American Scandal: Episode 4 - The Woman Who Sold Babies | The Cold Hard Hand
Introduction
In Episode 4 of Wondery's American Scandal series, titled "The Woman Who Sold Babies | The Cold Hard Hand," host Lindsey Graham delves deep into one of America's most disturbing adoption scandals. The episode meticulously unravels the dark history of Georgia Tann and the Tennessee Children's Home Society (TCHS), exposing a web of corruption, abuse, and greed that devastated countless lives.
Georgia Tann and the Rise of TCHS
By the end of World War II, Georgia Tann had established herself as a dominant figure in the adoption industry in Memphis, Tennessee. Leveraging her close relationship with political powerhouse Edward "Boss" Crump, Tann built a vast network that made the Tennessee Children's Home Society America's most recognized adoption agency. However, Tann's motivations were far from altruistic. For nearly two decades, she orchestrated a system where children were stolen and sold to new parents, generating substantial profits with each transaction.
Exposing the Abuses at Poplar Avenue
The episode chronicles the grim reality behind Tann's facade. While TCHS presented itself as a sanctuary with immaculate gardens and nurturing environments, the truth was horrifying. Children were subjected to severe abuse, neglect, and even molestation within the overcrowded and filthy dormitories of the Poplar Avenue facility. Tann's tyrannical rule, exacerbated by her worsening cancer, ensured that any dissent was met with harsh punishment, fostering an environment of fear and secrecy.
Gertrude Gibbs: The Relentless Nemesis
The turning point in the scandal comes with the introduction of Gertrude Gibbs, a compassionate housewife from Memphis. After witnessing suspicious activities at Memphis Municipal Airport, where Georgia Tann's TCHS was secretly transporting infants out of state for exorbitant fees, Gibbs takes it upon herself to investigate. Her determination leads her to uncover the financial irregularities and unethical practices of TCHS, despite facing significant opposition from Tann's influential lawyer, Abe Waldauer.
The Investigation and Tann's Downfall
Governor Gordon Browning's rise to power marks a critical phase in the investigation. Unlike his predecessor, Browning is unwilling to protect Tann and the TCHS. Attorney Robert Taylor is tasked with probing the allegations, leading to significant breakthroughs, including intercepted financial transactions and testimonies from involved individuals. However, Georgia Tann's manipulative tactics, including the closing of the TCHS and the dismissal of key figures like Judge Camille Kelly, impede the investigation. Tann's sudden death in September 1950 leaves many questions unanswered, and despite Taylor's relentless efforts, the scandal is ultimately buried, allowing Tann's legacy to tarnish only slightly.
Legacy and Continued Impact
The aftermath of Tann's actions had long-lasting effects on the American adoption system. Many of the oppressive policies she introduced, such as sealed adoption records, became widespread practices that hindered transparency and accountability for decades. It wasn't until the early 1990s that renewed media attention reignited interest in Tann's case, leading to both heartwarming reunions and tragic losses for the victims. In 2015, a memorial was erected to honor the children who perished under TCHS's neglect, serving as a somber reminder of the human cost behind the scandal.
Notable Quotes
-
Lindsey Graham [00:00]: "Scandals have shaped America since its founding. From business and politics to sports and society..."
-
Narrator [05:01]: "But it won't be enough to satisfy Judge Bates, who will continue to nurse suspicions."
-
Robert Taylor [19:51]: "Now it's time to go back to Memphis and finally put an end to Tennessee's black market baby ring."
-
Judge Camille Kelly [39:30]: "If you agree to step down from the bench, I give you my word that I will keep your name out of this investigation."
Conclusion
Episode 4 of American Scandal masterfully exposes the heinous crimes of Georgia Tann and the Tennessee Children's Home Society. Through meticulous research and compelling storytelling, Lindsey Graham brings to light the evils that lurked behind the adoption industry's respectable veneer. This episode serves as a crucial reminder of the importance of oversight, transparency, and the relentless pursuit of justice to protect the most vulnerable in society.
Recommendations for Further Reading
For those seeking a deeper understanding of Georgia Tann's atrocities, the episode recommends the following books:
- The Baby Thief by Barbara Bazance Raymond
- Babies for Sale by Linda Tollett Austin
- Before and After by Judy Christie and Lisa Wingate
Stay Tuned
In the next episode, Graham interviews journalist TJ Raphael, host of the upcoming Wondery podcast Liberty Lost, to discuss a modern-day adoption home potentially linked to Tann's legacy and its evangelical roots.