American History Tellers: "Evolution on Trial | Monkeytown | 2" Summary

Release Date: July 16, 2025
Host: Lindsey Graham (not the Senator)
Network: Wondery

Introduction to the Scopes Trial

In May 1925, Dayton, Tennessee, became the epicenter of a national debate when high school teacher John Scopes was accused of violating the state's law banning the teaching of evolution. This landmark case, often referred to as the Scopes Monkey Trial, pitted religious fundamentalism against emerging scientific thought, capturing the nation's attention.

[00:00] Lindsey Graham: "Imagine it's late May 1925, in Dayton, Tennessee... folks are going to travel miles to see him thunder on about Genesis."

Dayton Transforms into Monkey Town

As the trial loomed, local merchants in Dayton capitalized on the impending publicity. The town embraced the moniker "Monkey Town," a term coined by journalist H.L. Mencken, turning it into a symbol of the trial's central controversy.

• Economic Boost: Stores sold monkey-themed souvenirs, simian sodas, and even renamed the local police as "Monkeyville Police."
• Public Sentiment: While some residents like the store owner saw economic benefits, others like Frank, a local customer, remained skeptical about the monkey-themed merchandise.

[02:30] Store Owner: "I'm already selling those toy monkeys and the trial hasn't even started yet."

Legal Teams Take Shape

The prosecution, led by District Attorney Tom Stewart and bolstered by three Dayton-based attorneys and the renowned William Jennings Bryan, aimed to secure a swift conviction against Scopes. Bryan, a three-time presidential candidate, was determined to uphold the anti-evolution law.

Conversely, the defense assembled a formidable team, including the illustrious Clarence Darrow, a criminal defense attorney known for his impassioned speeches and staunch defense of individual liberties.

[15:45] Clarence Darrow: "Evolution's all in the past. You got to think about the future, is what I say."

Jury Selection and Public Perception

Selecting an impartial jury proved challenging in Dayton, a predominantly religious and rural community. Darrow faced an uphill battle in assembling a jury willing to deliberate without bias against evolution.

• Jury Bias: Many potential jurors openly opposed evolution, reflecting the town's conservative values.
• Challenge: Darrow had to navigate the prejudices of the jury pool, aiming to find jurors who could remain objective despite the town's prevailing sentiments.

[20:10] Judge Ralston: "I see no reason why prayer should influence the jury."

Trial Proceedings and Tensions Rise

The trial officially commenced on July 10, 1925, amidst scorching heat and a bustling crowd. Judge John Ralston presided over the court, emphasizing the religious undertones of the case by opening with prayers, much to Darrow's objections.

• Courtroom Atmosphere: The courthouse was transformed to accommodate reporters and spectators, making the trial one of the first to be broadcast live.
• Darrow's Defense: Emphasizing intellectual freedom, Darrow argued that the anti-evolution law infringed upon constitutional rights, setting the stage for a broader legal battle.

[28:55] Clarence Darrow: "It makes the Bible the yardstick to measure every man's intellect... an attempt to destroy liberty as was ever seen in the Middle Ages."

Media Frenzy and Public Spectacle

Dayton became a spectacle of conflicting ideologies, with preachers and atheists clashing in the streets, vendors selling related merchandise, and the media portraying the trial as a grand showdown between science and faith.

• Public Reactions: Many visitors viewed the trial as entertainment rather than a serious legal matter.
• Media Coverage: With 200 reporters covering the event and newsreel cameras transmitting proceedings nationwide, the trial garnered unprecedented attention.

[25:40] New York Times Reporter: "Whatever the deep significance of the trial, there is no doubt that it has attracted some of the world's champion freaks."

Climactic Moments and Legal Maneuvering

As the trial progressed, Darrow delivered a powerful two-hour argument challenging the constitutionality of the anti-evolution law, emphasizing the importance of separating church and state. His impassioned plea resonated nationally, garnering widespread acclaim.

• Storm Symbolism: A thunderstorm on the night of Darrow's speech was perceived by locals as divine displeasure, adding to the trial's dramatic atmosphere.
• Judge's Ruling Delayed: The following day, amidst rumors and a brief investigation into leaked information, Judge Ralston denied the defense's motion to quash the indictment, allowing the trial to proceed.

[30:12] Lindsey Graham: "Even though Darrow knew the deck was stacked against him... he delivered his dramatic conclusion."

Conclusion and Looking Ahead

With the indictment affirmed, the stage was set for a historic showdown in the courtroom. The trial promised to not only determine Scopes' fate but also to define the nation's stance on education, science, and religious influence.

[33:01] Lindsey Graham: "John Scopes would be tried for the crime of teaching evolution. And the showdown the country had been waiting for could finally begin."

Key Takeaways

• Cultural Clash: The Scopes Trial epitomized the national conflict between traditional religious beliefs and modern scientific theories.
• Legal Strategies: Both prosecution and defense employed strategic public relations and legal maneuvers to influence public opinion and judicial outcomes.
• Historical Impact: The trial highlighted the role of media in shaping public discourse and set precedents for future legal battles over educational content and constitutional rights.

Upcoming in Episode 3: "Evolution on Trial | Monkeytown | 3"

The final installment delves into the intense legal battles over expert witness testimonies, William Jennings Bryan's pivotal speeches against evolution, and Clarence Darrow's strategic moves leading to the trial's dramatic climax.

Experience more episodes ad-free and gain early access to the latest seasons by joining Wondery+ on the Wondery App or on Apple Podcasts. Start your free trial today!