she was going somewhere, she told you that she was going to do something, you need to tell us. Yeah. Okay.

Juju Chang (21:42)

For the whole interview, Liam is looking at the table, only raising his head once in a while to make eye contact with the officers. He's nodding a lot as he speaks and uncrossing his arms occasionally to emphasize a point with a hand gesture. He does this during what he says next. It's a question that comes out of the blue.

Detective Ryan (22:06)

One thing I want to talk to you guys about was she did jump off the bridge. What are the odds that she's not somewhere all the way out in the ocean by now?

Detective Brian Weisbrot (22:26)

I found the question very odd. I would have expected him to ask us questions like what are we doing to find her? What efforts have we made? Who assisting? Who's helping? Liam didn't ask any of those questions.

Juju Chang (22:43)

Detective Weisbrot pushes Liam on what he just asked about the possibility of Sarah's body being carried away by the Shark river current a few hundred yards out to the Atlantic Ocean.

Detective Ryan (22:57)

And did she tell you she was going to jump off the bridge? No. If she had told me that she was going to jump off a bridge, there would have been no way that I could have gone to work that night.

Juju Chang (23:11)

Liam says he had a great night, a great work shift.

Detective Ryan (23:15)

I made a bunch of money, all my tables were good. I had a great time. It definitely I would not have been able to do that if I did something new. Peter sang Tight right here. We're just gonna set that. Thanks. No problem.

Juju Chang (23:36)

The investigators step outside for 10 minutes and Liam sits in the room alone. When they come back in, Detective Weisbrot will get to the thing that they really want to ask. What about the bank?

Vybz Headphones Advertiser (23:56)

Life is full of choices. But the choice between getting crispy chicken nuggets or a crunchwrap slider isn't one you'll have to make. The new crispy Chicken Crunchwrap Slider at Taco Bell. All white meat chicken nuggets breaded in tortilla chips, wrapped up sauce and all inside a slider sized crunch wrap. Choose from creamy chipotle or jalapeno honey mustard. Well, here we go. Life still full of choices. The new crispy choice Chicken crunchwrap slider. A brand new classic only a Taco Bell and participating in those Taco Bell locations for a limited time and while supplies last.

Depop Advertiser (24:26)

CRM was supposed to improve customer relationships. Instead it's shorthand for customer rage machine. Your CRM can't explain why a customer's package took five detours. Reboot your inner peace and scream into a pillow. It's okay. On the ServiceNow AI platform, CRM stands for something better. AI agents don't just track issues, they resolve them, transforming the entire customer experience. So breathe in and breathe out. Bad CRM was then. This is ServiceNow. We have the tech to get food delivered in 15 minutes. But we all have horror stories about buying tickets. The GameTime app gives fans the advantage. Get amazing tickets in just a few taps. Fees are included, so what you see is what you pay. And the gametime guarantee means authentic tickets at the best price every time. Take the guesswork out of buying tickets to concerts, sports, comedy, and more with GameTime. Download the GameTime app and create an account for $20 off your first purchase term supply.

Juju Chang (25:28)

When Detective Weisbrot and another investigator sit back down, Weisbrot immediately brings up the bank.

Detective Ryan (25:36)

You haven't told us about the bank.

Juju Chang (25:39)

Yeah, Liam says he told the other detective in the room about the bank during. During an unrecorded interview at his house. The other detective doesn't react to this, doesn't confirm or deny that Liam ever mentioned the bank to him. But none of the detectives working on the case documented or even remembered Liam ever bringing up the bank in any of their multiple interviews with him.

Detective Ryan (26:04)

Did you go to the bank? I was with her. Okay. That's the way back from Taco Bell. And what'd she do with the bank? No idea. Him going.

Juju Chang (26:12)

Liam says he stayed in the car.

Detective Ryan (26:15)

Why did she stop at the bank? What did she tell you? She was stopped at the bank? Something to do with her money? I don't know. She had found money in the Avon house a few months ago, and she has a lockbox full of money in there? I don't know. She was taking money out, putting money in there.

Juju Chang (26:35)

Liam tells detectives it was her mother's money. And according to him, Sarah thought it could be up to 100 grand in cash.

Detective Ryan (26:44)

She wasn't sure how much money she found? Yeah. Now, does that make sense to you, that you wouldn't be sure how much money you found? Well, she told me the condition.

Juju Chang (26:51)

Even as Weisbrot pushes Liam, Liam stays calm and he doesn't clam up. He keeps responding to the detective's questions. It seems like he's trying to be helpful, offering whatever information he can.

Detective Ryan (27:09)

Well, she told me the condition of the money was pretty bad, like it was all stuck together. It was old. Old bills. So that could have been A reason for not knowing. Did you ever see it? No.

Juju Chang (27:25)

After ticking through some more questions about the day of Sarah's disappearance, Detective weisbrot return returns to the bank. It seems to really bother the calm detective that Liam left out this crucial detail from the day his friend went missing and now says he doesn't know much about it.

Detective Ryan (27:45)

Just hear me out. It just doesn't make sense that you would do all these things, stop at the bank so she could take care of her money and that you ask no questions. She doesn't. You don't inquire about anything. She doesn't share anything with you.

Juju Chang (28:06)

Liam says he isn't sure what more Sarah could have told him what she's

Detective Ryan (28:12)

doing at the bank. I mean, if I was in the car here, I gotta stop at the ATM to grab cash. Well, she was. I gotta deposit it. Yes. It's like I have to stop by the bank. That's all it was to it. It's like, all right, stay in the car. Stay in the car. Watched a YouTube video or something. And then we were at her house.

Juju Chang (28:31)

About an hour and a half into the interview, the officers leave the room again. Liam sits alone for about 30 minutes before they come back in and tell him that his parents have contacted attorneys on his behalf.

Detective Ryan (28:47)

We're not going to talk to you anymore further today. We do appreciate you coming down.

Detective Brian Weisbrot (28:52)

The interview ends. Ultimately, after approximately two hours of us gathering information from him, Something was not right. There was nothing at that point pointing in the direction that someone had hurt Sarah. Yet at the same time, I wasn't satisfied that something didn't happen to her.

Juju Chang (29:11)

For the first few weeks of the investigation, Police had been working with two theories on this case. But by mid December, reporter Jessica easthope said a third theory was suddenly emerging.

Reporter Jessica Easthope (29:25)

Police start to believe that something violent happened to Sarah. But one of the biggest questions is why? When investigators find out about the sum of money that Sarah came into, they start to think that this could be a possible motive.

Juju Chang (29:41)

Could someone have targeted Sarah for her money? In the minds of detectives, could Sarah's case more from missing person to murder? Liam was one of the few people who knew about Sarah's money, and investigators felt something was off about his story. But all they had was suspicion. They had no evidence that Liam had anything to do with Sarah's disappearance.

Reporter Jessica Easthope (30:09)

The case doesn't go cold, but it moves in that direction.

Juju Chang (30:14)

Investigators were still searching for Sarah, the promising artist whose life had only just begun. Missing posters featured photos of her and listed a $5,000 reward. Police were getting tips from all over California, Florida and Canada. People called in to say they thought they had spotted Sarah somewhere.

Detective Nick Catalona (30:35)

There was not one lead that came in that they wouldn't check.

Juju Chang (30:40)

Michael Stern said one of the YouTubers his daughter liked posted a video asking for help finding Sarah. It went viral.

Detective Nick Catalona (30:49)

There was 167,000 views on that. That was within a day.

Juju Chang (30:56)

But none of these efforts led to any answers. For weeks, Detective Weisbrot continued investigating, and her dad Michael, stayed involved in the case, too.

Detective Brian Weisbrot (31:07)

I tried to talk to Michael Stern every day or every other day, if not every day. Michael Stern was not sitting by without checking in with law enforcement and demanding to know what we were doing.

Juju Chang (31:25)

December passed. A new year started and the case was still stalled.

Detective Nick Catalona (31:34)

It's horrible. It's a sense of hopelessness when you don't. You just. You have no idea. Sarah's my only child and you know, that's a. It's a. It's a hard feeling that we couldn't find her.

Reporter Jessica Easthope (31:54)

It's weeks and weeks before police come in contact with the person who is going to break this case open

Juju Chang (32:04)

in the dead of winter. A month and a half after Sarah went missing, investigators finally got a tip that seemed like a breakthrough. It didn't come from another state or country. It came from within Sarah's community, from someone who went to school with Sarah and Liam. Pursuing this lead would require a dangerous undercover sting operation and a high stakes gamble between two friends.

Detective Nick Catalona (32:35)

The cops haven't questioned me.

Detective Ryan (32:36)

I know you. I know you're not a rat. But we gotta. We gotta play it safe, bro.

Juju Chang (32:41)

This is like movie. Bridge of Lies is a production of ABC Audio and 2020, hosted by me, Juju Chang. Produced by Camille Peterson and Sabrina Fang. Fact checking and production help from Audrey Mostek and Annalisa Linder. Tracy Samuelson is our story editor. Our supervising producer is Sasha Aslanian. Music and mixing by Evan Biola. Special thanks to Katie Dendos, Janice Johnston, Joseph Diaz, Avery Brooke and Michelle Margulis. Josh Cohan is our director of podcast programming. Eamon McNiff is our executive producer.

Depop Advertiser (33:41)

Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile with a message for everyone paying Big Wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop with Mint. You can get premium wireless for just $15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments. But that's weird. Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try@mintmobile.com switch.

Juju Chang (34:02)

Upfront payment of $45 for 3 month plan equivalent to $15 per month. Required intro rate. First 3 months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at Mintmobile. Do.

Detective Ryan (34:11)

Where is Daredevil?

Detective Nick Catalona (34:14)

I'm right here.

Detective Ryan (34:15)

Don't miss the return of Marvel Television's Daredevil Born Again.

Juju Chang (34:19)

So what's next? I feel liberated.

Detective Ryan (34:22)

We're gonna take this city back over medicated in an all new season. Now streaming only on Disney plus.

Juju Chang (34:28)

They're hunting us. It's time we started hunting them.

Detective Ryan (34:32)

I can work with them.

Juju Chang (34:35)

This should be tons of fun.

Detective Ryan (34:36)

Marvel Television's Daredevil Born Again now streaming only on Disney.