AdTechGod Pod: The Refresh News – June 9, 2025
Host: Kate
Release Date: June 9, 2025
Episode Title: The Refresh News: June 9 - Brand Safety Scandals, AI Missteps, and FTC Crackdowns
Introduction
In this episode of the AdTechGod Pod, host Kate delves into three major stories shaking the advertising technology landscape: a significant brand safety scandal, Meta's ambitious foray into AI-driven ad creation, and the Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) latest investigation into advertiser boycotts. Kate provides insightful analysis, backed by recent reports and her professional observations, offering listeners a comprehensive understanding of these pivotal issues.
1. Major Brand Safety Scandal: Ads on Inappropriate App X Shorts
Kate opens the discussion with a troubling revelation reported by Kendra Barnett of Adweek. Late last week, it was uncovered that prominent brands such as Verizon, Amazon, and Popeyes had their advertisements running on X Shorts, a highly ranked Android application. Disturbingly, X Shorts was found to feature sexually suggestive and racially offensive content, despite being rated as a teen-friendly app on Google Play.
Kate [02:15]: "When it comes to brand safety, the ad industry is relying on everyone to do their due diligence. But here's the thing. Time and time again, it's been proven that very few are actually doing their."
The issue was exacerbated by the app serving explicit content alongside banner and interstitial ads through major ad servers, including Meta's Audience Network, Amazon, and Epsilon. As a result of Barnett's report, Google swiftly removed X Shorts from the Play Store, and multiple ad platforms and brands took immediate action to block the app.
Kate emphasizes the systemic failures that allowed this breach in brand safety:
Kate [02:45]: "The app wasn't classified appropriately and Google didn't catch it, obviously, to some degree."
She underscores the dependency on top-tier platforms like Google, Meta, and Amazon to uphold adequate checkpoints for brand safety—a responsibility they are allegedly neglecting due to conflicting interests. This incident highlights the complexities and challenges within the programmatic advertising ecosystem, where ensuring brand safety remains a persistent struggle.
2. Meta's AI-Driven Ad Creation: Promise and Skepticism
Shifting focus, Kate addresses Meta's recent announcement to fully automate campaign creation and targeting using artificial intelligence. By the end of 2026, Meta intends to offer advertisers the capability to input a product image and budget, with AI handling the generation of complete ads—including imagery, video, and text—and determining optimal targeting across Facebook and Instagram platforms.
Kate [04:30]: "I'm skeptical of this application of AI. I just don't think we're at a point where the tools are legitimately smart and fine-tuned enough to do this successfully."
While recognizing the potential benefits for small and mid-sized businesses lacking creative resources, Kate voices significant concerns regarding creative control and the quality of AI-generated content. She recounts a personal anecdote highlighting the pitfalls:
Kate [05:05]: "I came across an ad from a race I'd run back in the fall. They were promoting the 2025 race with what was clearly very bad AI generated Creative. Many commenters were perplexed and upset, saying, why couldn't you have just used the plethora of race photography you surely have available to make these ads?"
The backlash from consumers points to a broader issue: the risk of generic, poorly executed AI-generated ads leading to consumer fatigue and diminished effectiveness, even from well-loved brands. Kate remains hopeful yet cautious, suggesting that AI's true value in ad creation will only be realized once it can genuinely understand and resonate with target audiences on a deeper level.
Kate [06:00]: "I'm an AI believer, but I'm also a believer that good creative will always be the most effective creative and brands should have control over how they're showing up, especially when they're paying for it."
3. FTC Investigation into Advertiser Boycotts: Implications for the Ad Industry
The final segment of the episode covers the FTC's initiation of an investigation into advertiser boycotts, probing whether coordinated efforts by advertisers to withdraw spending from specific platforms constitute anti-competitive behavior. This move aligns with the broader governmental push to enhance free speech, influencing how advertisers interact with content moderation policies and platform controversies.
The investigation has extended to organizations like Media Matters and Ad Fontes Media, with the FTC issuing civil investigative demands seeking detailed disclosures about their operations, communications, financials, and partnerships with entities such as the Interactive Advertising Bureau, Check My Ads, DoubleVerify, and IAS.
Kate [07:30]: "Choosing not to fund hate speech or misinformation is not censorship and also should not be controversial, but advertisers have found themselves in an era where it is."
Kate explores the delicate balance advertisers must maintain between supporting quality content and navigating the evolving landscape of content moderation. The FTC's scrutiny could have far-reaching consequences, potentially reshaping how brands make advertising decisions amidst social and political pressures and impacting the efficacy of media quality gatekeepers.
Kate [08:15]: "The investigation could have significant implications for how brands navigate social and political pressures in their advertising decisions, while also having serious implications for how effective our media quality gatekeepers and watchdogs are able to be."
Conclusion
Kate wraps up the episode by emphasizing the gravity of these stories and their deserving attention within the adtech community. She reiterates the need for heightened vigilance in brand safety, cautious optimism regarding AI advancements in advertising, and the importance of understanding regulatory impacts on the industry.
Kate [09:00]: "These are important stories that deserve more airtime, and I'm glad you joined us to talk about them. Catch you next week."
Note: This summary excludes sponsorship segments, intros, outros, and non-content sections to focus solely on the substantive discussions presented in the episode.