Something to Fix (Emmett Corrigan)

Summary

Anatomy of Murder: Something to Fix (Emmett Corrigan) – Detailed Summary

Release Date: December 17, 2024
Hosts: Anna-Sigga Nicolasi & Scott Weinberger

---

1. Introduction to the Case

In the gripping episode titled "Something to Fix," hosts Anna-Sigga Nicolasi and Scott Weinberger delve into the complex murder case of Emmett Corrigan. This episode not only examines the layers surrounding the victim and the crime itself but also explores the profound impact on the survivors, particularly Ashley Boyson, Emmett’s wife.

---

2. Background of Ashley Boyson and Emmett Corrigan

Ashley Boyson shares her heartfelt narrative, detailing her life as a dedicated wife and mother of five. She met Emmett Corrigan, a charismatic and ambitious law student from Boise, during her undergraduate studies at Utah State University. Their swift romance led to a marriage filled with optimism and dreams of a bright future together.

“I wasn’t surprised at all. Like six weeks in, we just started talking about our future and it wasn’t like an option to not have a future together.”
— Ashley Boyson (04:40)

Emmett’s move to his hometown of Boise marked the beginning of their new life, balancing his burgeoning legal career with Ashley's responsibilities as a mother.

---

3. The Marriage and Emerging Struggles

As Emmett established his law practice, the couple faced the typical strains of balancing work and family life. Emmett’s increasing work hours and rekindled struggle with alcoholism began to create a rift between them. Ashley recalls feeling a growing distance and uncertainty within their marriage.

“He was always running to the jail, he was always meeting with clients, or he wasn’t coming home. And I didn’t know why a lot.”
— Ashley Boyson (07:47)

By early 2011, Ashley sensed that Emmett was hiding something deeper, suspecting potential infidelity. Despite her efforts to seek help through marriage counseling and personal prayer, the underlying tension remained unresolved.

---

4. The Confrontation and Shooting

On the evening of March 11, 2011, a tragic confrontation unfolded in a Walgreens parking lot in Meridian, Idaho. Ashley had been confronting Emmett about his suspected infidelity when tensions escalated dramatically.

“I remember kneeling down by my bed going, heavenly father, I just need one answer.”
— Ashley Boyson (09:18)

Emmett’s defensive behavior led Ashley to seek external assistance, ultimately bringing Rob Hall, Candy Hall’s husband, into the equation. Rob Hall, a former deputy and part-time salesman, had his own suspicions about an affair involving his wife and Emmett.

The situation deteriorated when Rob arrived at the scene, resulting in a violent altercation. Gunshots echoed through the parking lot, leaving both Emmett and Rob injured. Emmett succumbed to his wounds at the scene, while Rob survived with critical injuries.

“Hey, you hear me? No, no, no, please.”
— First Responder (13:44)

---

5. Investigation and Evidence

The investigation revealed a tangled web of relationships and motives. Initially, Rob Hall claimed self-defense, asserting that Emmett had attacked him, leading him to fire the fatal shots. However, forensic evidence began to challenge this narrative.

• Gunshot Residue Test: Only Rob Halls showed gunshot residue on his hands, suggesting he was the one who fired the gun.

• Sequence of Shots: Candy Hall’s recording of the gunshots indicated a sequence that didn't align with Rob’s self-defense claim. She described hearing three distinct shots (“pop, pop, pop”), whereas Rob suggested only two shots were fired by Emmett before he retaliated.

“I just needed something to fix, not break my entire life.”
— Ashley Boyson (16:01)

These discrepancies cast doubt on the self-defense theory, pointing towards a more calculated motive rooted in infidelity and betrayal.

---

6. The Trial and Verdict

The trial that followed was intense and emotionally charged. Candy Hall’s testimony became a focal point, as her initial statements conflicted with her later court testimony. While she initially denied any romantic involvement with Emmett, evidence surfaced showcasing her affair with him, undermining her credibility.

“The judge at the end was like, jury, anything she said here, I just want you to discredit everything she said.”
— Ashley Boyson (44:16)

The prosecution successfully argued that Rob Hall had premeditated the murder, using his knowledge of Emmett and his personal grief over the affair as motives. Ultimately, Rob Hall was convicted of second-degree murder.

“On October 25, 2012, Rob Hall was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to 30 years to life in prison.”
— Screenshot from Transcript (44:54)

---

7. Aftermath and Ashley's Recovery

The aftermath of the murder left Ashley Boyson grappling with immense loss, betrayal, and the daunting task of rebuilding her life. She founded the nonprofit "A Reason to Stand," focusing on empowering survivors of similar tragedies. Through her blog "Moments We Stand," Ashley shares her journey of healing, aiming to support others facing grief and trauma.

“I see them showing up anyway, and I am just so proud to be their mom.”
— Ashley Boyson (46:25)

Despite the pain, Ashley remarried and expanded her family, demonstrating resilience and strength in the face of unimaginable adversity.

---

8. Conclusion

"Something to Fix" presents a poignant exploration of love, betrayal, and the profound consequences of unresolved tensions. Ashley Boyson's story serves as a testament to the enduring human spirit and the capacity for healing and growth even after the darkest of events. Through meticulous investigation and personal accounts, the episode underscores the intricate layers that constitute a murder case and the lasting impact on those left behind.

“He was trying to have it just be self-defense. And yet the gun that he brought, it was a present that Candy gave him that he kept at his parents’ house.”
— Ashley Boyson (42:22)

Ashley’s transformation from a grieving widow to a beacon of support for others encapsulates the essence of survival and redemption, offering listeners both a harrowing tale and a source of inspiration.

---

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• “I wasn’t surprised at all. Like six weeks in, we just started talking about our future and it wasn’t like an option to not have a future together.”
  — Ashley Boyson (04:40)

• “He was always running to the jail, he was always meeting with clients, or he wasn’t coming home. And I didn’t know why a lot.”
  — Ashley Boyson (07:47)

• “I remember kneeling down by my bed going, heavenly father, I just need one answer.”
  — Ashley Boyson (09:18)

• “I just needed something to fix, not break my entire life and break my family.”
  — Ashley Boyson (16:01)

• “The judge at the end was like, jury, anything she said here, I just want you to discredit everything she said.”
  — Ashley Boyson (44:16)

• “I see them showing up anyway, and I am just so proud to be their mom.”
  — Ashley Boyson (46:25)

---

This comprehensive summary captures the essence of the "Something to Fix" episode, highlighting the key events, emotional turmoil, and eventual resolution of a harrowing murder case. It provides listeners with a clear understanding of the complexities involved and the enduring strength of those affected.

Transcript

[Ashley Boyson]

Now streaming on Hulu.

[Scott Weinberger]

This guy is an evil genius. He's the best serial killer that ever existed. He compared himself to Ted Bundy, the serial killer.

[Ashley Boyson]

You don't know who is this guy? Pure evil.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

This is not just any killer.

[Ashley Boyson]

In his own words, put my head right up to her ear and I said, you knew this was coming. The hit true crime series returns.

[Scott Weinberger]

Wild crime.

[Ashley Boyson]

Eleven skulls. I'm more sane than most Americans. Now streaming on Hulu.

[Scott Weinberger]

This episode is brought to you by Progressive, where drivers who save by switching save nearly $750 on average. Plus auto customers qualify for an average of 7 discounts. Quote [e-mail] to see if you could save Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates national average 12 month savings of $744 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2022 and May 2023. Potential savings will vary. Discounts not available in all states and situations. This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. There's something about December that just feels like a warm hug. With chilly nights, cozy blankets, and those quiet, comforting moments at home, therapy is a great way to bring yourself some comfort that never goes away, even when the season changes. If you're thinking about starting therapy, give BetterHelp a try. It's entirely online, designed to be convenient, flexible and suited to your schedule. Find comfort this December with BetterHelp. Visit betterhelp.com AOM today to get 10% off your first month. That's betterhelp.com AOM oh my God, it's.

[Candy Hall]

The coolest thing ever. Hey guys, have you heard of Goldbelly? Well, check this out. It's this amazing site where they ship the most iconic, famous foods from restaurants across the country, anywhere nationwide. I've never found a more perfect gift than food. They ship Chicago deep dish pizza, New York bagels, Maine lobster rolls, and even Ina Garten's famous cakes. Seriously. So if you're looking for a gift for the food lover in your Life, head to goldbelly.com and get 20% off your first order with promo code gift.

[Ashley Boyson]

I just remember thinking like, there's no way this is my one answer. I said I just needed something to fix, not break my entire life and break my family and leave these kids fatherless.

[Scott Weinberger]

I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

I'm Anasiga Nicolasi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of Investigation Discovery's True Conviction.

[Scott Weinberger]

And this is Anatomy of Murder.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

We've often said that our primary goal on this podcast is to advocate for not just the victims of violent crimes, but for the survivors as well.

[Scott Weinberger]

That could mean the children of a murdered parent, the wife of a murdered husband, and even the many friends and extended family members of the people lost to homicide. We believe that their stories and their perspective on loss and justice are a crucial part of their healing process and can maybe even provide strength to others going through similar experiences.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Today's story is as much about its survivors as it is about the victim. It's about a mother and her then five children whose lives were forever changed by a deadly incident of gun violence. But for Ashley Boyson, the survivor's journey has also been about reconciliation, not only with the homicide, but also with the betrayal that led directly to that tragedy.

[Scott Weinberger]

Back in the early 2000s, Ashley was a bright eyed undergraduate at Utah State University. She was working in the school gym when she met upperclassmen Emmett Corrigan, a popular Boise native bound for law school.

[Ashley Boyson]

It was sparks right away with Emmett and I, we both just connected on so many levels and similarities and we were kind of inseparable.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

It was clear from the beginning that Emmett was ambitious and eager to get on with his big plans for the future. In fact, he and Ashley had only been dating for two months before he popped the question.

[Ashley Boyson]

I wasn't surprised at all. Like six weeks in, we just started talking about our future and it wasn't like an option to not have a future together.

[Scott Weinberger]

It was a huge storybook wedding. The newlyweds beaming with youth and optimism for a long, happy life with each other.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

After a spring break honeymoon on the Oregon coast, Ashley went back to Utah State, a married woman. Their twins arrived during Emmett's first year of law school. The young couple was deeply in love. But as you can probably imagine, juggling books and babies is no easy task.

[Ashley Boyson]

I remember during law school just almost feeling this, we gotta make this work. I mean, he was busy most of the time and I was in the depths of motherhood, but I never saw it as a burden. I was just like, this is what we're doing and we're just gonna get through this and then life together will start. Really, it was kind of a, we have to push through this school time and then it's all going to be amazing.

[Scott Weinberger]

Eventually, the couple moved to Emmett's hometown of Boise, where he would begin his career as a lawyer and Ashley would begin building the home and the life of their dreams.

[Ashley Boyson]

And he always wanted to have friends over and parties and cook food for everybody and he'd even invite, like everyone from our church over and we'd have this huge pig roast. He just was a connector and never wanted anyone to feel alone. He was an only child and just always wanted to be surrounded by people. And he just loved people, and people loved him.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

But according to Ashley, she had some reservations about putting down roots in Boise, a place where she knew Emmett had a long and sometimes troubled history.

[Ashley Boyson]

When he said, I've got a job in Boise. Let's move to Boise, I had some doubts. And I'll tell you the main reason why is he grew up here and knew a lot of people, and also during his high school years, made a lot of really bad choices. And I was like, I don't know if I want to move to the place where you had rough patches in your life. I kind of want to get a fresh start somewhere else. But this literally was the only option, and we ended up moving here.

[Scott Weinberger]

And by 2011, the couple had five children, a comfortable house, a couple of cars in the driveway. And from the outside, it appeared they had everything anyone would have ever hoped for.

[Ashley Boyson]

It was kind of one of those, like, you drew up your life when you were a kid, and now you have it. You're pregnant with your second boy. You have the white picket fence. Your husband has this amazing job, this amazing career. And yet I just kept feeling this, like, is something not right? So it was a very torn time. Like, I was living my dreams, and internally, something fell off a lot.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

After opening his own law practice, Emmett was working long hours, regularly staying late at the office. And with Ashley juggling five kids at home, the couple began to experience what many couples do, A growing distance between them, both physical and emotional.

[Ashley Boyson]

It had gotten to the point where he hardly was home. He was always running to the jail, he was always meeting with clients, or he wasn't coming home. And I didn't know why a lot. And I wanted my family, I wanted my marriage. I wanted back the man who I fell in love with and who I loved. And whatever it was, we were going to face it together. And that was kind of my mindset.

[Scott Weinberger]

Ashley also saw the return of one of Emmett's old demons. After years of sobriety, he had started drinking again.

[Ashley Boyson]

He would come home sometimes, and I could smell it. And that was some of the demons that I was afraid to move back to Boise because he had struggled with that when he lived here before.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

But By February of 2011, Ashley felt that there was something else causing a rift in their marriage. It was a rising suspicion that her husband was hiding something from her, that perhaps he Was not being faithful.

[Ashley Boyson]

I don't know if I didn't want to face the truth or if I just felt safer living in cognitive dissonance. I don't know. But there was always something inside of me pointing me in the direction that I knew something was wrong. I tried to find evidence of something wrong or some other woman or something. It was always a dead end. Except for the pit in my stomach. It just wouldn't stop.

[Scott Weinberger]

A month later, Ashley knew it was time to confront Emmett about her suspicions and hopefully convince him to begin the process of healing their marriage.

[Ashley Boyson]

I remember that morning waking up and it had been months of me starting to dig, like in a way that a full time mom with five little kids can't. I remember waking up though, and I'm like, I'm not gonna go through his truck while he's in the shower. I'm not gonna try to get in his phone. That has proved to not work. I'm going to find an answer and I don't care what it is. I'd gone to, like a marriage therapist and asked him for help. I'd gone to someone at church and asked him for help. And I'm like, I got this. And I remember kneeling down by my bed going, heavenly father, I just need one answer. Tell me what's going on and I will fix it. I'm a woman. I'm strong. I can face it. I'm ready. Just help me figure out what it is.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

On the evening of March 11, Ashley set Emmett down for a heart to heart, baring her soul in the hopes that Emmett would do the same.

[Ashley Boyson]

At one point I said, you know, lately when you don't want to be intimate with me, I feel like either I'm not doing it for you or someone else is. And he was silent.

[Scott Weinberger]

But instead of being open to the conversation, Emmett went on the defensive, denying that he was having an affair and instead accusing Ashley of being unfairly suspicious, ungrateful, and unhinged.

[Ashley Boyson]

As a lawyer, Emmett was really good at his words. And so when his actions didn't match the words, I doubted me before I doubted his words. It was just like, I have anxiety because I'm not trusting. Like my parents got divorced. Maybe I'm not a trusting person because of this or this or my past, and I would just always turn it inward. But the fear sometimes of knowing the truth keeps you from even wanting to look at it.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

As Ashley recounted to us, she finally convinced Emmett to speak to a friend who was also a marriage counselor.

[Ashley Boyson]

By the time he got off the phone. I had put the babies to bed and just kind of was waiting for him to come out. And I was hoping we were going to have this night where we just fought for each other. You know, you get those images of what this night could be. I had this grand idea that he was going to talk to him and his heart was going to be softened and he was going to come and open up to me and we were going to face it head on together.

[Scott Weinberger]

Instead, Emmett emerged from the bedroom, grabbed his coat and headed for the front door.

[Ashley Boyson]

He looks at me and he goes, I'm going to run to Walgreens real quick. I haven't been feeling really good. I have a scratchy throat. I need to get some medicine. And like that feeling of anxiety and chaos that I had felt, it was like 400 times stronger. And I just got this like pit in my stomach. I'm like, emmett, please don't go.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

At a little before 9pm Emmett left. It was the last time Ashley would see him alive.

[Ashley Boyson]

10:15, I called Emmett's phone like four times in a row and just texted him like, are you okay? What's going on? I knew something was wrong. And you know what I pictured for a moment? I'm like, maybe he wrecked his brand new truck. He's going to need me. We're going to go to this hospital, I'm going to take all five of these babies, and for the first time in a long time, he's going to be sitting there humbled and actually need and want his family. And we're going to be there and this is what's going to heal us.

[Scott Weinberger]

Then just after 10pm, a flurry of 911 calls were received at a local police department in Meridian, Idaho. Witnesses reported hearing gunshots in the parking lot in front of a local Walgreens.

[Rob Hall]

At Linda and McMillan. You said there was two gunshots? Three. Three gunshots at McMillan and Linder.

[Ashley Boyson]

And there were.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

When I, when I drove by, there were two people down. One of the 911 calls was from a woman identifying herself as Kandi Hall. And in the recording you can hear her frantically begging for help.

[Rob Hall]

The person that did this, where did they go?

[Scott Weinberger]

First responders rushed to the scene and what they found was anything but typical for this part of suburban Boise. Two men lying on the pavement, both suffering from apparent gunshot wounds. One is identified as the female caller's husband, Robert hall. The other is 30 year old Emmett Corrigan.

[First Responder]

Gunshot.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

The head.

[First Responder]

Who did this?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Dude.

[Ashley Boyson]

Hey, you hear me? No, no, no, please.

[First Responder]

Hey.

[Ashley Boyson]

Are you talking.

[First Responder]

You listen to me. Hey. Hey. I need you to stay with me, okay? Where's the head at? Where's your head injury at? On top.

[Ashley Boyson]

Okay.

[First Responder]

Who shot you? Do you know who did it?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Robert hall had what looked like a graze wound to the side of his head, but was still conscious. Emmett Corrigan, lying just a few feet away, had suffered two gunshot wounds, one to the chest and one to the head. He was declared dead at the scene.

[Ashley Boyson]

No suspect information? Not yet.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

I don't know.

[First Responder]

This is weird.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Ashley Boyson would get the news about her husband just a few minutes later.

[Ashley Boyson]

I don't even know how long I was asleep when I heard the pounding on my door. So I slowly walked myself to my door, and I remember opening it, and I'm like, it's going to be cops. And they're going to be like, come with us. We have him. Instead, it was three detectives who were all in street clothes.

[Scott Weinberger]

Making a death notification at the home of a family member is one of the hardest jobs a police officer has. But when that death has come as a result of a homicide, it is filled with its own set of challenges, not the least of which is gathering important information that may help to solve a murder.

[Ashley Boyson]

And they're like, we just really need you to sit down. And we all walked in and sat around this giant leather couch that Emmett and I had saved forever for and finally had this dream couch on our dream house.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

The plainclothes detectives informed Ashley that her husband had been shot. News that was still almost impossible for her to process.

[Ashley Boyson]

For the first second, I'm like, okay, he's shot. He's at the hospital. They're gonna take me there. And I think the detective knew he was like, ashley, he was shot in the heart and in the forehead, and he died.

[Scott Weinberger]

The bullet that hit Emmett's chest had passed through his sternum, through the right ventricle of his heart, through his left lung, and impacted his spinal column.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

That second bullet entered his skull. And I'm going to be pretty specific here. The bullet entered just inside the hairline of his upper right forehead, traveled in a slight downward and leftward direction through the entire right side of his brain.

[Ashley Boyson]

And I just remember thinking, like, there's no way. This is my one answer. I said, I just needed something to fix. Not break my entire life and break my family and leave these kids fatherless and leave me broken for the rest of my life is what I thought in that moment.

[Scott Weinberger]

Both gunshots were fired from close range. Ballistic tests would later confirm that the Bullets came from a gun found at the scene. A.380 caliber automatic pistol with a laser sight. A gun that was registered to the other male victim, Robert hall.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Hall was a 41 year old former deputy and part time salesman who lived just a few minutes away from where the shooting took place.

[Scott Weinberger]

According to hall, the two men had gotten into an altercation in the parking lot, a scuffle during which his gun fell out of his sweatshirt pocket. He claimed it was Emmett who picked up the gun and fired first, the bullet grazing the side of Hall's head.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Hall went on to describe how he then managed to wrestle the gun away from Emmett and return fire, striking Emmett twice, once in the chest and once in the head. He claimed that he acted instinctually out of fear for his own life.

[Scott Weinberger]

So hall admitted to shooting Emmett Corrigan, but whether it was done in self defense as he claimed, or was premeditated, that would still have to be determined and then proven out by the evidence.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

So was this argument over a parking space a falling out between friends or business partners? To answer those questions, police would rely on the one witness that actually witnessed the shooting, Rob Hall's wife, Candy Hall.

[Scott Weinberger]

While her husband was being stitched up at the hospital, Candy had been brought to the police station so investigators could immediately take her statement. The information she shared would be vital in piecing together the events leading up to the shooting and whether her version matched up with what was being described by her husband.

[Detective]

Are you good with talking with us right now? I mean, you got brought down here as a witness and the way I'm looking at this is, you know, are you going to voluntarily talk to us and tell us what happened tonight?

[Rob Hall]

Yeah, I'll talk to you. Absolutely.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

The first and most important revelation. These two men were not strangers. And this argument was not over a parking space or business. It was over her.

[Scott Weinberger]

It turned out that 40 year old candy hall worked Emmet's law office as a paralegal. And her husband had suspected that she and her boss had been having an affair for months.

[Rob Hall]

He was very, very, very, very jealous of, well, not very jealous. I don't think that he was just upset about my, my actions lately, which is just basically I just had enough. I just had enough.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

When police asked Candy if she and Emmett had a romantic relationship, she denied it.

[Detective]

Are you and Emmett involved in a romantic relationship?

[Rob Hall]

No.

[Detective]

Have you ever been romantic with Emmett?

[Rob Hall]

No.

[Detective]

Is there anything that's going to come out later that we're going to look back at this and say, hmm?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

But as you can Imagine police were curious if they would turn up any evidence at the scene that might contradict her statement.

[Detective]

Would you have a problem with the guys that built the scene? To photograph your car, open the doors, look through it, and if they see anything of evidentiary value, they'll take it. They'll leave your receipt. Are you okay with that? You're fine with that?

[Rob Hall]

Okay.

[Scott Weinberger]

Sure enough, law enforcement discovered printed personal emails in Rob Hall's truck between Rob and Candy that indicated that he had uncovered the affair between Emmett and his wife months earlier.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

So this had all the makings of a classic and tragic love triangle. Which meant that a motive for the altercation at the Walgreens parking lot may well have been coming into focus.

[Scott Weinberger]

But investigators still had plenty to figure out. Like was this really just all a heated argument that turned deadly? Or was it a planned ambush? Was it a matter of self defense or cold blooded murder? With colder weather and the stress of the holiday season, your hair can take a hit. That's why now is the perfect time to start taking extra care of your hair with Nutrafol. Nutrafol is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplement brand trusted by over 1 million people. They have multiple formulas that are tailored to give your hair what it needs to grow see thicker, stronger, faster growing hair with less shedding in just three to six months with Nutrafol. I've been taking Nutrafol for a few weeks now and I have to say I have noticed a reduction in hair shedding, which those results have been quite encouraging. For a limited time, Nutrafol is offering our listeners $10 off your first month's subscription and free shipping. When you go to Nutrafol.com and enter promo code anatomy nutrafol.com spelled N U T R A F O L.com promo code A N A T O M Y I've always said that information is powerful, so I've got a question for you. Have you ever had the feeling that someone wasn't being fully truthful with you when you needed to do a gut check because you're pretty sure something wasn't adding up about someone's past? Well, you should turn to Truth Finder. Whether it is a neighbor or a random phone number that keeps calling you, Truthfinder has you covered. You can search for people by their phone number, address, name, email and more. Truthfinder can be especially helpful for running confidential background checks on anyone you're planning to meet from online dating apps. If you're on a dating app, you need to be on Truthfinder. As well. Truthfinder helps you identify potential threats so you can avoid them and protect yourself. I found the website of truthfinder.com easy to navigate with lots of smart tools and shortcuts. Critical information could be just a few clicks away. Go to truthfinder.com anatomy for a special Anatomy of Murder offer. That's truthfinder.com a n a T O M Y to access your special offer today.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

On March 11, 2011, gunfire had broken out in a parking lot in Boise, Idaho. When the smoke cleared, two men had been shot. 41 year old Rob hall had survived. 30 year old Emmett Corrigan had not.

[Rob Hall]

I hear pop, pop and then pop. And that's all I heard. And I turned around and both of them are laying on the ground.

[Scott Weinberger]

The sole witness of the shooting was Hall's wife Candy, who claimed that her jealous husband Rob had been increasingly agitated and angry in the hours before the shooting. Incredibly, their argument was occurring just as Ashley Boyson was confronting Emmett over her own suspicions about his infidelity. Suspicions that turned out to be well grounded.

[Ashley Boyson]

They had met with an attorney that day to file papers for Candy to get a divorce.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

According to Candy hall, she left her home around 9pm to meet Emmett parking next to his black Range Rover in the lot of a local Walgreens. Here's a recording from her interview with police on the night of the shooting.

[Rob Hall]

He was there when I got there. He's like, hey, I didn't need to go get gas. You want to come with me? Let's talk about what's going on. And then I drove around and I parked my car and I got in his truck and we went, yep, that's exactly what happened.

[Detective]

The video will show that.

[Scott Weinberger]

Yep.

[Rob Hall]

Yes it will.

[Scott Weinberger]

Little did she know, her husband Rob had decided to follow her. His arrival was even caught on security video at the scene.

[Ashley Boyson]

On the video footage at Walgreens, you see Rob, his truck pulls up in just like a normal stall. You can see his whole truck. And in the video you see him get out of his truck with his hands in his pocket. And as he's walking inside Walgreens, his hands don't leave his pocket. He's like frantically looking through Walgreens and you can see through the Walgreens cameras, him going up and down every single aisle and just kind of looking around.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

As Emmett and Candy were driving back to the Walgreens pharmacy, Candy received a call from her irate husband who had spotted Candy's car in the parking lot. Here's more of that interview with Candy Hall.

[Rob Hall]

So then Rob calls and I pick up and he's like, what are you doing? And I said, I am out. He said, are you out with Emmett? And I said, I am. And he said, what are you doing? And I said, we're just talking. And then Emmett goes, let me talk to him. And then Emmett got really upset with Rob on the phone. Said something like a fucking break your head or something.

[Scott Weinberger]

Remember, Candy is the only witness to what happened next. But according to her, Emmett was riled up and itching for a confrontation.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And when they returned to the parking lot, Rob was there waiting.

[Rob Hall]

Emmett's a very aggressive man. He body builds, you know, so he's really pumped up all the time. And he got like this close up into Rob's face. Emmett says, what are you gonna do, Rob? Are you gonna hit me?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

At this point, Candy says that her attempts to de escalate the situation situation failed. So she turned away and headed back to her car to leave.

[Rob Hall]

And the next thing I knew is this car went by me and I don't know where it went. I waited for this car to go by and I turned around to walk to my car and I hear pop, pop. And then pop.

[Scott Weinberger]

And then she turned back around to find both her husband and Emmett bleeding on the ground.

[Rob Hall]

I didn't know what it was and I was like, what? And I turn around and I hear Emmett go, ugh. And kind of like, ugh. And he fell and looked over Robert, he's on the ground and blood all over. I was like, oh, my God.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Candy's version of events painted Robert as a jealous man whose emotions might have spiraled out of control. However, she also claimed that Emmett was the aggressor in the confrontation.

[Scott Weinberger]

Now, it's important to note that Candy never claimed to have seen the actual shooting. She only heard the gunshots. So police still don't know for certain what happened. Did Emmett really fire first? As Rob hall said, the truth seemed to lie in the sequence of gunshots.

[Detective]

Because your back was turned.

[Rob Hall]

My back was turned, yeah.

[Detective]

You heard pop, pop, pop. Pause. Yep. Okay, like how long have a pause? And those are time. Time questions can be tough, but seconds. But a definite pause.

[Rob Hall]

Yeah, pop up.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Pop.

[Scott Weinberger]

Now, you may be asking, why is this important? Well, just think about it for a second. If you're looking at from a self defense perspective, the one shot first followed by two more shots may mean that Rob's version could be correct. That he was shot and then fired two shots in self defense. Or if you're looking at the other version, two Shots pop, pop. And then a single pop could mean that Rob fired first two rounds and then turned the gun on himself and fired a self inflicted non lethal round. And anestiga. This would be a really important point if they can narrow it down and really figure out what happened.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

I mean, this is one of those things as prosecutors that we would. I mean, I'd probably use this in my opening and my summation. Right. Because what Candy says, it's absolutely going to be admissible at trial. And here's your legal trial evidence, 101 for the day. It's called an excited utterance because she says it in the heat of the moment when she's still under, you know, that mindset of what is happening at that moment. And what she says clearly is pop, pop, pop. So you're going to have to look at it because it certainly seems that what she recounted during that call sounds like someone is intentionally firing multiple shots, at least initially. So I would go with the way that you ended that, Scott, with like this is someone who is firing and then just maybe turn that gun on.

[Scott Weinberger]

Yeah. And I certainly see that this is an important aspect of the state's case to try to determine who was the aggressor here. Something clearly doesn't add up, but it shows how important that testimony will be.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And while firsthand witnesses can obviously be invaluable to a homicide investigation, Candy's relationship with both men meant that investigators would have to rely on physical evidence to verify her story. They can't know for sure if she's telling the truth or if maybe she was, I don't know, complicit in the murder or the COVID up or maybe none of them. But now that this horror has happened, police have to consider if she is going to stick with the last man standing, her husband, Rob Hall.

[Detective]

First thing we want to do is collect gunshot residue, see if there's any gunshot residue from your hands. Okay, so we have a kit for that.

[Rob Hall]

All right.

[Detective]

We're going to collect your clothes because they have blood on them. And that'll help, maybe help piece the puzzle together.

[Scott Weinberger]

Needless to say, Emmett's wife Ashley was blindsided by the events of March 11, 2011. First, there was a shock of her husband's violent death and then the revelation that her husband was cheating on her with the wife of the man who shot him. And it was at that moment she began to question so many things, even about herself.

[Ashley Boyson]

So it's not just the incident of your husband was cheating on you and now he's dead, and this guy killed him. It's like every insecurity just grows inside of you. And so the disassociation and the fog isn't just, you went through this moment. It's what did that moment tell you about yourself? And what do you think everybody else thinks about you now? And I think that was the biggest trap that I was stuck in for so long. I'm living in this fishbowl. Everybody knows I wasn't enough. Every time I go anywhere and they see me, like they feel sorry for me, but they're also like, oh, my gosh, in your head, this is what I'm thinking. Oh, my gosh, of course. Look at her. She's this and this and this. And I just felt like everything I had ever appreciated about myself, everything I ever thought I did, well, it was all stripped. Like I was just nothing and broken. And that was my destiny.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

One of the hardest things to face after she learned the truth about her husband's relationship with another woman was that she actually knew the other woman, Candy Hall. And while Emmett had described the older woman as just a friendly co worker, Ashley had always had her suspicions that there was something going on between them.

[Ashley Boyson]

I honestly only met her a few times. Like, I would go to an appointment for my pregnancy down by the office, and I would stop by, and some of the other paralegals and secretaries were like, you should just walk in. He's in there with Candy. And said just weird stuff. And so I did. I just walked in. And then Emmett looked at me like I was a ghost. Like, oh, hey, what are you doing here?

[Scott Weinberger]

Not acting sooner on those suspicions still haunts her to this day. But at the time, she had been committed to keeping their family together. But following her husband's death, the last time they would all gather together as a family would be at Emmett's funeral.

[Ashley Boyson]

I remember getting there, and the first thing I was afraid of, and this became the first thing I was afraid of everywhere I went for a very long time, is, what if she shows up? I mean, she's claiming she was his lover. What if she shows up? So a lot of the funeral, I was on, like, high alert, just watching for candy.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

On March 13, 2011, investigators from Meridian Police sat down with Rob Hall. He'd been released from the hospital, and now they were going to question him about the night of the shooting and try to get a clearer picture about what happened. Would he double down on what was sounding like an unlikely scenario? Or would he maybe come clean?

[Detective]

My name is Jim Miller, and I'm the detective in charge of this case. I know you've spoken to one of our officers initially about this, but since you got released, I wanted to, you know, talk to you about what happened, what led up to all this. I mean, how we ended up here today.

[Scott Weinberger]

But Rob hall exercised his right to an attorney and chose not to make a statement. And so he was placed into custody, charged with the murder of Emmett Corgan, and then transported to the county jail.

[Ashley Boyson]

A traveling judge offered bail and his mom paid it. And he ended up getting out of jail like 28 days later. And when I called frantic about that, they're like, oh, don't worry, he wasn't mad at you. He even had a letter on his seat that was addressed to you that was going to tell you everything that he was going to mail to you. And they thought that would make me feel better. But in that moment, I'm like, well, why the hell didn't he just mail the letter? We could have worked together and figured this out and not had someone die.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

A trial was set for the fall of 2012. Yet another painful ordeal to be endured by Emmett Corrigan's widow and their five young kids.

[Ashley Boyson]

I, for a long time was like, I'm not going to be part of this murder trial. I'm just. I got to put it in the past. I got to march. And then as it got closer, I just couldn't not. I had to have the rest of the puzzle pieces.

[Scott Weinberger]

Puzzle pieces that would come courtesy, not from the only witness to the shooting, Cany hall, but from the physical evidence left behind at the crime scene. Look, we all tell our friends about that great restaurant we just ate at or the book we just couldn't put down. So when you find a great wireless plan, why not spread the news? Mint Mobile offers Premium Wireless for 15amonth when you purchase a three month plan. Because friends don't let friends overpay for wireless, right? All plans come with high speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. Use your own phone with any Mint Mobile plan and bring your number along with all of your existing contacts to get this new customer offer and your new 3 month premium wireless plan for just 15 bucks a month. Go to mintmobile.com anatomy that's mintmobile.com ana t o m y cut your wireless bill to 15 bucks a month at mintmobile.com anatomy 45 dollars upfront payment required, equivalent to 15 dollars a month new customers on first 3 month plan only speed slower above 40 gigabytes on unlimited plan. Additional taxes, fees and restrictions apply. See Mint Mobile for details.

[Narrator]

What does the future hold for business? Ask nine experts and you'll get 10 answers. Bull market? Bear market rates will rise or fall. Can someone please invent a crystal ball? Until then, over 40,000 businesses have future proofed their business with NetSuite by Oracle, the number one cloud ERP bringing accounting, financial management, inventory and HR into one FL fluid platform with one unified business management suite. There's one source of truth giving you the visibility and control you need to make quick decisions. With real time insights and forecasting, you're peering into the future with actionable data. When you're closing the books in days, not weeks, you're spending less time looking backwards and more time on what's next. Whether your company is earning millions or even hundreds of millions, NetSuite helps you respond to immediate challenges and seize your biggest opportunities. Speaking of opportunity, download the CFO's guide to AI and machine learning at netsuite.com AOM the guide is free to you at netsuite.com Aom netsuite.com AOM.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

The prosecution's case against Robert hall was that he had gone to the Walgreens parking lot armed with a loaded unholstered gun with the intention of confronting Emmett Corrigan. He had the motive, his wife's infidelity, the means, a loaded automatic handgun with a laser sight, and the opportunity knowledge of exactly when and where to find his target.

[Scott Weinberger]

Robert hall claimed he acted in self defense. His attorneys would insist that he had no intention of killing Emmett, but only fired his gun because he believed his life was in mortal danger.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

He also claimed that Emmett, who was younger and more physically imposing, had attacked him first during their argument, pushing him to the ground, taking the gun and firing first, grazing hall on the side of his head.

[Ashley Boyson]

Rob's claim during court was he had to defend himself. At one point Emmett had the gun and then he handed it over to Rob and then Rob shoots.

[Scott Weinberger]

However, forensic evidence contradicted Robert's claim of self defense. On the night of the shooting, investigators had done a gunshot residue test on all three people present at the crime scene, Rob hall, his wife Candy, and the deceased victim, Emmett Corrigan.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Those tests proved that hall was the only one who had fired the gun found at the scene. Rob Hall's DNA was also found on the trigger.

[Ashley Boyson]

The DNA and all the gunpowder tests and everything, nothing was on Emmett's hand. It was all on Rob's and Candy's because she ended up picking up the gun and throwing it later. So his self defense story didn't really add up.

[Scott Weinberger]

The gunshot residue test undermined Halls and entire story. His credibility was shot.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Prosecutors also pointed to Candy Hall's own recorded statement in which she described the sequence of gunshots that she heard.

[Rob Hall]

I turned around and walked in my car and I hear pop, pop. And then pop.

[Scott Weinberger]

What she described in the aftermath of the murder did not support her husband's story that Emmett shot first.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Pop.

[Scott Weinberger]

And then he returned fire. Pop, pop.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

But the medical examiner determined that Emmett's wounds to his chest and head were instantly fatal. So then the question is, who fired that third shot? The prosecution's theory, Rob hall himself.

[Scott Weinberger]

Considering the path of the bullet that caused Hall's wound, the gunshot residue on his hand, and the sequence of gunshots heard by his own wife, prosecutors argued that after hall shot and killed Emmett Corrigan, he turned the gun on himself.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Incredibly, a statement surfaced from a jailmate of Hall's that this may not even have been a spur of the moment decision.

[Ashley Boyson]

He was talking to someone in jail with him that he had like practiced to know exactly how to get a graze wound. So it looked like self defense.

[Scott Weinberger]

And so if the prosecution could prove that this was not in fact an act of self defense, the next step would be to decide if the murder was carried out in the heat of the moment or whether it had been planned. You know what I think of the gunshot residue test is a big thing for me. The fact that the victim, Emmett Corrigan, had nothing in his hands to reveal that he had pulled the trigger completely blows a hole in the self defense case. Right. And it's the defendant's demeanor also on camera, that pacing back and forth before the shooting that the surveillance cameras captured is important, I think for the prosecution's case to show state of mind.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And I agree that I really think it's the front end of this that is so telling. I mean, let's just look at this. You have Rob hall going to the place that he believes his wife to be with, the man that he believes she is having an extramarital affair with. He doesn't just go on his own. He brings a gun. He has the gun with him. When he confronts them. You have Candy's quick rendition of the way that those gunshots are heard. Remember, she is saying that as the 911 operator is taking the call, as the officers are first responding, I mean, that is with the. In moments before she has time to think or reflect or to make up, like what might sound or what might help her husband at that point, it really does point to the fact that again, whether he planned to go kill him or just planned to confront him and hurt him, and then again in that heat of passion, which what that does, it's still a crime, but it takes it potentially from murder to manslaughter. It definitely seems to point much more in that direction just based on common sense than with what hall is saying to police.

[Scott Weinberger]

In backing up even what you're saying is, you know, there was a fiery conversation with them moments before the victim was challenged to a fight. And for Rob, the answer was in his pocket a small caliber semiautomatic handgun.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And even after the initial confrontation in the parking lot, hall still had time to de escalate that situation if he wanted to right, he could have simply left. Instead, he drew his weapon and fired more than once. And keep in mind, it wasn't just any weapon.

[Ashley Boyson]

He was trying to have it just be self defense. And yet the gun that he brought, it was a present that Candy gave him that he kept at his parents house. That was his only gun that had a laser pointer. So it was one of those. Like a lot of people said, no, this is first degree. You went to your parents house, got a specific gun, had it in your hoodie pocket.

[Scott Weinberger]

During the trial, Rob Hall's wife, Candy, was called to testify as a witness to the murder. It remained to be seen whether she would be able to offer a truthful and believable account of the shooting.

[Ashley Boyson]

So when Candy was on the stand, my stomach was just in knots and I just had to pinch myself. It was very, very triggering, but I couldn't look away. Like I just had to watch it.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Candy hall did finally admit that she and Emmett were indeed involved in a physical relationship. And that on the night of the murder, the plan was not just to drive around and talk as she told police.

[Ashley Boyson]

And her story is they went and had sex in some new neighborhood. She's talking about their relationship, she's talking about that night, the person dead. Everything can be brought up about them. Every weakness they've ever had, every struggle they've had. So she got to talk about whatever she wanted about Emmett.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

But in the end, Candy hall came to her husband's defense, testifying that she had never intended to leave him and was committed to their marriage.

[Ashley Boyson]

They stayed together even in the middle of court. They'd be like, I love you and like whisper to each other.

[Scott Weinberger]

In regards to the shooting. Her testimony veered from her original statements to police.

[Ashley Boyson]

Luckily, they took an interview with her the night it happened, she told all of what happened exactly. She said there was a pop, pop, pause, pop, and everything's on video. And then he got out 28 days later, went home to her for a full week without any stipulations. And so what the theory is is they had time to kind of plan out a new story of what happened. And that's kind of the story she brought to court. The news story was, oh, I actually heard a pop, pop, pop.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

It was clear to the judge and jury that Candy had changed her story. And so the veracity, the truthfulness of her entire testimony was thrown into question.

[Ashley Boyson]

She was up there for two days because her story didn't match what she had said the night of. And they just kept asking her questions over and over and over. And the judge at the end was like, jury, anything she said here, I just want you to discredit everything she said. We'll just show you the video footage of the night.

[Scott Weinberger]

Candy hall was clearly unfaithful. She tried to cover up her husband's guilt, and now she was a perjurer.

[Ashley Boyson]

The judge said she is the most discredible witness he's ever called to his stand.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

On October 25, 2012, Rob hall was convicted of second degree murder and sentenced to 30 years to life in prison.

[Ashley Boyson]

I actually requested probably nine times to be able to talk to him, but they never approved it because anything I would have said could have been used against me in court. I wanted to tell him how it felt to have a four year old who didn't sleep for a year and to have little children that would come and say, mom, what if the bad guy comes in and takes like. I wanted him to know what his choice had done to me and my kids.

[Scott Weinberger]

For Ashley, the loss of her husband was compounded by both the pain of his betrayal and the knowledge that another woman, Candy hall, was still living just a couple of blocks from where Ashley was raising her children.

[Ashley Boyson]

I ran into Candy once at a restaurant. When I saw her, I ran into the bathroom and was just like, okay, this is it. I get to talk to her. I get to tell her how it felt. I went up to her table and I didn't say a word. I just, like, my body was shaking and I just stared at her. I just had this, like, feeling washed over me. She doesn't care how it felt for you.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Incidentally, just two months after the trial, Candy hall would be convicted of theft for embezzling $300,000 from a former employee and sentenced to 14 years in prison.

[Scott Weinberger]

As for Ashley, she went on to rebuild her life. She has since remarried, and she and her husband have added two more children to the family, bringing the total to seven.

[Ashley Boyson]

They're doing amazing. They're successful. They're just out living life, and that was the goal. And I mean, they have fears come up and we have to work through trust issues sometimes. And just like everybody else, you know, the world's sometimes kind of hard to live in, but I see them showing up anyway, and I am just so proud to be their mom. I'm proud of the people they're becoming.

[Scott Weinberger]

In the years since her husband's death, Ashley has created a blog called the Moments We Stand, in which she shares her personal journey of loss and healing.

[Ashley Boyson]

And when I turned it into a book, it was mainly because my grandma was printing off every story that I wrote and sending it to all of her friends. And I was like, okay, there's gotta be an easier way, grandma.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Through her blog, her now multiple books and speaking engagements, Ashley hopes to provide support for those dealing with grief, loss, and trauma, particularly focusing on widowhood and surviving infidelity and homicide.

[Ashley Boyson]

I wanted to hug every single person who had sent me their story because I would sit on my bed at night and just bawl and just read their stories and like, how are people so strong? How is the human spirit still alive? Like, how are we still functioning? Because everybody's got a hard, hard story and I don't want them to be alone in theirs. So here we go. And we just kind of like throw up events and meet together and cry together and learn from each other.

[Scott Weinberger]

Ashley also founded a non profit to empower fellow survivors.

[Ashley Boyson]

The nonprofit is called A Reason to Stand. The purpose of it was just to help anyone who's ever felt broken not feel alone.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

And we want to thank Ashley for being so candid about her experience with such a traumatic and painful event in her life, one in which she and her kids will always be coping and healing.

[Ashley Boyson]

I literally had a man in chains in front of me, and I didn't realize. I also was just bound by the fears of what this experience told me I could live in and letting go of the wrongs that people have done to you. I know sometimes, like, you want justice, but mercy is also part of healing and just letting go and knowing that you're going to be watched over and in the end, you're going to understand some of the things you went through.

[Scott Weinberger]

The irony of Candy Hall's role in this tragedy is almost too stark to comprehend. Her choices, calculated yet Impulsive didn't just set the stage. They built it brick by brick for a confrontation that would leave her husband locked away for decades and Emmett murdered. She was the fragile thread that tied them together. And tugging on that thread, everything unraveled in devastating fashion. I was so impressed how Ashley was able to endure, find love once again and raising her now seven children while advocating for others on how to forgive and find a way forward. I was so sad to hear her say that she felt that she wasn't good enough, she wasn't pretty enough, not worthy enough for her husband's attention. Ashley turned unimaginable pain into purpose. A story of survival, redemption, and a path forward that inspires others to do the same.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

What happened to Emmett Corrigan is awful. And yes, Emmett's infidelity was wrong, obviously. But Rob Paul's revenge? You don't get to take a life because someone did you wrong. Hall also took a father away from five children and a husband from a woman. Ashley, who still loved him very much and at least at the time, wanted to try and make their family work and to get it back on track. Talking with Ashley for this interview struck me for many reasons. For the pain she lived through while she didn't know what was wrong in her marriage and then to be hit head on with her husband's murder, his infidelity, and that the murder was at the hand of the husband of the other partner in the affair. Devastating. Yet even with all that, it is Ashley's openness and strength that stays with me even now. She made it back into light out of deep darkness. It is Ashley's goal to help others out of the darkness by sharing her experience and for me, for us, that says so much about who she is. Survivor Strong. Tune in next week for another new episode of Anatomy of Murder.

[Scott Weinberger]

Anatomy of Murder is an audio Chuck.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Original, produced and created by Weinberger Media and Frasetti Media.

[Scott Weinberger]

Ashley Flowers is executive executive producer.

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

This episode was written and produced by Walker Lamond, researched by Kate Cooper, edited by Ali Sirwa and Phil Jean Grande.

[Narrator]

So what do you think Chuck?

[Anasiga Nicolasi]

Do you approve?

Did you know adults with financial literacy skills have 82% more wealth than those who don't? From swimming lessons to piano classes. As parents we invest in so many things to enrich our kids lives. But how much are we investing in their future financial success? With Greenlight, you can teach your kids essential skills like earning, saving and investing, giving them the tools for financial confidence. This investment costs less than an after school treat at Starbucks. Start prioritizing their financial education today with Greenlight. Invest in their [e-mail] podcast let's be.

[Chuck]

Honest, what most people really want for the holidays is to see their favorite people more often. I know I do. That's why this year the best gift you can give is an Aura Digital Picture Frame. I'm obsessed with mine. I have no joke over 100,000 photos on my phone and I've uploaded hundreds of photos to my Aura Frame. Name the number one digital photo frame by Wirecutter. Aura Frames are incredibly smart and easy to use, allowing you to upload unlimited photos and videos directly from your phone to the frame. Plus, you can order the frame online and preload it with photos and videos using the Aura app so it's ready to go right out of the box. My favorite photos I've uploaded are the throwbacks of my sister, my mom, my wife and our daughter. I truly love my Aura frame. For a limited time, visit auraframes.com and get $45 off Aura's best selling Carver Matte frames by using promo code Supernatural at checkout. That's auraframes.com promo code supernatural. This exclusive Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is their Best of the year, so don't miss out. Terms and conditions apply.