Podcast Summary: All Of It – Episode: "What's the Best SNL Sketch of All Time?"

Introduction

In this engaging episode of All Of It, hosted by Alison Stewart on WNYC, the spotlight shines brightly on the iconic television show Saturday Night Live (SNL) as it celebrates its 50th anniversary. The episode delves into a nostalgic journey, exploring the best sketches of all time, featuring expert insights from Abigail Covington, a contributing editor at Esquire. Throughout the discussion, listeners are invited to share their favorite SNL moments, fostering a vibrant community dialogue.

SNL's 50th Anniversary Celebration

The episode kicks off with excitement surrounding SNL’s milestone—the 50th anniversary. Alison Stewart sets the stage by mentioning the grand celebrations, including a live-streamed concert from Radio City featuring stars like Bad Bunny, Lady Gaga, David Byrne, Post Malone, and Lauryn Hill. Additionally, NBC is set to broadcast a three-hour special on Sunday, showcasing former cast members and hosts. Alison hints at a special tribute by revisiting the very first SNL episode, aiming to reminisce and celebrate its rich history.

Top SNL Sketches: Expert Insights

Abigail Covington shares her curated list of the top SNL sketches, emphasizing the subjective nature of comedy. She states, “I think it's important to remember that comedy is subjective” ([02:35]). Covington highlights that the greatest sketches are those that transcend time, remaining memorable and quotable long after their original airing. She cites “More Cowbell” as an example, praising Will Ferrell’s performance and the sketch’s enduring appeal:

“I do think that Will Ferrell here is just at his absolute best. He's so funny. He's like the little shirt... A comedy secret weapon.” ([04:44])

Listener Participation and Favorite Sketches

Listeners call in to share their favorite SNL sketches, contributing to the lively discussion:

• Arthur from Queens ([05:04]) reminisces about early sketches featuring Richard Pryor and a parody of The Exorcist with Tina Fey and Amy Poehler.
• Mo from Lynbrook, Long Island ([05:57]) shares a personal connection, having been cast in an SNL Christmas show sketch three years prior.
• Jane from Croton on Hudson ([17:44]) fondly remembers the Scotch Tape skit with Bill Murray, Jane Curtin, and Dan Aykroyd.
• Shelly ([18:58]) enjoys the “Dueling Brandos” sketch featuring Diane Keaton, blending Marlon Brando lines with comedic twists.

Iconic Sketch Highlights

Covington elaborates on several legendary sketches, providing context and notable quotes:

• "More Cowbell" ([03:30]): A simple yet brilliant sketch where a band relentlessly plays the cowbell, leading to the famous line:

  “I have a fever, and the only prescription is more cowbell.” – Bruce (played by Ferrell) ([03:27])

• "Too Hot in the Hot Tub" ([08:50]): Eddie Murphy’s charismatic impersonation of James Brown trying to enter a hot tub, delivering memorable lines:

  “You ran into me, which is a really good argument.” ([22:48])

• "Matt Foley: Motivational Speaker" ([12:55]): Although initially deemed “not really funny,” Covington appreciates the heart in Eddie Murphy’s portrayal:

  “Matt Foley is a down on, you know, down and out guy... There's a lot of heart in this character.” ([13:39])

• "Iceberg Who Sank the Titanic" ([21:27]): Bowen Yang’s portrayal of an iceberg discussing its new EDM album, humorously addressing the Titanic disaster:

  “Why are you attacking me?” ([21:34])

Great Cast Members and Hosts

Covington discusses the impact of exceptional cast members, highlighting:

• Eddie Murphy ([11:12]): Recognized for sheer impact and versatility.
• Will Ferrell ([11:20]): Known for his boundless energy and ability to overshadow even the sketches he appears in.
• Phil Hartman ([11:20]): Celebrated for his range and ability to enhance fellow cast members’ performances.

Regarding SNL hosts, Steve Martin is lauded as the number one host of all time for setting a versatile and enduring template:

“He was the first... He really explored the entire range of what a host could be.” ([28:53])

Memorable Female Contributions

The episode also acknowledges the significant contributions of female cast members:

• Tina Fey’s Sarah Palin ([26:44]): Her portrayal had a profound impact on public perception of Sarah Palin, capturing nuances that resonated with audiences and influenced political satire.

  “I think she really did [impact the election]. Her impression ... has become synonymous with Sarah Palin.” ([26:48])

• Molly Shannon’s Mary Katherine Gallagher ([20:05]): A beloved character, though Covington differentiates between a great character and a great sketch, emphasizing the importance of writing and broader appeal.

Commercial Parodies and Pre-Recorded Bits

Covington remarks on the evolution of SNL’s sketch formats, noting the significance of pre-recorded bits and commercial parodies. These elements have become integral to the show’s diversity and comedic breadth, allowing for innovative storytelling and memorable moments.

Conclusion: SNL's Enduring Legacy

As the episode wraps up, Alison Stewart and Abigail Covington reflect on SNL’s remarkable journey over five decades. The discussion underscores the show’s ability to remain relevant, innovative, and beloved by multiple generations. Covington emphasizes the importance of creating sketches that stand the test of time, ensuring SNL’s continued legacy in the realm of cultural comedy.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Abigail Covington on Comedy’s Subjectivity ([02:35]):

  “I think it's important to remember that comedy is subjective.”

• On "More Cowbell" ([03:30]):

  “No one else could have done it.”

• On "Matt Foley" ([13:39]):

  “There’s a lot of heart in this character.”

• On Steve Martin as Host ([28:53]):

  “He really explored the entire range of what a host could be.”

Final Thoughts

This episode of All Of It offers a comprehensive and heartfelt exploration of SNL’s rich history, celebrating its best sketches and the talents that have defined it. Through expert analysis, listener participation, and a deep appreciation for comedic art, Alison Stewart and Abigail Covington create a nostalgic yet insightful narrative that honors the cultural significance of Saturday Night Live.