Podcast Title: All Of It
Host: Alison Stewart
Episode: New York Magazine Celebrates Broadway
Release Date: April 18, 2025
Duration: Approximately 29 minutes

Introduction

In this vibrant episode of ALL OF IT, hosted by Alison Stewart, the spotlight shines on the rich tapestry of Broadway through New York Magazine's latest feature, Legends of Broadway. This special segment celebrates the enduring legacy of Broadway by showcasing a stunning portfolio of photographs and heartfelt interviews with 29 iconic Broadway stars, spanning over six decades of theatrical excellence.

Legends of Broadway Feature

Alison Stewart kicks off the discussion by highlighting the significance of the Legends of Broadway spread, which features luminaries such as Barbara Streisand, Andre de Shields, Dick Van Dyke, Rita Moreno, Lin Manuel Miranda, Mandy Patinkin, and Audra McDonald. These celebrated actors reflect on their most memorable roles, offering listeners a nostalgic journey through Broadway's illustrious history. The feature is complemented by captivating portraits captured by renowned photographer Mark Seliger and insightful essays by esteemed critics Frank Rich and Mark Harris.

Behind the Scenes: Insights from Mark Seliger and David Haskell

Joining Alison are two key figures behind the feature: Mark Seliger, the photographer responsible for the evocative images, and David Haskell, Editor-in-Chief of New York Magazine. Their conversation delves into the creative process and the challenges of encapsulating the essence of each performer and their iconic characters within a single frame.

Mark Seliger shares his approach:

"[...] the idea behind the portfolio is really about a performative experience. Getting to know the characters the actors played was first and foremost"
(02:38)

He emphasizes the collaborative nature of the shoots, working closely with stylists and allowing actors to embody their characters fully, creating multiple stages within his studio to facilitate genuine performances.

David Haskell elaborates on the selection process:

"We wanted to celebrate a manageable number of Broadway legends and do so with performances that resonated both with audiences and the actors themselves."
(06:06)

He highlights the mutual respect among performers and the intimate slice of American culture Broadway represents, underscoring the deep connections and motivations that drive these legendary actors.

Capturing Iconic Performances

The episode provides intriguing anecdotes about photographing some of Broadway's most beloved figures:

• Barbra Streisand posed with a 60s-inspired hat and cape, transforming into her younger self:

  "She came out with this beautiful 60s hat and cape. Once she embraced the character, everything just worked itself out."
  (09:06)

• Lin Manuel Miranda is featured as Usnavi from In the Heights, providing a fresh perspective beyond his global hit Hamilton:

  "He was all in," Mark notes about Miranda’s dedication to embodying Usnavi.
  (11:15)

• Dick Van Dyke, approaching his 100th birthday, brought unparalleled energy to the shoot despite initial hesitations:

  "He is 99 years old and just a lot of chutzpah and spunk."
  (17:34)

• Idina Menzel seamlessly recreated her role as Maureen from Rent, showcasing her unique ability to blend character and performer:

  "She just started to belt it out and play the character, found the moment, and it was pretty much over as it started."
  (22:24)

• Joel Gray discusses the transformative process of creating his iconic role as the Emcee in Cabaret:

  "I had to become disgusting, go very vulgar. It was a risk I took to develop that character."
  (24:42)

Listener Engagement: Sharing Broadway Memories

Throughout the episode, Alison Stewart invites listeners to share their favorite Broadway legends and unforgettable performances. Numerous callers contribute personal stories, enriching the conversation:

• Peter reminisces about Yul Brenner’s charismatic performance in The King and I, highlighting the emotional connection between actor and audience:

  "Such charisma, such presence. It was unforgettable."
  (07:43)

• Martin shares his long-standing love for Broadway, recounting memories of seeing Richard Burton, Julie Andrews, and Audra McDonald:

  "Camelot was the most wonderful show I think I ever got to see."
  (09:06)

• Steven praises the portrayal of Idina Menzel in Rent, celebrating her unique presence on Broadway:

  "We think she's so unique on Broadway. Redwood is such a heartfelt, you know, feelings musical."
  (21:39)

• Rosalind mournfully requests the inclusion of Zero Mostel, honoring his indelible impact on Broadway:

  "He was beyond human. He does belong in your story."
  (23:19)

• Yasmin reflects on the shared cultural affinity New Yorkers have for Broadway, emphasizing its central role in the city’s artistic landscape:

  "This is just the center of this art form. I feel really lucky to be able to be part of it."
  (28:19)

Emotional Resonance and Reflections

The feature not only celebrates Broadway's storied past but also captures the emotional depth and personal connections these legends have with their craft. Mark Seliger recounts moments when actors were moved to tears upon seeing their portraits, underscoring the profound impact of the project:

"Seeing the emotional experiences they were having from seeing the image was just pretty wonderful."
(26:42)

David Haskell reflects on the timeless nature of Broadway performances:

"The sense of past in the present is something that I'll always appreciate."
(27:49)

Conclusion

Alison Stewart wraps up the episode by reaffirming the significance of celebrating Broadway's legends through this remarkable feature. The collaboration between Mark Seliger and New York Magazine not only honors the past but also bridges it with the present, ensuring that the magic of Broadway continues to inspire future generations.

Listeners are left with a renewed appreciation for the artistry and dedication that define Broadway, as well as a deeper understanding of the intricate processes behind capturing its legends in such a meaningful way.

Notable Quotes:

• Mark Seliger (02:38): "It was a very performative experience. Getting to know the characters the actors played was first and foremost."

• David Haskell (06:06): "The actors who are performing at the very top of their game are motivated by each other in a really moving way."

• Mark Seliger (09:06): "Once she became that person, it all of a sudden just worked itself out."

• David Haskell (24:42): "I had to become disgusting, go very vulgar. It was a risk I took to develop that character."

Episode Highlights:

• In-depth discussion on the creation and significance of New York Magazine's Legends of Broadway feature.
• Personal anecdotes and behind-the-scenes insights from photographer Mark Seliger and Editor-in-Chief David Haskell.
• Heartfelt listener contributions sharing cherished Broadway memories.
• Exploration of the emotional and artistic connections between Broadway legends and their iconic roles.

Join the Conversation:

Listeners are encouraged to share their favorite Broadway legends and memorable performances by calling or texting WNYC at 212-433-9692, adding their voices to this celebration of Broadway's enduring legacy.