
Loading summary
Chris Hutchins
Navigating tax advice on the Internet can be tricky, so today we're digging into what most people get wrong about taxes and tax law, the myths that keep spreading wildly on social media, and how to avoid costly mistakes when you file. I'm joined by Jasmine Deluci, a seasoned tax pro who became an enrolled agent while she was still in high school. She knows this stuff inside and out and we're going to dive into the strategies and tactics to help you save money and and take control of your taxes. I'm Chris Hutchins. If you enjoy this episode, please share it with a friend or leave a comment or review. And if you want to keep upgrading your life, money and travel, click follow or subscribe now. Let's get into it right after this. This episode is brought to you by Cultural Care. Figuring out what to do about childcare is a challenge we all face as parents. Fortunately, we found a solution. We love hosting an au pair. If you're not familiar, an au pair is a young adult from another country who lives with you for the year and helps care for your kids. We've been a host family with Cultural Care au pair since 2021 and it's been so great for us. We love the personalized attention for our kids and the flexibility it gives us as parents. It's also a lot less expensive than most people think and we chose Cultural Care because they're the biggest agency in the US and work with hundreds of au pairs from over 25 countries who all go through an extensive multi step screening and training process. One reason we love having an au pair is that our family, and especially our girls get some exposure to the world outside of our community. So far we've had au pairs from Italy, Colombia and Spain and we've learned new cultures, languages and foods from each one. So if you're interested in flexible and personalized childcare, you have to check out Cultural Care au Pair. And as a new host family, if you go to allthehacks.com culturalcare you'll get 250 off your first year after you match with an au pair again. Find your next au pair@allthehacks.com cultural care or find the link in the show.
Jasmine Deluci
Notes Jasmine what do you think is wrong with so much of the tax advice you see on the Internet?
Chris Hutchins
A lot of my criticisms keep coming back to people. Just look at the statute and then they make up in their mind what the lies, right? Because we think, oh well, statute, we've got the law, that's it, right? But if you've watched any of my content. You know that we've got several layers of law, right? Tax law has statute, treasury regulations, court cases, and then we even have more guidance from that, like revenue rulings, revenue procedures. People don't love when I say this. People that are really deep in tax law just don't tend to post online. So what I tend to see is people that post online tend to have a very surface level of tax law. You know, they'll learn a little bit and they're like, well, shoot, do I want to work myself to death and make 1/100th of what I could or do I just want to post random thoughts online and make a hundred times more? So then they butcher that basic stuff and say it wrong. And I think it's genuinely like they don't know, not like a malicious intent. When you read base level tax law, you get the wrong answer a lot of times and that's what they're doing.
Jasmine Deluci
Is there an example that we could just use for everyone to understand something that you see posted all the time on the Internet that just isn't correct?
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, clothing is a big one. Fashion accessories or even like haircuts. Right. We think of all these personal things. First thing that's so fun for people to post, there was this one video that I use as an example where this licensed tax preparer is saying, I deduct all my haircuts because they're my brand. And he's, well, I deduct my blue suits because blue is my brand. And that's your perfect example of. He's saying he's relying on IRC162, which is our classic ordinary necessary business expenses. So you go there and you say, okay, yeah, well it says ordinary necessary business expenses. The mistake he's making is he's looking at it and saying, I think it's ordinary and necessary to my business. Literally just like made up in his mind when obviously what we want to do is go to the tax law. So then what do we do? We look at treasury regulations for this one specifically. It doesn't help us. So then we go to court cases. Court cases say, you're going to get a haircut anyways. They say personal grooming. It's just so inherently personal it can't be for business purposes. And then we get that same result for clothing. There's actually a three part tax court test for clothing. And so the one that everyone violates is it can't be suitable for personal use even if you only use it for business. So A blue business suit, very suitable for personal use, therefore not deductible.
Jasmine Deluci
Now I remember one time my wife was selling to college campuses and part of their brand for the company was everyone bought big animal, almost Halloween costumes. Presumably that's not a personal use, so that might have qualified as a business expense. But a suit, a shirt, a haircut, all these things are not.
Chris Hutchins
You obviously wouldn't have purchased that for personal reasons. At the end of the day, tax law, a lot of times they just look to substance. We want to look at the laws, but they're almost always built in a way to go back to substance. And so why did you really buy it? Well, probably bought a blue suit. Yeah, you're working in it, you can use that for whatever. And you probably are using it for whatever. And so they just draw a line there to prevent abuse versus something like super unique. There's probably no way she would have gone out and purchased that for any other reason.
Jasmine Deluci
And we're not just going to talk about business related things in our conversation, but I want to double click a little here on what would actually happen if it got to the point that you had to debate this. Is it kind of like innocent until proven guilty or like, do you have to be able to explain that? Well, I actually live in the hottest part of the country. I never wear suits outside of when I'm on video in my studio. So I actually think this suit is a business expense because I would never wear it for personal reasons.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, there's always a practical element to it. And I think that's also why people have gotten so comfortable giving whatever advice because first off, they don't do too many IRS audits. And then when they do, honestly, IRS auditors aren't super knowledgeable a lot of the time if you're a small business. So practically speaking, if you just spend too much on clothing, they'll probably just disallow it. Now if they look into it and they say, well, what were they? And you're like, well, they're suits at that lowest level. They're probably just going to deny it now. Not to say you couldn't then introduce, well, I've got my logo plastered all across the front of it and it made it super ugly. So I would never want to wear this thing for personal use. So there are like arguments you can start to pull out. And the way I view it is if you're on bad law, you want to be more careful. Right. And I think what a lot of people are doing online is they're Pretending like it's good law. And so then if you get into the argument, you have to be super careful, and you may still be able to get it through if you didn't abuse it so much, but because it's not going to be noticed, otherwise, you're going to have problems.
Jasmine Deluci
And by bad law and good law, you've kind of highlighted before that there's the statutes, there's the treasury regulations, and the court cases. Would bad law be where there's a statute but it's been heavily scrutinized or clarified in other ways?
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, I would say bad law is like, if I do a full research and I look up what the answer is, and I'm like, wow, everything's against us. The levels of authority you typically want to have, we call it, like substantial authority. 40% of what's out there gives you a good position. And if you think of haircuts, I've pulled all the court cases, they all say, no, it's just what it is. So then you thinking, well, it's yes. Right. A lot of people like to use the example of, like, Botox or different types of enhancements and stuff. We've got the court cases, and they just laugh at the taxpayer every single time. I'll see licensed preparers recommending it, or they'll say, oh, this is a case of first impression. It's like you're saying that because you haven't looked up all the court cases that actually exist already.
Jasmine Deluci
So I looked at a handful of the most common things on social media, and one that I've seen a lot of is around hiring your kids.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah.
Jasmine Deluci
And this one seems like both. I understand it. And it also seems a little skeptical. Do you have any thoughts on that?
Chris Hutchins
A lot of the themes, I repeat, one of them is substance. We know with tax court, we know with tax law, we've got substance over form. And so whatever form you put it in, it will always go back to, like, what were you really doing? I think if you're genuinely working in the business, they're genuinely adding value. And then you also do want to keep in mind things like state laws, if you are violating other laws, typically, that alone can be a reason the IRS could deny something. I do think to some extent, if you are careful in areas where the substance is light, then you want to be really strong on procedure. Right. If you're going to hire your kids, we want procedure to be really strong. Well, what would procedure be? That's all those technical formalities. Right. That's. I want an employment contract, I want an hours log, I want a calendar, I want to know exactly what they're doing. We want to actually issue A W2. So we have really strong procedure. The substance is a little light. They're your kids. We're like a little bit skeptical, but we've got all this proof that actually we've got some substance there. Where people tend to go wrong in these types of areas is they do neither. Right. The substance is light because you know what, it's my kid and I'm just kind of paying them to take out the trash. And I would never actually pay whatever $15,000 a year for someone to take out the trash. And then, oh, by the way, I have no employment contract, no proof, nothing. Whereas that might hold in a third party arrangement. Right. If I hired a random person off the street and paid them 20,000 a year, I may be fine with not having an employment contract, I may be fine with not having all these technicalities, but because there's no related party nature, it doesn't get the same scrutiny.
Jasmine Deluci
Yeah, that makes sense. And one of the things that I noticed was interesting was in a lot of these videos talking about all these great tactics, they don't clarify that even if you were doing them by the book, even if they were appropriate, if you just have a W2 income and you're working at a company, you can't write off your meals, you can't classify your car as a business expense. And a lot of these things that I've heard people, one on one talking to them, say, I work at Google and I'm taking a friend out to lunch, I'll just write that off. And I'm like, well, one, I don't know if you could write it off even if you did own the company. And, and two, I don't think you can do this as an employee. So are most of these things even relevant to people who don't own businesses?
Chris Hutchins
So ever since the tax reform passed in 2017, that started in 2018, there were some that would apply at the time. You have to still get over that itemized threshold. But things like home office, you could take some of those things. But actually I had a professor who was a part of drafting all of the tax reform at that time. They had to fit within a certain budget, over 10 year projections. And so because they made so many cuts in other areas, they had to have certain areas where they increase the revenue. And one of those is basically eliminating all of the deductions for employees. So right now, absolutely not you get nothing.
Jasmine Deluci
What advice do you have for people for how to handle and scrutinize tax advice on the Internet? How do you think people should try to figure out what's good and what's not?
Chris Hutchins
At the end of the day, you want to get real professional advice if you're going to rely on it. So ideally, finding someone that you actually trust that can apply it to your situation. And. And I think social media serves as a great way to introduce the question, not necessarily that they have their answer.
Jasmine Deluci
And when you highlighted there's statutes, there's treasury regulations, there's court cases, all of these things can also be found. I would encourage people to go look them up. I'm going to share one example that's particularly relevant to the audience, which is I've often talked about how credit card points are treated as a rebate and they are not taxable. So I've recently heard some people questioning whether that's true. And the argument being really more on the business side. Well, if you're using this to generate a profit, should it reduce your cost basis in whatever you bought or not? I looked and there was a revenue ruling that said a purchase incentive, such as credit card reward or points, is not treated as income, but as a reduction in the purchase price of what is purchased with the rewards or points. And then there was this case where they actually decided. And what I thought was interesting was this couple had generated a few hundred thousand dollars in rewards on two credit cards, buying gift cards and then liquidating and reselling them, as well as funding money orders. And the takeaway was when used to directly buy money, which they only included the money orders. You are turning to profit and that would be taxable. But to buy a gift card, which they felt was more of a product, you're okay. And so, yes, I could go online and look all these things up. If you want to get clarity around it, if you're doing a little bit of this, maybe it's okay to do a little bit of digging. But if you're generating hundreds of thousands of dollars of rewards a year, it might be worth going to read these yourself.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah. Or reading them yourself, realizing that maybe there's not full clarity, and then maybe even hiring someone to give an opinion on it. Right. Because I don't view it as like, you're ever fully safe. Right. Like, at the end of the day, you can have an awesome, easy, clear tax position with the irs, not something as complicated as the credit card rewards. And you still face issues in audits like the Reality is, people think, oh, I'll just be good. But there's just so much bureaucracy, you have to check so many boxes that even safe positions are questioned in an audit. So I just view it as like, you just want to protect yourself, like risk averse. So if you're taking a slightly more aggressive position, you can pre disclose it on the return on an 8275, and then you're allowed to rely on less authority to take that position and reduce your exposure for IRS penalties. And you quite literally disclose positions that you still have to have a basis for, but you're allowed to. Instead of having substantial authority at 40% basis, you're allowed to have, I think it's 20% basis and in your authority. So you're allowed to rely on less law. So whenever I have situations where I'm like, well, this is something that I feel comfortable with, we've got support for, but there is some support on the other side that I don't love. We can always proactively disclose it. And I've never seen that trigger an audit or do anything like that.
Jasmine Deluci
Okay, so that's basically saying, hey, I'm not as sure, but I want to let you know that I think I'm sure.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah. Saying I've got authority for this, but it's something you may disagree with. So I'm just going to proactively. I'm not trying to hide anything. Like, I'm trying to be really clear about it, tell you the authority that I'm relying on. And it's worked every time I've done it. I've never had an audit result from it, so.
Jasmine Deluci
And let's talk a little bit about audits. Almost everyone I know is scared of them, but don't actually understand them. Can you talk a little bit about what happens if you get audited?
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, the audit process. I've been trying to provide a lot more clarity for it because unless you're just doing it, like there's nowhere else you can learn about it, to me, it's not common sense. So when you get audited, that part is what you would expect. I do think people assume the auditor is really sophisticated, which if you were a much larger business, like there's different divisions. Right. So if you're a very large business, you're going to probably get someone sophisticated. But most people are under that $10 million gross receipt threshold, in which case they honestly, like these auditors are in the middle of training. They have so many checkboxes to get through. Like, they're just paper pushing and, and I don't say it to be mean, but it's just, it's government, right? They've been put into a position where it's like, just collect this, check the box. Collect this, check the box. They're not really put in a position or trained to think too much. And so first off, I see people like way over explaining, if anything, I always make it such that I don't want my client to ever even talk to the irs. Sometimes they're more insistent than others. There's never a positive that could come out of it. I mean, you probably hear this in like every area of law, right? People think, oh, I'll just explain everything. They'll just know that I'm not guilty, right? But they don't really care with their specific list of things they need to get through. Like they're looking for receipts. Missing the receipt, denied, missing the receipt, denied. That's it. And a lot of times they just try to get everything unless you control it. They'll ask for literally the back end of your books. They'll ask for every receipt known to man. And then that's where ideally you have representation coming in being like, okay, well, we're not going to give you the books because we actually printed everything out for you and we're not going to give you 8,000 receipts. So why don't you choose a sample size list of ones that are representative of the things that you're concerned about, Right? So trying to limit that. But even with great representation, I would say at the lowest level, we just have adverse decisions against us. And that's where I think a lot of people think, oh, no, I lost. Like, it's so expensive to go to the next level. What do I do? I'm pretty quick to say, okay, if we're just not getting there with this person, then we just go to appeals. And appeals is where you really get someone that is actually more concerned with the substance, the big picture. Not to say they don't care about it at all, but they're less going to be like, I need that receipt for this $40 meal. And they're more like, okay, well, is this person a real estate professional? Right. And so then at that point, if you still don't get where you need to go, you can go up higher. You go to IRS council before actually heading to tax Court. We almost never actually go to tax court. Like, if you're actually going to tax Court, you're probably a very large company because I would say they give more adverse decisions than negotiating with IRS counsel and negotiating with IRS appeals. So if you weren't able to resolve with IRS appeals and counsel, you're probably going to lose in tax court.
Jasmine Deluci
Obviously it's all subject to audit, but if there's something that looks egregious, do they put scrutiny on that thing that looks egregious or as soon as you hit that audit, they're like, we're going to look at everything.
Chris Hutchins
They pretty much look at everything. They may have picked it up for the thing that was egregious. Right. So whenever you have like a massive loss or maybe too much charitable contributions, that might have been the reason it was flagged. Every now and then an audit might be limited to specific items, but usually they're like, oh, there's a schedule C, give me all the receipts. There's a schedule E, give me all the receipts. You did a rental. Give me your material participation log.
This episode is brought to you by 1Password, which I have been using for over a decade and absolutely love. Okay, so I want you to think of a password now. Add a number, a special character. Not that one, a different one. Make it eight characters now, 12 characters and remember it forever and then do it a hundred more times. Seems impossible, right? 1Password can do all that for you, your family, your employees and more. 1Password combines industry leading security with award winning design to bring private, secure and user friendly password management to everyone. And that's important because countless hours are lost every day from people forgetting and resetting passwords. And a single data breach can cost millions of dollars. Best of all, 1Password works on any device anytime and and lets you securely switch between iPhone, Android, Mac and PC. All you have to remember is the one strong account password that protects everything else. Your logins, credit cards, even secure notes. So protect yourself, your global workforce or just your family with the award winning 1Password which is Wirecutter's number one pick and trusted by millions of users and over 100,000 businesses from IBM to Slack. Right now my listeners get a free two week trial at all the hacks.com 1Password for your growing business. That's two free weeks@allthehacks.com 1Password. Don't let security slow your business down. Go to allthehacks.com 1Password I love a great deal as much as the next person. But the best deals are the ones that are easy, with no hoops to jump through and no bs. That's why I love the deal from our sponsor, Mint Mobile because you can get a wireless plan for $15 a month with the purchase of a three month plan plan. And it's so easy to switch from your existing carrier unless you have to wait on hold with them. But that'll at least be the last time you have to do that. To get started, go to allthehacks.com mintmobile There you'll see that your first three month plan is only $15 a month, including the unlimited plan. After that, it's still a great deal. And we've loved having a line on Mint Mobile for the past year, so you should definitely check it out. All plans come with high speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. You can bring your phone number and use your own phone with any Mint Mobile plan. To get this new customer offer and your new 3 month unlimited wireless plan for just 15 bucks a month, go to allthehacks.com mint mobile that's all. Thehacks.com mint mobile M I N T Mobile Cut your Wireless bill to 15 bucks a month at AllTheHacks.com Mint Mobile $45 upfront payment required equivalent to $15 a month New customers on first 3 month plan only speed slower above 40 gigabytes on unlimited plan. Additional taxes, FE fees and restrictions apply. See Mint Mobile for details.
Jasmine Deluci
Just a personal question. On the receipt side, do you think that credit card transactions justify receipts or do you really need like the receipt? Receipt?
Chris Hutchins
You need the receipt at the lower level. Like if the IRS were up with the times, they would change that policy because it's just ludicrous. But they're like very behind on technology. Just everything is very slow moving. So they can barely find enough people to take the jobs that they need. So no, at the lower level, I mean, I have a lot of IRS audit cases at Appeals where what happens is people will not have the receipts. Literally. The auditor will just deny everything. A lot of times this is a generalization, but a lot of them will just say, oh, no receipt, nothing. And they'll just be like, pretend like there's not a business. We'll just recognize the gross income and deny every single deduction known to man. And that's where Appeals won't do that. There's what we call the Cohen Rule, which is formed in Tax Court, right? So it's not a law formally, but it's a doctrine created by Tax Court that basically says we can see there's a business. We can reasonably estimate the expense that you had. We can reasonably estimate what it was on which I would say credit card transactions and bank statements can meet that threshold to some extent, then they allow the expenses. But it's intended to be like a fairness doctrine, not so much an offensive sword against the irs. So it usually works at appeals, and I've never had it really work at appeals, the lower auditor level.
Jasmine Deluci
And are there common things that flag people for audits?
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, negative Schedule Cs, negative Schedule E's, large losses will flag. I see a lot of audits by association. So if you're involved in something else that has a problem. So I've seen people with like a conservation easement under scrutiny and getting audited. Iris doesn't like those. You're there by association. I've also seen audits jump from person to person in the medical area, especially like kickbacks. I had someone that got audited because he was written a check from the person with the problem, and then they look at your file and they say, oh, this person got a check. That check said roi. This is a little sketchy. And then they say, oh, you haven't filed. Boom. Audit.
Jasmine Deluci
What about when you're amending returns after the fact and making changes? Is that put you at higher risk.
Chris Hutchins
If you're asking for lots of money back? Yeah, that's also one of the ways I'll see people audited. You think about common sense, right? You filed your own return wrong. You already got it wrong once, and now you think, whatever, you're owed $200,000. And process wise at the IRS, amended returns actually land on someone's desk. So it's not the same as a superseded return or an original return, which is basically automatically processed. An amended return is much slower. It takes like honestly nine months up to a year sometimes, because it actually just gets stuck on someone's desk. And then if you think about a human looking at something, if you're like, I'm owed $300,000, we got all of these line items wrong and we changed literally everything. I mean, it's just so easy to push it to the audit.
Jasmine Deluci
And how long does this whole process take? Because I got a new CPA who reviewed my 2019 return, found a five figure mistake right before the deadline to amend. We amended it, I feel like over a year ago. And we literally just got the refund check.
Chris Hutchins
Oh, nice.
Jasmine Deluci
Now. So good. But it's 2024. It's almost 2025. It was like an 18 month process. When the IRS does flag things for audits, is that months later, years later, it just varies.
Chris Hutchins
But you can check your IRS Transcripts, you can actually see if you've been flagged for an audit. So that'll tell you up to six months before it'll be, like, forwarded for an audit. So that's one way to check the amended returns take a long time. Sometimes they get stuck on people's desks. Like, they literally just sit there. We do this only after several months have passed. But you could go through, like, the IRS tax advocate and check in on it and say, no one's getting back to me on this because the IRS doesn't have to process your amended return. In theory, they could sit on it. So usually they don't do that, but there are instances where it's like, is anyone going to get here? You know, at some point, you don't.
Jasmine Deluci
Want to just wait when you do get it wrong. I have one example where a friend of mine got what they thought was a gift from a parent, but what turns out was that parent had a business entity set up with all the children in the family as owners. And so that gift was actually a distribution from a company, and they never got a 1099 or anything. Three years later, they found out that the gift they got from their parents was taxable, but it took years, and they owed penalties and interest on top of that. That seems like something that was flagged because the business entity submitted something. Maybe they even filed the 1099 with the state, but didn't send it to the children. So that seems like something where it comes back to the transcripts. I want to talk about IRS transcripts because that's actually the reason we're talking today, because a really good friend of mine sent me a video you made about IRS transcripts and was like, I've never heard about this strategy. It's amazing. You have to talk to this person. And so how are you using IRS transcripts to make sure you get things right?
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, so you want to check them. So I was going to say, in that instance you just described, there probably was a K1. If you're telling me they're an owner.
Jasmine Deluci
Let'S even just define what they are.
Chris Hutchins
For people, it's the file the IRS has on you. So if the IRS has a file on you, why wouldn't you want to see it? It's publicly available. They make it electronic. You can literally just create an account with the IRS log in, and then there's multiple types of transcripts. So you've got your account transcript, which is going to show the base level of your account. It's going to Say, like, what payments have you made to the irs? For which tax year has your return actually been filed? Has your amended return been received? Right. So it's very much those base level things which if I'd filed an amended return, the first thing I'd be looking to see, you know, did the IRS receive it? You know, if they didn't receive it, you could wait two years and then be like, where's my refund? And then they'll say, oh, we didn't get it. Now you're outside the statute of limitations.
Jasmine Deluci
And how quickly are those kinds of things updated? If I file my return today, how soon will it show that it's been filed?
Chris Hutchins
Usually at least a couple of weeks. It still takes a little time. If you did it electronically now, if you mailed it, it'd be like six months, nine months. I would say after waiting a couple months, if it's not there, I would be very concerned. And usually you always want to have proof that you already submitted. But yeah, so that's the account transcript. So I look to that for like if you made a payment and sometimes they receive it, they cash it, but they don't credit it to your account. Right. So did it also get credited to my account? Then when you go to the wage and income transcript, that's the one that would avoid most of the problems. So that's the one where if a K1 was filed with your social on it, if a 1099 was filed, every document with your name and social is going to be on there. The problem is if you check too early, you won't have all the information, so it populates by the following year. So for example, right now we're in 2024. If you want your 2024 wage and income transcripts, you'll obviously need to wait till next year because things like your W2, all of that stuff hasn't even been filed with the IRS and then takes time to populate. Usually a safe time to check is going to be June of the following year.
Jasmine Deluci
So that means that in order to check, you would have to by default file an extension and not file in April.
Chris Hutchins
So what I recommend is we want to do one of two things. If you want to file early because you want a refund, usually is the reason, the only reason.
Jasmine Deluci
So.
Chris Hutchins
So for example, extend in February, file by April, but then if you notice a problem, you want to check in June or September, whenever, before the final deadline, you can file a superseded return. The reason we like superseded returns is one, they process faster and then Two, do you know you have. On an amended return, you have that page of, like, original change difference, like you're highlighting the problems that were there. Instead, it's just literally submitting a new original return.
Jasmine Deluci
Okay. And so it's not ending up on someone's desk like an amended return would.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, but the only reason you can do a superseded return is if it's timely. So if you never extended in the first place, you'd have to do an amended return if you're filing after April. But if you extended and then filed, you're still technically timely until October 15th, I think.
Jasmine Deluci
One takeaway for everyone listening. W2, employee, business owner. Even if you file in April, there's no extra cost or risk to just also filing for an extension.
Chris Hutchins
You just have to file the extension before you actually file the return.
Jasmine Deluci
So file the extension, then file the return, and then May, June. Check your IRS transcripts. If anything's off, file a superseded return, and you're in a way better position than if you filed an amended return. And if nothing's off, then you're fine. You already filed, you're done.
Chris Hutchins
Hopefully the IRS will start publishing transcripts earlier, but right now they don't. So either you do that work yourself, even though we could say in fairness, you shouldn't have to. Right. I think there's always this argument of, like, why should I have to do that? But if you're going to be the one holding the bag, you probably should just do it. Because the alternative right now, based on the way the IRS operates, is they give it a good two to three years and then send you a notice with penalties.
Jasmine Deluci
Yeah. What happens on the flip side? Let's say in my case, I filed an amended return years later, then they took another year and a half to pay me. Do they have to pay me penalties and interest?
Chris Hutchins
Not penalties. There is some interest, but it's not for the time that passed. It's for once you file your claim for refund, then the clock starts. They have, I think it's like 45 days to process it. And if they go wildly outside of that. Yeah, they will pay you interest. To me, what's always very scary is being outside the statute of limitations. Right. So with refund requests, which is what an amended return is, if it has a refund on it, you have to have specificity. So what I see people do, especially with not great repairers, is you file the amended return. You don't put enough detail, you blow the statute of limitations. If they were able to process that specific Amended return, it'd be fine. But if they say, hey, this amended return doesn't have specificity, we're rejecting it now, you're past the statute of limitations. You can no longer ask for the money back.
Jasmine Deluci
And what is the statute of limitations?
Chris Hutchins
It's the later of three years from a timely filing or two years from payment.
Jasmine Deluci
Does that fit into your favor in a way that filing earlier gives the IRS less time? Because it works both ways. Right. If they wanted to come after you and you filed right. On April 15, they'd have less time than if you wait and file on October 15th.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah. So that is one consideration. By extending and then filing later, you are extending the statute of limitations for them. I haven't seen any, like, correlation between them auditing those people less or being less likely to pursue.
Jasmine Deluci
My argument would be, if you're banking on the statute of limitations to allow you to do something you shouldn't do, you probably shouldn't have done it in the first place.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah.
Jasmine Deluci
Is there anything else you do personally with your taxes, like the IRS transcripts, that you think people listening might benefit from hearing?
Chris Hutchins
I personally extend. I always want simplicity in everything. Right. So not that we don't want to maximize the tax benefit. I do. And I care a lot about that as well. I care a lot about not just minimizing my taxes, but also minimizing penalties, interest, and honestly, problems. Right. The more busy you get, especially in business. But honestly, in any area, I know how painful it is to work with the irs. Like, even if I got audited today, I would be stressed about it now. I'd be in the driver's seat, so I'm not going to crazy worry, but it would stress me out because I know just the time it takes would be honestly a huge loss in money to me. Right. Huge loss in energy, effort, everything. So everything I do is built around that. And obviously transcripts is one of them. I like to actually extend. I want one return, submit it, that's it. And then everything I do is clean. I'm going to assume the IRS is looking at my return. If there's anything that doesn't look good, I would prefer to not make it stand out. Right. Without misrepresenting. So if someone were to look at it and you labeled meals as, I don't know, something, not meals, then I think that's misrepresenting. But you could also do, like, certain labels that just don't pull out attention. Right. So I might not label gifts. I may label it, you know, a part of Something else that represents what it is. For example, actually, I have a client that I've been working with. They're under audit and they're about to file. So whenever you're under current audit, they're going to look at the return and then decide, do I want to audit this return? And so things like clearing out any Schedule C's with a loss on them. I don't care if you truly had a loss. I would rather not take the deduction at that point, knowing that it's going to be under scrutiny if the deduction is small, rather than highlight the fact that we've got something that looks really interesting to look into. So those are the kind of decisions. Sometimes it's esthetic as well.
Jasmine Deluci
I was just thinking about how you look at the IRS transcripts and you're probably comparing them to your set of documents you've received. How often are the documents, the W2s, the 1090 nines, actually incorrect themselves?
Chris Hutchins
It happens all the time, especially 1099s. So W2s are usually accurate because they have to match up with the rest of the IRS's records on actual withholdings from the employer. But 1099s, I will see all the time. I log in to someone's account and it's a 1099 C, very often incorrect. It's just like, issued in the wrong year. It's something the client wasn't even aware of. Regular 1099s, you have to remember, it's just another human issuing it. On the other side, I was talking to someone that the bookkeeper added a zero to the 1099. And it's like, whoever's buying this 1099, a lot of times it's an administrative assistant, right? And if you were paid $2,500 and that administrative assistant makes it $250,000, that is what the IRS will have on file, and they'll automatically add it to your return.
Jasmine Deluci
What about ones from banks and brokerage firms showing mortgage interest or interest from your savings account or brokerage transactions?
Chris Hutchins
If they're incorrect, there's, like, not even much you can do about it a lot of times. But I don't tend to see huge errors on those. Those tend to be correct.
Jasmine Deluci
And when you find something that's not on an IRS transcript, but you got a 1099, the IRS didn't, is that a cause for concern? Do you try to look into why, or you just accept that they might have missed it and you're going to include it no matter what it probably.
Chris Hutchins
Wasn'T the IRS missing it. It was probably the employer not filing it with the irs. That's what I would assume. And then, you know, you look at it and say, well, did I receive the income? If I received the income, you're supposed to. You still report it.
Jasmine Deluci
Of course. Anything else that people should be thinking about? High level. I want to hear if we're missing anything about how to think about filing in taxes.
Chris Hutchins
High level. I think people tend to rely too much on their expert, especially when their expert's not an expert. And so to me, I always view it as like, you're the one holding the bag. It's your tax return. You're literally signing under penalties of perjury. The IRS cares about you, not your preparer. That's why I like to put out so much information, because it's actually just something you need to understand, even if it's something you're not that interested in.
Jasmine Deluci
I was talking to someone at a conference and she was interviewing for a job at intuit working on TurboTax.
Chris Hutchins
Oh, you think about this a lot.
Jasmine Deluci
What do you think of TurboTax?
Chris Hutchins
Yeah.
Jasmine Deluci
And I was like, look, it can help you fill out the forms. And they might have some policy where they're like, we will defend you, but at the end of the day, if you use the tool wrong, you're going to fill out the forms wrong, and that's not on them. What's your take on when someone could rely on a tool like that versus need a preparer versus just fill out the form themselves without needing any software?
Chris Hutchins
Yeah. It's ideally an unbiased assessment of your own skills. Right. Some people just have no business preparing their return. Even if it's on the simpler side, they will find a way to mess it up. Just not their thing being timely. I mean, there's benefits to a preparer beyond the actual knowledge. Right. A lot of times it's like peace of mind. It's just timeliness. It's actually just going to get done. So assessing your own skills and then at that point, I mean, TurboTax is great for whenever you've got clear tax documents that just need to be input. It will do it perfectly. Right. But I've seen people misuse it. We had an IRS audit. I don't know how they did this, but they use TurboTax and they input their Schedule C stuff on both Schedule C and Schedule E. And I think they don't know how to read the output. And they're the preparer. I think when it's W2. Stuff like TurboTax is great and if anything they're better than hiring someone who doesn't care about their return as much as you care about your return. But once you start going into business or if you're taking any specific tax positions, I would just find someone that knows what they're doing.
This episode is brought to you by Gelt. When it comes to building wealth, taxes are such a big part of the strategy and as the year comes to an end, being proactive now to lower your future liability is so important. And now that I'm working with Gelt, I finally feel like I have a partner I can trust to handle everything from my personal and business to taxes. Think of Gelt as the ultimate modern cpa. Of course they have an in house team of expert CPAs to work with who help you determine the most effective tax strategies to minimize risk and grow your wealth. But they also have an amazing tech platform that gives you personalized guidance to maximize deductions, tax credits and savings. It also has an amazing document vault where you can upload all your tax related files, tag them with the relevant years, and even see when your tax team has reviewed each file. Beyond that, the tax library you get access to as a client has dozens of in depth guides on things like choosing retirement plans, taxes for new parents, qualified business income or qbi and so much more. So if you're ready for a more premium proactive tax strategy to optimize and file your taxes, you have to check out ghelt. And as an all the hacks listener, you can skip the wait list. Just head to allthehacks.com Gmail G E L T Again, that's allthehacks.com G E L T to stop overpaying on taxes. This episode is brought to you by NetSuite. What does the future hold for business? Ask nine experts and you'll get 10 different answers. Bull Market Bear market Inflation up, Inflation down. It would be amazing if we had a crystal ball, but until we do, over 38,000 businesses have future proofed their business with NetSuite by Oracle. The number one Cloud ERP bringing accounting, financial management, inventory and HR into one fluid platform with one unified business management suite. There is one source of truth giving you the visibility and control you need to make quick decisions. And when you're closing the books in days, not weeks, you're spending less time looking backwards and more time planning for the future with actionable data. Which is exactly what I'd want as a CEO. Speaking of opportunity download their CFO's guide to AI and machine learning at all AllTheHacks.com NetSuite the guide is free to you at AllTheHacks.com Netsuite N E T S U-I T E AllTheHacks.com NetSUite I just want to thank you quick for listening to and supporting the show. Your support is what keeps this show going. To get all of the URLs, codes, deals and discounts from our partners, you can go to allthehacks.com deals so please consider supporting those who support us.
Jasmine Deluci
All right, because it's October, this will come out before the end of the year. Okay, I'm going to share some of the things that I try to do before the end of the year and you can let me know if there's anything else. One which is not often possible but accelerating or deferring income or expenses and I would say this is sometimes possible where if you've decided, okay, this year I'm going to itemize or I'm going to take the standard deduction, you might be able to make an extra property tax payment. Now with the current limits, there's $10,000 of state and local taxes, but if you are not at that limit, maybe you wanted to make extra tax payments or mortgage payments in one year and then the next year switch off. So that's one. Or if your company offers the ability to get paid a bonus and defer it for a few years. So thinking about whether there's any income or expenses that you can move around, that was one. Making charitable donations with the caveat that I think everyone should be donating to charity with appreciated assets, right? If you're making any donations to charity with cash, you're effectively leaving money on the table if you own any appreciated assets. So if you own any stock that you bought for less than it's worth today, those are the things you should be donating. And if that's not simple because the places you donate don't take stock, you can pretty inexpensively set up a donor advised fund. People that listen to the show for a while know that DAFI has been a partner. It's where we use our donor advised fund. There are other options. Not many are as simple and good in my opinion, for any equities. If you hold any stocks that are actually not at a gain but are at a loss, you can harvest those losses. Now you can't buy the exact same thing. So you wouldn't want to sell your Google stock and then rebuy it unless you wait 30 days. But if you held a S&P 500 index fund and it was down and you wanted to buy a different index fund, you could, if you're holding stock options. So specifically ISOs, depending on how many you exercise, it may affect your taxes. But sometimes, and this is one where I would say work with a professional for sure, there might be a number of ISOs you could exercise that wouldn't put you into AMT and cause your taxes to increase. And so if you're trying to exercise some ISOs, that's possible. A common one is if you have an fsa, make sure you use it all, because if you don't use it all, then you lose it. So FSA is the employer is going to keep the money if you don't use it by the end of the year. And I would say even if there's absolutely nothing you need, there are places online where you can buy things and donate them. So there are medical supplies that many shelters need. At a minimum, buy some of those things and donate them, even if you don't have expenses. And then there are HSAs, retirement accounts, 5, 29, all things that have annual limits. So if you wanted to contribute to those, make sure you do that before the end of the year if you want to give any gifts. So if you're trying to gift money to your children or family members, those gift exemption limits reset each calendar year. And then if you own a business, think about whether there are any business expenses that you want to get done before the end of the year. Sometimes you might want them this year, sometimes you might actually want them next year. But I have been able sometimes to ask vendors, hey, could we pay for this thing a little early right now? Or maybe you have net 30, net 60, net 90, but you want to pay for it right away so that you can have the expense in that calendar year. Did I leave any glaring thing off that checklist?
Chris Hutchins
No, that was great. I think the one that I like to talk about a lot is for business owners, just because I actually see no one talking about it. If you have a business specifically for S Corps, but really for any type of business, checking your tax basis. So I know it doesn't sound like super exciting like some of those, but it's a timing difference. And so there's a situation where basically if you take out the money in December from your business, you'll pay quite literally a voluntary tax, capital gains, because you access that money versus had you just waited till January to take the money out there would have been no tax. So there's a timing difference, especially with S Corps that have lots of depreciation and third party debt, where if you take the money out, you quite literally create an extra layer of tax just for fun.
Jasmine Deluci
Wow. So that's one that I would say go check with your CPAs on. And then the only other one, completely untax related, is that if you have credit cards that have all these annual credits like an airline credit or hotel credit, make sure you use those before the end of the year as well because those often reset. Some of them are on the card member year, some of them are on the calendar year. I'm going to put together a list of all the things I just mentioned and a few other ones that I find in the newsletter. So all the hacks.com/email and that'll come out sometime before the end of the year. I wanted to ask about a couple of business things. Specifically, you've said S Corps aren't as awesome as people might think they are and that people thinking they should just set up an LLC to save money on taxes probably might be mistaken. And I've had a couple friends say, oh yeah, yeah, I run everything through my llc, so I save money. And I'm curious what you think about that.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, well, I mean the tax law is the tax law, right? It doesn't say if an llc, it's treated this other way. It's based on the tax entities. An LLC is a legal entity, not a tax entity. So just forming an LLC does nothing. It doesn't make a business deduction. The business deduction is either already a business deduction or it's just not. And running it through your llc, it's that procedure versus substance. It's the procedure and it's not what's controlling. So the substance is like what did you spend it on? And do you actually have a business? I like to keep things simple. If you don't have legal liability and you're not doing anything other than sole prop treatment, you probably don't need the LLC or at least recognize it's not providing a tax benefit. And then S Corps, they work really well for businesses like service industry. Whenever there's not much equipment and not much third party debt, they work really well. And then the minute you have more of a business with lots of vehicles, and usually those vehicles are financed, right? Or real estate, all of those typically need to stay out of an S Corp.
Jasmine Deluci
Okay, I feel better because I was like I saw you talking about S Corps. I Was like, oh, I have an S Corp, but don't have a bunch of vehicles, don't have a bunch of third party debt and don't have real estate, so maybe I'm in the clear.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah.
Jasmine Deluci
Anything people should think about with a little bit longer horizon than the end of the year. Obviously we have no idea what's going to happen with an election that as of right now is in days, but the Tax Cut Job act is expiring. Are there any things people should be keeping on their radar in the next kind of 14 months as things to consider?
Chris Hutchins
I mean, yeah, a lot of stuff is going to expire. So even like the qualified business income deduction, I mean, there's lots of things that we've gotten used to lower tax brackets. Who knows at this point what's going to happen? So planning for it, maybe sometimes you think, oh, well, I want to push up my income for this year or for next year before QBI expires. Right. And so it could make a bit of a different decision if you account for the expiration.
Jasmine Deluci
Yeah. The other one that will probably be relevant to a very, very small number of listeners, but I do know some listeners that meet this requirement is that the estate planning gift tax limitations are going to be changing. And so I believe it's something like 13.6 million per person in a married couple is going to come down to about seven, I think. I don't know the exact numbers, but if you're sitting on tens of millions of dollars that you one day would like to give away to your heirs, now would be a really good time to figure out the estate planning to do that. Yeah.
Chris Hutchins
If you're going to be over the new threshold once it expires, you'd basically want to figure it out now because there's no clawback. If you use up the full, whatever 23, whatever million it's at now between a married couple, if you use that up by usually some type of like contribution to an irrevocable trust, then there's no clawback. So you'd want to hurry up and probably use it up because almost in every scenario we're expecting it to go down.
Jasmine Deluci
Yes. But similar to where we started this conversation with everything you see on social media, I've seen a lot of people being like, oh, you should set up.
Chris Hutchins
This trust so you can give money.
Jasmine Deluci
To your children and not have to pay taxes. And I'm like, that is true. However, if the amount of money in your lifetime you're going to give to your children is let's call it just really conservatively less than $5 million, then you don't have to worry about any of this. Sure, that limit could come down even more in the future, but right now it's over $20 million. So I don't want people to think I might leave $500,000 to my kids. Do I need to set up a complicated trust? And the answer is no, you do not.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, no, it would definitely hurt you to do that. I mean, because there's also costs of administering it, even knowledgeable people. I just saw a post the other day and someone's like, saying how revocable trust helps you get step up in basis. Like, they're just making stuff up because you already get step up in basis. So most of the tax benefits are already built in. And really it just comes down to estate tax, because income tax, it either stays the same or it gets worse, depending on what type of trust you choose. And then it's only that estate tax. And then, like we just said, the thresholds are huge. So if you don't have an estate tax problem, you don't want to pay to fix a problem you don't have.
Jasmine Deluci
Now, the only thing, we spent a lot of time at this conference talking about different trusts and all this crazy stuff. But for avoiding capital gains, you can potentially end up in better situations with some charitable remainder trusts and those kinds of things. So if you're about to have a massive sale of a company or sell stock that you bought at a really low basis, let's say you worked at Nvidia the last five years. There's a world where you might not be crossing that 10, 20 million threshold, but you might save money setting up a trust for that purpose. I'm not the expert. We did an episode a while ago on trusts. You absolutely want to work with an expert in this circumstance. But outside of a few of those small scenarios, I would say if you're not over these thresholds, then you're making yourself and your life more complicated. That said, a revocable living trust, a will, and like basic estate planning documents, you should definitely set all of those things up. I'm strongly in favor of those. But more complicated, irrevocable trusts are probably for very specific scenarios that are not common to most people.
Chris Hutchins
Yeah, it always goes back to, like, what are you trying to accomplish? And does it actually get you there? And people talk about trusts a lot, but the reality is they're really complex. Anybody that does regular domestic tax and just happens to like, name drop, random trusts, they're probably not super familiar. Usually on social media, when you think of, like charitable remainder trusts, it's because your purpose is different. It's not to keep the most dollars possible. It's actually with a strong purpose for charity. Right. And so then of course, there are tax benefits for that.
Jasmine Deluci
So if you're trying to pursue anything wild and crazy, talk to someone. Where can people find everything that you've published and where can they go deeper on all of your stuff?
Chris Hutchins
I'm just searching my name on YouTube and then Instagram. Those are my main platforms. I've actually got a video coming out today, but I'm trying to do every couple of weeks now. I'm doing a nice long form that I'm literally just going through court cases on a specific niche topic.
Jasmine Deluci
Yeah. For anyone interested, I propose that you go deep on the credit card stuff and if so, and you do it, by the time this comes out, look in the show notes and I will link to that and you can go get a little bit of a deeper dive there.
Chris Hutchins
It's on my list. Let me see what I can do.
Jasmine Deluci
Awesome. Thank you so much for being here.
Chris Hutchins
Of course. Thank you.
Okay. I hope you enjoyed this episode and that it's super helpful for your taxes in the future. Big thanks to my old co founder and past guest, Chris, Chris Doyle, for turning me on to Jasmine's content. Email is podcastllthehacks.com I will see you next.
Podcast Summary: "Debunking Tax Myths, Avoiding Audits and Maximizing Savings with Jasmine DiLucci"
All the Hacks with Chris Hutchins
Host: Chris Hutchins
Guest: Jasmine DiLucci, Enrolled Agent
Release Date: November 6, 2024
In this episode of All the Hacks with Chris Hutchins, host Chris Hutchins is joined by Jasmine DiLucci, a seasoned tax professional who became an enrolled agent in high school. Together, they delve into common misconceptions about taxes, strategies to avoid audits, and methods to maximize tax savings. The discussion aims to empower listeners with accurate tax knowledge, debunk widespread myths, and provide actionable advice for both individuals and business owners.
Jasmine DiLucci and Chris Hutchins kick off the conversation by addressing the prevalence of inaccurate tax advice circulating on the internet. Chris criticizes the superficial understanding many bloggers and influencers have about tax law, leading them to spread misinformation inadvertently.
A prominent example discussed is the misconception around deducting personal expenses such as clothing and haircuts as business expenses.
Jasmine adds that while certain specific business-related attire might qualify, general personal clothing or grooming expenses typically do not meet the IRS criteria for deductions.
The conversation delves deeper into why certain expenses are deemed personal and non-deductible, despite appearances.
Jasmine shares an example from her experience where unconventional business attire, such as apparel that cannot be used personally (e.g., branded costumes for college campus sales), might qualify for deductions, unlike standard business suits.
Chris and Jasmine discuss the often-feared IRS audit process, aiming to demystify it and provide clarity on what taxpayers can expect.
They explain that most audits focus on verifying specific elements of a tax return, such as Schedule C or E, and that preparation and proper documentation can significantly ease the process.
Chris advises that having strong procedural documentation, especially when dealing with relationships that might raise red flags (e.g., hiring family members), can help mitigate audit risks.
The discussion transitions to strategies for maximizing tax savings, emphasizing the importance of understanding IRS guidelines and regulations.
Credit Card Rewards:
Jasmine addresses misconceptions about the taxability of credit card rewards.
She cites a revenue ruling clarifying that rewards used for purchases reduce the cost basis of those items, while converting rewards directly into cash may result in taxable income.
Hiring Your Kids:
Chris elaborates on the complexities of hiring family members, emphasizing the need for genuine business purpose and thorough documentation.
A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to explaining IRS transcripts and how taxpayers can use them to ensure their returns are accurate and free from errors.
Jasmine highlights the different types of transcripts available, such as account transcripts and wage and income transcripts, and advises on the optimal timing for checking them to catch discrepancies early.
As the year concludes, Jasmine shares a checklist of strategies listeners can employ to optimize their tax positions before the deadline:
Jasmine emphasizes the importance of consulting with a tax professional when implementing these strategies to ensure compliance and effectiveness.
The conversation shifts to the implications of selecting different business structures, particularly S Corporations (S Corps) versus Limited Liability Companies (LLCs).
He explains that forming an LLC doesn’t inherently provide tax benefits unless it aligns with the business’s operational needs. For S Corps, they are beneficial for service-oriented businesses with minimal assets but may become cumbersome for entities with significant assets or liabilities.
Looking ahead, Chris and Jasmine discuss upcoming changes and considerations in tax law that listeners should be aware of, especially in light of potential legislative shifts such as the expiration of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act provisions.
They advise proactive planning for estate taxes and qualified business income deductions, suggesting that those nearing higher asset thresholds consult with their tax advisors to optimize their positions before changes take effect.
Chris Hutchins wraps up the episode by reiterating the importance of understanding tax laws beyond surface-level advice found online. He encourages listeners to take control of their tax situations by verifying information and seeking professional guidance when necessary.
Jasmine and Chris emphasize that informed taxpayers are better equipped to make strategic financial decisions, avoid pitfalls, and maximize their tax benefits.
By addressing these topics with expert insights and practical examples, this episode equips listeners with the knowledge needed to navigate the complexities of tax law, avoid common mistakes, and enhance their financial well-being.