Loading summary
Michael Batnik
Today's Animal Spirits is brought to you by Y Charts. If your current investment research and analytics platform is being phased out, shots fired. It's time to make the switch to Y Charts.
Ben Carlson
For a limited time, Y Charts is offering an unheard of discount to advisors making this switch. It's one of those rare moments we can upgrade to a better platform and basically get the rest of this year free. Sounds like a screaming deal. Click the link in the Show Notes. Lock in your deal before it's gone. See why thousands of advisors including including us, trust Y Charts to power the research and client engagement. New customers only must show proof of platform sunsetting to qualify. Check out the Show Notes. Click that link yarts.com for more.
Michael Batnik
Today's Animal Spirits is also brought to you by Fabric. One of the first things that I did as a new parent eight years ago was get life insurance protection. God forbid. Fabric by Gerber Life is term life insurance. You can get done right from your couch, all online and on your schedule. You can be covered in under 10 minutes with no health exam required, which is good for me because I hurt my back. I don't know if that impacts rates at all, but good to hear.
Ben Carlson
Fabric by Gerber Life has an app you can go on. You can go on the desktop. It's pretty easy. You get covered under 10 minutes. No health exam required. Term life Insurance Thousands of parents trust fabric to protect their families. Apply today in just minutes@meatfabric.com spirits that's meatfabric.com Spirits policies issued by Western Southern Life Insurance Company not available in certain states. Prices are subject to underwriting and health questions. Welcome to Animal Spirits, a show about markets, life and investing. Join Michael Batnik and Ben Carlson as they talk about what they're reading, writing and watching. All opinions expressed by Michael and Ben are solely their own opinion and do not reflect the opinion of Ritholtz Wealth Management.
Michael Batnik
This podcast is for informational purposes only.
Ben Carlson
And should not be relied upon for any investment decisions. Clients of Ritholtz Wealth Management may maintain positions in the securities discussed in this podcast.
Michael Batnik
Welcome to Animal Spirits with Michael and Ben. Good morning, Ben.
Ben Carlson
Good morning, Michael. You are in a lovely Marriott somewhere.
Michael Batnik
Looks like it's a Hyatt.
Ben Carlson
Oh, it's a hi Hyatt.
Michael Batnik
Back in the central time zone. Back again. Good to be back.
Ben Carlson
You were racking up those frequent flyer miles lately. Yeah, we had a lot of people hitting me up on social media with pictures of you from the Knicks game and there was one in particular where I Don't know if I think it was a close game. And it's you. So you were sitting, essentially, it looked like, at the scorers table kind of deal. That's how it looks, right at the scorers table. And it's you and your friends with your arms around each other and you have your hands in the air and a huge scream coming out of your mouth. Is that when the Knicks won't. What happened?
Michael Batnik
That was when OG hit a three with four seconds left.
Ben Carlson
Okay. So someone. Someone caught that. I couldn't find the game. It wasn't on wherever I was. It wasn't on my local settings. So what was your experience like with the very first courtside seats?
Michael Batnik
It was incredible.
Ben Carlson
Is it like first class, though, if you sit first class once, you can't go back. You feel like you can't go back with the plebes.
Michael Batnik
I have to go back. But yeah, no, it was great. The. The game was incredible. It was. It was so much fun. But enough of that. Let's talk about this. Last week we started the show saying that it feels like everybody just turned bearish, Right?
Ben Carlson
Yeah.
Michael Batnik
And we're starting the show this week where it feels like everybody thinks we're going back into a recession.
Ben Carlson
Oh, yeah. I mean, I don't think it's hyperbolic to say that the risk of a recession and. Or stagflation or a bear market is much higher now than it was a month ago. That's not hyperbolic at all. If you're doing probabilities, the risks are much higher than they were. I don't think you can call yourself a serious analyst if you don't think that. Yeah, if we continue down the path of government austerity and 25% tariffs on all of our trading partners, then a, the risk of recession is way higher now than it was before. Period, end of sentence.
Michael Batnik
Yeah. Last week I was saying, you know, the reintroduction of risk is actually a good thing for a reset of psychology. A lot of complacency. But the real risk of a recession is never a good thing. And as far as the stock market is concerned, if we do get a recession from elevated multiples, not crazy, but elevated multiples, the 24 times forward earnings, 26 times, whatever it was, that was all well and good in the world, that might not exist anymore. And if earnings are not going to deliver the growth that was being priced into that multiple, it can get ugly in a hurry.
Ben Carlson
I mean, the best guess would be we would have a bear market well before a recession even Hits our shores, right? Yeah, I think the stock market would immediately sniff that out.
Michael Batnik
Yeah, well, that's what's happening.
Ben Carlson
So the big chart of the week was GDP now, which is updated on a weekly basis. And last week, this thing crashed to show, well, the first quarter looks like it's going to be a negative GDP print. And then it went down even more this week, and now it's showing, I don't know, a negative 2.8% or something. This thing is not infallible. It's not totally predictive, but I think the trend is generally in the right direction.
Michael Batnik
So the tariffs are about to go into effect, or they did go into effect yesterday.
Ben Carlson
Today's tariff day, if we want to celebrate. So the idea is, okay, wow, it looks like the economy just fell off of a cliff. That's what it looks like from this chart. Now, a lot of people said, take a deep breath, hang on, this is not as bad as it might seem. A lot of it is import stuff, where the tariff is basically causing a lot of these companies to pull a lot of this stuff forward. So the tariffs are causing this. But the point was like, well, this could be more of a calculation kind of thing with the way imports and exports are calculated, that it's not necessarily all of a sudden economic activity is falling off a cliff.
Michael Batnik
Daryl Fairweather, she is the chief economist at Redfin. This morning she tweeted, unless we all wake up from this collective tariff nightmare, the reality is recession, recession with inflation, which is called stagflation. It's the worst kind of recession because people lose their jobs and prices stay high, along with interest rates.
Ben Carlson
Yeah, no, it's not good. So I guess the. So the Wall street supporters of Trump's policies were basically thinking, hey, listen, if we get deregulation tax cuts and not the tariff and austerity stuff, like, we're off to the races. I put this out in November. There was all these headlines at the end of November, and I said, the wall of worry is over. And it was how animal spirits are impacting behaviors and animal spirits are coming back. And it was all these headlines from all the financial publications talking about animal spirits, and here they are. And I feel like those have been extinguished almost immediately. Now the question is, how long does this stuff last for? Because a lot of people were betting on the fact that, well, these are just a negotiating ploy. He's not actually going to do it.
Michael Batnik
Yeah.
Ben Carlson
And now it's like, no, he. He's going to do it. The tariffs are coming. And so I Guess now the only hope is, well, the tariffs are only going to be here for a short time. That would be the hope for people. Is that okay, he's going to see some pain in the stock market. Everything is, is hurting and he's going to reverse these things.
Michael Batnik
The tax is such a, such a dominant piece of the conversation that Nvidia fell 10% yesterday and it seemed like a, like nobody. It was like an afterthought. This morning Target reported and pulled this from the transcript. In light of ongoing consumer uncertainty and a small decline in February net sales combined with tariff uncertainty, the company expects to see meaningful year over year profit pressure in its Q1 relative to the remainder of the year.
Ben Carlson
So you're going to hear a lot of this from CEOs in the coming quarters.
Michael Batnik
So to Ben's earlier point, I think the market is in the process of pricing this in. It's going to do it really quickly. So what does this mean for you as an investor? If you're listening to us and you're like, oh, the guys are getting nervous. This is not timeable, I don't know. I don't know what this looks, what this is going to look like, what the stock market look like, the recovery, who knows? But the market is going to react a lot quicker. And if you do get out because you're nervous, getting back in is always impossible. Right? There's never like the stock market and it's never like, welcome back in. Now's a great time to come back in. Thanks. Thanks for sitting the sideline. We'd love to have you back. It doesn't work like that.
Ben Carlson
I guess the thinking is that there's always the risk of a recession or a bear market or something. And again, you can't say that these things are happening with a certainty, just that there's a higher probability of that. So I guess if you're an investor, the reason for it doesn't matter as much as the fact that it could happen. I think that's the whole point, is that it could happen. And to your point that a recession is bad, there are people that are trying to spin this in a positive way. So Chamath tweeted yesterday, it stands to reason that a fall in asset prices will have very little impact on the core constituents of Trump's base. To that end, I wouldn't be surprised if he has little reaction to an equity or home price market correction. Separately, the upside of shrinking these asset prices is it gives folks legitimate chance to buy at lower levels, making equity, homeownership more possible. So he's saying that there's 50% of the country or so we're going to get to this in a little bit. That doesn't own many assets. They don't have a lot of financial assets. They're held in the hands of the few. As we talked about last week. He says said differently. Don't presume that the stock market going up is a useful barometer anymore. In fact, it going down may be a better signal for his popularity. This is the most Galaxy brain take I've ever taken I've ever heard.
Michael Batnik
What the is he talking about?
Ben Carlson
So the idea is that people who don't have own financial assets, if we get a recession and financial asset prices go down, they could benefit by buying them. So dude, this is the dumbest billionaire take I've ever heard. Because guess who has the ability to buy financial assets when they're down? People with money and who own financial assets. The people without the financial assets have no backstop. They're the ones who are hurt the most by a recession. So this idea that, well, if we get a recession, rates will be lower, maybe that's a good thing.
Michael Batnik
We spoke about this last week.
Ben Carlson
Good luck with that.
Michael Batnik
We spoke about this last week. Bloomberg created a chart about the amount of spending of the overall economy that's done by the top 10%. And it used to be, it used to be below 40% we mentioned last week. It's now 50%. The bottom 60%. The bottom 60% of people that, that he's talking about buying these assets spend less than responsible for less than 20% of spending. Guess what? Guess where their spending's going, especially in a recession. It's not to buy stocks on the cheap.
Ben Carlson
Right? And especially if tariffs cause higher prices. It's going to be their money is going to be going to more at the grocery store and the gas pump. So I do think like this is the kind of thing, this is a self inflicted wound if it happens. And that's the craziest thing, is that Trump and Musk were handed this not awesome economy, but low unemployment, decent growth, low inflation. And if they cause a recession through their policies, this is the biggest own economic goal ever. It's the most unnecessary recession we've ever seen. And so you would hope that cooler heads prevail and realize like wait, why are we doing this? What's the point here? And that's my hope here, is that they realize that there's why put us into recession if we don't need to. It's totally unnecessary.
Michael Batnik
Does the stock market make another all time high this year?
Ben Carlson
That depends. Do the tariffs stay on all year? If the tariffs are on all year, then no. We've seen the last of the highs. If the tariffs come off, could we see the stock market come back charging back? I don't know. Wouldn't shock me.
Michael Batnik
It really depends on if they lift the tariffs. We'll go back to highs. Real personal spending fell by the most since 2021. That's not great. Americans saved 4.6% of their after tax income in January up from 3.5% in December. Also probably not great, right?
Ben Carlson
Why? The fact that people are battening down the hatches basically.
Michael Batnik
Less spending, more saving is at the personal finance level. It's good, I suppose. But like the read on that is not positive. The reason people are spending less and saving more is because they're getting ready.
Ben Carlson
Do you think that if we didn't have 25% tariffs that the Fed would already be cutting rates again? Because I think the Fed would have already cut again if it wasn't for the threat of tariffs causing inflation to remain a little elevated.
Michael Batnik
I don't know.
Ben Carlson
Because back to the Neil Dutta point from before, it's not like all this stuff just happened on a dime. A lot of it is happening very quickly now, but some of this stuff was already slowing to begin with. And I do think that the Fed probably would have continued cutting rates had we not had the threat of tariffs.
Michael Batnik
Baby. Ben, why is Ray Dalio so obsessed with comparing this to the 1930s? He's been doing this since when did he start doing this? 2015.
Ben Carlson
2015 or so was the first time he did the 1937. So he was on odd lots this week and he said there's going to be a U.S. debt crisis heart attack within three years. And I pulled this took me five minutes. I just typed in Ray Dalio and recession predictions or debt super cycle stuff by years. And I feel like if you're a legendary investor, you want to kind of ride off into the sunset. And don't you think so it's kind of like Jordan winning the championship in his last year and walking off. Don't you think that you want to just call one more just because like that's the way to do it. But don't you read the Rob Copeland book about Dalio, Right? He's done this his whole career. He predicted a depression in the early 1980s right before we set off on the biggest bull market in history in the United States. So I think the most interesting thing about Dalio is the fact that he is constantly predicting a financial crisis, but that doesn't really translate into his returns of his fund because I think so much of the fund that he invests in at Bridgewater is quantitatively based and model driven. So I think it takes.
Michael Batnik
He's not in charge anymore.
Ben Carlson
I think it's a really good lesson in the way of don't allow your opinions and predictions to infiltrate your portfolio. And it seems like he hasn't done that. Right. Because otherwise Bridgewater never would have made as much money as it did if they would have been investing based on all of his recession and debt super cycle predictions.
Michael Batnik
Yeah, yeah, because he's been on this for a while. But what does it even mean? Like, I mean he said interest rates would spike, people would stop buying Treasuries. I don't know. Maybe. I hope not. Obviously that would be pretty, pretty catastrophic. But if you're an I would, I would pay this no mind. Ray Dalio is obviously incredibly smart guy, but not helpful.
Ben Carlson
So rates are coming down absent end of the debt super cycle rates are coming down. The 10 year is back close to 4%. The two year is below 4% now. So to your point about, I think last week you said, I don't think falling rates are a good thing if they're signaling a slowdown in the economy. And I think that's what we've been seeing though.
Michael Batnik
Yeah, it's way too early and way too cute to say that actually this is going to be good for asset prices because lower interest rates, lower inflation. Come on. No, bad news is bad news.
Ben Carlson
But are we finally seeing bonds act as the hedge of last resort now? Yeah, bonds are back to a diversifier. Right. So I did this yesterday. I think the numbers might be maybe a little worse now since things rolled over. But this, this was as of yesterday and we're recording this Tuesday morning. So this is like Monday afternoonish. The year to date returns for the Europe Vanguard European stock index were 13% on a year to date basis. And the S and P was up 1% or so. Again, those are probably a little lower now. The point is there was a huge spread between European stocks and US Stocks. And is this finally the year where we see diversification work in a real way for the first time in a while? I think that.
Michael Batnik
I don't know.
Ben Carlson
I think the setup, I think the setup is there for it if things continue to play out this way.
Michael Batnik
It's a very fluid situation, bud.
Ben Carlson
It is yes, and we've seen a million of these head fakes along the way. But could we see some, you know, see these insular trade policies actually strengthen the European Union in some ways and that be the catalyst for them to finally outperform? I think that story makes a lot of sense to me. This seems to me like the first catalyst you could see for international stocks doing well. You talked about a lot of the higher valuations and all the tech stuff with the US Market. The European market has none of that.
Michael Batnik
Did you read the Stripe annual report?
Ben Carlson
No.
Michael Batnik
It's very Berkshiresque. So Stripe is what is their mission? To increase the GDP of the Internet, I believe. Stripe is a payment processing platform. It's very Berkshiresque. This is what they wrote, one of the things that they wrote in their letter. The US corporate sector is both a cradle of invention and a densely populated graveyard of companies that had fabulous futures in their pasts. Of the 500 companies in the S and P at its inception in 1957, only 53 remain in the index today, more than half of that remaining 53. You strike back in 1957, companies could expect to remain in the index for 61 years. In 1980, the average tenure was 36 years. Today it's just under 20 years. Enduring businesses are increasingly rare.
Ben Carlson
This is why the historical bet is on the Mag 7 not continuing to stay at the top of the heap. At least not all of them.
Michael Batnik
So the best quote in the post was the revenue that businesses process on Stripe is growing seven times faster than that of all companies in the s and P500. And I threw this into ChatGPT, Ben, the entire thing. And it said, pick out the best quote. And that was the quote it picked out. Same quote that I picked out.
Ben Carlson
Okay, so you're using it for editing purposes as well now, huh?
Michael Batnik
No.
Ben Carlson
Oh, well, kind of. Sorry. Summarizing purposes.
Michael Batnik
Yeah. No, editing and summarizing are different things.
Ben Carlson
I do think that's a really good way to use these. These large language models is just taking a really long text and say, pull out the four or five best things.
Michael Batnik
But the reason why I jumped to this is because you mentioned, like, the catalyst for Europe. So they say that 45% of European founders say that the European business climate is getting worse compared with only 15% of US founders. Even more strikingly, founders in Europe are twice as likely to see North America as an opportunity for growth than Europe itself. Why? They go on to say that the evidence suggests that Europe needs a broader, deeper and more diverse array of financing solutions. In the US almost 80% of corporate lending is now from non bank sources, compared to a much smaller number in the eu. I don't know why that number's not in there, but they say that this raises the cost of capital for European firms, which in turn lowers investment rates. So anyway, yes, a lot of structural.
Ben Carlson
Advantages telling the US is what you're saying.
Michael Batnik
Right. So can we see cyclical outperformance out of Europe and the rest of the world? Can we see cyclical outperformance that lasts a couple of years? Yeah, why not? But we do have a considerable structural advantage, which again, might already be reflected. Might is reflected in valuations.
Ben Carlson
Right, to your point. The tech side of it especially. Right, that makes sense. All right. I think the easiest bull markets to continue in the years ahead. Here's my take. Gambling inequality and then laziness slash convenience. Okay, so someone posted this.
Michael Batnik
I think people will get unlazy in a bear market.
Ben Carlson
I don't know, man. I think this is. So someone posted this. Finchat posted this. Doordash has turned the corner to profitability and still continues to grow its order volume. Total orders are now up 735% over the past five years. So this shows total orders on a quarterly basis. And you can see this is just up and to the right.
Michael Batnik
I think this gets killed in a recession.
Ben Carlson
You think Doris gets killed in a recession?
Michael Batnik
Yeah, dude, I'm not paying $24 in service fees. I'm gonna go out and get my food.
Ben Carlson
I just think once people have a taste of this kind of thing and the convenience and they say, well, I don't know, it's $7 more or $12 more.
Michael Batnik
Man, if, if. If we're. If we go into a recession and people lose their jobs and they start to get scared and their neighbors lose their jobs and they start to get a little bit more cautious, this is the first thing to go.
Ben Carlson
Why didn't this go in the inflationary spike then? Prices went way higher. Why didn't people get rid of Doordash?
Michael Batnik
Because I think it's harder to change. Unemployment was 4%.
Ben Carlson
All right. I'm just saying the inertia piece, you could be right. And then next recession, whenever it comes, DoorDash could fall 60% or something.
Michael Batnik
You could be right, too. I could be overestimating.
Ben Carlson
I think it'll be a good test. I think it'd be a good test of this. This was an interesting one too, from the Wall Street Journal. Following almost a tenfold increase in the stock price since its IPO almost a decade ago. Ferrari is now worth $90 billion, making it the most valuable car company in Europe, despite delivering 13,752 vehicles last year. Volkswagen sold 9 million cars last year and has a market cap $40 billion lower. This is interesting. So the CEO of Ferrari said, we are not an automotive company. We are a luxury company that is also doing cars. I never would have expected to look at the Ferrari chart like this. I mean, it looks like the doordash piece, they're up, I don't know, 750% since going public. They sold fewer than 14,000 cars last year.
Michael Batnik
Wow. I. I got a lot of emails, by the way, from Toyota drivers.
Ben Carlson
What do people want you to drive for a Toyota?
Michael Batnik
You know what? Toyota's in the lead.
Ben Carlson
Okay.
Michael Batnik
If I was to get. If I was to get a new car today, I think. I think. I think I'm gonna do it.
Ben Carlson
What kind? Sequoia.
Michael Batnik
What's the big one? No, not, not the giant one.
Ben Carlson
Okay.
Michael Batnik
Just like the Four Ender, maybe Highlander.
Ben Carlson
I like the four runners. Isn't that a Toyota?
Michael Batnik
Yeah. I have to do some homework, but I don't want any problems out of my vehicle. No, nonsense.
Ben Carlson
You get the highest trim for one of these Toyotas or Hondas or whatever, and it still feels like you're driving a luxury vehicle. Right. That's your best bet. All right, Torsten, slot chart of the week from Apollo. Roughly half of US Households do not have any retirement assets. He breaks this out by age as well. And pretty much across the board, it's anywhere from 50 to 60% of people hold retirement assets, meaning 40 to 50% along these different age groups do not hold any zero retirement assets. So we talk a lot about wealth inequality and income inequality. This chart is the reason we need Social Security in this country, because without Social Security, half the. I mean, I guess you could say a lot of that. That 50%, they still own a home, Right. They just don't have a 401k, so that their home is probably their financial asset for many of them. But for most people, if Social Security didn't exist, they would be so screwed for retirement. Right? And guess what? If we get a bear market or recession, these people are not going to be picking up stocks on the cheap. I still can't believe that that was an actual opinion by someone who has a lot of money and maybe some intelligence. Anyway.
Michael Batnik
I got to be honest with you, I didn't hear a word you said for the last two minutes, but there was a noise Coming from my computer, and I was scrambling to find what tab it was coming from. I heard the last part, and I trust that the rest of it was great.
Ben Carlson
All right. Just not as many people hold retirement assets as you think. I think we've improved over the years, but it is still. It's a lower number than it feels like it should be.
Michael Batnik
All right, so the market's open. The S and P is in a. Ooh, a 5.69% correction. Nice. But also not nice.
Ben Carlson
Okay, so.
Michael Batnik
All right.
Ben Carlson
That's still nothing basically, though, as far as corrections go.
Michael Batnik
Well, Ben, Ben, my friend, it's not the current drawdown that gets people up scared, Right. It's the impending. How bad can it get? Yeah, it stops here. I don't think anybody's going to care too much, but Nvidia. Yeah. All right, there's some pain out there. Where are we going next? Oh, crypto. Oh, let's do it.
Ben Carlson
You know, I think. Listen, I'm going to zag on this one a little bit. Anytime you can pick up Cardano on the cheap, I think you have to do it.
Michael Batnik
Okay.
Ben Carlson
Because Cardano. With Cardano in Ripple, you get. You can see what with Cardano, it really is. So I don't know what a Cardano is. I don't know what Ripple does. I don't know. I don't.
Michael Batnik
Joel. So, all right, so for people that missed the headline because it came and went pretty quickly, at least with the. With the price pump. What did Trump. Trump tweeted that he's going to create a crypto reserve and it's going to be Bitcoin and Cardano and. And Ripple. And I don't know if he mentioned Solana in the first one, but then I guess somebody talked to him. Somebody gave him an elbow, was like, hey, also mention Eth. Mention Ethan Soul. So then he quote to him, it was like, of course there's going to be Ethan Sol there too. So all the coins pumped and this is just.
Ben Carlson
They pumped for a day and then they fell right back down.
Michael Batnik
It's a. It's a face palm. It's lots of face palms. Joe Lonsdale. Joe is the co. Founder of Palantir, founder of Addepar. He's very much in the. On the west coast tech scene. Joe tweeted, taxation is theft. It should be kept to a minimum. It's wrong to steal my money for a grift on the left. It's also wrong to tax me for crypto bro schemes. Efficient defense courts, national parks should fund themselves, prisons, etc. Fine. Cut it out with these schemes, guys. Credit to him because these are his people. So David Sachs, the crypto czar, quote, tweeted him and said, nobody announced a tax or spending program. Maybe you should wait to find out what's actually being proposed. So, I mean, the grift, the corruption, it's also bad. Why the do we need a crypto reserve? Why not? Why not an Apple reserve? Why not? I don't know why not. I just. It's nonsense.
Ben Carlson
I think we need an egg reserve in this country.
Michael Batnik
One thing that made me feel a little bit better, and maybe I'm naive and taking this at face value, is that the FT reported that David Sachs, prior to coming to the administration, sold all this crypto. He quote, tweeted and said, correct, I sold all my cryptocurrency, including bitcoin. Ethan sold prior to the start of the administration. I don't know if he was able to sell it for tax free. I don't know if that was part of the deal.
Ben Carlson
I don't know. That makes me feel kind of worse because if he was just trying to pump his own bags, I would actually understand it. If he's not trying to pump his bags, then I understand it even less.
Michael Batnik
Okay. Hunter Horsley, a CEO of Bitwise, said, I saw this Trump statement today. Same as everyone else, I imagine a strategic reserve would just be bitcoin. That makes the most sense to me. Now I understand this. Probably bitcoin reserve doesn't make a lot of sense to a lot of people, myself included. I don't think that we need a bitcoin reserve. But just back to Hunter's point, he said many crypto assets have merits. But we're talking about here isn't a US investment portfolio, we're talking about a reserve. And bitcoin is the undisputed store value for the digital age. Of course I'm grateful the new administration is so constructive on the space. Look forward to learning more about the thinking here. But what are we doing? What are we doing? Why are we doing this?
Ben Carlson
Because, yeah, essentially we would be using borrowed funds to go into more debt to buy these assets. It doesn't make any sense to me.
Michael Batnik
I think the reaction from the crypto crowd is mixed. As I just mentioned, there's obviously some people that are cheering it on and some people that are taking a little bit more of a sober view.
Ben Carlson
Oh really? Because I haven't seen one person who made a good case for why this should be, why this should Happen.
Michael Batnik
No, no, no, I didn't. I didn't say good case. I just said. I said, you're cheering it on. Many people, Many people in crypto are rejecting this, and many people are cheering on. I don't know what the.
Ben Carlson
Well, the people who are cheering it on just want to see the number go up.
Michael Batnik
Yeah, and I get that.
Ben Carlson
I think that. I think the worst thing for these crypto people is who are banking on all this stuff, is the government does all this stuff. They say we're gonna do a strategic reserve. They say we're gonna deregulate. And crypto still doesn't go to the moon. Then what? Then you actually. Then you're forced to, hey, we have to actually do something. We have to create something.
Michael Batnik
And then also, what if another administration comes in and dumps everything and says, no, we're undoing this?
Ben Carlson
Well, that's the thing when you have a reserve. Listen, the government is never in the same personal finance headspace as a household. People who make that, conflate those two, that's dumb. But if we're going broke.
Michael Batnik
Wait, hold on. We're going broke? Let's buy bitcoin.
Ben Carlson
Yes, but a reserve is. So let's. Let's say the government had a. Had billions and billions of dollars of crypto and they decided, okay, yeah, we're going to use this to pay off the debt. If they owned all that crypto and then they went to sell it to pay off the debt, guess what happens to the price of crypto? It crashes. So this, it's like a catch 22 thing where you can't. You can't say we're going to own all this crypto to pay off the debt, because once you try to pay it up, that's. It's like the, the value of all these meme coins and shit coins, if the largest holders ever went to sell them all, the price would effectively go to zero. So you're kind of holding yourself up with these values where it doesn't make any sense.
Michael Batnik
I don't understand. I don't understand the logic behind the bitcoin reserve. I think he's doing it because he said he was going to do it. But I don't like him one bit. Even as somebody that would benefit from higher prices, I do not like it.
Ben Carlson
I don't know. I think the US Government holding Cardano because Cardano, again, it can. You know, you can do stuff with it. And it's Cardano. I still don't know what that is. Someone tell me what it is. I have no idea.
Michael Batnik
Yeah.
Ben Carlson
Do you know what a cardano is? Come on.
Michael Batnik
I don't know what Cardano. It's a layer one. I don't know. It's a clown show. I really. Not Cardano. I don't know anything about it, but I don't like what's happening one bit.
Ben Carlson
All right?
Michael Batnik
This is why I bought Bitcoin in the first place. Because I hate this shit so much and because I'm a very petty person. If it was going up, I didn't own it. I'd be very spiteful. So does that make me a bad person or a bad investor or just an idiot or an asshole? I don't know, but I don't like it.
Ben Carlson
All right, how's this? I think we've been a little negative today. I think if we have a recession, the offset to recession is going to be the housing market. I'm pretty sure I believe this. So the housing market has been in a recession for the past, I don't know, 18, 24 months. Kevin Gordon tweeting us. Pending home sales have fallen to a new all time low. I'm coming around with the idea that the best hedge in the next recession will be housing. If interest rates continue to come down and mortgage rates get 6% then 5%.
Michael Batnik
No hard boiled eggs.
Ben Carlson
I think housing is going to be the hedge. I think you're going to see more activity in housing that has been pent up. Listen, if there is a recession and people lose jobs, that's bad. But if the unemployment rate went from 4% to 8%, that's still a large set of the population with a job and that have been waiting for lower rates and waiting for activity and waiting for people to get off the sidelines. And some people will because it's a recession. I feel like that pivot will make people want to sell. And then you have the home equity line of credit stuff come in where it's like, oh my HELOCs at 5% now. Now I'm going to tap this thing because I need the money. I think housing is going to be one of the automatic stabilizers during the next recession. Thoughts?
Michael Batnik
As long as banks don't pull back. Yeah, I like it. Listen, you said we're being very negative. I don't feel too negative. I like this. I like the idea that people have an opportunity to buy stocks at lower prices. Same same. Me and Shamath, same thing. Feel the same way. But again, no, this is, this is good. This. I don't, I don't like the tariffs. I don't like that. I don't like it. I think it's, it's dumb. But let's see.
Ben Carlson
How about this? What if the tariffs just offer people a really good buying opportunity and when they're taken off, then I think the, the big worry is that we go too far down this road and then things can't be completely prepared and back, well, back to where they were. We can't just go back. You hit a reset button. I think that's the worry. But I, I agree. Like, yeah, I'm, sometimes markets need to be shaken up a little bit.
Michael Batnik
I'm not a super bear. I'm also not an idiot who doesn't recognize that there's risk out there. Right. Like, can we go into a recession? Can we be, can we have a bear market? Yeah, obviously. But I'll, I'll, I'll say that I don't, I don't think that this is going to be a bear market. Could be wrong. This might age very poorly. But I think I, I don't see this going and why maybe giving opinion here, cause I'm making this up. But I don't think that this is gonna be more than a 12 percenter.
Ben Carlson
Okay, but so then that means that we're not having a recession. Because if you think we're going to have a recession, we're definitely going to have a bear market. Mark it down. Right. So I think that those two predictions have to go with one another and I think it's way too early to say like, we are definitely having a recession. I think that people have to probably pump the brakes again. The probability has risen. But you can't say like, we're definitely going into recession. I think that is a little too quick.
Michael Batnik
Yeah, but again, I said this last week. I'll say it again if you, because we've spoken to a lot of these people over the years who were Seduced by the 5% overnight raise and you had a lot of money in cash. Now's the time. I'm not saying now is the optimal time. I don't know. But if you were looking for an opportunity, at least start to plan your entrance. Okay. At least start to plan getting some money out of, out of cash and back into the market.
Ben Carlson
When all these high flying stocks that people go, oh, these stocks ran away from me. A lot of these growth stocks are already down 30, 40, 50%. Like we're, we could see another 20, 21 type of growth scare where a lot of these big stocks that were Up a lot are Palantir and Nvidia and whatever. And bitcoin is. Is falling again. Like all these things that you wish you would have bought. Now that they're falling, okay, now's your time to buy them at lower prices.
Michael Batnik
Yeah. All right, where we go next?
Ben Carlson
All right, from Bloomberg headline, Austin rent tumbles. Austin rents tumbled 22% from peak on massive home buying spree. And they, they say basically they built a ton of apartments in Austin. Guess what? Rents fell. They talked about these people who are getting two months free rent and 600 credit for signing their lease. So this says nowhere in the country have rents declined as much as they have in Austin now 22% off the peak reached in August 2023. According to Redfin, the median asking rent is $1,399 per month, down $400 in less than three years.
Michael Batnik
Wow.
Ben Carlson
We have a lot of problems in this country that have, that don't have readily made solutions, like how do we. How do we actually fix this big thing? That's a problem. A lot of them don't have easy answers. The housing market is the only one that has an easy answer. Now you could say, well, do we have enough labor and construction capacity to actually build more? Do we have enough financing available? But if, if government officials really wanted to fix the housing market, I think they could incentivize this to be done. They could incentivize builders with guaranteed mortgages or low rates or whatever it is. If we, if this was really something people wanted to fix, we could fix it. And it seems like there's no political will to do so for whatever reason. I don't understand it. But that is the one thing that there is a solution. It's very easy.
Michael Batnik
Fix it.
Ben Carlson
All right, don't look at this unless you did already. The Federal Reserve released household income for the Census data for 2020 through 2023. What is the mean? That's average for you non stat folks out there. The mean personal family income for household level. So anywhere that there's a household with more than one person bringing in an income, what is the average income for families in the United States?
Michael Batnik
I'm always afraid to take a guess here at the risk of sounding out of touch or like an idiot. The average household income.
Ben Carlson
Yes.
Michael Batnik
120,000.
Ben Carlson
Hey, you're pretty close. 136,000 or so higher than I would have thought, actually.
Michael Batnik
But why? I don't know. Two incomes, right? Is that what that's saying or. Not necessarily.
Ben Carlson
Yeah. No. Yeah, you're Right.
Michael Batnik
Yeah.
Ben Carlson
I don't know. I. It just high. High to mid six figures is now the. I don't know. It sounds. Sounds high to me. I think it's a good thing. That's why I do think getting back to the recession talk, if we do have a recession, it would. It would probably be a mild one because people have higher incomes and they have assets and they have a margin of safety in their house and all this stuff. If there is a slowdown, I. It's not. I don't see it being a calamity. I don't see it being.
Michael Batnik
I don't think tariffs are going to tank the economy.
Ben Carlson
No, I agree. Could they slow the economy? Yes. Could earnings fall and that hurts the stock market? Absolutely. Is it gonna cause a financial crisis?
Michael Batnik
No, I don't think so.
Ben Carlson
I don't think it gets to that point either.
Michael Batnik
So there's this guy that I follow on Twitter and his handle is. And I'll just link to it. It's not a great handle. It's his name and it's a bit. A lot of letters but post great stuff. His name is Karush and he has a chart. Where is this from? A company called Emarketer. It's showing that Amazon Prime's video ad tier launch in the first quarter of 2024 has suppressed US streaming ad prices into 2025. So it's. It's showing Netflix, Disney, Max Peacock and Hulu the average US ad supported video on demand CPM by platform.
Ben Carlson
Also when Amazon came in. So when Amazon came in, they set a lower bar and everyone else fell to it.
Michael Batnik
Yeah. You know, like the. Your march is my opportunity. This is pretty good illustration.
Ben Carlson
That's surprising. I would have not assumed prime video would have that much pull. I would have thought everyone would be to whatever Netflix sets. That's interesting but I guess all these other also ran they had to match Prime. If they're not as big as Netflix, they don't have as much power.
Michael Batnik
So Ben, Chris Ryan from the Ringer, he tweeted about a movie and so I clicked the link to the trailer but you know what I did not watching the trailer, reading the description. So here's the description. After a drug deal gone wrong, Tom Hardy's the star. After a drug deal gone wrong, a bruised detective must fight his way through a criminal underworld to rescue a politician's estranged son while unraveling a deep web of corruption and conspiracy that ensnares his entire city. I'm in.
Ben Carlson
Tom Hardy. All right.
Michael Batnik
Why would I Watch a trailer and spoil it. I'm in.
Ben Carlson
Yeah. I don't know. I'd personally just rather watch the trailer.
Michael Batnik
Really.
Ben Carlson
You can get a sense of the type, like the tone of the movie through a trailer. Like, oh, this is gonna be a really over the top action movie. That's not like. I don't think the description always matches the trailer.
Michael Batnik
What percent of movies of trailers do you see and say, this movie's gonna suck These days?
Ben Carlson
A lot of them. I love watching movie trailers, though. It's one of my favorite pastimes.
Michael Batnik
I watched a movie on the flight called Undercover. It's a foreign film.
Ben Carlson
Oh, look at you.
Michael Batnik
No big deal. And it's a woman goes undercover. Spy, espionage. Are we gonna get caught? Answer the phone. Who is it? Love it. I love movies like that where it's really tense. Is somebody's cover gonna get blown? Did you watch Zero Day? Is it Zero Day? What was the De Niro Netflix thing?
Ben Carlson
I made it like 15 minutes in and I just thought, eh.
Michael Batnik
Really?
Ben Carlson
Yeah.
Michael Batnik
How pretentious of you. 15 minutes and you thought you discarded Bobby D. You said, I get it, this is garbage.
Ben Carlson
When he was like working out and jogging. I don't know. I'm sorry. He mailed this performance in. Is he not. Is he mailing in everything these days? Does he really try anymore? He does so many, so many things. I don't know.
Michael Batnik
I like it.
Ben Carlson
All right. You're the only one.
Michael Batnik
All right, I have a dumb question. I was so. I was watching the combine, the NFL combine where college athletes compete. They do the 40 yard dash, they do the vertical jump. When these athletes do a vertical jump and it says like, oh, he has a 39 inch vertical. Tell me if this is what it means. Does this mean that his toes are 39 inches off the ground? Because I googled it. And the way that they do it is they put like this bar on top of you with like horizontal tags and you jump and you smack them, right? Yeah, so? So what they do is they measure the distance between you're standing arm up and however, whatever you hit, does that also by definition mean that their toes are 39 inches off the ground? Because it doesn't look like it. Like in the replay, it doesn't look like they're jumping three and a half feet.
Ben Carlson
Yes, that's what it means.
Michael Batnik
That's what it means, right?
Ben Carlson
Yes.
Michael Batnik
I don't believe it.
Ben Carlson
Okay, if you think about it, if you put your hand up and then your hand touches the top thing, it's just your Body's moving up by the same amount. Same thing.
Michael Batnik
Maybe, maybe, you know, it might be throwing me off is like when you jump, your feet go down.
Ben Carlson
Ah, true. The toes are pointed.
Michael Batnik
The toes are pointing. So maybe that adds that if you're, if these are big people. So if they're, if they're, if they've got 14 inch toes. That's why the 39 inches only looks like 26 inches or whatever.
Ben Carlson
Maybe we're measuring.
Michael Batnik
I'm looking at, I'm looking at things like, for frame of reference and like it just doesn't look like they're three and a half feet off the ground.
Ben Carlson
Measuring from the heels instead of the. Well, I have one of those box jumps. I don't do it as much anymore, but I have one of those box jumping things. Have you seen these before? You do box jumps for an exercise. For exercise you should do it. It'll help your back. And so you turn it on different sides and it says the, the height. And the tallest one I have is 30 inches. Right? It's. That's the tallest. And I put it up. And my kids always try to do it. They like, they have fun with it. But I can do, I can do 30 inches. Pretty. And that's not a. I have to pull my legs up, you know.
Michael Batnik
But do you think, do you think I could do 30 inches?
Ben Carlson
You might be able to keep them close. You possibly would blow out your Achilles. I just, I have to point out you sent us a picture of your old man basketball league.
Michael Batnik
My back hurts so bad. All week I couldn't. So on Tuesday I couldn't get out of bed. I felt getting out of bed like I thought I wasn't gonna be able to play, but.
Ben Carlson
So you play. How about once a week you play?
Michael Batnik
Yeah. But I couldn't bail because it's like the teams are decided and I can't be. Okay, guys, sorry. My back hurts. It's such.
Ben Carlson
I didn't realize how serious this was because I picture open gym. You show up, there's 15 guys and you shoot free throws to see who's on which team. And then you just play.
Michael Batnik
That is how it is. That is how it is. For every week, except for one week, we do an official thing.
Ben Carlson
Okay. Cause the picture you sent me, you had like a team uniform on.
Michael Batnik
Yeah.
Ben Carlson
Like a full out uniform that you guys like had printed up somewhere. So this is serious stuff. And of course you were number 69, which.
Michael Batnik
All right, dude, I was a statue out there. I couldn't move. It was Awful. Let my.
Ben Carlson
Okay.
Michael Batnik
By the way, you know what? If we're feeling. If this podcast is feeling a little extra dark. This is the darkest hotel room I've ever been in. There's no light. There's. With lamp. I'm using a lamp.
Ben Carlson
I feel like hotels should all have the same light switches in the same places, because that really always throws me off. Sometimes the switch is on the light, sometimes it's on like a switch on the wall in a weird place. It's always really hard to find the switches for the lamps in hotels legitimately.
Michael Batnik
I'm looking around this. There's. There's. Honest to goodness, there's no lights in here.
Ben Carlson
It does look very dark. All right, let's go to the Ben's Feelings section of the show now. So you said a couple weeks ago we were talking about my brother, that with your mother, you. The small stuff doesn't impact you anymore or like the.
Michael Batnik
Nope. Never.
Ben Carlson
Yeah. So this. So this Keanu Reeves meme that I've seen before, it's like I'm at that stage of my life where I keep myself out of arguments. Even if you tell me one plus one equals five, you're absolutely correct. Enjoy.
Michael Batnik
Yeah.
Ben Carlson
And I see people post this all the time. I don't think anyone actually has this line of thinking in their life. I feel like Keanu must be a one of one. But I can certainly see after going through a situation like this, there's like, immediately I feel like there was take all this stuff on the table that people think about and worry about on a daily basis and shove 60% of it off the table. For me, just a lot of stuff that people seem to care about. I just cannot find my. Make myself care about anymore. And I don't know if that's going to last. It might last, but I also. I also can see the situation where someone who goes through a tragedy like this and a really bad situation. Like, as someone who's tried to study, like, the. The emotions of investors in psychology for the past, I don't know, 20 years or so and try to understand them better. I feel like I'm, like, internally dissecting myself to have the feelings that I'm having. And I can easily see how someone would tip over the scale and fall into the land of nihilism or I don't care about anything and I'm just depressed. I can see how easily you could fall into that trap. I can't do that because I have a family, but I can see how easily that can go From a superpower of, oh, I don't care about this other. This menial stuff that no one should care about. I don't care about that anymore, too. I don't care about anything. And that's. That's like the. The balance you have to walk of. You can't get to that other place of not care about anything, because then what's the point of anything, right? Anyway, but. So my. My. My goal is that I'm going to be Keanu, and we'll see if that lasts or not.
Michael Batnik
But love it.
Ben Carlson
Yes, I'm trying.
Michael Batnik
I made a phone call last week to the. To a dog trainer. We have a boxer puppy, and she needs some training because boxer puppies are wild. So, anyway, I left a voicemail and I gave them my number you could reach me at, and I repeated it because that's. I guess that's what I do. I don't know if that's what you do, but. And I thought to myself, hey, wait a minute. This is 2025. They're going to get a missed call for me, and they see the voicemail, say transcribe. They could just hit the play button and call me back. They don't need. I don't need to leave them my phone number.
Ben Carlson
I think you do as a courtesy still, just in case. Okay, Right.
Michael Batnik
But, but, but wait, listen to this. So I had that thought, and then a day later, Robin forwarded me a voicemail. And I'm glad the person left their. Their phone number, because if you get forwarded a voicemail, it's not a missed call. Right? So you can't just, like. You can't just, like, press play or press callback. So I needed the phone number. In this case.
Ben Carlson
That's true. Especially with a business. Sometimes the call comes in from, like, a central number, and it's not the number you need to get for the person.
Michael Batnik
Ben, can I. Can I share a nitpick that is going to reveal a maybe? I don't know if there's a bad flaw in my personality and I'm not even bothered by it. It's not even a nitpick. It's just. It's more of, like, an observation. Okay. I'm not mad. Just like when you get picked up by an Uber driver from your home and they say your name with a question mark. Oh, Michael. Yeah. Yes. You're at my house. Of course it's Michael. I'm not. They should just say, good morning, Michael. Now, if you're. If you're. If you're At a city, obviously they say it's appropriate to ask with the question mark because there's thousands of people around.
Ben Carlson
Creatures of habit. What if they just have gone to the wrong house before? You know, I got. Speaking of convenience, I'd say once a week I will get doordash tomorrow. If I'm busy in the office and I'm doing something and I don't want to, like, go out to get lunch somewhere, I will just doordash it. And I did it the other day, and this doordash guy walks into my office and he's got this huge two bags of. From a subs shop. Fire something. Subs or whatever. He's like, here you go. And it's all these chips and it's probably like 16 sub sandwiches. And I was like. I was waiting for him to pull my bag out of these bags. So that's what he was doing. He's like, here you go. And I said, sorry, that's not my order. I didn't order it from that place. Or I don't have 16 people in here. And the guy's like, are you sure? I'm like, yeah, I'm pretty sure.
Michael Batnik
Are you sure?
Ben Carlson
Guess what? He realized the computer messed him up. He went all the way back to the restaurant, got my order, brought it back, and then he realized that it was messed up and was a nice guy about the whole thing.
Michael Batnik
He said, here, I'll leave these 16 sandwiches.
Ben Carlson
All right, let's do recommendations. I watched Anora this weekend, I think the night before the Oscars. I've heard good things about it, wanted to see it, and so here's my review. I watched it in two sittings. So I watched the first half Friday night, the second half Saturday night. And my review is this movie was the horse meme. The horse drawn meme.
Michael Batnik
I love this movie. I disagree, but go ahead. What's your review? You don't like the ending or the second half?
Ben Carlson
I thought the first half of the movie was amazing. I was ready to proclaim, like, okay, this should have won best Oscar. It was very good. And I thought the second half of the movie was way too long. It was tedious, it was annoying. And I didn't. It just totally fell off of a cliff for me. And I just. It was like, eh. It was an okay movie. I thought it just kind of really ended. It like limped to the finish line.
Michael Batnik
Okay. I was on a major high from seeing this in the theater, so I think that I was able to. More. I was better able to tolerate A maybe not so great second half, but.
Ben Carlson
I was a 220 minute movie and they could have easily cut 45 minutes off of anything from the second half of the movie. It was so.
Michael Batnik
Excuse me. What do you mean they easily cut? Sir, this is the Oscar winner. How dare you. You saw it from your couch. You don't get that?
Ben Carlson
I think the Oscar movies this year stunk. I think this is one of the worst best picture lineups in 20 years. I think that's my takeaway. The performance was amazing. The performance, I thought of the two. The Russian kid I thought was hilarious.
Michael Batnik
And then the goons were so funny.
Ben Carlson
I thought they were just okay. I thought the main girl, I thought she was great and she, she probably deserved the Oscar, but I just thought the movie was kind of. Eh.
Michael Batnik
Alright. I loved the movie but I agree this was a really, really good.
Ben Carlson
Now here's my question for you. Was she doing a Staten island or a Long island accent in the movie?
Michael Batnik
Staten Island? No, Brooklyn, I think. Or Staten Island. Not Long Island.
Ben Carlson
Okay, I thought Staten Island. So that was my review of the North. Here's my other thing. TV is so good right now. So my wife and I were talking the other day. Every week we get new episodes of the Pit, which is just a fantastic show. I mentioned this before. You have to watch it. The Pit, White Lotus and Severance. New episodes every week.
Michael Batnik
Can I tell you something?
Ben Carlson
These are three amazing shows.
Michael Batnik
I've never watched a medical. I never watched ER So I'm not a. Never watch Grey's Anatomy. It's different.
Ben Carlson
Okay, but watch the Pit. It is a fantastic show. It is so good. Such high quality.
Michael Batnik
Can I say one thing on so I'm late to Severance? I'm just. I don't know why I missed the start to season two and I've just been dragging my feet.
Ben Carlson
The last episode was fantastic.
Michael Batnik
Okay, I need to get. I'm having trouble breaking back into it. Like I thought the first couple episodes of this.
Ben Carlson
The first couple episodes of this season I felt were a little weird and. But it's grown in. The last couple have been. I think it's well on its way to being a prestige TV show. It's great.
Michael Batnik
Okay. Yeah, I need to. I'll break through the barrier. I just need to last two weeks ago. I forgot to mention this. They did Wayne's World on the rewatchables. Oh, I saw Rocky drop this morning, by the way. They did Rocky. I'm psyched to listen to that. So Kyle Brandt was on Wayne's World with Bill Simmons and those guys just. Especially Kyle Brandt just destroyed.
Ben Carlson
Yeah, I rewatched it. I rewatched it because I listened to that. It is funny how much of a. It's more of like a skit based movie than it is. I forgot how skit based it is. But yeah, Mike Myers is kind of a genius.
Michael Batnik
I never saw it. So they also did Blues Brothers. I never saw that movie. I don't think I'm ever going to.
Ben Carlson
I feel like it's one of those movies that it was either in your time and you loved it or it was past your time and you kind of go, wait a minute. What? Yeah, it's kind of a weird.
Michael Batnik
Yeah.
Ben Carlson
Pop culture thing.
Michael Batnik
Oh, I. We'll do the top 10 shows. But before we do, I flagged one thing that I want to. That I want to get a chuckle with you out of. I saw this on Instagram from barstool. They made a bracket. What is the best old guy phrase? Did you see this by any chance? Okay, we're going to go through this. This is historical news flash. Buddy versus yellow. All right, next. Next one is look who the cat dragged in versus hate to burst your bubble. And look, it's all. It's all just old guys. Next is. I don't know why this tickles my funny bone. Let me sneak past you versus don't mind if I do.
Ben Carlson
I guess these aren't a lot of phrases that are probably going to die at some point, aren't they?
Michael Batnik
Next is it's not the heat, it's the humidity. Of course, a classic versus working hard.
Ben Carlson
Or hardly working is beer o'clock on there.
Michael Batnik
All right, so that's one side of the bracket. The other side is what's the damage Right. When you're going to pay the bill versus see you later, alligator. Next is you in one army versus talking about food. These are dangerous. Okay, next is no more Mr. Nice Guy versus Nice Blinker. Oh, and people don't put on their blinker. All right, and lastly, ready to rock and roll versus cool your jets.
Ben Carlson
See, I feel like these are more funny to you because you're a middle aged guy now.
Michael Batnik
I don't know why. These are all very, very funny to me.
Ben Carlson
All right, shows we're doing it. I got a big list. I got a huge list here.
Michael Batnik
Me too.
Ben Carlson
Okay, I'm going to go first. These are the ones that are unimpeachable for me. So this is.
Michael Batnik
Hold on, let me grab my list.
Ben Carlson
This is the best shows of this century, basically, since we have prestige, and I'm going to include the Soprano since that.
Michael Batnik
Wait, wait, wait a minute.
Ben Carlson
Kick this off.
Michael Batnik
No network shows.
Ben Carlson
Well, there's one network show on Friday Night Lights. Yes.
Michael Batnik
No, it's not allowed because I don't make the rules. The emailer made the rules, and he said no network shows. But fine, go.
Ben Carlson
All right, so my unimpeachable ones are Breaking Bad, the Wire, Sopranos, Mad.
Michael Batnik
Wait, hold on, hold on. Dude, you got it. Sorry, Slow down.
Ben Carlson
I got a lot. Okay, so Breaking Bad, the Wire, Sopranos, those are on everyone's list. Mad Men, which I was an early adopter of. I was in Mad Men from the start. Six Feet under is my one that not a lot of people have. I think that's one of the best shows ever, and it has the greatest finale of all time. Succession is made under the list. Then Friday Night Lights, those are my unimpeached ones. I think that's seven. Okay, so my ones that could have made it, that are probably pretty close. I have Game of Thrones.
Michael Batnik
Hold on. You still have three more spots.
Ben Carlson
I know, and I'm going to tell you, there's a lot of them that are jockeying for those positions. I think Severance could get there.
Michael Batnik
Hey, cool your jets.
Ben Carlson
I think Severance could get there. I think White Lotus will probably be there. I rewatched. I tried to watch your De Niro show, and I decided, you know what? I'm just going to watch the first season of White Lotus again. And I forgot how good of a character Armand is. I think he's the best White Lotus character ever.
Michael Batnik
So good.
Ben Carlson
And that was only six episodes. I could have gone another four episodes of that crew. I think Veep could potentially be on the list. The Leftovers, I think, is a really underrated one. And then the Bear and Fleabag. So those are ones that are, like, very close. For me, that could. The positioning could be jostle. Then the ones that could have been there but trailed off. House of Cards, I think people forget how good those first few seasons were. The Americans, it kind of died down in the middle. And the ending was great. Dexter started off great, like the first four seasons and trailed off. Arrested Development was one of the original comedies, I think, and then Justified in the Office. So I got a whole list of stuff here. I'm the guy with the strings on the wall.
Michael Batnik
And so what do you. What are you. What. What's. Which Three you plucking.
Ben Carlson
So I'd probably say Veep, I think, is the funniest comedy show maybe ever written or not Funniest, smartest. So I'd say, like, Veep, White Lotus, and probably the bear.
Michael Batnik
Oh, wow. You love the bear.
Ben Carlson
Yes, I love the bear.
Michael Batnik
Okay, Flea guy.
Ben Carlson
You said fleabag.
Michael Batnik
Fleabag. Really?
Ben Carlson
Yeah. I think that's a great show.
Michael Batnik
I have three separate lists. One is my list, and one is this is off my list because I didn't see these shows, so I didn't see a lot of these shows. I never saw the Wire, the Americans, Deadwood, Atlanta, Veep, and I only saw three seasons of Sopranos.
Ben Carlson
Okay, that's good to know.
Michael Batnik
These are. Okay. So they're not on my list. I never saw them. I know they're on everyone else's. These are not on my list. But these are like my next 10, True Detective. I know 2 and 3 were terrible, but one was so epic. Game of Thrones, Girls, True Blood, Ray Donovan, the Boys, True Detective, Entourage, Yellowstone, Sons of Anarchy. All good shows. Not top 10. All right, my top 10, in no order. I think the only one that's really out there. I don't know if there's a great list. Actually, I have two that probably don't belong. All right, the two that don't belong. Bloodline was a show on Netflix where the first two seasons were two of my favorite seasons ever.
Ben Carlson
It was very good. The first season especially was very good.
Michael Batnik
The third season stunk, but, hey, it's on my list, so what can I tell you? And then the other one that probably shouldn't be here but is Boardwalk Empire. Is that a big stretch? That's a stretch.
Ben Carlson
I know. I love that show.
Michael Batnik
Okay, all right, so a succession.
Ben Carlson
Very high quality show.
Michael Batnik
What else do I have here that's different from yours? I have Succession on Bloodline. I put House of Cards here because I love that show. I have White Lotus. Oh, Curb. Did you not put Curb on yours?
Ben Carlson
No. Probably could have.
Michael Batnik
Homeland, Breaking Bad. Two others that I missed that you don't have. Silicon Valley and Ali G. Borat, Bruno.
Ben Carlson
All right, I think we cover them all on our list. You picked up a few that I missed, and I picked up a few that missed. I did love Ali G. Back in the day.
Michael Batnik
I listened to him recently on Smartless.
Ben Carlson
Yeah, he's very good.
Michael Batnik
Genius. All right, what else is going on, Ben?
Ben Carlson
I got nothing.
Michael Batnik
All right, what's the market doing? Let's see. Down.
Ben Carlson
Okay, next week at this time, are we In a correction, 10% down from the highs, or does he blink this weekend? See, this is the hard part. If you're trying to predict this stuff and you're saying this is definitely going to happen. He could wake up Sunday and say tariffs are gone. And that changes the entire landscape of any prediction you can make.
Michael Batnik
Yeah. I mean, the, the news flow, like I said, Ben, it's a very fluid situation. The news flow is happening so quickly that who knows, a lot of things that we said today might look very foolish, even tomorrow.
Ben Carlson
But I feel like, I feel like everything that the Wall street people predicted is completely wrong. Anything Wall street firms have been saying, this is a negotiating tactic. He's not going to actually do it.
Michael Batnik
All that stuff, throw it up, full steam ahead.
Ben Carlson
Yeah. And those, the Wall street firms have been completely offsides on this. On this the whole time. They were wrong.
Michael Batnik
Yeah.
Ben Carlson
So anything they say, I don't, I don't trust it. I don't, I, I don't think you can trust anyone in this that tries to handicap this right now. Because we don't know.
Michael Batnik
Yeah. Yeah. Who knows where we'll be next week? We'll be here. We'll be recording. We'll be reacting animal spirits@the compoundnews.com thank you for listening. We'll see you don't get.
Animal Spirits Podcast - Episode 402 Summary: "Is a Recession Coming?"
Released on March 5, 2025
Hosts: Michael Batnick and Ben Carlson
Podcast: Animal Spirits Podcast by The Compound
Description: Animal Spirits delves into markets, life, and investing, featuring discussions on current readings, writings, listens, and views by Michael Batnick and Ben Carlson. New episodes are released every Wednesday morning.
Timeframe: 03:04 - 04:45
Michael Batnick and Ben Carlson kick off the episode by addressing the prevailing bearish sentiment in the market, highlighting an increased belief among analysts and investors that a recession is imminent.
Ben Carlson emphasizes the heightened risk:
"I don't think it's hyperbolic to say that the risk of a recession and/or stagflation or a bear market is much higher now than it was a month ago. [...] If we continue down the path of government austerity and 25% tariffs on all of our trading partners, then the risk of recession is way higher now than it was before."
— [03:19]
Michael Batnick adds context on market multiples:
"... if we do get a recession from elevated multiples, not crazy, but elevated multiples, the 24 times forward earnings, 26 times, whatever it was, that was all well and good in the world, that might not exist anymore. And if earnings are not going to deliver the growth that was being priced into that multiple, it can get ugly in a hurry."
— [04:35]
Timeframe: 04:45 - 07:25
The discussion shifts to the implementation of new tariffs and their immediate effects on GDP predictions and corporate earnings.
Ben Carlson references the GDP Now model:
"Last week, this thing crashed to show, well, the first quarter looks like it's going to be a negative GDP print. And then it went down even more this week, and now it's showing, I don't know, a negative 2.8% or something."
— [04:58]
Michael Batnick addresses the broader economic implications:
"...tariffs are causing this. But the point was like, well, this could be more of a calculation kind of thing with the way imports and exports are calculated, that it's not necessarily all of a sudden economic activity is falling off a cliff."
— [05:59]
Daryl Fairweather, Chief Economist at Redfin, weighs in via tweet:
"...unless we all wake up from this collective tariff nightmare, the reality is recession, recession with inflation, which is called stagflation. It's the worst kind of recession because people lose their jobs and prices stay high, along with interest rates."
— [05:27]
Timeframe: 07:25 - 11:34
The hosts analyze how tariffs and economic uncertainty are affecting stock valuations and corporate earnings, citing specific company reports.
Ben Carlson observes:
"The tax is such a dominant piece of the conversation that Nvidia fell 10% yesterday and it seemed like nobody. It was like an afterthought."
— [07:25]
Michael Batnick cites Target's earnings outlook:
"...in light of ongoing consumer uncertainty and a small decline in February net sales combined with tariff uncertainty, the company expects to see meaningful year-over-year profit pressure in its Q1 relative to the remainder of the year."
— [07:53]
Timeframe: 12:56 - 15:11
The conversation turns to renowned investor Ray Dalio's persistent predictions of economic downturns and how Bridgewater Associates navigates these forecasts.
Ben Carlson critiques Dalio:
"...if you're a legendary investor, you want to kind of ride off into the sunset. [...] He predicted a depression in the early 1980s right before we set off on the biggest bull market in history in the United States. So I think the most interesting thing about Dalio is the fact that he is constantly predicting a financial crisis, but that doesn't really translate into his returns of his fund because I think so much of the fund that he invests in at Bridgewater is quantitatively based and model driven."
— [12:56]
Michael Batnick summarizes Dalio's current stance:
"He's not in charge anymore."
— [14:10]
Timeframe: 16:12 - 19:48
Exploring beyond the U.S., the hosts discuss the potential for European markets to outperform, supported by insights from Stripe's annual report.
Ben Carlson notes a significant market divergence:
"The year-to-date returns for the Europe Vanguard European stock index were 13% on a year-to-date basis. And the S&P was up 1% or so."
— [16:12]
Michael Batnick references Stripe's analysis:
"The revenue that businesses process on Stripe is growing seven times faster than that of all companies in the S&P 500."
— [17:50]
They discuss structural advantages in Europe, such as diversified financing solutions, which might contribute to sustained growth amidst global economic challenges.
Timeframe: 25:03 - 29:15
A contentious segment where the hosts dissect former President Trump's proposal to create a cryptocurrency reserve, triggering mixed reactions from the crypto community.
Ben Carlson expresses skepticism:
"It doesn't make any sense to me. [...] Because if we're going broke. [...] And if they owned all that crypto and then they went to sell it to pay off the debt, guess what happens to the price of crypto? It crashes."
— [28:11]
Michael Batnik criticizes the logic behind the proposal:
"I don't understand the logic behind the bitcoin reserve. I think he's doing it because he said he was going to do it. But I don't like him one bit."
— [29:01]
They further discuss the implications of government involvement in cryptocurrency markets and the potential for market manipulation and instability.
Timeframe: 30:07 - 34:04
The hosts shift focus to the housing market, suggesting it could serve as a stabilizing force during a recession.
Ben Carlson proposes:
"I think the housing market has been in a recession for the past, I don't know, 18, 24 months. [...] the best hedge in the next recession will be housing."
— [31:18]
Michael Batnik agrees, noting the role of banks:
"As long as banks don't pull back."
— [31:21]
They discuss how lower mortgage rates and pent-up demand could drive housing market activity, despite broader economic challenges.
Timeframe: 35:51 - 37:27
The conversation touches on recent data released by the Federal Reserve regarding household incomes.
Ben Carlson presents the figures:
"The mean personal family income for household level is around $136,000 or so."
— [36:44]
Michael Batnik reflects on the implications:
"But why? I don't know. Two incomes, right? Is that what that's saying or not necessarily."
— [36:29]
They analyze how higher household incomes might provide resilience against economic downturns, although Ben suggests that if a recession occurs, it would likely be mild due to these financial buffers.
Timeframe: 38:07 - 60:09
Beyond economics and markets, the hosts engage in light-hearted discussions covering topics such as:
Streaming Services and Ad Rates:
Analyzing how Amazon Prime's introduction of an ad-supported tier has influenced the broader video on demand landscape, leading to suppressed ad prices across platforms.
— [38:07]
Personal Anecdotes and Recommendations:
Sharing experiences with movies like "Anora," discussing personal activities such as playing in a local basketball league despite back pain, and exchanging thoughts on TV shows like "Severance," "White Lotus," and "The Pit."
Old Guy Phrases Bracket Challenge:
A humorous segment where the hosts compete in selecting the best old guy phrases, illustrating generational differences in communication styles.
— [53:24]
NFL Combine Observations:
A curious inquiry about the measurement of vertical jumps during the NFL Combine, sparking a brief technical discussion.
— [40:30]
Timeframe: 59:54 - 60:09
As the episode wraps up, the hosts reflect on the unpredictability of current economic indicators and reiterate the fluidity of the situation, emphasizing that future developments could swiftly alter current perceptions and predictions.
Michael Batnik concludes:
"The news flow is happening so quickly that who knows, a lot of things that we said today might look very foolish, even tomorrow."
— [59:29]
Ben Carlson adds a note of caution against relying on Wall Street's narratives, hinting at their own skepticism regarding institutional forecasts.
"So anything they say, I don't trust it. I don't think you can trust anyone in this that tries to handicap this right now."
— [60:00]
Finally, they invite listeners to stay tuned for future discussions and updates, signing off with their usual sign-off.
Recession Risks: The risk of a recession has increased due to government austerity measures and tariffs, potentially leading to stagflation.
Tariffs' Impact: New tariffs have significantly affected GDP predictions and corporate earnings, particularly in sectors reliant on imports.
Market Sentiment: Elevated stock market multiples may not hold if earnings growth falters, risking a swift market downturn.
International Outlook: European markets show potential for outperformance, supported by faster revenue growth rates in sectors like payment processing (e.g., Stripe).
Cryptocurrency Concerns: Proposals for government crypto reserves are met with skepticism, highlighting fears of market manipulation and instability.
Housing as a Hedge: The housing market may provide stability during economic downturns, supported by lower mortgage rates and continued demand.
Household Income Resilience: Higher average household incomes could buffer against severe economic shocks, suggesting a potentially mild recession if one occurs.
Notable Quotes:
Ben Carlson:
"If we continue down the path of government austerity and 25% tariffs on all of our trading partners, then the risk of recession is way higher now than it was before."
— [03:19]
Michael Batnik:
"... if we do get a recession from elevated multiples... it can get ugly in a hurry."
— [04:35]
Ben Carlson:
"I don't think you can trust anyone in this that tries to handicap this right now."
— [60:00]
Conclusion
In this episode of Animal Spirits, Michael Batnick and Ben Carlson provide an in-depth analysis of the growing fears surrounding a potential recession, the impact of new tariffs on the economy and stock market, the skepticism towards prominent economic forecasts, and the promising outlook for international markets, particularly in Europe. They also delve into the controversial topic of cryptocurrency reserves proposed by political figures and explore the housing market's role as a possible stabilizer in uncertain economic times. Throughout the discussion, the hosts intersperse their dialogue with personal anecdotes and lighter segments, maintaining an engaging and informative discourse for listeners navigating the complexities of current market dynamics.