All Of It: Remembering David Lynch – Detailed Summary

Hosted by Alison Stewart and featuring film and TV critic Matt Zoller Seitz

Introduction

In the January 23, 2025 episode of All Of It, hosted by Alison Stewart on WNYC, the show pays tribute to the late David Lynch, a seminal figure in both television and film. The episode delves deep into Lynch’s enduring legacy, exploring his unique artistic vision, influence on the entertainment industry, collaborations, and the profound impact of his work on audiences and creators alike.

David Lynch’s Legacy and Influence

Matt Zoller Seitz on Lynch’s Unique Style and Influence

Matt Zoller Seitz, a distinguished film and TV critic, leads the conversation on David Lynch's unparalleled influence. Seitz emphasizes Lynch's ability to captivate a mainstream audience despite his avant-garde approach. He remarks, “There’s nobody who can be Lynchian except Lynch” (03:16), highlighting the difficulty in defining what "Lynchian" truly means—a testament to Lynch’s unique and eclectic style that melds surrealism, darkness, and unconventional humor.

Seitz further discusses Lynch's revolutionary impact on both television and film. He notes Lynch's role in shaping the modern television landscape through Twin Peaks, which became a cultural phenomenon by blending mystery, horror, and surreal storytelling. Seitz reflects, “...Lynch was absolutely sincere... an extension of his own personality and values” (05:21), underscoring how Lynch’s personal ethos permeated his creative works, making them resonate deeply with audiences.

Collaborators and Actors

Lynch’s Relationship with Actors and Collaborators

The episode explores Lynch's distinctive approach to casting and collaboration. Seitz points out, “He would use people like Robert Loggia, Bill Pullman, Patricia Arquette, Jack Nance, and Dean Stockwell...” (14:27), illustrating Lynch’s preference for actors who brought a unique, often off-kilter presence to his projects. This preference fostered a repertory-like relationship, similar to Wes Anderson’s ensemble casts, creating a cohesive and mutually understanding creative environment.

A notable highlight is Lynch's final on-screen appearance in Steven Spielberg's The Fabelmans, where he portrayed John Ford. Seitz marvels, “It's so great, the idea of David Lynch playing John Ford... he’s a hero. He’s an American cultural hero...” (12:00), symbolizing the mutual respect and artistic synergy between Lynch and his contemporaries.

Use of Music in Lynch’s Work

Collaboration with Angelo Badalamenti and Impact of Musical Choices

Music plays a pivotal role in Lynch’s storytelling, with his long-standing collaboration with composer Angelo Badalamenti being a focal point of discussion. Seitz recounts, “Lynch was able to essentially give Angelo Badalamenti a handful of words... and Badalamenti would come back with this completed piece of music that was perfect” (29:48). This seamless integration of music and narrative is exemplified in iconic moments like Laura Palmer’s theme from Twin Peaks, where the juxtaposition of Roy Orbison’s “In Dreams” with haunting visuals creates an unforgettable emotional resonance.

Seitz elaborates on the transformative power of Lynch’s musical choices, stating, “The use of music was great. He’s right up there with Scorsese and Spike Lee” (25:56). Lynch’s ability to manipulate soundscapes not only enhances the surreal atmosphere of his films but also leaves a lasting imprint on the audience’s perception of the narrative.

Listener Interactions and Questions

Addressing Audience Perspectives on Lynch’s Work

The episode incorporates listener feedback, addressing diverse viewpoints on Lynch’s portrayal of women and recommendations for newcomers to his filmography.

1. Treatment of Women in Lynch’s Work

   • A listener expressed concerns about the representation of women in Lynch’s films. Seitz responds thoughtfully, “It’s complicated... opinions differ as to that... I personally have found there are a number of people who appreciate the way he delved into trauma” (13:13). He emphasizes that Lynch’s work often explores deep and complex emotional landscapes, sometimes involving themes of trauma and violence, which can be interpreted in various ways.

2. Recommendations for Starting with Lynch’s Films

   • For those new to Lynch’s oeuvre, Seitz recommends starting with The Elephant Man over the more abstract Mulholland Drive, noting its emotional depth and accessible narrative. He states, “I think the Elephant Man has all of the hallmarks that we associate with David Lynch...” (20:41). This recommendation aims to provide newcomers with a foundational understanding of Lynch’s thematic and stylistic preoccupations.

Conclusion and Reflections on Lynch’s Impact

As the conversation draws to a close, Seitz reflects on the profound influence David Lynch had on his own career and the broader cultural landscape. He expresses a desire for Lynch to be more widely recognized and honored, proposing, “There should be parades in honor of him... he’s a hero. He’s an American cultural hero...” (30:20). Seitz envisions Lynch’s legacy continuing to grow, inspiring future generations of artists and audiences to explore the depths of surreal and emotionally charged storytelling.

Notable Quotes

• Matt Zoller Seitz: “David Lynch rearranges your brain” (00:35)
• Seitz on “Lynchian”: “There’s nobody who can be Lynchian except Lynch” (03:16)
• On Lynch’s Emotional Depth: “Lynch was absolutely sincere... an extension of his own personality and values” (05:21)
• On Collaboration with Badalamenti: “Lynch was able to essentially give Angelo Badalamenti a handful of words... and Badalamenti would come back with this completed piece of music that was perfect” (29:48)

Final Thoughts

All Of It masterfully encapsulates David Lynch’s multifaceted legacy through an engaging and insightful conversation with Matt Zoller Seitz. The episode not only honors Lynch’s contributions to culture and art but also invites listeners to reflect on the enigmatic and transformative nature of his work.

Note: Timestamps correspond to the points in the transcript where the quoted statements were made.