Anatomy of Murder: Hot Air (Cassandra Robinson) Released on June 3, 2025
Hosts:
- Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi: Former New York City Homicide Prosecutor and host of Investigation Discovery's True Conviction.
- Scott Weinberger: Investigative Journalist and Former Deputy Sheriff.
Introduction
In the gripping episode titled "Hot Air (Cassandra Robinson)," Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi and Scott Weinberger delve into the mysterious disappearance and subsequent murder of Cassandra Robinson, a young mother from Pensacola. The episode meticulously dissects the layers of the crime, the victim's background, and the intricate investigation that ultimately unravels a web of deceit and violence.
The Disappearance of Cassandra Robinson
The story begins in June 2018, when Cassandra Robinson is reported missing by her sister, Carlisa. Cassandra had not been seen or heard from since February 1, 2018, the day she left after her one-year-old daughter Evelyn's birthday party. Initial indications suggested that Cassandra might have left voluntarily, but inconsistencies in her behavior raised suspicions among the investigators.
Notable Quote:
"Cassandra may have been missing for over four months. So you can imagine why her family was overwhelmed with fear and worry" - Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi [03:44]
Initial Investigation and Red Flags
Detective Chad Wilhite, assigned to the case, begins by examining Cassandra's relationship with Henry Steiger, her daughter's father. Henry, 28 years Cassandra's senior, became the primary suspect due to conflicting statements and suspicious behavior.
Key Findings:
- Sudden Departure: Cassandra left in her BMW with bags after the birthday party, and her car was later found abandoned at their home ([04:57]).
- Relationship Dynamics: Henry denied a romantic relationship, referring to himself as a "brother figure" to Cassandra, which contradicted the father-daughter relationship.
- Digital Footprint: Cassandra's social media and mobile phone showed no activity post-disappearance, a stark contrast to her previously active online presence.
Notable Quotes:
"When we asked if she left was on her own and he responded she is either not coming back because something happened or occurred against her will. We're like holy cow." - Chad Wilhite [06:58]
"She could not imagine a scenario where Cassandra would have ever left her daughter behind in the custody of the man she was leaving." - Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi [07:54]
Henry Steiger: The Prime Suspect
As detectives delve deeper into Henry's background, they uncover troubling aspects of his character and activities:
- Financial Troubles: Henry was involved in a coffee bean roasting business that was a front for money laundering and cocaine smuggling. He was on probation and under federal investigation ([25:35]).
- Suspicious Behavior: Despite financial crimes, Henry maintained a calm demeanor but exhibited odd habits, such as being overly meticulous about his daughter's cereal preferences ([18:42]).
Notable Quote:
"He deflects blame to everybody else except himself. That is one thing we notice pretty quick." - Chad Wilhite [21:29]
Breakthrough in the Case
The investigation took a pivotal turn when detectives obtained a search warrant for Henry's home, initially targeting financial crimes. During the search, they discovered:
- Large Sums of Money: Hidden cash in unconventional places, including an orange toolbox filled with $100,000 in cash ([32:10]).
- Cassandra's Belongings: The missing purple suitcase containing Cassandra's personal items was found in a storage unit ([32:46]).
A subsequent raid on Henry's property revealed even more damning evidence.
Notable Quote:
"Henry Steiger appears to be preparing to make a quick exit, purchasing a disposable phone and some untraceable phone numbers." - Scott Weinberger [34:07]
Discovery of Cassandra's Body
The detectives' relentless pursuit culminated in the discovery of Cassandra's remains in a trailer owned by Henry Steiger. Hidden within a hot air balloon basket, Casssandra was found in a state of decomposition, confirming foul play.
Notable Quote:
"More than five months since Cassandra Robinson was last seen alive, her remains have been discovered in a trailer owned by her partner, Henry Steiger." - Scott Weinberger [40:16]
Interrogation and Confession
Faced with overwhelming evidence, Henry Steiger's facade began to crumble during interrogation. Initially deflecting blame, his true nature and involvement became evident as he faltered under pressure.
Key Admission:
- Steven confessed that he strangled Cassandra, leading to her death, while their daughter was still in her arms. This act of brutality underscored his capacity for violence ([47:17]).
Notable Quotes:
"Something happened. I don't think it was a planned thing. I don't know what happened, but I know in my heart I don't think it was a planned and on purpose thing." - Henry Steiger [45:36]
"Steiger strangled Cassandra while their one year old child was still in her arms. An act of cruelty hard to fathom." - Scott Weinberger [47:51]
Legal Proceedings and Aftermath
In court, the prosecution presented a compelling case against Henry, emphasizing the evidence and his inconsistencies. Despite his attempts to downplay the relationship and deflect responsibility, the jury found Henry guilty of second-degree murder and accessory to the murder.
Verdict:
- Second-Degree Murder: Henry Steiger was sentenced to 18 months for financial crimes and his role in Cassandra's murder.
Impact: The case not only brought closure to Cassandra's family but also highlighted the systemic issues in recognizing and addressing coercive control in abusive relationships.
Notable Quote:
"His tactics may have worked in private, but they didn't hold up under the real weight of an investigation." - Scott Weinberger [49:52]
Conclusion
The "Hot Air (Cassandra Robinson)" episode serves as a poignant reminder of the intricate layers involved in uncovering the truth behind a murder case. Through meticulous investigation and unwavering determination, Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi and Scott Weinberger illustrate the profound impact of justice on the lives affected by such tragedies.
Final Thoughts:
"Cassandra, your love for your daughter will forever be part of who she is. And let's all hope that she will forever continue to thrive." - Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi [50:56]
Production Credits:
- Produced by: Weinberger Media and Frasetti Media
- Executive Producer: Ashley Flowers
- Episode Writer/Producer: Daryl Brown
- Researcher: Kate Cooper
- Editors: Ali Sirwa and Phil Jean Grande
Note: This summary intentionally excludes advertisements and non-content sections to focus solely on the narrative of Cassandra Robinson's tragic story and the investigative process that led to justice.