Podcast Summary: 20/20 – "Since You've Been Gone (Rebroadcast)"
Introduction In the rebroadcast episode titled "Since You've Been Gone," ABC News' 20/20 delves deep into the unresolved disappearance of Alyssa Marie Turney, a 17-year-old girl who vanished on May 17, 2001. This heart-wrenching true crime story uncovers layers of family dynamics, law enforcement investigations, and shocking revelations that span over two decades.
Background and Disappearance On May 17, 2001, Alyssa Turney was last seen leaving Paradise Valley High School with her stepfather, Michael Turney, a former sheriff's deputy. Contrary to typical runaway cases, Alyssa left behind her cell phone and most personal belongings, indicating a more ominous situation.
- Quote: “What teenager planning to run away would ever leave their cell phone behind?” – Detective William Anderson [15:30]
A handwritten note was found on Alyssa's dresser stating her intention to move to California, sparking initial thoughts of a planned escape from her strict household.
Family Dynamics and Estrangement Alyssa grew up in a blended family where her mother, Barbara Farner, had passed away when Alyssa was nine. Michael Turney, her stepfather, was known to be highly controlling and protective, often clashing with Alyssa over her desire for independence.
- Quote: “As long as you're under my roof, we're going to have to check in with Daddy because Daddy's a nervous wreck if you don't.” – Michael Turney [12:45]
Friends and family noted a shift in Alyssa's behavior leading up to her disappearance, with increased tensions at home fueling her desire to leave.
Initial Investigation and Media Involvement The Phoenix Police Department treated Alyssa's case as a standard runaway incident, which contributed to the initial lack of urgency. Michael Turney took proactive steps, including media campaigns and involving prominent figures like NASCAR drivers to garner attention.
- Quote: “Dad's doing what he said he was going to do. He's reaching out as far as he possibly can.” – Alyssa's Brother, James Turney [25:10]
Despite these efforts, Alyssa was never found, and months turned into years with no leads.
Breakthrough and Suspect Identification In 2006, convicted murderer Thomas Hymer confessed to multiple killings, including Alyssa's. However, discrepancies in his accounts led detectives to doubt his credibility. This false confession shifted focus back to Michael Turney, especially after media investigations revealed disturbing elements of his household.
- Quote: “He said he was a serial killer. Stop.” – Detective Stuart Summershoe [38:50]
Michael Turney's Dark Secrets Further investigation unearthed alarming evidence in Michael Turney's home, including multiple surveillance cameras, improvised explosive devices, and a manifesto detailing plans to attack a union hall. These discoveries painted a darker picture of Turney's potential motives and capabilities.
- Quote: “Most of it was for security. Looking back, the camera inside wasn’t for safety.” – Detective William Anderson [50:25]
The Trial and Legal Proceedings After serving ten years for federal weapons charges, Michael Turney was indicted for the second-degree murder of Alyssa Turney. The trial, filled with emotional testimonies and circumstantial evidence, culminated in an unprecedented courtroom twist.
- Quote: “This is the insanity of this state.” – Michael Turney [1:25:40]
In a shocking turn of events, the judge granted a Rule 20 judgment of acquittal, effectively dismissing the case without it going to the jury. This decision left the family devastated and the mystery unresolved.
Family's Struggle and Continued Advocacy Alyssa's siblings, particularly her younger sister Sarah, refused to accept the acquittal. They launched their own advocacy efforts, including podcasts and social media campaigns, to keep Alyssa's case in the public eye and pressure authorities for further investigation.
- Quote: “There was no justice in this case.” – Sarah Turney [2:10:15]
Conclusion Nearly two decades after Alyssa Turney's disappearance, her family remains haunted by the lack of closure. The case highlights significant challenges in missing persons investigations, especially when significant evidence like a body is absent. Despite legal setbacks, the Turney family continues to seek answers, embodying unwavering hope amidst lingering questions.
- Quote: “Since 2001, we've been looking for Alyssa. We're not done yet.” – John Quinones, Investigator [2:30:50]
Final Thoughts "Since You've Been Gone" serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities surrounding missing persons cases and the profound impact they have on families. It underscores the necessity for thorough investigative processes and the relentless pursuit of truth and justice.