
Should you use make or take in this scenario?
Loading summary
Podcast Announcer
This is an All Ears English podcast.
Lindsay McMahon
Episode 2567. Make a Photo or take a photo. Welcome to the All Ears English podcast. Downloaded more than 200 million times. Are you feeling stuck with your English? We'll show you how to become fearless and fluent by focusing on connection, not perfection, with your American hosts, Lindsay McMahon, the English adventurer, and Michelle Kaplan, the.
Podcast Announcer
New York radio girl, coming to you.
Lindsay McMahon
From Colorado and New York City, usa. To get real time transcripts right on your phone and create your personalized vocabulary list, try the Allears English app for iOS and Android. Start your seven day free trial at allearsenglish.com app.
Michelle Kaplan
You know that make versus do is tricky, but what about make versus find out when to use these two verbs to clean up your English.
All Ears English Fluency Quiz Narrator
Do you feel like you know English but you're always using the same basic words? You can't find the precise or professional phrase when it matters. Maybe you only hear sounds. When natives speak without subtitles, you're lost fast. Speech, similar sounds, accents, it all blends together. And when you do speak, you hesitate. You overthink every sentence. You worry people don't understand you or that you don't sound natural. It's not a confidence problem, it's a clarity problem. You can solve it by knowing your current level. Our two minute fluency quiz shows you your current English level for free. So you stop guessing and start improving. Go to allersenglish.comfluencyscore and find out what's really holding your English back. One more time, go right now to allersenglish.comflu e n c Y S C O R E.
Michelle Kaplan
Hey Lindsay, how are you?
Lindsay McMahon
Hey, Michelle. I'm feeling good. I am fresh off my trip to Italy and feeling, feeling refreshed, I guess.
Michelle Kaplan
Yeah, that is great. I love Italy. Did you take a lot of pictures when you went.
Lindsay McMahon
I did take a fair amount of pictures and it's. It helps when you have the camera phones now. Right. You don't need another camera anymore. It's amazing. You can create albums. Yeah, but the weather was nice. It was sunny. No complaints, right? Yes.
Michelle Kaplan
Yeah, that's great. So, yeah, tell us a little bit more. You went on a wine tour?
Lindsay McMahon
I went on a wine tour in like in the Florence area. And, and it was interesting because, you know, when you go on wine tours often, international wine tours, we booked this, I think possibly through Airbnb. Usually the, the language is English. The language of the tour is English. And usually the tour guides are really high, have very high level English. And this tour guide had Very high level English, 100%. But for me, being a linguist, I'm always listening in for not so much mistakes because I don't, you know, we're not about. All about mistakes, mistakes. We're about connection. But I'm always interested in kind of mistranslations and what happened there. I always think, huh, I wonder what happened there. Right. So there was a moment we were at a vineyard, and the sun was just setting, and it was gorgeous right outside of the vines, watching the vines. And he said, come on, everyone, get together. Let's make a picture. And I thought, oh, okay, that's not quite right. Right. We knew exactly what he meant. We all got together, we had a beautiful photo, but it wasn't quite right, Michelle.
Michelle Kaplan
Yeah, exactly. And of course, it didn't take away from the connection. You had a wonderful time.
Lindsay McMahon
Yes.
Michelle Kaplan
So again, guys, we don't want to stress that, oh, these things are gonna ruin everything, but, but I. But what Lindsay is saying is, like, that it's interesting to analyze after and to see if we can use this.
Lindsay McMahon
To help our listeners a hundred percent, 100. Because they're just little things around the edges that when we're translating directly, and that's what my hunch is what was happening, that we can make some small mistakes. So, I mean, this is why we travel, right? Because we understand connection goes so much deeper than just the choice of words, Michelle.
Michelle Kaplan
Yeah, yeah, yeah. But, yeah, this is really interesting. And if you think about it, it's very understandable why someone would say, make a picture. I mean, you're getting together to make a picture.
Lindsay McMahon
Exactly, yes.
Michelle Kaplan
So it, it's. It makes sense. But here is the difference. So basically, when you say take a picture, I'm thinking of physically, someone is pressing the button. You're gathering together. It doesn't matter who's in the picture or who's pressing it. It's just that it's. Someone is taking the picture. So the tour guide, what would have been correct would have been, let's stand together and take a picture.
Lindsay McMahon
Yes.
Michelle Kaplan
So the focus is on the actual posing for the camera. So that that's what it would be. Or what's another example?
Lindsay McMahon
You could say, I want to take a picture of you in front of the Coliseum.
Michelle Kaplan
Right.
Lindsay McMahon
Or in front of this museum, the Ufizi Gallery, or something like that.
Michelle Kaplan
Right, right.
Lindsay McMahon
And if you think of it that way, Michelle, I mean, like, logistically speaking, it's not completely wrong. It just sounds awkward because he was asking us to get together and create. Create a scene. For a photo. Right, right. And in many cases you would use make for that when you're. We've talked in other episodes about make versus do, where make means create. Right. So.
Michelle Kaplan
Yep.
Lindsay McMahon
So I, I got exactly what he was saying. We understood it, the picture got taken. But I think a native speaker probably would have said take because take encompasses the making of the scene of coming together.
Michelle Kaplan
Right, right. I. I think it's really about that pressing of the button we're using.
Lindsay McMahon
We're.
Michelle Kaplan
It's a photograph. Right. In this kind of context, I mean, make a picture. To me this sounds more like, I mean, this goes what you were saying about create. Right. You're like creating a picture, maybe a drawing or creation. So let's take out our watercolors. We're going to make a picture of what makes us happy. Right.
Lindsay McMahon
It's more like creating from scratch in. Right. So you're gonna actually draw that. That photo or make a picture with your crayons of what you see in front of you. You might say that to kids. Right, Right, right. Giving them a blank sheet of paper. But in this case, we're taking a picture, taking a photo because the people are already there, the scene is kind of already created. But logistically it kind of makes sense. Right. Make a picture. But we just don't say it in that context. Right. When you exact someone to stand together for a photo, you don't say make a picture.
Michelle Kaplan
Make a picture. Yep. Yeah. Ye. Really what we think is happening is a translation issue. Right. You know, especially with Romance languages. So for example, French, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese. Y, if we understand it correctly. And guys, you know, always write in and let us know. But they might be using more like one general verb, so.
Lindsay McMahon
Right.
Michelle Kaplan
And this verb could encompass other things like do or make or perform form. Right. And it works naturally in those languages. But in English we kind of have separate boxes for that.
Lindsay McMahon
That's why, I mean, we've done other episodes, guys. And you should search in our archives on our make do episodes that we've done because I know it's opening up a whole can of worms that we want to work on. But we know in Spanish the verb aer. Right. Aer una photo. Or in. In French. Fair. We need Aubrey for the French accent here. These verbs tend to be used for make and do. Right. In Portuguese and Italian as well. So that's. Our hunch, is that this is some kind of trans. Direct translation going on. But guys, write in, ask us a follow up question or correct us if we're wrong here. We'd love to hear from you.
Michelle Kaplan
Yeah, absolutely. So in English, let's talk about take a little bit more. So take is more like to experience something or receive could be to receive. You take something, consume, or capture. So capture, like take a picture, right?
Lindsay McMahon
For sure, yeah. Capture a photo, consume, receive something, take. I guess, I guess take is kind of similar to the verb fair or has said where it's broad. Right. So capture, consume, receive, experience. It can, it can include a lot of, a lot of things, right?
Michelle Kaplan
That's true. Yeah. Yeah, it does. Right. Take a seat, take a break. Right. So that's kind of, I guess I would say about experiencing something take a bite or take a sip to consume.
Lindsay McMahon
Yeah. So much. Or take a shower, right? Oh, yeah, there's so much there. And we could go on and on. So in a way, it's kind of learning these as chunks based on the scenario. That's why it's so helpful to kind of why we always encourage our listeners to take 10 minutes out of your day and think in English. You know, do it in the morning when you're making your breakfast. I'm going to make my coffee. I'm going to take a shower in a few minutes. Right. I'm gonna take a break and just read the newspaper before I start work. Okay.
Michelle Kaplan
Right. And yeah, I, I really like that. I, I personally think that this learning in chunks and just kind of remembering these and kind of taking some time to just memorize them and practice them is more useful than saying, does this.
Lindsay McMahon
One break down the rules? Yeah.
Michelle Kaplan
Does this one me? You know, I, I just think it's more useful. It's helpful to know, but in your daily life, it's really good to just to, you know, to get, I mean, it sounds funny, but get your flashcards out. Just do it. Put them around the house. Yeah, it can, can help. Sometimes that's just the best way. What about make?
Lindsay McMahon
Yeah, make. So make is more like causing something to come into being or to create it.
Michelle Kaplan
Right.
Lindsay McMahon
So, for example, make a picture again, not, not snapping that photo, not lining up together in front of the vineyard. It is. Maybe you're gonna draw something from scratch.
Michelle Kaplan
Right, right.
Lindsay McMahon
What else, Michelle?
Michelle Kaplan
Make a friend. Right? Oh, I, I, I need to, I want to make some friends at the party or, oh, I made a new friend. Right. So you caused something, Something happened.
Lindsay McMahon
Yes, yes. Make noise. It would be another way of say, like there's a racket. Right. You're just causing noise to occur. Make the bed. Right. Yeah.
Michelle Kaplan
You wouldn't say, take the bed. That means you' picking it up and.
Lindsay McMahon
No, totally different. Right here. We're putting the covers back up. We're making it look nice and neat for the day.
Michelle Kaplan
Do you make the bed every day? Were you just about to ask me that?
Lindsay McMahon
I usually try to, yeah. I like to have my bed made because that way, I mean, I don't spend a lot of time in my bedroom during the day, but it makes me feel like I'm like ready for the day. Certain rituals that I need, I need to take a shower, I need to have breakfast. I mean, take my dog out for a walk. Right. Like to be ready mentally. But not everyone. Some people just roll out of bed and just go right to work. I don't know.
Michelle Kaplan
That's me. I don't make the bed. I. I really should. It's only like on a special occasion where I'm clean, you know, cleaning up. Or my mom's here and she'll say, I'm your bed. So then make a change, right? Oh, I want to make a change in my life for my career or whatever it may be.
Lindsay McMahon
Exactly. Yes.
Podcast Announcer
When you first start your own business or go into management, no one tells you how hard but important hiring is. I've learned that I need to hire for attitude and willingness to learn as much as I need to look for hard skills. If you're hiring, stop struggling to get your job post. Even seen on other job sites. Give your job the best chance to be seen with Indeed sponsored jobs. They help you stand out and hire quality candidates who can drive the results you need. If I needed to hire a new software developer, I'd be super specific in my job post with Indeed. I'd specifically look for someone with AI experience and who has built tools in our industry language learning in the past. With Indeed sponsored Jobs, you only pay for results. No monthly subscriptions, no long term contracts. Just a boost whenever you need to find quality talent fast. Spend more time interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress, less time, more results. Now with Indeed sponsored Jobs and listeners of this show will get a 75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves@ Indeed.com a e e just go to Indeed.com aeed right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. I n d e e d.com a e e Terms and conditions apply. Hiring do it the right way with Indeed.
Lindsay McMahon
Okay, Michelle. So are. Do we find any other common mistakes? I mean, it's good to be aware of common mistakes that can Happen between romance languages. And not everyone listening to this show speaks a romance language, of course. So think about common mistakes from your native language being translated into English. What are some of them, Michelle?
Michelle Kaplan
So we already did make a photo and take a photo. Make a break. You might hear someone. You know, maybe you've said this before to make a break instead of to take a break.
Lindsay McMahon
And when we say break, what? It sounds strange to me. Make a break. But what.
Michelle Kaplan
Yeah, right.
Lindsay McMahon
What do we. What is break?
Michelle Kaplan
Just. Just for a rest, a moment.
Lindsay McMahon
You could.
Michelle Kaplan
There is, you know, you could have probably heard, make a break for it. Right. But that's different.
Lindsay McMahon
Oh, what does that mean? Make a break for it? Is that, like, run away?
Michelle Kaplan
Like, try to, like, quickly run away.
Lindsay McMahon
Okay, okay, got it, Got it.
Michelle Kaplan
You rang someone's doorbell and you're trying to play a prank on them. Let's make a break for it.
Lindsay McMahon
So it's. It's interesting that I had to actually ask you, like, to clarify the meaning of break. B R E, A k. Because when we set it with make, it made no sense to me. Right. Make a break. I was like, what is that? Right? Take a break. Makes total sense. So when you get the right chunk, you get the right verb with the noun, People understand you instantly. Right. So that's why, again, we're not translating word for word. We're translating idea for idea in a sense.
Michelle Kaplan
Right? Yeah, yeah. And then what about this one, Lindsay? Have you heard this Do a mistake instead of make a mistake?
Lindsay McMahon
I definitely heard it right, but I don't want to hear it again. Yeah, make a party. I've heard this one, too, but it's wrong. What should we say instead, Michelle?
Michelle Kaplan
You should really say have a party or throw a party. However, this one doesn't bother me as much, like, oh, I want to make a party for you. I don't know. What do you think?
Lindsay McMahon
Party for you? I guess there could be. I guess there could be edge cases where you're trying to express something special that you want to create something for your friend. Yeah, right, right. Yes, I decided.
Michelle Kaplan
Yeah.
Lindsay McMahon
But I think it's a real edge case, and I think most like 95 of the time, you're going to say, have a party, Throw a party, host a party. True, right. Have. I would say. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So we'll. We'll focus on the majority of the times for our listeners today. Another one that feels wrong. Right. Kind of nails in a chalkboard for me is take a decision. Right.
Michelle Kaplan
Make a decision. Right. Because it's to Make a decision. Yeah, we don't say take a decision. So, guys, I mean, what we've learned is in a Romance languages, generally maybe using a single verb for both to make and to do.
Lindsay McMahon
Yeah.
Michelle Kaplan
And so this is a common way that it can get confusing because English has kind of this clear distinguish, like, way to distinguish between the two. Yes. So something that might be able to be expressed with one verb in a Romance language has maybe have two different ones in English.
Lindsay McMahon
So we just want to be aware of that. Right. It's a pitfall. And if we know that it's out there, we can just think more about conveying ideas. Right. Not translating words, not breaking up an entire sentence into words. Okay, what's my native language word here? Now let's say that in English. No, we want to stay away from that. And ultimately the focus is connection. Of course, as we know, Michelle.
Michelle Kaplan
Exactly.
Lindsay McMahon
Shall we do a role play? Shall we do it?
Michelle Kaplan
Sure. Okay. So here we are, we are friends talking about our weekend.
Lindsay McMahon
Okay. So how'd it go?
Michelle Kaplan
Oh, it was so much fun. I took so many pictures. My phone is dead, but I'll show you later.
Lindsay McMahon
Oh, that's great. Did you make any decisions on whether you're gonna buy a car or not?
Michelle Kaplan
Oh, not yet. I think I might need to take a break from big decisions. They make me too stressed.
Lindsay McMahon
Oh, I hear you.
Michelle Kaplan
How was your weekend?
Lindsay McMahon
Good, thanks. I went out and made some new friends at a meetup. It was fun.
Michelle Kaplan
Great.
Lindsay McMahon
There is such a thing as decision fatigue, right, Michelle?
Michelle Kaplan
Oh, my God, yes. Yes.
Lindsay McMahon
That's why they say, like, make your big decisions in the morning when you have full energy, when you're feeling good. If you are a morning person, there is a such thing as, like, it gets exhausting if you have to make more and more decisions and your decision making skill gets worse.
Michelle Kaplan
Yeah. And if it's not good to begin with, then that's where. Right.
Lindsay McMahon
Yeah. You struggle with that, right, Michelle?
Michelle Kaplan
A little bit. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Especially with things like design. Like, you know, I moved into a house and, you know, it's like. Oh. I mean, literally, we, we. There are some things that we just haven't done from a year ago.
Lindsay McMahon
Yeah.
Michelle Kaplan
That we meant to complete a project because it's just too. It's just like, whatever.
Lindsay McMahon
No, I'm kind of the same way. I overanalyze everything and I need to know all the details and then I still don't know. It doesn't help me with my gut feeling of which color of this or that to Go with. Right.
Michelle Kaplan
And then no matter which one I choose, I'm going to really think, oh, I should have done the other one.
Lindsay McMahon
So, yeah, for sure.
Michelle Kaplan
Might as well just choose something, though.
Lindsay McMahon
Yeah. All right, let's go through the role play. So here, Michelle, you. I asked you how did it go? And you said, it was so much fun. I took so many pictures. And again, take. Right. I took so many pictures. Okay.
Michelle Kaplan
And then you said, did you make any decisions on whether or not you're going to buy the car?
Lindsay McMahon
Yeah. And then you said, oh, not yet. I think I need to take a break. So take a break from big decisions. Right. You would. You wouldn't say make a break. You would never say that there. That's strange, right? Yes.
Michelle Kaplan
Then I said, how was your weekend? And you said, good, thanks. I went out and made some new friends at a meetup. It was fun.
Lindsay McMahon
Love it. So good. This is a good one, Michelle. I mean, I love when we go out into the world and we hear things, then we can take them back to the show. And we love to get these from you guys, too. So send in your question. If you hear a kind of a mistranslation or something, you're not sure if it's correct, send it to support allersenglish.com tell us the context, what you were doing when you heard it. We want that context. We want to bring your question to the show. Okay.
Michelle Kaplan
Exactly. Yeah. Guys, Check out episode 2565 just from the other day that was. Is English all Greek to you? A really good one.
Lindsay McMahon
Really good one. Any final takeaway for today, Michelle, where we should leave our listeners.
Michelle Kaplan
Don't worry about this too much and don't analyze it too much. Just learn the specific pieces and I think life will be a lot easier.
Lindsay McMahon
Love it. And get down. I love that, Michelle. And also just to top that off, get into thinking in English. You know, we always Recommend that grab 5 minutes out of your day, even 3 minutes would be great because you have a dialogue already happening in your head. At least I do. I hope I'm not the only one.
Michelle Kaplan
No, no, no.
Lindsay McMahon
There's a dialogue happening.
Michelle Kaplan
You're not the only one. No, don't worry, don't worry.
Lindsay McMahon
And maybe choose like three different contexts. Maybe on Mondays it's breakfast time. Maybe on Wednesdays it's lunchtime. Whatever you want to do, but start thinking in English so you're starting to adopt these chunks properly. Okay.
All Ears English Fluency Quiz Narrator
Love it.
Lindsay McMahon
Love it. So great. All right. All right, Michelle, well, we'll see you in the next one. You have a good day. All right.
Michelle Kaplan
All right. I'm going to go take a break. Bye, Lindsay.
Lindsay McMahon
Bye. Thanks for listening. To all ears English. Would you like to know your English level? Take our two minute quiz. Go to allearsenglish.com fluency score. And if you believe in connection, not perfection, then hit subscribe now to make sure you don't miss anything.
Podcast Announcer
See you next time.
LifeLock Advertiser
It's tax season and at Lifelock, we know you're tired of numbers, but here's a big one you need to hear. Billions. That's the amount of money in refunds the IRS has flagged for possible identity fraud. Now here's another big number. 100 million. That's how many data points LifeLock monitors every second. If your identity is stolen, we'll fix it, guaranteed. One last big number. Save up to 40% your first year. Visit lifelock. Com podcast for the threats you can't control. Terms apply.
Title: Make a Photo or Take a Photo?
Date: February 17, 2026
Hosts: Lindsay McMahon and Michelle Kaplan
This episode dives into one of the most common and confusing verb choices for English learners: when to use “make” versus “take” with common nouns—especially the phrase "take a photo" versus the direct-translation error "make a photo". Lindsay and Michelle explore how these verbs differ in English, why the confusion arises (especially for speakers of Romance languages), and offer practical advice for mastering these everyday expressions. Expect real-life stories, language insights, and helpful practice strategies.
[02:26 - 04:14]
“This is why we travel, right? Because we understand connection goes so much deeper than just the choice of words.”
— Lindsay [04:26]
[04:14 - 07:11]
[07:11 - 08:24]
“In English, we kind of have separate boxes for that.”
— Michelle [07:37]
[08:24 - 09:44]
[10:21 - 11:58]
“Make” is about creating something new or causing something to happen:
“Take” is about experiencing, capturing, or physically acting:
Visual, memorable contrast:
[13:37 - 16:40]
“When you get the right chunk, you get the right verb with the noun, people understand you instantly.”
— Lindsay [14:35]
[17:03 - 18:38]
[19:51 - End]
| Segment | Time | |------------------------------|-----------------| | Italy anecdote & topic intro | 02:26 – 04:14 | | Explanation of “take a photo”| 04:14 – 07:11 | | Translation issue analysis | 07:11 – 08:24 | | Learning in chunks strategy | 09:14 – 10:21 | | Contrasts: make vs take | 10:21 – 11:58 | | Common mistakes & idioms | 13:37 – 16:40 | | Role play | 17:03 – 18:38 | | Takeaways & listener advice | 19:51 – End |
Next Steps:
Closing Note:
Michelle wraps up with a bit of self-irony about not always making her bed, demonstrating again that real, imperfect habits are common—even for English teachers.