American Scandal: ENCORE: Watergate | The Cancer Within | Episode 4 Release Date: July 1, 2025
Host: Lindsay Graham

Introduction

In this gripping episode of American Scandal, hosted by Lindsay Graham, Wondery delves deep into the intricate web of the Watergate scandal, focusing on the internal turmoil within President Richard Nixon's administration. Titled "The Cancer Within," Episode 4 provides a detailed reenactment of pivotal moments that highlight the betrayal, paranoia, and desperation that ultimately led to the unraveling of one of America's most infamous political scandals.

Patrick Gray's Senate Confirmation Hearing

The episode opens on February 28, 1970, with Patrick Gray, the acting director of the FBI, facing a grueling Senate confirmation hearing amid the burgeoning Watergate investigation.

• Patrick Gray's Determination: Gray emphasizes his commitment to an aggressive investigation.

  “Told him to go to the hilt, spare no horses. It was my decision to conduct an aggressive investigation.”
  [00:45]

• Disclosure of FBI Files: In a bold move, Gray declares his willingness to allow the Senate to examine the FBI's Watergate case files, despite conflicting instructions from President Nixon.

  “Any member of the US Senate may examine the FBI's file on Watergate. We have nothing to hold back.”
  [03:15]

• Involvement of White House Counsel John Dean: Gray admits that John Dean was present during FBI interviews, raising suspicions about the FBI's impartiality.

  “Mr. Dean was present during the FBI interviews. Is that a normal procedure?”
  [04:05]

Gray's candidness hints at deeper connections between the Nixon administration and the Watergate burglars, setting the stage for further revelations.

John Dean's Descent into the Cover-Up

Transitioning to March 21, 1973, the narrative shifts to John Dean, Nixon's White House Counsel, who grapples with the escalating Watergate crisis.

• Confrontation with Nixon: Dean informs President Nixon about Howard Hunt's blackmail threats, urging a strategic pivot away from merely paying hush money.

  “Watergate and the cover-up has become a cancer on the presidency.”
  [10:30]

• Meeting with Nixon's Allies: Dean faces pressure from Jeb Magruder and John Mitchell to commit perjury to protect the administration, highlighting the internal paranoia.

  “The more he thinks about the aftermath of Watergate, the more he thinks they can all work it out.”
  [15:20]

• Dean's Moral Struggle: Torn between loyalty and integrity, Dean decides to take a stand, recognizing the need to expose the corruption despite personal risks.

  “I have to work harder and do more to make sure this crisis quickly comes to an end.”
  [20:45]

Dean's Attempt to Cooperate with Prosecutors

On March 30, 1973, John Dean seeks legal assistance, leading to his pivotal cooperation with federal prosecutors.

• Meeting with Defense Lawyer Charles Schaefer: Dean confesses his involvement in the Watergate cover-up, seeking a deal for immunity.

  “I want to call cooperation. Deal. I'll tell the truth, but I want some guarantee I won't be prosecuted.”
  [18:50]

• Revelation of Prior Crimes: Dean discloses the involvement of top officials in illegal activities, including a previously unnoticed burglary targeting Daniel Ellsberg's psychiatrist.

  “Nixon's operatives broke into the office of Ellsberg's psychiatrist.”
  [22:10]

This revelation adds another layer to the scandal, linking the Watergate break-in to attempts at discrediting whistleblowers like Ellsberg.

Presidential Reactions and Strategic Maneuvers

The episode explores President Nixon's responses to the mounting pressures and Dean's betrayal.

• Nixon's Frustration: Upon learning of Dean's cooperation, Nixon contemplates severe measures but recognizes the potential downfall if he retaliates harshly.

  “Revenge is not the best option, at least for now.”
  [28:40]

• Final Confrontation: In a tense late-night meeting, Dean confronts Nixon, refusing to implicate the President further, solidifying his role as a whistleblower.

  “I have not told the prosecutors about your own involvement, and I have no plans to do so.”
  [34:15]

Nixon, visibly rattled, acknowledges Dean's loyalty but remains determined to navigate the scandal without conceding control.

Health Decline and Administration Turmoil

By April 15, 1973, the strain of the scandal takes a physical toll on President Nixon, signaling the administration's fragility.

• Chief of Staff Alexander Haig's Observation: Haig notes the declining morale and the personal toll on Nixon, underscoring the administration's instability.

  “This must be one of the toughest stretches of his entire presidency.”
  [40:10]

• Nixon's Health Crisis: Nixon experiences a severe coughing fit, raising concerns about his ability to lead effectively amidst the ongoing scandal.

  “Nixon is clearly sick. He needs help.”
  [44:50]

This physical manifestation of stress highlights the profound impact Watergate has on both the President and the White House team.

Conclusion and Implications

Episode 4, "The Cancer Within," paints a vivid picture of the internal decay and ethical compromises within Nixon's administration during the Watergate scandal. Through detailed reenactments and insightful commentary, the episode underscores how ambition, deceit, and the quest for power led to the downfall of a presidency and reshaped American politics.

Notable Quotes:

• “Watergate and the cover-up has become a cancer on the presidency.”

  John Dean [10:30]

• “I have to work harder and do more to make sure this crisis quickly comes to an end.”

  John Dean [20:45]

• “Revenge is not the best option, at least for now.”

  President Nixon [28:40]

• “I have not told the prosecutors about your own involvement, and I have no plans to do so.”

  John Dean [34:15]

Outro

In "The Cancer Within," American Scandal masterfully chronicles the unraveling of the Nixon administration, providing listeners with an in-depth understanding of the complex motivations and consequences that shaped one of America's darkest political chapters. Stay tuned for the next episode, where the pressure mounts as Nixon faces increasing scrutiny from special prosecutors, edging closer to a historic reckoning.

Recommended Listening:
For those interested in exploring more about the Watergate scandal, consider reading "All the President's Men" by Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, or "The Secret Man: The Story of Watergate's Deep Throat" by Bob Woodward.

Subscribe to Wondery+ for Exclusive Content:
Unlock early access to new episodes, enjoy ad-free listening, and explore exclusive seasons by joining Wondery+.