← 99% Invisible
Loading summary
Transcript154 lines
- [00:01]
Edward Jones
What does it mean to be rich? Maybe it's about measuring life and laugh lines and time. Not by how much you have, but by how often it stands still. At Edward Jones, we believe the key to being rich is knowing what counts. Our dedicated financial advisors provide one on one support meeting you where you are through all of life's changes. Because what matters most is living a life you love. Let's find your rich together. Edward Jones Member, SIPC this episode is.
- [00:32]
Roman Mars
Brought to you by Progressive where drivers who save by switching save nearly $750 on average. Plus auto customers qualify for an average of 7 discounts. Quote now@progressive.com to see if you could save Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates national average 12 month savings of $744 by new customer surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2022 and May 2023. Potential savings will vary. Discounts not available in all states. This is 99% invisible. I'm Roman Mars. In the Tempelhof Schunenberg district of Berlin, there's an enormous concrete structure that sits across the street from a supermarket. It's obscured by trees, surrounded by residential apartments and gently flecked with German graffiti.
- [01:20]
Vivian Ley
Okay, check 12. It is 8:34am I am quite possibly the most jet lagged I've ever been in my entire life and I'm waiting for my Uber or as they say here in Germany, my u bah.
- [01:36]
Roman Mars
We sent 99pi producer Vivian Ley there to check it out.
- [01:40]
Vivian Ley
Jet lag be damned. I met up with Hanna Fischer and Vincent Bruckman. Hanna is the curator and deputy director for the Tempelhof Schunaburg Museums and Vincent is a journalist and tour guide. They were there to show me around a curious neighborhood landmark. From afar it kind of looks like a derelict brutalist grain silo. Is it a popular site for people to visit this one? Yes, it's the most popular and it is the least aesthetically pleasing.
- [02:09]
Hanna Fischer
Yeah, that is true.
- [02:10]
Vivian Ley
Yeah.
- [02:12]
Roman Mars
This structure is a bit hard to describe because there's literally nothing else like it in the world. On the surface it's a very, very big, very, very heavy cylindrical block of solid concrete about the height of a four story building.
- [02:27]
Vincent Bruckman
This concrete 12,650 I think tons of concrete.
- [02:34]
Roman Mars
And sitting underneath those 12,650 tons of concrete is a narrow chamber about 8ft in diameter that descends 60ft into the ground.
- [02:45]
Vincent Bruckman
There's a ladder here that we can't use now unfortunately. And then it goes I think 18 meters into the ground.
- [02:52]
Vivian Ley
Have you guys ever Crawled down there? No, not allowed. This entire structure was designed to test the soil in this area of Berlin. That chamber was once an observation area where researchers measured how the soil below was responding to the pressure exerted by the weight of the cylinder on top of it. Whether the cylinder itself was shifting, sinking into the ground. Exciting stuff like that.
- [03:16]
Roman Mars
People from all over the world come to Berlin to see what is essentially an abandoned soil testing research tool. And the name of this unusual tourist site is just about as easy to pronounce as it is to describe.
- [03:29]
Vincent Bruckman
In German, it's Schwerbe last Tungstkopper. And in English, then it's the heavy load bearing body. Does it make sense in English, even?
- [03:37]
Vivian Ley
It's like, not entirely. The Schwerbe Lastingskorper is kind of a tongue twister, but luckily there's a few other simpler nicknames for it. The cylinder, the concrete cylinder. The concrete mushroom, because it sort of looks like a mushroom.
- [03:52]
Roman Mars
But locals in the area have referred to it by a much more nefarious nickname.
- [03:57]
Vincent Bruckman
It used to be the nickname Nazi Klotz. A klotz is like a heavy kind of stone that you put onto something and Nazi. So it's kind of like Nazi block.
- [04:06]
Vivian Ley
The Nazi block, the Schwerrbelastingskorper is not famous for what it does, but who built it. This big crumbling piece of concrete was actually the first step in a monstrous urban planning scheme dreamed up by Adolf Hitler.
- [04:25]
Roman Mars
Thankfully, that plan never materialized. Now this Nazi block is one of the only remaining monuments to the Third Reich's most colossal architectural failure.
- [04:39]
Vivian Ley
There was a phrase that leaders in the Third Reich said about architecture, that it was wrte aus stein, or words in stone. It means that architecture has a specific ability to bypass language and reasoning, to have a direct impact on a person's emotions. If you've ever walked into a family friend's farmhouse style home and immediately felt a sense of coziness or had your breath taken away while standing at the top of the Empire State Building, then you know exactly what I'm talking about. Architecture can move you and shape your actions in ways that you aren't even aware of.
- [05:13]
Roman Mars
Hitler not only understood this innate power about architecture, he weaponized it.
- [05:19]
Despinus Strategis
When we think about architecture and weaponization, especially around the Third Reich, you know, you might think about the Atlantic Wall or bomb shelters.
- [05:31]
Vivian Ley
This is Despinus Strategis, an architectural historian at the University at Buffalo.
- [05:36]
Despinus Strategis
But there are a lot of ways in which architecture can be instrumentalized for ideological purposes that are not maybe as Obvious, but that can be very powerful.
- [05:54]
Roman Mars
Hitler was infatuated with art and architecture enough that he was famously rejected from art school a couple of times. Even early on, he spoke openly about the ways architecture and power are intertwined.
- [06:06]
Despinus Strategis
If you look at Mein Kampf, and I hope you won't, but if you want to torture yourself. In Mein Kampf, he writes about the importance of architecture, and particularly the importance of architecture to create the Volksgemeinschaft. And the Volksgemeinschaft is this absolutely central concept in National Socialism. It is the racially unified community.
- [06:35]
Vivian Ley
The Volksgemeinschaft literally translates to people's community. And the concept was central to Hitler's racist and anti Semitic ideology. It claimed that there was a racial hierarchy, which there isn't, and a quote, ideal way of German life. Again, which. Which there isn't.
- [06:53]
Roman Mars
Look, Hitler was an ahistorical idiot who made a number of false assertions. One of them was that the ancient Roman Empire represented the peak of human civilization and that Germans were, quote, racial ancestors of the Romans. And therefore at the top of that.
- [07:08]
Vivian Ley
Hierarchy, which they aren't.
- [07:11]
Despinus Strategis
Hitler's looking in particular at ancient Rome and more specifically at the public buildings, the state buildings of ancient Rome, the temples, the baths, the Coliseum. And he says that in its great monuments, a culture expresses its most profound values. It shapes the Volksgemeinschaft. And also he's thinking about the things that will remain when everything else fades away. And he says wars come and go, but it is the art and the architecture of a civilization that remains. So he's thinking about this long before he gets into power.
- [07:56]
Vivian Ley
In 1933, Hitler was appointed Chancellor of Germany and finally had the political power he needed to create these monuments.
- [08:04]
Roman Mars
He just needed an architect to actually build them.
- [08:07]
Vivian Ley
Could you tell me a little bit about Albert Speer? Like, how did I know it's how.
- [08:12]
Magnus Brechtgen
Many, how many hours would you like?
- [08:16]
Vivian Ley
This is Magnus Brechtgen, Deputy Director of the Institute for Contemporary History in Munich.
- [08:22]
Magnus Brechtgen
Albert Speer was a highly ambitious young architect. He was the son of an architect. His father made a lot of money. His mother had a lot of money. So Albert Speer was completely financially independent. He could do whatever he wanted.
- [08:41]
Vivian Ley
And what he wanted was the resources and backing of the Nazi Party.
- [08:46]
Roman Mars
Speer was sufficiently talented as an architect, but it was his charm and ruthless ambition that landed him in Hitler's orbit.
- [08:53]
Despinus Strategis
Albert Speer would magically appear whenever Hitler was coming to do a tour of the construction site. You know, a few minutes beforehand, there was Speer and he would join, you know, the architects and the patron and they would walk around the site and you know, the workmen would just kind of make jokes about this young hanger on. But Schwer was there to learn, like he was there to learn and to figure out what it was that Hitler wanted, what he liked, what he didn't like, and to be noticed.
- [09:33]
Vivian Ley
Speer was still a relatively young man when he had a streak of good luck. Hitler's top architect suddenly dropped dead at 28 years old. Speer was launched into the position of chief architect for the Third Reich.
- [09:46]
Roman Mars
Hitler apparently loved pageantry and Speer was more than happy to cater to his theatrical whims. He was tasked with staging the notorious Cathedral of Light display at the Nuremberg rally grounds and designing a new Reich Chancellery.
- [10:00]
Vivian Ley
Soon after, Hitler entrusted Speer with his most ambitious design project yet.
- [10:04]
Despinus Strategis
He wants a capital that is architecturally worthy of being the center of a global empire.
- [10:13]
Vivian Ley
In 1937, Hitler declared five cities as fewer cities, which meant that five cities, Berlin, Nuremberg, Munich, Hamburg and Linz would all become cultural capitals in a future Nazi dominated Europe.
- [10:27]
Roman Mars
Each city would offer its own special contribution towards the Third Reich. Linz, Hitler's favorite city, would become the center of culture. Munich would be the Nazi Party headquarters. Nuremberg would be the city of Nazi party rallies. Hamburg would be the capital of putting a piece of meat between two pieces of bread.
- [10:48]
Vivian Ley
Berlin would hold the highest title of them all. Hitler believed that Berlin would become the capital of his, quote, Greater Germanic Reich and the Nazi seat of power to the rest of the world.
- [10:58]
Roman Mars
But there was one glaring problem with Berlin carrying that particular title.
- [11:03]
Paul Kuric
Hitler did not like Berlin at all.
- [11:05]
Vivian Ley
This is Paul Kuric, assistant professor and postdoctoral fellow at the University of Michigan. Hitler understood that Berlin was an important city to the cause of National Socialism. It was the capital city of Germany and a cultural center populated by millions of people. But for Hitler, that culture was all wrong.
- [11:25]
Paul Kuric
Berlin was in the Weimar Republic became known in the 1920s as this kind of really progressive city with a lot of cabaret and people were kind of experimenting with different identities and sexualities and it was very decadent. So he did not like that at all. This kind of progressive environment, I don't.
- [11:47]
Vivian Ley
Know, it sounds pretty cool to me.
- [11:48]
Roman Mars
And outside of its politics, Hitler also hated the city on an aesthetic level.
- [11:53]
Paul Kuric
Berlin was kind of all over the place. It was the kind of the epitome of modernism. You know, there was Bauhaus and all of these styles that Hitler despised.
- [12:06]
Vivian Ley
Hitler's disdain for progressive Modernist Berlin meant that the entire city would have to be rebuilt from scratch. Hitler even proposed that once the complete urban redesign was finished, the city would be renamed Germania, a name that he believed evoked unity of the German people.
- [12:24]
Roman Mars
In 1937, Hitler gave Speer near complete control over all building projects throughout the city, and he was granted essentially unlimited budget and resources.
- [12:34]
Paul Kuric
Speer, as a matter of fact, had more power than anyone else when it came to building. So he always wanted more and more and more and bigger and bigger and bigger.
- [12:42]
Vivian Ley
This Berlin 2.0 was planned to be everything that the city was not. Rigidly symmetrical, ordered, devoid of color. And given Hitler's obsession with ancient Rome, the buildings would need to be stylistically reminiscent of Imperial Roman architecture.
- [12:58]
Roman Mars
But these buildings wouldn't just be neoclassical, they would be monumental, meaning that the city would be built on a massive scale, never before seen.
- [13:07]
Magnus Brechtgen
I mean, that's. It's just huge. It says there's no sophistication.
- [13:12]
Vivian Ley
Magnus Brechtkin, again, I mean, if we.
- [13:15]
Magnus Brechtgen
Talk about architectural history and how architects think buildings. Yeah, it's always about size, to form, to function, to human dimension and so on.
- [13:29]
Roman Mars
Yeah.
- [13:29]
Magnus Brechtgen
So it's a combination of finding the best formula when you build something, and this is just to make people quiet, to impress them, and to push with violent might away every kind of obstacle against your own ideological conviction.
- [13:50]
Roman Mars
When it came to architecture, Speer did not put much thought into creating a satisfying user experience for those living there. Instead, he focused on how these buildings would propagandize Hitler's beliefs, how they would intimidate, and, surprisingly, how they would eventually die.
- [14:08]
Paul Kuric
Yeah, it's the famous Ruinenwert theory or theories. He said the way he designed his buildings was, was with the foresight then, in thousands of years, they will just be ruins.
- [14:25]
Vivian Ley
Speer claimed to have conceived of a design principle that he called ruin value. Hitler and Speer believed that every empire comes to an end and the Third Reich would be no exception. Hitler used to marvel at the ancient Roman ruins, and he wanted civilizations of the future to do the same at his buildings by avoiding materials like steel rebar and concrete facades, which tend to erode in an ugly way as they break down. He thought their monuments could decay more gracefully that way. Even after the Third Reich ended, their pretty, pretty ruins would pass on their racist ideology long after they were gone.
- [15:04]
Paul Kuric
So kind of antiquity was coming together with the past, the present and the future. We're all becoming one. And that captures what the Nazis really believed.
- [15:22]
Vincent Bruckman
Yeah, so we're basically now on, on top of this platform, which is built next to the Schwerbelastungskoper. And we're basically at, on the same height as the top of the heavy load bearing body. So we can kind of have the panoramic view of Berlin and also what the National Socialists were planning to do.
- [15:41]
Vivian Ley
Back in the Tempelhof Schuneberg district of Berlin, I followed Vincent Brookman up a platform about 14 meters above street level. This weird concrete cylinder I'd come to Berlin to see was marked as the starting point of Speer's proposed redesign for the city.
- [15:56]
Vincent Bruckman
It's really important to understand that everything or most of what the National Socialists were planning was not constructed.
- [16:04]
Vivian Ley
Vincent showed me how Speer and Hitler planned for this Nazi megacity to be framed by two long intersecting axes, one of which would be a, quote, Avenue of splendors that ran 4.3 miles from south to north. It would serve as a celebratory parade route.
- [16:20]
Roman Mars
And looming at the end of this avenue would sit a structure that would define the city.
- [16:27]
Vincent Bruckman
This is basically where you can imagine or the direction where you can imagine this hall, Volkshalle, Great hall, hall of the People, which was kind of the center of the plans.
- [16:41]
Roman Mars
Years before he became leader of the Nazi Party, Hitler sketched two architectural drawings that he one day wanted to build. The first was a colossal Volkshalle, or People's Hall. It would have been a massive neoclassical assembly space inspired by the Pantheon, only, you know, bigger.
- [16:58]
Vivian Ley
The Volkshalle featured a copper dome that towered nearly 88 stories high and would have fit up to 180,000 spectators inside. For reference, that's nine times more people than can fit in the crypto.com arena.
- [17:13]
Vincent Bruckman
And they thought that even there was kind of a micro climate within the hall. If there were, I don't know, 150, 180,000 people within there, they were even thinking, if there were, I don't know, condensation clouds because there were just so many people in there. And you must imagine it was supposed to fit, like, almost 200,000 people, which is huge.
- [17:32]
Vivian Ley
It's just rain made of, like sweat and spit.
- [17:38]
Despinus Strategis
Yeah.
- [17:41]
Vincent Bruckman
Exactly.
- [17:43]
Roman Mars
At the beginning of the parade route would be the other monument that Hitler sketched. It was a triumphal arch commemorating the German soldiers killed in World War I. Structurally, he wanted it to be reminiscent of the Arc de Triomphe in Paris, only, you guessed it, bigger.
- [18:00]
Paul Kuric
This triumphal arch was planned as the southern gate to Germania, the new Berlin. And so all the tourists, international tourists, would have arrived at this train station in the south and then walked up to the arch. And then they would have seen in the distance, on the other side of town, this huge congregation hall.
- [18:19]
Roman Mars
The buildings would be built on a scale never before seen in human history, which came with one very obvious structural engineering problem.
- [18:28]
Paul Kuric
There was no data supporting the fact. Will the ground even carry these monstrous monuments?
- [18:35]
Roman Mars
The ground in Berlin is very difficult to build on. The city sits on swampland, so it has mushy, gushy soil.
- [18:42]
Vivian Ley
You know what doesn't pair well with all that mushy, gushy soil? The weight of the largest buildings ever conceived. The Triumphal Arch in particular, was exponentially more complicated because all of the weight of the entire monument would be concentrated onto narrow pillars. This meant that the ground pressure exerted by the arch would be incredibly intense.
- [19:02]
Paul Kuric
And if you want to build the biggest of everything, well, you need technological solutions for that.
- [19:09]
Roman Mars
And Speer's technological solution was to build Schofen Balanskorper. Schwerr Balandstandskorper.
- [19:18]
Paul Kuric
It's Schwehr Belastungsk. So schwerr Belastungsk.
- [19:27]
Vivian Ley
In 1938, Speer was assigned to carry out any testing necessary to construct Hitler's mega monuments. And part of that testing was the construction of the Schwerbelastingskorper, that heavy concrete cylinder.
- [19:40]
Roman Mars
The reason why it was so big and so heavy was because the weight of all that concrete was supposed to simulate the pressure of one of the arch's pillars pushing down onto the ground. Those 12,650 tons weigh more than the Eiffel Tower, the Statue of Liberty, and the Christ the Redeemer statue combined.
- [20:00]
Paul Kuric
And also in terms of soil pressure, it even puts more pressure on the ground than the Cheops pyramid in Egypt. So it is really extraordinarily heavy.
- [20:15]
Roman Mars
Not much is known about the actual construction process of the cylinder. The Nazi party kept details of this megacity project under a tight lid, mainly because the complete reconstruction of Berlin would have demolished somewhere between 50 to 100,000 homes in the middle of a housing crisis.
- [20:32]
Vivian Ley
That was, of course, not even close to the worst consequence of Berlin's urban redesign. It was Jewish Berliners who were targeted first for deportation, and the labor and materials for the project would be supplied at a horrifically inhumane cost.
- [20:47]
Vincent Bruckman
There were a lot of people who suffered from it. For example, the Jewish population of Berlin, but also the forced laborers who had to build these projects, and also the inmates of the concentration camps who are responsible for bringing the building material. For example, like the stones and the bricks.
- [21:07]
Roman Mars
In 1941 the concrete cylinder was completed. But by that time it didn't even matter anymore.
- [21:14]
Vincent Bruckman
The problem for the air quotes problem air quotes for the National Socialist was that the war started and then there was the question of how to, how to proceed.
- [21:27]
Vivian Ley
By this point, the US had entered World War II and Hitler's makeover for Berlin would have to be tabled.
- [21:35]
Roman Mars
Soon after, Speer was promoted from general building inspector to Minister of Armaments and Munitions. He was responsible for maximizing war production. So rather than using slave laborers to build Germania, he, he used them to produce weapons and war material for the German war effort.
- [21:51]
Vivian Ley
Speer was no longer an architect. It was his job to make sure the Third Reich could maintain its military operations. And it was a role that he was unfortunately very good at.
- [22:03]
Magnus Brechtgen
He is responsible for keeping the war going for months on end when the war was lost and he knew that the war was lost. In, in the last year of the war, more people died than in the previous five years combined. Every day the war was prolonged. On average, more than 16,000 people died per day on every single day. So every day the war went on, another 16,000 people were killed.
- [22:38]
Roman Mars
Killed.
- [22:39]
Magnus Brechtgen
Speer knew this and he went on regardless. The tribunal is of the opinion that Spear's activities do not amount to initiating, planning or preparing wars of aggression or of conspiring to that end. He became the head of the Arm and Industry. Well, after all the wars.
- [23:02]
Vivian Ley
In 1945, after the war ended, Albert Speer appeared before the court at Nuremberg along with 20 other National Socialist leaders.
- [23:11]
Roman Mars
But over the course of his trial, Speer once again used his charm and charisma to get his way. He condemned Hitler and offered the Allied Council valuable details about how he achieved such a productive war economy for Germany. In the end, he was only sentenced to 20 years in prison.
- [23:28]
Vivian Ley
I mean, he did spend 20 years in prison. He was found guilty. But do you, in your opinion, did you get away with it?
- [23:36]
Magnus Brechtgen
Yes, of course, of course. I think most people who knew what Speer had done and himself knew what he had done. You see his reaction, there's a film and his reaction. And he saw this kind of instinctively knew, I'll survive. Yes, sure, he got away with it, you know.
- [23:58]
Roman Mars
While serving out his 20 year sentence, Speer authored a best selling memoir about his time as quote, Hitler's architect. He filled it with claims of remorse and left out the extent of the part he played in the war. By the time he was released from prison in 1966, some historians even referred to him as, quote, the good Nazi.
- [24:20]
Magnus Brechtgen
Hitler said it to me, you are my architect and you will do it for me. I was on the way to be one of the most famous aytech in Europe, if I would have succeeded in the world.
- [24:37]
Vivian Ley
Speer and Hitler's monumental world capital was a city that never came to be. Almost no piece of architecture from this grand urban redesign of Berlin survived, except one thing. It wasn't even possible to tear it down after the Second World War because it's too big.
- [24:55]
Roman Mars
And Albert Schwerr's concrete cylinder, what would.
- [24:59]
Vivian Ley
It take to tear it down? A lot of.
- [25:08]
Vincent Bruckman
A lot of dynamite. Yeah.
- [25:10]
Vivian Ley
The Schwerrbelassingskorper was a 12,650ton block of solid concrete in the middle of a city surrounded by residential buildings and train tracks. So blowing it up with explosives after the war was out of the question. Berlin was sort of stuck with.
- [25:32]
Hanna Fischer
Wasn'T really used by anybody. And also except the scientists, the engineers, no one really had any interest in it.
- [25:42]
Vivian Ley
This is Michael Richter, an architect and one of the leading historians of the Schwerbelastungskorper.
- [25:50]
Hanna Fischer
So it was more of a pragmatic approach to this building.
- [25:55]
Vivian Ley
Richter says that within just a few years of World War II ending, the German Society for Soil Mechanics picked up the geological research where the fascist structural engineers left off, only minus the fascism. For decades after the war, civilian scientists quietly used the cylinder to generate lots of data on how to build very big buildings on top of really squishy soil. It's actually been helpful for structural engineers all over the world.
- [26:29]
Hanna Fischer
It also has a high scientific significance because a lot of the information that we know today about building in this kind of soil, we actually have from the research that has been done on this cylinder. So between 1948 up until the mid-80s, the experiments that the engineers did on this specific structure is where a lot of the information today comes from.
- [26:53]
Vivian Ley
Why is it that in the 1980s it stopped being used?
- [27:02]
Hanna Fischer
No one had any questions left.
- [27:07]
Vivian Ley
In 1983, having run out its use, the concrete cylinder was pretty much abandoned by researchers and fell into disrepair.
- [27:15]
Roman Mars
It sat neglected for about a decade until the district realized that this space could be of some use to teach people what almost came of Berlin. The cylinder was listed as a protected monument in 1995, and today it's the only tangible relic of the National Socialists master plan for Berlin.
- [27:35]
Vivian Ley
Even though it's a protected monument, the Schwerbelastenskorper was never built to last. It wasn't constructed with the best materials, since it wasn't even supposed to be seen. So now the concrete is crumbling. The district has even had to set up netting around the outside of the cylinder so that chunks of it don't fall onto people's heads.
- [27:55]
Vincent Bruckman
I think it would be sad if this structure would not exist anymore, because I think actually it is a little embarrassing for the National Socialists because there are a few other things but what is really visible from this plan in Germania to changing this megalomanic world capital, and then you come here and it's just basically this like concrete block.
- [28:22]
Vivian Ley
When Speer dreamed of the ruins his buildings would eventually become, he probably wasn't anticipating that they would be ruins so soon or take the form of this decaying concrete cylinder. But in a way it's the perfect object to preserve Hitler's grand urban planning vision. There is no beauty, there is no glory. It's just an ugly piece of history set in stone.
- [28:50]
Roman Mars
More with Vivian after the break.
- [28:54]
Vincent Bruckman
Every.
- [28:55]
Roman Mars
26 seconds, a burglary takes place in the U.S. according to FBI data. Now that may seem like a lot or a little, but mostly I don't want to do the math on that at all. And you can avoid that worry with SimpliSafe. ###'s proactive security system SimpliSafe helps to stop threats before they even have a chance to break in. SimpliSafe's Active Guard Outdoor Protection uses AI powered cameras backed by live professional monitoring agents to monitor your property and detect suspicious activity. If someone's lurking around or acting suspiciously, those agents see and talk to them in real time, activate spotlights and even contact the police, all before they have a chance to get inside your home. Here's the thing about Simplisafe. You don't want to trade one worry, the fear of break in with another worry, the fear that your security system isn't working right or that you're overpaying for it. With SimpliSafe, I'm confident about all of it, from the design to the functionality to the price. Visit simplisafe.com invisible to claim 50% off your new system with a professional monitoring plan and your first month free. That's simplisafe.com invisible there's no safe like simplisafe. Article makes it effortless to create a stylish, long lasting home at an unbeatable price, whatever your personal style may be. Article offers a curated range of mid century, modern, coastal and Scandi inspired pieces that not only shine on their own, but also pair seamlessly with nearly any other Article product. Their carefully selected collections feature high quality, meaningful pieces that will stand the test of time. There is no filler. Every item is chosen for its craftsmanship, design and lasting value. My house is like an article furniture longitudinal study. I sleep in an article bed my wife Joy works at and we eat at an article dining room table and we sit in article chairs. And it has been this way for years and years and years. All the furniture I've ever gotten from Article is still in service and performing at its peak. Article is offering our listeners $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. To claim, visit article.com 99 and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout. That's article.com 99 for $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. It's 2025 if your B2B marketing strategy for the new year doesn't include improving your ad targeting, your ads can get lost in the noise. With LinkedIn ads, you can precisely reach the professionals who are more likely to find your ad relevant. LinkedIn Ads allows you to build the right relationships, drive results and reach your customers in a respectful environment. You'll be able to drive results with targeting and measurement tools built specifically for B2B in technology, LinkedIn generated two to five times higher return on ad spend than other social media platforms. And 79% of B2B content marketers said LinkedIn produces the best results for paid media. Start converting your B2B audience into high quality leads today. They'll even give you a $100 credit on your next campaign. Go to LinkedIn.com Invisible to claim your credit. That's LinkedIn.com Invisible. Terms and conditions apply. LinkedIn the place to Be to Be this podcast is sponsored by Squarespace. Squarespace is the all in one website platform for entrepreneurs to stand out and succeed online. Whether you're just starting out or managing a growing brand, Squarespace makes it easy to create a beautiful website, engage with your audience and sell anything from products to content to time, all in one place. All on your terms, you can get 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain@squarespace.com Invisible now introducing Design Intelligence from Squarespace. Combining two decades of industry leading design expertise with cutting edge AI technology to unlock your strongest creative potential. Design Intelligence empowers anyone to build a beautiful, more personalized website tailored to their unique needs and craft a bespoke digital identity to use across one's entire online presence. I personally found that Squarespace is A way to have a website with all the bells and whistles without knowing how to make a bell or a whistle. It's that easy. Go to squarespace.com for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch squarespace.com invisible to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. So we are back with 99pi producer Vivian Ley, who just brought us that story. Vivian, how are you doing?
- [33:13]
Vivian Ley
I am exhausted, Roman. How are you? Thank you for asking, by the way.
- [33:18]
Roman Mars
I'm okay. Yeah. Okay, well, so what do you want to talk about today?
- [33:23]
Vivian Ley
Yeah, I don't know if I necessarily want to talk about this. It's just something that has to be addressed. But, Roman, as you are aware, on the first day of his second term in office, Donald Trump issued a memorandum called Promoting Beautiful Federal Civic Architecture. It's basically, at its core, in order to promote the use of, quote, traditional and classical architecture for civic buildings.
- [33:47]
Roman Mars
And this is something that he did back in 2020 at the end of his term, right?
- [33:51]
Vivian Ley
Yeah. Yeah. So Donald Trump signed a version of this executive order in, like, the waning days of his first term in, like, December of 2020. I remember even back then, everyone here at 99pi were just like, what the is he talking about? But Trump claims that the purpose of the order was to, quote, uplift and beautify public spaces and ennoble the United States. Biden overturned it pretty much soon after he got into office in 2021, but now it is 2025, and we are back, baby.
- [34:28]
Roman Mars
So even back in 2020, what was Trump trying to accomplish with this order?
- [34:35]
Vivian Ley
So, basically, Trump wants to make classical architecture the preferred style of all federal buildings. The founding fathers, you know, famously wanted the design of the Capitol to evoke ancient Greece and Rome. And so classical was the de facto style for about a century and a half. But, of course, tastes change over time. So in 1962, the GSA, which is the agency that oversees federal property, revised its guiding principles for federal architecture. And they stated that an official style should be avoided and that, quote, design must flow from the architectural profession to the government and not vice versa. And so you see that the most common style for federal buildings built between the 1950s and the 1970s actually was brutalism. And, Roman, you and I both know that brutalism has been a very divisive style for a very long time.
- [35:29]
Roman Mars
For sure. For sure.
- [35:30]
Vivian Ley
Someone else who apparently hates it is, of course, Donald Trump. And his argument is that we in this country have stopped building beautiful buildings. An early draft for the 2020 executive order was actually titled, quote, making Federal Buildings Beautiful Again, which is very on the nose.
- [35:52]
Roman Mars
Right. I mean, it's pretty much echoing the rhetoric that Trump always says, which is about America returning to greatness. So returning to a classical style of architecture, in his eyes, is the return to the glory of the past.
- [36:06]
Vivian Ley
Yes. Now, if you listen to the story that we just played, you might already into it why many people are concerned with this particular rhetoric. Critics have argued that when the far right and or white supremacists push for a return to, quote, traditional values of classical architecture, they specifically mean a return to the values of traditionally white, traditionally European, traditionally Christian heritage. And the styles that deviate from that are bad.
- [36:37]
Roman Mars
Right. And since these federal buildings are the buildings that represent the United States, it's easy to see how the arguments against diverse architectural styles are arguments against diversity writ large.
- [36:51]
Vivian Ley
Yes, it's very culture war, but make it architecture.
- [36:55]
Roman Mars
Yeah.
- [36:55]
Vivian Ley
This has basically become a debate about what American identity is supposed to look like.
- [37:01]
Roman Mars
Yeah, yeah. So there's been a lot of noise on either side of this order, but I'm curious what the real world impacts are of this executive Order, because actually, there's not a lot of federal buildings being built at any one moment. So what does it actually mean?
- [37:17]
Vivian Ley
So, like, first of all, I do think that putting limitations on creativity is bad. Also, who is Trump to define what beauty is? To be sure, yes, I have seen his buildings. They are hideous. Yes. But, you know, I will admit that this so far hasn't been the most consequential move he's made since getting back into office, mostly because he's done so many terrible things. As of recording this, the GSA is facing much bigger problems. So we will have to see how this will be implemented. There has been some speculation that one thing it could have a direct impact on is the J. Edgar Hoover Building, which is FBI headquarters. It's this big, blocky, brutalist concrete building with these perfectly aligned square windows, and it kind of looks like a house of waffles. Like, not. Not a waffle house, but like a house made out of waffles.
- [38:08]
Roman Mars
That's right.
- [38:09]
Vivian Ley
So it has apparently been falling apart for quite some time. And the plan has been to rebuild a new facility in Greenbelt, Maryland. But Trump has been very vocal about this posting in all caps. The new FBI building should be built in Washington, D.C. not Maryland, and be the centerpiece of my plan to totally renovate and rebuild our capital city into the most beautiful and safest anywhere in the world. So there's that that might be indirectly impacted by this.
- [38:38]
Roman Mars
Yeah, that is very reminiscent to the story we just heard. I mean, to me what is interesting is that the stories behind these design choices are all kind of based on non truths. I mean, what we see in the main story and from this executive order is a kind of cherry picking of history that is just wrong. I mean what Hitler and Trump and even the founding fathers, what they did was kind of use architecture to tell kind of incorrect and pretty much ahistoric version of what the past was like. I mean, ancient Greece did not look like the white austere Lincoln Memorial. It was full of color and it was chaotic and just the paint just wore away. And so we see it as sort of monochromatic and sort of has this sort of like august bearing, but like it really was a mix of things. So not only is it sort of problematic in its execution, it's also just kind of just wrong on the face of it, which is sort of, you know, I don't know. I don't know if that's the most important part of it. Maybe the values are more important than them being wrong about it, but it's still like it's doubly wrong.
- [39:45]
Vivian Ley
Yes. And you know, I will say that the debate with classical architecture today, it's become more of a political battle than about aesthetics at this point. And I don't necessarily think that if you think that the Parthenon looks nice, that you are a racist, or if you hate the FBI headquarters, you know, it doesn't mean that you're not progressive. But the thing that I've run into over and over again while reporting the story is that architecture is always political and you can't separate the two. So you know, what you build, where you build it, who's it for and how it expresses your values. It's all political, man.
- [40:28]
Roman Mars
That's right. That's right. So yeah, I totally agree. When I go to Washington D.C. and I see the Capitol building in particular, it awes me. Like it does the job that it's supposed to do. And I think that is a great and noble thing to feel like this sense of, of permanence and strength and all that stuff that's centered on the US Capitol building, I totally feel those things. So there's nothing wrong with that. But if somebody comes up to you, one of these trad architecture bros comes and talks to you about the values of traditional architecture, man, turn on your heel and walk the other direction. Because that point of view is a linked trait to a bunch of even more. More horrible ideas and ideologies. So just, just walk away.
- [41:12]
Vivian Ley
For sure. For sure.
- [41:14]
Roman Mars
Thank you, Vivian.
- [41:15]
Vivian Ley
Thanks, Roman.
- [41:20]
Roman Mars
99% invisible was produced this week by Vivian Le, edited by Joe Rosenberg, mixed by Martin Gonzalez, music by Swan Rial, George Langford and apm Fact checking by Graham Hacha Translation and tape sync by Sara Zerea Husheriha Special thanks this week to Paul Keurek and the Berlin Underworlds Association. Kathy Tuitz, our executive producer, Kurt Kolsted is the digital director. Delaney hall is our senior editor. The rest of the team includes Chris Farube, Jason De Leon, Emmett Fitzgerald, Christopher Johnson, Lashma Dawn, Kelly Prime, Jacob Medina Gleason and me, roman Mars. The 99% invisible logo was created by Stefan Lawrence. We are part of the SiriusXM podcast family now, headquartered six blocks north in the Pandora building in beautiful uptown Oakland, California. You can find us all on Bluesky. That's where we're meeting with the public these days, as well as our own Discord server, where we have like, private discussions about the power broker, about architecture, about flags, about this and that. There's a link to that Discord server as well as every past episode of 99pi@99pi.org I know, I know. This is this. I need to get. I literally can't see this. Chauffam. Balance Corpor Schwar Balance Dun Scorper. Schwar balance dong. Scorper. Schwar Balance dong Scorpar.