American History Hit: Battle of Fort Donelson – Detailed Summary

Episode Release Date: April 3, 2025
Host: Don Wildman
Guest: Professor Chris Makowski, Copie Hill Fellow at the American Battlefield Trust

1. Introduction to Fort Donelson and the Western Campaign

The episode delves into the strategic significance of Fort Donelson, located in western Tennessee between the Tennessee River and the Cumberland River. Don Wildman sets the stage by highlighting the dire circumstances of the Confederate soldiers encamped at Fort Donelson in February 1862—hunger, cold, and encirclement by Union forces.

Don Wildman [01:03]:
"It's February 1862, at Fort Donelson in western Tennessee. Thousands of Confederate soldiers hunker down, huddling for safety, hungry and shivering in their thin coats."

2. Strategic Importance and Geography

Professor Chris Makowski explains the strategic importance of the Tennessee and Cumberland Rivers as vital "waterway highways" deep into the Confederacy. Control of these rivers would grant the Union access to key Confederate states like Mississippi and Alabama, with Nashville as a primary target due to its manufacturing capabilities and proximity to the Northern frontier.

Chris Makowski [03:27]:
"Nashville is important because it's a huge manufacturing area for the Confederacy. It's very close to the Northern frontier of the Confederacy, too."

3. Leadership and Tactical Strategies

The episode examines the leadership dynamics on both sides. Union Brigadier General Ulysses S. Grant emerges as a pivotal figure, orchestrating the Western Campaign with strategic precision. On the Confederate side, Brigadier General John B. Floyd, a political appointee with limited military experience, commands Fort Donelson, relying heavily on his second-in-command, Gideon Pillow.

Don Wildman [10:35]:
"Talk to me about Brigadier General John B. Floyd. He's appointed the commander of Fort Donelson. He does not believe any kind of retreat is necessary. He digs in here."

Chris Makowski [10:45]:
"Floyd is a political appointee. He's a former Secretary of War under President Buchanan... he's trying to hold out to save his own skin."

4. The Course of the Battle (February 13-16, 1862)

The battle unfolds over several critical days. Initially, Union gunboats bombard Fort Donelson, but Confederate artillery on higher ground effectively repels the naval assault. Grant anticipates a swift victory, expecting to capture the fort within two days. However, logistical challenges and adverse weather conditions impede the Union's progress, forcing Grant to adapt his strategy.

Don Wildman [09:09]:
"It has to do with the elevation, doesn't it? Fort Henry was very low... But over here at Fort Donelson is a much higher elevation."

Chris Makowski [12:19]:
"The gunboats are supposed to be the stars of the show. That engagement... the fort's able to resist."

As the Confederates attempt a breakout on February 15th, poor communication and leadership weaknesses lead to a failed Confederate counterattack. Grant seizes the moment to launch a decisive Union counteroffensive, ultimately leading to the Confederate surrender.

Don Wildman [16:54]:
"This is the tactical advantage of Grant, isn't it? He is able to keep his head cool under these circumstances."

Chris Makowski [21:05]:
"He's got a really good sense of psychological insight... That's why he launches that counterattack."

5. Surrender and Aftermath

The Confederate surrender at Fort Donelson marks a significant Union victory, with approximately 13,000 Confederate soldiers captured. The episode highlights the personal relationship between Grant and Confederate General Simon Bolivar Buckner, illustrating the complexities of war relationships.

Chris Makowski [25:00]:
"Grant sends word that says, I will accept no terms other than unconditional surrender... Buckner is the first Confederate general to surrender during the Civil War."

Post-surrender, the Union implements a parole system for the prisoners of war, a logistical challenge given the number of captives. The episode also touches on the enduring friendship between Grant and Buckner, culminating in Buckner serving as a pallbearer at Grant's funeral.

Don Wildman [26:56]:
"Grant's voice was so shot, much of what he had to say was written down... They had this wonderful sort of last meeting during Grant's dying days."

6. Legacy and Impact on the Civil War

The fall of Fort Donelson had profound implications for the Civil War, effectively opening the Cumberland River to Union advances and setting the stage for future campaigns in the West, including the pivotal Siege of Vicksburg. Professor Makowski emphasizes that this battle was not just a military victory but also a strategic turning point that heightened the urgency of the Western Campaign.

Chris Makowski [28:04]:
"The impact of this battle is more important than perhaps the battle itself. It really does create this new importance and urgency to the Western campaign."

Don Wildman [30:09]:
"The union has won this battle outright. And as we said earlier, it's the beginning of the story of unconditional surrender."

The episode concludes by framing Grant's leadership at Fort Donelson as a precursor to his future successes, showcasing his ability to blend tactical acumen with psychological insight, thereby transforming Union military strategy.

Notable Quotes

• Don Wildman [09:35]:
  "Grant was expecting a pretty easy walk here, wasn't he? He said this would be taken in two days."

• Chris Makowski [13:37]:
  "He decides what to do next. And he's going to do a counterattack of his own."

• Chris Makowski [21:58]:
  "He understands that whoever attacks first is going to win now, and the enemy's gotta be in an awful big hurry if they're gonna beat me."

• Don Wildman [30:09]:
  "Compel me, notwithstanding the brilliant success of the confederate arms yesterday, to accept the ungenerous and unchivalrous terms which you propose."

Conclusion

The Battle of Fort Donelson serves as a crucial episode in the American Civil War, highlighting the interplay of strategy, leadership, and geography. Through engaging discussions with Professor Chris Makowski, Don Wildman unpacks the complexities of this battle and its lasting impact on the course of American history. This victory not only elevated Ulysses S. Grant's military reputation but also set the Union on a path toward ultimate victory by securing key waterways and undermining Confederate infrastructure.

For more in-depth exploration of American history, subscribe to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries and ad-free podcasts.