Summary of "The Plot to Eliminate Alyssa Burkett" – 48 Hours Podcast by CBS News

Episode Title: The Plot to Eliminate Alyssa Burkett
Release Date: November 18, 2024
Host: CBS News' 48 Hours

Introduction

"The Plot to Eliminate Alyssa Burkett" delves deep into the harrowing case of Alyssa Burkett, a young mother whose life was brutally taken amidst a complex custody battle. This episode meticulously unpacks the events leading to her murder, the ensuing investigation, and the shocking revelations that emerged, ultimately highlighting the roles played by Andrew Beard and Holly Elkins in this tragic narrative.

Background: Alyssa Burkett’s Life and Custody Battle

Alyssa Burkett, a 24-year-old assistant property manager from Carrollton, Texas, was deeply entrenched in a bitter custody battle with her estranged partner, Andrew Beard, over their one-year-old daughter, Willowann. The discord began when Alyssa discovered her pregnancy, leading Andrew to aggressively seek full custody, straining their relationship from the outset.

Shelby Wright (Friend and Roommate):
“Alyssa was terrified that Andrew wanted Willow and he was going to get her.”

Alyssa's mother, Teresa Collard, noted the palpable fear Alyssa harbored regarding Andrew's intentions.

The Crime: September 2020

On October 2, 2020, Alyssa was tragically murdered at the Green Tree Apartments where she worked. Initially, eyewitnesses believed Alyssa was fatally shot, but she survived the gunshot wound. However, the assault escalated when her assailant, later identified as Andrew Beard, attacked her with a large hunting knife, resulting in her death after being stabbed 44 times.

Alyssa Burkett (via Transcript):
“What was lost when Alyssa was taken? What was lost with her murder? My daughter Willow's mother. Everything.”

Investigation and Initial Suspicions

Detective Michael Harding quickly identified Andrew Beard as the primary suspect, given Alyssa's expressed fears about him.

Detective Harding [00:05:30]:
“I knew immediately it was Andrew Beard. He cannot get away with this.”

However, the case took unexpected twists as evidence suggested a more elaborate plot involving manipulation and deceit.

Escalation: Framing and Fear

In September 2020, Alyssa received a suspicious 911 call from Frank Morrow, falsely accusing her of selling drugs. Upon investigation, police discovered that the drugs and a pistol in her car had been planted, leading Alyssa to believe that Andrew was behind the frame-up.

Alyssa’s Message to Roommate Shelby:
“he is going to try to get someone to kill me next. That wasn’t who she was. She wasn’t a fearful person.”

This revelation intensified Alyssa's fear for her safety, confirming her suspicions that Andrew was orchestrating a sinister plan against her.

Andrew Beard’s Involvement and Holly Elkins’ Role

Andrew Beard, despite initial attempts to evade capture, was eventually apprehended. However, significant evidence pointed towards Holly Elkins, Andrew's fiancée, playing a crucial role in the conspiracy to eliminate Alyssa.

Detective Chevalier:
“Holly Elkins... orchestrated this whole thing.”

Holly's manipulation and influence over Andrew were pivotal in the planning and execution of Alyssa's murder. Text messages and evidence uncovered in Holly's possession revealed her derogatory remarks about Alyssa and her obsessive desire to secure custody of Willow.

Holly Elkins (via Text):
“I want a man who protects his women and child before anyone.”

The Trial and Conviction

In April 2024, Holly Elkins faced trial as a co-conspirator in Alyssa's murder. The prosecution presented compelling evidence of her manipulative involvement and her active role in devising the plot against Alyssa. During the trial, prosecutors depicted Holly as the mastermind behind the conspiracy, asserting that without her influence, Andrew might not have committed the heinous act.

Prosecutor [Courtroom]:
“Andrew Beard is a monster, but he was Holly Elkins' monster.”

After a brief deliberation of just 90 minutes, the jury found Holly Elkins guilty. She was sentenced to two life terms, highlighting the gravity of her actions.

Impact and Aftermath

Alyssa Burkett’s murder left an indelible mark on her family and the community. Alyssa's mother, Teresa Collard, and sister, Madison Grimes, continue to grapple with the loss, striving to provide a loving environment for Willow while processing the betrayal and tragedy inflicted upon their lives.

Teresa Collard:
“I hope that one day she grows up and she feels the love that her mom sincerely had for her.”

The case underscored the devastating effects of custody battles gone awry and the extreme lengths individuals might go to secure what they desire, even at the cost of another's life.

Concluding Thoughts

"The Plot to Eliminate Alyssa Burkett" serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities surrounding personal relationships, custody disputes, and the dark paths they can lead to. Through in-depth reporting and gripping interviews, 48 Hours sheds light on a case that not only solved a tragic murder but also highlighted the resilience of those left behind.

Notable Quotes

• Alyssa’s Mother, Teresa Collard [00:02:15]:
  “I hope that when she learns what happened, she doesn't let her let her apart.”

• Detective Harding [00:04:45]:
  “When you learned that your sister was dead, did you have a suspect in mind?... He did.”

• Holly Elkins [During Interview]:
  “I don’t want or need a lawyer because I don’t have anything to hide.”

• Andrew Beard [During FBI Interview]:
  “I did it out of mercy. I knew that she was still alive and I was somehow doing her a favor by killing her.”

Conclusion

This episode of 48 Hours not only uncovers the layers of deceit and manipulation that led to Alyssa Burkett's untimely death but also emphasizes the profound impact such tragedies have on families and communities. Through diligent investigation and compelling storytelling, the podcast ensures that Alyssa’s story is remembered and serves as a cautionary tale about the perils of obsession and control.