Loading summary
Transcript94 lines
- [00:00]
Stitch Fix Advertiser
Stitch Fix Shopping is hard. Let's talk about it.
- [00:03]
Defense Attorney Wendy Lewis
I don't have time to shop for clothes.
- [00:06]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
I have to buy everything in three sizes to find one that fits. They know me at the post office.
- [00:11]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
Workout wear is my only wear.
- [00:12]
Stitch Fix Advertiser
Stitch Fix makes shopping easy. Just show your size, style and budget and your stylist sends personalized looks right to your door. No subscription required, plus free shipping and returns.
- [00:22]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
Oh wow, that was easy.
- [00:24]
Stitch Fix Advertiser
Stitch Fix Online Personal styling for everyone. Take your style quiz today@stitchfix.com
- [00:33]
Court Clerk / Judge
we the jury unanimously find that the defendant, Corey Richins, is guilty of aggravated murder.
- [00:42]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
There is a verdict in the trial of Utah children's book author Corey Richins, who had been charged with murder and attempted murder of her husband Eric in 2022, along with insurance fraud and forgery. Corey Richards was found guilty on all five counts. As Eric's sisters and father watched emotionally and reacted emotionally to the decision in court. I'm 48 Hours correspondent Natalie Morales, and this is 48 Hours inside the Cory Richins trial. Now, the state of Utah alleged that Cory Richins poisoned Eric with a lethal dose of fentanyl served in a Moscow mule back in March of 2022 after previously attempting to poison him via a sandwich. On Valentine's Day of that same year, before her arrest in 2023, she published a children's book about grief to help her kids mourn the loss of their father. Here with me to discuss the verdict and the trial is Sky Lazzaro, a defense attorney who represented Corey Richards before the trial. But she was there inside the Summit county courtroom for closing arguments. So, sky, the decision really came down after just a few hours once the jury went to deliberate. What was your reaction to then hearing the verdict and were you surprised?
- [02:05]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
I was surprised by how quickly the jury came back, really. There was a lot of evidence that was presented in this case. And just, you know, from experience, I somewhat expected the jury to go back, probably do a little bit of deliberation with the few hours they had, go home, get some rest, and then come back the next day.
- [02:26]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
So the defense did make the decision not to call any witnesses and not to put Corey Richards on this stand. Was any of that a mistake in your opinion? As a defense attorney?
- [02:37]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
You hate to Monday morning quarterback what somebody else does in trial. This is really difficult work and these are decisions that you make in real time. I understand why they did not. The state actually held back some evidence, I think because they expected Corey to probably testify and for the defense to put on a defense. And the Strategy really becomes, do we put on what we have? And is what we have enough to make a difference? Because what you do, the state gets a rebuttal in these cases. So the state then gets to come back because it's their burden of proof and put on even more evidence or more character evidence. So really it gives them one more chance to send the jury back to deliberate or listen to closing arguments. Having heard even more negative things about your client, it's always a really, really hard decision to make. You never know which one's right. You second guess everything you do, especially when you get a conviction, then you really question it. But in this case, I think the state, to their credit, did a really, really good job of painting a picture of Corey Richards, that someone who's capable of murder and who did commit it.
- [03:57]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Let's talk about the murder and attempted murder charges. And here's prosecutor Brad Bloodworth during his closing arguments talking about the motive here. And the motive in this case truly was money. You know, Corey was in over her head in debt with her house flipping business. Eric's estate was worth over $4 million, including a life insurance policy which the prosecution alleged that Corey was forged to sign over to her name. Let's take a listen to Bloodworth in his closings.
- [04:28]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
The substance here happened to have been fentanyl. Could have been any part of the illicit street drug that she bought. Happened to be fentanyl that she administered in a Moscow mill. And a shot, or a shot, but we know that's how she administered it because it was in his belly. We know it was a lethal amount. The death certificate. Fentanyl killed him. That's the substance. Lethal amount can be as small as 3 nanograms per milliliter. And in this case, he had 15, five times what can be a lethal amount. That, by the way, is not an accident. That amount of fentanyl shows that Corey Richards wanted Eric not only dead, but good and dead.
- [05:29]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Well, that was Brad Bledworth from the prosecution. Now here is defense attorney Wendy Lewis. She insisted that the prosecution did not prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt.
- [05:41]
Defense Attorney Wendy Lewis
Okay, so they have to prove that Eric, or I'm sorry, that Corey Richards intentionally or knowingly caused the death of Eric Richards. The state has not proven this. They haven't even proven that she obtained fentanyl. They have not proven where the pills ended up or how Eric took them. States stood up here and argued, well, it really doesn't matter what drug she purchased, as long as it was an illicit street drug. It absolutely matters because what did he die of. He died of fentanyl. There was no oxycodone in his system. There was no other drug in his system. They must prove that she purchased and gave him fentanyl.
- [06:24]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
So, sky, the defense really leaned into the fact that the prosecution couldn't 100% prove that Corey was the one who procured the fentanyl and put it into that Moscow mule. The defense made the case that Eric Richens was a recreational drug user, that he used to take gummies with a THC at night to help him sleep. Perhaps he got a tainted supply of THC gummies with fentanyl in it. So in your mind, the defense did not present that as strong enough evidence to the jury?
- [06:59]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
I think with the jury's decision, it's clear that it wasn't presented strong enough, that there wasn't enough follow up, that they didn't, they didn't, they put it on through cross examination. But maybe looking back at what should we have done differently or should we have put on a defense, maybe those are the people you try to put on.
- [07:19]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Now, according to the prosecution, the key witness here is Carmen Lauber. She was a woman who worked with Corey Richards as a cleaning person, but also had a criminal history in dealing drugs and also admitted on the stand to having used drugs and having a past with drug abuse. Although she claims she's clean now. But Lauber said that Corey had come to her on four different occasions asking for drugs from her, saying this was all for an investor. And then Corey apparently asked Carmen Lauber for something even stronger than the painkiller that she had received in the past. Carmen talks about her contact here when it came to buying those drugs. Take a listen.
- [08:02]
Key Witness Carmen Lauber
He said he had a buddy that had some fentanyl pills.
- [08:09]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
What then did you do?
- [08:12]
Key Witness Carmen Lauber
I text Corey back and told her that I had a friend that could get them, but they were fentanyl pills.
- [08:25]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
So you told Corey you had a friend a hookup for fentanyl pills?
- [08:29]
Key Witness Carmen Lauber
Yes.
- [08:30]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
How did Corey Richards respond?
- [08:32]
Key Witness Carmen Lauber
She said, okay, go ahead and get him.
- [08:39]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
So did you go ahead and get him?
- [08:41]
Key Witness Carmen Lauber
Yes.
- [08:43]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
So, Sky, I know Carmen Lauber is somewhat of a, of a tough witness when it comes to the prosecution because even, even though she is the key witness here, she also has this history with drugs. And she also seems to be, according to the defense's side, changing her story on multiple occasions, right?
- [09:03]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
That's correct. The state really had a lot to overcome. When you pin your entire case on someone like Carmen Lauber, we look back at the Investigation. And we look at the interviews that were done, and she does say that she sold Corey drugs, but that wasn't fentanyl. And it wasn't until several interviews later when the state investigator is really pushing on her. This is your get out of jail free card. And remember, she's on probation for first degree felony drug charges at the time. Those carry a potential sentence of five years to life in prison. So this is serious. And that was played during the course of the trial.
- [09:41]
Prosecutor Investigator
They're looking to pull your drug court deal and ask for seven years on your two firsts. Five years for the first, the one felony, and then a 40% portion for the second for seven years. The only exception to that and the only thing that they're willing to kind of help you out with is if you can help us out with this.
- [10:06]
Court Clerk / Judge
And by so he means, like, give
- [10:09]
Prosecutor Investigator
us the details that will ensure Corey
- [10:13]
Court Clerk / Judge
gets convicted of murder.
- [10:14]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
And I want to talk about how the defense also went after Carmen Lauber's testimony. You know, they presented her with stacks of binders.
- [10:23]
Defense Attorney Wendy Lewis
I'm going to ask you to refer to these as we talk. These are the transcripts of the interviews that you did in April and May of 2023.
- [10:32]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
So in presenting those binders, it seems she's presenting the situation to Lauber as this is all your testimony over the time and look how much it's changed. Right, Sky?
- [10:43]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
That's exactly what they did. And they went her pretty harshly. I. I think at times she almost came across as sympathetic, which didn't help the defense either, because up till this
- [10:55]
Defense Attorney Wendy Lewis
point in the interview, you've said no fentanyl. I don't deal in fentanyl. I didn't get her fentanyl. I got her Roxies. I got her Oxys. Oh, she asked for Michael Jackson drugs. Oh, I guess I got her fentanyl. How else would fentanyl be in my head?
- [11:11]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Right.
- [11:11]
Defense Attorney Wendy Lewis
That's what's happened up to this point.
- [11:14]
Key Witness Carmen Lauber
Correct.
- [11:14]
Defense Attorney Wendy Lewis
And the only person up to this point who has put the word fentanyl in your head are these detectives correct? Miss Lauber, you're on the stand at that point. They are the ones that told you it was fentanyl.
- [11:34]
Key Witness Carmen Lauber
They're the ones that told me that Eric passed away from fentanyl.
- [11:38]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
They really did try to hammer on, you know, you don't remember. You keep changing your story. You know, you were saying whatever the state needed you to say.
- [11:48]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Now, one of the other big points for the prosecution is some of the web searches made shortly thereafter Eric's death queries about, for example, how to delete information from your phone if cops can force you to take a lie detector test. Searches about life insurance and luxury prisons for the rich in California, and also this query about a lethal dose of fentanyl. Did you think that that went over with the jury in a compelling way? Enough so that it was. It was convincing?
- [12:19]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
I think it was confusing from what I saw when those happened. And I think that was really the important part of it. A search warrant was executed in April, long after Eric's passed away. And they take. They search Corey's home, they take all of her electronics, and those searches were conducted on her new phone. So we know that those searches were conducted after she was given a copy of a search warrant. That said, we are investigating you, Corey Richards, for the homicide of Eric Richards, and we believe he died with a lethal dose of fentanyl. So those search warrants or those searches that were done, I think are explainable. When she's learning for the first time I'm being investigated for murder, they think I did it. And, you know, now they've taken my phone. I don't know what a lethal dose of fentanyl is. You know, actually, I think that could probably be spun in her defense. She didn't know what a lethal dose of fentanyl was. Had she killed him, she would know. What is enough.
- [13:21]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Let's talk about that walk the dog letter. Now, we had reported on this in our 48 hours report. You couldn't talk to us really at length about that letter at the time. Now, allegedly, this was a letter from Corey to her mother giving her brother Ronnie instructions on what to say in terms of how to present the case and her story. And this was written in September of 2023. And the jury was shown this redacted version of the letter. And here is Detective Jeff o' Driscoll reading from that letter in the court.
- [13:56]
Court Clerk / Judge
Page one, Walk the dog. But take vague notes. So you remember, here is what I'm thinking. But you have to talk to Ronnie. He would probably have to testify to this, but it's super short, not a lot to it. He will need to tell sky at the meeting next week. Upon information and belief, just like they say, a year prior to Eric's death, Ronnie was over watching football one Sunday, and Eric and Ronnie were chatting about Eric's Mexico trips. Eric told Ronnie he gets pain pills and fentanyl from Mexico from the workers at the ranch. Not to tell me because I would get mad because I always said He. He just gets high every night and won't help take care of the kids. There are pictures in my phone of Eric passed out on the floor or in the chair.
- [14:54]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
So this letter, I mean, how big a deal is this letter? I mean, was it witness tampering from Corey Richards in this case? Is this Cory trying to set up her story? What did you make of it? Because you are actually named in it. You know, Corey says, please tell Sky a couple of times in the letter.
- [15:13]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
This letter was probably the single worst thing that probably could have happened to Corey. It was published immediately by the district attorney's office to the press. It really set the scene for. Cori's a bad person, and Corey will lie to get whatever she wants and use whoever she needs to. The reality is, and I think this was discussed at a hearing that we had after we talked on 48 hours when I couldn't really talk about it was this letter was found in her cell after they executed a search and took a whole bunch of documents, including things I had to fight to get back because they were privileged. This letter was never given to anyone. There was never an indication that it was going to be given to anyone or mailed. Corey knew that they read all her mail that she sent out. There was no way she was getting this letter out without knowing. So, you know, my perspective on it still is it's thoughts on a page. It's not witness tampering. I certainly don't appreciate parts of it and, you know, would never cross any lines as an attorney, you know, the way she may hope. But it reads really problematic. It's always been a problem. In this case, I expected it to continue to be a problem. And it just in conjunction with everything else that was presented about her, it just really does not help put her in a positive light.
- [16:53]
National Debt Relief Advertiser
Do you have $10,000 or more in credit card debt? Maybe you're even barely getting by by making minimum payments. With credit card debt hitting record highs, National Debt Relief offers real debt relief solutions for people struggling to keep up. These options may reduce a large portion of credit card debt for those who qualify. You don't need to declare bankruptcy, and you may be able to pay back less than you owe regardless of your credit. National Debt Relief has already reduced the credit card debt for more than 550,000 consumers. So don't wait if you owe 10, 20, or even hundreds of thousands of dollars in credit card debt. You can now take advantage of this financial debt relief as the cost of living increases to find out how much you could save. Visit National Debt Relief.com that's National Debt Relief.com.
- [17:45]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
So the prosecution really talked about the financial motive, but they argued that Corey also wanted to start this whole other life with Robert Josh, as he goes by Grossman. This was the man that she was having an affair with. Now, when we spoke sky back in 2023, that affair, there had been rumors of it, but we didn't have confirmation of it. So now we're seeing we have confirmation of it and his testimony. When he took the stand, he seemed somewhat nervous. He seemed to really hate the fact that he was there even when he was taking the oath. He seemed confused at times. Would you say?
- [18:26]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
I would agree with you and you're correct. When we previously spoke on this, it'd been kind of thrown out there that there perhaps was an affair. This other individual existed, we now know, and through text messages that have been, you know, obtained and entered into evidence that he does. His testimony was interesting, for sure. That was probably the first time he had seen Corey since the relationship ended. And he was, you know, clearly upset by either having to be there or having to testify against her or the relationship in and of itself.
- [19:07]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
And the prosecution, they spent hours with him and taking him through some of those text messages that they were sending to each other back and forth. Now, these text messages showed both of them professing their love. But when Corey got arrested, he said that's when he started feeling really guilty. And that's when he said he actually went to Eric's family and he spoke to one of the sister's husbands and then they had him meet with their private investigator. And Josh recalled that conversation also that he had with Corey soon after Eric's death.
- [19:45]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
Did she ask you a question about killing? She did.
- [19:48]
Robert Josh Grossman (Affair Partner)
Asked me if I. If, yeah.
- [19:56]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
What's her? What's her? Did she ask.
- [19:58]
Robert Josh Grossman (Affair Partner)
She asked if I had ever killed anybody.
- [20:05]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
Was that specific to killed anybody while serving in Iraq?
- [20:09]
Robert Josh Grossman (Affair Partner)
Right.
- [20:11]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
Did you respond?
- [20:12]
Robert Josh Grossman (Affair Partner)
I did.
- [20:13]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
Did she ask a follow up question? Yes, sir. What was that follow up question?
- [20:20]
Robert Josh Grossman (Affair Partner)
She asked me how it made me feel or something along those lines.
- [20:26]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
The way it was presented in court, I think was really effective for the state. And they talked about it again in their closing argument and said it's not like she said, have you ever seen anyone die or has a loved one or a close person to you ever died? It was, have you ever killed? It was really, I think, damaging to Cory.
- [20:52]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Did the defense have much when it came to cross examining Josh?
- [20:57]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
You know, there really wasn't a lot there. I mean, you know, the cross of Josh, I think, really needs to be. Did Cory ever tell you that she killed him? Did you ever see her buy fentanyl? Did she ever ask you to get her Fentanyl? Did you ever. She ever have any conversation, you know, about getting rid of Eric and what she would do? I know there was conversations about her wanting to just be with Josh, you know, but really, you know, and if you can't provide any. Anything on that, then it's like, okay, thank you. So she had an affair.
- [21:28]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
But that affair, I mean, to the jury, you know, an affair does not make a murderer. But in this case, it was just one more thing that you think was more damaging to Corey?
- [21:40]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
I think so, no. An affair never makes a murder. And this affair had gone. Had been going on and off for years. And actually, you know, if. If, as the state alleges, that one of the reasons she killed Eric was to be with Josh, this relationship, as he testified, understand, really just fizzled out shortly after Eric died. And so it really is kind of flies in the face of that theory, but I think, you know, when you couple it with all of these other things that. That they just never were really able to. The defense was never really able to counteract and humanize her in a real effective way. The circumstantial evidence just really, really adds up.
- [22:24]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
And then finally, I want to talk to you about the book. This is the book, I think, that got everybody's attention. It was a children's book about grief to her children, but it drew, I think, a lot of attention to this case. I want to play some sound once again from the prosecutor, Brad Bloodworth, during the closing argument. Argument about the book.
- [22:45]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
She wrote it, had it written and published it. In early 2023, when she knew that investigators were investigating her for the murder of Eric Richards. She promoted it. Her mother sent a book to investigators, all to deflect attention away from Cory Richards. She also wrote it to make money. You see the emails? They're in evidence. She thought she would sell 100,000 copies in 10 months at $5 profit a copy. That is not tethered to reality, but it does provide insight in how desperate she was for money that she would trade. She would trade on her sons and the death of the. Her father to make money. The final thing it tells you about Corey Richards is that she wanted, as part of her facade, as part of her appearance of success, privilege, and affluence, she wanted to be an author,
- [23:59]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
but
- [23:59]
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth
she didn't write it. And you can see from her writings and text messages, orange notebook, the notes, the walk the dog letter. Not only does she not write it, she's not a good writer, but she wanted to appear as one. The appearance was what was important to her.
- [24:16]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Bloodworth there is alleging that this was written by a ghostwriter. And this was really, again, Corrie trying to put on appearances of that grieving widow, that grieving mom with her children. What did you make of that presentation of Corey?
- [24:34]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
That was their entire theory of this was everything she did, she did for attention. And he came back to that numerous times in his closing argument, talking about the timing of why she did things or when she did them, because they would get more attention or more sympathy for her. And he tied it to the book. And the book, in and of itself, it didn't really sell that many copies. I know it was taken off. Probably would have sold a lot more if it had been left up after she'd been charged. But Corey at all times, you know, maintained to investigators, to everyone, that she loved her children. You know, there was no. There was no evidence presented that she didn't love her children. I think the timing of the book, I'll concede, was absolutely terrible. Please don't write books when you're under investigation for murder. But, you know, it doesn't help things. But, you know, I think the state's idea of why she did it is wildly speculative, and I'm not sure there's really any evidence to back that up.
- [25:42]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Well, I know Eric's family was, of course, very much relieved by the verdict. It is what they wanted all along. His sister Amy said she was happy that they finally got justice for her brother. The sentencing for Corey Richards is scheduled for May 13. What do you expect will happen then? What do you expect will be the outcome of that? With all five counts coming back as
- [26:04]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
guilty, there's two options the judge has on count one, and I think regardless of what he does with counts two through five, probably don't matter. Count one, aggravated murder in Utah. The sentencing possibilities are 25 years to life in the Utah State Prison or life without parole. That'll really be the decision the judge makes on a 25. Even if he gives her the lower end of that, the 25 years to life. Whether or not he adds consecutive sentences for the remaining charges, I think really probably doesn't matter. It's going to be so long before she's eligible for parole, unless this case comes back on appeal for some reason, that she's going to spend a significant amount of time, if not the rest of her life in prison.
- [26:58]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Well, I know the defense had at multiple times asked the judge for a mistrial. The judge did not buy that. But I imagine there will be an appeal. Is that your understanding of what might happen next?
- [27:12]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
I would expect an appeal to come in this case without any personal knowledge. She was convicted of aggregate aggravated murder and the remainder of the counts. I think there's no other option but to file an appeal. There were enough rulings and pretrial litigation rulings, rulings that the judge made during the trial that an appellate attorney will pick this up and say, hey, look, some of these were detrimental and it should come back. That would be up to our Utah Supreme Court as to how they're going to rule on those.
- [27:44]
48 Hours Correspondent Natalie Morales
Well, once again, Sky Lazaro, thank you so much for your expert insight into this case, the Cory Richards trial.
- [27:51]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
Thanks for having me, Natalie.
- [27:58]
Howie Mandel
Hey, it's Howie Mandel and I'm inviting you to witness history as me and my How We Do It Gaming team take on Gilly the King and wallow two six seven's million dollars gaming in an epic global gaming league video game showdown. Four rounds, multiple games, one winner, plus a halftime performance by multi platinum artist Travy McCoy. Watch all the action and see who wins and advances to the championship match against Neo right now@globalgamingleague.com that's globalgamingleague.com everybody games.
- [28:28]
Pluto TV Advertiser
Pluto TV has thousands of free movies and TV shows.
- [28:32]
Defense Attorney Wendy Lewis
You swear?
- [28:33]
National Debt Relief Advertiser
If I'm lying, I'm dying.
- [28:34]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
This is the mindset. Free. This is the mantra.
- [28:37]
Prosecutor Investigator
Free.
- [28:38]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
This is
- [28:41]
Pluto TV Advertiser
with movies like Titanic, Dream Girls and Gladiator.
- [28:45]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
Why you're not entertained.
- [28:46]
Pluto TV Advertiser
And TV shows like Survivor, SpongeBob SquarePants, the fairly odd Parents and Ghosts. Pluto TV is always free.
- [28:54]
Defense Attorney Sky Lazzaro
Huzzah.
- [28:55]
Pluto TV Advertiser
Pluto TV stream now pay never.