48 Hours: Under The Moonlight – Episode Summary

Release Date: July 23, 2025
Host: CBS News

Introduction to the Tragic Night

The episode "Under The Moonlight" delves deep into a harrowing crime that unfolded on a serene summer night in Utah. It recounts the terrifying experience of Yvette Rodier and her friend Zach Snarr, who were brutally attacked, leaving a lasting impact on their lives and the community.

The Night of the Shooting

Yvette Rodier opens the narrative by setting the scene of a beautiful full moon night on August 28, 1996, when she and Zach went on their first date. Initially hesitant, Yvette recalls the excitement and connection she felt with Zach:

“We just started driving up the canyon. I remember feeling that little twinge of excitement when you realize you really have a crush on someone and that they have a crush on you.” [00:01]

As they approached a cement pathway, an ominous white truck appeared. The assailant approached them, and before they could react, he unleashed a barrage of gunfire:

“He turned around, and he didn't. Instead, he was looking for money, I assume...” [07:45]

Yvette vividly describes the chaos that ensued—the pain of being shot, the fear of potential sexual assault, and the sheer terror of the moment:

“He was breathing on me. And then the man ran up the mountain. And I know he's gone for sure when I hear Zach's car start up.” [08:30]

Immediate Aftermath and Rescue

In the immediate aftermath, Zach and Ryan Reynolds, a responder, arrived at the scene to find Yvette covered in blood but able to communicate:

“She was in shock, but she was able to hold a conversation.” [09:56]

Despite the urgency, fear lingered as they awaited further help, with Yvette repeatedly asking when help would arrive:

“When is the help coming? And we just kept saying, they're coming, they're coming.” [10:05]

The rescue operation culminated with Yvette being airlifted to the hospital, where she experienced a fleeting moment of peace looking at the night sky:

“And it was a beautiful night. And I do remember looking out at the sky and being up in the air and feeling safe.” [11:03]

Recovery and Emotional Impact

Yvette details her severe injuries, including multiple gunshot wounds and extensive surgeries, leading to long-term physical pain and nerve damage:

“I was shot at least four times, and then several bullets grazed my head. One of them came in behind it, up higher, and came all the way through my torso to my inner thigh.” [13:13]

The emotional toll on both Yvette and Zach's family is profound. Zach's mother recounts the moment she learned of her son's shooting and the ensuing grief:

“I could not believe that he could do that to us again... It’s like being kicked in the stomach so hard.” [37:14]

Yvette shares her struggle with survivor's guilt and the lasting psychological scars, expressing a shift from being a trusting individual to harboring deep-seated fears:

“Before the shooting... after the shooting, I was terrified of everyone. Didn’t trust. Didn’t want to socialize, didn’t want to leave my house.” [23:53]

Investigation and Arrest of the Perpetrator

The investigation quickly zeroed in on Jorge Benvenuto, a 19-year-old immigrant from Uruguay. His erratic behavior and fascination with death raised suspicions:

“Investigators say Jorge Benvenuto had developed a fascination with death in recent weeks.” [17:08]

Benvenuto was apprehended at a gas station, attempting to buy cookies with Zach's wallet:

“They knew immediately who it was because he had taken my brother's car and left his car behind. He also had my brother's wallet.” [17:36]

During an interview, Benvenuto revealed his motives, expressing a desire to experience the power of taking life, albeit with a hint of regret over his actions:

“He was almost disappointed that this gun that he treasured and thought so highly of let him down.” [18:04]

Court Proceedings and Plea Bargain

The court process was emotionally taxing for the victims and their families. Yvette and Zach's mother testified against Benvenuto, expressing their anguish and the desire for justice:

Zach's Mother: “He just looked like this normal kid... When I saw him in the courtroom, I realized he has no soul.” [28:04]
Yvette Rodier: “I had to point him out and lift my finger, and it just shook while I’m pointing at him, that this is the man who did it.” [29:36]

Initially seeking the death penalty, the families were confronted with a plea bargain offered by Benvenuto, who pleaded for life imprisonment without parole, citing depression as a mitigating factor:

Zach's Mother: “I don’t want my son's trial turned into a freak show. He deserves more dignity than that.” [33:16]
Yvette Rodier: “Having him just spend the rest of his life in prison is fine with me.” [33:38]

The families opted for the plea bargain to avoid prolonging the ordeal and to spare their son a public trial:

Zach Snarr: “That's why we, as a family, decided to take the plea bargain.” [32:24]

Aftermath and Moving Forward

Years after the tragic event, both Yvette and Zach's family have sought ways to heal and find purpose. Yvette pursued a career in law, dedicating herself to aiding victims of crime:

“I realized that the law is where a lot of good can happen for people. And I decided to go to law school and am now able to help people in the law side of the criminal justice system.” [40:40]

Zach's family continues to honor his memory, with his legacy living on through his children:

Zach Snarr: “I miss Zach and I think about him all the time. I have three children. My oldest is Zachary Taylor Davis.” [41:54]

Yvette reflects on the enduring bond formed between her and Zach's family, emphasizing resilience and the pursuit of a meaningful life despite the shadows of the past:

“I really value when she tells me that she's happy that I'm here. I don't deserve it, but I appreciate it a lot.” [39:15]

Conclusion

"Under The Moonlight" masterfully intertwines personal testimonies with investigative insights, painting a comprehensive picture of a night that forever changed lives. The episode highlights themes of loss, resilience, justice, and the long road to healing. Through poignant narratives and emotional honesty, it underscores the profound human impact of violent crime and the enduring quest for closure and peace.

Notable Quotes:

• Yvette Rodier: “I was terrified of everyone. Didn’t trust. Didn’t want to socialize, didn’t want to leave my house.” [23:53]

• Zach's Mother: “I will never, ever forget that day in court. Just knowing I was going to see Jorge Benvenuto for the first time scared me to death.” [28:12]

• Zach Snarr: “I miss Zach and I think about him all the time. I have three children. My oldest is Zachary Taylor Davis.” [41:54]

• Yvette Rodier: “I don't say his name out loud, and I never will. I've had five operations total... I would much rather have a surgery every other week than have to feel the survivor's guilt.” [37:33]

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the key moments, emotional journeys, and pivotal events discussed in the "Under The Moonlight" episode of 48 Hours. Through structured sections and highlighted quotes, it offers a clear and engaging overview for those who haven't listened to the episode.