wavePod

Get Wave AI

Muhammad Ali vs. The Draft | What’s My Name? | 2 - American Scandal | Wave AI Podcast Notes

Back to American Scandal

Muhammad Ali vs. The Draft | What’s My Name? | 2

American Scandal

Tue Feb 25 2025

Summary

American Scandal: Muhammad Ali vs. The Draft | What’s My Name? | Episode 2

Host: Lindsay Graham
Release Date: February 25, 2025

1. Introduction: The Controversial Conscience of a Champion

In early November 1966, amidst the escalating Vietnam War, heavyweight boxing champion Muhammad Ali finds himself at the epicenter of a national controversy. Ali, originally known as Cassius Clay, applies for a draft deferment, citing his role as a minister of the Nation of Islam and his sincere opposition to war. However, his initial application is rejected by the Louisville draft board, setting off a legal and personal battle that challenges his career, beliefs, and identity.

2. The Draft Deferment Battle Begins

Oscar Smith, an attorney with the Department of Justice, is tasked with reviewing Ali's conscientious objector application. As the day of the final decision approaches, Smith grapples with doubts about Ali’s sincerity.

Oscar Smith ([02:15]): "Ali’s claim… seems like his objection is political, not religious."

Despite the judge's favorable recommendation, Smith contemplates the implications of denying Ali his deferment, balancing legal obligations against public sentiment and Ali's burgeoning fame.

3. Ali’s Defiance and Legal Maneuvering

Upon Oscar Smith’s recommendation to deny his deferment, Ali faces immediate induction into the U.S. Military. Determined to uphold his principles, Ali refuses to comply, leading to a criminal case against him.

Oscar Smith ([04:39]): "We're here to uphold the law."

Ali's stance is not just a personal battle but a defiant stand against what he perceives as a flawed justice system.

4. The Fight Beyond the Ring

In February 1967, Ali’s boxing prowess remains undiminished as he defeats Ernie Terrell in a highly publicized match. However, his legal troubles intensify as the draft board solidifies his induction status, forcing Ali to confront the harsh realities of defying governmental authority.

Howard Cosell ([02:41]): "He considers Vietnam a white man's war. It seems to me his objection is political, not religious."

This fight symbolizes more than a sporting event; it mirrors Ali’s internal and external struggles against societal and governmental pressures.

5. The Personal Cost: Legal Battles and Lost Titles

Ali's refusal to be drafted leads to severe repercussions. His boxing license is revoked, his heavyweight title stripped, and he faces indictment for draft evasion. The financial and professional toll weighs heavily, leaving Ali isolated from his earlier support systems.

Oscar Smith ([34:17]): "Lawyers are expensive, especially good ones. The Nation of Islam wanted the best for you."

Conflict with his lawyer, Hayden Covington, exacerbates Ali's predicament, culminating in a bitter fallout that leaves him without legal representation at a critical juncture.

6. Seeking Support: The Athlete’s Advisory Council

Facing the dual threats of incarceration and career termination, Ali turns to his friend Jim Brown and other prominent black athletes for support. A pivotal meeting convenes in June 1967, where athletes debate the merits and risks of Ali’s stance.

Jim Brown ([06:23]): "Ali, if you make a deal with the army, you can keep boxing and help bolster our community efforts."

Despite the persuasive arguments, Ali remains steadfast in his refusal, emphasizing the broader implications for racial justice and personal integrity.

7. The Criminal Trial and Its Aftermath

In June 1967, Ali is formally tried for draft evasion. Despite compelling arguments from his defense team highlighting racial biases and legal inconsistencies, the all-white jury convicts him swiftly.

Oscar Smith ([17:02]): "Be inducted into the service."

Judge Joe Ingram imposes the maximum sentence, ordering a hefty fine and potential imprisonment, while also seizing Ali’s passport to prevent his departure.

8. Suspension from the Nation of Islam: Betrayal from Within

Ali’s defiance does not go unnoticed within the Nation of Islam. In March 1969, Elijah Muhammad confronts Ali, condemning his public statements about financial necessity and suspending him from the Nation for a year.

Elijah Muhammad ([34:20]): "By going on television and saying he had no other way to make money, Ali effectively admitted he had no faith."

This suspension marks a profound personal and spiritual betrayal, leaving Ali to navigate his legal battles and personal turmoil without the support of his once-steadfast community.

9. Renewed Hope and Ongoing Struggles

As public opinion shifts against the Vietnam War, Ali finds renewed hope in the possibility of appealing his case to the Supreme Court, especially with revelations of illegal FBI wiretapping that could invalidate key evidence against him. Despite these developments, the path to vindication remains fraught with uncertainty and personal sacrifice.

Oscar Smith ([35:07]): "And when were you gonna tell me all this? That you expected to lose?"

Ali's journey embodies the intersection of personal conviction, legal injustice, and the broader fight for racial equality, setting the stage for a climactic resolution in the next episode.

10. Looking Ahead

As Episode 2 concludes, Ali stands at a crossroads, battling legal adversities, personal losses, and the quest for redemption. The upcoming episode promises to delve deeper into his appeal to the Supreme Court, the impact on his legacy, and the enduring question of identity versus obligation.

Recommended Further Reading:

Sting Like a Bee by Lee Montville
A Life by Jonathan Eig

Note: This summary is based on historically researched dramatizations and may include reenactments for illustrative purposes.

Loading summary...

Transcript

Lindsey Graham (0:00)

Hi, this is Lindsey Graham, host of American Scandal. Our back catalog has moved behind a paywall. Recent episodes remain free, but older ones will require a Wondery plus subscription. With Wondery, you get access to the full American Scandal archive ad free, plus early access to new seasons and more. Join Wondery plus in the Wondery app.

Narrator (0:19)

Or on Apple podcasts. It's early November 1966 in Washington, D.C. attorney Oscar Smith sits in his office in the Department of Justice reading interview transcripts to prepare for an upcoming case. Smith is in charge of reviewing applications for draft deferment. It's his job to determine whether applicants claiming to be conscientious objectors are sincere in their beliefs or if they're just lying to get out of military service. Today he's assessing the most controversial case that's ever crossed his desk, one involving heavyweight boxing champion Cassius Clay, or as he's now known, Muhammad Ali. Ali is claiming that he's a minister of the Nation of Islam, a religion that does not believe in war, and therefore he must be excused for military Service under the 4D exemption for all religious ministers. Ali's claim has already been rejected once by the draft board in his hometown of Louisville, Kentucky. But Ali's lawyer appealed the case to a state draft board, which triggered a weeks long investigation by the FBI and a formal hearing. Ali and his lawyers, along with several witnesses, went before a judge to testify about his beliefs, and in the end, the judge ruled he was in fact sincere and should not be drafted. But now the task of making a final determination comes down to Smith, and today's the day he has to decide. Smith hears a knock at his office door, sees a colleague poke his head in.

Oscar Smith (2:06)

Hi, Oscar. Just wanted to see how you're doing with this Clay case. Are you ready to make a recommendation? Not really.

Colleague (2:13)

But come in and sit down.

Oscar Smith (2:15)

Help me talk through this thing one last time. I'm surprised you're still on the fence. I was just reading the report from the judge and he doesn't leave much room for doubt. As far as he's concerned, Clay or Ali, I guess, is sincere. I know, I know. But there's just something about this case that feels fishy to me. Ali never mentioned that he was a conscientious objector until after.

Colleague (2:39)

After he faced the threat of being drafted.

Oscar Smith (2:41)

Now all of a sudden he's a minister? Seems odd, but he addressed that. He said the Nation of Islam is controversial and it would have cost him and his promoters a lot of money before the Sonny Liston fight. So money trumps his religious beliefs. I understand your hesitation, but the Nation of Islam does oppose war. Elijah Muhammad spent four years in prison during World War II for resisting the draft. That seems pretty sincere to me. But look at what Elijah Muhammad actually says. The Nation of Islam members cannot serve in the military of the United States. But he says they could serve in a holy war to defend Islam. That means they're not true conscientious objectors. You can't just oppose particular wars. You have to be against all war. Okay, but every witness for Ali said that he does oppose war. Three dozen people. Sure, his friends and family members. They're biased in his favor, but they're not all on good terms with him. Ali's parents said they hate the Nation of Islam, and since he changed his name they've barely spoken to him. But that doesn't mean they want him to go to war. Plus, I keep coming back to the fact that Ali has told reporters over and over again that he considers Vietnam a white man's war. It seems to me his objection is political, not religious. And the law is clear. You cannot dodge the draft for political reasons. That's a fair point. But do you really want to contradict the judge's recommendation? It's non binding, so I don't see why not. We've overruled judges in cases like this before. We've never had a case like this. Oscar, we're talking about one of the most famous athletes in the world here. If we go against the judge's recommendation and deny his deferment, people are going to get angered.

Narrator (7:27)

From Wondery hi, I'm Lindsey Graham and this is American Scandal. In the early 1960s, boxer Muhammad Ali rocketed to stardom by becoming the heavyweight champion of the world. But he courted controversy along the way, both with his flamboyant Persona and his decision to join the Nation of Islam. Ali was first drawn to the nation's message of self determination for black people, but he quickly embraced all of the nation's teachings and its rules. Ali began praying five times a day, abstaining from alcohol and pork and declaring his opposition to war. In early 1966, Ali applied for a draft deferral as a conscientious objector and minister, but the government rejected his application. And when Ali in turn refused to be drafted, the justice system decided to pursue a criminal case against Ali to the full extent of the law. This is episode two what's my name? It's December 28, 1966 in New York City, sports reporter Howard Cosell is standing in the press room at Madison Square Garden holding a microphone, looking down the lens of a TV camera. He smiles, glancing up at the two giant men on either side of him. Muhammad Ali and another African American boxer, Ernie Terrell. Both men, well over 6ft tall, are set to fight in a highly anticipated heavyweight title match, and Cosell has brought them together for an interview ahead of the bout to help sell the conflict between the two fighters. Cosell starts the interview with a jab at Ali. As the camera starts rolling, Cosell announces that Terrell has just told him that he's the only man in the world that Muhammad Ali is afraid of knowing. Ali has a response. Cosell asks him to read a poem he's prepared just for the occasion. Ali recites the poem in his Kentucky drawl, carefully enunciating rhyming couplets like, at the sound of the bell, Tyrell will catch hell. He gets a few laughs from others in the room, but Tyrell remains stone faced. And then he takes a dig of his own, saying he'd like to say something about his opponent, Cassius Clay. Cosell glances over at Ali and can see anger cloud his face. Ali quickly interrupts Tirrell and demands to know why he's refusing to use his real name. Tyrell responds by reminding the champ that they've known each other for years and he doesn't remember him going by Muhammad Ali in the past. Ali is incensed. He insists that Terrell call him by his Muslim name, but Terrell refuses. As the argument escalates, Cosell tilts his microphone back and forth, trying to catch every word, knowing this is great television. The two boxers are squaring off as if they're already in the ring. But then, when Ali calls Terrell an Uncle Tom, Cosell can sense the energy in the room change. Ali might have crossed a line with this insult. Cosell tries to wrap things up as Terrell steps in closer, looking as if he's about to hit Ali. But then Ali reaches past Cosell and shoves Terrell. Cocell barely escapes from between the two boxers as the room erupts in chaos. Ali and Tirrell's entourages dart forward to grab the men who keep taunting each other. Cosell gestures at the camera crew to keep rolling, but at the same time, he's unnerved. Tension in the boxing world over Ali and his antics is already high, and this little scuffle ignited by his Muslim name will only ratchet things up even more. Ali's bout with Ernie Terrell occurs two months later, in February 1967. Tirrell lasts about 15 rounds, but he's clearly outmatched by the eighth round. Ali is toying with him, taunting him with shouts of what's my name? In the end, Tirrell loses the match in a unanimous decision. Commentators say that Ali looks unstoppable in the ring. Even those who might despise his politics or behavior are forced to admit that he's the best boxer alive, and Ali is inclined to agree. He is faster, stronger and more agile than ever. He is also continuing to stick to Nation of Islam tenets and has hired an all black team of managers headed by Herbert Muhammad, the son of Nation of Islam leader Elijah Muhammad. In many ways, Ali feels like he's reaching the peak of his abilities, which makes him all the more anxious that he might be drafted into the US Military. The war in Vietnam is ramping up and the army is recruiting heavily. So in early 1967, when the Louisville draft board decides to take the Department of Justice's recommendation and deny Ali's request for a deferral, the boxer is shaken deeply. Ali is now officially eligible for the draft, and his lawyer, Hayden Covington, immediately fights back. Covington files a lawsuit in federal court to declare Kentucky's draft boards unconstitutional because there's only one black draft board member in the entire state. He argues that just like juries, draft boards need to be reflective of their communities, which means they must be more racially diverse. But federal cases can take years to resolve, and Ali doesn't have that kind of time. Every morning he wakes up wondering whether he'll be called to serve, and on March 15, 1967, he is. That evening, Ali is inside a suite at Madison Square Garden, eating dinner after an intense training session for his next big fight, when he hears a knock at the door. Ali looks up from his meal to see the Garden's publicity manager, John Condon, enter the room. Condon approaches Ali and shakes his hand but has a solemn look on his face. Then he places a hand on Ali's shoulder and says he has some bad news. He just got a phone call from Louisville. The draft board has released the next round of draftees, and Ali's name is on the list. He's going to be inducted in a month, on April 11th. Ali's heart sinks. He always knew there was a chance of being drafted, but he hopes somehow he'd be spared. So Ali stands and starts pacing the room, his mind going through all the possible scenarios. If he refuses to Join. Finally, he looks at Condon and says that whatever happens this next bout will probably be his last. And if that's true, he needs to make the most of it. A week later, Ali easily dispatches his opponent in a seven round knockout. But news of the fight is overshadowed with speculation about Ali's impending induction into the Army. Ali has been saying for years that he'll never join the military. But most observers don't believe it. There's no way he'd throw away his boxing career by defying the government. So Ali's best hope is his legal case. And his lawyers are already hard at work. Covington knows the suit, claiming that draft boards are racially biased could take years to resolve. So he tries another gambit. Since Ali has been living in Houston, Texas nearly full time for a few years now, Covington files a motion to transfer Ali's induction from Louisville to Houston, hoping that military red tape will delay the process. But the ploy doesn't do much. The military only expedites Ali's case and grant the transfer. Soon, the boxer receives a letter instructing him to report for induction in Houston on April 28, 1967, only 17 days after his initial induction date. And when the time comes, Ali wakes up that day feeling resolved. He's already decided that he's not going to serve. Still, the thought of having to subject himself to induction makes him nervous. And he's not the only one who feels that way. For U.S. army Lieutenant Stephen Dunkley, he faces the day with dread, too. Dunkley is one of the officers charged with overseeing Ali's induction. And while he doesn't want to force the boxer to join the military against his will, the thought of sending him to prison for refusing feels even worse. So as the hour of Ali's arrival approaches, Dunkley hopes that the boxer will just change his mind. He watches from a third floor window as Ali's cab pulls up outside the US Custom House in downtown Houston, which houses the Armed Forces Induction Center. The car is immediately surrounded by a mob of reporters, protesters and counter protesters. But Ali looks perfectly calm as he steps out of the cab and heads for the door, ignoring the reporters shouting questions at him. Anxiously, Dunkley heads to the lobby and counts the draftees gathered there. All 36 have shown up, so he begins to lead them back to an exam room to start the induction. Over the next four hours, Dunkley and other officers lead the men through a series of medical evaluations. They fill out paperwork and get their blood drawn. Then, after lunch, it's time for the moment Dunkley has been dreading. Dunkley leads eight men, including Muhammad Ali, into a small room and instructs them to stand in a straight line. Then he grabs a clipboard with a sheet of paper and clears his throat.

Narrator (20:28)

Just minutes after refusing to be drafted, Muhammad Ali and his lawyers walk into a press room in the US Customs House in downtown Houston. The room is swarming with reporters, all eager to ask Ali about his decision. But to the reporter's disappointment, the highly quotable Ali declines to answer any questions. Instead, he hands out a pre written statement. It reads in part, many newspapers have given the American public the impression that I have only two alternatives in taking this stand. Either I go to jail or go to the Army. There is another alternative, and that alternative is justice. Within hours of the press conference, the powerful New York Athletic Commission revokes Ali's boxing license and strips him of his heavyweight title. Several other states follow, effectively banning Ali from boxing in the country. Ten days later, Ali is indicted by a federal grand jury. He's formally arrested and fingerprinted. His mugshot is taken, and then he's released on bail, sent home to await trial. Ali feels certain he's doing the right thing, even as many people in his inner circle try to convince him to back down and just join the military. They're worried he's not thinking clearly, or that he may not fully understand what going to jail could do to his career and public image. But Ali has his share of supporters, too, and none of them are more loyal to him than his friend and business associate, former NFL football star Jim Brown. Since first meeting in 1964, Brown and Ali have bonded over their shared status as elite athletes and their interest in black activism. Brown has also become a partner in Ali's career through his company, Main Bout, which handles the television rights for Ali's fights. And at first, when Ali was drafted, Brown felt like he was in a no win situation. Either Ali would have to stop boxing while he performed his military service or or he would be banned from boxing for refusing to serve. No matter the outcome, Ali would be unable to box and Brown's company would lose millions in TV rights. But then Brown gets word of another possible solution from an unlikely source. He receives a phone call from Herbert Muhammad, who is also a partner in Main Bout as well as Ali's manager and the son of his spiritual mentor, Elijah Muhammad. Herbert tells Brown that he's gotten word from a US District attorney that if Ali agrees to serve, he'll be allowed to continue boxing professionally. He'll never see combat, and the Nation of Islam wants him to take the deal. This all comes as a shock to Brown, but he agrees to discuss it with Ali. Still, Brown isn't comfortable telling his friend to do anything that goes against his beliefs. Instead, he decides to organize a meeting of other prominent black athletes, including several who have served in the military themselves. He wants them to act as a kind of advisory council to Ali to help him weigh the pros and cons of taking a deal and entering the military. So on June 4, 1967, a group of black NFL players and basketball stars gather in Brown's office in Cleveland, Ohio. But even in a room of top athletes, Brown is struck by how dominant Ali's personality is. No one can match his charisma. Ali cracks jokes and works the room like a politician, shaking every hand. And only when Ali is settled does Brown open up the floor to discussion. One of the athletes, an army veteran, speaks up first. He says Ali should enlist and notes that it's extremely unlikely that he'll end up on the front lines. He reminds Ali of what happened with former heavyweight champ Joe Louis, who enlisted during World War II. Lewis spent most of his time giving boxing exhibitions for the troops, and Ali will likely do the same. When Ali looks dubious, Brown chimes in and says he has good reason to believe that Ali can cut a deal to keep boxing professionally while he serves. The army has hinted that it would grant him permission. Brown also points out that Ali's fights would support Brown's production company, Main Bout, which employs many black workers. Brown would also use the proceeds to bankroll his latest venture, a support organization for black entrepreneurs. All Ali has to do is cut a deal with the army and he can continue his boxing career and funnel millions of dollars into black communities. But wrapping up his pitch, Brown says he'll support whatever decision Ali makes. And he sees the other men in the room nodding their heads as well. Ali leans back in his chair, contemplating everything. But then he shakes his head. The answer is still no. He will not serve in the military. His religious convictions won't allow it. Hearing this, several of the athletes try to reason with him, saying that there's more to a man than just religion. There's his country, too. And Ali acknowledges this, but says it's not the right path for him. Trying a different tack, one athlete asks Ali point blank if he's willing to walk away from all the money, not just for him, but for his black management team and Brown's production company. Ali stands and looks at every man in the room. He says he's sorry, sincerely apologetic, but he can't do it. His decision is bigger than the war in Vietnam. It's about the treatment of black people all across America. He says he would never be in this position if the draft board and Department of Justice had treated him fairly. The broader issue is one of a broken criminal justice system in America. And as Brown looks around the room, he can see that what Ali's saying resonates with the other athletes. A few of them ask Ali about the Nation of Islam's stand against integration, worrying that this might lead to an American apartheid. But Ali says he's confident that black men and women can make do for themselves. And then for the next several hours, the men continue going back and forth about the plight of black people in America. By the end, Ali has won over every athlete in the room. They're all convinced that he has thought the this through and that for him, resisting the draft is the right thing to do. Brown leaves the meeting feeling disappointed because if Ali can't box, Brown's company stands to lose a lot of money. But he's also fearful for the sake of his friend and the continued backlash he'll face for taking this stand. He's sacrificing so much just to stand by his principles. On June 19, 1967, Ali enters a Houston courtroom to begin his criminal trial for draft evasion. And immediately it seems like the cards are stacked against him. The presiding judge is Joe Ingram, a 63 year old World War II veteran with a reputation for being strict and conservative. And the jury is all white. The government's case is simple. According to the law, Ali has a duty to serve. But Ali refused that duty and therefore alone must be found guilty. But Ali's lawyer, Hayden Covington, raises a host of issues. He complains about the racial makeup of the draft board and the fact that the Department of Justice rejected the recommendations of the judge who first reviewed Ali's case. Even the FBI report on Ali concluded that he was sincere in his beliefs. Covington also notes that the draft board faced undue pressure to force Ali into service. A congressman from South Carolina had publicly threatened an investigation if Ali was ruled exempt. But Judge Ingram proves unsympathetic to these arguments. He expresses skepticism about Ali's claims of being a minister and seems to think that Ali's objections to the war are political, not religious. The trial lasts only two days and Ali's defense team decides against having him testify on his own behalf. After closing arguments, the jury deliberates for just 21 minutes before before deciding to convict. When the word guilty rings out, Ali sits at the defense table, stunned. He feels his lawyer, Covington, pat his shoulder and assure him they'll appeal the verdict. But it's not much comfort to Ali. He can't believe things have reached this point. Ali is even more shocked when Judge Ingram ignores the prosecution's recommendation for a reduced sentence. Instead, he announces that he's giving the boxer the maximum sentence allowed by Law, a $10,000 fine and five years in federal prison. Ali will be allowed to remain free while he appeals his sentence. But until then, Ingram orders that Ali surrender his passport so he can't flee the country. Hearing this sentence, Covington jumps up and objects. Even the prosecutor looks stunned. But Ingram bangs his gavel and refuses to hear the objection. A few weeks later, on July 2nd 7th, Ali and his lawyers are back in Judge Ingram's court again, filing a motion to permit Ali to leave the US For a boxing match in Japan. Since Ali has been banned from boxing in America, fighting overseas is his only chance to earn money. And at this hearing, Ali gets a chance to testify. As he steps into the witness box, he's looking forward to speak in his own defense. And initially, everything seems to be going well. One of Ali's defense attorneys act asks the questions they've rehearsed and he gets to assure the court that he's traveling overseas purely for professional reasons. Then, after a brief recess, it's the prosecution's turn to question Ali. U.S. attorney Mort Sussman rises and gives a tight lipped smile.

Narrator (35:53)

Ali rises and storms out of the conference room, leaving Covington stewing in silence. But as soon as he reaches the hallway, Ali finds a gaggle of reporters staring at him. He realizes they were eavesdropping the whole time, and this makes him even more angry. But Ali knows any outburst will only make things worse. So he bites his tongue, ignoring their gazes and heads straight outside. After firing Hayden Covington, Ali names Chauncey Eskridge as his new attorney. Eskridge was a decorated pilot in World War II. He's one of the most prominent black lawyers in the nation. Although primarily a tax attorney, he's done work on Ali's case already, including testifying before the Kentucky judge. And he immediately takes responsibility for the appeal in federal courts. But although Ali feels better with Eskridge in charge of the case after filing the appeal, the 25 year old boxer doesn't know what to do with himself. He's one of the most famous people in the country, but he can't earn money boxing. And it could be more than a year before his case is even heard. Ali retreats inward, looking for peace and stability in his life. He proposes to Belinda Boyd, a 17 year old woman whose parents are prominent members of the Nation of Islam. And they are a happy newlywed couple, but plagued by financial troubles. Belinda is even forced to dip into her college savings to pay for groceries. Still, they have reason to feel hopeful. By 1968, public opinion about the Vietnam War has begun to shift as American casualties mount and anti war protests grow. President Lyndon Johnson announces that he will not seek re election. The war has become a quagmire and effectively driven him from office. This shift in the public's attitude about the war is met by a change in attitudes about Ali. Young people inspired by Ali begin burning their draft cards, chanting hell no, we won't go at protest rallies. But the courts don't share the feelings of the young public. In May 1968, a three judge panel on the Fifth Court of Appeals upholds Ali's conviction, leaving him with just one more chance to clear his name by appealing his case all the way to the U.S. supreme Court. And at first the court agrees to hear Ali's case. But in March 1969, the court announces that it's remanding Ali's case to the lowest branch of the federal system for more hearings. This decision surprises both the public and Ali. But what they don't know is that behind the scenes, something important has recently come to light. For the past decade, the FBI has been illegally wiretapping dozens of prominent Americans, including Elijah Muhammad and Martin Luther King Jr. Five of the illegally recorded conversations involve Ali. In no instance was Ali the primary target of the wiretaps, but the Supreme Court rules that doesn't matter. Because of the wiretaps, the Department of Justice had access to information that Ali's lawyers did did not, potentially violating his civil rights. So the Supreme Court wants a lower court to determine what role, if any, the wiretaps played in denying Ali's conscientious objector request. Ali is overjoyed at the news. Kicking his case back to the lower courts means he'll have several more chances to get his draft deferral, which would also overturn his conviction. So Ali starts feeling optimistic about the future, and he publicly floats the idea of a possible return to boxing. At a press conference with sports reporter Howard Cosell, Ali also admits that he has a lot of debt to pay off and that a heavyweight bout would help with that. But Ali's feelings about the future take an abrupt turn when, in March 1969, he's suddenly summoned to meet with Elijah Muhammad at his Chicago home. When Ali arrives at his mentor's mansion, he opens the door to find a dozen high ranking members of the Nation of Islamic sitting around a table in the parlor. At the head of the table sits 72 year old Elijah Muhammad himself. Normally Muhammad has a wide, radiant smile, but not today. Instead, he points to an empty chair at the end of the table and curtly tells Ali to sit. Ali obeys and Muhammad begin speaking. He tells Ali that the Nation has always granted him independence to pursue professional opportunities. Nahli nods in agreement. He knows that other Nation members have sometimes been forced to give up their careers in singing and other fields that were considered at odds with the Nation's tenets. But Ali has always received special treatment in that regard. Muhammad continues, noting that the Nation has indulged Ali outside the boxing ring as well. He mentions that two years ago Ali met with Martin Luther King Jr. Without the nation's permission and faced no punishment. Then Ali nods again, knowing it's true. Muhammad then asks Ali, given the special treatment he's received, why has he so flagrantly betrayed the Nation's teachings? Ali sits back, confused. He racks his brain trying to remember a misstep, but can't think of anything. He doesn't think he's betrayed the Nation's teachings. In fact, he thinks he's risked his career for the sake of the Nation. Noting Ali's confusion, Muhammad shakes his head sadly. Then he says he saw Ali's recent interview with Howard Cosell where Ali said he needed to fight again to make money. Ali admits he said that he has a wife and child now and legal fees to pay. Muhammad leans forward and says to Ali that the Nation teaches that Allah alone provides. And that by going on television and saying he had no other way to make money, Ali effectively admitted he had no faith. Ali sits back in his chair, baffled. He thinks about Muhammad, speaks the newspaper with the cartoon that first drew him to the Nation of Islam. Which is now constantly celebrating his achievements with gushing stories. He also thinks about the fact that he fired his original promoters from Louisville. So that Muhammad's son Herbert could manage his career. Both Herbert and the Nation have made plenty of money off Ali as a result. Ali glances at Herbert, who's seated at the far end of the table. But Herbert ducks his eyes, looking embarrassed. Elijah Muhammad then rises from his chair and announces that he's suspending Ali from the Nation for a full year. Ali is stunned. It seems harsh to suspend him just for saying he needs to earn a living. And Ali wonders if there's another unstated reason for this punishment. But Muhammad says there will be no further discussion of the matter. The boxer made a fool of the Nation, and there must be repercussions. Then he announces that for one year, no other member of the Nation of Islam is allowed to interact with Ali, and if they do, they'll be suspended as well. He also says that Ali is not to be allowed to enter any Nation mosque. And that members of the Nation will refer to him exclusively by his birth name, Cassius Clay. Elijah then turns to Ali with a thin smile and asks, do you have any questions? Cassius, hearing that name on his mentor's lips, stabs Ali in the heart. He scans the room, looking for comfort, but no one says anything. Ali feels every bit as bereft as when he was sentenced to prison. But there's nothing he can do. The Nation teaches that followers must submit to authority. And he has to submit now, however unjust it seems. As he gets up to leave. Leave, Ali is flooded with grief. He sacrificed so much for the Nation. Not just boxing and career opportunities, but old friendships and the close bond he once had with his parents. He's even risking prison time to uphold the Nation's teachings and refuse military service. But now, when he needs them most, the Nation is abandoning him. So if he wants to keep fighting in the ring or in the courts, he's going to have to do it on his own. From Wondery, this is episode two of Muhammad Ali versus The Draft for American Scandal. In our next episode, as Ali's career remains in limbo and his personal life unravels, his case makes its way back to the Supreme Court for one final decision that will determine his fate. If you're enjoying American Scandal, you can.