Loading summary
Ryan Reynolds
Wondery plus subscribers can listen to this podcast ad free right now. Join Wondery plus in the Wondery app today.
Margo Hunt
True crime fans know the feeling when a story pulls you in. You can feel like part of the investigation. And with Audible, there's a lot to uncover. Listeners might like after you've gone By Margo Hunt this Audible original is a gripping thriller that follows one woman as she tries to solve her best friend's murder in the French Quarter of New Orleans. As an Audible member, you can choose one title a month to keep from the entire catalog, including the latest bestsellers and new releases. New members can try audible free for 30 days. Visit audible.com 48 hours or text 48 hours to 500500 audible.com 48 hours hey, I'm Ryan Reynolds.
Ryan Reynolds
Recently I asked Mint Mobile's legal team if big wireless companies are allowed to raise prices due to inflation. They said yes. And then when I asked if raising prices technically violates those onerous two year contracts, they said, what the are you talking about, you insane Hollywood? So to recap, we're cutting the price of mint unlimited from $30 a month to just $15 a month. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch $45 upfront payment equivalent to $15 per month.
Natalie Morales
New customers on first three month plan only taxes and fees, extra speeds slower.
Ann Marie Green
Above 40 gigabyte C details. Welcome back to another episode of Post Mortem. I'm your host Ann Marie Green and today we're discussing the death of Alex Penig. She was last seen alive by her former co worker Matthew Ecker, with whom she also had a one time affair. Now he called 911 after he said she shot herself with his gun, but investigators would unravel a different story. So with me now to discuss this mysterious case is CBS News correspondent Natalie Morales and 48 Hours producer Betsy Schuler. Thank you so much for joining us guys.
Natalie Morales
Of course. Thanks for having us.
Betsy Schuler
Good to be with you again, Anne Marie.
Ann Marie Green
If you have not listened to the 48 Hours episode that we're about to talk about yet, you can find the full audio version just below this episode in your podcast feed. So go take a listen and then come on back for this conversation. All right. So the title of this episode is the Strange Shooting of Alex Pinig. It's a great title because it was a strange one. And this was one hour where I found myself completely convinced of a different scenario every five seconds. One of the things that I was watching is Matthew Ecker's reaction. He was certainly incredibly Distraught. He was breaking down. But I couldn't tell if I thought it was too much or not. You interview the first responders. What was their impression of Ecker when they spoke to him?
Betsy Schuler
You know, I think that's what was so fascinating, is that we had so much of that body cam footage. First responders were with him for about an hour, and that's what everybody was looking at and analyzing. And it's not just the amount of footage, but it's also that it's minutes right after Alex was shot. I think people enter a situation and look at things and say, okay, does it seem genuine? Does it not seem genuine? And I think first responders analyze all the evidence in front of them as he was very distraught and grieving and trying to process the trauma in that moment. It was interesting when we questioned them about what they thought, they thought he was not producing real tears, and they questioned how he was responding to what they perceive as real grief versus, you know, not grieving. And I think, you know, throughout the course of our reporting, we look back at that footage so much. Right, Betsy. And we just analyzed and overanalyzed, and we thought of all the different scenarios, and it was. It's really hard to decipher how somebody processes grief is what we've come down to.
Natalie Morales
Yeah, yeah, for sure. I mean, I think our impression of the footage is one thing, but the way the people involved with the case sort of saw the footage is a different thing. Detectives noticed Ecker talking to first responders in the hallway. He seemed really emotional, but they didn't see him crying any actual tears. And I think that stood out to them.
Betsy Schuler
All of this was what ended up in trial, being questioned, his behavior, whether or not he produced real tears.
Natalie Morales
And also for Alex's family, right, they're looking at this footage, and they see a guy who's disingenuous, who's overacting, who looked rehearsed to them. Matthew's family sees, you know, their. Their son, their brother breaking down. His mom is a nurse and had worked as a hospice nurse for a while. So she said she had some experience dealing with people going through trauma. And she said that in her experience that people don't always produce tears, and also that sometimes when you're crying for that long, you might not produce tears the whole time. If you're dehydrated, you may not produce tears. You know, in that scenario, Matthew had been drinking for hours with Alex, so there was a lot of things at play there, you know, and for our viewers who just watched this episode, they might remember that we also show someone else responding to grief. We show the moment where Shane Anderson learns that his girlfriend Alex had just died. And he doesn't produce tears either. You know, so I found that really interesting.
Ann Marie Green
Yeah, and that did stand out to me. You know, early on, as the hours unfolding, I started to wonder, well, I don't know, what is the right way to respond to this terrible, shocking news? So, yeah, like I said, I went back and forth about a million times during the hour. So. Speaking of conflicting evidence, first responders found Alex dead in her bathroom with the gun laying on her shoulder. Her left hand was sort of resting on top. The detectives later learned that she was right handed. Did detectives think that this was a slam dunk in terms of evidence that she could not have been the one to shoot herself? Because why would you use your non dominant hand?
Natalie Morales
I mean, I definitely think they thought it was a piece of the puzzle. I'm not sure it was a slam dunk at that point for us. This one was really hard. I think we go back and forth on what this means. You know, initially you think, oh, well, if she's right handed, how could she use her left hand? One of the editors on this, interestingly enough, is in the military, and she had an interesting perspective. If you picture a pistol, when you go to rack the chamber, you pull back this sliding mechanism to load it. And apparently that's really heavy and not so easy to move if you don't know what you're doing. So it could make sense that you would make that motion with your dominant hand, which means the gun would be in your non dominant hand.
Betsy Schuler
And according to Alex's family, Alex did not have any experience with shooting guns. Mm. And remember, according to Ecker, this all happened so quickly. He says she ran into the bathroom, locked the door, and then he heard a gunshot. And then when he broke down the door, what he saw was her on the floor. That's according to Ecker. So I think that's like a split second thing that you have to consider, timing, time to switch hands. Also, let's say she has her hand on the door and is locking the door. Wouldn't you do that with your dominant hand? I mean, it's hard to say what somebody does with the left and the right. But obviously, if you're in the moment and in a frenzy, I think it could be seen differently.
Ann Marie Green
Right. Matthew Ecker also didn't give detectives the whole story about the gun at first. It was more than two hours actually into his interview that he admitted to moving it first, putting it in his suitcase, and then he placed it back on Alex's body. That's what he says. Did detectives think, you know, this was suspicious, that this perhaps showed a bit of guilt?
Natalie Morales
Yeah, that's exactly what they thought. One of the detectives was like, what innocent person would do this? I mean, I think that was a really big moment for them. If you didn't fire the gun, why would you pick it up and move it? So that one didn't look good for him.
Betsy Schuler
And the explanation that Ecker's attorney gives was, you know, in that moment, realized, oh, my gosh, that's my gun. And so maybe there was a panic or something, and he picked up the gun and went to put it away, but then realized, well, I've got to explain what happened here. I better put it back. So, you know, that's how Bruce Rivers, who is Ecker's attorney, explained that at trial. So you can look at this from two different sides again and be very conflicted, as we all are.
Natalie Morales
But as a viewer of true crime, you know, when someone starts changing their story, your spidey sense goes up.
Betsy Schuler
That's your tell.
Ann Marie Green
Yeah. Especially after two hours because, you know, he's been questioned about the positioning of the gun. Probably a couple of times it comes off like he's thinking, I better have a better answer than the one I had an hour ago.
Betsy Schuler
Also, the gunshot residue was actually on Alex's left hand, but Ecker didn't have any gunshot residue at all on him. And keep in mind, he had no blood on him. His entire shirt, outfit, everything was clean.
Ann Marie Green
You know, he doesn't have anything to indicate that he was near her body at the time.
Natalie Morales
No. Which is really interesting. And so, you know, Natalie laid out the one side of it the detectives would say that, you know, that would be because the door would have shielded him, that they believe there was a struggle at the bathroom door, and she was trying to push the door closed and he was trying to reach around. So he would have been shielded from some of that.
Betsy Schuler
You know, I think that's what's so interesting about this case, is you try to add up all the pieces, and the position of her body in the bathroom was a big one. That was a big tell.
Natalie Morales
Yeah. I think that was one of the first things for the detectives that sort of made them a little suspicious about the scene. Just seeing the position of her legs, they were like, how could she have gotten in this position?
Betsy Schuler
When first responders arrived there, her legs were straddled around the door and that according to the scenarios that were presented by detectives, they were like, well, that shows that there had to have been some sort of struggle, you know, that she was sort of caught in the middle of the door when this happened. Whereas Ecker's attorney explains that as he was trying to help her, he went in, broke the door. There was enough room in the bathroom that her legs could have shifted and moved with the door being pushed back and opened. So again, one more thing that makes us very conflicted.
Natalie Morales
Americans agree that everyone should be able to make their own health care decisions. You and only you should control your health care decisions. But the truth is attacks on reproductive health care, including abortion, are only intensifying. That's why your gift to Planned Parenthood is so important right now. No matter the battle, no matter the stakes, no matter what Planned Parenthood is there, protect our rights, protect our health care. Make your gift to Planned Parenthood@PlannedParenthood.org Protect.
Luke Lamanna
Did you know that parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach? Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families. With Greenlight, you can send money to kids instantly, set up chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye on your kids spending with real time notifications, kids learn to earn, save and spend wisely. And parents can rest easy knowing their kids are learning about money. With guardrail rails in place. Sign up for greenlight today@greenlight.com wondery that's greenlight.com wondery.
Ann Marie Green
Welcome back. Matthew Ecker claims that he went to Alex's apartment that day because she told him that she was scared of her boyfriend, Shane. Shane was never considered a suspect, though. You interviewed him in that hour. What was your impression of him?
Betsy Schuler
Well, I have to tell you, first of all, he was very reluctant to do the interview with us, and he was hesitant. He was very unsure about what to expect. I think many of his reasons for deciding to do it was he wanted to honor Alex, who he loved very much. But also he was, I think, still processing a lot of what he had heard. I mean, a lot of what he was first hearing happened to come out of the trial. And the first time he was hearing, for example, that Matthew Ecker and Alex had had a previous romance affair was at that trial. So I think talking to us gave him some sort of sense of, you know, closure, but also wanting to be able to process his emotions.
Ann Marie Green
To me, it appears as if he, you know, truly loved Alex, but it also seemed like, you know, it wasn't the best relationship, or I should say it wasn't perfect.
Natalie Morales
He was accused of doing some stuff to Alex that she was scared enough to call this other guy, Ecker. So, you know, he was brought into this through that he wasn't a suspect. But I think he also wanted the chance to respond to some of that and tell his side of the story.
Ann Marie Green
Yeah.
Betsy Schuler
He says, I mean, Alex was the love of his life and they were planning a future together. In fact, it was right before the holidays when Alex died and he was planning to go with her to meet her parents for the first time. So he was looking forward to that.
Natalie Morales
Yeah, it did seem like he really cared about her, even all these months later. We could feel it when we were with him.
Ann Marie Green
You do certainly get that in the hour. And I just want to stress to everyone, even though it's clear in the hour, he was never considered a suspect.
Betsy Schuler
At all after that altercation at the bar. He was told to get out and go home, and that's what he did.
Natalie Morales
Yeah, there were only two people in that apartment. It was Ecker and it was Alex.
Betsy Schuler
Yeah.
Ann Marie Green
Speaking of Ecker and Alex, pretty unusual relationship. That day he made a three hour drive from his home to help Alex get out of what he says is, you know, a bad situation with her current boyfriend. When I heard it in the hour, I go, wait a minute, there's no one else that's closer to you? I mean, in three hours, an argument flares up and then it's over. It just seemed a little. A little off. Was the affair truly over?
Natalie Morales
According to his family, the affair had ended and they were just friends. Seemed like a bit of an interesting friendship because he was giving her money.
Betsy Schuler
As we see in the trial and court records showed he was financially helping support Alex, paying her rent and pay some of her expenses. About $28,000 that he ended up giving Alex or loaning Alex. He was also, according to the text messages that we see between the two of them, prescribing her with drugs. Ecker is a licensed nurse practitioner, so with that he is able to prescribe medications. Alex, of course, was not his patient. And while detectives and even Ecker's own family, who are also nurses, all agree it is unethical, they all point out it is not illegal.
Ann Marie Green
Ecker really did seem to care about Alex. And so the big question, of course, is what could the motive have been here?
Betsy Schuler
Yes, I mean, certainly when you talk about motive, I mean, what could have been the motive for murdering Alex? I think that's probably the most Mysterious part of this case, and something that is still not very clear. I mean, one thing that detectives thought it could be was that perhaps maybe Alex was threatening to go public and to tell his wife even about their affair. But then there's that question of why would she do that to the guy who was providing for her at that time?
Ann Marie Green
What about the phone? What about the text messages? It was clear in the lobby of the apartment building that she was looking at her phone.
Betsy Schuler
Yeah, you know, we saw that surveillance footage, and that's the last time you see Alex alive. It looked like she was texting with somebody, but we don't really know if there were text messages or not because police were never able to get into her phone. Detectives did tell us that multiple forensic examiners did try to get into Alex's phone, but they were unsuccessful. The defense also tried as well.
Natalie Morales
It would have been really revealing to be able to see some of her text messages. You know, we have the messages between her and Ecker from Ecker's phone. We go through some of those in the hour, and I think they're very telling. But we don't know who else she may have been messaging and what she may have been saying to them. Some people wonder if she was messaging with Shane. You know, this fight at Camp Bar had just happened, but Shane had lost his phone, so they weren't able to get the messages from his side either. So, yeah, there's a lot that we don't know that maybe could have come out if they would have been able to get in the phone.
Betsy Schuler
When I talked to Shane, I asked him, like, did you ever. I mean, if you sign onto a computer, you can see your messages or, you know, if you. You know, can you check Facebook messages? And he said there was nothing.
Natalie Morales
Yeah, he told us he was not messaging with Alex at all.
Ann Marie Green
Ultimately, Ecker is found guilty. He's sentenced to 30 years. It's a hefty sentence. Is he appealing his conviction?
Natalie Morales
Yes, he is appealing his conviction.
Betsy Schuler
His family was not happy with how the trial was presented and how it went on.
Ann Marie Green
What was it that they were unhappy about?
Natalie Morales
So there were a couple things. Obviously, the outcome, you know, their son, their brother is in prison for 30 years. But they would have liked to hear Ecker on the stand. They would have liked him to tell his story. His defense attorney, Bruce Rivers, said that, you know, through all the footage in the hallway in the interrogation room, that he did get to tell his story. So Rivers told us that he didn't feel like it was necessary for Ecker to testify. You know, I think the family also felt that his, you know, his character wasn't brought into it. The way he helps people, his past, some more sides of his personality like that. I think they really hoped that that would have been a part of it.
Ann Marie Green
I sort of wondered about that because I thought the way they describe him, there are some things at odds with that. You know, he runs to the aid of this young woman, but it's still sort of questionable.
Betsy Schuler
I think that's why ultimately, his attorney decided, you know, is the risk worth taking putting the defendant on the stand? I think that's always the analysis you do. Here's a guy who has a wife with four children and knowingly he cheated on her. Granted, an affair does not make a murderer, as we've talked about so many times in our 48 Hours shows. We know that's not the case.
Ann Marie Green
Right. I was kind of curious about how Alex's family felt about how she had been depicted.
Natalie Morales
Her parents knew she had some struggles. She had some things in her past, and they really didn't shy away from it. They certainly didn't shy away from it in our interview, and I respected that. I mean, it's. It's who she was.
Betsy Schuler
And they're wonderful people, the Penigs, and still dealing with so much grief and losing Alex. Alex was a beautiful person, and they wanted to make sure that her memory was honored.
Ann Marie Green
Ecker's family totally convinced that he's innocent. Alex's family and friends totally convinced that he's guilty. You have to present this hour. How challenging was it to strike a balance?
Natalie Morales
I think it's always a challenge, but sort of also always a part of our job and part of what we do as journalists is to present both sides. I mean, that doesn't change a fact that a jury found him guilty, but I think that is a part of our responsibility that we take really seriously.
Ann Marie Green
Yeah.
Betsy Schuler
And we walk away from this one seeing two families that are destroyed. One lost their daughter, who they adored and had been through so much with her. And the other family is grieving. The son sentenced to 30 years in prison. I think you see both sides here of two families that are grieving a loss. And I think that's what our reporting shows is it's never easy to tell these stories, but we do our jobs and present all the evidence, and ultimately, you know, it's what the jury came back with, and we'll have to see what happens next.
Ann Marie Green
Yeah. Well, thank you guys for another really fascinating episode. I'm sure viewers are still debating about how they feel about the outcome of this case. Natalie Betsy, just want to thank you.
Natalie Morales
Of course, thank you, thank you Natalie.
Ann Marie Green
You have a brand new podcast that's dropping.
Betsy Schuler
I'm hosting a new six episode podcast. It's called 48 Hours NCIS. It takes listeners inside the case of Aaron Corwin. This is a tough one. She was a 19 year old Marine wife found dead in an abandoned mine shaft in Joshua Tree National Park. We go behind the scenes with the real life NCIS agents as they worked through the case and their tireless efforts to try to locate the body, then finally ultimately reaching the conclusion of that case and the verdict. So be sure to pull up your podcast app where you're listening, type in 48 hours NCIS and tap Follow to check out our new episode. New episodes come out, by the way every Tuesday so you don't want to miss it.
Ann Marie Green
So you know what else comes out on Tuesdays? Postmortem. And if you like this series postmortem, please rate and review 48 hours on Apple Podcasts and follow 48 hours wherever you get your podcasts. You can also listen ad free on Amazon Music Wondry plus in the Wondry app or with a 48 hours plus subscription on Apple Podcasts. Thanks again for listening.
Ryan Reynolds
If you like this podcast, you can listen ad free right now by joining Wondery plus and the Wondery App. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a quick survey@wondery.com survey did you know that after World War.
Nadine Bailey
II the US government quietly brought former Nazi scientists to America in a covert operation to advance military technology? Or that in the 1950s the US army conducted a secret experiment by releasing bacteria over San Francisco to test how a biological attack might spread without alerting the public? These might sound like conspiracy theories, but they're not. They're well documented government operations that have been hidden away in classified files for decades. I'm Luke Lamanna, a Marine Corps recon vet and I've always had a thing for digging into the unknown. It's what led me to start my new podcast, Declassified Mysteries. In it I explore hidden truths and reveal some eye opening events like covert experiments and secret operations that those in power tried to keep buried, follow redacted, decline Classified Mysteries with me, Luke Lamanna on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts to listen ad free. Join Wondery plus in the Wondery App.
H
You don't believe in ghosts? I get it. Lots of people don't. I didn't either until I came face to face with them. Ever since that moment, hauntings, spirits, and the unexpected explained have consumed my entire life. I'm Nadine Bailey. I've been a ghost tour guide for the past 20 years. I've taken people along with me into the shadows, uncovering the macabre tales that linger in the darkness and inside some of the most haunted houses, hospitals, prisons and more. Join me every week on my podcast, Haunted Canada, as we journey through terrifying and bone chilling stories of the unexplained search for Haunted Canada on Apple Podcast, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you find your favorite podcasts.
48 Hours: Post Mortem | The Strange Shooting of Alex Pennig
Release Date: October 29, 2024
Host: Ann Marie Green (CBS News)
Guests: Natalie Morales (CBS News Correspondent) and Betsy Schuler (48 Hours Producer)
In the gripping episode of "48 Hours" titled "Post Mortem | The Strange Shooting of Alex Pennig," host Ann Marie Green delves deep into the baffling circumstances surrounding the death of Alex Pennig. Joined by CBS News correspondent Natalie Morales and producer Betsy Schuler, the discussion unpacks the intricate details of the case, exploring conflicting evidence, emotional testimonies, and the profound impact on the families involved.
Alex Pennig was found dead under mysterious circumstances, with her death initially ruled as a suicide. However, the case took a dramatic turn when Matthew Ecker, Alex's former coworker and someone with whom she had a brief affair, reported the incident. Ecker claimed that Alex shot herself with his gun, but as the investigation unfolded, numerous inconsistencies emerged.
Notable Quote:
Ann Marie Green [04:09]: "It was a split second thing that you have to consider, timing, time to switch hands."
The investigation revealed several puzzling aspects:
Gun Handling:
Alex was right-handed, yet evidence showed the gun was in her left hand. Initially, this pointed towards foul play, as it contradicted typical handling behavior. However, a military editor provided a perspective that the sliding mechanism of the gun might have necessitated use of the non-dominant hand, offering a possible explanation.
Notable Quote:
Natalie Morales [06:40]: "This one was really hard. We go back and forth on what this means."
Behavioral Analysis of Matthew Ecker:
Ecker's emotional state was under scrutiny. First responders and detectives observed discrepancies in his grief responses. While he was visibly distraught, the absence of tears raised suspicions.
Notable Quotes:
Betsy Schuler [02:59]: "It's really hard to decipher how somebody processes grief is what we've come down to."
Natalie Morales [04:32]: "Detectives noticed Ecker talking to first responders... he didn't see him crying any actual tears."
Gunshot Residue and Physical Evidence:
Gunshot residue was found on Alex's left hand but none on Ecker. Additionally, there was no blood on Ecker, and his clothing remained clean, suggesting he was not physically near Alex at the time of the shooting.
Notable Quote:
Betsy Schuler [09:50]: "The gunshot residue was actually on Alex's left hand, but Ecker didn't have any gunshot residue at all on him."
Gun Movement Post-Incident:
Ecker initially claimed he saw Alex dead and moved the gun before later returning it to her body. Detectives viewed this as suspicious behavior indicative of guilt, while his attorney argued it was a momentary panic.
Notable Quote:
Natalie Morales [08:46]: "If you didn't fire the gun, why would you pick it up and move it?"
Matthew Ecker:
Ecker expressed deep love for Alex and claimed he was trying to help her out of a threatening relationship with her boyfriend, Shane Anderson. Despite their past affair, Shane was never considered a suspect.
Notable Quote:
Betsy Schuler [14:26]: "Alex was the love of his life and they were planning a future together."
Shane Anderson:
Alex's boyfriend, Shane, was interviewed to provide his perspective. Despite being aware of Ecker's affair with Alex, Shane maintained he had no involvement in her death.
Notable Quotes:
Natalie Morales [14:07]: "He was accused of doing some stuff to Alex that she was scared enough to call this other guy, Ecker."
Ann Marie Green [14:47]: "He was never considered a suspect."
Alex's Family:
The Pennig family provided insights into Alex's character, revealing past struggles but also emphasizing her vibrant personality. They perceived Ecker as guilty based on the evidence presented.
Notable Quote:
Betsy Schuler [20:45]: "Alex was a beautiful person, and they wanted to make sure that her memory was honored."
Matthew Ecker was ultimately found guilty and sentenced to 30 years in prison. His conviction was met with mixed reactions:
Ecker's Family: Believed in his innocence and were dissatisfied with the trial's presentation, feeling that his character was not adequately represented.
Notable Quote:
Natalie Morales [18:51]: "They would have liked to hear Ecker on the stand... They really hoped that that would have been a part of it."
Alex's Family: Remained convinced of Ecker's guilt, viewing the evidence and his behavior as indicative of his involvement in her death.
Notable Quote:
Ann Marie Green [22:09]: "Alex's family and friends totally convinced that he's guilty."
Ecker is appealing his conviction, citing dissatisfaction with how the trial was conducted and the portrayal of his character.
The case has had a devastating impact on both families involved:
Alex's Family: Grapples with the loss of their daughter, struggling to reconcile the evidence against Ecker with their memories of Alex.
Ecker's Family: Endures the pain of having a loved one convicted, believing in his innocence and facing the harsh realities of a prolonged legal battle.
Notable Quote:
Betsy Schuler [21:31]: "You see both sides here of two families that are grieving a loss."
"The Strange Shooting of Alex Pennig" episode of "48 Hours" presents a complex narrative where evidence and emotions intertwine, leaving listeners to ponder the true nature of the incident. Through meticulous reporting and in-depth interviews, the episode highlights the challenges in discerning truth within the gray areas of human behavior and legal proceedings. As the appeal process unfolds, the case remains a poignant reminder of the profound and lasting impacts criminal investigations have on all parties involved.
Stay Connected: For more in-depth analyses and updates on the case, listen to new episodes every Monday, delve deeper with the "Post Mortem" series on Tuesdays, and revisit classic episodes every Thursday.