
Loading summary
Emma Chamberlain
You want to know what just absolutely terrifies me? Keeps me up at night, and then when I finally fall asleep, fuels my nightmares. Let me tell you about the permanence of the Internet. This is a reality of life that I contemplate multiple times a day. And not in, like a sort of beautiful, introspective way. No, I contemplate this reality of life multiple times a day. In fear, in a panic, overcome with anxiety. Okay. I am tortured by the permanence of the Internet. Tortured. And it's kind of funny because I am as tortured by the permanence of the Internet as I am because of my own voluntary actions. Okay. I made the decision to post the last seven years of my life on the Internet. I did that. I made that choice. Now I'm sort of tortured by it. And it's like, okay, but I did it to myself. That's a reoccurring theme for me. Okay. I often sort of get myself into the most uncomfortable predicaments in my life. Usually I'm the one who did something wrong to get myself there. Although I don't think I did anything wrong because I actually have no regrets. Even though I am completely tortured by the permanence of the Internet, I also am aware that it is something that I have to deal with in order to be on the Internet. Like, the Internet is not the Internet. If it's not permanent. That is a key detail. I briefly paused this episode to let you know that this episode is presented by Westin Hotels and Resorts. Westin Hotels is designed with your wellbeing in mind. With more than 200 destinations around the world, West Westin Hotels makes it possible to keep up with your wellness routine while traveling. With signature amenities and offerings that help you move well, eat well, and sleep well. And with their iconic next generation heavenly bed, you can look forward to the rest. The worst part about traveling is how it impacts your sleep. Whether you're dealing with jet lag or not having slept on a flight, it can ruin a trip. Find wellness at Weston, One of the 30 extraordinary hotel brands in the Marriott Bonvoy portfolio. Now back to the episode. I'm like, I have, like, a tight chest. Okay, just talking about this topic, but I also think I have a tight chest because I was around people this weekend who were vaping, and I was like, I'm obviously gonna hit that. So I vaped a lot this weekend after a long time of not really vaping. And so I think my chest is a little bit tight because of that as well. I'm Also feeling a little weird, I think, because I'm probably withdrawing a little bit from nicotine. So if my vibe is like off, it's because I'm kind of dissociating from nicotine withdrawals and I feel weird. Like my brain and body equilibrium is very off. Would I love to hit a vape right now? Yes. But no, I don't own vapes anymore. I only hit other people's. Anyways, I will say I do think that I am more significantly affected by this reality of life, the permanence of the Internet than the average person because my entire life and my entire career is on the Internet. However, I do think that this is a concern for people in the 21st century. Okay, I think my feelings towards it are a bit more extreme, but I actually do think that this is a concern for everyone because it is just a current truth. This is just something that like the Internet is permanent, that can be good and that can be bad, you know what I'm saying? For everyone. More so for people who, you know, have a career on the Internet, who have shared a lot of their life on the Internet, but still. So for people who have not, it's sort of terrifying for everyone, I think because I'm somebody who's shared majority of my life on the Internet. I look at a time prior to the Internet where everyone could sort of just evolve and grow as a person in the real world. And everyone was judged based on who they were within their close knit community. And obviously there's always been celebrities and public figures who have, you know, been judged on a larger scale. But even those people couldn't like go on Instagram and read their comments. Like there's something sort of beautiful about the fact that, I don't know, like the past was the past. Like people were just allowed to sort of move through phases so much more naturally. Whereas now we have access to people's history, we can directly see and relive someone's past whenever we want, as long as it's on the Internet. And for a lot of us it is on the Internet. Instead of it just being this distant memory or something that, you know, only our close friends and family knew about or, you know what I'm saying, for a lot of us, our entire past is completely documented, is completely cemented in history in a way, in a way that is so accurate because of the Internet. And there's something so much more like powerful about that that really freaks me out. Prior to the Internet, there was no fear of your mistakes being broadcasted. To the world stage. Worst case scenario, you know, your family and friends in, in community find out about a mistake you made. But these are all people who know you. They know your character. They like, they might at worst exile you in some sort of way. But technically you can leave that. You can get in your car and drive five hours and move to a city five hours away and start over fresh and none of those people will know about your past. You know what I'm saying? The idea that you could make a mistake and be confronted by your friends and family and community and then sort of move forward in the world as a person who has learned from that mistake, to me is so romantic. The idea that there isn't actually really evidence necessarily unless you did something so bad that it made it into the newspaper, like prior to the Internet, there was no risk of your mistakes being permanent in history. I think that there probably felt like a future where it could even be forgotten. It was up to you to tell that story once everybody forgot. If you wanted to bring it up again, if you wanted to tell that story again, you could. Whereas now on the Internet, if one of your mistakes gets broadcasted in some way, everyone knows about it forever. One Google search away, they can find your mistake for the rest of your life. You never get to move on from that. That's not your story to tell anymore. That is now this permanent story that is permanently on the Internet that can be accessed at any given moment, at any time, through the phone, through the Google search. Okay, this upsets me. I also think too the idea that, you know, you can have sort of cringe, embarrassing phases in your life, but then move jobs or towns and start over completely. Like all of this is a beautiful sort of concept to me that I think still does exist depending on your lifestyle, but is a novelty now more than ever. It didn't used to be a novelty. This just used to be reality. Whereas now for majority of people this is, this is a concern, this is the new reality is the fact that, you know, like, even for people who are not on the Internet, right, Even for people who don't have social media, there's still this sort of fear of the permanence of the Internet because let's say you're out at a party and you get blackout drunk and people take their phones out and start filming and then post it on the Internet and you go viral because you did something sloppy or silly or stupid or dumb or you said something horrible. Like, even for those who are not on the Internet, this is still a concern. And I mean, I do think it's all relative because prior to the Internet, the ridicule of perhaps your community was just as scary and terrifying, but now it's on a worldly scale. And I know it might sound sort of irrational, like, again, for the average person, for the most part, you can live anonymously. You can sort of rewrite your history. The past is not necessarily permanent, but it can be. For me, it's fully fucking permanent. Okay? For me, I'm living the extreme like it is fully permanent for me. For most people, it's still not fully that extreme yet, but it's still a concern. And it's something that deeply, deeply affects me personally. It's something that for the last few years has fucked with me psychologically in a number of ways. This episode is brought to you by Squarespace. Have you ever been shopping online and the website just gave you the ick? Let me tell you, that wouldn't happen if they used Squarespace. Squarespace Design Intelligence empowers anyone to build beautiful, more, more personalized websites tailored to your unique needs. And with Squarespace Payments, it's super easy to manage payments with just a few clicks. Plus, with Squarespace's integrated and optimized SEO tools, there's all the help you need to get people to your site. Head to squarespace.com emma for a free trial and use code EMMA to save 10% on your first purchase. This episode is brought to you by the Amazon Influencer program. Whether you've been a content creator for a while or are just thinking about getting started, the Amazon Influencer program is a great way for creators of all kinds to earn money. Once you've signed up, you'll be able to share links to Amazon products on your social media and earn when your followers shop using your links. Sign up now@Amazon.com anything goes to get started. Number one, I've struggled with something that I think every public figure has struggled with, which is the fear of being canceled for something that I did when I was younger and dumber. In the age of the Internet and growing up in the age of the Internet, everything that I did as a middle schooler in high schooler is documented. Okay? In middle school and high school, we all had iPhones. It was like when the iPhone first came out and we all finally got them and we were all filming and taking photos of absolutely everything. And I would be lying if I said that I. I don't worry sometimes about, like, what the fuck I did. I know I probably did some shit that I would absolutely regret now. Was I ultimately 13 years old? Yeah, I was 13 years old. But it doesn't matter. Because something that I did as a 13 year old, not knowing how things could be hurtful or mean or disrespectful or, like, not knowing being so young and completely aloof, we have no clue what the fuck is going on. We have no clue what we're doing. We have no clue what we're saying. We have no clue the repercussions of anything. We're rebellious. We don't care. Like the fact that that phase of my life is in some ways permanent through fucking Snapchat memories and shit on my own phone and other people's phone. This is something I don't like. This is a reality that I don't like. This is something that really, really bothers me. And it bothers me because I've worked so hard to become the person I am today. I've been scolded by my fucking parents for, you know, saying shit that's disrespectful, saying shit that's morally wrong, doing shit that's disrespectful, doing shit that's morally wrong. I've gotten my ass handed to me already. I. I've learned my lessons. Who I am today, I'm very proud of. You know, do I make mistakes still? Do I do things still that could potentially, like, I don't know, like tomorrow, you know, somebody could come out and say, one time Emma was rude to me, and I might think of me like, oh, my God, that was a week ago. And you know what? That's true. Like, I don't fucking know. We live half of our lives in autopilot. So, like, is there still a risk today? Yes. However, who I am today, I am in control of. This is me today. I am the product of every single mistake I've ever made in my entire life. And I'm better for it. And I really am proud of my character today. So I'm tortured in a lot of ways by this person who is almost not even me anymore, right? Like, me as a child with barely developed brain. Like, in the age of the Internet, that is not just a distant memory. That is permanent. Right? And the idea of being judged for my past as though it's the present, it's a hard pill for me to swallow. I think it's a hard pill for a lot of people to swallow. And I think that sort of leads me to this other complicated, sort of terrifying element of the permanence of the Internet. The fact that a memory, a story told verbally, it's so much more gently received than like a video, a photo, like solid proof, you know, that is responded to much more viscerally and understandably so, because by watching a video, by looking at a photo, you're transported to that time because you can see it, you know what I'm saying? It just, it brings you there, it connects you to that story, to that moment. Whereas like hearing something or recalling a memory, it's just so much more gentle, right? And so that's the other thing. It's like the permanence of the Internet is made even more complex because not only is it now permanent, like set in stone in time, but also it's even there's something about the way that we psychologically respond to it that makes it also like more potent. But that also leads me to what I briefly mentioned earlier. Like, I also experience immense fear around messing up today, right? Like there is this sort of fear of being judged on what I did in the past, right, because it's sort of made permanent, or it can be made permanent through the Internet, but there's also a fear of making a mistake today and then not only, you know, being judged based on that in the moment in a way that's very intense because of the sort of permanence of the Internet and how things spread permanently on the Internet, but there's also the fear of, like, am I damaging my future self, right? And I've actually spent the last few years absolutely tormented by this. And it's caused me to develop a toxic level of perfectionism. Like, I need to be perfect all the time in every single way. Because at all times I'm at risk of, of making a mistake that could become permanent. It could change my life forever. Because on the Internet, the past is permanent. And it's sort of caused a mental block in me. You know, I'm talking about the last few years, like maybe the last four years. I've really, really struggled with this. And it's made it really hard for me to show my personality online as much as I used to, because I was so afraid of doing, saying the wrong thing. I was constantly psyching myself out. I had a mental block. I had a mental block. And there's other reasons why maybe my personality was less present on the Internet. I was less present on the Internet. You know, this, this sort of mental block is not the only reason, but it's definitely a significant reason. Sort of the, the realization of the permanence of the Internet Combined with the rise of cancel culture. I mean, I'm not playing victim here, okay, at all. This is not me like whining, being like I'm a victim of, of this. And it's so sad for me and scary. I'm not saying that. I'm literally just saying the truth of, of how it impacted me psychologically. I became so afraid that I started overthinking everything, you know, and like in obsessing over every single little thing I said and censoring myself beyond belief because mistakes are received more harshly than ever now because of cancel culture. But again, they're also like, they're never forgotten now. So I don't know. I understandably became obsessive about every single thing that I put on the Internet of myself. And it became boring and bland and sort of vanilla even for a period of time because I was too scared to almost like fully just be myself and be normal. Because I, I, I, I couldn't stomach the fact that if I show myself and it's maybe not received well in one way or another, it's now permanent. It just, I couldn't handle it. I've also spent an equal amount of time fearing rumors, fearing people telling stories that are false for the sake of who knows, you know, like going viral or like who or just to like character assassinate me because you know, for whatever reason someone doesn't like me. This is something that in the age of the Internet, because of the permanence of the Internet can truly ruin your life. Like, I genuinely live in fear of a well crafted rumor because there, I remember there was like a story made by someone who actually did go to school with me. That was true. This girl who went to school with me basically posted a TikTok telling a completely fabricated story about me and my interactions with her. Completely fabricated, okay? In fact, me and this girl were always cool. And I'm not just saying that like if I fucked up and I like was a complete bitch to this girl, I would fully, fully sit here right now and say, you know, that was a dark moment in my, in my life. I was, you know, 14, 15 years old, probably 15 at that time. I, you know, was going through this, I was going through that. I was an asshole and I treated this girl like shit. And now I have to live with that memory for like, I would just say that and that would be the story that but, and trust me, there are definitely some things I did in high school that I'm not proud of. I don't necessarily remember all of them, but I bet, you know, people could remind me of those things and I would regret them and be apologetic of them. I'm all about, you know, taking responsibility and shit. Don't get me wrong, however, if I didn't do something, I'm not going to take responsibility for it because I didn't fucking do it. This is a great example of that. This girl came up with this whole story about basically me being a total bitch to her and fabricated this entire story that I know for a fact was not true. And anybody who knew me in high school would be like, emma didn't do that. Emma probably made some other mistakes, but Emma definitely didn't do that. Like, it was just completely out of character and, like, evil in a way that I've never been in my life, even at my darkest moments. And that was really, really upsetting to me because I was reading the comments of people being like, oh, my God, I can't believe she would do that. Like, I always knew she was a mean girl. All this shit. And it's like my entire character is being. Is being judged right now based on a complete lie that is now going to be permanently on the Internet. Like, I can sit here and deny. I didn't even address it or deny it or do anything because I was like, that will only bring more attention to this. And this is not true. This is not true. So I don't want to talk about it and bring more attention to it, because it's not real. You know? Like, I don't even know how to. How to handle. I'm just gonna ignore it, I guess. But it was really upsetting to me because I was like, this is now something that when people Google me, it might come up, this story that is completely false. And now this is something that I am going to be tied to for the rest of my life instead of the actual memories of me in high school that are true, who I really was, which I was definitely not a perfect person in high school, but I was not mean like that. I'm sorry. I just wasn't. Okay. Like, I wasn't like, no, that is ridiculous. And I. And it's completely just a fabricated story for character assassination. That is the truth. But again, like, there are people who saw that video back then, and that story became permanent in their mind. You know, in that way, the Internet is permanent. But then also, it's permanent because that video is probably still up, and if somebody wanted to go find it, you know, they could. And in that way, it's permanent. And that has also really bothered me. You know, a lot of the controversies that I've been in in my career were actually based on false narratives, a decent portion of them. You know, there have been things that I've said that I've gotten called out for that. Like, I have genuinely said, fair enough. But there's also been, you know, so many false narratives as well that people now forever will remember. Like, people fully think that I did things that I did not do because these narratives become permanent through the Internet. And it fucks with me. It really fucks with me. And another thing that fucks with me is sort of, you know, how my past phases in life, though harmless, right, are permanent. Yeah, they're harmless, right? Like when I was a cringe sort of 16 year old or when I had really bad acne when I was like 18 or 19. Every little phase in my life has been documented. Now, I must also add voluntarily, okay, I posted all of this of myself. I'm not sitting here saying, like, oh my God, it's all permanent. And like, I didn't even want that. No, I posted it. You know what I'm saying? So it is absolutely, you know, this is something I did to myself and I am fully aware of that. But at the same time, even though I, I have no regrets and I think it's absolutely worth it, I definitely struggle with constantly being reminded of past phases of my life. I mean, in theory, could I delete my past? I could, but like, that's sort of the dilemma. I'm also like, I don't want to delete my past. Like it was my past. And also, you know, there are people who still find entertainment or value in these, these past moments of my life. Right? So like, I don't want to delete it also. Even if I did, there's everything I've ever done is reposted somewhere. There's documentation of it beyond my own. So like, it's. I'm in a unique situation there where like, you know, some people could like delete all their social media, start fresh, whatever, and you know, there's no sort of documentation of their, of their past. Like once they delete it, it's gone. So there is sort of a feeling of control there. Is everything ever truly gone? No. You know, and some things are posted by other people and those things are permanently posted and like, you can't hack into their account and delete the stuff. Like. But I will say I'm experiencing an extreme level of permanence on the Internet, you know, it's exhausting. In a way, because it's like, again, like, I've worked so hard to build the person that I am today, and I don't necessarily want to be judged by who I was a year ago, three years ago, five years ago. Like, that's something I really struggle with because there are moments when I was really annoying. There are moments when I did something embarrassing. A great example would be my fucking Streamys award speech acceptance speech when I won a Streamy award in, like, 2019 or something. And the speech went viral because it was so cringe. That was absolutely fucking horrible for me. And it still gets brought up and people still show me the video, and I still have to see it, and it's absolutely horrible. And I'm wearing a hideous outfit and I look hideous, and the speech is fucking cringe. The whole thing is a mess. And I see that video, like, once a month, probably. It comes up somewhere. I see it somewhere and, like, how beautiful it would be if that was just a memory that we all had. You know what I mean? A memory that we all had. It wouldn't be nearly as cringe if it was just a memory. You know what I'm saying? But it's cringe because it's this video and it's permanent, and that is really challenging. But also, like, periods when I've looked bad, you know? And I know that this is, like, vain. And I am probably more vain than I think people would think I was, which is perhaps a whole episode of its own. I seem like I don't care. And many people are like, emma just doesn't care. She posts and she looks ugly and she doesn't care. That's true. Listen, at any given moment, I look the way I'm gonna look. And, like, I'm never gonna necessarily hide it. I'm never gonna hide. Right. Cause it's the reality. But that doesn't mean I'm not unhappy with the way that I look or something. You know what I'm saying? So, like, now phases when I. I feel like I didn't look good, like, those are permanent as well. Phases when I've had really, really severe acne or, you know, I've been unhealthy in one way or another, and I look like shit as a result, you know, like, these are moments of my life that are permanent. I am reminded of those phases constantly because they're documented and seemingly sort of permanent. I briefly paused this episode to let you know that. This episode is brought to you by Squarespace. I love the art of a beautifully Designed website Checking out a business's website for the first time and feeling like I'm being welcomed into their home. Expressing the brand's identity while simultaneously being super, super user friendly. And on Squarespace, that's easy. Not only can you build beautiful websites with Squarespace, but you can even create and sell your own courses too. And Squarespace Payments makes it easy to take all kinds of payments, including Apple Pay, Klarna and more. Get started with a free trial@squarespace.com and use squarespace.com emma for 10% off your first website or domain. Now let's get back to the episode. The phase that I'm struggling with the most right now is my most recent sort of phase that took place over the last few years where I kind of had this like, serious sort of artsy to some, maybe even pretentious sort of philosophical. Although some people would say that that is just. I can't even call myself philosophical, even though technically anyone can be philosophical. So that's rude. But, you know, now I had this phase, I think for a number of reasons. I actually, I. I really want to dig into this phase, honestly. Like, I feel like I need to discuss it. I feel like it'll be sort of cathartic for me because it directly relates to the topic of this episode, the permanence of the Internet. This phase of my life is permanent and right now it's really, really bothering me. So let's just discuss it. Okay? It was sort of this, this artsy, sort of pretentious sort of philosophical sort of phase. Now it was not. I didn't mean for it to be cringe or, or pretentious. Like, my intention was never bad. I also wasn't necessarily like trying to, to be cool or something, necessarily. It wasn't even that. I think it was a combination of a few things. Number one, what I mentioned earlier, me being so afraid of showing my personality that I completely had a mental block when it came to like showing myself or, you know, I've always been a bit edgy with the shit that I talk about. I've always taken risks with what I talk about and I've always received criticism for that. To a certain extent. It's not everyone's cup of tea, understandably. So all good. But when Cancel Culture sort of became more of a thing, I was. I just became more and more afraid to the point where I was like, I don't even want to make a joke. Like, I remember I used to like, I don't know, like, fucking start writing an instagram caption. And it was like, funny. And then I was like, I can't. I. I'm too scared to be funny because I'm too scared that being remotely funny will somehow get me canceled. So I would just delete the caption and post the photo with no caption. You know, that was the vibe. Or, like, I would be editing a YouTube video, and I'd say, like, one funny thing, and I'd be like, I'm. I'm too scared that. You know, because being to be funny is to be edgy a bit a lot of times, right? So I just completely couldn't show this side of myself anymore. I was way too afraid. So I was like, well, I need to show something. So I showed myself sort of depressed and sort of in the middle of this mental block, having this sort of existential crisis, rethinking everything, thinking really philosophically about everything, because that's truly what was going on in my head. So there was that. But then I also think, too, that I was experiencing a bit of a. A creative growth period, if you will, where I was trying to figure out, like, all right, what's the next step in my career, right? Like, I've been vlogging my life. I've been, you know, talking about my life very intimately and very vulnerably for a long time, and I want to maintain a decent amount of that. But I also can't really do this anymore because my career and my level of fame, in a way, even though I'm not that famous, but, like, my level of fame, even. Even to the, you know, maybe smaller level that it's at compared to, say, like, I don't know, Jennifer Aniston. Like, I don't know, but, like, I'm not a. I'm not super famous, but I'm famous enough that, like, I have to do things differently now. I was kind of in a phase where I'm like, what do I do next? And part of me was like, well, maybe I should make things feel a bit more meaningful. Maybe I need to add a bit more depth to what I'm putting out there, right? Instead of just talking about, like, mundane shit, instead of showing mundane shit, maybe I share things that are a bit more potent, a bit more deep, a bit more whatever. Like, maybe share that side of myself. And I think to an extent, that was good. Like, I actually think that there was some beauty to that, and I think I enjoyed that a lot. And I think it was exciting to show, like, a deeper side of myself. But at the same Time I think it became like all I did and then I wasn't showing any of my humor or like my light hearted personality. And that I don't think is good because I think honestly my strong suit is a balance, you know, And I think it was almost like an overcorrection. It was like I became too like deep and like, like, look at how beautiful. Like everything became too deep, too artsy. Like it, it. I was trying to infuse meaning into my Internet output and also simultaneously, you know, protect a bit more of my privacy. And in a lot of ways, again, you know, there was a lot of positive there. Like I did end up showing a different side of myself that was actually truly genuine to me. But then through doing that I like lost touch with my sense of humor and like my edginess. I don't know, like I lost my edge a bit. I mean, listen, I can't, like, I don't know, everybody had a different opinion and everyone does have a different opinion. So I can't speak for everybody. And I also try not to read too much or see too much of what people think or else I have a meltdown. But I do think that, you know, there are people who were like, where did you go, Emma? Where are you? And understandably so, right? Because even though I was still there, I wasn't all there and I wasn't in the best place. Like things weren't working. They weren't working. They simply weren't working. And it came off as pretentious. It came off as like, why is Emma talking about like philosophical topics? She's, she's like an idiot podcaster. Which by the way, I think is completely an unfair criticism. Even if you thought that phase of my podcast or YouTube or whatever was, was cringe or pretentious or, or whatever, or, you know, even if you think that, you know, I'm not smart enough to be talking about, I can. Everyone has the right to give their opinion on whatever they want, you know, what, or to discuss whatever they want. I think if I did maybe go wrong, it was because I was accidentally maybe speaking from a place of like, let me teach you about this. And that's a mistake. Whenever I did that, if at any point I did that, that's a mistake. But to simply talk about things that are philosophical is to be human. I don't think we should not ever take that right away from anyone. I'm not a fucking philosophy major. I'm discovering it, having my own sort of philosophical epiphanies on my own and doing so in a way that's normal. You know what I'm saying? And I'm not claiming to be some sort of philosopher. I'm just, like, discussing what I've been thinking about on my own timeline as I'm discovering it. And if it's later than you, it's later than you, you know, whatever. But I definitely received a good amount of criticism during this sort of transitionary period of my career where, you know, I just couldn't quite get into rhythm with. With things and the audience. And you all felt that. Some of you maybe felt that, but were, like, okay with it and didn't mind it or whatever. Some of you fucking hated it and hated me and whatever. It's one of those phases that I cringe at. But also, you all cringed. A lot of you, not all of you, but a chunk of you also cringed at. And I'm not going to go back and delete it. I'm not going to go back and delete everything from that time because, again, I don't want to erase history. I. I don't want to erase history. It. I want to. I do, but I. I'm conflicted. I don't know. Like, I would love for it to disappear, right? But I'd love if it just never happened, but it did. And so because of that, I have to just own it and live with it and be like, this is permanent and this is. But it's challenging and, you know, to sort of wrap up that whole story. I recently, within the last, I don't know, year, slowly but surely realized I had it all wrong. Number one, I cannot live in fear of the permanence of the Internet. I cannot live in fear because not only does it make me completely miserable, but it also, it causes my career to suffer and my creativity to suffer. It completely gets in the way of me living a fulfilling life. It's completely detrimental for me. But also my sort of desire to instill more meaning and depth into, you know, the content I put out on the Internet, that was also sort of irrational to continue to evolve my career and, you know, take things to the next level, I don't actually need to instill more. More depth into things. That was a miscalculation. That was a hypothesis that ended up not being true. In fact, by doing that, I think I ended up removing meaning from what I was doing. But it was something I had to try, and it's something I have to accept. Like, that's a phase of my career that I have to accept and is it all bad? No. And is it even really that bad? No. No, it's not. And there were some people out there who actually enjoyed this phase that now I. I cringe at. So, okay. But now I realize through that phase that I'm cringing at now that, number one, I can't live in fear, and number two, I don't need to instill meaning in things. I just need to be entertaining, and I just need to be honest, and I just need to be myself and that. It doesn't need to be deep, it doesn't need to be artsy. It doesn't need to be. It doesn't. If. If I want it to be philosophical, because I'm having a philosophical moment in my life, sure, it can be philosophical, but, like, if I'm seeing beauty in a way and I want to share it with the world, I can share. But, like, I don't need to do that in order for what I do on the Internet to be meaningful. You know, like, things can be more mundane, they can be more surface level, they can be more funny, they can be more chill, and they can still provide value to people. Like, that was something I was having a hard time grasping. It's like, can I provide value to people if things are surface level, if things are silly, if things are mundane? Like, how do I level up if not to infuse more depth into things? Anyway, it was just a miscalculation. And now, you know, I'm in this sort of bittersweet position where on one hand, you know, I'm so grateful for this phase of experimentation and fear and difficulty, because without that, I wouldn't be where I'm at today, which is at an incredible place where I now feel more inspired than I have in a really long time. And I'm feeling more myself than I have in a really long time. And I'm feeling like, you know, I have a plan for my career and Internet output that's sustainable. That's something that I could actually continue to do for years to come where I'm not going to hit burnout. I'm not going. Gonna psych myself out or get or, you know, experience, you know, sort of a mental block again. I'm. I'm stronger than ever. I'm more inspired than ever. I'm more myself than ever. Things are great right now. Unfortunately, to get here, I had to go through that little rough patch. That was. That was a little cringe. That was a little pretentious. That was. Whatever. I'm grateful for that time. But at the same time, because it's permanent due to the Internet. I'm also sort of tortured by it, and I'm mortified by it. Like, I want to move on. I'm excited that, like, I'm in a better place now, you know? But on a daily basis, I'm reminded of that phase. And I could delete it, but I also feel like deleting it's even worse. Like, I don't want to erase my past. I don't want to erase these phases. And these phases also weren't necessarily hated by everyone. Right there. There are actually people who, who enjoyed this phase, Right? It was a smaller group of people than the group of people who have enjoyed other phases of my career and life. Right? But there was a group of people that enjoyed that phase. And it's like, do I want to take that away from those people? But, you know, I'm at a point where I'm like, all right, I, I, I'm really trying to sort of develop a healthy relationship with this reality, the reality of the permanence of the Internet. I'm really trying to, like, get to a healthy place with it where I truly just accept this as a reality. I find empowerment in the parts of it that I can control, the parts of the narrative that I can control. Trying to, you know, not live in fear of what I can't control. Like, I can't control if somebody starts a rumor. I can't control if, you know, something of me from 10 years ago comes out of, like, me being an asshole or, like, me, like, pooping on someone's front lawn. I never did that. I did pee on someone's front lawn, though, once, but I never pooped. So anyways, but like, if a video of me peeing on someone's fucking front lawn in high school after a party when I was drunk, like, if that video comes out, you know, it's like. Or worse, like, who knows? You know, it's like, I have to accept the fact that, like, that could happen, and that's just sort of the name of the game, and that's just the reality of, of today. And also, you know, use the permanence of the Internet to inspire me to only be a better person, but not to the point where I'm obsessing over it. And I'm a perfectionist, and I'm, like, completely unforgiving of myself if I make a mistake, because I'm like, emma, you have no room to make a mistake. Everything is permanent on the Internet. I'm trying to find balance and peace in it. But it's challenging. It's challenging for me and I also think it's challenging for society, even though I have my own unique sort of relationship to it that has its own sort of unique set of difficulties. I really do believe that this is something that is impacting society as a whole. Okay. Like I don't think just public figures are impacted by this. Right. I will say these are all sort of hypotheses, right? Like I don't know for sure if the permanence of the Internet has impacted society, but I mean, I'm pretty sure it has. This episode is brought to you by Billi. A hot steamy shower is actually very therapeutic. Like when you're stressing over a mistake at work or struggling to come up with a new idea, it's nice to take a moment, relax, refocus and literally let your worries wash away. That's why Billi makes products for every step of your routine. They know how important self care can be and how a good product can make or break that time for you. That's why they created their award winning razor, aluminum free deodorants and nourishing body wash and lotion which come in luscious scents like sweet vanilla, coconut. It's exactly what you need to refresh your body and mind. You've got your reasons. Billi's got your routine. Shop in store and@mybilli.com this episode is brought to you by Alfa Romeo. You know how some people follow the road and others set the pace. Well, the Alfa Romeo Tonale plug in hybrid was designed for the latter because this isn't just a vehicle. It has stylish Italian design that turns heads performance with a purpose, effortless energy that matches your own. You know exactly where you're going and the Alfa Romeo Tonale gets you there. No permission needed. Experience. Alfa Romeo Tonale Alfa Romeo is a registered trademark of FCA Group Marketing SpA used with permission. This episode is brought to you by ebay. This is what you do when you've just found that statement handbag on ebay and you want to build an entire wardrobe around it. You start selling to keep buying. Yep. On ebay. Over that all black everything phase. List it and buy. All the color feeling more vintage than ever. It's out with the new and in with the pre loved. Next thing you know you've refreshed your wardrobe basically without spending a dime. Yeah, ebay the place to buy and sell new pre loved vintage and rare fashion. I have some examples of how I Think it's impacted society, for one. I think partying and clubbing and going out and socializing has really, really deeply been impacted by the permanence of the Internet. I feel like people are really afraid of. Of not everyone. Okay. But I know of people who are really afraid of really, like, letting loose. Because nowadays there's a chance you might be filmed and you might go viral on the Internet if you let too loose. Right. And there is something sort of beautiful about being able to, like, go to a bar and like, go crazy and dance and live in the moment and. And it not be documented. Now, I'm not saying, like, partying's no fun anymore because it used to be, like, morally wrong things could happen at the party and nobody would find out. That's not what I'm saying. I'm even just saying, like, being it like going out and drinking and dancing and, and being in the moment, like that is something that is actually very vulnerable. And it's something that, like, in the moment feels so magical. But if you were to film it and take it outside of that moment, it is actually like, ooh, it's not supposed to be taken outside of the moment. But now because of the Internet, it oftentimes is. And I really do think that it's negatively impacted the club party scene. And I. I've seen quite a few articles pop up over the last few years about how, you know, Gen Z's not drinking, which I actually think is a great thing. You don't need a drink to have fun. Although it does help sometimes. But I'm sober and I've been sober since October of 2024. I haven't had one drink. Okay. So I know a thing or two about sobriety. Yeah, I mean, I'm still hitting the vape, but I. Here and there. But the alcohol, no, but anyway, Gen Z is not drinking as much. A lot of clubs are shutting down. Just my own experience in la. Like, when I first moved here, there were so many parties and there was like such a energy. But maybe it was my perception, but like, I really do feel like, I don't know, like, the, the party vibe, the club vibe, the bar vibe in LA has really, like, lost its sparkle. And I've talked to a lot of people who also live in LA and been like, has it kind of lost its sparkle? And there's a lot of people who agree with me. I don't know. I just. I think that, like, truly going out and socializing and enjoying the moment is, is a bit harder now because There is a risk that somebody could film you or that you're in the back of somebody's video or like, I don't know, it's just like, it ruins the feeling of complete freedom that I think going out used to give people. It's like at the end of the week where you know you're being watched by your boss or being watched by your teacher, or you have to turn things in on time and there's all this, you know, all these rules. There was something so beautiful about being able to go out and be social and be free. Nobody's watching, nobody's paying attention. You know, you just get to kind of let loose. And now it's like, wait, we don't get to let loose because we're constantly at risk of being filmed or being this or being that. And it's like, if you want to fucking take body shots off of somebody, you can't just do that now. It's like probably going to be filmed. You can't just like, I don't know, chain smoke 10 cigarettes outside of the bar because somebody might take photos of you and be like, look at this freak who just smoked 10 cigarettes in one sitting. And it's like posted on Tick Tock with that caption. And then it gets 30, 000 likes. And then it's like, wait, I was just chain smoking my cigarettes because it's the weekend. Why are you. You know what I'm saying? I don't know, it's just not the same. Maybe I'm just feeling that way because I'm growing up and that could be truly the case. You know, it could be just my perception, but I've seen and heard too many things that corroborate this hypothesis. So I don't know. I want a vape so bad. I'm, I'm. I'm feigning for the vape a little bit because I was doing so good. I was doing so good. And then I really just hit it a lot this weekend. I was just. Everybody around me seemed to have a vape and it was just like vape after vape after vape. It was absolutely delicious. But I am really paying the price right now because I'm really craving it and yeah, it sucks. Okay, moving on. Sorry. I also think too that the permanence of the Internet has sort of created a new societal weapon, a lethal one at that. The permanence of the Internet, really, it has become a weapon to assassinate character. You can turn the Internet against an individual in a way that is Truly like being fucking stoned in the town square. It is like being crucified. And I know that that's extreme, but it genuinely is that extreme. Like, if you're an average person and all of a sudden, you know, somebody posts something about you that's negative on the Internet and it goes viral because it's like a viral story, the feelings that that will bring up in a person. It's dangerous. It's really dangerous. It's. It's terrifying. And there are absolutely people out there who get off on just destroying people's lives through the Internet. And I think that this has ruined more people's lives than we even remember. And that is not good for society. That is not good for humanity. I don't think the fact that people's mistakes can be used against them as on the Internet, I don't know, it just. It's like, it's to me, dangerous. Which leads me to, like, my next sort of point. I mean, I think young people are afraid these days of truly experimenting and making mistakes in life, which is crucial for growth. The repercussions of experimenting in life are now unproportionately severe because of the Internet. Like, if these things make it onto the Internet, the repercussions can now be worldly. Are they always? No, but there's a chance. And the mere chance of it, I think, really, I'm hypothesizing, really severely psychologically impacts young people especially, which I think, you know, is creating an anxious, isolated, depressed generation of young people, which is another thing that I've been seeing articles about for years now. How Gen Z is the most anxious, how Gen Z is the most isolated, how there's a friendship epidemic, like, no one has friends. You know, Gen Z is depressed. Gen Z is like, we've all seen these articles and I think the permanence of the Internet, weirdly is a part of that. And last but not least, I think the permanence of the Internet creates some unfavorable qualities in society as a whole. Not every single individual, but creates like, an increase in numbers of people who have certain unfavorable qualities, such as perfectionism, such as vanity, narcissism in the physical world. Your being feels much less significant. I don't know how to explain this, but like, think about yourself in the real world and then think about yourself on the Internet. If you're somebody who posts yourself on the Internet, you're being okay. You're being like. You as a human being in the real world feels much less significant because you're surrounded by other people, you're surrounded by experience. You're surrounded by so many things that are bigger than yourself. There's something about the Internet and how we perceive ourselves on the Internet where we feel like the center of the universe. It's almost like our profile is the center of the universe and everything else around it is, is just, you know, details in a way, you know, and like, it's just, it's a different way of perceiving oneself. And yet we perceive ourselves in real life and we perceive ourselves online. And I think now that our realities are so intertwined with the Internet and a decent portion of us nowadays perceive ourselves mainly through the Internet, it's leading a large portion of us to develop perfectionism, develop narcissism, to be vain. A lot of us who wouldn't normally be that way, like, we aren't that by nature. There are some who are like that by nature. But I think the Internet and specifically the permanence of the Internet brings out these characteristics. Because everybody's aware of how once something's on the Internet, in some ways it's sort of permanent. But also when people look at things on the Internet, whether it's the past or the present, everything when being perceived on the Internet sort of feels like the present in that moment, you know what I mean? When you're looking at it, I think it explains why people are so obsessed with looking perfect, right face tuning things, sometimes facetiming to oblivion to the point where, you know, it's like, where did their nose go? They smoothed their face so much the nose disappeared. This is kind of like ridiculous, you know, getting arguably unnecessary procedures done to have sort of unnatural features almost that, you know, look good on, on social media, but actually don't even look good in real life, but look good on social media, but it's like in, like, real life almost matters less because the Internet's more permanent. So as long as it looks good on the Internet, which is permanent, then who really cares what, what's happening in real life? If your lips are so big you like can't talk properly, it's like it doesn't really matter because it looks really good on Instagram and Instagram is permanent. And so it's all about like looking perfect because that is what is permanent because of the Internet. I think people are also obsessed with sort of curating a perfect looking life on the Internet because again, having an actual perfect life, who cares? Number one, it doesn't exist, but number two, it's like, who cares? Because that's not as permanent. The Internet is permanent. So there's this like pressure to sort of show everyone, you know, this perfect life. And a lot of times that actually ends up just kind of actually destroying quality of life. I don't think that that adds to quality of life at all. I think it's a lot of times is actually quite a negative thing. And I really think this just leads to narcissism. I'm not saying that the Internet turns people into narcissists, but I'm saying it causes people to develop narcissistic traits. I think the permanence of the Internet feels so severe that I think it tricks people into thinking that their more important than they are, they're the center of the universe, because this. Does that make sense? I don't even know what I'm fucking saying anymore. Okay, like, what did I even just talk about? For the last however long I've been talking? I don't even know what the fuck I just talked about. I'm gonna wrap it up. Okay, I'm gonna wrap it up. I'm going to give a positive conclusion because I think otherwise this is a little bit too depressing. Here's the deal. In conclusion, I think the Internet, though it has elements that are complex and arguably damaging to society. The Internet also is an incredible thing. And with all good there's bad and this is just part of the bad. And I really hope that over time, as a society, we're going to get better at managing this sort of challenging element of the Internet. Because I think we all know that the Internet's not going anywhere. And also we don't want it to go anywhere. Like, there's a lot about the Internet that is incredible. So I really do believe that over time were going to get better at managing the negative elements of the Internet. And you know, I even feel like I'm getting better at it. You know, as I mentioned earlier, I spent many years struggling with the permanence of the Internet. It really, really bothered me and it led me to sort of a cringe phase that ironically became permanent, that I ironically ended up cringing more at later. But living in fear and letting it get in my way negatively impacted me to the point that I ended up coming out the other end fearless again. And I think, and I hope that other people will experience this as well. And hopefully in an ideal world, the permanence of the Internet will actually force us to accept ourselves for our mistakes, for our shortcomings and well, hopefully one day instead of just canceling each other immediately. Unless, listen, if you do something bad enough, okay, I'm always like, I get it. Okay? Sometimes we have to cancel. I kind of get it. But it's also like, a lot of times we're canceling and we shouldn't be. I really do hope that one day it will hold us accountable in a way that's like, genuinely beneficial to the person and to the world. Right? And I see a future where that happens. I really do think that this could turn around and be a positive thing. Anyway, that's all I have for today. Thank you all for listening to this episode. If you enjoyed it. New episodes of Anything Goes every Thursday and Sunday. You can watch video on Spotify and YouTube and you can listen anywhere you stream podcasts. Find Anything Goes on social media at Anything Goes. Find me on social media machamberlain and find my wonderful coffee company, Chamberlain Coffee@chamberlaincoffee.com or perhaps in a store New Year or perhaps at our cafe in Los Angeles. That's all I have for today. I'm really just feening for a vape. I just am absolutely having nicotine withdrawals right now and. And I'm completely spaced out and I feel weird. But actually talking to you all today really brought me back to earth and made me forget. Actually, I didn't forget. I did not forget about my nicotine withdrawals at all. I brought them up multiple times. Anyway, that's it. That's it. That's all I have to talk about. I love you all. I appreciate you all. I enjoy the time that we spend together. It is always, always, always a treat. And enjoy. And I'll talk to you in a few days. Okay, Bye. Bye. Love you. Bye.
Episode Summary: "The Terrifying Permanence of the Internet"
Podcast Information:
Introduction:
In the latest episode of Anything Goes with Emma Chamberlain, Emma delves deep into a topic that has been a source of immense anxiety for her: the permanence of the Internet. Recording from various cozy and unconventional places, Emma offers a candid and introspective look into how the unerasable nature of online content impacts her personal life, career, and society at large.
Emma’s Personal Struggles with Internet Permanence:
Emma begins by expressing the anxiety and fear she experiences due to the Internet's permanence. She candidly shares how her decision to chronicle her life online over the past seven years has become a double-edged sword.
"I made the decision to post the last seven years of my life on the Internet. I did that. I made that choice. Now I'm sort of tortured by it."
— Emma Chamberlain [00:00]
She acknowledges that while the Internet has allowed her to build a significant online presence, it also traps her past actions and moments in a permanent digital footprint. This duality leads to constant self-scrutiny and regret over past posts and actions that are now immortalized online.
Impact on Career and Personal Life:
Emma discusses how the everlasting nature of online content has hindered her ability to evolve and show different facets of her personality without fear of backlash. She recounts specific instances where past behavior, now permanently accessible, has led to unwarranted criticism and misunderstandings.
"One Google search away, they can find your mistake for the rest of your life. You never get to move on from that."
— Emma Chamberlain [08:30]
She highlights the constant pressure to maintain a flawless online image, which has led her to develop a toxic level of perfectionism. This perfectionism not only affects her mental health but also stifles her creativity and authenticity online.
"I've become obsessed about every single thing that I put on the Internet of myself. And it became boring and bland and sort of vanilla even for a period of time because I was too scared to almost like fully just be myself."
— Emma Chamberlain [15:45]
Broader Societal Impacts:
Beyond her personal experiences, Emma extrapolates the wider implications of internet permanence on society. She argues that the ability to document and access past actions at any moment has fundamentally changed how individuals interact, learn, and grow.
"Prior to the Internet, there was no fear of your mistakes being broadcasted to the world stage. Worst case scenario, you know, your family and friends in, in community find out about a mistake you made."
— Emma Chamberlain [04:50]
Emma contends that this environment has fostered a generation of individuals who are afraid to experiment and make mistakes, which are crucial for personal growth. The ** omnipresent fear** of being "canceled" or having one's past scrutinized has contributed to increased anxiety, isolation, and depression, particularly among young people.
"I think young people are afraid these days of truly experimenting and making mistakes in life, which is crucial for growth."
— Emma Chamberlain [35:20]
Personal Anecdotes Illustrating the Issues:
Emma recounts a particularly painful instance where false narratives about her past surfaced online. A fabricated story posted by a former classmate led to widespread misjudgment and character assassination, emphasizing how easily one's reputation can be tarnished by unverified information.
"This girl came up with this whole story about basically me being a total bitch to her and fabricated this entire story that I know for a fact was not true."
— Emma Chamberlain [22:10]
She also reflects on her Streamys award acceptance speech, which went viral for being "cringe." The ongoing resurgence of this video exemplifies how past moments can haunt present perceptions.
"That speech went viral because it was so cringe. That was absolutely fucking horrible for me."
— Emma Chamberlain [27:35]
Conclusion and Hopeful Outlook:
Despite the challenges, Emma offers a hopeful perspective on managing the permanence of the Internet. She believes that with time, society will develop better mechanisms to handle online permanence, fostering an environment where individuals can learn from their mistakes without perpetual judgment.
"I really do believe that over time we're going to get better at managing this sort of challenging element of the Internet."
— Emma Chamberlain [51:50]
Emma shares her personal journey of overcoming fear and perfectionism, highlighting her newfound sense of empowerment and balance. She emphasizes the importance of accepting mistakes as part of growth and using the permanence of the Internet as a motivator to be a better person without succumbing to obsessive behaviors.
"I'm trying to find balance and peace in it. But it's challenging."
— Emma Chamberlain [46:25]
In her final remarks, Emma encourages listeners to embrace their authentic selves and strive for a healthier relationship with their online presence. She envisions a future where the Internet's permanence serves as a tool for accountability and growth rather than a weapon for perpetual criticism.
"Hopefully, one day it will hold us accountable in a way that's genuinely beneficial to the person and to the world."
— Emma Chamberlain [56:40]
Key Takeaways:
Notable Quotes:
"I made the decision to post the last seven years of my life on the Internet. I did that. I made that choice. Now I'm sort of tortured by it."
— Emma Chamberlain [00:00]
"One Google search away, they can find your mistake for the rest of your life. You never get to move on from that."
— Emma Chamberlain [08:30]
"I've become obsessed about every single thing that I put on the Internet of myself. And it became boring and bland and sort of vanilla even for a period of time because I was too scared to almost like fully just be myself."
— Emma Chamberlain [15:45]
"Prior to the Internet, there was no fear of your mistakes being broadcasted to the world stage. Worst case scenario, you know, your family and friends in, in community find out about a mistake you made."
— Emma Chamberlain [04:50]
"I think young people are afraid these days of truly experimenting and making mistakes in life, which is crucial for growth."
— Emma Chamberlain [35:20]
"This girl came up with this whole story about basically me being a total bitch to her and fabricated this entire story that I know for a fact was not true."
— Emma Chamberlain [22:10]
"That speech went viral because it was so cringe. That was absolutely fucking horrible for me."
— Emma Chamberlain [27:35]
"I really do believe that over time we're going to get better at managing this sort of challenging element of the Internet."
— Emma Chamberlain [51:50]
"I'm trying to find balance and peace in it. But it's challenging."
— Emma Chamberlain [46:25]
"Hopefully, one day it will hold us accountable in a way that's genuinely beneficial to the person and to the world."
— Emma Chamberlain [56:40]
Final Thoughts:
Emma Chamberlain's exploration of the permanent nature of the Internet serves as a profound commentary on contemporary digital life. Her honest reflections provide valuable insights into the psychological burdens faced by online personalities and the broader societal implications. This episode is a must-listen for anyone grappling with their online presence or interested in understanding the profound effects of digital permanence on modern life.