← America's Most Infamous Crimes with Katie Ring
America's Most Infamous Crimes with Katie Ring
Caylee Anthony: What Forensics Found On Her Changed Everything Pt. 2
00:32:02
Loading summary
Transcript7 lines
- [00:00]
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Foreign.
- [00:06]
Katie Rang
This is Crime House. Casey Anthony was behind bars, but her two year old daughter Kaylee was still missing. For months, investigators had been building a case based on lies, inconsistencies, and a car that smelled like death. But they still didn't have the one thing they needed most. A body. That changed on a December afternoon in 2008. And what came next would turn a missing person's case into a murder trial that captivated 40 million Americans. Today I'll walk through the evidence that the prosecution believed proved Casey Anthony killed her daughter. Then I'll get into the defense's explosive counter theory, one that pointed the finger at someone else in the Anthony family. Every crime tells a story about the people involved, the system that tried to stop it, and the nation that couldn't look away. Some cases are so shocking, so deeply woven into who we are, that decades later, we're still asking, how did this happen? I'm Katie Rang and this is America's Most Infamous Crimes. Every Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday, I'll take you deep into cases that have a lasting imprint on society and still haunt us Today. I want to thank you for being part of the Crime House community. Please rate, review and follow America's Most Infamous Crimes wherever you get your podcasts and to get all episodes at once ad free. Subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. Before I get started, please be advised that this episode contains descriptions of child death and disturbing forensic details. So please listen with care. This is the second of our three episode series on the death of Kaylee Anthony. Today I'll take you through the forensic clues that turn this case from a missing child investigation into a murder trial. The smell in the car, the hair in the trunk, the the discovery of Caylee's remains in the woods, and the duct tape that may be the single most important piece of evidence in the entire case. Then I'll break down both sides of the trial, what the prosecution argued, what the defense fired back with, and why the case became the kind of courtroom battle that defines a generation.
- [02:19]
Progressive Insurance Advertiser
Insurance isn't one size fits all, and shopping for it shouldn't feel like squeezing into something that just doesn't fit. That's why drivers have enjoyed Progressive's Name youe Price Tool for years. With the name youe Price Tool, you tell them what you want to pay and they show you options that fit your budget enough. Hunting for discounts, trying to calculate rates, and tinkering with coverages. Maybe you're picking out your very first policy. Or maybe you're just looking for something that works better for you and your family. Either way, they make it simple to see your options. No guesswork, no surprises. Ready to see how easy and fun shopping for car insurance can be? Visit progressive.com and give the name your price tool a try. Take the stress out of shopping and find coverage that fits your life on your terms. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and coverage match limited by state law.
- [03:05]
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
This episode is brought to you by Prime Obsession is in session. And this summer, Prime Originals have everything you want. Steamy romances, irresistible love stories and the book to screen favorites you've already read twice off campus Elle every year. After the Love Hypothesis, Sterling Point and more slow burns, second chances, chemistry you can feel through the screen. Your next obsession is waiting. Watch only on Prime.
- [03:36]
Katie Rang
When we left off Casey Anthony had been arrested on charges of child neglect, providing false information to law enforcement and obstructing an investigation. Her bail was set at $500,000, and on July 22, 2008, she was officially declared a person of interest in the disappearance of her daughter, Kaylee. At that point, investigators were still treating this as a missing child case. Kaylee's body hadn't been found, and there was no physical proof that she was dead. All they had were Casey's lies, a missing toddler, and a growing sense that something terrible had happened. What they did have, though, was that white Pontiac Sunfire. And the more forensics examined it, the worse things looked for Casey Anthony. Remember when Casey's parents, George and Cindy, picked up the car from the tow yard on July 15? Multiple people immediately remarked that it smelled like human decomposition. George, a former police officer, recognized the odor right away. He'd encountered plenty of death in his career, and this was unmistakable to him. The supervisor of the tow truck company said the same thing independently that the car smelled like a dead body had been inside of it. Even Casey Anthony's friend Amy, said Casey had texted her about a bad smell in her car at some point during the month, Although she'd blamed it on a dead animal she'd supposedly hit while driving. Well, forensics went a lot further than a sniff test. Sometime before August 27, about a month and a half after the car was discovered, investigators performed what's called an air sample test on the trunk. The way this works is that scientists analyze the chemical compounds present in the air that was trapped inside of an enclosed space. Different substances leave behind different chemical signatures as they break down, and those signatures can tell you a lot about what was in that space. The results from Casey's trunk Were significant. The samples showed very high concentrations of chloroform, along with other chemicals that are specifically associated with human decomposition. Now, chloroform in a car trunk could mean a few different things, and this eventually became a major point of contention at the trial. It could suggest that someone used chloroform to sedate or kill Kaylee, or it could have been released naturally as part of the decomposition process, which does happen When a body breaks down in an enclosed environment. Either way, the presence of those chemicals in those concentrations Was not something you'd expect to find in a normal car trunk. And it was not good news for Casey Anthony. But the air samples weren't the only thing forensics found. There was also a collection of small flies in the trunk. According to an insect expert who later testified for the prosecution, the type and quantity of flies suggested that Kaylee's body had already passed through the initial stages of decomposition before it was placed in the car. In other words, whoever put her body in that trunk had didn't do it immediately after she died. There was a gap between the time of death and the time the body was moved into the vehicle. That detail suggested that someone had kept the body somewhere else first and then transported it in the Pontiac. And then there was the hair. A single human hair Was recovered from the trunk of the pontiac. DNA analysis showed it belonged to either Casey, Cindy, or Kaylee. They shared enough genetic material As a mother, daughter, and granddaughter that the test couldn't distinguish between the three of them Based on DNA alone. Investigators used other characteristics to narrow it down, Though. The hair wasn't the length of Casey's, and it wasn't color treated like Cindy's, who dyed her hair regularly. But it did match the color and length of Kali's hair. When compared to a sample taken from Kali's hairbrush and examined under a microscope, Investigators were confident it was a match. The most important detail about the hair Was something called a post mortal mortem root band. This is an opaque, dark band that appears near the root of the hair when it falls from a decomposing body. It's essentially a forensic marker telling you that the person the hair came from Was already dead when the hair detached. It only forms after death during the decomposition process. And this hair had one. Which meant that whoever that hair belonged to and the evidence pointed strongly to Kaylee Was no longer alive when they were in the trunk of that car. So by this point, investigators had a car that multiple people said smelled like human decomposition. They had air sample results showing chemicals Consistent with a decaying body. They had insects that suggested the body had already started breaking down before being placed in the trunk. And they had a hair with decomposition banding that was consistent with Kaylee's. Piece by piece, the forensic evidence was building a case that Kaylee's body had been in that car. But there was still one enormous piece missing from the puzzle. They didn't have Kaylee's body. Not yet. And on August 21, 2008, about a month after her initial arrest, Casey was released from jail. Her bail was paid by a bondsman with the help of her parents, and she went back to the house on Hope Spring Drive, where she was fitted with a monitoring device. But the investigation didn't slow down just because Casey was out on Bailey. If anything, it accelerated. On October 14, 2008, the charges against Casey got a lot more serious. Despite not having a body, the authorities were sure that Kaylee was dead. And Casey was now charged with first degree murder, aggravated child abuse, aggravated manslaughter, and four counts of providing false information to law enforcement. Prosecutors were building toward a capital case, which is a crime punishable by the death penalty. They believed they had a child killer on their hands, and they were determined to prove it, even though they still hadn't found Kaylee's body. That changed a couple months later. On December 11, 2008, a utility worker named Roy Cronk was on his usual route through the woods about a half mile from the Anthony's home when he stepped off of the path looking for a spot to relieve himself. And that's when he saw what were unmistakably the bones of a child. The remains were partially concealed by vegetation and debris and had clearly been there for a long time. The Florida heat, rain and wildlife had taken a devastating toll on whatever had been left in those woods months earlier. Eight days later, on December 19, 2008, the remains were positively identified as Caylee Anthony's. The little girl who had been missing since June, who her mother claimed was with a nanny who her grandparents believed was safe somewhere, had been lying in the woods less than half a mile from her own home this entire time. The location alone was significant. This wasn't some remote stretch of the wilderness. It was some woods just off of the road in their own neighborhood. Whoever left Kaylee's body there knew the area. They were familiar with those streets, those woods, those shortcuts. And they were close enough to home that it didn't require a long drive or an elaborate plan to get there. That proximity weighed heavily on investigators, it suggested the person responsible wasn't a stranger. It was someone in Kaylee's life. So good, so good, so good.
- [11:02]
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Everything you want for summer is at Nordstrom Rack stores now and up to 60% off. Stock up and save on the brands you love, like Vince, Sam, Edelman, Frame and Free people. Join the Nordic to unlock exclusive discounts. Shop new arrivals first and more. Plus, buy online and pick up at your favorite Rack store for free. Great brands, great prices. That's why you rack.
- [11:28]
Katie Rang
I'm going to spare you from the most disturbing details of Kaylee's autopsy, because some of it is genuinely difficult to hear. But here's what you need to know from what the forensic investigator could determine. Kaylee's body had most likely been left out in the woods during what they described as the initial stages of decomposition. Based on the condition of the remains and weather patterns during the months of Kaylee's disappearance, the Florida summer heat, the humidity, and the frequent rain, they estimated she'd been dead for approximately six months. That timeline lined up perfectly. Kaylee first went missing in mid June, and the remains were found in mid December. Kaylee's death was determined a homicide. But here's the critical problem that would haunt the prosecution throughout the trial. They couldn't determine the actual cause of death. The remains were simply too decomposed. No trauma was evident on the bones, no fractures, no signs of blunt force, and no drugs were detected after toxicology testing on what remained of her body. That last point is actually worth pausing on, because one of the early theories in this case was that Casey had been drugging Kaylee with Xanax to go out and party with her friends, and that the fake nanny, Zenida, AKA Xanny the nanny, was actually code for Xanax. The idea was that maybe Kaylee died from an accidental overdose of Xanax, but the toxicology results didn't support that theory. Now, it's worth noting that six months of exposure to the Florida elements could have destroyed whatever chemical evidence might have been present. So a negative toxicology result didn't necessarily rule out drugs entirely, but it meant the prosecution couldn't prove that angle either. However, there was something else that investigators found on Kaylee's remains, something that would become one of the most debated pieces of evidence in the entire case. Duct tape. Three pieces of duct tape had been found on or near Caylee's skull. The autopsy report noted that they believed the tape had been placed over the lower facial region before decomposition set in, which is what kept the jaw in place even as the rest of the body broke down. And one of those pieces of tape appeared to have the outline of a heart shaped sticker on it. That's a brutal thing to think about because the duct tape on the face of a two year old is not something that happens by accident. There's no reasonable explanation for an accidental death that includes someone putting tape over a child's mouth and nose. And the heart shaped sticker residue added a layer of detail that was deeply unsettling, almost disturbingly personal. Especially because, as investigators would later discover, heart shaped stickers exactly like that were found in Casey Anthony's bedroom at the house on Hope Spring Drive. With the remains identified, the manner of death officially ruled a homicide. And the physical evidence continuing to point in Casey's direction, prosecutors made their next move. On April 13, 2009, they announced they would be seeking the death penalty, but it would take another two years before the trial actually began. Casey's initial bail had been revoked at this point, which meant she spent a significant stretch of time behind bars awaiting trial. The case generated enormous pre trial publicity, making jury selection a complicated process. Attorneys had to find people who could set aside what they'd already heard about the case and evaluate the evidence on its own merits. It took almost three years after Casey's arrest, but the trial finally kicked off on May 24, 2011, when both sides delivered their opening statements to a packed courtroom. Let's start with the prosecution's case, because they came out swinging. The prosecution painted Casey Anthony as an irresponsible party girl who showed absolutely no remorse after her daughter vanished. And they backed that characterization up with evidence of her shopping, drinking and going out to nightclubs during the month Kaylee was supposedly missing. They pointed to a tattoo Casey got during that time that said Bella Vida, meaning the good life in Italian, as proof that Casey was celebrating her newfound freedom from motherhood, not grieving a missing child. The prosecution's argument was essentially, look at how this woman behaved while her daughter was dead. Does that look like a grieving mother to you? A lot of witnesses who testified against Casey were people who had been close to her. Her ex boyfriend, Jesse Grund, who had once believed he was Kaylee's father, took the stand and spoke about Casey's behavior and her tendency to lie. Her friend Amy Huizenga, who'd helped Cindy track Casey down that July afternoon, testified about what she'd observed. Even Casey's own family was called to testify against her. Cindy's 911 calls were played in court While she was quitting. Questioned about the disappearance, Lee, Casey's brother, spoke about the smell in the car and about the night everything fell apart. And George discussed the smell of decomposition that he had noted the day they picked up the Pontiac from the tow yard. But let's talk about the hard forensic evidence because that's where the trial really became a battle. The prosecution presented the air sample results from the Pontiac's trunk showing the high concentrations of clothes chloroform and other decomposition related chemicals. Their main theory was that Casey had used chloroform to sedate Kaylee, then used duct tape to suffocate her. After that, Casey placed the body in the trunk of the car and later disposed of it in the woods near her parents home. It was a clean narrative, simple and devastating. But the defense had their own expert. A chemist testified that the primary compound in the air samples was actually gasoline. And while there was chloroform present, he argued that it could have come from a variety of cleaning products that contain bleach. He stated he could not conclusively, quote, determine that the presence of those compounds indicated that there had been human remains in the trunk of that car. In other words, the same chemical evidence the prosecution was using to prove a body had been in the trunk could just as easily have been explained by someone claiming cleaning their car with household products. The insect evidence was contested too. The prosecution's expert said the flies in the trunk indicated Kaylee's body had already started to decompose before it was placed in the car. But the defense's expert countered that they only found a few bugs on some paper towels inside of the trunk. They argued that if a body had actually been stored there, you would have expected to see hundreds of dead flies trapped inside, not just a small handful on some trash. And then there was the duct tape. The most emotionally powerful piece of evidence in the case. The prosecution argued it proved the death was a homicide and not an accident. They had an FBI latent print analyst testify about the heart shaped sticker residue found on the one piece of tape. And heart shaped stickers matching that description were recovered from Casey's bedroom. But the defense cited another expert, expert who testified they couldn't see the outline of a heart shaped sticker on the tape at all. They disputed whether the residue was even there. And to be clear, the FBI agent who testified that she saw the heart wasn't able to get a picture of the heart. It was expert against expert, test against test, interpretation against interpretation. And for the jury, that is exactly the kind of thing that starts to plant seeds of doubt. Now let's get into the defense's case because this is where things got really complicated for the entire Anthony family. Casey's lead defense attorney was Jose Baez, a lawyer who has also represented Aaron Hernandez and Harvey Weinstein and who is known for taking on high profile cases involving defendants the public has already convicted in the court of opinion. From the beginning, Baez knew that his job was not to make the jury like Casey Anthony. It was to make them doubt the prosecution's case. The defense's argument was straightforward in its logic, even if the details were messy. Casey did not kill her daughter. Instead, they said Kaylee's death was a tragic accident. One that was mishandled, covered up and spiraled out of control. But an accident at its core. Their theory was that Kaylee had accidentally drowned in the family's above ground swimming pool on the morning of June 16th, 2008 and that her body had been hidden as part of a panicked cover up with the help of Casey's father, George. That might sound like a stretch at first, but the defense had some details working in their favor. For starters, George was the last person besides Casey to see Kaylee alive. He was home with Casey on the day Kaylee disappeared. He claimed he went to work that day and records confirmed he was at the office by 3:04pm with about a 9 to 10 minute commute. So he would have left the house no later than around 2:55pm when he came home later that day, both Casey and Kaylee were gone. Those details alone don't point fingers, but they established that George had proximity in and opportunity on the day his granddaughter vanished. Then there was the pool itself. The family's above ground pool had a removable ladder. And the Anthony's knew that Kaylee absolutely loved the water. They could barely keep her out of it. The defense showed the jury a photograph of two year old Kaylee opening the sliding glass door to the backyard all by herself, demonstrating that she was physically capable of getting outside without the help of anyone. They pointed out that on June 15, the day before Kali disappeared, she'd spent time splashing around in the pool with her grandmother Cindy. That evening, the defense suggested Cindy forgot to pull up the ladder when they were done swimming. So the defense's theory was on the morning of June 16, while George and Casey were preoccupied inside the house, Kali slipped outside on her own, climbed the ladder, fell into the pool and drowned. And then Instead of calling 911, George helped Casey cover it up. The defense argued that Casey's bizarre behavior in the weeks that followed, the partying, the lies, the tattoo, wasn't the behavior of a cold blooded killer. It was the behavior of a deeply dysfunctional young woman from a deeply dysfunctional family doing what she'd been taught to do her entire life. Bury the truth and pretend everything was fine. To support this theory, the defense pointed to some deeply uncomfortable facts about George Anthony. Detectives had learned that George allegedly had a mistress, a woman the defense claimed he met during the search for Kaylee. She took the stand and testified that in private, George had told her Kaylee's death was in fact an accident that, quote, snowballed out of control. That's an incredibly specific and damaging thing for a grandfather to say in confidence. When George was asked about this on the stand, though he denied ever having an affair with the woman, he said he had only gone to her home a handful of times to console her because she had a brain tumor. Then there was George's suicide attempt. In January of 2009, about a month after Kaylee's body was found, George attempted to take his own life. Using medication and alcohol. He was discovered by the police at a motel along with a flight five page suicide note. The note is genuinely difficult to decipher. His handwriting and his thoughts both deteriorated as it went on and you can sense him becoming more and more disoriented. But in it he wrote, quote, I blame myself for her being gone. That sentence can be interpreted in a lot of different ways. A grieving grandfather might say that. A man racked with guilt over a cover up might say it too. The defense argued it was the latter, that George was consumed with guilt over his alleged involvement in hiding Kaylee's death. And then there were the abuse claims. This was perhaps the most explosive and controversial part of the entire defense strategy. According to Casey, her father had sexually abused her from the ages of 8 to 12 years old. And the defense team didn't stop there. They also suggested that Casey's brother Lee had abused her as well as. Both George and Lee denied the allegations on the stand and they continue to deny them to this day. But the defense used these claims to construct an explanation for Casey's behavior. Why she didn't report Kaylee's death, why she lied so compulsively, why she went on living as if nothing had ever happened for 31 days. They argued it was a trauma response deeply rooted in years of alleged sexual abuse that had taught Casey to suppress reality no matter what was happening beneath the Surface. Casey would later go even further. In interviews after the trial, she told reporters that George had abused Kaylee as well, and that George had killed Kaylee to cover up that alleged abuse. Those claims were never substantiated, and they remain among the most contested allegations in the entire case. It was a lot for the jury to process. The forensic evidence, the competing experts, the family dysfunction laid bare in open court, the abuse allegations, the COVID up theory, and the overarching question that hung over every single moment of this trial. Did Casey Anthony deliberately kill her daughter? Or was this a terrible accident that spiraled into an unthinkable cover up inside a family that was already broken? Casey never testified about it herself. She took her lawyer's advice and chose not to take the stand at her own trial. After nearly six weeks of testimony from dozens of witnesses, it was finally time for closing arguments. Both sides made their case one last time, and then the jury went to deliberate. What they came back with would stun the entire nation. And it's a verdict people are still arguing about to this day. At the end of each episode, I'd like to take a moment to answer any questions you may have about the case and share my thoughts. So make sure to comment below. The trial seemed like a battle of the experts. Both sides had forensic witnesses who directly contradicted each other. How does a jury make sense of that? I think this is one of the hardest things about a case like this, because when you put two credible experts on the stand and one says the chloroform proves there was a body in the trunk, and the other says it could have come from cleaning products, the jury is left in a really difficult position. They are not scientists. They're regular people being asked to evaluate competing scientific claims. And when the experts cancel each other out, what you're left with is a gut feeling and whatever else you can point to in this case, that's a dangerous place for the prosecution to be, especially in a death penalty case where the standard is beyond a reasonable doubt. And the duct tape, that feels like the one piece of evidence that's really hard to explain away, right? You would think so. I think one thing that may have hurt the prosecution on this one is that they really painted the picture of the duct tape being wrapped around her nose and mouth. But the reality of the evidence is that the duct tape was really found just hanging from her hair and on her skull. In cases like this, reasonable doubt is everything. In this instance, the defense simply said there's no evidence the tape was even on her nose or mouth, let alone used to suffocate her. Personally, I don't buy the accident by drowning story. And the duct tape being found on her gives that even more doubt. Why would you put duct tape on a child's face after them accidentally drowning? There's no logical reason to me other than the fact that they didn't call right away after an accident. The duct tape is the strongest piece of evidence suggesting that this was not an accident. What about the defense's claims that George was involved? Do you think there's anything to that? To be honest, I don't really know. On one hand, he was a former police officer. He recognized the smell in the car and didn't call anyone. He was home on the day Kaylee disappeared. And his behavior after Kaylee's body was found, the suicide attempt, and the note where he said he. He blamed himself do raise legitimate questions. In the newer documentary where he takes the polygraph test, he does definitely hesitate on the question of whether he helped her. And the guy administering the test had to probe him a few times on it. But in the end, it showed that he was telling the truth when he said he didn't help cover it up. Also, from his experience as a cop, it doesn't really make sense that he wouldn't immediately call it in if it was genuinely an accident. So that whole thing doesn't really make sense to me. But it does make sense that Casey's team wanted to spin it this way because George was really one of the prosecution star witnesses. So getting the jury to doubt or question whether he was involved in the COVID up or even involved in her death at all is very helpful for the defense. But what I will say is, personally, I think there's something about George that feels kind of off to me and I can't quite put my finger on it. To be clear, I do not buy the story Casey is now going with about how George abused Kaylee and killed her to hide the abuse. For me, maybe it was just how contradictory he was with the media and the police. He was doing all these media interviews, swearing up and down that his daughter would never do this and that it had to be an accident if she really did die. But at the same time, behind the scenes, he was the prosecution star witness for the grand jury hearing, the grand jury hearing where they were deciding if they were going to try his daughter, who he was saying he doesn't think did it, at least not on purpose for death. I'm also hesitant to really take all of the polygraph results from that one documentary at face value because it said that he was being truthful when he said he didn't cheat on Cindy. But Cindy seemed to quickly disagree with that. However, she did give the caveat that maybe he justifies it by saying that they were on a break. There was also a woman who was credible enough to testify in the trial saying that she had an affair with him. So unfortunately, I don't think we'll ever really know. Thanks so much for joining me. Come back tomorrow for our final episode on the murder of Kaylee Anthony. Make sure to rate, review and follow America's most infamous crime so we keep building this community together and to get all episodes at once. Ad free. Subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. Come back tomorrow for our final episode on the murder of Kaylee Anthony.