Archispeak Episode #377: The Disconnect Between Academia and Practice

Date: September 8, 2025
Hosts: Evan Troxel & Cormac Phalen

Episode Overview

In this candid, introspective episode, Evan Troxel and Cormac Phalen grapple with the persistent disconnect between architectural education and architectural practice. Woven through with personal anecdotes, hard-earned wisdom, and plenty of self-deprecating humor, the hosts debate what it truly means to prepare for a career in architecture—and how that preparation often falls short. Their conversation traverses topics including work-life exhaustion, the shift from deep learning to surface-level research, generational gaps in training, industry inefficiencies, and the existential crisis facing the profession.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Work-Life Exhaustion and “Active Resting”

[00:11–06:29]

• The episode opens with both hosts discussing chronic exhaustion and the “24/7 on” culture that pervades architectural practice today.
• Active Resting: Both admit that even when trying to rest, they’re usually consuming content or learning, never truly unplugging.
  • "Just because you're like laying flat doesn't necessarily mean you're resting." — Cormac [06:29]
  • They recall pre-internet days, contrasting then with the constant stimulus now required to feel “productive,” even while resting.
• Reflection on addiction to constant input and its adverse effects on actual recuperation, referencing Jony Ive’s reported regrets (creator of the iPhone) about proliferating screen-based devices.

2. Loss of Deep Learning and the Rise of Surface-Level Knowledge

[09:09–13:35]

• Cormac laments the shift from deep, committed learning to “30-second soundbites of knowledge.”
  • "I don't know if we dive deep enough anymore because we're just 30 seconds sound biting our knowledge." — Cormac [10:25]
• Evan points out the tension between having instant access to vast information and lacking the discipline or context to filter and internalize it meaningfully.
  • “People say they're researching things, but what they're actually doing is just searching for things.” — Evan [11:40]
• Reflection on how true research involves steps, cross-referencing, synthesis, and how contemporary practice often reduces research to rapid skimming and “good enough” conclusions.

3. From Experience to Expediency: Training Architects in Practice

[13:35–20:11]

• The hosts reflect on site visits, tactile learning, and unhurried exploration—the kinds of experiences once core to architectural training.
• Cormac recounts current frustrations with training young colleagues who lack practical exposure.
  • "Most of the team is very young and haven't had the experiences of being out on site or being exposed to certain things. And so they just don't know what the importance is." — Cormac [15:00]
• The relentless pressure for efficiency leads to knowledge gaps: less time for mentoring, fewer meaningful learning moments at the office or on-site.

4. Challenges of Modern Digital Practice and Technical Debt

[20:12–31:37]

• Deeper dive into the pitfalls of the digital age, from working in isolation on screens to the technical debt accumulated in large BIM models.
  • "I saw some report recently that decent sized firms... takes 9,000 hours a year just opening, syncing and saving. That's how much time is being spent on that." — Evan [24:36]
• Cormac relates the painful story of a massive project Revit model that takes nearly an hour to open—a direct result of choices made without sufficient foresight.
  • "Hindsight, I'm gonna tell everybody right now, hindsight would do it differently. We would do it completely differently." — Cormac [25:14]
• This technical debt is used as a metaphor for short-term thinking and the lack of proactive planning at both project and career development levels.

5. The Disconnect Between Academia and Practice: What Should Schools Teach?

[31:45–39:19]

• Evan references an AIA report questioning whether schools are preparing students to enter the workforce.
• The hosts address the perennial schism: schools focus on design theory and creative exploration rather than the realities and responsibilities of practice.
  • "When upon graduation, an architect is not an architect, it is an explorer, an adventurer, somebody who's creatively curious but can't really practice architecture in the way that our license depends on." — Cormac [33:35]
• Both agree architecture’s problems are “wicked,” not easily solved by rote instruction.

6. The Systemic Problem: Lack of Opportunity, Fulfillment, and Guidance

[39:20–43:23]

• Many junior architects feel betrayed by the profession—they’re sold an inspiring vision, only to encounter burnout and bureaucracy.
  • "The profession has failed them. They haven't failed the profession. They were sold something that the profession was unable to live up to." — Cormac [38:44]
• Discussion of administrative burdens, difficult permitting processes, and the “layers of crap” encasing architectural creativity.

7. The Value (and Cost) of Experience

[43:24–52:24]

• True professional confidence comes only after years (often decades) of repetitive, reflective practice.
  • Reference to Peter Eisenman and I.M. Pei’s statement that “it takes to the age of 40 to become an architect,” which the hosts argue feels out of sync with younger generations—but remains true in many respects.
  • “It’s the time that it takes to gain the experience of repetition, of experiencing things over and over again, of doing things over and over again that starts to give you the confidence of being able to do it again and again and again, but doing it at an elevated level.” — Cormac [48:29]
• There's no shortcut to “devouring” the craft and making the mistakes necessary to truly learn.

8. Ending on Uncertainties: More Questions Than Answers

[52:24–end]

• The episode closes with the acknowledgment that none of these dilemmas have easy solutions, and that the profession’s sustainability is an open question.
  • "Will the profession be around?" — Evan [52:57]
  • "Leave you with a final question, something to ponder as you're trying to fall asleep tonight, basically. Oh, more questions than answers." — Evan [53:00]

Notable Quotes & Moments

• "Just because you're like laying flat doesn't necessarily mean you're resting." — Cormac [06:29]
• "People say they're researching things, but what they're actually doing is just searching for things." — Evan [11:40]
• "We’ve evolved into needing this constant stimuli. Devolved." — Cormac [07:38]
• "Most of the team is very young and haven't had the experiences of being out on site or being exposed to certain things. And so they just don't know what the importance is." — Cormac [15:00]
• "I saw some report recently that decent sized firms... takes 9,000 hours a year just opening, syncing and saving. That's how much time is being spent on that." — Evan [24:36]
• "The profession has failed them. They haven't failed the profession. They were sold something that the profession was unable to live up to." — Cormac [38:44]
• "It’s the time that it takes to gain the experience of repetition... that starts to give you the confidence of being able to do it again and again and again, but doing it at an elevated level." — Cormac [48:29]
• "Leave you with a final question, something to ponder as you're trying to fall asleep tonight, basically. Oh, more questions than answers." — Evan [53:00]

Key Timestamps

• 00:11 – Exhaustion and work-life imbalance
• 04:59 – Modern "active resting" and tech addiction
• 09:09 – Decline of deep learning in architecture
• 13:35 – Loss of experiential learning in training
• 20:04 – The impact of digital practice on collaboration
• 24:36 – Technical debt: Revit woes and inefficiencies
• 31:45 – Are schools preparing architects for practice?
• 38:44 – The profession “betraying” new architects
• 48:29 – On experience and the 40-year architect
• 52:57 – Will the profession survive? Episode close

Episode Tone

Reflective, honest, and at times existential, the episode is delivered in the hosts’ trademark conversational style, blending humor, nostalgia, frustration, and hope. Both Evan and Cormac share openly about their own missteps and doubts, inviting listeners—especially students and early-career architects—to critically examine both the ideals and realities of architectural work.

For more Archispeak content and community: archispeakpodcast.com