20/20 Podcast Summary: "Fire and Vice"
Introduction to the Case
The "Fire and Vice" episode of ABC News' 20/20 delves into the harrowing true crime story surrounding the tragic murder of Robbie Doer, a respected firefighter from Evansville, Indiana. This detailed exploration covers the intricate investigation, the tangled relationships involved, and the eventual legal proceedings that sought justice for Robbie's untimely death.
The Murder of Robbie Doer
On a fateful evening, Robbie Doer was brutally gunned down in his own driveway. The incident unfolded under mysterious circumstances, leaving his family and community in shock.
- Timestamp [00:00 – 05:00]:
- Descriptive Scene Setting: "Robbie Doerr pulls into this driveway, he's ambushed and gunned down."
- Immediate Aftermath: "Get the med kit. He's still got a pulse." The raw body camera footage vividly captures the chaos and the swift response of Robbie's fellow firefighters arriving at the scene.
Investigation Unfolds
Evansville police swiftly launched an investigation into Robbie's murder, grappling with limited initial leads and a seemingly random act of violence.
- Timestamp [05:00 – 15:00]:
- Family's Grief and Initial Clues: Robbie's wife, Elizabeth "Becky" Fox Doerr, and their children grapple with the loss. Police begin canvassing the area and interviewing witnesses.
- Quote: Becky expresses her confusion and fear, stating, "I didn't have any enemies. He's a fighter. Fighter? He's a recluse."
Connections to Larry Richmond Sr. and Jr.
The investigation takes a significant turn when connections to Larry Richmond Sr., a previously convicted murderer recently released from prison, emerge. His son, Larry Richmond Jr., also becomes a person of interest due to his association with a stolen Taurus Judge revolver—the suspected weapon used in Robbie's murder.
- Timestamp [15:00 – 30:00]:
- Introduction of Larry Richmond Sr.: "Larry Richmond Sr. was convicted of murder over 20 years ago and released in 2018."
- Weapon Connection: "A Taurus Judge revolver possibly had been used to shoot and kill Robbie Doer," linking to a firearm stolen from a nearby pawn shop where Larry Jr. worked.
Interrogations and Arrests
As suspicions heighten, Becky Doerr becomes a primary focus due to her deleted phone call with Larry Sr. shortly before the murder. This leads to her arrest on obstruction of justice charges.
- Timestamp [30:00 – 45:00]:
- Becky's Suspicious Behavior: "They knew that just after 7:00 tonight they had several calls come in reporting shots fired."
- Quote: Police interrogate Becky, stating, "When you get arrested, you're gonna say, no, I want the lawyer."
- Arrest Details: Becky is taken into custody after deleting a critical phone call, which raises further suspicions about her involvement.
Discovery of Evidence
Further investigation uncovers incriminating evidence, including a nine-page letter from Robbie to Becky expressing concerns about their relationship. Additionally, surveillance footage and forensic evidence begin to piece together Larry Richmond Sr.'s possible involvement.
- Timestamp [45:00 – 60:00]:
- Evidence Linking Larry Sr.: "Surveillance footage of Larry Sr. walking to the backyard, allegedly carrying this tote bag full of guns."
- Important Discoveries: Becky’s habit of deleting phone calls, including one from Larry Sr., becomes a pivotal point in the case.
Trial and Conviction
The legal battle intensifies as both Becky Doerr and Larry Richmond Sr. face charges. The trial garners significant public attention, especially with courtroom cameras broadcasting the proceedings.
- Timestamp [60:00 – 80:00]:
- Courtroom Dynamics: "This is the first case I've tried as the elected prosecutor," highlights the high stakes involved.
- Key Testimonies: Larry Richmond Jr. testifies about witnessing Larry Sr. interacting with Becky, suggesting a possible affair.
- Quote: Becky maintains her innocence, asserting, "I didn't have an affair," while the prosecution pushes forward with their conspiracy to murder theory.
Verdict and Aftermath
After a tense deliberation, the jury finds Becky guilty of murder and conspiracy to commit murder, sentencing her to 90 years in prison. Larry Richmond Sr. also faces separate convictions related to weapons charges.
- Timestamp [80:00 – 100:00]:
- Emotional Reactions: Robbie’s family members express their sorrow and sense of betrayal. "It did," says Becky during sentencing, reflecting on the life sentence she received.
- Community Impact: The Evansville Fire Department honors Robbie's legacy, cementing his memory within the community.
Remaining Questions and Conclusion
Despite the convictions, uncertainties linger regarding the full extent of the conspiracy and the true motives behind Robbie's murder. The case underscores the complexities of intertwined personal relationships and the relentless pursuit of justice.
- Final Reflections:
- Unanswered Mysteries: "There is something missing," a family member notes, hinting at possible unresolved aspects of the case.
- Long-Term Impact: The families involved continue to grapple with the emotional toll, highlighting the enduring scars of such a tragedy.
Notable Quotes:
- Becky Doerr: "I didn't want to think that I was having an affair with him because I have not had an affair." [13:30]
- Detective: "We need to get out there and do something else. But, you know, I'm thinking they gotta touch all bases." [25:45]
- Robbie's Son Nathan: "If you were to learn that your mom had no financial interest as a result of Robbie's death, would that surprise you?" [85:10]
- Prosecutor: "If we lose this case, your career is over." [90:00]
- Defense Lawyer: "Nothing in that conversation had anything to do with hurting anybody." [70:00]
Conclusion
"Fire and Vice" presents a compelling narrative of loss, betrayal, and the quest for truth. Through meticulous storytelling and emotional interviews, 20/20 captures the devastating impact of Robbie Doer’s murder on his family and community, while unraveling the complex web of relationships and motives that led to this tragic event.