Podcast Summary: "48 Hours" Episode - "A Cop Behind Bars"
Introduction
In the gripping episode titled "A Cop Behind Bars," CBS News' "48 Hours" delves deep into the harrowing case of Patrick Bradford, a once-revered police officer in Evansville, Indiana, who was convicted of murdering his girlfriend, Tammy Lohr. Released on November 7, 2024, this episode meticulously examines the events leading to Bradford's conviction, the investigation's integrity, and the ongoing fight by his family and friends to exonerate him.
Background: Patrick Bradford’s Heroic Beginnings
Patrick Bradford was the epitome of a dedicated police officer. From a young age, he aspired to be a hero, a sentiment he carried into his professional life. As a respected member of the Evansville Police Department, Bradford was known for his bravery and commitment to saving lives.
Patrick Bradford (Timestamp: 02:15): "All my dreams as a kid had to do with being a hero, rushing in and saving the day."
His exceptional skills were evident early on. In June 1990, a local TV crew captured Bradford saving a man from committing suicide, highlighting his heroic nature.
Patrick Bradford (Timestamp: 04:30): "I had a lot of respect for him. I really believe that Patrick felt the same way."
The Crime: Tammy Lohr’s Tragic Murder
Tammy Lohr, a 24-year-old civilian jailer, was brutally murdered in her home. She sustained 21 stab wounds to her back, neck, and face, and her body was set ablaze with gasoline. The crime scene was gruesome, with Tammy's dog also found stabbed to death.
Tammy’s Parents (Timestamp: 07:45): "I think they got the right person. Yes, he's the right person and he is in the right place."
Initial Investigation: Rising Suspicion on Bradford
On the night of August 1, 1992, Bradford visited Tammy’s house on his way to work. Upon discovering the fire, he entered the house to find Tammy but ultimately retreated, calling for help. Despite his initial portrayal as a hero at the scene, lines of suspicion quickly emerged.
Detective Guy Minnis (Timestamp: 13:50): "I just have a hard time believing that Evansville city police officer would stab his girlfriend to death, kill the dog, set the house on fire."
Fire investigator Jesse Story was instrumental in pointing suspicion towards Bradford, noting the fire's rapid extinguishment and the impossibility of another party committing the crime within the narrow timeframe.
Fire Investigator Jesse Story (Timestamp: 17:20): "The fire burned less than 10 minutes, start to finish. Therefore, if Patrick Bradford didn't do this, he could tell us who did."
Evidence Against Bradford: A Case of Circumstantial Proof
Several pieces of evidence were stacked against Bradford:
-
Timing Discrepancy: A security camera recorded Bradford’s car arriving at Tammy’s house just 65 seconds before he called for help, insufficient time to commit the murder and set the fire.
Detective Guy Minnis (Timestamp: 21:10): "I thought that, you know, there's no way at that time that he could do all his stuff in 65 seconds."
-
Polygraph Test: Bradford failed a second polygraph test, which further convinced investigators of his guilt.
Detective Guy Minnis (Timestamp: 25:40): "I was going through some pretty frightened emotions there. This was the first interview that was hostile or adversarial."
-
Staged Break-In: Crime scene investigator Mike Ford identified that the break-in appeared staged to mislead investigators.
Mike Ford (Timestamp: 29:15): "He wanted to make it look like a burglar came in to commit this crime."
Despite these points, physical evidence such as DNA or the murder weapon was conspicuously absent.
The Trial: A Conviction Sealed by Circumstantial Evidence
Patrick Bradford's trial began ten months after Tammy's murder. The prosecution painted him as a man who had "snapped," with motives centered around his affair with Tammy and the strain it placed on his family life.
Prosecutor Stan Lefkoe (Timestamp: 38:00): "I was looking for just that extra piece, and we finally got it."
Bradford's demeanor in court was described as "cocky and arrogant," leading to a disastrous performance under cross-examination that may have influenced the jury's perception.
Patrick Bradford (Timestamp: 42:30): "I think I probably came off terribly. It may have cost me his freedom."
After 18 hours of deliberation, the jury found Bradford guilty, sentencing him to 80 years in prison.
Jury Verdict (Timestamp: 44:15): "Guilty."
Post-Trial: The Fight for Exoneration
Nine years after his conviction, Patrick Bradford remains behind bars, with his family and friends steadfast in their belief in his innocence. Deborah Nolan, Bradford’s childhood friend, left her teaching career to study law, dedicating her life to overturning his conviction.
Deborah Nolan (Timestamp: 51:20): "I believe that had I been allowed to testify at the original trial, that Patrick would not have been convicted."
New evidence has come to light, including discrepancies in the fire’s duration and alternative suspect Vincent Jr., who was initially dismissed by investigators.
Deborah Nolan (Timestamp: 55:40): "We have an affidavit by him signed saying, my brother never showed up that night at my birthday."
Current Status: Ongoing Efforts and Contrasting Views
Despite repeated appeals and new investigations, the courts have yet to overturn Bradford's conviction. Prosecutor Stan Lefkoe maintains that the case against Bradford is closed, acknowledging the emotional toll it has taken.
Prosecutor Stan Lefkoe (Timestamp: 1:05:00): "If they had had a really good fire expert, it could have made a difference in the sense that it could have been a more difficult case for a jury."
Detective Guy Minnis, who led the original investigation, continues to assert Bradford’s guilt, although he expresses lingering sympathy for his former colleague.
Detective Guy Minnis (Timestamp: 1:10:30): "There was still a part of me that felt sorry for Patrick."
Conclusion: A Case Steeped in Doubt and Determination
"A Cop Behind Bars" presents a compelling narrative of a man who was once a symbol of law enforcement bravery but now languishes in prison under questionable circumstances. The episode underscores the profound impact of circumstantial evidence, the challenges of wrongful convictions, and the relentless pursuit of justice by those who refuse to accept a flawed verdict. As Deborah Nolan and Patrick Bradford's family continue their fight, the case serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities inherent in the criminal justice system.
Notable Quotes
- Patrick Bradford: "All my dreams as a kid had to do with being a hero, rushing in and saving the day." (02:15)
- Detective Guy Minnis: "I just have a hard time believing that Evansville city police officer would stab his girlfriend to death, kill the dog, set the house on fire." (13:50)
- Deborah Nolan: "I believe that had I been allowed to testify at the original trial, that Patrick would not have been convicted." (51:20)
- Prosecutor Stan Lefkoe: "If they had had a really good fire expert, it could have made a difference in the sense that it could have been a more difficult case for a jury." (1:05:00)
Final Thoughts
This episode of "48 Hours" masterfully navigates the intricate details of Patrick Bradford's case, balancing testimonies, expert opinions, and emotional narratives to provide listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the events that led to his incarceration and the ongoing quest for justice. Whether you're a true crime aficionado or new to the story, "A Cop Behind Bars" offers a thought-provoking exploration of truth, evidence, and the human spirit's resilience.