Podcast Summary
Episode Overview
Podcast: All Of It with Alison Stewart
Episode: 'Fight Back' Turns Audience Members into Participants in an Act Up Meeting
Host: Alison Stewart
Air Date: May 7, 2026
Guest: David Wise, creator of Fight Back
This episode centers on Fight Back, a groundbreaking immersive theater experience that brings audience members into a recreation of a 1989 ACT UP meeting, where activists planned direct action against New York City Hall and then-Mayor Ed Koch in the midst of the AIDS crisis. The production is held in the very room where the real meetings took place and assigns each attendee the persona of an actual historical participant, challenging them to inhabit their character throughout the event. Host Alison Stewart speaks with creator David Wise about the creation, research, and significance of the project, how activism is remembered and embodied, and the role of theater in advocacy.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
The Inspiration & Structure of Fight Back
- Sarah Schulman’s Book as Foundation:
David Wise was inspired by Sarah Schulman’s Let the Record Show: A Political History of ACT UP New York. Reading about the weekly planning meetings—described as, “cruisy and electric and boring all at once”—revealed to him how the empowerment and community ACT UP members experienced came not just from public actions, but the intensity and complexity of organizing together.
"They found their power in that meeting… And when I read Sarah's book, I thought, wow. I never thought about that part of it, and I'd love to experience that." (David Wise, 01:26)
- Full Participation, Not Spectatorship:
From inception, Wise envisioned the piece as interactive—true participation, not guided immersion. No audience plants or hierarchies: every person in the room is on equal footing, challenging the convention of immersive theater as passive.
"There are no plants at Fight Back. Everybody… is a participant on equal footing." (David Wise, 02:36)
"Anyone can do it. In fact, I don't think it's even better to be an actor to do it. You just have to try." (David Wise, 03:17)
Research & Historical Authenticity
- Rich, Sometimes Painful, Oral Histories:
Wise immersed himself in hundreds of oral histories, aided by Schulman’s research. A key challenge: many of those who did not survive the AIDS crisis are underrepresented, complicating the act of recreation and remembrance.
"Most of the oral histories are made by people who survived… The people who didn't survive are underrepresented. And that eats at me a little bit." (David Wise, 03:48)
- Inclusivity Across Generations:
The show balances “those who know the history… versus people who are just learning,” allowing both perspectives to inform the process. Modern sensibilities and language (“gender non-conforming,” “non-binary”) contrast with 1989’s context, often requiring negotiation and translation.
"Some of the younger people… want to be someone who's gender non-conforming or non binary. And it's like, well, those weren't words that we were using at that time." (David Wise, 04:48)
Why a Regular Meeting? Significance of Everyday Activism
- Wise selected a standard planning meeting (two weeks before a major protest) instead of dramatizing the action itself. The details, reconstructed from detailed meeting minutes, offer insight into the day-to-day democracy and labor of the movement.
"It's not about the big action, it's about the minutia, the tedium, the inner workings… There were so many people who were involved, and they were regular people." (David Wise, 07:54; 11:17)
The Context of the AIDS Crisis in 1989
- After years of neglect, the LGBTQ community shifted from shock to anger by the late 1980s. ACT UP targeted City Hall and Mayor Koch for their inadequate response, catalyzing activist engagement and policy change.
"It was clear that nobody was going to save us, that we had to save ourselves… ACT UP brought about faster access to effective treatments." (David Wise, 06:23)
"The city… just wasn't devoting enough resources… was in the pocket of the church… just not providing enough education." (David Wise, 10:12)
Engagement and Emotional Resonance
- Wise describes the onstage experience as a “fusing” of the self and the historical persona, with moments of deep immersion interspersed with inevitable slips out of character. The emotional toll and empowerment are both present, often expressed through procedural work rather than direct confrontation—a conscious directorial choice.
"It's more like a fusing that I'm both me and Jason at the same time." (David Wise, 14:11)
"What's actively happening is minutia. And it's… a more interesting artistic way of exploring it because… that's how they activated their power." (David Wise, 15:42)
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
- On the Participatory Structure:
"When it really works is when you're not thinking about it, when you're just doing… If your body is doing it, it's actually happening, even if the circumstances are fictional." (David Wise, 14:36)
- On The Power of Collective History:
"A lot of things try to heroicize one person… This explores the stories of so many more people… regular people who, because they had to, came together and did something heroic." (David Wise, 11:17)
- On the Role of Women and Internal Frictions:
"The women were such heroes… Many came from activist backgrounds and really had a deep knowledge about how to do activism that the gay men… were not accustomed to not having power. Suddenly there was such a wonderful camaraderie between them. It was prickly sometimes, too." (David Wise, 19:59)
- On Civil Disobedience Training:
"The police's relationship to people with AIDS was particularly fraught at that time. The police were afraid of touching the people, and that could be a useful tool when doing civil disobedience then." (David Wise, 23:02)
Audience Participation & Reflections
Caller Experiences & Reminiscences
- Documentary photographer Jamie (13:21): Shot the 1989 City Hall protest; offers to share his book documenting the era.
- Charlie from Midtown (18:10): Remembers losses among friends, the early AIDS ward at St. Vincent's, and the profound generational pains.
- Listener Texts (17:11 & 19:28): Recall the empowerment of meetings, learning activism, and the anxieties surrounding misinformation about AIDS at the time.
- Mark from UES (20:50): Describes being an extra in a recreation of an ACT UP protest for the TV show Pose, highlighting the emotional intensity and chaos that paralleled real activism.
Participant Reactions to Fight Back
- Many are initially nervous but quickly adapt.
"Almost everyone has said that they were nervous about doing it… Almost everyone has said afterwards that they were fine. It was completely fine." (David Wise, 17:27)
- Attendees report a sense of collaboration and embodiment rather than “performance.”
The Role of Theater in AIDS Advocacy
-
Wise and Stewart emphasize that theater has historically led the way in bringing AIDS issues to the public consciousness—predating mainstream film and television.
"Theater tends to be on the forefront… There were AIDS plays long before there were any AIDS TV shows and movies." (David Wise, 24:43)
-
The act of physically "inhabiting" history—especially in a world where activism is often reduced to virtual participation—underscores the difference between observing and acting. Wise notes that being in the same room is transformative:
"One thing about Fight Back is that it's actually happening in your body." (David Wise, 24:36)
Timestamps for Key Segments
- Inspiration from Sarah Schulman / The Power of Meetings: 01:12–02:29
- Immersive Participation/No Spectators: 02:29–03:27
- Challenges with Historical Gaps: 03:27–04:18
- Generational Gaps & Modern Language: 04:18–05:31
- Context: Where AIDS Activism Stood in 1989: 06:23–07:50
- Why Focus on an Ordinary ACT UP Meeting: 07:54–09:06
- Process & Reconstructing from Minutes: 10:39–11:55
- Embodiment and Emotional Immersion: 14:11–15:42
- Audience Memories and Women in ACT UP: 19:28–20:43
- Civil Disobedience Training Then & Now: 22:58–23:53
- Social Media’s Hypothetical Impact: 24:01–24:36
- Theater as Advocacy: 24:36–25:11
Summary
Fight Back by David Wise offers a unique, body-first exploration of a pivotal moment in AIDS activism, turning audience members into living history. Rooted in rigorous research and designed for both insiders and newcomers, this participatory theater piece highlights the everyday heroism, complex democratism, and emotional truths of ACT UP’s 1989 fight against neglect and inaction. Through recollections, spirited calls, and thoughtful analysis, the episode affirms theater’s crucial role in preserving and reenacting activist memory—not just as story, but as vital, embodied experience.