Loading summary
A
This is all of it on wnyc. I'm Alison Stewart. Happy Friday, everybody. We had a great week of conversations, and if you couldn't be with us each and every second, you can go back and listen to them wherever you get your podcasts or on our show page@wnyc.org we talked to actor and writer John Leguizamo about his new show at the Public titled the Other Americans. We spoke about comedy in the era of censorship with NPR correspondent David Folkenflick and Vulture editor Jesse David Fox. We puzzled over New York City neighborhood names with Greg Young of the history podcast the Bowery Boys. And yesterday we spoke with actor Timothy Olyphant about his new role on the TV series Alien Earth. And that interview in particular was quite lively, shall we say? And next week is shaping up to be quite special as well. Baker Paul Hollywood will be here on Monday to talk about his new cookbook. Now let's get this hour started with a look at the history of movie music. You know that theme, it's not the AOI theme. It's the 20th century studio fanfare, one of the most recognizable sounds in the history of movie music. That theme was originally composed in 1933 by Alfred Newman, an accomplished Hollywood composer who won nine Oscars for scores for movies like Wuthering Heights and the Hunchback of Notre Dame. He is also the father of film composers David and Thomas Newman. And, of course, there's his nephew, Randy Newman. Movie music is an art form going back more than a century. Of course, it predated dialogue in movies, and the form has made stars out of people like John Williams, Terrence Blanchard, Rachel Portman and Hans Zimmer. On Sunday, WQXR host Elliot Forrest will speak to conductor and composer Leonard Slotkin about the history of movie music. That'll be in the Green Space Live. But first with a preview, I have Elliot with me here in studio. Hi, Elliot.
B
Great to see you. Great to be with you.
A
Hey, listeners, we want to hear from you about this. Who are your favorite movie composers? What are your favorite movie scores and soundtracks? We might get you to sing a little bit. Our number is 2124-3396-9221-2433. WNYC. Elliot, when do you first remember noticing the music, the movie, the music in movies, when you went to see them?
B
I think the entry point for me to really focus on movie music was the music of Bernard Herrmann, which we cover. Once I started to really focus in on not just music in films or even Classical music or orchestral music that was used in films but written specifically for movies. And I sort of zeroed in on Bernard Herrmann. I realized what an incredible art form it was. I mean, when you think about Bernard Herrmann's very first film was Citizen Kane, and his last film was Taxi Dr. And everything for Alfred Hitchcock in the middle, including Psycho, that's a career from Citizen Kane to Taxi Driver with all the Hitchcock in the middle. That's amazing.
A
Yeah. What did he understand about Hitchcock thrillers? What did he understand that they needed?
B
Musically, I think that he understood some aspects of psychology and really capturing what was going on emotionally. Sometimes a film composer is just like, bum, bum, bum, and it's about the action, and sometimes it's what's going on internally. Also, there's little hints every once in a while. For example, the famous Psycho scene. We've just spent 20 minutes with him with birds, and all of a sudden it's reap, reap, reap.
A
Whop, whop.
B
I mean, he's giving you a hint as to who the killer is in the music. So there's a lot. It can be dense and really interesting.
A
Well, let's hear it.
B
So this is the famous driving scene. And so what's interesting about the couple of things. First of all, on Sunday, when we go through the history, I'm gonna show this scene without any music whatsoever.
A
Oh, it's gonna. Oh, it's gonna be great.
B
So you're just sort of like, she's just driving and, oh, that looks like an interesting hotel. Let's check into that. And then I'm gonna play it with the music, and you can see where the drama is. The other thing that Bernard Herrmann did was he would orchestrate specifically for the film. For example, films like Jason and the Argonauts only has percussion and brass, but there's only strings in Psycho. And the reason is that it makes it that much more strident and that much more tense.
A
Movies were around music, and movies were around before people could speak in movies.
B
Right? Yes. Silent. We like to say the silent movies were not silent. Even at the beginning, there was someone playing live. And even if you jump to some of the later films of Charlie Chaplin, they would add film, add music to it, even before there was dialogue. So music has always been a part of the films, even in the quote, unquote, silent era.
A
All right, so tell us about the. One of the first films that used underscoring.
B
So there's this thing called diegetic. It's not a word people really know that much about it. But a diegetic music is when it's part of the film. Like, for example, you see a scene and there's an orchestra, there's a radio that makes sense. So there was a period where they could music and they went, well, we can't just add music. Where is it coming from? We're in a doctor's office. Where's the orchestra? They didn't think that the audiences would buy the underscoring, the non diegetic music. So there was a film in the 30s, Symphony of Six Million, where Max Steiner was scoring the thing and the scene really wasn't working. And they just went, well, put some music underneath it. And they were like, well, the audience won't know where the music is. Just do it. Just put it underneath it. And underscoring was born.
A
Let's listen to Max Steiner's Symphony of Six Million.
C
It may interest you to know, Dr. Felix Klob, that he died calling your name. I feel sorry for you.
A
I feel sorry for you.
B
And the main theme underneath that really was not an original theme. It was both the moldau and people might know it as Hat Tikva, the Israeli national anthem. So there's this Israeli sense, this Jewishness underneath it, which is a theme of the film.
A
Let's take some calls. Kristin's calling from Baskin Ridge, New Jersey. Hi, Christine, thank you so much for calling, all of it. You are on the air.
C
Hi, thank you guys for taking my call. Longtime listener, first time caller.
A
Love it.
C
So, you know, I heard you guys ask, what's your favorite soundtrack? And the first thing that comes to my mind is, well, honestly, musical theater and movies that I've seen, which is just. Sorry, that's not important because that's not about underscoring. We're talking about underscoring. I'm all about Howard Shore, Lord of the Rings films. I mean, just thinking about it gets me emotional because every. Every important moment in this film, which a lot of people are big fans of, is just really empowered by Howard Shore's music and that film and how important it is to me in my life is nothing without the music that underscores it. So thank you, guys.
B
The thing about Howard Shore really harkens back almost to Wagner because Wagner was really one of the first composers that would create these leitmotifs in his operas in the sense that the characters had theme or a prop would have have a theme. And I don't remember the exact number. I did a full hour. It was such an honor last Year I sat on stage with Howard Shore, just with him alone for 90 minutes with his entire film, all of his films or most of them. And I, I, I can't remember Lord of the Rings, maybe a couple of dozen themes. The characters has the, the Ring has a theme. The, you know, there's all these different themes that it created massive amounts and, and he got Oscars for it and well deserved.
A
Let's listen to Howard Shore. Eric is calling us from South Orange, New Jersey. Hi, Eric, you're on the air.
C
I wanted to just put out a shout out to one of my favorite scores. I have a lot of favorites, but I wanted to just put a spotlight on under the Skin by Mika Levy, which is like one of the more terrifying and unique and distinctive scores. It's so eerie, and I like that it's a sort of a modern score, but it hasn't sort of given up on melody because a lot of modern scores are kind of more amorphous. But this one actually does have a lot of really strong melodies in it. I just think it's a real masterpiece.
A
Thank you so much for calling. I'm speaking to WQXR host Elliot Forrest about the history of movie music. He'll be in conversation with conductor Leonard Slotkin in the Green space this Sunday at 7. A lot of composers and directors develop a working relationship. Why do you think that happens?
B
You know, it's interesting because directors will use actors and then not use them again, or even sometimes cinematographers. But there's this bond between directors and filmmakers. My friend Doug McGrath, who wrote and directed the films Emma with Gwyneth Paltrow and Infamous and Nicholas Nickleby had said to me that the composer is the second major voice in the film. And when you start to look at both Hitchcock and Bernard Herrmann and of course, John Williams and Steven Spielberg and Terence Blanchard and Spike Lee, they create these relationships almost for life. And they say, we're gonna go on this journey together. It almost doesn't even matter what the film is. You're gonna come with me and you're gonna help create this new world.
A
Steven Spielberg and John Williams, I believe they worked on more than 25 films, something like that.
B
And they've said that that Fabelman's the last film would be their last original collaboration. I mean, we all hope not. The last time I saw John Williams on stage, he was, he was having trouble with mobility. So I don't really know how physically active he is at this point, but what a legacy. I mean, just so much it was Johnny Williams when he started, he played the piano. There's some scores that I really love. To Kill a Mockingbird was actually scoring by Elmer Bernstein, but the piano playing was John Williams. He just goes back throughout the entire history of this business and. And just all the films that Jurassic park, you just. It just. It just doesn't end. Star Wars. Amazing stuff.
A
Let's listen to a little bit of E.
C
Sam.
B
So Sunday in the Green space, we're gonna let John Williams tell this story, but they were editing the film for ET at the end. The last 20 minutes, if you remember, is this huge chase scene, and they meet up and they finally get up to the alien and it goes up to space. Wasn't working. Traditionally, what happens is that the composer will write the music and then they'll cut it up a great deal and fit it to the film. And it just wasn't working. So Spielberg says, you know what? You just play the music. You just play this big suite of music in the last 20 minutes, and I'll cut the film to the music. Extremely generous. Rarely happens. And so the first time John Williams conducted live with the New York Philharmonic, I was in the audience, and I'm watching this scene, and it's just big and sweeping and operatic. And I'm thinking, you know what? I don't really want to watch a film unless the New York Philharmonic's playing live anymore. This is really good. I love this. This.
A
Let's talk to Tex, who is calling in from New Jersey. Hi, Tex. Thank you so much for calling all of it. You're on the air.
C
Oh, it's my honor and a pleasure speaking of otherworldly. And not to take anything away from John Williams, but I don't think any film has eclipse to score to the wizard of Oz. When I listen to the wizard of Oz, I don't see how physically you can. You can write that and play it. It's just otherworldly. It's just. It's just so far and above anything I've ever heard since.
B
You know, it's an amazing score. These are amazing songs. I think a lot of people know this. They almost cut over the Rainbow because it didn't really fit. They thought it slowed the film down. But it's an amazing musical. We are on Sunday. Just so people know. We're going to leave out a lot. I'm just telling you now, we're going to leave out a lot. We're going to leave out a lot. And I love movie musicals, from the wizard of Oz to Singin in the Rain to Rocky Horror Picture Show. We're really gonna focus on orchestral and symphonic music. And one of the reasons is there was a time when orchestral and symphonic music was heard primarily in the concert hall. And I think I can say without equivocation, the majority of the symphonic and orchestral music heard today is heard in the movies. Whether it's the movie theater or streaming, that's where people are hearing orchestras.
A
We're talking about movie music with WQXR host Elliot Forrest. After the break, we'll talk about Spike Lee and Terris Blanchard as well as Tim Burton and Danny Elfman. And we'll take more of your calls. This is all of it. You are listening to all of it on wnyc. I'm Alison Stewart. I'm speaking with my colleague, WQXR host Elliot Force about the history of movie movie music. He'll be in conversation with conductor Leonard Slotkin in the Green Space this Sunday at 7pm could you fill people in on Leonard Slotkin who don't know?
B
So Leonard Slatkin is one of the great American conductors. He just turned 80. He is still very active. Multiple Grammy Award winner, National Medal of Arts recipient, longtime conductor of the St. Louis Symphony, the Detroit Symphony. He was conductor of the National Symphony at the Kennedy center when it was run by professionals. And his parents were both in orchestras in the 40s for a lot of these film scores. And Leonard as a kid would go and sit when they were making these movies, sit with his parents when they were in the orchestra. And I don't want to give too much away, but let's just say there's a famous, maybe the most famous two note movie theme ever, which is played on a cello. And in the original score, it's his mom. So. And we'll talk more about that on Sunday in the Green Space. But Leonard grew up with this and it's been a big part of his life. And he's just now actually creating a new radio program himself on the, on the history of movie music. So it's, I just have to say I asked him to join me for this and he readily agreed. We did it once in Nyack already together, and immediately we got off stage and he went, I want to do this again. So we had a great time. And he's just a great raconteur and a great musician and a great American conductor.
A
Let's talk about another prominent pair, Spike Lee and Terrence Blanchard. We have a clip from Blanchard's score for Malcolm X. What do you want to say about.
B
That that's another great pairing, another great relationship. Terrence Blanchard has scored many things for Spike Lee, and just another great example of how a director finds this other voice that says, I want you to be a part of this. And Malcolm X is really great, I think. I'm not sure which clip you're going to have, but if you hear trumpet, that is Terence Blanchard, because he is and was primarily at first a trumpet player and then went on to compose.
A
Let's listen. It's almost like you said, it's like another voice.
B
And you know, what's really great about some film music is you can see the movie. You can see the film in your head. It just takes you right there. Whether it's Jurassic park or Star wars, it's like you're in the movie the moment you hear some of these themes.
A
Let's talk to Monk, who's calling in from Brooklyn. Hey, Monk, you're on the air.
C
Hi. Thank you for having me. Yeah, I just wanted to touch on, you know, you mentioned you were gonna talk about Danny Elfman here in a minute. I just, you know, artists who are usually associated with more kind of popular culture music, not so much symphonic music, who kind of take the route of movie scoring, like Johnny Greenwood from Radiohead for There Will Be Blood, you know, even Quincy Jones, Danny Elfman. And I just. I love seeing the versatility of these musicians and what they have to offer to movie scores. And when you realize just how grand their mind is that they can switch it up just like that and do a movie score, easy peasy. It's kind of mind blowing.
B
And I really love it 100%. I mean, Danny Elfman was in a rock band for a long time and then some, you know, and whether it's his own ambition to do it or whether somebody like Tim Burton says, maybe Danny Elfman would be good for this. It's interesting how many films Danny Elfman and Tim Burton have done. And then, you know, sometimes you'll hear these scores and other things. I love the scores to Edward Scissorhands. It's one of my favorites. And you'll see even a whole nother movie about Christmas has nothing to do with Danny Elfman or Tim Burton. And they're going, oh, that's Edward Scissorhands. They're just putting that in there because it just feels right.
A
Edward Scissorhands, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Batman. Well, let's hear Beetlejuice as well. I remember from Oingo Boingo, right?
B
Danny Elfman, you know, I did A full hour special for WQXR with Danny Elfman right in these studios here at wnyc. And again, there's this connection. You know, he's a little offbeat, that Danny Elfman, and so was Tim Burton. So I think they found each other.
A
I am going to bring in the woman, the woman Rachel Portman. Describe Rachel Portman for People.
B
So Rachel Portman is this great English film composer. Again, she partnered with Doug McGrath on films like Emma Infamous and Nicholas Nickleby. And she, you know, we do find a lack of women in this business still for all sorts of stupid reasons. But Rachel is really an elegant, elegant woman and wrote some beautiful music, particularly for that first film that Doug did with with Emma.
C
Let's listen. Sam.
A
Let'S talk to Laura, who's calling in from Westville. Hi, Laura, you're on the air.
C
Hi there. Thanks so much for having me. So, as an Italian, when I heard you guys in this conversation, I immediately thought about two other pairs of composer directors that are iconic, in my opinion. One is Ennio Morricone and in particular his relationship with Seth Giuliani and his movies. And if I think about the theme from the Good, the and the Ugly, I mean, talk about an immersive sensory experience. I think it just transports you there in that movie, in that scene. It's just fantastic. And then, of course, Nio Rota and Federico Fellini and in particular, Eight and a Half. I think that music just really makes the movie. So, yeah, just wanted to put it out there.
B
We talk about both these composers on Sunday in the Green Space, particularly. I've got a fun story about Nino Roto. If anybody knows anything about his music, they know the theme from the Godfather. He was tentatively nominated for an Oscar for that score, but it was for an original score and they yanked the nomination from him because it wasn't an original score. He had used it in a previous film in a whole nother way. And we'll play both of them on Sunday.
A
Let's talk to Bianca from Westchester. Hi, Bianca. Thank you so much for calling all of it. You're on the air.
C
Thanks for taking my call. You know, I was thinking about how you were saying that you can hear some music and instantly think of the visuals that come with it. It made me think of, like, Disney, Pixar's up, the beginning of Up. But then I thought, you know, this is really spread into all forms of visual media. I mean, the opening music to Game of Thrones or Westworld are just incredibly iconic and immediately give you the visual of the entire series.
A
It's true. Thank you so much for your comment.
B
And Michael Giacchino, who wrote the theme to up and got an Oscar for that. Really a beautiful score and obviously well deserved and a very active composer these days as well.
A
As we're starting to wrap up on time, do you want to give us a little bit of what Sunday's going to be like?
B
So 7 o' clock in the green space. Leonard Slatkin and I were going to play about, I don't know, 30 different film clips. We're going to work through the history of, of the films. We'll talk a little bit about the early days, a little bit of history, some about this relationship. I will say that we are sold out. We've sold all the tickets to this event in the green space. We're happy about that, but we're going to stream it so you can find out about streaming this event in the green space, wherever you are around the planet. 7:00 clock Eastern Time from the green space. From here in New york, go to wqxr.org and you can find out information on how to join us virtually.
A
What are some of your first personal favorite scores?
B
Well, I, I have a fun story that I'll save for Sunday, but Lawrence of Arabia is an amazing score and I mentioned it earlier, To Kill a Mockingbird. I had the opportunity to meet Elmer Bernstein a couple of times and his score to To Kill a Mockingbird is very reminiscent of Aaron Copeland, very American. And I just don't think that film, that classic film with Gregory Peck would be what it is today without that beautiful score by Elma Bernstein.
A
I think the thing we're gonna go out on, I'm looking at the list and I'm gonna go out on Hans Zimmer. Okay, we're going Hans Zimmer, Interstellar. Do you want to add anything before we go?
B
He's clearly one of the most popular and active composers today. He's got a big staff working with him. And when you think drama and fight scenes and big motion pictures. Hans Zimmer's right there.
A
I've been speaking to WQXR host Elliot Forrest. His show about movie music will be. He'll be in conversation with conductor Leonard slatkin in the GRE Sunday at 7pm they'll be talking about movie music. It sounds like a great conversation and you can stream it live. Thanks, Elliot.
B
Thank you, Alison.
A
Our state has changed a lot in the last 140 years. We know because Multicare has been here guided by a single purpose, making our communities healthier. That comes from making courageous decisions, partnering with local communities to grow programs and services, and expanding healthcare access to those who need it most. Together, we're building a healthier future. Learn more@ multicare.org NYC now delivers the most up to date local news from WNYC and Gothamist every morning, midday and evening. With three updates a day. Listeners get breaking news, top headlines and in depth coverage from across New York City. By sponsoring programming like NYC now, you'll reach our community of dedicated listeners with premium messaging and an uncluttered audio experience. Visit sponsorship.wnyc.org to get in touch and find out more.
Host: Alison Stewart
Guest: Elliot Forrest, WQXR Host
Air Date: September 26, 2025
This episode dives deep into the evolution, artistry, and emotional impact of movie music. Host Alison Stewart and guest Elliot Forrest (WQXR) trace the history of film scores, highlight iconic composer-director collaborations, and feature listener calls on favorite soundtrack moments. The show balances behind-the-scenes stories, technical insights, and passionate listener engagement, capturing the essential role music plays in shaping our cinematic experiences.
Opening Context (00:08):
Alison Stewart introduces the episode’s focus on movie music, referencing the famous 20th Century Fox fanfare composed by Alfred Newman, and noting his legacy as the father and uncle of multiple renowned composers.
Early Film Music (05:33):
Elliot Forrest explains that "silent" films always featured live music, even before soundtracks, underscoring how music has been integral since cinema’s inception.
“Even at the beginning, there was someone playing live. So music has always been a part of the films, even in the quote, unquote, silent era.” (06:00, Elliot)
Birth of Underscoring (06:06):
Discussion of "diegetic" (music present in the world of the film) vs. "nondiegetic" or underscoring (background score). Forrest recounts how Max Steiner helped pioneer underscoring in the 1930s with Symphony of Six Million when adding music under a scene proved more effective than logic about “where the orchestra is.”
“Underscoring was born.” (06:54, Elliot)
Bernard Herrmann’s Partnership with Hitchcock (02:52):
Forrest describes his awakening to film music via Bernard Herrmann, lauding Herrmann’s ability to convey emotional and psychological content, notably in films from Citizen Kane to Taxi Driver, covering most Hitchcock thrillers in between.
“He understood some aspects of psychology and really capturing what was going on emotionally... he’s giving you a hint as to who the killer is in the music.” (03:37, Elliot)
Psycho’s String-Only Score (05:04):
Herrmann’s orchestration choices (e.g., exclusively strings in Psycho) create heightened tension and unique aural landscapes.
Listener Call: Kristen on Howard Shore (07:50):
Kristen describes how Shore’s music for The Lord of the Rings is essential to her emotional connection to the films.
“Every important moment in this film… is just really empowered by Howard Shore’s music and that film… is nothing without the music that underscores it.” (07:50, Kristen)
Wagnerian Influence and Leitmotifs (08:33):
Forrest highlights how Shore’s scores use recurring themes for characters and objects, echoing Wagner’s operatic approach.
Collaborative Relationships (10:45):
Discussion about why some directors like Spielberg continually partner with composers like John Williams—because the composer “is the second major voice in the film.”
“They create these relationships almost for life… you’re gonna help create this new world.” (11:00, Elliot)
Scoring E.T.: Cutting to the Music (13:08):
Forrest relays how, in a rare move, Spielberg edited the ending of E.T. to fit Williams' sweeping music, rather than the usual reverse.
“It’s kind of mind blowing.” (19:23, Monk)
Listener Call: Laura on Morricone & Rota (23:46):
Laura admires the immersiveness of Ennio Morricone (The Good, the Bad and the Ugly) and Nino Rota (Fellini’s 8½), noting how their music transports the listener.
Oscar Anecdote (24:29):
Forrest tells how Rota’s Godfather score was disqualified from the Oscars because it recycled material from a previous film.
Sunday Event Details (25:52):
Forrest previews his upcoming live/streamed Green Space discussion with conductor Leonard Slatkin, promising “about 30 different film clips” and more stories.
“All the tickets to this event in the green space [are] sold out, but we're going to stream it... wherever you are around the planet.” (25:57, Elliot)
Favorite Scores & Legacy (26:29):
Forrest names Lawrence of Arabia and To Kill a Mockingbird as personal favorites, crediting Elmer Bernstein’s work as “very American” and indispensable to the film’s texture.
Final Salute to Hans Zimmer (26:56):
Alison Stewart cues “Interstellar,” praising Zimmer as a “most popular and active” modern film composer, especially known for big, dramatic moments.
On Bernard Herrmann’s influence:
"That's a career from Citizen Kane to Taxi Driver with all the Hitchcock in the middle. That's amazing." (02:52, Elliot Forrest)
On the psychological power of music:
"He's giving you a hint as to who the killer is in the music. So there's a lot. It can be dense and really interesting." (03:37, Elliot Forrest)
On collaborative relationships:
"The composer is the second major voice in the film." (10:45, Doug McGrath via Elliot Forrest)
Listener impact:
"Every important moment in this film... is just really empowered by Howard Shore's music." (07:50, Kristen, listener from NJ)
On the mainstreaming of orchestral music:
"The majority of the symphonic and orchestral music heard today is heard in the movies." (15:26, Elliot Forrest)
On film music enabling visual recall:
"You can hear some music and instantly think of the visuals that come with it." (25:02, Bianca, listener)
The conversation is enthusiastic, inclusive, and passionate—balancing musicologist insight with cinematic nostalgia and listener engagement. The show honors both the technical craft and emotional heart of film music, inviting both experts and newcomers to appreciate its history and ongoing evolution.