Lindsey Graham (5:04)
From Wondery. I'm Lindsey Graham and this is American Historytellers. Our history, your story in the summer of 1980, President Jimmy Carter faced multiple crises. That July, news broke that his younger brother Billy had been engaged in shady deal making with Libya's dictator Muammar Gaddafi. Billy was called before a Senate Judiciary Committee and accused of influence peddling. And the scandal proved a major distraction at a time when Carter was fighting desperately for the American people's approval. Meanwhile, American citizens were still being held captive in Iran, the economy continued to struggle and members of Carter's own party were gearing up to challenge his bid for re election. Ultimately, Carter would lose his 1980 re election campaign to Republican Ronald Reagan, only to embark on a remarkable post presidential career devoted to advancing peace, combating disease and promoting democracy around the world. He and his wife Rosalynn took a hands on approach to advocacy and when Carter died in late 2024 at the age of 100, he left a legacy of service that reshaped what it meant to be a former president in the modern era. This is episode three of our series on the Carter years. Homecoming. In the spring of 1980, President Jimmy Carter was still reeling from the failure of Operation Eagle Claw, the military operation to rescue American hostages in Iran which had resulted in the death of eight American service members. Nearly every day the public was reminded that more than 50American hostages were still being held captive in Tehran and many blamed the President for failing to secure their freedom. As a result, heading into the summer that year, Carter struggled to focus on his troubled re election campaign. Massachusetts Senator Ted Kennedy was challenging Carter for the Democratic Party's nomination and had won key primary races in New York, Pennsylvania and California. Meanwhile, the Maine Republican challenger, former California Governor Ronald Reagan, was shaping up to be a formidable adversary. Reagan pledged to reduce the size of the federal government and stimulate the economy. His slogan, to make America great again was picking up momentum. Worried about the Democrats chances in the race against Reagan, Vice President Walter Mondale tried to play peacemaker. He met with Kennedy and begged him to step aside and let Carter have a clean shot, telling Kennedy, this is going to get nasty. But Kennedy refused to back out, still hoping to find a way to oust Carter at the Democratic National Convention in August. Then on July 15, 1980, Carter's younger brother Billy made headlines. The New York Times revealed that Billy Carter had been doing business with Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi and had made multiple trips to Libya in 1978 and 79, negotiating an agreement to help sell crude oil. In exchange, Billy received lavish gifts and was paid $220,000, which he would later claim was only a loan. The Justice Department launched an investigation into Billy's activities and formally reprimanded him for failing to register as an agent doing business on behalf of a foreign nation. Billy quickly registered and disclosed the payments and gifts he had received, but it did nothing to quash allegations of influence peddling by the President's brother. And when the Senate launched their own investigation, President Carter was forced to confront the scandal head on. In an effort to be transparent. On August 4, a week before the Democratic Party convention, Carter held a primetime news conference to address what the press was now calling Billy Gate. Carter told reporters, I am deeply concerned that Billy has received funds from Libya and that he may be under obligation to Libya. He added that he loved his brother, but I cannot control him. But the continuing bad press of Billy Gate wasn't the only blow to Carter's campaign. Only a week later, on the eve of the Democratic National Convention, Carter gave an interview to 60 Minutes reporter Dan Rather, who flatly suggested that Carter had exhibited ineffective leadership on air. He asked Carter to honestly grade himself, and despite being coached to avoid this question, Carter sheepishly admitted he'd give himself a C on foreign policy and a C on domestic affairs. Carter's frank admission to only meager performance as a president cast a pall over the convention. But despite the bad press and family scandal on August 11, 1980, Carter managed to win the Democratic Party's nomination. A defeated Ted Kennedy begrudgingly threw his support behind Carter, declaring, the work goes on, the cause endures, the hope still lives, and the dream shall never die. But the real fight was only beginning. Carter now had to face his Republican challenger, Ronald Reagan, a handsome and witty opponent who was campaigning on promises to increase military spending, cut welfare and boost the long suffering economy. All the while, American citizens were still languishing in captivity in Iran, in what was becoming less a hostage crisis and more a campaign issue. On September 22, 1980, Saddam Hussein and his Iraqi army invaded neighboring Iran, sparking a war between these two nations. As the conflict escalated, Iran was in desperate need of funding for weapons for its military. But because of the ongoing American hostage crisis, President Carter had frozen billions of dollars of Iran's assets that were held in US Banks. This gave Carter's campaign renewed hope that Iran's revolutionary leader, the Ayatollah Khamenei, might be willing to negotiate release of the hostages. Ideally, in time For Election Day. The hostages had now been held for nearly a year, and Carter was desperate to bring them home before Americans went to the polls on November 4th. But Reagan's campaign team was just as desperate to prevent what they called an October surprise. Reagan's campaign manager, William Casey, a former spy who was in line to become Reagan's CIA director, led an effort to spread false rumors to the press that Carter's team was paying the Iranians to free the hostages and that Carter was playing politics with American lives. Meanwhile, Casey's allies traveled to the Middle east and signaled that the Iranians would get a better deal for the hostages in if they waited until Reagan became president. The presidential race was growing contentious. And to have a chance at winning over Reagan, everyone in the Democratic camp knew it was crucial that Carter reassured the American public by demonstrating strength and competence. Imagine it's October 21, 1980, in Washington, D.C. you're President Jimmy Carter's chief of staff, and you've just arrived at the White House to help him prepare for next week's televised debate against Republican candidate Ronald Reagan. This is the President's first debate with Reagan, and you're worried that Carter is rusty. You need to make sure he's ready for the smooth talking, silver screen cowboy. You enter the Oval Office and find the President behind the Resolute desk, tension written all over his face. Everything okay, Mr. President? You still want to do this today? Yeah. Yeah. Let's just get on with it. All right. Take a seat on the sofa and consult your notes. So, as you know, Reagan. Well, he comes across as relaxed and always kind of smirking. We think you should focus on your posture and more than that, on staying calm. You don't think I'm calm? Well, to be honest, sir, no, I don't. I think you seem tense and angry lately. Some of that anger is showing up on tv. You talking about the Barbara Walters thing? You nod. During a recent interview with Walters, Carter was asked about his claims that Reagan was running a racist campaign by invoking states rights and even pandering to the kkk. But these comments backfired. Yeah, the press has been accusing you of running a mean campaign. We all know you were just calling out Reagan's tactics, but it seems like the public didn't like your tone. My tone? I'm simply just trying to tell the American people that racism has no place in the country. Well, sir, I obviously agree, but it's not just what you say, it's how you say it. And that's why the press has latched onto this idea that the tone of our campaign is too aggressive. Oh, you guys told me to point out the differences between me and Reagan. We did. And you should. But try to be more careful with your words, especially any ad lib comments. I'm like calling your opponent racist. He's stirring up hate using coded words like states rights. You expect me to ignore that? Well, don't ignore it, but maybe tone down the rhetoric a little. You watch the President bury his face in his hands, shaking his head. Oh, God, I'm just tired. Don't worry so much. I'll be ready for Reagan. You'll see. All right, sir. I'm sure you're right, but try to get some rest. You know, the President can be stubborn and often discards advice he doesn't like. But as you stand to leave the Oval Office, you hope your words have sunk in. The election is less than two weeks away and you're starting to worry you may be out of a job soon. On October 28, 1980, a week before the election, Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan faced off in their one and only debate. This 90 minute showdown was one of the most watched presidential debates in history. Carter's team had worried that Reagan, as a former actor, might have the advantage. He could easily memorize lines and look great in front of TV cameras. He had wit, charm, and an ability to spin out quotable one liners. Carter's aides coached the President to try to appear relaxed and confident. But it was clear from the start that Carter was tense. His chief of staff later said he looked like a coiled spring, ready to pounce. Like an overtrained boxer, too, ready for the bout. During the debate, when Carter pointed out Reagan's past opposition to Medicare, Reagan just shook his head and with an exasperated smile, said, there you go again, hinting that Carter didn't have his facts right. Then, in his closing statement, Reagan looked directly into the camera and asked Americans, are you better off than you were four years ago? It was a stinging question since many Americans were frustrated with the faltering economy and the ongoing crisis in Iran. As one voter put it, if Carter can't handle the Ayatollah, I'll take my chances with the cowboy. And in the wake of this debate, Carter's campaign faltered even more. Carter confessed to Vice President Mondale, they aren't listening to me anymore. And Mondale worried that Carter had lost all confidence. He later said, you could feel it slipping away. Then on November 2, two days before election Day, Carter attended a raucous rally in Seattle where a crowd of 36,000 people turned out to demonstrate their support during the flight back to D.C. aboard Air Force One, Carter was elated, and some of his aides thought a come from behind victory might be possible. But when Carter's pollster, Pat Cadell, got the latest numbers, Reagan had surged ahead by 10 points. Cadell called Air Force One to break the News, telling Carter, Mr. President, I'm afraid it's gone. Carter sat down, ashen faced. In only one short instant, Carter whiplashed from a moment of confidence to now believing he was hurtling toward defeat. American HISTORYTELLERS is sponsored by Selectquote There are so many things in life we just never get around to taking up that hobby, cleaning out the garage, things that don't really make huge differences in our lives yet. There's one thing many of us have been neglecting that can have a huge impact on our family's future. Life Insurance with Selectquote Getting covered with the right policy for you is easier and more affordable than you may think. Selectquote is one of America's leading insurance brokers with nearly 40 years of experience helping over 2 million customers find over $700 billion in coverage since 1985. And that's even for those of you with pre existing health conditions. Selectquote partners with carriers that provide policies for a variety of health conditions high blood pressure, diabetes, heart disease. Selectquote has partners that can cover those conditions and others. And if you're lucky enough not to have any major health issues, they work with carriers that can get you same day coverage with no medical exam required. Get the right insur insurance for you for less@SelectQuote.com tellers go to SelectQuote.com tellers today to get started. That's SelectQuote.com tellers with the Spark Cash plus card from Capital One, you earn unlimited 2% cash back on every purchase and you get big purchasing power so your business can spend more and earn more. Steven, Brandon and Bruno, the business owners of Sandcloud, reinvested their 2% cash back to help build their retail presence. Now that's serious business. What could the SparkCashPlus card from Capital One do for your business? Capital One?