A Book with Legs Podcast Summary

Episode: Padraic Scanlan - Rot: An Imperial History of the Irish Famine
Host: Cole Smead & Conroe Callahan Connor
Guest: Padraic Scanlan
Release Date: June 2, 2025

Introduction

In this compelling episode of A Book with Legs, hosted by Cole Smead and Conroe Callahan Connor of Smead Capital Management, the focus shifts to a harrowing yet pivotal chapter in Irish history—the Great Famine. The guest, Padraic Scanlan, an esteemed Associate Professor at the University of Toronto, delves into his latest work, Rot: An Imperial History of the Irish Famine. With a rich academic background from Princeton University and a history of insightful publications, Scanlan provides a nuanced exploration of the socioeconomic and political factors that exacerbated the famine's impact on Ireland.

Background and Motivation

[02:27] Padraic Scanlan:
"I had sort of a personal impetus to think a little bit about my own relationship to Irishness and my own relationship to the British Empire and Ireland's relationship to the British Empire."

Scanlan discusses his initial avoidance of Irish history due to his focus on British labor history. Personal family research and contemporary events, particularly the COVID-19 pandemic, reignited his interest in Ireland's past, leading to the development of Rot. The pandemic's parallels with the famine underscored the complexity and enduring vulnerabilities within Irish society.

Ireland's Historical Relationship with England

[06:44] Padraic Scanlan:
"Ireland has been under some form of English rule since shortly after the Norman invasions in the 11th century."

Scanlan provides a succinct overview of Ireland's subjugation by England, highlighting key historical events:

• Norman Invasion (11th Century): Introduction of the Anglo-Norman aristocracy.
• Cromwellian Conquest (1650s): Attempted ethnic cleansing of Irish Catholics.
• Acts of Union (1801): Political integration into the United Kingdom without economic empowerment, exacerbating existing vulnerabilities.

He emphasizes that despite nominal independence, Ireland functioned effectively as a colony, with its parliament subordinate to Westminster and its economy heavily reliant on agricultural exports to Britain. This setup laid the groundwork for severe economic disparities and social unrest.

Landlord-Tenant Dynamics in 18th Century Ireland

[12:25] Padraic Scanlan:
"It's a kind of pyramid structure where the landlord owns large tracts of land, and tenants rent smaller plots, often too small to sustain themselves."

The discussion delves into the hierarchical and exploitative land ownership system:

• Aristocratic Landlords: Often absentee owners who maintained feudal-like estates.
• Land Agents: Professional managers handling day-to-day operations and tenant relations.
• Farmers and Cottiers: Sub-tenants renting minimal land, struggling to pay rent.
• Middlemen and Gombeen Men: Loan sharks and intermediaries extracting additional economic rent.

This convoluted system created a precarious environment where economic downturns, like the famine, led to widespread hardship and social collapse.

The Role of the Potato in Irish Society

[50:50] Padraic Scanlan:
"The potato was both a lifeline and a vulnerability for the Irish poor."

Scanlan explores the centrality of the potato in the Irish diet and economy:

• Staple Crop: Essential for subsistence, enabling larger families.
• Monoculture Vulnerability: Overreliance on a single crop made Ireland particularly susceptible to the potato blight (Phytophthora infestans).
• Cultural Significance: Potatoes were ingrained in Irish cultural practices, such as the expectation of sharing surplus during harvest.

The potato's dual nature as both a sustenance source and an economic tool underscores the complexity of the famine's impact.

Famine Relief Policies and British Inaction

[16:53] Padraic Scanlan:
"The British government's response was a mix of ineffective public works and restrictive grain imports."

The conversation critiques the British administration's famine relief strategies:

• Importing Grain: Attempted to alleviate hunger without altering the underlying economic structures, ensuring continued dependency.
• Public Works Projects: Low-paying, non-improving jobs that offered minimal relief and often exacerbated poverty.
• Economic Policies: Favoring market discipline over humanitarian aid, influenced by Malthusian theories that viewed charity as counterproductive.

Scanlan argues that these policies failed to address the systemic issues, leading to mass starvation and emigration.

Social Impacts and Human Suffering

[88:46] Padraic Scanlan:
"The famine was not just about crop failure but about the collapse of social and economic systems."

Several poignant topics emerge:

• Social Strain: Public works projects were cruel and ineffective, forcing desperate individuals into futile labor.
• Rumors of Cannibalism: Reflect the extreme desperation and moral narratives imposed by suffering communities.
• Emigration: Mass departure as the only means of survival for many, further destabilizing Irish society.
• Psychological Toll: Instances of suicide and severe mental distress among both the afflicted and the administrators.

These elements paint a grim picture of human resilience under systemic oppression and natural disaster.

Concluding Reflections and Future Outlook

[96:34] Padraic Scanlan:
"Humanity has a propensity to repeat its mistakes, but there is also room for hope in adaptation and resilience."

Scanlan offers a historian's perspective on cyclical human behaviors and the lessons from the famine:

• Historical Patterns: Recognition that certain human tendencies persist, often leading to repeated crises.
• Adaptation: The Irish diaspora's resilience and ability to flourish despite historical adversities.
• Cautionary Outlook: Awareness of the potential for future catastrophes if systemic issues remain unaddressed.

He emphasizes the importance of understanding history to inform present and future actions, highlighting the enduring relevance of the famine's lessons.

Notable Quotes

• Padraic Scanlan [02:27]:
  "It was a sort of personal impetus to think a little bit about my own relationship to Irishness and my own relationship to the British Empire and Ireland's relationship to the British Empire."

• Padraic Scanlan [06:44]:
  "Ireland has been under some form of English rule since shortly after the Norman invasions in the 11th century."

• Padraic Scanlan [12:25]:
  "It's a kind of pyramid structure where the landlord owns large tracts of land, and tenants rent smaller plots, often too small to sustain themselves."

• Padraic Scanlan [50:50]:
  "The potato was both a lifeline and a vulnerability for the Irish poor."

• Padraic Scanlan [16:53]:
  "The British government's response was a mix of ineffective public works and restrictive grain imports."

• Padraic Scanlan [88:46]:
  "The famine was not just about crop failure but about the collapse of social and economic systems."

• Padraic Scanlan [96:34]:
  "Humanity has a propensity to repeat its mistakes, but there is also room for hope in adaptation and resilience."

Final Thoughts

Rot: An Imperial History of the Irish Famine by Padraic Scanlan offers a meticulous examination of the Great Famine's roots, execution, and aftermath. Through economic analysis, social critique, and historical insight, Scanlan unravels the intricate web of factors that transformed a natural disaster into a human catastrophe. This episode serves as a profound reminder of the consequences of systemic neglect and the enduring strength of the human spirit amidst unparalleled adversity.

For listeners intrigued by the depths of this discussion, purchasing Rot is highly recommended to gain a comprehensive understanding of this pivotal historical event.

Connect with the Podcast:
Listen to A Book with Legs on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or your preferred podcast platform.
For book recommendations or to share your thoughts, email podcast@smeedcap.com or follow us on X (@smeedcap).