Against the Rules: The Big Short Companion
Episode: The FrontPoint Boys
Host: Michael Lewis with Lidia Jean Kott
Date: October 28, 2025
Overview
This episode of Against the Rules: The Big Short Companion revisits the real-life FrontPoint Partners traders whose story formed a core part of Michael Lewis’s 2010 book The Big Short and its Oscar-winning film adaptation. Michael Lewis and co-host Lidia Jean Kott reflect on the legacy of the financial crisis, focusing on the team led by Steve Eisman (fictionalized as Mark Baum in the film) and brought to life by the actors Steve Carell, Ryan Gosling, and Jeremy Strong. The episode features candid conversations with the actual traders—Porter Collins, Danny Moses, and Vincent Daniel—probing what the subprime mortgage collapse meant to them, how it felt to be proven right against the financial system, and the burden of having profited while others lost everything. The group also reflects on the enduring impact of the crisis and how markets—and justice—have changed in the years since.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. The Real FrontPoint Boys: Fact vs. Film
- [02:16] Michael and Lidia Jean introduce the episode’s focus on the FrontPoint team.
- [02:51] Michael plays a movie clip, highlighting the personalities and camaraderie among the team, remarking on the accuracy of the film’s portrayal.
- “The movie just kind of nailed them.” – Michael Lewis
2. Meeting Greg Lippmann – The Catalyst for the Short
- [04:31] Porter Collins describes meeting Deutsche Bank’s Greg Lippmann (the real-life inspiration for Ryan Gosling’s film character), whose confidence—and Wall Street “coolness”—made them skeptical.
- “He walked in the room and he was 120% confident...made it so much easier for us to not like him and, and to be skeptical of him and to go after him.” – Porter Collins [04:48]
3. Explaining the Financial Crisis in Plain English
- [06:11] Michael asks Vincent Daniel to explain the financial crisis as if to a child.
- “There was a lot of bad loans that were made to people who shouldn't have gotten those loans...and they had an inability to pay.” – Vincent Daniel [06:27]
- [07:02] On why they made money: They did their homework when others didn’t.
- “So, kids, this is why you spend a lot of time going to school and doing your homework...” – Vincent Daniel
4. Who Was on the Other Side? Betting Against Wall Street
- [07:42] They describe how “middlemen” (brokers) allowed them to make their investment, so they rarely knew the other side of their trades.
5. Why Did Few See the Disaster Coming?
- [08:10] Michael pushes Vincent: Why didn’t others do their homework?
- “Imagine if you’re in school and you’re getting away with good grades without doing your homework...”
- [09:00] Vincent: Their edge was deep experience—he “had a PhD in what was happening” from covering subprime mortgages since the 1990s.
- “We had the data better than everyone.” – Vincent Daniel
6. The Ignorance (and Greed) of the Financial System
- [11:06] Michael probes why big institutions missed the warning signs; Vincent blames greed and money.
- “There was just too much money to be made. So they all turned the most intelligent ones turned a blind eye.” – Vincent Daniel
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
Disney World Anecdote – Chaos Amidst Normalcy
- [15:47] Vincent recalls being at Disney World with family as the markets crashed. His calm contrasted with his father-in-law’s panic over market news.
- “I was there with my nieces, my nephews, my kids...thankfully that was the only solace was that [we were on the right side of it].” – Vincent Daniel
- “He would just go, Vinny, what in the world is going on?” [16:33]
On Profiting From Crisis—and Trying to Warn People
- [18:01] Vincent on public reaction:
- “Every once in a while you get, well, why didn’t you stop this? Or...how do you feel comfortable profiting from this?”
- He and colleagues did try to warn D.C. but “no one really listens to you unless you go...with a suitcase full of money.” [18:29]
“Price Discovery” and the End of True Market Downturns
-
[19:54] New market reality: Government prevents busts for the influential but lets the less powerful suffer.
- “...the minute something goes bad, the SWAT team and the fire hoses are out immediately to make sure it doesn’t go poorly.” – Vincent Daniel [21:01]
-
[21:36] Example: The sudden rescue of Silicon Valley Bank—trouble “remedied...in two days over the weekend.”
- “The market, rightfully so, ignored the adverse price discovery because they realized that the Fed had its back...” – Vincent Daniel [22:08]
The St. Patrick’s Cathedral Moment
- [23:15] Danny Moses describes the shock of suddenly realizing the scale of the crisis as Lehman Brothers collapsed. They left their desk and sat on the Cathedral steps, overwhelmed.
- “That moment on St Patrick's Cathedral on those steps was real.” – Danny Moses
- “I wish I was one of the people who didn’t know anything that was going on...” [23:28]
Guilt and Public Perception
- [24:52] Porter Collins shares family discomfort with their windfall.
- “He made all this money and everyone lost their homes. Like, how does that make you feel?” [24:52, Porter Collins quoting his grandfather]
Justice Not Served
-
[25:58] On the lack of consequences for those most responsible and Vincent’s expectations for systemic reform:
- “I would have imagined that there would have been more justice...But I was naive.” – Vincent Daniel
-
[26:30] Danny underlines the core problem:
- “The system is set up in a way to reward the risk and not really punish the people that make the wrong bets...No one went to jail afterwards.”
Timestamps for Important Segments
- 02:16 – Introduction to the FrontPoint episode; movie clip of team dynamic
- 04:31 – Porter Collins on meeting Greg Lippmann
- 06:11-11:48 – Vincent Daniel explains the crisis in simple terms; discussion on greed and ignorance
- 15:47-17:38 – Disney anecdote; how vivid memories conflict with movie/book adaptation
- 18:01-19:54 – Public criticism and attempts to warn the government; issues of morality
- 19:45-22:32 – Price discovery, Fed intervention, and market changes post-crisis
- 23:15-24:52 – The St. Patrick’s Cathedral moment; that day’s emotional impact
- 24:52-26:30 – Family reactions, guilt, lack of justice and lessons learned
- 26:30-27:00 – Consequences, moral hazard, and why justice hasn’t prevailed
Tone & Language Notes
The episode is candid, reflective, and occasionally laced with dark humor and regret. The participants discuss complicated financial subjects in down-to-earth metaphors—“doing your homework,” “price discovery,” and gambling analogies—often converting Wall Street complexities into language accessible to any listener. There’s an undercurrent of frustration at system failures and a measure of sadness or unease about the aftermath and unresolved lessons of the crisis.
Conclusion
This episode offers an insightful, personal look into the real FrontPoint traders’ experiences during the financial crisis, their feelings about being right when everyone else was wrong, and the lasting consequences—both personal and systemic—of 2008. The team stresses how little has changed at the highest levels, with markets and policymakers still protecting the powerful and leaving the underlying moral hazard unaddressed. For those interested in financial history, ethical dilemmas, or how Wall Street shapes (and escapes) crisis, it’s a must-listen.