American History Tellers: ENCORE - The Fight for Women's Suffrage | Created Equal | 1

Release Date: March 5, 2025

Introduction

In this compelling episode of American History Tellers, hosted by Lindsay Graham from Wondery, listeners are transported to the mid-19th century to explore the arduous journey of the women's suffrage movement in America. Titled "ENCORE: The Fight for Women's Suffrage | Created Equal | 1," the episode delves into the pivotal events, influential figures, and internal conflicts that shaped the struggle for women's voting rights. Through vivid storytelling and dramatic reenactments, the episode brings to life the triumphs and tribulations of early suffragists, highlighting their enduring impact on American society.

Early Life of Elizabeth Cady Stanton

The episode opens by introducing Elizabeth Cady Stanton, a central figure in the women's suffrage movement. Born in 1815 in Johnstown, New York, Stanton faced significant personal tragedies, including the loss of five siblings and her last surviving brother at a young age. These losses deeply affected her father, who expressed a preference for a son over his daughters—a sentiment that fueled Stanton's determination to challenge societal norms.

Stanton's education was unconventional for women of her time. She attended an all-female boarding school where she excelled in subjects like Greek, Latin, and mathematics. Her intellectual prowess extended to law, as she gained experience by spending time in her father's office. This foundation set the stage for her future activism.

The Seneca Falls Convention

A turning point in Stanton's life—and in the suffrage movement—occurred in July 1848 during the Seneca Falls Convention in Seneca Falls, New York. Organized alongside Lucretia Mott, the convention aimed to address the injustices faced by women. At a pivotal moment, Stanton introduces a bold resolution advocating for women's right to vote.

Notable Quote:

"That it is the duty of the women of this country to secure to themselves their sacred right to the elective franchise."
[16:13] Abigail

Despite resistance from some attendees and even her own husband, Henry Stanton, the resolution sparked significant controversy. Frederick Douglass, an influential African American abolitionist, played a crucial role in garnering support for the suffrage resolution, ultimately leading to the passage of all twelve resolutions proposed at the convention. However, only a fraction of attendees signed the Declaration of Sentiments, highlighting the nascent stage of the movement.

The Split in the Suffrage Movement

As the movement gained momentum, internal divisions began to surface, particularly concerning the intersection of women's rights and African American rights. Initially, the suffrage movement was closely tied to the abolitionist cause, but post-Civil War dynamics strained this alliance.

Notable Quote:

"How can we achieve true equality until we have a voice?"
[16:46] Abigail

The schism became pronounced during the American Equal Rights Association (AERA) era, where differing priorities between activists led to a split. Stanton and Susan B. Anthony advocated for universal suffrage, encompassing both women and African Americans, while others like Lucy Stone prioritized black suffrage first. This ideological rift not only fragmented the movement but also set back the cause of women's voting rights for decades.

The Role of Susan B. Anthony

Susan B. Anthony emerges as a pivotal ally to Stanton, bringing strategic prowess and unwavering commitment to the suffrage cause. Born into a Quaker family in 1820, Anthony's activism was shaped by her involvement in the abolitionist and temperance movements. Her partnership with Stanton proved instrumental in advancing women's rights beyond initial setbacks.

Anthony's efforts included organizing petition campaigns and pioneering direct action, such as her own illegal vote in 1872, which underscored the urgent need for voting rights. Her collaboration with Stanton highlighted the complementary strengths of intellectual leadership and grassroots organizing within the movement.

Challenges and Setbacks

The suffrage movement faced numerous obstacles, including societal opposition, limited financial resources, and strategic disagreements. The Kansas referendum of 1867 exemplified these challenges, where conflicting support for black and women's suffrage led to the passage of neither amendment. George Francis Train, a controversial figure, momentarily revitalized the campaign with his support, but his racist rhetoric further deepened divisions within the movement.

Notable Quote:

"I can't believe she's trying to stand in the way of the 15th amendment."
[40:21] Abigail

The fallout from the Kansas campaign resulted in the dissolution of the AERA and the formation of separate organizations: the American Woman Suffrage Association led by Lucy Stone, and the National Woman Suffrage Association spearheaded by Stanton and Anthony. This division hindered unified efforts towards achieving voting rights.

The Rise of Racism in the Movement

A significant and troubling aspect of the suffrage movement's history is the emergence of racist ideologies among its leaders. As the movement grappled with whether to prioritize universal suffrage or focus on black men's voting rights, figures like Stanton and Anthony expressed derogatory views towards African Americans, undermining the inclusivity of their cause.

Notable Quote:

"Think of Sambo, who does not know the difference between a monarchy and a republic?"
[34:33] Elizabeth Cady Stanton

These racist sentiments not only alienated African American activists like Frances Ellen Watkins Harper but also exposed deep-seated prejudices that threatened the moral integrity of the suffrage movement. Harper's powerful confrontation at the AERA meeting in 1869 underscored the necessity of addressing both gender and racial injustices to achieve true equality.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The episode concludes by reflecting on the enduring legacy of Stanton, Anthony, and their contemporaries. Despite the setbacks and internal conflicts, their relentless pursuit of women's suffrage laid the groundwork for future generations. The struggle was far from over, but the foundational efforts of these early activists paved the way for the eventual passage of the 19th Amendment in 1920.

Notable Quote:

"A bold new era for women's suffrage was on the horizon, but one marked not by speeches and petitions, but by radical action."
[34:59] Narrator

The episode sets the stage for subsequent installments, promising to explore the emergence of new leaders and the continued fight for equality in the face of societal resistance.

Key Takeaways

• Elizabeth Cady Stanton's personal experiences and education fueled her passion for women's rights.
• The Seneca Falls Convention was a seminal event that outlined the grievances and aspirations of early suffragists.
• Internal divisions, particularly regarding the prioritization of universal suffrage versus black suffrage, significantly impeded the movement.
• Susan B. Anthony's strategic leadership complemented Stanton's intellectual contributions, driving the movement forward despite challenges.
• The movement's internal racism posed moral and strategic dilemmas, highlighting the intersectionality of social justice struggles.
• The enduring legacy of these early activists underscores the complexity and resilience inherent in the fight for equality.

Upcoming Episode Preview: In the next episode, listeners will witness the rise of a scandalous new leader in the suffrage movement, the first woman presidential candidate, and the dramatic events surrounding Susan B. Anthony's arrest for illegal voting—further illustrating the bold actions that propelled the movement towards victory.

Credits:

• Host/Producer: Lindsey Graham
• Voice Actors: Ace Anderson, Cat Peoples, Cynthia San Luis
• Writing: Ellie Stanton
• Editing: Dorian Marina
• Sound Design: Derek Barnes
• Music: Lindsey Graham
• Executive Producers: Jenny Lauer Beckman, Marsha Louie

For more engaging histories and to support the show, join Wondery+ through the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify.