Loading summary
Transcript125 lines
- [00:00]
Ryan Reynolds
Hey, Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. You know one of the perks about having four kids that you know about is actually getting a direct line to the big man up north. And this year he wants you to know the best gift that you can give someone is the gift of Mint Mobile's Unlimited Wireless for $15 a month. Now you don't even need to wrap it. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment.
- [00:21]
Commercial Announcer
Of $45 for a three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required new customer offer for first three months only. Speed slow after 35 gigabytes if network's busy. Taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com this holiday, Verizon is helping you bundle up incredible gifts and savings. You'll get the latest phone with a new line on MyPlan and a brand new smartwatch and tablet. No trade in needed even on our lowest price plan. That's two gifts for your family and one for you. Or two for you and one for someone else or three gifts for you and only you. Either way, you save big on three amazing gifts at Verizon, all on the best 5G network. Visit Verizon today. Rankings based on Root Metric Truth score report dated 1 2025. Your results may vary. Service plan required for watch and tablet. Additional terms apply. Protect your pet insurance from Pets Best plans start from less than a dollar a day. Visit petsbest.com Pet insurance products offered and administered by Pets Best Insurance Services LLC are underwritten by American Pet Insurance Company or Independence American Insurance Company for terms and conditions, visit www.petsbest.com. policy products are underwritten by American Pet Insurance Company, Independence American Insurance Company or Ms. Transverse Insurance Company and administered by Pets Best Insurance Services LLC. $1 a day premium based on 2024 average new policyholder data for accident and illness plans. Pets age 0 to 10.
- [01:35]
Don Wildman
New Year's Day 1889 in the vast open skies of western Nevada, a solar eclipse begins as if a bite's been taken out of the sun, then gradually more and more until fully consumed by the moon. On the horizon, the golden mountain range simmers, dimming to dusk. All around, bird songs rise to a frantic crescendo, then suddenly go silent in the eerie silver glow of totality, the sun's corona bursting from behind the lunar disk, a Paiute prophet suffers the ill effects of scarlet fever. Seized by delirium and chills, he slips in and out of a deep trance, experiencing visions of a different world, a renewed world where his people's ancestors have returned where the buffalo roams free again and native nations thrive in peace. Moments later, as the day is reborn and the sun brightens, this man Wovoka, returns to the living, his visions becoming revelation, sparking a movement, the Ghost Dance, that will soon spread across the land.
- [02:58]
Greetings, all. Welcome to another episode of American History hit. Glad you're listening. Thanks very much. I'm Don Wildman. Today's subject, in many ways, is a last chapter. Literally so open almost any book on the history of Native tribes in North America. Turn to the final pages, and you'll find in there the story we're covering today, a dark closing moment in the long erosion of what was once a stable and vibrant civilization. It's a chapter that ends with what even at the time was recognized as an unthinkable atrocity. US Troops firing on defenseless families. The era to which I refer is known as the Ghost Dance Movement, and it's often reduced in those books to a cult, an oversimplification of what was so much more a profound spiritual response to the pressures of extinction inflicted by conquering European Americans. Why did it begin? What did its believers hope to achieve? And how did the Ghost Dance era echo onward against all odds, not only in American history, but in the living memory of today's Native cultures? We'll discuss this all with Gregory Smoke, professor of history at the University of Utah, A leading scholar of Native American history and religion, he's the author of Ghost Dances and Identity, the definitive study of prophetic movements in the 19th century. Professor Smoke has worked extensively with tribal nations and led major research projects for the National Park Service, including at Little Bighorn, Pipe Spring, and Zion. He's also a past president of the National Council on Public History. Professor Smoke. Greg, welcome.
- [04:30]
Gregory Smoke
Thanks. Great to be here.
- [04:31]
Don Wildman
The Ghost Dance Movement begins In the late 19th century, as I mentioned, around 1890, the end of a century that has witnessed the conquest and collapse of tribal societies across the continent, but most recently, of course, in the west, specifically with Last Tribes Resisting expansion, the Apache, the Shoshone, Lakota, and others. The management of this conquest after the wars were over was done, as it still is today, by pushing Native peoples onto reservations. Starts with the Indian removal Act of 1830. Can you take us through this process historically?
- [05:03]
Gregory Smoke
I'd be happy to. I would also add, though, you know, right up front, one of the things that I'm going to argue here today is that the Ghost Dance isn't the end, and the Ghost Dance is still practiced today. And from my perspective, the Ghost Dance is as Much a beginning as an ending. And we'll get back to that. But you're absolutely right.
- [05:22]
Don Wildman
I'm glad you said that, because as I was reading that opening that I wrote, it has such a downer feeling. And I want to tell people that's not the note we mean to strike today. Of course, there's that element to this, but that's. Your point, is that there's as much of a cultural kind of rediscovery going on through this movement. Is that fair to say?
- [05:42]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah, I would say that's fair to say, but I would say you're absolutely right when it comes to the popular understanding of the Ghost dance movement of 1890, which is not the first Ghost Dance movement, but it is. That's the popular understanding. And one of the most famous books written about it in the early 1960s was called the Last Days of the Sioux Nation, clearly linking it to Wounded Knee. That would come as a great surprise to Sioux people today who would say. Lakota people would say, hey, we're still here.
- [06:10]
Don Wildman
Yeah, exactly.
- [06:11]
Gregory Smoke
So this Lakota nations, plural, is certainly still living anyway. But, yeah, so removal and confinement on reservations. You know, 1830, the Indian Removal act makes removal of native people east of the Mississippi federal policy, and people are pushed west. The idea is to clear land for white Americans. That idea of a permanent Indian frontier in an Indian territory where they would remain doesn't last very long. And very, very soon, Americans, white Americans, are spreading across the continent. And so removal will take place in the west as well. But it's not going to be a centralized policy. It's not going to be pushing people hundreds or thousands of miles from or a thousand miles or more from where they had lived. It's going to be concentrating them onto smaller pieces of ground, often within their aboriginal territory, but also, in some cases, moving people fairly large distances. And this becomes really the central policy of the federal government in the 1850s and reaches its, you know, its zenith that after the American Civil War, in this period that we think of as, you know, the classical period of the Indian wars, which stretches from, you know, even before the Civil War, but really after the Civil war up to 1886, when Geronimo surrenders at Skeleton Canyon, Arizona, and that sort of ends the armed resistance to this system.
- [07:47]
Don Wildman
Yeah. I mean, there's.
- [07:48]
Gregory Smoke
And people are then confined on reservations.
- [07:51]
Don Wildman
Those policies you talk about are Indian Removal Act, 1830, then the Indian Appropriations Act, 1851, the General Allotment act, which is also known as the Dawes Act, 1887. All of these were created policies. And my curiosity is, how did they grow through the. Through the century in terms of an evolution?
- [08:12]
Gregory Smoke
Well, this is all linked to transforming Native people, making them essentially disappear. And I say that very intently, that going back even into the colonial period. And if we think of British colonialism as a basis for the United States, obviously there are other colonial powers, the French and the Spanish and so on. But British colonialism has the greatest impact on the creation of American federal Indian policy. It is a centralized policy, and it really doesn't have a place for Native people within Euro American society. The Indian Removal act illustrates this. The idea was to move people from these areas. And the argument in humanitarian terms is we're gonna move them out of the way where they'll be free of the vices and the problems of white society, where then they can slowly assimilate. Even before the Removal act, though, there were provisions and treaties to provide farming implements to people, even to the Cherokees, who got most of their diet from farming. The idea is we're gonna civilize them by making them farmers with that policy. I mean, that kind of idea of transforming Native people is a constant. It becomes incredibly intense after the American Civil War when assimilation becomes the policy of the federal government. And controversially, some people argue that it is not a policy of genocide. But arguably it is. If we define genocide as making a group, a group of people disappear as a distinguishable group. Absolutely right. The Dawes act that you mentioned in 1887 is a cornerstone of this policy. The idea of the Dawes act was to take communally owned reservation lands and to break them up into individual private land holdings. The idea here was that this would work a transformation of Native people, that they would become individual, capitalist yeoman farmers. They would assimilate and melt into white society, and tribes would simply go away. This is the same intent of the boarding school system, Right. Started your first major boarding school, 1879. Richard Henry Pratt's Carlisle boarding School. That school and others like it were intended to take Native youth and transform them culturally. I mean, very famously, people have heard of the English only rule that is imposed that students are punished for speaking Native languages. The physical transformation of students, they're cutting their hair, right? And young Native men wearing military uniforms, young Native women wearing Victorian dresses. All of this was meant to transform Native people and make them disappear as tribes and as a group in American society. And this culture war is a larger context for the Ghost Dances?
- [11:19]
Don Wildman
Sure. Was it controversial at the time? I often wonder. We think of this as just a Sort of a singular era of Manifest Destiny, all that stuff. And the treatment of Native tribes was that controversial? For many people back east, it was.
- [11:33]
Gregory Smoke
And first, I'll say that the program I just mentioned, allotment, boarding schools, the transformation of Native sovereignty. These three prongs, right? They are pushed by people who see themselves as humanitarian. They see this as the only path forward. There is this idea of the vanishing American, that Native people are simply going to disappear. This is, in part impelled by their view of atrocities against Native people. The Sand Creek Massacre causes a major investigation. There are court cases. There are removals of people like the Ponca that arouse a reform spirit. So these people have cultural blinders on. They call themselves, however, the Friends of the Indian.
- [12:22]
Don Wildman
Yeah, right.
- [12:22]
Gregory Smoke
And they see this as the only path forward. There are others who do not, others who believe the military should still be in charge. And as a matter of fact, the Indian Bureau was originally situated in the Department of War when it was founded. Then it was transferred to the Interior Department in the late 1860s. With the Indian wars going on, there's an argument that Indian affairs should be returned to the War Department. But then there is a tragic and well publicized massacre of Blackfeet people in northern Montana on the Marias river that really derails that plan. And Indian affairs remains civilian at that point. But I think, you know, this culture war is something that they see as necessary, humane, and the best thing for Native peoples to turn them into indistinguishable American citizens.
- [13:14]
Don Wildman
So this lands US in 1890, as I mentioned. What is the. Let's look at the other side of this issue from the Native American side. What is the vision behind the Ghost Dance movement? Where does it come from and who thinks of it?
- [13:27]
Gregory Smoke
First of all, the ghost dance of 1890 is not the first Ghost Dance. And certainly it's not the first prophetic movement or millennial movement among Native peoples. Documented movements like this go all the way back into the 18th century, even before Pontiac's War. And the Delaware prophet, Nyoland. There's a Shawnee prophet, Tenskwatawa, in the early 19th century, associated with his brother Tecumseh. Right. So there's lots of these movements. But in terms of Ghost Dances, there's one in 1870. There's one that begins around 1869. 1870. And then this is a forerunner of the 1890 movement. Both of these begin in western Nevada among Paiute people.
- [14:10]
Don Wildman
Okay, what does it mean? What does Ghost Dance mean?
- [14:13]
Gregory Smoke
Well, first of all, no Native people called it The Ghost Dance. The names were. There you go, two tribes, some people said, translated as spirit dance. Among some Shoshones it was called everybody dragging. And that was a reference to the slow counterclockwise shuffle of a round dance, the ceremonial base of that. So Ghost Dance is not something any native person called it and it actually is not that often used by white Americans at the time. The people who are shocked by it and responding to it call it the Messiah craze. You see that in newspapers. It's the anthropologist James Mooney who, you know, calls it the Ghost Dance religion in his initial study in 1896. And you know, since that time it's largely known as the Ghost Dance. It is, you hear that phrase here and there back then, but it's not often used at that point. But I mean the gist of this is in 1870 and in 1890, if these ceremonies are followed, you have the ability to reunite with your lost loved ones on a renewed earth. And that's essentially the end goal here.
- [15:27]
Don Wildman
So it's a vision of resurrection.
- [15:29]
Gregory Smoke
Basically it is a vision of resurrection. It's also the one of.
- [15:35]
It's kind of. It's always off putting to use the terms that social scientists might use. But you can think of the movements as transformative or redemptive. The 1870 Ghost Dance was more transformative. The message was more of an immediate transformation of conditions and a radical change like just reshaping the Earth by 1890. Wovoka. The 1890 Ghost Dance prophets message, social scientists might say is more redemptive. It incorporates more elements of Christianity, but it also is a more forward looking religion in the sense that it gives people the wherewithal to survive in a colonized world. And I mean that's worth talking about too is what are conditions like on reservations, you know, for native people.
- [16:29]
Don Wildman
I'll be back with more American history after this short break.
- [16:36]
Commercial Announcer
This holiday, Verizon is helping you bundle up incredible gifts and savings. You'll get the latest phone with a new line on MyPlan and a brand new smart smartwatch and tablet. No trade in needed even on our lowest price plan. That's two gifts for your family and one for you or two for you and one for someone else or three gifts for you and only you. Either way, you save big on three amazing gifts at Verizon, all on the best 5G network. Visit Verizon today. Rankings based on rootmetric truth score report dated 1 2025. Your results may vary. Service plan required for watch and tablet. Additional terms apply.
- [17:06]
Ryan Reynolds
Hey Ryan Reynolds here wishing you a very happy half off holiday because right now Mint Mobile is offering you the gift of 50% off unlimited. To be clear, that' half price, not half the service. Mint is still premium unlimited wireless for a great price. So that means a half day.
- [17:25]
Don Wildman
Yeah.
- [17:26]
Ryan Reynolds
Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment.
- [17:29]
Commercial Announcer
Of 45 for 3 month plan equivalent to 15 per month required new customer offer for first 3 months only. Speed slow after 35 gigabytes of network's busy taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com with stays under 250 a night Vervoe makes it easy to celebrate sweater weather. Book a cabin with leaf views or a home with a fire pit for nights with friends. With stays under $250 a night. Find a home for your exact needs. Book now@vrbo.com with stays under $250 a night. VRBO makes it easy to celebrate sweater weather. You could book a cabin stay with leaf views for days or a brownstone in a city where festivals are just a walk away. Or a lakeside home with a fire pit for cozy nights with friends. Or if you're not a sweater person, we can call it corduroy weather. More flexible and with stays under $250 a night, you can book a home that suits your exact needs. Book now@vrbo.com.
- [18:28]
Don Wildman
We're talking about a movement that's spread throughout the culture, right? Throughout different tribes and across great regions. And how do they view the white man in this?
- [18:37]
Gregory Smoke
Well, I.
- [18:38]
Don Wildman
There's no place for it, of course.
- [18:40]
Gregory Smoke
Well, that is not necessarily true. So again, if we look at the 1890 Ghost Dance, which is the more redemptive supposedly of the two, if we use those phrases, the only written doctrine of the Ghost Dance that we have recorded by a native person is a so called Messiah letter. And this was given to James Mooney, that anthropologist I just mentioned. It was written down by a young Arapaho man named Caspar Edson. And Edson had attended Carlisle. He wrote this down as the prophet spoke in a very broken English that was rewritten by a young Cheyenne woman when he returned to his home in Oklahoma. And then that letter was given to Mooney. And Mooney provided a free he in his in his work, he publishes all three of these, but he provides a free rendering of this letter. And white people do not really have a place, but it is not a violent necessarily removal of white people. He preaches. And this is directly what he says. Grandfather says when your friends die, you must not cry. You must not hurt anybody or do harm to anyone. You must not fight. Do always right. It will give you satisfaction in life. Do not tell the white people about this. Jesus is now upon the earth. He appears like a cloud. The dead are all alive again. I do not know when they will be here. Maybe this fall or in the spring. When the time comes, there will be no more sickness and everyone will be young again. Do not refuse to work for the whites and do not make any trouble with them until you leave them. So that's another ominous note there. When the earth shakes, do not be afraid. It will not hurt you.
- [20:37]
Don Wildman
What year was that again?
- [20:39]
Gregory Smoke
That is recorded in 1889. Well, Volcke had his. It was given to James Mooney in the early 1890s. Wovoka's vision was probably around the 1st of January, 1889. It spread very rapidly and ironically as it's branded as this kind of primitive, backward looking movement. The irony is it spread through the English language. Native people who had learned to read and write English and technology. The trains people, you took the trains to see the prophet. They went, took trains there. So this word can spread very rapidly in this modern world. It is people. Native people, as they always have done, are adapting to the world in which they live.
- [21:23]
Don Wildman
You've mentioned Wovoka, that's his native name, also goes by Jack Wilson, I suppose.
- [21:28]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah.
- [21:29]
Don Wildman
And that speaks to the cultural mixing that's happening at this point. Enforced or not, it is a reality for different reasons. So we're talking about a redemptive ritual. Is ritual the right word for it?
- [21:42]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah, I mean, it is a religious ceremony that is meant to bring about a particular end. So I guess, you know, you could call that. I mean, the ceremony itself was based on a traditional round dance, which is people counterclockwise, slowly shuffling. There's no drum, people are singing. Round dances can be social, but they can also be ceremonial. In this case, obviously, it's a ceremonial dance. One thing I want to add about Wovoka, though. Wovoka means the cutter or wood cutter. And Jack Wilson is the name that he got when he lived among the Wilson family. And this is very indicative of life among Native people, especially in the Great Basin at that time. Many survived by wage labor. Well, Voca is the first generation to really grow up in a colonized world. People survive through often wage labor. Woodcutting is one of those occupations. But also, you know, people who were alive at the time, white and Indian, often simply call them Jack Wilson, the Redemption.
- [22:42]
Don Wildman
They're looking for is a return to kind of, I suppose, the pre contact age. Right. That's the. To go back to that time.
- [22:49]
Gregory Smoke
That might be the way that they understood it, but it's really difficult to say how an individual Native person understood that. But certainly that is the promise.
- [22:58]
Don Wildman
Okay. And they will be assisted in this through the ancestors coming back and making themselves present in life. Right.
- [23:05]
Gregory Smoke
And I think one way to think about it, though, is that this is not when people hear Ghost Dance, they think about raising the dead, and it's as if it's some horror movie. Think of it more in terms of a millennium. Millennium. Right. The return of a golden age. But being reunited with your lost loved ones in their full prime in a world in which you can live with your own traditions, your own religion, and be prosperous and happy. That's the message.
- [23:37]
Don Wildman
And it's a pacifist message as well. It's not about war. It's not making war. Right.
- [23:43]
Gregory Smoke
Well, sir, I mean, the way that Wovoka described it here, it's certainly a pacifist message. Do always. Right? Right. Do not hurt anyone. In the literature, the scholarly literature on the Ghost Dance, there was this idea that came about that the Lakota people misinterpreted or perverted the Ghost Dance into a violent message. And this is a factor leading to wounded niece. More recently, scholars have really pushed back against that. But in that early book, in the early 1960s, this last days of Sioux Nation, that's certainly the idea that this is a peaceful message, that the Lakotas, because of their culture and because of the conditions they were suffering, turned this into a militant, anti white religion. And that is not true. And, you know, the bit of evidence that's used there has been really debated whether or not this was an accurate account. It appeared only one newspaper never reported truly through military channels. So it's.
- [24:47]
Don Wildman
It's.
- [24:47]
Gregory Smoke
There's debate there. But overall, this is a message of saying, this is the way that you can survive in the world you face today.
- [24:57]
Don Wildman
Yeah. I want to be clear on what distinguishes this from traditional dances, which, of course, we've all seen and have some understanding of. This is a unique ceremony. In what regards? Is it what they wear or how they dance, or what's the difference?
- [25:13]
Gregory Smoke
Well, again, the dance is fairly typical of a round dance. People shuffle sideways, counterclockwise, hold hands. They sing. The difference here is this dance could last, you know, two to four days. That's not unusual for some dances like the Sun. Later, the Sun Dance becomes a center of a Pan Indian religion. As people dance, as they become exhausted, some people fall and they essentially pass out. And during that time, they have visions. And when they come back, when they regain consciousness, they speak with people, with shamans, with others, and they start to sing the songs that were revealed to them in this dance. So this is a very much a religion that is adaptive at that moment. The songs that people are singing are changing, and it differs from tribe to tribe. But that's kind of the core ceremonial there. And the idea is that if this is carried out, that you will hasten or bring on this transformation.
- [26:22]
Don Wildman
In my notes, I have ghost shirts which are worn. I'm sure they weren't called that, but the actual performance looks different. Right. By virtue of that.
- [26:29]
Gregory Smoke
That is very specific, again, to certain groups like the Lakota. And a lot is made of the ghost shirts. And that theory I said that the Lakotas perverted or changed the ghost dance to make it militant often hinges on that factor. Right. And so the ghost shirts were meant to make people invulnerable. And they're often called bulletproof shirts. Right. And this was the way that this was interpreted at the time was that this is whipping them up into a frenzy, that they believe that they're bulletproof. Not all people had that kind of tradition. The idea of a piece of clothing bringing invulnerability was new to the Lakota.
- [27:10]
Don Wildman
Was it like a hair shirt or something like that? I mean, what was.
- [27:13]
Gregory Smoke
They take different forms. There are pictures of them online at the Smithsonian and other museums. There are some. Some have tufts of hair on them. Most are painted in various ways with symbols that have been revealed to people. So, yeah, there's a number of examples online that people can see if they search that North Dakota Historical Society, the Smithsonian institutions, so on.
- [27:37]
Don Wildman
Right. And through this ritual, which, as you say, could last for days and involve, in one case in Nevada, what became Nevada, a thousand Shoshones dancing all night. I mean, these are massive gatherings. In some cases, they could be. Yeah. Shouting in unison. And the Christian and Native religions sort of mixing up. You know, Christ has come. They hear they're collapsing, they're weeping. There are elements of Pentecostal, you know, behavior in this. Not intentionally, but I'm saying you could sort of reference that by fall of 1890, I have down that at least 30 nations had adopted some version of this particular ghost dance. It's a. It's nationwide, I guess, is the word to say. The Lakota were particularly enthusiastic. Their. Their leader, Sitting Bull. They graft some symbols of their primary religion onto this stance. I mean, it's a very plastic thing, isn't it? It can be flexible.
- [28:29]
Gregory Smoke
I think that Native religions in general are adapted. They're not dogmatic. They're very important traditions in all Native religions. But if we look at this in the perspective of Western Christian, Judeo, Christian religion, with written books and dogmas and ceremonies and fundamentalism, it's hard to understand. But incorporating spiritual power from many different sources was not something unusual in Native beliefs. And so you find that adaption. Right. And so the Lakota adopt this dance and they make it their own. So do the Cheyennes, so do the Arapahos, so do the Shoshones and Bannocks, the people at Fort Hall, Idaho, major conduits of this religion. And so the important thing here is that it is a pan Indian religion. It is not for a single tribe.
- [29:23]
Don Wildman
Right.
- [29:24]
Gregory Smoke
It crosses those tribal boundaries, it unites people, but it doesn't dictate or mandate that there's a single way to pursue this religion. People interpret it on their own. And in fact, that's the way religious culture and religious distinctions evolve anyway in any civilization.
- [29:42]
Don Wildman
Yeah, exactly.
- [29:43]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah.
- [29:45]
Don Wildman
I'll be back with more American history after this short break.
- [29:53]
Commercial Announcer
This holiday, Verizon is helping you bundle up incredible gifts and savings. You'll get the latest phone with a new line on MyPlan and a brand new smartwatch and tablet. No trade in needed even on our lowest price plan. That's two gifts for your family and one for you or two for you and one for someone else or three gifts for you and only you. Either way, you save big on three amazing gifts at Verizon, all on the best 5G network. Visit Verizon today. Rankings based on root metric Truth score report dated 1 each 2025. Your results may vary. Service plan required for watch and tablet. Additional terms apply.
- [30:23]
Ryan Reynolds
Hey, Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. You know, one of the perks about having four kids that you know about is actually getting a direct line to the big man up north. And this year he wants you to know the best gift that you can give someone is the gift of Mint Mobile's unlimited wireless for $15 a month. Now you don't even need to wrap it. Can give it a try@mintmobile.com switch.
- [30:43]
Commercial Announcer
Upfront payment of $45 for three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required. New customer offer for first three months only. Speed slow after 35 GB if network's busy. Taxes and fees extra. See mintmobile.com.
- [31:00]
Don Wildman
So so much of this is a Matter of perspective in those days and even now. What was the response in the country to the word that this was happening? Did it receive wide publicity?
- [31:11]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah. Oh, yeah. It was reported widely in the news and in New York Times and all of the newspapers. It was debated in Congress. The United States responds with a major military expedition against Thalakotas to put down the unrest that is perceived there.
- [31:31]
Because.
- [31:32]
Don Wildman
They had experienced this as a prior. I mean, were these sort of previews of military militant action or what?
- [31:41]
Gregory Smoke
No, I. You know, that's. That is really debatable. Scholars have argued that, you know, this is the way in which the United States imposed colonialism. Right. That this was a resistance to the system that was being put in place on reservations to control native people. The United States responds with overwhelming force. In the past, in situations, the United States may not have done this, but again, this is 1890. You got Nelson A. Miles, who is the commanding general of the United States army, who wants to really make this a show of force. So you have.
- [32:19]
Half of the United States army descending on the Dakotas to put down the unrest on the reservations. You have Indian agents who are freaking out the agent at Pine Ridge who's writing these inflammatory letters. You have sort of a boogeyman perception of Sitting Bull, who isn't even really involved in this religion.
- [32:39]
Don Wildman
He's already been out with the Wild West Show. He's now back from that. Right? He's.
- [32:43]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah, but he's a very influential leader. He's Ankpapa Lakota, so he's at Standing Rock.
- [32:48]
Don Wildman
Right.
- [32:49]
Gregory Smoke
But people look to him, even though he may not be leader within their band.
- [32:54]
Don Wildman
I just am curious, why was it so inflammatory to when it seems so clear that it was about a pacifism and a. And a reach back as religiously oriented. How would it have been such a trigger for American troops?
- [33:08]
Gregory Smoke
That is not the way that the popular mind understood it. That's not the way the military understood it. That's not the way it was reported in the press. Okay, the inflammatory stuff in the press, just to give you an example. And October 31, 1890, in the Chicago papers, supposedly these were the words that came from Shortbull, one of the two Lakota apostles. Short Bull and Kicking Bear were the first Jew to go out and visit the Prophet. And the newspaper reported this. That Shortbull, it said, my father has shown me these things. Therefore you must continue this dance. If the soldiers surround you, four deep, three of you on whom I have put the holy shirts, will sing a song which I'VE taught you. And then some of them will drop dead. The rest will start to run, but their horses will sink into the earth. Right. And so scholars like Jeff Osler, you know, they have said, you know, this is suspect that this was not reported through military channels, even though it supposedly comes from the military. There's no evidence of it in those records. It might be the fanciful reporting that happening at the time. But this is the kind of thing that people are reading and they think this is a major uprising. Sitting Bull is a household name. Right, right. Sitting Bull, Crazy. Other Lakota leaders, Geronimo. These are the names of Native people that white Americans know. And they are all military leaders, people who led a military resistance. And so the assumption is that's what this is. They don't hear the Messiah letter.
- [34:39]
Don Wildman
Right.
- [34:40]
Gregory Smoke
They're not in a Native community. They're not listening to Native people. They're reading these papers, these kinds of reports.
- [34:44]
Don Wildman
You know, so much of the. The west at that time was energized by the Mormon movement, too. I mean, that entire Messiah craze of the Mormons out there in the west, it was a hotbed of lots going on. But most of all, this was seen as a. The desire was to preempt an unrest and an uprising by confronting this head on. Right.
- [35:06]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah. There's a belief that this is going to turn into something more, but there is also a desire to continue the colonial policies, to control the west and to incorporate the West. It's funny that you mentioned the Mormons, something I've written about in my work on the Ghost Dance, but they are looked at in sometimes the same ways as Native Ghost Dancers. And they're blamed for the Ghost Dance directly by Nelson Miles, who. Because he can't believe, and many white Americans can't believe that a Native person could be behind this religion or have created this religion, or Native people could have spread this religion. He says there has to be some designing white men behind it, and it must be the Mormons because they are un American and they're against the government.
- [35:51]
Don Wildman
A few years before this, 1882, US Secretary of the Interior Henry Teller issued new orders to suppress. He calls them hedonist dances such as the Sundance, the Scalp Dance, and so forth, in order to bring Indians, as he says, into line with conventional Christian practice.
- [36:09]
Gregory Smoke
Right.
- [36:10]
Don Wildman
That hits the nail on the head, I would say, in terms of the motivations here. Right.
- [36:14]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah. I think, you know, what are the conditions in 1890? Native people face that culture war is part of it. And the fact that you have your native religions being suppressed, there's pressure to become Christian. And you put on top of this, you know, specifics on. On most reservations where there's little income source, Tuberculosis is killing people.
- [36:35]
Don Wildman
Yeah.
- [36:35]
Gregory Smoke
By the scores. And it becomes the real horrible disease that peaks in the nineteen teens and twenties in Native Americans.
- [36:43]
Don Wildman
We didn't even mention that the land that they were put onto was not great for farming. Which was supposed to be the idea for so many of you.
- [36:50]
Gregory Smoke
Exactly. That's the idea of that. So, for instance, at Fort Hall Land Sessions, the railroad comes in in the 1880s, and then the Pocatello land session, and there's no development of irrigation. There's no development of irrigation in a place like Fort hall till after most of the reservation is ceded and white farmers are agitating for that irrigation development. So you can't even become the thing that they're trying to turn you into.
- [37:14]
Don Wildman
Yeah. November 13, 1890. President Harrison orders a third of the U.S. army to prevent any outbreak. That's a lot, right? I mean, the US army is not as big as we know it today, but it's a lot of people that they've been. A lot of troops they're sending out there. And the press gets involved. As it begins to do more and more over this time period about bloodthirsty Native Americans. There were about 4,200 Ghost Dancers at peak, I suppose, in the Lakota area. Right. Is that the idea?
- [37:43]
Gregory Smoke
Maybe that's accurate. I'm not really certain of that estimate, but that would be about right considering Lakota populations.
- [37:49]
Don Wildman
Yeah.
- [37:49]
Gregory Smoke
I'm citing the majority of Lakotas were Ghost Dancers.
- [37:51]
Don Wildman
I'm citing an article in the New York Times which actually estimated to be 15,000. I'm just making the point that the, you know, things were out of proportion in the press for sure.
- [38:00]
Gregory Smoke
Definitely.
- [38:01]
Don Wildman
Which leads us to this incident. We have to address what happened in Wounded Knee.
- [38:07]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah.
- [38:07]
Don Wildman
How is Wounded Knee located in this story? And is it a climax or how does this fit into what we are talking about?
- [38:15]
Gregory Smoke
Well, I think Wounded Knee is the central event that shapes public perception of the Ghost Dance for a long time. Right. So the way Wounded Knee came about was that as the army descended on the Lakota reservations, a number of events transpired that set up this situation. Sitting Bull was assassinated in the middle of December 1890. The Indian agent, James McLaughlin, at Standing Rock, wanted to remove Sitting Bull. He sent Indian police out to arrest him under the premise that Sitting Bull was participating in the Ghost Dance. He really wasn't. And it turns into a shootout. Sitting Bull and his son are killed. This is a shocking news, right? This shocks people. That news reaches to the next reservation to the south, Cheyenne River. And the leader, Bigfoot, who they're. His people, are practicing the Ghost Dance. And they flee the reservation. They flee south, right? So all of western South Dakota at one point was the great Sioux reservation. Now it's broken up into individual reservations. They flee south towards Pine Ridge. And they're going to Pine Ridge because the most influential Lakota leader with the United States government, Red Cloud, is there. And so they're going there. They don't make it to the Pine Ridge Agency because they're intercepted by The United States 7th Cavalry, Custer's old unit. And at Wounded Knee Creek. And the morning after they're intercepted, the 7th Cavalry moves to disarm the camp.
- [39:53]
Don Wildman
How large is this camp?
- [39:55]
Gregory Smoke
Fairly large. It's between four or 500, you know, 200 or more people are going to die. So it's extensive casualties that come out of this.
- [40:03]
Don Wildman
And this is not a warrior movement. These are families.
- [40:06]
Gregory Smoke
This is village. This is village. These men, women, and children and elderly.
- [40:11]
Don Wildman
I just want to paint the pictures. So they have encamped at this place, Wounded Knee Creek. There are shelters built, and they're going to be there for a bit of time. And in comes the 7th Cavalry, and they basically surround them, right? I mean, there are literally.
- [40:25]
Gregory Smoke
Well, they weren't going to be there for a time. They were moving through, trying to get to Pine Ridge. So they're stopped by the cavalry. They go into camp there. The next morning, the cavalry moves to disarm them. And the stories from Lakota people is that, you know, one young man who was hard of hearing refused to give up his rifle. And remember, rifles are critical for survival, for hunting, for life, and they're very expensive. And in this struggle, you know, the stat story at least, the gun goes off. And then the 7th Cavalry opens fire. The 7th Cavalry is around them on three sides and fires directly into the village. Some of the casualties among the soldiers are actually many of their friendly fire because the shooting from across that square. They also employ a light cannon called a Hotchkiss gun, and then fire on the people who are fleeing. And that's where you get those horrific pictures. That night. Blizzard comes in, and, you know, when people go out to bury the dead, you have these horribly contorted, frozen bodies, and the picture's there, and then the picture of filling the mass grave of people. And really the effect of Wounded Knee is to Turn the Ghost Dance movement into this desperate last gasp of a dying culture. That's the popular perception. But all of these other things are not being reported or being seen. And the survival of the ghost ants after Wounded Knee is not widely understood or reported.
- [41:53]
Don Wildman
Exactly. I just want to cap that by saying, I mean, of my generation, I'm born in 61. So much is defined by that book, Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee. I just remember that being such a huge impact.
- [42:05]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah, that's Dee Brown. I was referring to Utley's Last Days of Sud Nation earlier. But Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee, that is the coda. That is the dramatic end. You get that scene of them bringing the wounded into that chapel at Wounded Knee with the banner saying, goodwill to all men. And, you know, that's how Dee Brown, you know, twist, you know, that's the dramatic end point of that book. And it shocks a lot of people. And I read that when I was in middle school. Yeah, it's one of the books that really.
- [42:34]
Don Wildman
The same age exactly got me interested.
- [42:36]
Gregory Smoke
In doing this kind of history.
- [42:38]
Don Wildman
Huge cultural impact. Also went along with the Alcatraz occupation and all the rest of that that was happening at that point. There was suddenly a groundswell of understanding of what had happened. But as you say, the Ghost Dance, which had been so much of the phenomenon at this time, was lost in this, and the more positive story of it was lost. So let's talk about that. I mean, Wounded Knee happens, and we're moving past this. How does the Ghost Dance move on into even into modern culture today?
- [43:06]
Gregory Smoke
Well, the Ghost Dance survives to today. It is practiced on some reservations, not all, but. So, for instance, people at Fort Hall, Idaho, where I've spent much of my career working for the tribes at various times, the Ghost Dance is still practiced there in a fairly traditional form. And Ghost Dancers are a proud group of people up there who continue this religion. But the religion itself, though, is transformed in some areas. It becomes other things. Among the Pawnee people in Oklahoma, there is a hand game, a game that is invented out of that. Among Nakot or Canadian Sioux people, the new tidings religion is a version of it. And it certainly is a forerunner of other redemptive Pan Indian religions in the 20th century, most notably the Sun Dance. Right. So it survives. And the fact that James Mooney, you know, when he's studying this, he goes out and. And he gets permission to study the Ghost Dance and goes out in 1892, and he publishes book in 1896. What he says in that book is that the Ghost Dance is still being practiced and it's taking on new forms at every performance.
- [44:19]
Don Wildman
Interesting.
- [44:20]
Gregory Smoke
And a lot of people don't see that at the time. They don't read that part of it. They don't. Doesn't register with them. And so this idea that Wounded Knee marks the death of the Ghost Dance and that after that it proves that the prophecy was not right, it's not true at all. Some people continue to practice it, and then it takes these other forms into the 20th century. And then it's resurrected at various times. Like at Wounded Knee, in the occupation of wounded knee in 1973. In various forms.
- [44:56]
Don Wildman
Yeah. Well, it speaks to the resilience of that whole civilization and those cultures which have been remarkably strengthened over the last century. For sure. Quite the opposite of what was expected to happen back in the 19th century, which was, as you call it, assimilation. That's true of so many different societies. That's how it used to be seen. And that had so much to do with Christianity and how to help these people through changing them. Now it's seen differently. There's a patchwork of conversation about that whole subject because reservations are troubled places in so many places. But in others, it's a different story. It's a fascinating and pluralistic world we're talking about here. And that's now the fair way to discuss it.
- [45:37]
Gregory Smoke
Yeah, it is. And any approach to Native history has to incorporate diversity and the fact that there never was a typical Native person. There are people from hundreds of tribes, hundreds of religions and traditions. The Ghost Dance is a modern religion and forward looking in the sense that it speaks to all Native people, to the shared American Indian identity. It is not simply a tribal religion, but it's also redemptive and interpreted to teach people how to survive and, you know, prosper and survive in this new world that they faced. Yeah.
- [46:13]
Don Wildman
Gregory Smoke is a professor of history at the University of Utah who has in the past also taught at Colorado State and Minnesota. He's the author of Ghost Dances and Prophetic Religion, An American Indian ethnogenesis in the 19th century. He has worked with Native nations, authoring research projects for Park Service, as well as numbers of indigenous nations and as I mentioned, past president of the National Council of Public History. Thank you, Greg. Nice to meet you.
- [46:39]
Gregory Smoke
All right. Pleasure being here.
- [46:42]
Don Wildman
Hey, thanks for listening to American History hit. You know, every week we release new episodes, two new episodes dropping Mondays and Thursdays. All kinds of content from mysterious missing colonies to powerful political movements to some of the biggest battles across the centuries. Don't miss an episode by hitting like and follow. You help us out, which is great, but you'll also be reminded when our shows are on. And while you're at it, share it with a friend. American History Hit with me. Don Wildman so grateful for your support.
- [47:17]
Commercial Announcer
This holiday, Verizon is helping you bundle up incredible gifts and savings. You'll get the latest phone with a new line on my plan and a brand new smartwatch and tablet. No trade in needed even on our lowest price plan. That's two gifts for your family and one for you. Or two for you and one for someone else. Or three gifts for you and only you. Either way, you save big on three amazing gifts at Verizon, all on the best 5G network. Visit Verizon today. Rankings based on RootMetric Truth Score Report dated 1 2025. Your results may vary. Service plan required for watch and tablet.
- [47:46]
Don Wildman
Additional terms apply Drafty Windows Sky High Energy Bills Tired of the hassle of constant repairs this holiday season? Renewal by Andersen helps you slay the savings.
- [47:58]
Gregory Smoke
Buy one window or door and get.
- [48:00]
Don Wildman
One 40% off, plus take $200 off.
- [48:02]
Gregory Smoke
Your entire purchase with a minimum of four.
- [48:04]
Don Wildman
And with special financing available, replacing those old, inefficient windows has never been easier. Don't let drafty, worn out windows crash your holiday cheer. Visit renewalbyanderson.com today to schedule your free consultation.