Anatomy of Murder: The Music Stopped (Scott Sessions & Heather Frank) Hosted by Anna-Sigga Nicolasi and Scott Weinberger
Introduction
In the gripping episode titled "The Music Stopped," hosts Anna-Sigga Nicolasi and Scott Weinberger delve deep into a harrowing murder case that intertwines passion, obsession, and tragedy. The episode meticulously dissects the layers of the crime, the victims, and the intricate investigation that ultimately led to justice.
Background of the Victim: Scott Sessions
Scott Sessions, a 53-year-old trumpet player in a beloved blues and rock band from Greeley, Colorado, was known for his exceptional talent and magnetic stage presence. Described by a local journalist as "the kind of magnetic performer that many people wanted to get close to," Scott was a reliable bandmate who never missed a gig.
On Saturday, February 8th, 2020, Scott informed his father that he was heading to Fort Collins for a date with Heather Frank. However, Scott never returned from that evening, setting the stage for the investigation that would follow.
Discovery of the Body
On Sunday morning, February 9th, 2020, a snow plow driver in Pingree Park, a remote and rural area in northern Colorado, discovered the burned remains of an unidentified male. The body was severely mutilated, with extensive burning and a brutal throat wound, indicating a savage homicide.
Donnie Robbins, Lieutenant of the Larimer County Sheriff's Office, reflected on the case:
"I've worked a lot of homicides over the last 30 years and this is the first one that I had a set of circumstances anywhere close to this... it's one I'll think about for a long time."
[04:07]
The initial discovery raised immediate questions about the true location and circumstances of the murder, as the crime scene did not match the condition of the body.
Linking the Missing Person to the Body
By Monday, February 10th, Scott Sessions was officially reported missing after failing to show up for a scheduled band performance. The timing was critical, as it was just one day after the body was found. Investigators quickly matched the missing person report to the unidentified body, confirming Scott as the victim.
Scott's disappearance and subsequent identification as the John Doe shifted the investigation into high gear, focusing on uncovering the motive and identifying the perpetrator.
Investigation Progress
Donnie Robbins and his team began by examining Scott's cell phone records, which placed his last known location in Greeley, contradicting his claim of being in Fort Collins. This discrepancy led investigators to a local King Soopers grocery store, where Scott's car was found parked just hours after his body was discovered.
"The car didn't yield any immediate clues about what had happened to Scott Sessions or why his car was parked at a Greeley store instead of being in Fort Collins."
[09:58]
Surveillance footage from the grocery store revealed that Scott's car entered the lot at 6:30 AM on Tuesday morning, indicating that Scott was already deceased when the car was parked.
Identifying Key Suspects: Heather Frank and Kevin Eastman
Through meticulous investigation, it was uncovered that Scott had been in communication with Heather Frank, a woman he had been romantically involved with. Heather lived just 200 yards from where Scott's car was found, placing her in close proximity to both the victim and the crime scene.
Investigators discovered that Heather had invited Scott to her home the night he disappeared. Additionally, Heather's ex-boyfriend, Kevin Eastman, a 48-year-old with a history of assault and weapons possession, emerged as a person of interest. Eastman had a volatile relationship with Heather, who had previously reported him for domestic violence.
"Donnie and his team were convinced that Eastman was involved with not only one, but both murders."
[22:19]
Collection of Evidence
Cell phone data played a pivotal role in connecting Eastman to the crime locations. Tracking revealed that both Heather and Eastman’s phones were near the Poudre Canyon area, the site where Scott's body was ultimately dumped. Additionally, surveillance footage placed Kevin Eastman's vehicle close to the body discovery site, strengthening the case against him.
"Eastman's claims that he was incompetent to go to trial was denied."
[43:16]
Arrest and Interrogation of Kevin Eastman
One week after Scott's disappearance, Donnie Robbins tracked Kevin Eastman to a rural gas station in Kersey, Colorado. Eastman was seen filling a gas can, presumably to burn evidence, similar to how Scott's body was disposed of.
During the interrogation at the Larimer County Sheriff's Office, Eastman initially appeared cooperative but gradually became evasive and contradictory. He confessed to an abusive relationship with Heather Frank, expressing jealousy and possessiveness.
"I love somebody, I can't go screw somebody else."
[31:03]
Despite his initial cooperation, Eastman's inconsistent statements and mounting evidence against him led detectives to suspect his involvement in both murders.
New Developments: Discovery of Heather Frank’s Body
While conducting the investigation, a second body was discovered near the original crime scene. This body was identified as Heather Frank, who had been shot twice in the chest. The proximity of her body to the burn pit where Scott was found further implicated Eastman.
"Inside of a sheriff's office interrogation room, investigators were listening to Eastman's repeated denials when miles away, Lieutenant Donnie Robbins team made a horrible discovery."
[38:22]
The revelation of Heather's death solidified the theory that Eastman was responsible for both murders, either acting alone or coercing Heather into assisting him.
Conclusion of the Case
Kevin Eastman was formally charged with two counts of first-degree murder and additional charges related to tampering with evidence and domestic violence enhancement. The prosecution presented compelling evidence linking Eastman to both crime scenes, including cell phone data, surveillance footage, and the presence of his vehicle at critical locations.
After a three-week trial in Greeley, Eastman was found guilty on all counts and sentenced to two consecutive life sentences plus 27 years without the possibility of parole.
Reflecting on the case, Lieutenant Donnie Robbins expressed deep frustration and sorrow:
"If we would have been one day earlier of getting the arrest warrants, if we'd have got them both in custody safely and she would probably still be alive."
[45:11]
Final Reflections
"The Music Stopped" serves as a poignant reminder of the tragic consequences of obsession and abuse. Scott Sessions' vibrant life was cut short by violence rooted in possessiveness and control. Heather Frank's untimely death underscores the devastating impact of abusive relationships.
The episode also highlights the relentless pursuit of justice by law enforcement, emphasizing the challenges and emotional toll of homicide investigations. Robbins' reflections offer a sobering perspective on the "what-ifs" that often haunt those tasked with protecting the community.
Notable Quotes:
-
Donnie Robbins:
"I've worked a lot of homicides over the last 30 years and this is the first one that I had a set of circumstances anywhere close to this... it's one I'll think about for a long time."
[04:07] -
Scott Weinberger:
"If I can't have you, no one will. It's tied to many domestic violence homicides. It often reveals the deeply rooted possessiveness and control that can drive a domestic partner to murder."
[45:37] -
Anna-Sigga Nicolasi:
"Scott Sessions, an innocent, likely had no idea the violent web he was entering when he went to Heather's home."
[46:25]
Conclusion
In this episode of "Anatomy of Murder," Anna-Sigga Nicolasi and Scott Weinberger expertly unravel the complex and tragic case of Scott Sessions and Heather Frank. Through detailed investigation insights and emotional reflections, listeners gain a comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted nature of murder investigations and the profound human stories behind them.
Tune in next week for another compelling episode of "Anatomy of Murder," where more intricate and riveting cases are dissected and explored.
This summary was crafted based on the transcript provided, excluding advertisements, intros, outros, and non-content sections as per the instructions.