Aisle 52 (Brooklyn Sims)

Summary

Anatomy of Murder – Episode Summary

Episode Title: Aisle 52 (Brooklyn Sims)
Release Date: October 28, 2025
Hosts: Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi & Scott Weinberger
Guests: Bridget Jensen & Trey Myers (Pensacola District Attorney’s Office)
Case: The March 2023 murder of Brooklyn Sims at a Home Depot in Pensacola, FL

---

Overview:

This episode explores the intricate and tragic murder of 18-year-old Brooklyn Sims, shot and killed in a Pensacola Home Depot in 2023. Hosts Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi and Scott Weinberger break down how a seemingly random public shooting was quickly revealed to be a targeted killing. Through detailed interviews with the prosecutors and examination of text messages, the episode uncovers a stunning family conspiracy—the orchestration of Brooklyn’s murder not only by her ex-boyfriend, but also by his own mother. The episode exposes themes of manipulation, domestic violence, and the devastating impact of rumors and false narratives.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Shooting: Initial Chaos & Investigation

• Incident:

  • On March 30, 2023, gunshots erupted at a busy Home Depot, causing chaos as customers and staff sought cover and called 911 ([04:02]–[04:23]).
  • Police arrived to reports of an active shooter but quickly determined only one person was directly targeted: Brooklyn Sims ([06:20], [08:01]).

• Victim:

  • Brooklyn Sims, 18, had just graduated high school and was a mother to a two-year-old ([08:22]).
  • Described as a devoted daughter, mother, and friend ([08:22]–[08:52]).

• Details of Crime:

  • Brooklyn was shot at least seven times at point-blank range ([06:42]), with evidence suggesting the shooter went straight to her ([07:17]).
  • "It was clear that he was on a mission to take the life of Brooklyn Sims." – Trey Myers ([08:10]).

• Break in Case:

  • Witnesses, store surveillance, and traffic cameras helped police rapidly identify the shooter and his vehicle ([10:23]).

---

The Killer: Keith Agee

• Identification:

  • Gunman identified as Keith Agee, 20, Brooklyn’s ex-boyfriend and the father of her daughter ([10:58]–[11:18]).

• Relationship History:

  • Volatile, on-again-off-again relationship with Brooklyn. He wasn't a regular presence in their daughter's life ([11:31]–[11:48]).
  • "He played almost no role in raising her." – Scott Weinberger ([11:31]).

• Manhunt and Surrender:

  • Agee dumped his weapon by the roadside and then, feeling lost, called 911 to surrender ([13:03], [15:23], [17:06]).
  • Notable moment: Tension during his surrender at a crowded movie theater, with officers concerned about possible "suicide by cop" scenario ([16:37]–[17:06]).
  • "He placed his cell phone on the ground. He didn't have anything in his hands. I believe he took his shirt off as well in an effort to make sure that they did not shoot him." – Trey Myers ([17:18])

---

Motive: Rumors, Jealousy, and a Mother’s Influence

• Superficial Motive:

  • Agee believed Brooklyn had given him an STD—a rumor that turned out to be false ([21:04], [30:17]).
  • "Keith Agee, we found out later, actually did not get an STD from Brooklyn. Brooklyn tested negative." – Bridget Jensen ([30:17]).

• Deeper Manipulation:

  • Examination of Agee’s phone revealed a string of texts with his mother, Sheila Agee, stoking anger and fueling the plan ([20:19]–[22:14]).
  • "Her text messages encouraged her son to not just confront Brooklyn, but to take his revenge." – Anasiga Nicolasi ([22:34]).

• Sheila Agee’s Role:

  • Sheila, Brooklyn’s supervisor, suggested Keith commit the murder at Brooklyn’s workplace and sent him the exact address ([23:51]).
  • Sheila was present on-site during the murder.

• Effort to Avoid Blame:

  • Sheila initially denied and tried to deflect responsibility in interviews; later evidence (including her wiping text messages) indicated deliberate cover-up ([24:51]–[26:39]).
  • When confronted:
    "What was interesting is when they received her phone and did a download on her phone, she had deleted that whole conversation." – Bridget Jensen ([26:32]) "Police were facing one of the strangest family dramas they'd ever seen. A mother and her own son pointing fingers at each other." – Scott Weinberger ([27:29])

• Text Exchanges (Paraphrased/Quoted):

  • Sheila belittled and pressured Keith, called him names, told him not to worry about his child, and provided Brooklyn’s location ([22:41]–[23:51], [29:15]):
    • "She was calling him names, telling him if he didn’t come do it, he was an MF bitch..." – Trey Myers ([22:41])
    • "You basically put these things in motion... you set that girl up to be killed." – Scott Weinberger to Sheila ([29:54])

---

Legal Proceedings: The Case and Trials

• Evidence:

  • Security footage, DNA on weapon, witness testimony, and the damning text messages were the backbone of both prosecutions ([31:12]–[33:45]).

• Keith Agee’s Defense:

  • At trial, Keith admitted to the killing but claimed he "snapped" in the moment, minimizing claims of premeditation ([34:05]–[35:04]):

    • "I was enraged until I arrived on aisle 52. When I got to aisle 52, seeing Brooklyn, all sort of a sense to... brought me back down to earth." – Keith Agee ([34:18])

  • Prosecutors pointed out the planning and Sheila’s persistent encouragement ([35:26]):

    • "This man started talking about killing Brooklyn almost two hours prior... If that’s not premeditation, I don’t know what is." – Trey Myers ([35:26])

• Outcomes:

  • Keith Agee convicted of first-degree premeditated murder ([37:10]).
  • First trial of Sheila Agee ended in a mistrial due to a distracted juror ([38:29]–[39:12]).
  • Second trial: Sheila found guilty of first-degree murder (as principal to murder), both she and Keith sentenced to life without parole ([40:41], [41:05]).

---

Aftermath & Reflection

• Impact:

  • Brooklyn’s death orphaned her daughter, now raised by Brooklyn’s family ([41:22]–[41:55]).
  • Both families destroyed—a promising young woman lost, her killer and his mother incarcerated for life ([41:22]–[41:42]).

• Memorable Insight:

  • "A single false story, one built on emotion, jealousy and misinformation, can take control of everything... a rumor became motive. A lie became lethal." – Scott Weinberger ([42:33])

• Domestic Violence Awareness:

  • The family released balloons for Brooklyn in her memory and to highlight how rapidly domestic violence can escalate ([43:28]).
  • Episode released during Domestic Violence Awareness Month.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Sheila’s Role:

  • "She did everything short of putting a gun in his hand." – Scott Weinberger ([23:02])
  • "You set that girl up to be killed." – Scott Weinberger to Sheila ([29:58])
  • "Keith Agee used a gun. Sheila Agee used her words as an equally powerful and destructive weapon." – Anasiga Nicolasi ([43:28])

• On Narrative Control:

  • "What happened to Brooklyn Sims... shows how a single false story, one built on emotion, jealousy and misinformation, can take control of everything." – Scott Weinberger ([42:33])

• On the Aftermath:

  • "This little girl does not have either one of her parents." – Trey Myers ([41:55])

• On Premeditation:

  • "If that’s not premeditation, I don’t know what is." – Trey Myers ([35:26])
  • "The content is sickening in its ruthlessness to read." – Anasiga Nicolasi ([43:28])

---

Timestamps for Critical Segments

• The Shooting & Police Response: [03:56]–[08:22]
• Identification of Keith Agee: [10:58]–[11:18]
• Keith’s Surrender: [13:03], [15:23]–[17:18]
• Mother’s Manipulation Revealed (Texts): [20:19]–[23:51], [29:15]–[29:58]
• Legal Proceedings/Evidence: [31:12]–[33:45]
• Keith’s Testimony/Claim of Heat of Passion: [34:05]–[35:04]
• Sheila’s Trials/Mistrial Detail: [38:29]–[39:12], [40:49]
• Sentencing and Family Impact: [41:05]–[41:55]
• Domestic Violence Reflection & Narrative Control: [42:33]–[43:28]

---

Concluding Thoughts

Themes:

• The psychological and emotional factors driving a targeted killing.
• How “narrative control”—a false rumor, toxic family influence, and lack of intervention—can escalate a volatile situation to murder.
• The enduring damage left on families and communities when violence erupts from jealousy, misunderstanding, and manipulation.

Final Reflection:
Brooklyn Sims’s tragic murder illustrates how words and actions—especially when fueled by rumors and reinforced by those we trust—can lead to devastating consequences. The episode serves as a call to recognize the warning signs of domestic violence and the vital role of truth in preventing escalation.

---

For more: The hosts provide a link to specific text exchanges and the prosecution’s closing argument on the AOM website, highlighting the ruthless, calculated nature of the crime.

Transcript

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Every mystery has an answer, but some have way more than one possibility. I'm Yvette Gentile. And I'm her sister Racha Pecorero. Every week on our podcast so Supernatural, we invite you to explore the unknown and to consider the many theories behind each unsolved mystery. We'll guide you as you question the world you think you know through investigations into spine chilling hauntings, unexplainable encounters, strange disappearances, and so much more. So if you're ready to be haunted by stories of the unsolved and of the unknown, listen if you dare to sew Supernatural every Friday wherever you get your podcasts, it's the big Sale of the year at Allmodern, a wayfair specialty brand, October 26th through the 29th. Save up to 70% off modern furniture and decor, plus fast and free shipping. Shop the big sale of the [e-mail] they say if you want to go fast, go alone. But if you want to go far, go together. At Amica Insurance, we know what matters most to you, and we work even harder to protect it together. As a mutual insurance company, we're built for our customers and prioritize your needs. Amica empathy is our best policy. Visit amica.com and get a quote. Today, when a cold has you down, it's the little comforts that lift you up. A warm blanket, a cup of tea, and a tissue that actually feels good on your skin. Infused with aloe Kleenex Cooling plus Aloe provides a hint of cooling freshness to help your skin feel restored. So whether your skin is feeling dry, chafed or irritated, you're only one wipe away from helping it feel relieved. The next time you have a cold, get a hint of instant cooling relief with new Kleenex Cooling plus Aloe. For whatever happens next, grab Kleenex.

[Scott Weinberger]

Let me ask you this while we're.

[Bridget Jensen]

Here, why on earth would you send him that address?

[Scott Weinberger]

He had no idea where that girl was.

[Bridget Jensen]

If it hadn't been for you sending.

[Scott Weinberger]

That address, you basically put this these things in motion.

[Bridget Jensen]

Look, you sit here and tell me.

[Scott Weinberger]

That you love Brooklyn, but you set that girl up to be killed. I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

I'm Anasiga Nicolasi, former New York City Homicide prosecutor and host of Investigation Discovery's True Conviction.

[Scott Weinberger]

And this is Anatomy of Murder.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Unfortunately, one of the awful and tragic truths about modern life today is the increasing number of indiscriminate deadly assaults in public spaces.

[Scott Weinberger]

A mass shooting is defined as an attack on multiple people over a short period of time, often occurring where unsuspected citizens gather in a public park, at a workplace where or house of worship, or most tragically, in a school.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

The increasing number of gun deaths from mass shootings is undeniably an epidemic in this country that seems to show no signs of abating. But we'll leave that discussion of the causes and possible solutions for another time.

[Scott Weinberger]

Today we'd like to talk about an incident in Pensacola, Florida, that had all of the markings of yet another deadly public attack. That is, until police discovered evidence that the shooting at a local Home Depot may not have been what it initially seemed.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Skimmy. County Sheriff911, this is Andrea.

[Scott Weinberger]

Where is your emergency?

[Bridget Jensen]

Home Depot on Davis Highway.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

What's going on?

[Bridget Jensen]

I got an active shooter in the store.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

At approximately 1:30pm on the afternoon of March 30, 2020, three, customers at a crowded Home Depot suddenly found themselves confronting one of their worst fears. The an active shooter inside the building and the unmistakable sound of gunshots.

[Scott Weinberger]

Customers screamed and ran for cover while employees attempted to lead people to safety. You could hear the panic in their voices as several customers managed to find safety and dial 911.

[Bridget Jensen]

You gotta run, hide, fight.

[Scott Weinberger]

You saw him leave.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Is anybody injured? Yes, there's a victim on R52's hey, lock the door.

[Bridget Jensen]

Lock the door. They said the shooter ran.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

I don't have a description.

[Bridget Jensen]

Turn this off and close the door lock.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Police from the surrounding area rushed to the scene with very little information about the scale of the threat or potential casualties. Sadly, it was something local law enforcement had trained for. But this was not a drill.

[Trey Myers]

When the call went out as an active shooter, it basically became an all hands on deck. There were a number of agencies that responded from the area. We had the Pensacola Police Department, we had the Escambia County Sheriff's Office. I believe highway patrol also responded.

[Scott Weinberger]

Joining us today are two veterans of the Pensacola District Attorney's office, Bridget Jensen and Trey Myers, who are going to walk us through what I can only imagine must have begun as a community's worst nightmare.

[Trey Myers]

When law enforcement arrived, it was. It was chaos. There were employees and customers from the Home Depot that were running out into the parking lot. They were running to their cars. I mean, literally, people were just freaking out thinking that there was an active shooter inside the store.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Deputies from the Escambia County Sheriff's Office were the first to arrive. Witnesses reported hearing as many as 10 gunshots. But at this point, police still had no idea how many people may have been hurt or if the shooter was still in the building, Trained to put.

[Scott Weinberger]

Themselves in harm's way, officers entered the store. According to some witnesses, the shooter had fled, but not before his attack claimed the life of at least one victim.

[Bridget Jensen]

When officers entered the Home Depot, they were directed to aisle 52 in the lighting section where there was one gunshot victim, a female, lying on the floor. And that's where they located Brooklyn Sims.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

18 year old Brooklyn Sims had suffered multiple gunshot wounds and had likely died within seconds of being struck.

[Trey Myers]

She was shot at least seven times. And the reason we say at least seven times is because that's how many casings were found at the Home Depot. There could have been more.

[Scott Weinberger]

Let me take a moment to talk about Brooklyn's injuries. She was shot at point blank range multiple times to her face and chest. And evidence would point to the fact that Brooklyn was facing her killer at the time she was shot. And there was also other victims as well. Some were struck by ricochet or flying debris. But incredibly, it seemed that no one else in the store had been seriously injured.

[Trey Myers]

There certainly could have been a number of victims during the course of this shooting. There were employees that were on the same aisle as Brooklyn Sims when she was shot. However, the shooter immediately, immediately went directly to her and fired shots directly at her. We thought a couple of the other employees had been grazed by some of the bullets, but it was an absolute miracle that no one else was harmed or killed.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

After securing the scene and tending to the injured, officers began to gather as much information as they could from witnesses at the store. And pretty soon it became clear that despite the chaos and terror that the shooting caused, the shots fired all seemed to be directed at just one person, Brooklyn.

[Scott Weinberger]

Which meant that this may not have been an indiscriminate shooting at all. This attack may have been targeted and personal.

[Trey Myers]

Certainly when you have an individual go into a store in broad daylight, in front of everybody and go directly to a person, it was clear that he was on a mission to take the life of Brooklyn Sims.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

A life that had changed, just gotten started. Brooklyn, a recent high school graduate and the young mother of a two year old daughter, was described by her friends as the kind of person who lit up a room. A devoted mom and friend with nothing but joy in her heart. An unlikelier target for violence you would not find.

[Trey Myers]

She was working for a inventory company that provided services to Home Depots in a particular area in Alabama, I believe, and also some certain areas of Florida.

[Bridget Jensen]

She seemed to be hard working and trying to get her life Together and take care of this child.

[Scott Weinberger]

Brooklyn was working that morning, stocking shelves, trying to earn enough money to keep food on the table for herself and her daughter. Tragically, she would never make it home for dinner. Now it was law enforcement's job to find out who was responsible.

[Bridget Jensen]

The investigation moved relatively quickly. While they were on scene there, they got a description of the vehicle that may have been used. The police officers were notified and a bulletin was placed for trying to locate that vehicle. There were also statements by numerous employees describing what the shooter looked like. There was also video surveillance that was obtained while on scene there.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Detectives also accessed the store's video security system, pulling footage from multiple cameras inside and outside the store.

[Bridget Jensen]

The security video from the Home Depot was obviously of good quality. It showed the shooter entering the Home Depot. It showed the shooter go to the lighting section. However, the video does not shoot down the aisle, so the actual shooting was not caught on camera.

[Scott Weinberger]

The footage seemed to corroborate many of the witness statements that the male gunman entered through the front door, fired multiple shots from a handgun, and then fled the scene back through the front door and into the parking lot, into a parked car.

[Trey Myers]

From the video surveillance, they obviously had a description of what the shooter looked like because he came in, went immediately to the lighting aisle, fired shots, and then immediately ran out. And he was in his work attire. I mean, he had a fluorescent like work jacket on. So they were able to get a good description of him pretty quickly. And so at that point, they were just on the hunt for him and the car that he had driven there in.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

A description of the gunman's car was broadcast to surrounding law enforcement agencies. And thanks to traffic cameras and those automated license plate readers, it wasn't long before police had a name.

[Scott Weinberger]

The vehicle owner and the gunman seen shooting Brooklyn Sims was a 20 year old Alabama man named Keith Agee. He had a very personal connection to his victim.

[Bridget Jensen]

Keith Agee was the father of the child shared between he and Brooklyn Sims.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Brooklyn's suspected killer was her own child's father, confirming what police already suspected, that this terrifying and deadly attack in a public space was actually targeted and very personal.

[Scott Weinberger]

According to Brooklyn's family, AG and Brooklyn had an on again, off again relationship for the last several years. Years. And while he was the father of her daughter, he played almost no role in raising her. But he was not totally out of Brooklyn's life.

[Bridget Jensen]

Looking into the background of Keith Agee and Brooklyn Sims, it came to light that they had somewhat of a volatile relationship. I believe there was a restraining order between Keith Agee and Brooklyn's mother. At some point we learned that they did not live together on a consistent basis, but that they were still in communication with each other.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

But what could have possibly led Agee to kill the mother of his child was a total mystery. According to police reports, he was not a career criminal and had no history of violence. And yet on that day he had showed the savagery of the most cold blooded killer.

[Scott Weinberger]

He was on the run, armed, dangerous and obviously a huge risk to public safety. So police were in a race against time to get him in custody.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

The shooting took place in Pensacola, Florida and AG lived across the nearby border in Alabama. So the multi state manhunt would have its complications.

[Trey Myers]

There was, I believe a law enforcement officer that actually spotted a firearm on the side of the road, so they were able to locate that relatively quickly.

[Scott Weinberger]

Their luck continued when law enforcement got another assistant from an unlikely source. AG himself.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Tentacle One on one where's your emergency? I'm trying to turn myself in. What are you trying to turn yourself in for? Oh man, I'm an earth. I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know. It's the big sale of the year at All Modern a Wayfair specialty brand. October 26th through the 29th. Save up to 70% off Modern furniture and decor plus fast and free shipping shop. The big sale of the [e-mail].

[Scott Weinberger]

What does the future hold for business? Ask nine experts and you'll get 10 answers. It's a bull market. It's a bear market. Rates will rise or fall, inflation up or down. Can somebody just invent a crystal ball? Until then, over 43,000 businesses have future proof their business with NetSuite by Oracle. The number one AI Cloud ERP. Bringing accounting, financial management, inventory and HR into one fluid platform with one unified business management suite. There's one source of truth giving you the visibility and control you need to make quick decisions. When you're closing the books in days, not weeks, you you're spending less time looking backwards and more time on what's next. Download the CFO's guide to AI and machine learning for free at netsuite.com AOM that's netsuite.com AOM netsuite.com AOM In March of 2023, a brazen daytime shooting in a Pensacola Home Depot claimed the life of 18 year old Brooklyn Sims. The suspect, a 20 year old man named Keith Agee, an ex boyfriend of the Victim and the father of her two year old daughter.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Armed with the description of A.G. and his car, police initiated a massive manhunt. One that was over before it really began.

[Trey Myers]

And then what helped us was the shooter actually called 911 to turn himself in.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

What are you trying to turn yourself in for? I made a mistake. I don't know, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know.

[Trey Myers]

When Keith Agee called 911, he told them that he was at a movie theater and that he wasn't armed. I think he had a concern that police were gonna respond and shoot him.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Look, I threw my gun.

[Bridget Jensen]

I don't have a gun, but I.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Just want them to shoot me.

[Bridget Jensen]

I can't. I can't.

[Scott Weinberger]

So being an officer who's responded to these types of calls, you're already on a heightened state of alert. The subject who is currently admitting to committing a murder and wanting to turn himself in, that doesn't happen every day. But you can't take what they say at face value. And two things to consider here, he may actually be armed and wants to engage with you in something known as suicide by cop. And is also, you have to consider he's calling from a public location which here is a theater, which is probably crowded. And as the officer responding, you have to think about your backdrop. Meaning if you end up engaging in some type of gun battle, innocent people could be hurt. So to say this is a tense situation may be a bit of an understatement. Anasega. So it's important to understand how and what you're going into.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And I think it's like a really good point because I think you said it perfectly. It's like you can't take it at face value. It could be legitimate, it could be, by the way, a hoax. They don't know what this is. Or it could be again, luring police in because, you know, unfortunately it's not so uncommon. I think those of us that have worked these cases for a long time have seen multiple that if they're going to go down, they want to bring law enforcement with them to make them somewhat a martyr of sorts with others. So police definitely had to be careful as they arrived.

[Scott Weinberger]

So within minutes of AG's call, deputies had swarmed the movie theater parking lot where they found AG already on the ground and, and he was ready to surrender to police.

[Trey Myers]

He placed his cell phone on the ground. He didn't have anything in his hands. I believe he took his shirt off as well in an effort to make sure that they did not shoot him.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

So there are at least two reasons that quickly come to mind about why someone might surrender like this so soon after the murder. One, that here, Keith Agee really felt guilty about what he had just done, which definitely is possible and does happen after some homicides.

[Scott Weinberger]

And I'll throw in number two here on Sega. He realized that shooting someone in a public place in broad daylight was a really bad way to get away with murder. And it was only a matter of time before he got caught, in which case, it was not remorse as much as it was self preservation.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And you could hear that in his voice on that 911 call. He told them he was unarmed. He tossed his gun on the side of the road. So he's clearly most concerned at this point by what he's saying with not getting shot by police. And you don't have any weapons on you now. You said you threw your gun. My gun's in the street. I threw it way back there when I left.

[Trey Myers]

I don't think the 911 call was in response to any feelings of guilt whatsoever. I believe it was more so that he had no idea where he was in Pensacola. He wasn't familiar with the area. He had dumped his car and taken off running. He went through some water and then just ended up at a movie theater. So I think at that point, he had nowhere else to go, and he knew that he was going to be caught, so he called 911.

[Scott Weinberger]

So AG was taken into custody with that incident and transported to the Escambia County Sheriff's Office for questioning. And that interview was recorded on video. We're going to play you some of those parts right here. Before we ask any questions, could you.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Mind if I get your first name.

[Trey Myers]

So I know who I'm talking with?

[Scott Weinberger]

Listen, what's happened?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

This happened, okay?

[Scott Weinberger]

We can't go back now.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

All right? What we can try to do is.

[Scott Weinberger]

Yeah, go on. This thing will help us understand. We want to understand.

[Bridget Jensen]

It doesn't matter.

[Scott Weinberger]

Yes, it does. It does, too, because I don't want to be talking to a stranger.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Nobody cares.

[Trey Myers]

When Keith Agee was taken into custody by the sheriff's office, he gave an interview after he was read Miranda rights and basically confessed to the entire situation, acknowledged that he went inside to kill Brooklyn Sims.

[Bridget Jensen]

Will you be real with me?

[Scott Weinberger]

Absolutely. Go ahead.

[Bridget Jensen]

Is she still alive?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

No, she's dead. In the taped interview, Ag is visibly upset and can be heard crying as he admitted to several things that he was the father of Brooklyn's daughter and that it was a recent argument that had caused him to drive to Florida to confront Brooklyn, where she worked.

[Scott Weinberger]

But the disagreements AG described, they didn't seem to add up to a motive for murder. AG's grievances, they sounded more like those of a jilted ex boyfriend, not someone angry enough to kill. Investigators were sure that there had to be something more. And as it turns out, there was.

[Bridget Jensen]

When Keith Agee was arrested, a cell phone was found on the ground where he was located. Police took the cell phone, applied for a warrant, and did a download on that cell phone which enabled them to locate and read his text messages.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And those messages were very telling because they showed extensive communications in the hours leading up to the murder, not with Brooklyn, but with another woman. And that woman, Agee's own mother, Sheila Agee.

[Bridget Jensen]

After the detectives received the download of the cell phone from Keith Agee, they were able to read text messages between himself and his mother. Those text messages revealed what we call a motive or why he did it.

[Scott Weinberger]

So what was the motive? It seemed to stem from Keith Agee's suspicion that despite being broken up, Brooklyn had started seeing another man.

[Bridget Jensen]

The detectives were able to learn that the defendant, Keith Agee, or the shooter, was texting his mother about Brooklyn giving him an std, or what he believed was Brooklyn giving him an std.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Brooklyn knew that wasn't true and decided it was in her best interest to make their on again, off again breakup more permanent. But if you listen to Agee's interview with police, it's clear that this latest fight did not fill him with homicidal rage. In fact, from the way he spoke, he admitted to being more sad than angry.

[Bridget Jensen]

I didn't get a chance to fix him. Every time we break up and something.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Like that would happen, I just leave and, you know, I got it.

[Bridget Jensen]

Stop us from, you know, taking it any further because you that mad, you don't want to put your hands on somebody.

[Scott Weinberger]

But Keith Agee's mother, Sheila, she was a different story. In her texts to her son. She seemed determined to stoke his anger and his jealousy.

[Trey Myers]

The text messages that we saw between Keith AG and his mother were pretty shocking, to be honest with you. This was a son who was very upset about what he believed the mother of his child had given him. And his mother, Sheila AG did not do anything to calm him down.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

In fact, her text messages encouraged her son to not just confront Brooklyn, but to take his revenge.

[Trey Myers]

She was calling him names, telling him that if he didn't come do it, he was An MF bitch. She was saying not to worry that someone would take care of his small child. She was providing him information as to where Brooklyn Sims was located. They were shocking that this was the advice that a mother was giving to her son.

[Scott Weinberger]

Faced with an opportunity to calm Keith and keep him and briefly Brooklyn out of danger, Sheila Agee instead bullied her own son into a murderous rage. But she didn't just stoke his anger. She did everything short of putting a gun in his hand, including telling her son exactly where Brooklyn would be on the day of her murder.

[Bridget Jensen]

Sheila AG Also worked for the same company as Brooklyn Sims doing inventory. She was, in fact, her supervisor, and they were both working at the Home Depot in Pensacola on that day.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

In one of the most shocking exchanges, Sheila Agee even suggested that he should do it while Brooklyn was at work to spare their daughter the sight of her own mother being killed on the.

[Bridget Jensen]

Day of the homicide. Sheila Agee was the one to suggest Keith Agee come to Pensacola and commit the homicide here to kill her here in Pensacola. She then sent him a screenshot showing the exact address of where they were working that day. Without that, Keith had no idea where they were.

[Scott Weinberger]

The text exchange painted a picture not just of a conspiracy to commit murder, but a manipulation of a son by his own mother, who, I will point out, was actually at the Home Depot when her son arrived with a gun and a plan.

[Bridget Jensen]

When investigators went to interview Sheila Agee, they interviewed her and confronted her with those text messages and even told her that what her son had said and that he was honest and forthcoming, and she still denied it.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Sheila Agee did agree to cooperate, at least by giving investigators a statement, but it was clear that her goal was to downplay what those text messages really meant.

[Scott Weinberger]

So what was your involvement in what happened on Friday?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

My involvement in what happened? My only involvement in what happened was Keith text my phone. He said that he was gonna. Things come back thinking Brooklyn gave me something, but he was gonna let it go, and that's fine. I told Brooklyn, I said, crazy's Texan.

[Bridget Jensen]

What'd you call him?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Crazy. Okay, I'm sorry, but I said crazy Texan. And she wasn't above blaming her own son, too, as she tried to distance herself from any responsibility for the. And then I went to telling him, look, you're gonna do this to Casey and this. Listen, you'll leave her without a mom and a dad and this and this and this, this. And he was like, I don't care. Things like, I don't have nothing to live for or whatever. I was like, so you hate Brooklyn that bad that you believe Casey to be molested or abused? Or. I said, because she won't have her mom or dad or whatever. He's like, I think it cussed me or something.

[Trey Myers]

And actually she initially tried to blame them on the victim, Brooklyn Sims. She made comments to law enforcement that she actually gave her cell phone to Brooklyn and that Brooklyn probably sent those. So she was initially trying to blame the victim for her own death.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

She said, let me see the phone. I said, okay. So I gave her the phone back. And then whenever I got the phone back, she had linked the message or something. And then they said, well, when I went in the bathroom, that's when she gave me the phone. But the guy that's out there on the floor, a couple of guys said that she was texting. They ain't saying she was texting him, but she was texting somebody. That's what they said. I'm not sure. And when she gave me the phone back, I just took the phone back and went back to work.

[Bridget Jensen]

What was interesting is when they received her phone and did a download on her phone, she had deleted that whole conversation.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

From the perspective of investigators, the fact that she had deleted all those conversations she'd had with her son about Brooklyn showed not just consciousness of guilt, but a clear effort to cover up her crime.

[Bridget Jensen]

I believe she knew those text messages were damning for her and she needed to get rid of the evidence, and she attempted to do so. She even told her son to delete his phone, but he never did.

[Scott Weinberger]

Would it surprise you to find out.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

That the text messages on Keith's phone.

[Scott Weinberger]

Weren'T deleted between you and him that day?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Between me and him, I mean, I wouldn't surprise you.

[Bridget Jensen]

Okay.

[Scott Weinberger]

Would it surprise you that I have 32 pages of yalls text messages?

[Bridget Jensen]

Sure.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

That wouldn't surprise you.

[Bridget Jensen]

Okay.

[Scott Weinberger]

Do you want me to read some of those?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

You can. I mean, you can if you want to, sir.

[Scott Weinberger]

Police were facing one of the strangest family dramas they'd ever seen. A mother and her own son pointing fingers at each other. It would take not one, but three high stakes trials to finally uncover the truth behind the murder of Brooklyn Sims.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Have you met Allmodern? Allmodern brings you the best of modern furniture and decor all in one place. Save up to 70% during their big sale of the year. Update your space with modern dining tables, chairs and more. All on sale at Allmodern, a Wayfair specialty brand. Plus get fast and free delivery. That's Modern made simple. Shop the big sale of the year, October 26th through 29th, [e-mail] Want the same expert advice from the pros at a discount tire store while shopping for tires online. Meet Treadwell, your personal tire guide. Treadwell is an online tire buying guide that gives you personalized recommendations. Shop for tires with [e-mail].

[Scott Weinberger]

So Key's intention was to shoot Brooklyn, and then.

[Bridget Jensen]

When the Citro police showed up, he.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Was going to shoot at them so that they could kill him.

[Scott Weinberger]

That's what Keith intentions were up until he said he was leaving work. And you said in a text message, about to leave work.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

That's up to you. A text exchange between mother and son had revealed a dark plot to kill Brooklyn Sims. Listen as the detective reads back some of the most damning texts found on Keith Agee's phone.

[Scott Weinberger]

And I have to drag her out or can't. I'm going to ask you to step out because I'm going to open the door and just shoot her. As long as you don't shoot me.

[Bridget Jensen]

But I know you got work.

[Scott Weinberger]

Just don't forget me this evening. Hell, if you're getting off right now, I'll give you the address here. You send a screenshot of the address of the address from your work.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

I did.

[Scott Weinberger]

So you acknowledge the sending the address?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Yes, sir, I did.

[Scott Weinberger]

Let me ask you this while we're here.

[Bridget Jensen]

Why on earth would you send him that address?

[Scott Weinberger]

He had no idea where that girl was. If it hadn't been for you sending that address, You.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

You.

[Scott Weinberger]

You basically put this. These things. You sit.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Look, you sit here and tell me.

[Scott Weinberger]

That you love Brooklyn, but you set that girl up to be killed despite her denials that she had in fact put the plan into motion. Sheila A.G. was arrested and charged with first degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder. Her son Keith was also charged with first degree murder.

[Bridget Jensen]

The reason why Keith Agee committed this crime always seemed senseless. He committed a crime for what in his mind was something that a shot of penicillin could have cured. Keith Agee, we found out later, actually did not get an STD from Brooklyn. Brooklyn tested negative for an std. So even in his mind, if it was valid, in reality, it was not.

[Scott Weinberger]

The truth is that the real motive may not have been Keith Agee's at all. Prosecutors believed it may have been Sheila's idea for Keith to take revenge. And if you follow the chain of texts, it is clear that Sheila Agee had so many opportunities to calm her Son down.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

You almost get the feeling that Keith was not really convinced that killing Brooklyn at that moment was what he really wanted to do. But it seems like his mother's encouraging, almost coercing him into taking action.

[Scott Weinberger]

Now, there was a good amount of evidence to corroborate Keith Agee's confession and prove he was indeed the killer. Security cameras and phone location data verified his movements on the day.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Multiple witnesses also placed him at the scene, entering the Home Depot, walking to aisle 52, and firing at least seven bullets into Brooklyn's body with the gun he later threw out the window as he fled.

[Bridget Jensen]

Keith Agee's DNA was located on the firearm that was recovered on the side of the road. The ballistics from that firearm match the shell casings and projectiles found at the Home Depot, as well as the projectiles located in Brooklyn Sims during her autopsy.

[Trey Myers]

We felt like Keith Agee's case was obviously very strong for the state. We had video surveillance, we had DNA, we had the firearm, we had a confession. But when it came to Sheila Ag, we definitely had some concerns on whether a jury of 12 people was going to convict the non shooter, pretty much based on text messages alone.

[Scott Weinberger]

Keith Agee went to trial in December of 2023, and while the case against him seemed pretty, pretty cut and dry, it still would not be easy, especially for the family of the victim. Brooklyn Sims.

[Bridget Jensen]

Anytime we are getting ready for trial, we like to meet with the victim's families to go over the evidence that we anticipate showing. That way, they're not seeing it for the first time in court. We don't want any kind of emotional outbreak or outbreak from the victim's family in front of a jury, because a jury's not supposed to be swayed by emotions. And so we did that in this case, and we brought in Brooklyn's family, showed them photos and videos from the crime scene and also from the autopsy.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

It was just one of the many painful experiences the family would have to endure as the prosecutors walked the jury through the crime one step at a time.

[Scott Weinberger]

The jurors would see the full surveillance video which captured Keith Agee entering the store, approaching the aisle where he killed Brooklyn, and quickly fled the scene.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And there was forensic evidence, too.

[Bridget Jensen]

Keith Agee's DNA was located on the firearm that was recovered on the side of the road. The ballistics from that firearm match the shell casings and projectiles found at the Home Depot, as well as the projectiles located in Brooklyn Sims.

[Scott Weinberger]

During her autopsy, Keith Agee testified in his defense. But while he Admitted to killing Brooklyn. He claimed it was all in the heat of the moment and that a killing was not meticulously planned, as prosecutors alleged. Well, I'm gonna quit beating around the bush now.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

You killed Brooklyn Steps? Yes, sir.

[Scott Weinberger]

When you arrived at the Home Depot, was it sure. Until intention.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

To shoot Brooklyn?

[Bridget Jensen]

Not fully.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And what I mean by that is, I was enraged until I arrived on aisle 52. When I got to aisle 52, seeing Brooklyn, all sort of a sense to.

[Bridget Jensen]

Me brought me back down to earth.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

You know, being high hot the whole way there, driving mad. Seeing her kind of brought me back down to earth.

[Bridget Jensen]

The biggest thing I remember from Keith Agee testifying is that he tried to say he was not coming to kill her. He was trying to minimize the premeditation and that he only decided to shoot her and kill her. When he confronted her, and she said something to the effect of not you again, and turned her back on him, he says that's when he shot her.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

In other words, AG was claiming that he just snapped, that the murder was committed in the heat of the the moment with no premeditation, and happened in a moment of instant rage. And the reason for that, that you would say something like that at trial as a defense, would be to lessen the degree of crime and also potentially the sentence if convicted.

[Scott Weinberger]

But that was an argument prosecutors weren't buying.

[Trey Myers]

In this case specifically, I think premeditation was absolutely clear. This man started talking about killing Brooklyn almost two hours prior to the homicide. He left his work. He went to his grandma's home, got a gun. He then drove an hour and a half to two hours to Pensacola, Florida, went directly in the store, and shot and killed Brooklyn Sims. So if that's not premeditation, I don't know what is.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

It would be up to the jury to decide who to believe. And there were some factors that Bridget feared could complicate their decision.

[Trey Myers]

The only concern I really had with Keith Agee's trial is the fact that he was so young. And then when he testified, he came across very sympathetic. I mean, Trey and I met with him on several occasions, and he was always very respectful, very polite. And we were worried that that might come across to the jury and that they would do a lesser included offense.

[Bridget Jensen]

I had no concern whether the jury would convict Keith Agee of killing Brooklyn Sims. The only concern or question was to what degree the jury would find. Would it be first degree or would it be second degree?

[Scott Weinberger]

There was also concern that the jury's anger at Sheila Agee and her malicious Influence on her own son might also contribute to their sympathy for the actual killer.

[Trey Myers]

Like I said, Keith Agee came across as kind of sympathetic. But Sheila Agee, I thought jurors would dislike, even though she wasn't the shooter, just because this was a mother that was speaking to her son in the way that she did and encouraging him and just egging him on to come commit this horrible crime.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

In the end, the jury found Keith Agee guilty of first degree premeditated murder. Next on trial would be his mother, Sheila Agee.

[Trey Myers]

The defense attorney did file some pretrial motions in an effort to keep some of the text messages out. We had a hearing on that. Obviously, we presented case law in support of our position, and the judge denied his motion.

[Scott Weinberger]

And in her testimony, Sheila Agee denied helping her son plan the murder or egging him on towards violence.

[Trey Myers]

She was certainly trying to act like she did not believe he was really going to come all the way to the home depot and shoot and kill the mother of his child. She said, you know, that was just the way she talked, and she didn't mean anything by it. And she was basically, you know, just telling him he was stupid, and she was trying to dissuade him from doing it. But the one thing she couldn't get away from was the fact that she sent the address to where Brooklyn was.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Located, and the fact that at no time did she warn Brooklyn that her son was on his way and that he was armed with a gun. Well, that certainly didn't seem the actions of someone who loved Brooklyn. As Sheila had said in her statement.

[Scott Weinberger]

To police, the case against Sheila Agee was solid, but the attention of one of the jurors proved to be considerably less so.

[Trey Myers]

Well, when Trey was questioning a witness, I was actually sitting relatively close to this juror, and I could hear some kind of paper rustling. And I looked over, and I thought she was doing a crossword puzzle. So I asked our legal assistant, who was directly behind, behind me, to kind of keep an eye and see if that was what she saw. And, of course, we learned that that was, in fact, true. Then we were told during the course of deliberations that she was again doing crossword puzzles after the judge had instructed her not to do that. So that is what ultimately led to the mistrial.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

The judge's decision to declare a mistrial and then dismiss the jury was a huge blow to prosecutors, who had presented a powerful and likely very persuasive case.

[Bridget Jensen]

Obviously, with all the work that it takes and the preparation and the coordination of Witnesses and schedules. Getting a case to trial is extremely difficult. And so when we have a mistrial, for whatever reason, it's always kind of disheartening because, you know, with all that work, you're going to have to do it all over again.

[Trey Myers]

I agree with everything he just said. My heart also went out to Brooklyn's family because we knew that they'd already been through Keith's trial. We were trying to give them some finality with Sheila's trial and the fact that we were going to have to do it all over again. I felt very sad for the family of Brooklyn simes.

[Scott Weinberger]

Sheila Agee's second trial began in July of 2024. It was as open and shut as it gets.

[Bridget Jensen]

Trial number two for Sheila Agee we were able to do in two days.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Prosecutors again told jurors this was a, quote, mother's role in orchestrating her son's revenge and pointed to her texts as calculated directives that resulted in Brooklyn's death.

[Trey Myers]

The focus of the defense attorney in both trials was the intent. They were trying to say that Sheila ag loved Brooklyn. She loved the baby that Brooklyn and Keith shared in common. She had no intent for Brooklyn to be killed. And so that was what their main focus was.

[Scott Weinberger]

But this time, the jury was not buying it.

[Bridget Jensen]

Sheilag was also found guilty of first degree premeditated murder or being a principal to her son, Keith Agee.

[Trey Myers]

When the verdict came back, I immediately turned around and I looked at Brooklyn's mom and her sister and her aunt that were there, and they were just overcome with emotion. They were sitting with our victim advocates, and they were crying and obviously very upset.

[Bridget Jensen]

Keith Agee was sentenced to life in state prison without the possibility of parole, as well as his mother, Sheila Agee, the same sentence, life in state prison without the possibility of parole.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

It was the painful but rightful ending to a tragic story.

[Bridget Jensen]

This case was unique and important, Important to us, I think, mostly because of Brooklyn's age. She was so young, and she had a young daughter at home and a whole life together that they're both going to miss out. Two families in this case have been totally upended, and it's unfortunate, and it was really all for nothing.

[Scott Weinberger]

And in like so many homicide cases, the killer did not just claim the life of his victim, Brooklyn Sims, but all the people she left behind, especially her daughter.

[Trey Myers]

These cases, when we're done, always come back to the victim for me, because that's why we do what we do. We do this to get justice for our victims. And this case was, was so sad. They're all sad. But this case was so sad because it left a young child with her mother dead and her father spending life in prison. So she's orphaned, essentially, and she's being raised by wonderful grandparents and Brooklyn's wonderful family. But still, obviously, it's not the same. And that's what's so heartbreaking, is this little girl does not have either one of her parents.

[Scott Weinberger]

I came across this term recently, narrative control. And it really stuck with me, because when you look at this case, it's exactly what's at play. And here's what I mean. What happened to Brooklyn Sims? She shows how a single false story, one built on emotion, jealousy and misinformation, can take control of everything. The moment she was accused of giving him an std, that lie became the narrative. It shaped how he saw her, how he justified what he was about to do, and eventually how the public first heard her name. That's the danger of losing control of the truth. When anger and humiliation take over, they start writing the story for you. And in this case, that false belief became the fuel for murder. So when I talk about the narrative control here, I'm talking about the power of perception. A rumor became motive. A lie became lethal.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Brooklyn Sims was only 18 years old, murdered by the father of her young child and murdered at the direction of his mother. Keith Agee used a gun. Sheila Agee used her words as an equally powerful and destructive weapon. I've read some of the text messages between mother and son, and this was absolutely a premeditated act by them both. The content is sickening in its ruthlessness to read. We'll put a link on the AOM website to part of Bridget's closing argument, which goes through some of the specific texts, so you can read them for yourselves if you'd like. The reasoning here was petty, hollow, and ultimately even proved to be false. But no matter their feelings for Brooklyn, how on earth did they decide that the thing to do would be to take this teenager's life? No matter how many decades I've been involved in prosecuting or talking about these cases, I still cannot wrap my head around some of these crimes. And this is one of them. Brooklyn Sims had barely lived life when she was killed. After her death, family and friends gathered to release balloons into the sky in her memory and to bring awareness to domestic violence and how quickly it can escalate. October is recognized as Domestic Violence Awareness Month, so we thought it was a fitting time to release this episode. Brooklyn Sims brother said that all his sister wanted in life was to be a good mom to her daughter. Her daughter is being raised by Brooklyn's family. We hope she is doing well and is often reminded of the incredible love felt for her by her mom. Tune in next week for another new episode of Anatomy of Murder.

[Scott Weinberger]

Anatomy of Murder is an audio Chuck.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Original, produced and created by Weinberger Media and Frasetti Media.

[Scott Weinberger]

Ashley Flowers is Executive producer.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

This episode was written and produced by Walker Lamond, researched by Kate Cooper, edited by Ali Sirwa, Megan Hayward and Phil Jean Grande. I think Chuck would approve have you met AllModern? AllModern brings you the best of modern furniture and decor all in one place. Save up to 70% during their big sale of the year. Update your space with modern dining tables, chairs and more. All on sale at AllModern, a Wayfair specialty brand. Plus get fast and free delivery. That's modern made simple. Shop the Big Sale of the year October 26th through 29th [e-mail].

[Trey Myers]

Want the.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Same expert advice from the pros at a discount tire store while shopping for tires online?

[Trey Myers]

Meet Treadwell, your personal tire guide.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Treadwell is an online tire buying guide that gives you personalized recommendations based on your location, driving habits and tire performance. Just enter your vehicle info, zip code and driving routines, and then Treadwell will match you with the perfect tire for your vehicle. Shop for tires with [e-mail] let's get you taken care of.