E436 Mayoral Messages and a Lemonade Haunting

Summary

Podcast Summary: And That's Why We Drink – Episode E436: "Mayoral Messages and a Lemonade Haunting"

Release Date: June 15, 2025
Hosts: Christine Schiefer and Em Schulz

---

1. Introduction

In Episode E436 of And That's Why We Drink, hosts Christine Schiefer and Em Schulz seamlessly blend chilling storytelling with poignant discussions on current social issues. This episode delves into unsettling events unfolding in Los Angeles, personal updates from the hosts, and a heartfelt exploration of the missing and murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (MMIWG) crisis through the tragic story of Nevaeh Kingbird.

---

2. Current Events in Los Angeles

The episode opens with Christine and Em expressing deep concern over recent tumultuous events in Los Angeles. They discuss widespread protests against ICE operations targeting Latino communities, highlighting the fear and chaos engendered by these actions.

Christine Schiefer [02:25]: "It's just the time of the hour... It feels like if some elected officials are allowed to do whatever they want, then I can keep my air conditioning for a few more minutes."

Em Schultz [03:17]: "It's such a terrifying time and I'm privileged enough to not even have to experience it firsthand, but just seeing what's happening in LA is so scary."

The hosts emphasize the tension between fear of potential violence and the desire to stand up against perceived authoritarianism. They critique the police response, noting a lack of urgency and support for Indigenous communities.

Moreover, they address the spread of misinformation online, where outdated riot footage is being circulated as current events, further fueling public anxiety.

Christine Schiefer [07:32]: "People are intentionally sharing images from the 2020 riots and posting those as current day footage of what's going on in LA."

---

3. Personal Updates and Lighthearted Banter

Christine and Em transition into lighter topics, sharing personal anecdotes about birthdays, pets, and recent activities. A notable segment includes Em discussing upgrades to his dog, Hank, emphasizing responsible pet ownership amidst challenges like dealing with a skunk encounter.

Em Schultz [18:00]: "It's been a really nice, nice, nice week."

They also announce the expansion of their "Yappy Hour" segment to Apple subscriptions, enhancing accessibility for their audience.

---

4. The Dead President's Pub: A Ghost Story

Injecting their signature blend of true crime and paranormal, Christine and Em share a haunted tale about the Dead President's Pub in Somerset, Kentucky. They concoct a fictional ghost story surrounding a character named Lemonade Molery, a notorious prankster whose untimely death turned him into a restless spirit.

Em Schultz [35:52]: "And so one night, while drinking at the bar, Lemonade Molery went down to the bathroom, slipped on some pee next to the urinal, fell, and broke his neck, dying instantly."

Christine and Em humorously critique the pub's presidential-themed menu, advocating for more authentic representations of deceased presidents' favorite foods.

Em Schultz [54:57]: "Here are the favorite meals and foods of every dead president that..."

The segment balances spooky storytelling with playful criticism, maintaining an engaging and entertaining narrative.

---

5. Spotlight on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls: The Story of Nevaeh Kingbird

The heart of the episode shifts to a somber and critical examination of the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (MMIWG) crisis. Christine narrates the tragic case of Nevaeh Kingbird, a 15-year-old from Bemidji, Minnesota, whose disappearance underscores systemic failures and racial disparities in law enforcement responses.

a. Background on Nevaeh

Nevaeh Kingbird was a vibrant, two-spirit Indigenous teenager deeply connected to her community and family. She was passionate about art, fashion, and her cultural heritage.

Christine Schiefer [72:14]: "Nevaeh was the boss of everybody, even me. She was in charge of everything."

b. Disappearance and Circumstances

In October 2021, Nevaeh went missing after attending a party. Initially reported as a runaway, her case quickly lost momentum, with minimal police action despite alarming circumstances.

Christine Schiefer [84:49]: "Teddy was filled with dread... Nevaeh is intoxicated alone outside somewhere."

c. Police Response and Systemic Issues

The hosts critique the police’s delayed and inadequate response, highlighting how societal prejudices contribute to neglecting Indigenous cases.

Christine Schiefer [84:34]: "Daniel Wind says... 'The police... did not treat her case with any urgency.'"

Statistics reveal that homicide is the third leading cause of death among Indigenous girls and young women, emphasizing the urgency of addressing these disparities.

Christine Schiefer [100:06]: "According to the National Congress of American Indians, more than four in five American Indian or Alaska Native women, 84.3%, have experienced violence in their lifetime."

d. Family and Community Response

Nevaeh's family, particularly her sister Lakele and uncle Daniel, mobilize the community despite personal hardships, including a bout of COVID-19 that hindered initial search efforts.

Em Schultz [99:04]: "It's like, this is crazy. It's so sad."

They face numerous obstacles, including misleading rumors and ineffective police investigations, which further complicate the search for Nevaeh.

e. Advocacy and Ongoing Efforts

Nevaeh’s case inspires her sister Lakele to pursue a career as a peace officer, aiming to transform personal tragedy into systemic change. Additionally, Nevaeh's uncle Daniel becomes a passionate advocate, striving to ensure that no other Indigenous person suffers the same fate.

Christine Schiefer [105:38]: "Nevaeh's family will not give up until they find her and bring her home."

The hosts emphasize the critical need for community support, better resources, and systemic reforms to address the MMIWG crisis effectively.

---

6. Conclusion

And That's Why We Drink Episode E436 masterfully intertwines personal narratives, haunting tales, and pressing social issues. Through Christine and Em's candid discussions, listeners gain insight into both the eerie and the urgent, highlighting the importance of awareness and action in combating systemic injustices facing Indigenous communities.

---

Notable Quotes:

• Christine Schiefer [02:25]: "It feels like if some elected officials are allowed to do whatever they want, then I can keep my air conditioning for a few more minutes."

• Em Schultz [03:17]: "It's such a terrifying time and I'm privileged enough to not even have to experience it firsthand, but just seeing what's happening in LA is so scary."

• Christine Schiefer [72:14]: "Nevaeh was the boss of everybody, even me. She was in charge of everything."

• Em Schultz [54:57]: "Here are the favorite meals and foods of every dead president that..."

• Christine Schiefer [100:06]: "According to the National Congress of American Indians, more than four in five American Indian or Alaska Native women, 84.3%, have experienced violence in their lifetime."

• Christine Schiefer [105:38]: "Nevaeh's family will not give up until they find her and bring her home."

---

Resources and Support:

For those moved by Nevaeh Kingbird's story and wishing to support MMIWG advocacy, And That's Why We Drink provides links and resources in their show notes to organizations such as MMIW218 and the Bring Nevaeh Kingbird Home Facebook page.

---

Stay Connected:

To support continuous storytelling and stay updated on crucial social issues, listeners can follow And That's Why We Drink across their social media platforms and subscribe to their expanded content available on Apple subscriptions.

---

Disclaimer: This summary captures the essence of Episode E436 based on the provided transcript, focusing on significant discussions and narratives while omitting advertisements and non-content sections as per the instructions.

Transcript

[Em Schultz]

All right, everyone. Summer's right around the corner. That means people are looking for seasonal jobs or getting seasonal jobs. And look, I had a lot of seasonal jobs growing up. And if you are someone hiring people in those seasonal jobs, whether you're hiring for one of those roles or any other role, how do you find top talent before the competition gets to them? Ziprecruiter.com and right now you can try ZipRecruiter for [e-mail] Drink and immediately after you post your job, ZipRecruiters smart technology starts showing you qualified people for it. So if you are looking for a kite salesman, you might find that I bet you would actually hire me. See a candidate who really shines. ZipRecruiter lets you connect with them ASAP. And you can use ZipRecruiter's pre written invite to apply message to personally reach out to your favorite candidates. As you know, we love ZipRecruiter. We found Eva within hours of even starting our account on ZipRecruiter. It's one of those websites that you might spend very little time on because you will get such quick sample success. So please hear our cry. We love ZipRecruiter. You will too. Gear up for summer with ZipRecruiter's high speed hiring tools and see why 4 out of 5 employers who post on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate within the first day. Just go to this exclusive website address right now to try ZipRecruiter for free at ZipRecruiter.com Drink again that ZipRecruiter.com Drink ZipRecruiter the smartest way to hire.

[Christine Schiefer]

Close your eyes, exhale, feel your body relax and let go of whatever you're carrying today. Well, I'm letting go of the worry that I wouldn't get my new contacts in time for this class. I got them delivered free from 1-800-contacts. Oh my gosh, they're so fast.

[Em Schultz]

And breathe.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, sorry. I almost couldn't breathe when I saw the discount they gave me on my first order. Oh, sorry. Namaste. Visit 1-800-contacts.com today to save on your first order. 1-800-contacts. Well, it's that time of the month.

[Em Schultz]

Here we are again. Wait, like a period?

[Christine Schiefer]

Well, I. Well, almost, but mostly I meant, you know, the part where the world's burning to the ground and all of our civil rights are being trampled and what else?

[Em Schultz]

Oh, not even that time of the month. It's just that time of the hour.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's just the time of the hour. It's the time of the minute ticking clock. My air conditioner's on and I kind of don't care, even though it might make a sound in the background background. But I wanted to wear this grumpy troll sweatshirt and it was too hot to wear without the AC on, so I do apologize. But, you know, it feels like if some elected officials are allowed to do whatever they want, then I can keep my air conditioning for a few more minutes.

[Em Schultz]

You fucking say it. I. This has been such a dastardly week over here in la.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, yeah. You. I'm worried about y' all. I've. I have been keeping an eye on that LA news. It's of kind scary over there, man.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, it's for like, it's. It's so weird because some people in my life are saying like, have like a bug out bag and get ready to leave. And then other. And. But then other parts of me are like, no, I want to stay and you know, protest and fight and be a part of it.

[Christine Schiefer]

And it is a hard line to find, like where, where to step in, where to step away.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, it's. But anyway, I'm. I. There was a protest yesterday at City hall that was, by the way, peaceful, everybody. But just in case you have been living under a rock or in Iraq.

[Christine Schiefer]

Or another country where, where this is not happening right now. Yeah. But the whole world is watching, so, you know, you're probably right. Most people know about it.

[Em Schultz]

If you happen to be Xenon and you've been on Planet Glorp for a while, let me just fill you in that LA is having protests right now because ice and also people cosplaying as ice, unfortunately, it's a bit of both have been going into Latino communities and they have been rounding up people, kidnapping them, let's be perfectly honest, putting them into a lot of times unmarked vans instead of just like properly detaining them, which that doesn't even make sense because a lot of these people are doing the right things to.

[Christine Schiefer]

They're getting these people from work. Like it's, you know, I saw elementary school graduation, elementary school graduations. Like they're pulling people out of their workplace. They're doing this intentionally to cause fear and mayhem and chaos and just rubbing our everyone's face. Like the authoritarianism, it's like sickening and horrific. And the day this comes out is, is the day after Donald Trump's birthday, which is the day that a lot of these like counter protests are happening and so who even knows what it'll.

[Em Schultz]

Look like by the time this.

[Christine Schiefer]

I mean, I accidentally, I seriously accidentally stumbled in. I was looking on Facebook to find like an event page for the one in my town and I found a forum of people in the truth and Patriotism, some group, like talking. And they said, look what we've discovered, this thing. And all these people are saying, well, this is where the civil war will really begin. And I'm like, what? Like, nobody's asking for a civil war. We're just asking you to stop kidnapping our neighbors. Right? Like, like Jesus Christ.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. So we've, we've all been testing, we've been protesting because it's, it feels, I'll say it, a little Gestapo. Y. Yeah, it feels very Gestapo.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. No due process. I mean, that's not how this country is supposed to work, man.

[Em Schultz]

And full blown bigotry because they're just going into brown communities and they're just saying, well, we'll figure it out later. If you're actually a legal resident here.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

And even if you are, that doesn't, that won't stop us. Maybe we'll keep you anyway. I don't know, it's. It's such a terrifying time and I'm privileged enough to not even have to experience it firsthand, but just seeing what's happening in LA is so scary. I feel so bad for the families going through it. And if you are able to protest, if you are able to get organized, if you're able to help in any way, either be on the ground or a lot of people are off site buddies in case people are getting arrested and you can be the, the check in person, and if so they don't check in with you, you call the police on their behalf or you call a lawyer for them on their behalf. However you can help, you have rights.

[Christine Schiefer]

And I think a lot of this is an attempt to, to instill fear and make us feel like, oh, that they're in charge, we're not, but there are more of us than them and you do have rights, whether they believe it or want you to or not. So. Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Yes. And the fact that. Sorry, I don't mean to keep interrupting.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh no, I keep interrupting you.

[Em Schultz]

No, we're both in the same headspace. It's just the. On top of everything, the, you know, Trump going around Newsom to be able to bring in the National Guard and deploy literal Marines to. And calling it an insurrection, by the way. Right. Where was the center on January 6th? All those people got fucking pardoned.

[Christine Schiefer]

By the way, insane.

[Em Schultz]

So it's, it's just really terrifying to know that these protests have been peaceful. Everyone in LA are, we're all telling each other non stop, like, whatever you do, don't do, don't. They're inciting violence or trying to incite violence so like don't feed into it. They want a riot, they want a reason for why he did this.

[Christine Schiefer]

Right.

[Em Schultz]

Everyone is actively being hypervigilant on how peaceful these protests are. I'm getting calls from physical. Yeah, I'm getting calls from people on the other side of the country thinking that like the whole place is on fire and we're, we're not doing anything. Whatever you're seeing on.

[Christine Schiefer]

Also on that note, apparently a lot of people, especially on the far right, have been intentionally sharing images from the 2020 riots and, and posting those as current day footage of what's going on in la. And it's so easy to debunk, but once it's spreading around the Internet, people just see what they want to see, you know?

[Em Schultz]

Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

So it's, it's really disturbing and scary. I mean, it's a blaze told me yesterday, like, this is the first time in a while that we've been genuinely like, things are really, I mean, I wouldn't say first time in a while, but first time that it's sort of like we gotta do something. I don't, I don't even know. It's like so scary and daunting. But like, who else is gonna do it? You know? We all gotta step in, I guess.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. Anyway, I'm glad you said something because I wanted to say something. I had, I wasn't even going to.

[Christine Schiefer]

I just, it just like came out. I said time of the month and then I went. Well, I, I also, my period's about to start, so that's not wrong either.

[Em Schultz]

And have you heard about like Granite Thunberg and all that too?

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh my God, this is like, what is happening this year is like rivaling 2020 already. And you remember 2020. A lot happened that year.

[Em Schultz]

I sure do. Anyway, it's, I, I had something much more eloquent prepared. I was actually going to talk. Sorry, no, no, no. But I pushed you into this. No, I, I, I, I kind of blanked. Anyway, so thanks for helping me through that. I just, I don't, I know, don't. I feel like I have a million things to say and nothing I know at all. So just know that we are not silent about this. We're not going to be silent. About this and we are doing our part. And yeah, it's just really dark learning.

[Christine Schiefer]

And it's a dark. We're listening, we're learning, we're growing, we're shrinking away from the horrors of the world.

[Em Schultz]

If there's anything you can do. I know I'm not speaking for you, but I already know you well enough to know that this is what would be happening. Both of us, intermittently, I'm sure, on our socials will be posting, like, ways you can help or like, you know, we are aware of what's going on and if there's any way that people can help or if we can be a resource, let us know what else we can do. And it's just. It's just scary. And I hope everyone, especially the Latino community, is doing okay, so.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, me too, me too. So we'll hopefully we can put some resources as well in the show notes.

[Em Schultz]

I didn't throw that on you either, Christine. I just.

[Christine Schiefer]

No, no, no. I think that's a good idea to do, though. I was gonna mention it anyway, just to have it in a, you know, one spot and that way all of us can throw in our own.

[Em Schultz]

You know what we should also do? I'm like, imposing work on myself already, but I feel like maybe in the show notes we should also, like, write down, like, what your rights are, you know.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Well, there.

[Christine Schiefer]

We could also, like, link to, like a.

[Em Schultz]

Yes.

[Christine Schiefer]

What was that? What was that? I say with full awareness of what that was a dog toy when I hear one.

[Em Schultz]

Sorry, I didn't mean to give us more work, but however, you know.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, no, I think that's.

[Em Schultz]

We can definitely post a link.

[Christine Schiefer]

Maybe we link to, like a list of. Of. Of do's, don'ts.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

Rights as a citizen, etc.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, yeah, we should definitely compare notes. We should compare notes, you and me, on, like, what you're hearing on the east coast versus what I'm hearing over here.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, God. I mean, honestly, I think most of my feed is very LA heavy, so I don't think I'm hearing much different.

[Em Schultz]

Like, okay, cool.

[Christine Schiefer]

Most of the people I'm following the updates are LA people, so I feel like I'm kind of following from afar and I don't obviously watch, like, TV news or anything, so I don't really know what the old fogies on Fox News are saying, but I'm sure it's not something I want to listen to.

[Em Schultz]

I do. Because all of a sudden any old fogies, any Fox News fogies in my family have all of a sudden reached out and suddenly care about me and I'm like, well, you voted against. Really, you voted against quite a lot of my values and. And also you voted for this exact thing that's happening right now. He. He talked about this in his campaign.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, we know that. Please don't be surprised to happen. Right, guys?

[Em Schultz]

Anyway, I didn't mean to be such a bummer coming up. I brought it up.

[Christine Schiefer]

Listen, my fault other than that.

[Em Schultz]

Christine, I wanted to ask you how your birthday was.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, thank you for asking. First thing I wanted to mention earlier and I forgot immediately, even though I told em right off the top I was gonna say it and I forgot and started talk period. And then I started talking about insurrections.

[Em Schultz]

Sure.

[Christine Schiefer]

And the lack of them. So I. We have this yappy hour which is what we do every week after the episode. We go on Patreon and let off some steam and talk about something silly. Usually something we talked about earlier in the episode. Like maybe, I don't know, we take some sort of quiz, personality quiz or we show like show and tell, you know, the haunted pictures I've got recently or we talk about Hank or whatever it might be. And that is staying the same on Patreon. But it's also now available on Apple subscriptions. So if you prefer that platform over Patreon, you can also access it via the Apple podcast app, which I don't necessarily use. So I don't know what the layout or the format, but it's pretty cool. Our team, Megan, Katie, Eva have been working really, really hard on getting this set up and, and so we're really excited about it. But it's more. Makes it more accessible to more people. So if that's something you prefer, we can send. We will be sending those episodes and well, you'll see, we'll post about it. It'll be pretty clear pretty soon, but it's kind of exciting. So if you want to listen to the app, the hours but don't want to go into Patreon, you can do that through Apple.

[Em Schultz]

Yes. And Hank and his toy on the floor are great.

[Christine Schiefer]

And don't you want more of that after you listen to this real quick. I just want to say that I did have a wonderful bir birthday that I'm gonna ask about yours but I went to Blaze Blaze playing this like fun surprise trip to Lake Cumberland with it was my mom, Tim Alexander, he flew in and then Aunt Lisa and Sherry and they all came in and we did like my stepdad brought his boat and Leona got to go boating and, you know, we went magnet fishing, Whereas you. Whereas when. Which is when you drop a giant magnet into the river and then see what you pull up.

[Em Schultz]

Just know that that was your fucking jam. Oh, I.

[Christine Schiefer]

There's a photo of me I posted, actually, with all the resources or a resource to an event that I posted on Instagram as Clickbait, because I knew that if I just posted the, like, rally information, it just wouldn't get any traction on the main feed. So I was like, here's me, magnet fishing. Not that anyone knows what that is.

[Em Schultz]

That sounds like. It sounds like a lot of fun.

[Christine Schiefer]

Thank you.

[Em Schultz]

It is. Was that Leona's first time on a boat?

[Christine Schiefer]

No, she's been on it one other time, but this time she really got into it and she was cap for a few minutes and only when the boat was off and we went treasure hunting because there had been that tornado. So there were a lot of weird items in the water. It was a very strange.

[Em Schultz]

It was perfect time for your magnets.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. Honestly, that part was more interesting. But, yeah, it was great. I do want to give a quick shout out because I promised I would do this and I, as you know, never forget about my promises. Just kidding. But I did write this one down, which is that we went to which Blaze had already planned a visit to the Paranormal Road Trippers Nightmare Gallery, which is in Somerset, Kentucky, right near where we were staying. And it's run by this local high school teacher and his wife. He's a paranormal investigator, and his name is Zach Bales.

[Em Schultz]

Shut the up, Lisa.

[Christine Schiefer]

Literally. So it was an amazing museum. It's free, it's like, donations, and it's so professional. He did it all himself. They have a lot of movie props, which I felt like I need to ask you about, of horror movies that had connections to the central Kentucky area. Then he talked about what he called the Blue Bluegrass Triangle. And I think he named it, but it's like this triangle in Kentucky.

[Em Schultz]

Like the Bermuda Triangle, but yes, but a bluegrass triangle.

[Christine Schiefer]

And I was like, I am so into this. I'm so into this. And he said at the end, kind of like, you know, it's a bummer growing up in Appalachia and having all this history in town and folklore and even alien stories and true crime and everything. And he's like, but, you know, we don't really get any of the Bigfoot, like, credit or anything like that. Like, they had Bigfoot cast, you know, footprint cast and stuff. And he said, you know, it's A bummer, people. And I said, well, I'm gonna do my best to change that. So I want to say right here that thank you, Mr. Bales, for your awesome museum and for spreading the folklore around the Kentucky. The Kentucky folklore and legends. And also sorry that my Aunt Lisa accused you of having a fake name. I know that that was very rude, and you were really caught off guard, and your own brother had to say, nope, that's his name. And I do apologize. But it was because she thought of Zach Baggins and was like, there is no way that's a coincidence.

[Em Schultz]

I know that Blaze, either one, has been holding on to this place for so long in his back pocket. Or two, when he saw the paranormal. What was it called again? Give a shout out.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, it's called the Paranormal Road Trippers Nightmare Gallery.

[Em Schultz]

Okay.

[Christine Schiefer]

The Paranormal. Yeah, the Praying.

[Em Schultz]

The Praying. Well, I feel like when he saw the Pring for the first time and then he saw Zach Bale's name to it, I know he was kicking his feet in the air.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, I was like, I've done it.

[Em Schultz]

This is exactly the spot. Wow. So. And how did Leona feel about that? Or was it a.

[Christine Schiefer]

So she actually did not attend that. She went to a fun little water park with Blaze, and they had their own good time, but we got a great.

[Em Schultz]

Oh. Even Blaze was like, I found I.

[Christine Schiefer]

Actually have some busy things to do in the water park by myself. And they had. He had, like, a collection of haunted items. He'd been all over. He'd been a Crescent hotel. He'd been to Europe and seen haunted places there. He had, like, tchotchkes from all over the world and haunted dolls that people give him and, like, ooh. The whole thing was pretty wild. So it was very cool. If you're in the area, central Kentucky area, please make it a visit on your road trip. And, yeah, m. I would love if you looked into the bluegrass triangle. I don't know if that's a real thing, but maybe Zach can send you some info, or at least we can take a picture of his exhibit and you can use that for information.

[Em Schultz]

Sure, sure.

[Christine Schiefer]

How was your birthday?

[Em Schultz]

It was good. It was. It was different because everyone was out of town, including Allison, so. Nope. Because I have Hank. He did. What did he do for my birthday? Oh, he actually did do something for my birthday for myself. I bought a screen door for the. Like, one of those magnet screen doors for the back so he could, in theory, use the backyard. If we keep the door open because it's tall enough, he Wouldn't be able to jump out.

[Christine Schiefer]

Right.

[Em Schultz]

And when I say backyard, it's like a tiny little patch of grass, but at least he can, like, pee and stuff like that. And for my birthday, that on that day, he learned to use the screen door, which up until then, he was terrified to try it. We know he doesn't like doors. And so as of my birthday, he now can go outside by himself.

[Christine Schiefer]

That's amazing.

[Em Schultz]

It's really lovely. Especially because he already was a really good dog about nuts, waking me up in the morning to go to the bathroom. But now I have an alarm to just get up and open the door, and then I go back to sleep, and I never get bothered at all. So. Oh.

[Christine Schiefer]

And then. Yeah. Oh, my gosh. That's a really good setup.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. Downside, on my birthday, he learned to dig, and we have a crater in our yard now. That's cool.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, that's going to be hard. That's a hard one to break them of.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. He also learned humping at the dog park, so we're trying to as well. Anyway, so that's the Hank update. And then for my birthday, other than that, I had one, two friends come over and surprise me with lunch. And they had. We all had lunch together. And then I saw another friend for dinner, and then in between, I went to Universal, which I. I've always wanted to start taking more advantage of because I'm, like, so lucky to live 15 minutes away from an amusement park. Right. And there are times where I'm like, oh, man, I really wish I could just go ride a roller coaster and then come back and. Fun fact, there's only certain roller coasters I'm allowed to ride anymore because of my heart. But all my favorites are still, like, the ones that don't, like, they're still acceptable, so.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, good.

[Em Schultz]

I'm just gonna.

[Christine Schiefer]

So like the teacup one?

[Em Schultz]

No, that one would actually fuck me up, actually.

[Christine Schiefer]

I was gonna say, actually, that one makes me so nauseous.

[Em Schultz]

Anyone with anything with, like, a G force where, like, you have to, like, pull your own body weight is a. Is. Is a no go for me. But great. Like, all the slow ones, like the. Or like the VR ones, like.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like the more experiential ones.

[Em Schultz]

Yes, Immersive.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, immersive.

[Em Schultz]

So anyway, I. I got myself a Universal season pass because I had so much fun walking around. I was like, there's no reason why I can't make this part of my regular thing whenever I need a day off. And it was also a gift to Me, because I'm trying to. I told you this already. But I'm terrified of turning him into a dog with separation anxiety. So I needed a reason to leave for several hours. And so now getting myself a season pass, I'm actually being a good dog owner because I.

[Christine Schiefer]

That's exactly what they recommend in the books. Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Is that true or no?

[Christine Schiefer]

No, no, Tobias. Season pass to Universal. Not quite. But I'm sure there are other related, related tips and tricks.

[Em Schultz]

Well, anyway, that's, that was, that was my birthday. Did you get a cake or a yummy meal?

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, yeah, we got a couple cakes. My mom made me my classic. I'll post it online. My classic birthday cake from when I was little that has a marzipan gnome on the top with some mushrooms and some grass. And she and Leona made it, but they put it on before the marzipan, before the cake had fully cooled. So it kind of like melted into this, like, creepy looking. I loved it. And when I was little, there's a very, there's quite a traumatic story behind that cake that I will not go in. Hey, maybe I'll tell in the yap yard. There's a traumatic story about this cake when I was little. But essentially every time, every few years, my mom, like remakes it for me to be like, now you can have any piece you like. So it was sweet. And then Blaze got a cake somewhere in Somerset, Kentucky. I don't, I don't know where, but.

[Em Schultz]

From Zach Bales, from Zach Bale's Bakery.

[Christine Schiefer]

And it was delicious. So, you know, it's been a really nice, nice, nice week. Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Do you, do you have. I'm only, I know, like, usually this is where my story is short. So I, I, I don't mind taking up a little more of your time. I wanted to ask, outside of the state of the world, do you have a reason why you drink or is that it?

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, I mean, Gio got fleas, but I know you've been there and you've had an even more skunk related instant incident based on your Instagram. So I don't even want to go into the dog woes. But the flea thing was really a nightmare with no, it is a cat.

[Em Schultz]

You're allowed to. And like, for sure.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, the bedding. And then we were traveling and like, we had to put him at doggy or like to a dog sitter. And we were like, we have to treat him before that. And oh my Lord, I mean you. Anyway, now you know how it is, right? We could, we can commiserate.

[Em Schultz]

I feel worse for you, though, because you have multiple animals.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, the cats were a pain, but honestly, they're. They're all right.

[Em Schultz]

You also have a much bigger house. Like, I mean, I promise I could complain forever about having to clean my house, but at the same time, it's like, at the end of the day, like, two rooms, and I have no carpet, so I feel like you're rugs.

[Christine Schiefer]

And the pillows and. Oh, my God.

[Em Schultz]

So you have a much bigger ordeal than I do.

[Christine Schiefer]

I'm a much, like, more low key about it, so I'm just like, whatever, as long as I get the fleas out, get it clean enough, get them out, get them off us. Our stuff. I try not to panic, but, you know, we're good. We're good now.

[Em Schultz]

And. Yes.

[Christine Schiefer]

And I'm drinking this juice, by the way, because I wanted to give vegetables to my body for once.

[Em Schultz]

Oh, brilliant.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, wow.

[Em Schultz]

34 is looking on the up and up.

[Christine Schiefer]

I need it.

[Em Schultz]

Um, and yes, Hank did get skunked. I. We both still wreak. That's why the windows are open.

[Christine Schiefer]

I can't imagine that. Fortunately, it apparently lasts a long time. Yeah. Yeah. That's something I don't know about.

[Em Schultz]

We went to the. I mean, he also. It happened direct. Like, he was smelling the butt of the skunk as if it was a dog. So it was like looking down the eye of the barrel of a gun and just directly into his face. And then he jumped on me because he was scared. He rubbed on everything. So all of our. Every cushion is in the wash for the fourth time. It still reeks. And we've done all the baking, so I promise I have.

[Christine Schiefer]

I'm sure you've done a remedy. Remedy. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But it's like the candle wax spill. We've tried all the candle wax filler remedies, thanks to you all. It was so helpful.

[Em Schultz]

It was so embarrassing, though, because I thought I finally, like, maybe I didn't smell like skunk and he didn't smell like skunk anymore. And, like, I'm getting too used to the smell in this house. But then we went to the dog park yesterday, like, 10 people. Is there a skunk around here? Is there a skunk around here? And I was like, oh, no, we're the smelly kids, Hank.

[Christine Schiefer]

At least they don't know. At least they're like, it could be someone. You're like, yeah, who knows?

[Em Schultz]

Okay, last thing. I swear to God. I know that this is going our usual amount, actually, but good Reason why I drink. I got a message from Mayor Max.

[Christine Schiefer]

No, you didn't.

[Em Schultz]

The mayor of Idlewild, The Little Golden.

[Christine Schiefer]

Was it for your birthday?

[Em Schultz]

No. Apparently, Mayor Max, because he's a dog and doesn't know how Instagram works. Mayor Max did not know that people were DMing him. I guess don't totally know, but I guess at some point when we mentioned Mayor Max in a previous episode, we, like, tagged them, or I tagged them, and so it showed up in their DMs. And all of a sudden, I got a message saying, like, I don't know what you posted, but, like, we wanted to say hi or something like that. And I went, this is the best day of my life. I'm obsessed with Mayor Max. And Mayor Max gave me their personal number to arrange a visit to meet Mayor Max. Happy what birthday? To me. I have Mayor Max's number.

[Christine Schiefer]

You are, like, famous or something.

[Em Schultz]

I know he's famous, and I'm just. I'm not worthy.

[Christine Schiefer]

You're just one degree away. Where do you get to go? When do you get to go? Or do you not?

[Em Schultz]

I haven't planned anything. I. I know, like, they host, like, events where, like, Mayor Max. It's like, it's a thing that Mayor Max is going to be there. But they, like, in the message, it. I mean, I could read it if you want. It just says, like, if you want to arrange a visit or if you want to stop by for an event or whatever works, just call us. And I went. Because I mentioned that. Anyway, I'm very excited. I told Mayor Max that I have custom shirts from our listeners. People have sent me merch of Mayor Max. Yep. So I said, I'm a big fan. We talk about them on the show, and it just became a thing. So very exciting.

[Christine Schiefer]

Listen, that's huge news.

[Em Schultz]

So that's why I drink.

[Christine Schiefer]

What are you drinking?

[Em Schultz]

I'm drinking an iced tea with a lot of brown sugar in it.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, that sounds good.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, I have way too much brown sugar. So we're going through it at the end.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's gonna be a nice, gritty little mess.

[Em Schultz]

I kind of love it. Oh. Oh. You know what's wild? I hate the feeling of sand, but when it's sugar in my mouth, I'm like, oh, sand. Did you like that? No.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay. No.

[Em Schultz]

Christine, I actually can't record tomorrow because I have a doctor's appointment. And guess What? I used ZocDoc. I used ZocDoc. I'm very excited about it. I'm finally getting this Cough checked out.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yay.

[Em Schultz]

It's been, you know, a casual almost two months.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's been, I've been suffering for a.

[Em Schultz]

While about this and nobody else, not even me, so. But luckily with Zocdoc I was able to find someone who can help me with this. I'm very excited and if this doesn't work, then I'll, you know, go to an allergist or someone else and I'll use ZocDoc for them.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, it's the best. Sockdoc is a free app and website where you can search and compare high quality in network doctors and click to instantly book an appointment. We're talking about booking in network as in insurance appointments with more than 100,000 doctors across every specialty from mental health to dental health, primary care, urgent care and more. Whatever M's ailment comes up with next.

[Em Schultz]

You know, there's always, there's always a new one. Yeah, you can, you can filter for doctors who take your insurance are located nearby are a good fit for any medical need you have. If you happen to have also been coughing for two months, zocdoc is going to help you. Once you find the right doctor, you can see their actual appointment openings. Choose a time slot that works for you and click to instantly book a visit.

[Christine Schiefer]

Stop putting off those doctor appointments and go to Zocdoc.com drink to find and instantly book a top rated doctor [e-mail].

[Em Schultz]

Drink Zocdoc.com Drink.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay, so I've talked about this before, but OCD as we hopefully all know, is so much more than stereotypes. It's a serious and highly misunderstood condition. I am unfortunately someone who suffers from ocd. But I have found no CD to be an incredible resource for me and I've been recommending it for years. So I'm really, really proud that they're one of our sponsors.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. Not every therapist understands OCD or is qualified to treat it effectively, which can make it difficult to find the right help. But it doesn't have to be that way. OCD is highly treat with specialized type of therapy called ERP or exposure and response prevention. And I have seen up close and personal sometimes Christine, you know, taps on the notes in the Google Drive and has, has some, some tendencies that, that.

[Christine Schiefer]

We look at this Google Doc. Am I clicking we we?

[Em Schultz]

No, you're not.

[Christine Schiefer]

Look at me go. NOCD is on the move making my life better one clickety click at a time.

[Em Schultz]

So proud of you. With NOCD you can do live virtual ERP therapy. With licensed therapists who specialize in ocd. NOCD therapists are highly trained, so they really understand OCD and won't judge you no matter what your thoughts are about or if you're like, Christine, what? You're like, random tapping on Google Drive documents is all. Yeah, it's okay.

[Christine Schiefer]

No. CD therapy is covered by insurance for over 155 million Americans. If you think you or someone you know might be struggling with ocd, please don't wait to get help. Go to NOCD and book a free call with their team to learn more. That's nocd.com to schedule a free call and learn more.

[Em Schultz]

Well, Christine, I have a story for you. It's very short, but this was recommended to me. Not by Mayor Max, somebody else in my DMs. And I went, oh, that sounds fun. And it worked out because as I told you and I've told everybody many times now, I'm trying to do all 50 states by the time I'm 35. And I gotta get on that because now I got less than two years. So, yeah, one place I haven't been at least since I was a kid and I haven't really experienced is Delaware. So this was a story from Delaware, and it was in my DMs right after Mayor Max and I went, great, perfect timing. I'm going to do this.

[Christine Schiefer]

Let's do it.

[Em Schultz]

It's also lighthearted. Ish. Because of the state of the world, I thought we could all use a silly escape, so.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, good. Glad I'm not doing that.

[Em Schultz]

I got it. Don't worry, everyone.

[Christine Schiefer]

Thanks.

[Em Schultz]

So this is from Wilmington, Delaware, which, by the way, didn't even mean to make this political. But that's the hometown of Joe Biden. Hey. Also their hometown. It's also hometown. It's also the hometown of Aubrey Plaza and.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, okay. I can get behind that.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, see? Okay, we've all got something. Fun fact. If you happen to be going to Bloomington, Delaware, for some reason, they looked up a New York Times article of places that Aubrey Plaza specifically recommends. And she recommends Trolley Square, a cafe called Brewhaha, which I love.

[Christine Schiefer]

I love it.

[Em Schultz]

And then a restaurant called Mrs. Robino's. And then there's a local legend there called the Devil's Road. And number one, ironic, because she was just in Agatha all along, where they're walking the Witches Road. And two, what are the odds I'm doing this ghost story and then find out about a local legend recommended by Aubrey Plaza. So that might be next week's story.

[Christine Schiefer]

Is that the Dover demon?

[Em Schultz]

No, that's Dover. Is. Is Dover. I thought. For some reason, I thought Dover was in West Virginia, but there's a Dover, Delaware. Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, sorry. Dover, Massachusetts. Okay. I always thought it was Dover, Delaware. Okay. So that's so totally separate. I thought that was what the devil's thing was about, but. Wow. Okay, we gotta look into that next, I guess.

[Em Schultz]

Okay. So the story I'm cover. The story I'm covering today is called the Dead President's Pub, and it's in a building that is fun fact. Probably like, up to 220 years old, which is crazy.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

But no presidents actually died here.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh.

[Em Schultz]

In fact, I don't know why it's called Dead President's Pub, especially when it's in the hometown of a living president. Yeah, it's. I think it's just about the vibe in there. Apparently. The decor is. There's a bunch of, like, presidential memorabilia and stuff. So that's kind of okay. Whatever. Sure. It was opened in 1997 by brothers Michael and Stephen Lucy. And before it was a pub, it was thought that this building was actually multiple buildings that over time, kind of got converted into one big building. They were private residences, and then. Sorry for Hank. Yeah. Became their own businesses and then became one big building. But when they were in the basement, they discovered that whatever the buildings used to be, they're assuming a private residence. They found a chapel down there. And I guess back then people would make, like, makeshift chapels for wakes to, like, display the body.

[Christine Schiefer]

And so they use a parlor like a normal person.

[Em Schultz]

Why don't they use a chapel? Like, also fair. But. So they found this whole, like, really creepy room where I guess bodies used to be displayed in wakes. And honestly, maybe it used to be a chapel. Maybe that was, like, one of the businesses maybe.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

But the basement. Yeah. It was a makeshift and fun fact. Down there, they found a large carving of Jesus, which is still down there. Probably because they were too scared to touch it. That's what I mean.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

But it was from the chapel days, and it was. It's this big old car.

[Christine Schiefer]

You don't touch that.

[Em Schultz]

It's just leaning against, like, I'm assuming, like, a stack of Coors Light now or something.

[Christine Schiefer]

You know, they're like, just don't touch the Jesus. Okay. That's just the house rules. House rules.

[Em Schultz]

House rules. Well, in the 1950s, I saw 50s, I saw 60s, depending on the source. But it was a different pub at one point. And when it was this pub, there was a guy that Was a regular there. And I think his last name was Mullery.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay.

[Em Schultz]

I don't. I can't imagine that was his first name, but his last name was Mullery. He's now known as Lemonade. Oh, sure. Also. Also, interestingly, no real reason for why they call him Lemonade. It's just Lemonade. Lemonade Molary.

[Christine Schiefer]

This feels like a really mean joke. Like, why are they not telling me why all these nicknames are happening?

[Em Schultz]

It feels like they found him on Mulberry Street. Like, it's like Lemonade Mullery feels like a friend of Dr. Seuss.

[Christine Schiefer]

Lemonade Mullery went to the pier and sat on a ledge and drank his beer.

[Em Schultz]

Anyways, not his Lemonade.

[Christine Schiefer]

No, that's. That's the big mystery.

[Em Schultz]

Can you imagine a Lemonade who loves beer and a guy.

[Christine Schiefer]

I mean that. I can. I can and I am.

[Em Schultz]

And you say it too.

[Christine Schiefer]

And I'm saying it too.

[Em Schultz]

Well, okay, so in the 50s and 60s, there was this pub. One of the regulars was Lemonade Molary. And he apparently was. Again, I don't understand the source because a lot of these websites were like, he was a prankster. Like, really? He was like a regular who would get really drunk and then throw dishes at the staff.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, good.

[Em Schultz]

And they keep saying, like, he was so well loved by the whole staff. They all thought it was so funny. I was like, really?

[Christine Schiefer]

Really?

[Em Schultz]

I don't think so. Or were they, like, forced into a. The customer's always right situation?

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, exactly. That feels more like what it might be.

[Em Schultz]

I. I guess, like, maybe if he was like childhood friends with the staff and he thought it was funny to, like, prank them. But, like, I can't imagine pranking being like, I'm gonna break all your dishes so you have to buy new ones.

[Christine Schiefer]

Teehee, isn't that funny? Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Not only break them, but I'm going to throw them at your head while you're working and other people. Yeah, yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

And everyone's going to laugh.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

Good time.

[Em Schultz]

Did you ever do any. Did you ever work in food service?

[Christine Schiefer]

No, I didn't. I did. I did a lot of, like, desk stuff for. For my early jobs. I don't know. I worked at a library and I shelved books, like that kind of boring.

[Em Schultz]

Stuff when I worked Chipotle.

[Christine Schiefer]

Chipotle, right.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. That was the only food service I worked.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

It was enough for me.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. I was gonna say, I don't envy those who have there.

[Em Schultz]

The only prank that anyone did at Chipotle which wasn't funny at all. Is that during a rush, the. The people in the back who would, like, be grilling meat, they would say, oh, we ran out of chicken. We don't have any. And then I would. And then they had it. It was. They had it. They just didn't want to cook it, like. And so I don't even know if that's a prank. I think they just didn't want.

[Christine Schiefer]

I was gonna say, yeah, what a good prank.

[Em Schultz]

It felt similar. So they might as well have just an employee throwing or a staff. A customer throwing dishes at us.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. It's just not great.

[Em Schultz]

Well, okay, so that was his whole thing. He would get drunk and then throw things at employees, but nobody kicks him out. And I guess because they never kicked him out, the story has been passed on that they were, like, in on the joke. Okay, well, one night, while drinking at the bar, Lemonade Molery went down to the bathroom, and he slipped on some pee next to the urinal, and he fell and broke his neck and died.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, my God. Imagine what a way to go. Like, that is not what you expect, slipping on someone else's piss and breaking your neck.

[Em Schultz]

I think that's why he's called Lemonade.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, you just. Okay. Remember when I was so mad. I wish I could go back to before I knew that. Honestly, I, like, ignorance is bliss. And everyone else was right. I shouldn't have.

[Em Schultz]

You know what? The older I get, though, the more convinced I am that I will just die from a. A happenstance.

[Christine Schiefer]

Just a ridiculous accident. Yep. Like a freak accident.

[Em Schultz]

I. Okay, so there's a. There's a patch where. When I'm walking, Hank. Where, like, you know, like, on the roads, like, the. When it's painted white or something. For some reason, the texture or the material they use to paint on the roads is so much slicker than the actual road. And so when it gets wet, all of a sudden, it's like a fucking slip and slide. And I imagine in the 1950s, if you go to a downstairs basement bathroom, it's probably a slick cellar floor.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oof.

[Em Schultz]

And I have wiped. I've eaten for sure. On the roads. So, like.

[Christine Schiefer]

Or just ice. I mean, to use, like, a slippery substance. But. Yeah, that sucks.

[Em Schultz]

I. There have been a few times where I've fallen recently because I just slipped on something, and I'm like, there's no way I can judge this person for just slipping on.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, hell no. I don't judge at all. I mean, I'm just sad that it ended up with them. Broken neck. Like, damn, that's bad luck.

[Em Schultz]

Imagine like you are a whole ass person with a whole life and then you slip in some poop and then for the rest of your life, everyone calls that's what Brownie Schieffer, you know?

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, that's insane. And don't start anything. I see what your eyes twinkling over there. And I don't think that I approve.

[Em Schultz]

Of any of this little brownie. Come on. Anyway, I just like, I'm like. Of all the things. But maybe that was a way of getting back because like, if you ever threw dish. If you just threw dishes at my face all the time and then you died, I'd go, well, now you're. I'm gonna remember you for the poop you slept on, you know?

[Christine Schiefer]

Well, now I'm gonna make a shitty nickname for you. Thanks.

[Em Schultz]

So because of, well, let's just say flash forward to the 1990s, because I happened in the 50s or 60s. In the 1990s, the dead president's Pub is opened. And now people are starting to report haunted activity. Which is interesting because there were like 40 years where like there was no activity.

[Christine Schiefer]

Well, so what was it during that time then?

[Em Schultz]

Still there's. There was very little information, so maybe.

[Christine Schiefer]

There was just not anything happening. And then they're like, let's get it up and renovated and open and clean. And then all of a sudden everyone's like, ah.

[Em Schultz]

Maybe my thought too is if, let's say like this was the. It was a pub when lemonade died and now it's finally a pub again. Maybe now it's like back. It's his. Is his expertise. His. His favorite kind of place all over again.

[Christine Schiefer]

Aha. He's like, I know about this.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, because maybe throw shit a sewing business or something before. And he was like, I'm not going to get boring.

[Christine Schiefer]

And also you throw like a piece of thread or a needle and nobody even notices. Like if you thought it's glass, that's different. Or if even if you throw a ball of yarn, like someone might notice, but they'll be like, it just rolled off the table. Like it doesn't strike fear like a glass would.

[Em Schultz]

That's true. Although I will counter your point when you say needles. If they were being thrown, I would be aware of that.

[Christine Schiefer]

I did say that. And I thought to myself, that's not entirely true. That's. There is a more nuanced answer to that. But in general, unless it came near you, you probably wouldn't even notice.

[Em Schultz]

You know, is it interesting that in sewing it's Everything's either incredibly soft or incredibly not.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, that's such a good point. There's not really much in between, is there?

[Em Schultz]

If I were 14, I would consider that the deepest thing I've ever said in my life.

[Christine Schiefer]

I mean, you're 33, and I consider that the deepest thing you've ever said, so I hope that helps.

[Em Schultz]

Thank you. So anyway, yeah, that's what I'm operating under. Kind of similar to you is like, maybe it just, like, wasn't a happening spot until the 90s, and that's when he decided to come back and. Hang on. I'm just gonna.

[Christine Schiefer]

What is that?

[Em Schultz]

It's. You know what it is?

[Christine Schiefer]

I don't hear anything.

[Em Schultz]

No, no, it's. It's Hank being an.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh.

[Em Schultz]

So here's what I did. Recently. I'm trying out a new thing where I took the cushions off the nook so that he won't want to lie down here.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, that's so smart. Make it less comfy.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, I'm sitting on a pillow right now.

[Christine Schiefer]

You're so smart.

[Em Schultz]

Okay, so. Because again, now that he smells like skunk, every time I want to take him to a kennel, it gets delayed. So. Oh, look who came here with the hardest, loudest toy. You're not gonna lie down?

[Christine Schiefer]

He's like, who can play this game?

[Em Schultz]

He is gonna lie down. Okay, let's see where this takes us. Okay, so far, so good. Okay, where were we? Blah, blah, blah. So now the 90s are here, and all of a sudden, there's haunted activity. Mainly the staff are realizing that dishes are getting chucked at their heads while they're working.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, good.

[Em Schultz]

And so for the obvious, you know, association there, we think it is Lemonade Mullery coming back to continue haunting a bar. Yeah, he'll not just throw dishes head on at staff, but he will also throw glassware. He'll throw ashtrays. He'll throw whatever he can find. And often this activity is then followed by the sound of someone holding back a laughter or just straight up cackling.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, my. What? He's so amused by his own.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, I'm like, you couldn't. I'm sorry.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, that's the funniest. You've got.

[Em Schultz]

A prank gets old.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, that's what. Exactly. And it's like, we weren't really laughing when you did it alive. Like, we were just trying to be nice. And now, like, you're doing it again, like, it wasn't that good.

[Em Schultz]

He kind of strikes me as, like, A guy who goes to a bar and thinks everyone there's his buddy and doesn't realize that, like, they're only nice because he pays them.

[Christine Schiefer]

Right. It's like a read the room boo buddy sort of situation.

[Em Schultz]

Yes.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, read the room lemonade.

[Em Schultz]

You know, you got it. For sure. Well, people will hear this giggling also in the bathrooms. They'll hear it in the stairs, and they sense temperature drops a lot of times. They'll also feel a heavy presence in empty areas. And staff will often hear glasses clinking themselves. And dominoes in the game room have been seen floating in the air. Firm pass.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay. I love that they're floating in the air. I was like, oh, have they been seen, like, tipped over or, like, a domino? You know, I thought it was gonna be, like, something cool, like, just like.

[Em Schultz]

Like a. Like a.

[Christine Schiefer]

But they're just floating around, trying to find the next placement.

[Em Schultz]

Like a nursery mobile in my mind.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, yeah. Just, like, kind of dangling on string.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. Also, so sorry. He's literally right in my face. If I sound off, it's because I'm, like, trying to juggle.

[Christine Schiefer]

Trying not to breathe in the scent.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. And I also. So I. Again, controversial. I don't know if this is, like, everyone's favorite thing in the world, but I found this, like, spray corrector. Have you. Have you heard of that?

[Christine Schiefer]

I don't think so.

[Em Schultz]

It's just, like, I think a can of aerosol, but the sound is supposed to kind of, like, get them, like, to pay attention to something.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, I see it has worked. My mom spray the cats with water with a. With a water. With a spray nozzle if they ran into the street to, like, teach them to not run into the road when we live close to the street.

[Em Schultz]

But it's like that, but sound instead of water in the face. He's terrified of water. That would be extra cruel, I think.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, true.

[Em Schultz]

But it's this, like, pet spray corrector, and you're only supposed to use it, like, when they're, like, really not listening to you. But the last few times that he's tried to put his hands on the dining room table and I sprayed it, he, like, won't go near it now.

[Christine Schiefer]

So hopefully he's like, that thing makes crazy sounds.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. So I think we've solved our crisis, by the way. That. Wow, it's finally happening.

[Christine Schiefer]

Well, that was just.

[Em Schultz]

He just went outside.

[Christine Schiefer]

I was gonna say don't jinx it, but it sounds like it's working anyway.

[Em Schultz]

I'm sorry. This is, like, the most zigzag story today. I'm just trying to get through it with him.

[Christine Schiefer]

No, listen, I love it. I hope everyone else loves it too, but I do.

[Em Schultz]

I appreciate everyone being so patient. It's just, it's a. We're all learning together.

[Christine Schiefer]

We're all kind of in hell, first of all. And second of all, we're all learning together what Em said.

[Em Schultz]

Well, okay, so the. It's kind of the last part I have of Lemonade Mullery is that. Yeah. Glasses get thrown at people. You can hear them clinking, which is terrifying because that feels like he's almost tempting fate of like it's like clink, clink, like clink, clink.

[Christine Schiefer]

Look what I can do.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. It's like that's what I. Yeah, I could send it on its way right now if you'd like.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, I don't like that. That seems like what it's saying.

[Em Schultz]

And then you go in the game room to like take a breath and the dominoes are dancing around you. Oh God.

[Christine Schiefer]

And they're like take a nap. Little baby spinning around.

[Em Schultz]

Sometimes the laughter. Because remember you hear laughter, it starts as a faint light hearted laugh elsewhere in the building and then quickly gets closer and louder to you hate that good it had. It was literally described by one source as childlike and then maniac. Like.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, I don't know what's worse. Probably maniac.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, probably maniac. But either I'm never coming back in.

[Christine Schiefer]

The building, but either one's really not fun.

[Em Schultz]

Other than the laughter. People have also heard screams in the pub, especially where Lemonade Mulleria is said to have died. So imagine you've it's. You got it whipped out by the urinal and then you just hear a scream.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh my God. I would never pee by that in that spot. I don't think. I think I'd be way too pee in there.

[Em Schultz]

Lemonade makes himself most known to. To the staff when they're closing up at night, AKA when they're alone. Great.

[Christine Schiefer]

And when they're probably so exhausted and really just want to go home. Imagine this guy really needs to lear to like respect a boundary every now and then, you know.

[Em Schultz]

Awful.

[Christine Schiefer]

Awful.

[Em Schultz]

Anyway, that is literally. They only have one ghost. It's lemonade molery. I actually thought about calling this place and asking them like if they.

[Christine Schiefer]

But you were already on the phone with Mayor Max, right?

[Em Schultz]

I have other things to tend to, you know.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yes.

[Em Schultz]

But I did decide I was going to check their website and while I was checking their website, like I have a grievance that I really need aired out that, yes, they're listening. I'm about to change their world, actually. Am I not to give unsolicited advice? But it's great unsolicited advice.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. So listen up. Whatever it is, I can't wait.

[Em Schultz]

Here's the situation. It's called the Dead Presidents Pub.

[Christine Schiefer]

Right, Right.

[Em Schultz]

I looked at their menu. I'm so sorry. Dead Presidents Club. Beyond disappointing.

[Christine Schiefer]

Whoa.

[Em Schultz]

Here's the situation. There's a whole ass menu. There are only like four mentions of presidents. Okay. Here's, here's the ones that are. Everything else is like, okay, but are.

[Christine Schiefer]

We talking four out of how many? Is it like a Cheesecake Factory style or like just a brunch?

[Em Schultz]

So it's, it's like, I mean, it's, it's big enough where there's salads or sandwiches, there's wings, there's.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, wow. Okay. So you've got like different categories, and across all categories, there are only four presidential themes. See, it's like, yeah, you eat either go all in or you just don't go in at all, you know?

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, just call it something else then.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, or just have a president section where you're like, this is all the President jokes.

[Em Schultz]

Like the presidential menu.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, yeah, yeah. That should be the one for kids, you know?

[Em Schultz]

Here are all the political options you can get on the menu. There is the Kennedy melt. There is the voter's choice burger, which isn't a present.

[Christine Schiefer]

What?

[Em Schultz]

There's the Garfield's Garden burger. So that's two Kennedy and Garfield.

[Christine Schiefer]

Was he a vegetarian? Because if not, that would probably piss him off in the grave, my friend.

[Em Schultz]

I looked it up. His favorite food was squirrel.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay, we can officially agree that our brains have unfortunately merged into one. Second of all, what the fuck? Third of all, continue, please.

[Em Schultz]

Third of all, I was going to say none of the President's fun fact have ever openly been vegetarian. Although the closest that we can assume were heavy plant eaters were Thomas Jefferson and Woodrow Wilson. Fun fact.

[Christine Schiefer]

Wow. Thank you. See, this is the kind of information I'm here to learn. And you know what else? Let's start a rumor that Donald Trump is a vegetarian. A vegan. Oh, it would kill him.

[Em Schultz]

His favorite food is McDonald's, actually literally on listicles. His favorite food is McDonald's.

[Christine Schiefer]

He's a Sabaro pizza slice. Probably I, I with no comment.

[Em Schultz]

Okay, so anyway, we've got Kennedy melt. We've got Garfield's Garden burger. We've got the bull moose, which is a. Thanks a Thanksgiving sandwich. And for those who don't know, Bull Moose is like something Teddy Roosevelt started. So Teddy Roosevelt doesn't even get his own name.

[Christine Schiefer]

Isn't that a nickname?

[Em Schultz]

I think. Isn't that the name like the Progressive Party?

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, maybe that's what it meant. Yeah, I think he was called. Oh, yeah, he said he boasted that he felt strong as a bull moose, so they started calling him the Bull Moose. And then the Bull Moose Party. Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

So we'll give it to him. Sure. There's Kennedy, Garfield and Roosevelt.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay.

[Em Schultz]

And then there's the Tricky Dicks, pretzel nuggets and the chicken Nixon, which means two. Two of them are about Nixon. So there's. That's a.

[Christine Schiefer]

That's all. Whoa, Is it Chicken Nixon was the other one.

[Em Schultz]

And Tricky Dick, which was Nixon. Richard.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, I don't even know that name. Tricky.

[Em Schultz]

That was what they called him.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, okay. So he got two. Nixon, of all people got two.

[Em Schultz]

That's what I'm saying. Nixon is one of the, like the notoriously most hated president.

[Christine Schiefer]

Look like he's literally got fired. What are you talking about?

[Em Schultz]

So you've got a rose, Delaware.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like what?

[Em Schultz]

But he's not dead yet. True.

[Christine Schiefer]

You know what, that's a good point. But then you're right. They gotta fucking commit. I'm sorry. You can't do like four of the dead presidents. If you're going to call yourself like.

[Em Schultz]

You can't have five items and two of them are the same person. It's also like one of the most.

[Christine Schiefer]

Hated people and one of them is voters choice. Whatever that's supposed to mean. It sounds like, like a call to action on American Idol. I don't know.

[Em Schultz]

Yes, exactly.

[Christine Schiefer]

I just, I don't approve of this either. And I didn't think I'd get so heated. But also a Garfield garden burger just because of the gar. Like, if he ate squirrel. You better rethink that or you're going to get a new kind of haunting.

[Em Schultz]

If Garfield was here to order a garden burger, he would not, let's put it that way.

[Christine Schiefer]

He would probably actually do more than not. He would probably. That's like, if I die, squirrel in spite. Out of spite.

[Em Schultz]

If I die and someone made a Schultz salad, I would like really die all over again. I'd resurrect to die again.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like. Like, why would you do that?

[Em Schultz]

So anyway, yeah, there are five mentions of presidents. Two of them are the same person who was. Is also like, not very liked. And by the way, another thing I wanted to Say is that there's a random person who also gets two mentions in this menu named Val because, like, Val's famous Mac and cheese. So I guess it's like Val works in the back. But how come Val gets two and.

[Christine Schiefer]

Well, what. And all the dead white men only get 1m? Is that what you're gonna say?

[Em Schultz]

How come Val and Nixon have the same amount and then nobody else, you.

[Christine Schiefer]

Know, they're bringing Val into the menu?

[Em Schultz]

You know what? You said it. You said it.

[Christine Schiefer]

No, you're right. And it's also weird to give one of the president, one of the presidents, Nixon, two menu item. Like, I still can't get over that. And then, like, Val gets two, but then also, so did Nixon, so. What a compliment. I don't know. It's just weird.

[Em Schultz]

Even worse, the logo of the dead President's Pub is of four dead presidents that aren't even the ones mentioned in the menu. They're just four random other dead presidents. It's. I think. I think it's Ulysses S. Grant. And then there's Thomas Jefferson and both Roosevelts. So I guess one of the Roosevelts.

[Christine Schiefer]

I'm impressed. You know any of that? I would not know not know that. But good job.

[Em Schultz]

Anyway, so here's my. Here's my pitch to the dead President's Pub. Here's my pitch. Okay, first of all, scrap your menu immediately. Expeditiously.

[Christine Schiefer]

Expeditiously with expedition, please.

[Em Schultz]

And my pitch to you, Dead President's Pub, which this is a reason I would go is you should make the menu all of the favorite meals and foods of every dead president that.

[Christine Schiefer]

Except squirrel.

[Em Schultz]

Especially when the day comes that Biden dies, he better have a menu mention in his own hometown of the ducks.

[Christine Schiefer]

An ice cream cone, per chance. It's easy, guys.

[Em Schultz]

Interesting you mentioned that because I looked up every single favorite food and meal of every dead president.

[Christine Schiefer]

Weird luck. And I would literally so insane.

[Em Schultz]

And I would like to read to you the menu if it were up to me.

[Christine Schiefer]

You know what? This is fantastic. Let's go all in. I'm investing in it before you even give me the pitch, so take my money.

[Em Schultz]

Okay. The first one. Thomas Jefferson macaroni and cheese. Why isn't that on?

[Christine Schiefer]

Fucking hell. Easy.

[Em Schultz]

Roosevelt. Who is in the logo? This is Franklin Roosevelt. He's in the logo with no men. You mentioned grilled cheese. Hey, it's not even hard to.

[Christine Schiefer]

Grilled cheese.

[Em Schultz]

This is. This is. I just want to put this one out immediately. This is sinful. Richard Nixon, his favorite food. Remember, he's the one with two menu mentions, and he's a very bad person.

[Christine Schiefer]

Chicken and the balloon. And M and I support Richard Nixon all day. Unfortunately, my. My effects have turned off, so the balloons are nowhere to be seen. But M is really rallying over there at the campaign headquarters of Nixon, and the balloons are just going wild.

[Em Schultz]

Well, since they love Nixon so much over there, you'd think they'd at least have his favorite food on the menu. Guess what it is. It's as awful as him. Cottage cheese with ketchup.

[Christine Schiefer]

That has to be a joke. Is that for real? That's disgusting.

[Em Schultz]

It's so funny.

[Christine Schiefer]

I didn't think I would be, like, as, like, actually physically grossed out as I feel.

[Em Schultz]

So, anyway, let's scrap him again. Expeditiously. Expeditiously.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. Take those two off the menu already.

[Em Schultz]

The ones that we should focus on are macaroni cheese, grilled cheese, and then other options. I'm not going to go through every name, but here's the food of the menu. Corned beef and cabbage. Sure. Fried steak or. Sorry. Corned beef and cabbage. Fried chicken, Steak Virginia ham. Bratwurst with sauerkraut. Beef stew, meat pies, boiled meat and potatoes. Seafood chowder, barbecue and pot roast.

[Christine Schiefer]

Boiled meat.

[Em Schultz]

It was a long time ago, but still, you could have, like, a bratwurst or something.

[Christine Schiefer]

This was bratwurst.

[Em Schultz]

Couldn't have been Warren Harding.

[Christine Schiefer]

Warren Harding.

[Em Schultz]

Bratwurst with sauerkraut.

[Christine Schiefer]

I was gonna say died in 1923. So he never really got to see the 40s. Come on up, because I was like, there's no way anyone from, like, the 40s to the 60s said bratwurst. Anyway. Wow, that's amazing. M. And.

[Em Schultz]

And hang on, I'm not done. Oh, that's the entrees. Okay, here are the sides. Fruit, corn, cornbread, cheese grits, caramelized tomatoes.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay.

[Em Schultz]

Red. Red flannel hash, which is potatoes and beets, I guess. And then Hoppin John, which is a peppers and rice meal. And then for desserts, jelly roll, figgy pudding, rice pudding, chess pie, jelly beans. And when Biden dies, vanilla ice cream.

[Christine Schiefer]

You can't have vanilla ice cream until he's dead. Sorry.

[Em Schultz]

I'm not saying the desserts are the best in the world, but if you wanted to have, like, a living history experience, you could go and get. Get like, all their favorite foods. Hello.

[Christine Schiefer]

Exactly. And you don't even need to necessarily go, like, strictly with what they. Their favorite food. Like, you could even stretch it to, like, oh, the name is like, a Clever take on something. I mean, you know, there are other ways to do this. Like Biden my time. Okay, that's stupid. But you know, like a play on some word that makes it this better than chicken Nixon. That's right. Hank Nixon. Chicken Nixon.

[Em Schultz]

Chicken Nixon. Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's not for me.

[Em Schultz]

Or like you could do like even like a mix and Nixon.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. Something.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. I don't know. I'm trying to think of like, I'm trying to think on. On the fly what I would do.

[Christine Schiefer]

For like hash browns with all the Nixons.

[Em Schultz]

It'd be funny if you did like jfk, blt.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, if you just said, now we're talking. But I can even get into beverages. Sam Adams was he, you know, by.

[Em Schultz]

Region, like, oh, they're from Virginia. You could just get like exactly.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like this represents like garden burger. Like, try to explain that to me that it's anything but Gar. And gar.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

And I don't want to be cruel. Like, I'm not trying to bully these people. I'm just saying, you know. Oh, wait, Sam Adams was not a president, was he?

[Em Schultz]

Sorry, no, but he was a. He was in our minds. It's a historical figure. It's like at least I just, I.

[Christine Schiefer]

Wanted to wait for all the people to. I wanted to get ahead of the story, you know, you were trying to.

[Em Schultz]

Get engagement in the comments.

[Christine Schiefer]

That's exactly right. Thank you.

[Em Schultz]

Anyway, I. That's my pitch and that was thank you. And I'm sorry that it was like that, like a very short ghost story. But someone recommended it because I think is his name's Lemonade. And. And I was like, hell, yeah. And we needed something light hearted this week, so there you go.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. A man slipping in his own piss and breaking his neck. It's really the remedy for a tough week, you know?

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. And it's not even a restaurant that's like, like got a special menu. Like, first of all, let's talk about. Val can have a menu option but lemonade can't.

[Christine Schiefer]

I know.

[Em Schultz]

Well, lemonade is lemonade.

[Christine Schiefer]

I mean, exactly. I just, I. I feel that they could just. I feel like if they listen to this, I will melt into the ground and never want to be seen alive again. So I am treading on some thin ice here. But I, I feel like you've really brought a lot of inspiration to the table.

[Em Schultz]

And I don't care if they hear, I will happily not melt into the ground. I'm. I am handing you on a silver platter. A great idea. A great idea.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

And if you don't take it, then when lemonade throws another dish of your head, I can't say it wasn't deserved, you know?

[Christine Schiefer]

You know what, maybe that's what will finally appease him, you know?

[Em Schultz]

You know, at the very least give him an item on the menu so like people will order and talk about him. Or like give him a page.

[Christine Schiefer]

Be like, oh, what's the story about this? And then it has like a little blurb, you know, you literally can't put.

[Em Schultz]

Something on the maze that says lemonade. Mullery. You can't put lemon. Are you kidding me?

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, oh, the guy who slipped in someone else's piss and everyone's like, yum, Lemon.

[Em Schultz]

No one has to know.

[Christine Schiefer]

No one has to know.

[Em Schultz]

But you know, you could eat with a lemonade. Mullery. A brownie Schieffer.

[Christine Schiefer]

Stop. That's where I draw the line, my friends.

[Em Schultz]

The end. That is the dead President's Pub.

[Christine Schiefer]

That was fantastic. Well, you know, M always craving their next action packed adventure. And thankfully Audible delivers thrills of every kind on Em's command. From electrifying suspense and daring quests to spine tingling horror and romance in far off realms. Unleash M's adventure aside with gripping titles.

[Em Schultz]

That keep you guessing. Exclusive captivating Audible originals and hotly anticipated new releases. Plus best listened bestsellers that hook you from the first minute. Whether it's heart pounding suspense like an Audible original, mad love, a fantastic romance adventure like Onyx Storm or elicit with a light on epic like Stephen King's latest number flinch. If you like adventure and I know you do, then what are you doing? Gone over to Audible and give your ears a spin.

[Christine Schiefer]

I'm listening to Demon Copperhead right now. Freaking amazing. Barbara Kingsolver if anybody is interested. The Audible version is amazing. So start listening and discover what's beyond the edge of your seat. New members can try Audible now free for 30 days and dive into a world of new thrills. Visit audible.com drink or text Drink to 500.

[Em Schultz]

500 that's audible.com drink or text Drink To 500. 500. This week's sponsor is Neon's new film the Life of Chuck. This movie is so good everybody. We got to see it a while ago and I'm not kidding. I I it's very few movies would I watch again. I'm going to see this again. I'm going to theaters to watch this. It's it's just such a good movie. The rap calls the life of Chuck Mike Flanagan's best film yet. And Jason Gorber from Collider says it's the best Stephen King film ever made. Can confirm. I don't know who Jason Gorber is from Collider. It might as well say M. Schultz. It really is the best Stephen King film ever made. I'm not kidding. This is such a good movie. Everyone, please, please, please go watch it. If you like Tom Hiddleston, if you like Jacob Tremblay, if you like Karen Gillen, if you like Matthew Lillard, I mean, if, if you like spooky stories. I mean, it's, it's got this air of mystery around it the entire time. It's not as scary as I thought it was going to be, but it actually, the story is incredible. The acting is incredible. Please go check it out. Watch the Life of Chuck now playing everywhere. The Life of Chuck now playing everywhere.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay, so I have, as promised, a continuation of our missing and murdered Indigenous Women and Girls month stories. I forget how I began the sentence, but my point is I am bringing the story I promised. This is the story of Nevaeh Kingbird. And I have a couple notes up top because it's relevant to the story. And I know we've talked about what the term two spirit means, but I, I figured we could just refresh anybody who doesn't know. So, in regards to Nevaeh specifically, her mother says that Nevaeh is two spirit and likes girls. And Saoirse said while researching the case, they found one comment on a forum that said Nevaeh uses they them pronouns. But there was no source for that. And any other sources, including her siblings and parents use she her. And so, you know, it doesn't mean that maybe she never used they them pronouns. But Nevaeh's mother speaks about her two spirit identity with a lot of love and support, but still uses she her pronouns. And because this is siblings do as well, we're just going to go with that today and defer to the pronouns her family uses. And just keep in mind the possibility that perhaps you would have preferred something else. Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

So two spirit itself is a term that's sometimes equated by non native people to mean an indigenous person who identifies as gay or transgender. But that's not exactly true. Two spirit is more. It's something that doesn't have a direct translation. It's a cultural identity. There's no like, one to one comparison. It's more than an indigenous version of being lgbt, you know? You know what I mean? It's a sacred identity, and it's it's something that I think means something very personal to everybody who identifies as that, including Nevaeh. So here is the story for you. Bemidji, Minnesota, is where we're starting. This town gets its name from the Ojibwe word Bemidjigamag, which means where the current cuts across or lake with crossing waters.

[Em Schultz]

Oh, beautiful. I think that's my. That sounded really good on my ears. That was a very lovely sound.

[Christine Schiefer]

Very satisfying word. Bemidji Gamag. I know it, like, tickles the brain in a way. And Saoirse sent, like, a. A video of the pronunciation guide and this person talking about who lived there, talking about the pronunciation, who lives there currently talking about the pronunciation. And every time he said it, I was like, rewind.

[Em Schultz]

Sing songy.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah, yeah. And then they call so Bemidji. So Bemidji Gamag means where the current cuts across. But Bemidji is the name of the town. That's it. But it gets the name from that. So the word describes Lake Bemidji, which is intersected by the Mississippi River. And although the river begins at Lake Itasca, it flows north to Bemidji before turning south and is actually dubbed the first city on the Mississippi because it's the northernmost point of the Mississippi river, and the Mississippi river is, like 2300 miles long. So kind of a cool little.

[Em Schultz]

She's a big girl.

[Christine Schiefer]

She's a big girl, and they're at the tippy top. So kind of a cool little fun fact.

[Em Schultz]

Cool.

[Christine Schiefer]

The town of 15,000 people sits between three Ojibwe reservations. There's the Leech Lake, Red Lake, and White Earth Nations. Now, the Red Lake nations government maintains full sovereignty over itself and its land. And Nevaeh Kingbird was born a member of the Red Lake Nation, and she grew up the third of six children in Bemidji. She was only two years old when her mother, Teddy Wind, which. I think Teddy is such a cute name with an I at the end. Teddy Wind. Isn't that cute?

[Em Schultz]

I. I do. I, I.

[Christine Schiefer]

Speaking of the bull moose.

[Em Schultz]

I know I like it more as a guy's name. I don't know why, but it's always one.

[Christine Schiefer]

I do, too. I like it as a boy name, too. Yeah. But I also like Theo, and I'm like, those are both from Theodore. You know, it's kind of funny, but I like Theo and. And Teddy.

[Em Schultz]

You know what's wild is I. I have a friend who has a Theodore, hates Theo, hates Teddy. And hates.

[Christine Schiefer]

Really. But that's a danger zone because I feel like you can't control the Nick. You can only control the nicknames up to a point. Right. And then.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, and. But here's the thing is I'm. I'm the opposite. Where I love Teddy and I love Theo. Can't stand Theodore.

[Christine Schiefer]

Theodore is not for me. It reminds me of the Alvin and the Chipmunks a little bit.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. Well, yeah, that would make sense. I.

[Christine Schiefer]

You know, one of those little guys.

[Em Schultz]

I have a friend whose last name is Bear and he always wanted to have a son to name Teddy Teddy Bear.

[Christine Schiefer]

I mean, it's hard to give that a polar bear. There's so many options. Grizzly bear, bull moose, Polar would be such a polar is kick ass. Okay, thank you very much. If we have anyone with a listener, with a child named Pole, or if we have any people named Polar listening, let me know because it's pretty kick ass.

[Em Schultz]

Perfect.

[Christine Schiefer]

Hell yeah. So, all right, here we go. She was two years old when her mother, Teddy with an eye, and I imagine a heart over the eye, Teddy Wind and her father. So they got separated when she was just under 2 years old. Old or when she was just 2 years old. As she grew up, she sort of took charge of the household. She was very capable. And her mom explained Nevaeh was the boss of everybody, even me. She was in charge of everything. She made sure of that. And I allowed her to be that way. So she really wanted to keep everyone safe, keep everyone on track, get the house under order, you know, run the show. And she was good at it. She was also really close with her family, especially her siblings. And she would dote on her younger siblings. And even her five year old sister Natalie would fall asleep in her bed every night. Like, she just was really affectionate with these kids. She was actually best friends with one of her sisters, Likle, who was older by just one year. Lake Haley said that Nevaeh was the perfect combination of friend and sister. Quote, just everything in one which is like, makes me cry. That's like a dream, you know, to have that kind of a relationship. Like that's like a once in a lifetime thing.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

Every night, Nevaeh told Lake Haley every detail about her day at school. And likewise, they told each other everything. They planned a future together. Nevaeh wanted to move to New York one day for college and get her bachelor's degree. And so she told Lakele that she planned to go there together with Lakele and they would share an apartment in the city and live together, you know, just like. Like childhood dreams. Nevaeh also loved her culture and nation that she was born into. Teddy said that Nevaeh loved their language. She spoke fluently. And Nevaeh was also a born artist who enjoyed exploring diverse mediums. She painted, she wrote poetry. She used pencils and pastels. Like, she's just a very creative and artsy person. She also was into fashion. She owned a lot of clothes and loved to express herself through, you know, creative outfits. And people really like this about her. She was very much. Even though she was very. How do I put it? Like, capable at home and kind of, like in charge. She was also very approachable, and people really, really liked her. She had this kind of energy that drew people in, and she had a lot of friends for that reason. So she kind of had a very busy life. She was balancing her friendships. She was balancing all her siblings and their family life, and she liked to keep up with everyone and everything. She had social media to help her do that. As a young teenager, Nevaeh was also pretty popular. She was very pretty, and Teddy was a little worried about that because she feared that because her daughter was, you know, traditionally beautiful and was very outgoing, that this might attract people who would want to take advantage of her. An interviewer once asked Teddy if she struggled with Nevaeh being two spirit. And Teddy said she knew from the time Nevaeh was young that Nevaeh was interested in girls and that she supported Ne. Nevaeh fully. But she only disapproved of the people Nevaeh spent time with because they didn't treat her well. Teddy said they were outright unkind to her daughter. And she said she was so afraid of her daughter that she wanted to hide Nevaeh from the world, which sometimes made her feel like a strict parent. But also, you know, she knew she had to give some freedom because otherwise that's just, you know, recipe for disaster.

[Em Schultz]

You don't want to dim her light. Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yes. I mean, yes, exactly. And you don't want to, like, lose their trust or what have you, but. Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

You also don't want others to dim her life.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yes, good point.

[Em Schultz]

That's beautiful. If I were 14. Wow. I would be.

[Christine Schiefer]

Scratch that last thing. You just one upped yourself.

[Em Schultz]

I. I would be telling people, I'm going to go to school for philosophy, for sure.

[Christine Schiefer]

Wow. Wow. And you. And you should. And you can.

[Em Schultz]

And I do. In that lifetime.

[Christine Schiefer]

I do, absolutely. So she did give her, you know, some freedom to explore, make her own choices, and Learn from her experiences. So instead of sheltering her, Teddy actually did something really awesome and enrolled her daughter in boxing and self defense courses.

[Em Schultz]

Okay. I have been saying forever, if I have children at all, especially if they are born female, no questions asked, they're in a self defense class.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. We're waiting for Leona to be four, I think is when they start here. Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Let me tell you something about Leona. Batgirl. I can already tell you. She can. I already know she can.

[Christine Schiefer]

She. She's really all on legs.

[Em Schultz]

A fierce. A fierce kick. A haiya. She's gonna have a haya. I can.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, she's gonna love a haya. With that nugget couch with wobbly mountain in the way. Just. Hi. Yeah. All over the place.

[Em Schultz]

The day that she learns how to, like, throw someone over her shoulder.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, yeah. Fireman, carry, lookout, playground. Want.

[Em Schultz]

I'm telling you, no one's safe when Leona's around. Lightning. Leona.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, my God. Lightning Leona.

[Em Schultz]

Anyway, no, I, I'm so glad to hear that. I, I. Every time I hear someone enrolling their child, especially raised female in self defense, I'm like, I can't think of a better thing to do.

[Christine Schiefer]

I think it's an awesome thing. It's very. As far as I've heard, it can be very. What's the word? Like, emboldening for people, especially if they're insecure or, or, you know, don't feel necessarily capable in that way. I feel like it gives a lot of. What's the word? It, like.

[Em Schultz]

Empowering.

[Christine Schiefer]

Empowering. Thank you. It, like, empowers people. And I, I feel like that's half of it. And then the other half is actual translatable real life skills, like disarming someone.

[Em Schultz]

It's. Yeah, truly. And it's. I think that's the one thing. If I have kids, I've, I've told Allison, like, I don't care if they played in spit. I don't care if they do sports. I don't care about any of that. The only thing I'm going to be strict about is that, that I get them in self defense early. That's.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Kind of my only. My only rule. Everything which I would argue is around.

[Christine Schiefer]

Which I would argue is a sports. So definitely you should get those credits at the element at the middle school or whatever.

[Em Schultz]

Excellent point.

[Christine Schiefer]

Don't let them talk you out of those. If chess is a sport, then martial arts are also a sport.

[Em Schultz]

Boom.

[Christine Schiefer]

We're making some really hot takes here tonight, folks. Okay, so instead of Sheltering her daughter. Teddy did what I think is a really, really smart, smart and awesome parenting move and enrolled Nevaeh in boxing and self defense courses so that Nevaeh would have the confidence and skills to defend herself if necessary. And Nevaeh did struggle quite a bit, despite, you know, the many friendships and the big social circle and the loving family. She was diagnosed with bipolar disorder. She experienced periods of mania during which her behavior became uncharacteristic and unpredictable. She fought with her mom, which was unlike her. Sometimes she would even run away from home, and so did Lakeley. And once they ran away together, together because, you know, you're thinking they're best friends and their sisters a year apart. So I can see why, you know, they'd kind of both be in on it in certain ways. But even when the two of them ran away or when Nevaeh herself ran away, she would always make sure to stay active on social media so her family knew she was okay. So even if she was pissed off and wanted to get away, she would at least write her aunt or siblings or somebody and say, I'm over at this place and like, leave me alone, you know, or what have you. She would always check in. She would always make sure that her, her mom knew where she was. Through their ups and downs, Teddy and Nevaeh maintained a very close bond. Teddy said in an interview, I felt like she was still holding on being a baby to me. In October of 2021, Nevaeh was 15 years old and was having a particularly rough patch in life. Two of her friends, and this is something that, like, we don't necessarily talk about specifically when we talk about missing and murdered indigenous women and girls, but suicide, the idea of how high the rates of suicide are in marginalized groups compared to non marginalized groups. So two of her friends, she's 15, two of her friends had died by suicide that year, one in April and one in October. And I mean, that's a devastating thing to deal with at any age. But at 15, to have two friends die by suicide is just, I mean, how traumatic would that be? I, I, it just like the grief alone, I don't think I experienced that kind of a loss at that age, thankfully. I know a lot of people have, but that's just a lot. So she was overwhelmed by grief. She was, was really struggling to cope with the loss. So Teddy, her mom worked a 4pm to midnight shift at a nearby casino and she actually took off five days to be with Nevaeh because her daughter was grieving so intensely that she felt like she needed her mom there.

[Em Schultz]

It's so sad.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's horrible. Then on Thursday, October 21, Teddy gave Nevaeh permission to go to the movies with friends. And Nevaeh was finally upbeat. She was really excited about her plans. According to Teddy, she was beyond happy. So Teddy left for work, and she called Nevaeh at 8pm to check in. But Nevaeh didn't pick up. So as the hours passed, she called again and again until Nevaeh finally answered. And it was clear immediately that something was wrong. Nevaeh was slurring her words. Teddy asked what was wrong, and Nevaeh said that nothing was wrong. And then she burst into tears.

[Em Schultz]

Oh.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh, gosh. Teddy left work early and found Nevaeh at home with Sarah, six other teenagers. This is where this story becomes unbelievable to me in a few short bullet points.

[Em Schultz]

Oh, okay. Okay.

[Christine Schiefer]

It turned out that Nevaeh had gone to a party with her friends instead of the movies. And when that party was busted, Nevaeh's friends went home with her. Teddy didn't know any of the teenagers in her house. And as you know, she didn't approve of Nevaeh's friends because she said they didn't treat her well.

[Em Schultz]

Right. So they're probably coming in and now taking advantage of your house. Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. Who knows, Right? Exactly. You're already thinking like, these are dangerous people. My daughter to be around. Now they're all in my house.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. And they're looking through my. What?

[Christine Schiefer]

You know, who knows what. And so they all went to her house, and Teddy didn't know any of them. She was really nervous about what was going on with Nevaeh, and she went to look for her. Teddy found her upstairs drunk. It was completely unlike her. And when Teddy tried to get to her daughter, one of the teenagers started pushing Teddy backward.

[Em Schultz]

Oh, yeah, A grown. A grown ass.

[Christine Schiefer]

Woman.

[Em Schultz]

Woman.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Like. Like the. Like. Not. Not that it's okay to push your friends, but you're pushing your friend's mom, who you have met in her own house. That's crazy. Okay.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yep. And they refused to let Teddy anywhere near Nevaeh. And the rest of the group refused to leave her house. I mean, this is terrifying. It escalated to a near fight, like a near brawl. I mean, she's trying to get to her daughter. And Teddy announced she was going outside to call the police. As she waited outside for the police to arrive, she heard someone banging on the garage door. The girl who'd been shoving Teddy took the wrong door and went to the garage instead of out of the front. And Teddy let her out through the garage door and asked her where Nevaeh was. And she said Nevaeh left. Teddy rushed around the house and found the back door open. While police were escorting teenagers out of Teddy's home. And an ambulance transported one teenager to the hospital with alcohol poisoning. Teddy told the officers that her daughter was missing. He seemed unconcerned, of course.

[Em Schultz]

Wow. You know what? One day maybe tell a story where they are concerned. How about that?

[Christine Schiefer]

Hey, it's really hard to find em. Yeah, it's really fucking hard to find unless you fit a certain set of criteria, you know, unless you're, you're white.

[Em Schultz]

Straight, able bodied, Christian, anything. You just insert that.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. Yep. He seemed unconcerned. He said she must have just run away. Teddy said, well then you need to go find her. Keep in mind at this point it is past 1am in northern Minnesota. It is 23 degrees out, negative 5 Celsius. Nevaeh is intoxicated alone outside somewhere.

[Em Schultz]

Also, if she's intoxicated, doesn't that mean that she doesn't realize how cold she is?

[Christine Schiefer]

Yep.

[Em Schultz]

Okay.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's a lot easier to. Yeah. To not feel that sensation when you're drunk. They call what they call beer jacket. It's like kind of up, but it's true. So the police sort of looked around for a second and Teddy is like gearing toward full panic. She figures, okay, Nevaeh is probably sleeping at a friend's house and she'll send me a message tomorrow morning on social media. But Nevaeh did not contact her for two days. Teddy's brother Daniel Wind was sure at the end of this two days that Nevaeh would have reached out, but she didn't.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, I would think the same.

[Christine Schiefer]

Teddy was filled with dread at this point because two days was longer than she had ever gone. And the way that she had last seen her obviously didn't confidence in her well being. And Lakeley also was really filled with panic. She was working at a residential treatment program for, for teenagers struggling with mental illness. And you know, her younger sister having been diagnosed with bipolar disorder and now is missing and not in contact. I mean this must be terrifying. On top of that Lake was away from home and wasn't able to get home to help search. So she fell felt hope, like help helpless. You know, she felt like she really couldn't contribute. And she knew this was different from other times that Nevaeh ran away because Nevaeh hadn't come back for any of her clothes, which locally said is the moment she knew. No, she. If she were. If she were going somewhere for a while to cool off or what have you, she would have come, taken her clothes.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah.

[Christine Schiefer]

She also, like I said, hadn't reached out to anybody, and that was completely out of character. Like, she. She. Even during a mental health crisis, she would reach out to a relative just to say where she was or just to answer that she was okay. So.

[Em Schultz]

And like you said, she's like, she's a super friendly person. She's super extroverts. Like, she. Someone would know where she is. There would be somebody. It's not like she doesn't have any friends, so there would be no eyes.

[Christine Schiefer]

On her, you know, and she was with a group. Right. Like, somebody had to have seen where she went. And. And that's exactly it. Drinking was apparently also completely out of character for Nevaeh. According to Teddy, it seemed like she planned to go to the movies with her friends, wound up at a party, and somehow got in over her head, which, of course, happens to teenagers every day. Her family hoped she'd come home within a few days, but the circumstances of the disappearance was. Were scary. And they thought, you know what? They're. The fact that the police called this a runaway, by the way, officially felt damning almost. And because she was considered a runaway, police really didn't treat her case with any urgency. It was more than a week before the officer who took Teddy's report called her back. He. This is. This part killed me. He asked if Nevaeh had come home yet. Teddy said that when she told him no, he said he'd call back in another week to check again and then hunt up. Oh, are you kidding?

[Em Schultz]

Sick.

[Christine Schiefer]

It would be up to Teddy now, as I feel like has become the running refrain of my stories recently, it would be up to the family, Teddy, specifically to advocate for her daughter. But in the days after Nevaeh disappeared, her entire household got sick with COVID 19.

[Em Schultz]

Oh, my God. So it's, like, completely derailed child. I can't imagine being real. I. I mean, I. First of all, I can't imagine, like, just being sick when you, like, really need to be, like, on your. On your A game. Yeah, but I mean, I'm assuming this was like, COVID 19, when, like, we. Every person who got sick, we thought they might die. Like, yeah, you've got to worry about other people who may or may not.

[Christine Schiefer]

Right. If your whole family's sick now, it's like, now everyone's at risk for.

[Em Schultz]

Can you get. Do you have to go to the hospital and get, like, intubated and all this? Like, what's gonna. What's gonna happen to these. These people? I can't even think about the other person there. And then you think, what if she has Covid? What if. What happened? Like, what if she died from COVID What if it was just.

[Christine Schiefer]

God. Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

What if she just couldn't breathe? You know, something terrible?

[Christine Schiefer]

It's really, really. It must be. It's like a. Feels like an extra cruel twist of fate, you know, like, that you are just about to hit the ground running, looking for your daughter, and you realize you have to do it on your own. And then the universe is like, never mind. Just think about it while you have a fever for many days.

[Em Schultz]

Like, oh, my God. Just spiraling and just seriously. And then, of course, trying to get better, but you're. It's like when you're stressed and sick, it makes a cold worse, so you're hurting yourself by not. It's. There's no relax. There's no moments of relax.

[Christine Schiefer]

Oh. Teddy, specifically, was extremely ill. She was barely able to get out of bed, and she had sick children at home now. So she's caring for her sick children. She's barely able to get out of bed. She would have these feverish nightmares that Nevaeh was. Was trapped in a fancy house with a teenage girl.

[Em Schultz]

What?

[Christine Schiefer]

I don't know, but it freaks me out. And in those nightmares, Nevaeh told Teddy that she was dead and that she couldn't come home.

[Em Schultz]

Absolutely disgusting and horrific. Also, like, at this point, I would. I didn't even know this was during. It didn't occur to me. This was, like, during COVID 19. That absolutely makes me think for sure that something happened to her, because, like, this is not the time to be anywhere but in your home with your family.

[Christine Schiefer]

Good point. You're trapped in someone else's house.

[Em Schultz]

Oh. Like, if Nevaeh were alive, she would be thinking, like, I need to get home. What if my family is sick? Or, like, what if they caught something? What if. What if the people. I don't know, like, it could. That's a whole other thought of, like, if she heard that they were sick.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

The community. She would go home immediately.

[Christine Schiefer]

Right, right, right. And. And the fact that in the nightmare, she said she told her mom, I'm dead and I can't come home. Like, that's just a special level of hell that I can't fathom. So once Nevaeh had been missing. I mean, thankfully Teddy survived this bout, as did her family. When Nevaeh had been missing for a month, a detective said, I'll start looking into this case. Case, which NBC News apparently reports is department protocol for runaways who are still missing after a month. Okay, so Nevaeh's family couldn't believe this runaway. She wouldn't have left behind Natalie. And who slept in her bed every night. And Lake Haley believed that Nevaeh would have reached out over social media, especially to her, by this time. Teddy's brother, Daniel Wind, said in an interview that he felt there would have been more official and community urgency about Nevaeh immediately after her disappearance if she weren't indigenous. Well, I know. What a shocking statement. What a hot, honest.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, right.

[Christine Schiefer]

The police who responded to Teddy's call the night Nevaeh vanished knew this part gives it talk about fury. Like, it makes me furious. The police who responded to Teddy's call the night Nevaeh vanished knew that she was an intoxicated and incapacitated minor outside in temperatures below freezing after midnight. Yet nobody even tried to look for her in an organized way until months after she disappeared. It's months. I mean, if somebody went missing in an upscale neighborhood, a young white girl, and she was barefoot, and she went missing drunk in the woods, like, do we think that. Yeah, the police would say she ran away like, you.

[Em Schultz]

No. Maximum I can see for 24 hours being like, oh, well, she's a drunk teenager. Like they. They do this all the time. Something. Yeah, that. But. But months. There's no way. There's no way.

[Christine Schiefer]

And the runaway label wouldn't have stuck.

[Em Schultz]

No. That wouldn't have even happened.

[Christine Schiefer]

No. Daniel said the world reacts different to us. You know what I mean? I'm not saying that directly to anybody. It's just the way of life for us, you know? And that's the thing. Like, he's just making a statement of how it is. Not like a political statement, not like a. Whatever. He's just saying that's how our lives go. Yeah, that's like, now you can see, this is how it happens. Weeks passed with no leads. And then someone told Nevaeh's 12 year old brother that there had been a sighting of Nevaeh before she disappeared.

[Em Schultz]

Imagine being a 12 year old kid.

[Christine Schiefer]

I know, I know.

[Em Schultz]

And getting that information, like, imagine how scared you are to like. And in hindsight, it's like, well, I should have asked this. Well, I should have asked this. And like, is my mom mad that I Mean, like it. Horrifying.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's horrifying. So this 12 year old boy hears that his sister was spotted one more time after disappearing or after disappearing from. From the hat. From her home. And this is the story. So apparently Nevaeh and a friend had apparently run down the road to a trailer where another friend lived and climbed through the window into the friend's bedroom. They hung out there until their friend's dad or stepdad, it varies by source, heard the teenagers talking and began knocking on the door. And that's when, apparently, Nevaeh panicked. She tried to climb back out the window, but in her hurry, she either fell or jumped and sustained a head injury by hitting her head.

[Em Schultz]

And where is she now? Someone had to drag her away from that site. Or is she still there?

[Christine Schiefer]

So according to Teddy, the friend said Nevaeh had lain on the ground for a long time before she finally got back up and ran away into the night.

[Em Schultz]

Oh, my God.

[Christine Schiefer]

So now they're thinking sort of like what you were wondering, well, where. How did she get away from there? Well, apparently the friends are saying she ran away after a while and we don't know where she went.

[Em Schultz]

So she had a major head injury. Nobody thought to tell the parents or the police or anything, and she just fled into the night as if she has a head injury. Because she's not responding normally.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

And she just. And they think she watches. Just like, died in the wilderness. Yeah, they're gonna say, oh my God.

[Christine Schiefer]

Well, if Nevaeh had hit her head hard enough to lose consciousness and sustain a concussion, it made some sense that if she was also drunk and, you know, whatever else might be affecting her that like, you know, it could have messed with her reasoning and what, Whatever. But we also have no proof or evidence that this happened. So it's like, you know, know, it's hard to say. It's like, is this. It's kind of just a hearsay type of event. I don't know how valid you can make it. No, that's not the right sentence.

[Em Schultz]

I don't know what you're saying.

[Christine Schiefer]

I don't know how. God, with you, words are hard today. Okay, so if she had had any level of head injury, that would have put her at a greater risk than she already was. And if she had fled her mom's house after being kind of caught drunk or whatever and being upset, and then had fled to a friend's house and then thought she was going to get in trouble when the dad knocked, like, I don't know, Maybe. Maybe she did climb out the window and hit her head and they were too scared to. I have no clue. This is just what they claimed happened. And Teddy took this information from her son and reported it to the detective on Nevaeh's case. Nevaeh's friend, the one who lived in the trailer, had found her phone. It had been between his bed and the wall, and Nevaeh apparently left it behind when she ran away. He didn't notice the phone for several weeks. And when they searched the phone, there were no clues at all as to where Nevaeh may have gone. So it sort of just felt like another dead end. There were security cameras in the neighborhood that. That likely would have recorded Nevaeh that night, but, huh, they only store footage for a limited time. It's almost like they should have looked for her, you know, right away, instead of months later. Huh? Hey, while we're pitching, you know, Gordon Ramsay style bar rescue ideas.

[Em Schultz]

How about defund the police? And how about actually, how do we actually get some real technology and equipment in there and resources?

[Christine Schiefer]

How about somebody care. How about somebody just cares about brown.

[Em Schultz]

People for a second, you know, how about abolish racism? Actually, that's a great idea.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. Yeah, good idea at the least. Okay, so the police searched nearby for Nevaeh, but they called off their search because a winter storm moved in and covered Bemidji in deep. In knee deep snow. So there's just no searching at that point.

[Em Schultz]

Okay, well, great.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. Teddy and Daniel say nuh. They conduct their own search. Hundreds of volunteers answered the call to meet near Teddy's house. Daniel, who is a veteran Wildland firefighter, organized the search and the second search that took place four days later. So they're looking through this trailer park. They find a pair of women's jeans buried in the snow. Several days later, someone else finds a sweatshirt that may have belonged to Nevaeh's grandmother. And they're thinking maybe she wore it out that night. Five months after Nevaeh's disappearance, a woman named Lissa Yellowbird joined the search, driving from North Dakota with her cadaver dog.

[Em Schultz]

Dogs? Oh, yeah, brother.

[Christine Schiefer]

This is hell yeah, brother. This list is the one I want to watch like an HBO special about, you know, or like an HBO like, you know, biopic. So Lissa Yellow Bird brought her cadaver dogs, which are dogs trained to locate human remains. She had dedicated years to searching for missing indigenous people and advocating for their families. And she, in turn, became a crucial support for Nevaeh's family. Months passed with no sign of Nevaeh, despite Lissa's help. And once the snow melted in the spring, police finally decided they were strong enough to go do a search themselves, which I'm really. I think was really brave of them. So once the snow melted, police conducted new, more involved searches, and they urged the public to come forward with any information that might lead to her whereabouts. Police also released statements dispelling rumors about. About Nevaeh being abducted in a vehicle with Louisiana license plates. The reason this was even a rumor is because there was a different case in another state, and people were just conflating the two cases. And so now there's all this misinformation spreading that Nevaeh had been kidnapped in this car, and that was a story from a completely different town.

[Em Schultz]

Jesus Christ. Oh, my God.

[Christine Schiefer]

So it's a mess. And while this mess is trying to be untangled, investigators also follow up on a property damage report they believed may have linked to Nevaeh. Here's what that's about. There was a couple who lived near the trailer park community, and they reported that someone had broken two windows in their garage the night Nevaeh vanished. They said the same night, a teenage girl who matched Nevaeh's description had knocked on the door without any shoes on. The detective on the case said that Nevaeh had asked for somebody, and then she left. And when the couple was shown a photo of Nevaeh, they said it was a different girl who knocked on their door that night. Night. But the detective later suggested that they might be mistaken because their original description of the girl, like, matched almost perfectly to Nevaeh. So they may have, like, okay, misremembered their own visuals. As volunteer searches continued for Nevaeh, more and more Bemidji residents became involved. Lissa encouraged Daniel, Nevaeh's uncle, to canvas neighborhoods, literally knocking on doors and showing a picture and asking if anyone knew anything about Nevaeh. And when people learned about her, they wanted to help. On October 22, 2022, one year after her disappearance, there was a candlelight vigil in Nevaeh's honor. The mayor was in attendance as a representative of the community's continued support for Nevaeh's family and the efforts to find her and bring her home. But another year passed with no answers. The police tested hairs found in the sweatshirt discovered by the volunteers, but they didn't belong to Nevaeh. And that was in the sweatshirt that. That looked like it could have been her grandma's. Yeah, the hairs didn't belong to Nevaeh. Police also realized the genes that the searchers found could not have been the jeans Nevaeh wore the night she vanished, because they had been left outside for far longer than Nevaeh had been missing. So those were red herrings.

[Em Schultz]

Okay.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah.

[Em Schultz]

Well, great. So we actually have moved backwards. Great.

[Christine Schiefer]

Correct. Or at least we're just treading water.

[Em Schultz]

You know, why isn't anyone, like, they were at a party that got busted that, like, busted forever ago? Why didn't anyone go interview other people that were at the party?

[Christine Schiefer]

These people know something easy.

[Em Schultz]

And also, like, this might have been the sweater that she wore. Why didn't anyone, like, get a description of what she looked like from any of the people who saw her that night?

[Christine Schiefer]

I'm just really, like, it's not that hard.

[Em Schultz]

And also, like, we keep saying, like, wow. Like, I love how, like, hard working all these people are. Like, they're bringing their friends out to, like, with cadaver dogs and like. But they shouldn't have to do this. Like, no, of course. Exactly the point of even having. Having a police department. It's like, you're doing the job for like, pay me. Damn.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, yeah, seriously, Volunteers have to come up with all this. Like, it's like, infuriated.

[Em Schultz]

And also it's like, oh, well, we have to wait for the snow to melt and then we're gonna go keep looking. It's like, that should not be your job. Your job is to be at home and just cry and be with your family because it sucks.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, you should be protected in this case, not put to work. Like, that really infuriates me. It's. And it's the fact that it's so blatantly obvious who ends up in this scenario over and over and over again. It's. It's like just a crocus.

[Em Schultz]

It's like I always feel like it, like, accidentally, like, seems like performative or something when we're like, oh, wow. Like, they're so brave. It's like, you shouldn't have to do this.

[Christine Schiefer]

No.

[Em Schultz]

Like, this is crazy. This is awful.

[Christine Schiefer]

No, I.

[Em Schultz]

It's just. It's just so sad.

[Christine Schiefer]

And I'm sure to them it felt like they had no choice, right? Like, they have no choice. They have to do it themselves. It's not like, out of honor. Whatever. It's like, there's no one else looking.

[Em Schultz]

Also with, like, with time going on, like, the people who already didn't give a shit on day one certainly don't care a year later.

[Christine Schiefer]

Like, it's correct after Two years later, after the candlelight vigil, like, they're over there, they've moved on. And the amount of crime and, you know, things that are happening that they're just going to focus on instead. It's.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. Sad, awful.

[Christine Schiefer]

So now they're not sure. Now they don't think the sweater or the jeans belong to Nevada Nevaeh. They also discovered an eyeliner that was the same brand Nevaeh always wore. But when they turned it over to police, police had no clue. Nobody had a clue how to determine if it was hers. Right.

[Em Schultz]

Because it's like DNA, babe. What are you talking about? Eyeliner on her eye? You can't get DNA off of that? Am I a crazy person?

[Christine Schiefer]

Hang on. That's a really good point.

[Em Schultz]

It's like, oh, well, we can't get DNA off this used lipstick. What are you saying?

[Christine Schiefer]

What the talking about hang the on done.

[Em Schultz]

That literally just sounds like a man didn't want to work. He just went, well, there's nothing we can do.

[Christine Schiefer]

However, I will say I know they tested the hairs, but I'm just wondering what. What. What do you think? Like, what would have that have done? I guess it would have shown, like, maybe where she had run.

[Em Schultz]

It would have given us a clue. Like, okay, she was here. Great. Okay, so now we know she made it this far. Like, yeah, yeah. Anything.

[Christine Schiefer]

I'm curious about that.

[Em Schultz]

That if you died and then there was, and we didn't know where you went, and a mile away, something that might have been yours was found, and we just don't test it. I'd be like, are you kidding me? I want to know, like, if you.

[Christine Schiefer]

Were there, test this lemon for. For saliva. She used to kiss it a lot.

[Em Schultz]

Anyway, I feel like I'm taking crazy pills because, like, how. What do you mean? Oh, we couldn't.

[Christine Schiefer]

Well, it's funny because I said, well, obviously they can't figure it out. And you went, well, obviously they could. And I was like, oh, my God. God.

[Em Schultz]

I just felt very crap fingerprints. Like, they couldn't. I mean, maybe. Maybe they're too disintegrated at this point. But, like, yeah, I don't know. I don't know. Maybe they. Maybe they tried. Let's give them the benefit of the doubt.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay.

[Em Schultz]

I don't know.

[Christine Schiefer]

Let's. Let's do that. Here we go. Doing that. Police told reporters that they have no evidence of foul play, but many people worry someone might have harmed her. And I think we already know this, but I'm going to tell you again. Because that's how important it is. According to the National Congress of American Indians, more than four in five American Indian or Alaska Native women, 84.3%, more than four in five have experienced violence in their lifetime. And in 2019, homicide was the third highest cause of death among American Indian, Alaskan Native girls 15 to 19 and women 20 to 24. So essentially what I'm saying is ages 15 to 24, homicide, third highest cause of death among girls that age and women that age some. That is how up that is and how jarring it is to see the difference between that number and then hearing police say she's just a runaway. And it's like, really? Because actually, statistically speaking, she's probably not a runaway. You know, like, it's just, it's. The gap is so obvious there. It hurts. Nevaeh, of course, was not the first indigenous teenager to disappear from Bemidji in recent years. Lissa Yellowbird, who helped Nevaeh's family organize searches and brought down her dabber dogs. She had actually been in Bemidji five years prior to assist a resident there named Teresa Jourdain in search for her missing 17 year old son, Jeremy, who to this day has never been found either. He vanished after leaving a party less than a mile from the trailer community where Nevaeh was last seen. So, like, within a mile radius, both of these kids disappeared. Someone later found his backpack in the road, and that's kind of where they left that case. The detective leading Nevaeh's case does not believe the disappearances are related. But aside from that, of course, rumors started swirling about Nevaeh and what might have happened to her. People speculated on her disappearance without any care for how their words might affect the family. I mean, all over Reddit, like, it's just really alarming. And Teddy expressed some very sincere hurt and anger about this. She said that the deep pain of uncertainty, like the. It's unbearable to not know what happened and for people to be online saying, like, oh, she was probably trafficked. Oh, it was probably a drug overdose, like it, she said, it's just hurt on top of the hurt and completely unacceptable, you know, so all that to say, families, hearts shattered, and now they're just stuck with no closure, no answers, not even the right questions to ask because there's just no avenues to go down. In September of 2023, which was nearly two years since Nevaeh was last seen, the missing and murdered Indigenous relatives office MMIR worked alongside volunteers and local, federal, state and tribal investigators to conduct what was reportedly the largest ever search search for an indigenous person in Minnesota.

[Em Schultz]

Oh.

[Christine Schiefer]

They conducted a meticulous grid search of 150 acres. The search was conducted on the ground, by air, and with divers searching nearby swamps. The main focus was Nevaeh's case, but searchers were also told to look for any sign of Jeremy Jordain, as well as an indigenous man named Damon Boyd, who had disappeared in 2014. So even though. Though this was based on Nevaeh's case, there were two other people that had gone missing in the area that they were told that searchers were told to look out for as well. Even Jeremy's mother, Teresa Jourdain, joined the search and tried to help Nevaeh's family find her. She said she. I imagine it was a little bit bittersweet. She said that she wished efforts like this had been conducted when her son had vanished years earlier. So it's sort of like. Like, you know, we should have been doing this sooner. Right.

[Em Schultz]

It's like. It's almost like a really nice thing that you're doing to be a part of this when you know that it wasn't.

[Christine Schiefer]

When it must be so hard. Yeah, yeah. To realize, like, that wasn't. Yeah, exactly.

[Em Schultz]

Yeah. That's big. That's big of you.

[Christine Schiefer]

Likewise, Teddy Wind wished that such thorough searches had begun for Nevaeh when she initially went missing, not two years later. Right. Because. Because we know why. Tragically, the searchers uncovered not a single clue about Nevaeh, Jeremy, or Damon. So it was a complete bust.

[Em Schultz]

Great.

[Christine Schiefer]

Determined to make a change for people experiencing the same pain as their families, Nevaeh's sister Lakele began taking courses at Leech Lake Tribal College to become a peace officer. She said in an interview, our people go missing, and not just the women, the guys, too. It's a pandemic for our people. People. Just the pandemic of missing people. I mean, it's. It's horror. It's like real life horror. Yeah. Lakele felt Nevaeh's case was neglected and mishandled from the start, and she wanted to be in the position to handle future cases with the care they deserve, which is just always incredible when you see people, like, turning their pain into help for someone else. It's just. Just unbelievable. Similarly, Daniel Wynn became an advocate for missing and murdered indigenous people. And again, like, they shouldn't be having to spend their lives doing this. Right.

[Em Schultz]

It's like, wow, what, Becoming your life's work. Yeah, exactly.

[Christine Schiefer]

Which, like, of course, you'd rather have your child back, your niece back, you know, and sister back. Of course.

[Em Schultz]

I feel like there's so many. I might be. I'm kind of putting this together as I'm saying it.

[Christine Schiefer]

It.

[Em Schultz]

But I think there's a reason why so many disenfranchised communities have such bigger community. It's like, because they have personal experience. Like, way too many of them have personal experience, and people with privilege don't have that going.

[Christine Schiefer]

We can rely on, you know, we can rely on more of the resources. Yeah. And we don't have.

[Em Schultz]

And we don't suffer as often or we're not as often. Statistics, you know, and so, you know, why would we have community when there's nothing to have to regularly?

[Christine Schiefer]

It's like the kids.

[Em Schultz]

Because no one else will do it.

[Christine Schiefer]

Yeah. It's like the kids who are having to represent themselves in court and things like that, and they're saying, you know, why would I trust you as a police officer? Like, you've never. Whatever.

[Em Schultz]

It's.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's. You know. Anyway. Okay. So he had met a lot of families who were going through something similar when he was conducting the search effort for his niece. And so after meeting this whole community of people who had gone through something similar, he began to speak on behalf of Nevaeh and their family. With the encouragement of Lissa Yellowbird, as well as other missing and murdered indigenous people and their families, Nevaeh's family will not give up until they find her and bring her home. This past May, Nevaeh would have graduated high school. Her school and classmates honored her at the graduation ceremony, which, you know, bittersweet. Nevaeh was passionate about school and worked very hard in all of her classes. She. She was remembered as a dedicated student and beloved friend. The organization MMIW218 helped Nevaeh's aunt Flower create a Facebook page called Bring Nevaeh Kingbird Home, where Nevaeh's family shares updates regarding her case. So if you want to follow along and find out more information, you can check that out. The continuing searches for Nevaeh require community support to secure. Like you were saying, to secure crucial financial resources, equipped equipment, skilled personnel that are not available elsewhere. Those who want to support Nevaeh and her family can find volunteer and donation information on the Bring Nevaeh Kingbird homepage, which we will link in our show notes. And that is the end of that story.

[Em Schultz]

And there's many more like it.

[Christine Schiefer]

I know, right? I know, I know.

[Em Schultz]

Well, that's awful. I'm glad That I covered President's favorite Foods.

[Christine Schiefer]

Me too. I would like to go back to that menu. Maybe we can do that for the yappy hour. I like to listen to your menu again. It was comforting.

[Em Schultz]

Oh, okay. I worked really hard.

[Christine Schiefer]

So wait, I know what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna open a competing pub across the street and I'm gonna do all the vice president. I'll do all the vice presidents or all the First Ladies. Ladies. I. I'm gonna do First Ladies.

[Em Schultz]

First Ladies. Do it, Christine.

[Christine Schiefer]

It's gonna be Brownie Schieffer. Don't you call me that. It's gonna be Living Ladies, Dead Presidents.

[Em Schultz]

Living First Ladies, Living Ladies. And yeah, obviously it's woman owned and everyone who works there is a woman. And especially.

[Christine Schiefer]

What could go wrong?

[Em Schultz]

Yeah, nothing literally compare. Literally nothing compared to the place across the street. Look around.

[Christine Schiefer]

No, I meant the world. But yeah, the place across the street is having a tough stuff done too.

[Em Schultz]

Living Lady. That would be such a good. Oh, my God. Imagine. Imagine. Imagine if the owner of the dead President's Pub and the person who runs Living Ladies were. Are married or divorced. Do you think that's like.

[Christine Schiefer]

Well, do you think that whoever owns it would be willing to marry me and divorce me? The first one. I'm sure they'll agree to the divorce part. I feel like that's going to be a hard sell. Sure.

[Em Schultz]

I think you're right. Let's put it though. Let's leave it there.

[Christine Schiefer]

Okay. I already found a list of first lady's favorite foods. Thank you everybody for listening. Sorry for bumming you out again. I know I do it every week, but it's important to tell these stories and keep them in people's ears and minds. If you want to check anything out that we have, it's basically all at. And that's what we drink.com. we have social media, ATWD, podcast, and I think that's everything.

[Em Schultz]

And that's why we drink.

[Christine Schiefer]

Stop by Sherwin Williams and get 30% off select paints and stains June 13th through the 23rd. It's the perfect time to transform your space with color. Refresh your home inside with colors that make every space feel brand new. From cozy interiors to stunning exteriors. We've got the perfect shade for your next project. Shop the sale online or visit your neighborhood Sherwin Williams store. Click the banner to learn more. Retail sales only some exclusions apply. See store for details. Stop by Sherwin Williams and get 30% off select paints and stains June 13th through the 23rd. It's the perfect time to transform your space with color. Refresh your home inside and out with colors that make every space feel brand new. From cozy interiors to stunning exteriors, we've got the perfect shade. For your next project, shop the sale online or visit your neighborhood Sherwin Williams store. Click the banner to learn more. Retail sales only some exclusions apply. See Store for details.