Loading summary
Paris Hilton
You wake up, put on your Ray Ban Meta glasses. You're living all in. You realize you need coffee so you say hey Meta.
Meta Assistant
How do I make a latte brew.
Joe Getty
Two shots of espresso.
Paris Hilton
After Meta AI gets you caffeinated, you're ready for some beats.
Meta Assistant
Hey Meta. Play hip hop music.
Paris Hilton
You head to meet some friends but can't remember the place.
Meta Assistant
Hey Meta.
Paris Hilton
Call Eva Ray Ban Meta glasses the next generation of AI glasses. Just say hey Meta to harness the power of Meta AI shop now at meta.com smartglasses hey loves it's Paris Hilton.
Meta Assistant
Are you ready to sliv your best life this holiday season? Well, I've got the ultimate holiday giveaway just for you. Go to parishilton.comgiveaway to win a fabulous gift basket filled with handpicked faves. From my gift guide, from my iconic cookware and chic apparel to glam goodies from my go to brands, this bundle has it all. Don't wait. Enter now@parishilton.com giveaway good luck and happy holidays. Keep sliving. That's hot.
Jack Armstrong
Every day our world gets a little.
Joe Getty
More connected, but a little further apart. But then there are moments that remind us to be more human.
Meta Assistant
Thank you for calling Amica Insurance.
Jack Armstrong
Hey, I was just in an accident.
Meta Assistant
Don't worry, we'll get you taken care of.
Joe Getty
At Ameca, we understand that looking out for each other isn't new or groundbreaking. It's human. Ameca empathy is our best policy.
Steve Post
Ready to unleash the power of 4K? Vizio's 4K TV collection has you covered with sizes ranging from 43 inches all the way up to a jaw dropping 86 inch screen. Experience stunning clarity like never before. Bringing your favorite shows and movies to life. And with Watch Free plus built in, you'll enjoy free live and on demand TV right out of the box. You can even stream your favorite songs with the iHeartRadio app ready to go on every Vizio 4K TV. Upgrade your entertainment to Walmart to find your Vizio 4K TV today.
Jack Armstrong
Want to know the latest in short track racing around the country? There's one show that has you covered NASCAR coast to coast. Hi, I'm Kyle Rickey. Join Chris Wilner and I each week as we break down the biggest headlines in NASCAR's regional and touring series.
Joe Getty
What has been told from NASCAR to.
Jack Armstrong
Bowman Gray Management is that it's not broke. Don't fix it. That's NASCAR coast to coast. You can listen today in the Iheart Apple or on your favorite podcasting Platform.
Meta Assistant
Broadcasting live from the Abraham Lincoln Radio studio at the George Washington Broadcast Center, Jack Armstrong and Joe Getty.
Joe Getty
Armstrong and Getty. And now here's Armstrong and Getty.
Jack Armstrong
Wow. You should not have to pay for today's episode. I mean, barely going through the motions. Barely. Barely going through the motions of fulfilling the least conratch contractual requirement to be considered working today. That's what I'm going for. Wow.
Joe Getty
I, I, on the other hand, am loaded for bear.
Jack Armstrong
Barely. Barely doing it at all. Live from Studio C, See Senior Something or other. Something or other. And today we're under the tutelage of our general manager, Donald J. Trump. Oh, my God.
Joe Getty
President of the United States right now.
Jack Armstrong
Clearly.
Joe Getty
Everything but to the keys to the Oval Office. And then soon Biden may wander off anyway, so Trump might as well actually sit behind the desk.
Jack Armstrong
I promised yesterday we would not talk about the government shutdown and all that sort of stuff, but. So they had that bill that was gonna try to take care of all that. And Speaker Johnson, Holy as always. Yeah, Speaker Johnson was pushing hard to get. Let's get this signed and go off for Christmas and all that sort of stuff and look good. And elon had over 100. Don't sign this bill. Don't vote for this bill. Tweets yesterday from him explaining all the different parts of it that he hated. And that stirred up enough stuff and Trump got on board. And so now the bill has been pulled and might be a government shutdown and I don't care. I just don't care at all. Maybe that makes me a child, I don't know. But this is all. This is all such a D.C. thing.
Joe Getty
Oh, no, no. I must step in there. This is wildly different than anything that has ever happened in the history of the United States government.
Jack Armstrong
No, that part.
Joe Getty
This is insane.
Jack Armstrong
That part I agree with the crisis of the government shutting down. How many times have I lived through this? And it's just no memory of it whatsoever. It's just. It comes and goes and whatever.
Joe Getty
No, the other worst threat in the history of threats.
Jack Armstrong
Yeah, I know, I know. Whatever. But the other part, yeah. Is for better or worse, and there's a lot of hair on fire. This is. We have a co president, an unelected co president who is an oligarch. The richest man on earth is our co president, blah, blah, blah, Elon Musk with so much power.
Joe Getty
On the other hand, nobody listens to you people anymore. You lost badly. Remember, it was just last month.
Jack Armstrong
On the other hand, you got the world's Richest man who knows something about business, weighing in on stories and, and, and having some, getting some attention about it.
Joe Getty
And the aspect of it that I really enjoying and I'm so curious to see where it goes going forward obviously into Trump's actually actual term is that the Republican Party had through. And I'm gonna be a little sympathetic here through just fatigue cuz there's almost no constituency for it. Abandoned the idea of constantly calling for fiscal restraint and calling out the excessive spending and just they were going along to get along these days, let's face it. And Elon's like, I don't need to get elected in two years. I don't care what anybody thinks of me. Here's the truth. And he's hurling truth bombs around like.
Jack Armstrong
He'S the Israeli military on this stuff. This is where I'm the most maga. If, if MAGA could be defined as let's just tear it down. Because that's. I was kind of there in 2016 and I now look back on it and think that's ridiculous. You can't, you can't just be breaking every norm and tearing everything down. It's not good. It's the opposite of conservative. And there's. And you just, you don't know what's going to come out of it. But when it comes to the way we spend, I'm full maga. Freaking tear it down. Do it a different way. How could it possibly be worse? And, and every single time there's some reason that the Republican Party or the Democratic Party explains. No, just this one. We need to get this one passed. I know it's full of a lot of things spending that people don' like. But this one we have to get.
Joe Getty
Past and then shut down. We'll be blamed for the shutdown, right?
Jack Armstrong
And then we'll come back after Christmas and then we'll, we'll blah, blah, blah. And the blah blah, blah never ever happens every single time, every twice a year or every two years or whenever you have one of these giant gargantuan bills, all this crap gets thrown in there. They all vote for it. Spending money on everything in the world that we don't have. So this is where I'm the most maggot. Just freaking burn it down. Let Washington D.C. be shut down for a month to where people are crying in the streets to get enough attention that something has to change.
Joe Getty
Weeping yes, yes. Hey, Michael, I hate to chew you out this close to Christmas. Can we get an explosion sound or something? Every time Mr. Armstrong screams blow it up.
Jack Armstrong
Blow it up.
Joe Getty
I want to hear Kurt Bluey.
Jack Armstrong
More public crying.
Joe Getty
Yes, that's what we need, public weeping. Yes. Have gone far enough until you see people weeping in the streets of the country.
Jack Armstrong
Well, but, but it's just so annoying. I listened to Speaker Johnson, who I'm sure is a good guy and everything like that. I listened to him yesterday. Well, it's very important we get this passed. And we only have one half of one branch, but coming back after the year and after the inauguration and. Yeah, that's what everybody says every single time on why you gotta pass this unholy bill. I've heard this, I don't know, 60 times since we've been doing talk radio. Just, we gotta pass this one. There's reasons for this one. Because of the war, the pandemic, the oil crisis, the, the dot com meltdown, whatever. This one we have to pass. But then we're. No, you're never, ever going to stop spending wildly. You're just never gonna stop.
Joe Getty
Well, he says, knowing full well he's about to get yelled at, he could make the argument, hey, we've got the Senate in January after Trump gets elected. We've got all three branches. So this just funds it through March. March will come and go before you know it. Like, like pages of a book, like leaves in the wind. And then we'll get down to brass tacks. Right, with help of the Doge brothers.
Jack Armstrong
Sure they will. It's never this one. It's never this gargantuan bill full of crap.
Joe Getty
Yeah.
Jack Armstrong
And it's always the next one.
Joe Getty
All of the above.
Jack Armstrong
So frustrating.
Joe Getty
So just blow it up.
Jack Armstrong
Blow it up.
Joe Getty
Yes.
Jack Armstrong
Until there is PW public weeping and, oh, my God, the, the endless. The government shutdown. Well, whatever.
Joe Getty
I tell you what. Yeah, shut it down for six months. Let's see how we do out here in the private sector. And if you close the national parks, we will fight our way in. And I. Okay.
Jack Armstrong
And I fully get the grownups when they push back. Here's why you can't shut down the government and the things that happen. The problem is this. You never, ever stop spending wildly. It never happens.
Joe Getty
Yeah. And it is utterly, you know, at the risk of repeating ourselves for the millionth time, but it is no less true. It is utterly immoral. What we are doing, we the people, what we are doing right now is indefensible. Fiscally, morally, patriotically. It's, it's, it's treasonous. I am not exaggerating. I'm not kidding. We are Spending future generations into oblivion. It's incredibly selfish and evil.
Jack Armstrong
Yeah. We'll be a much weaker country and our children will have much higher taxes and less services.
Joe Getty
Hey, seriously, if I were a congressman and I like, was a mole for the Chinese for a decade, you know, unless I was on an extra, had an extremely high security clearance on an extremely important committee, for instance, I could not possibly do more damage to the country 20 years from now than I would do by simply continuing to vote for wildly irresponsible spending and deficit spending. That is treasonous.
Jack Armstrong
I don't know how you pull out of it with the. Each party can claim the other parties to blame. I don't know how you end the spiral, the downward spiral, because there's always a. Well, you started it with this. Well, you started it with that. On everything. On absolutely everything.
Joe Getty
And I'm sorry, I, I hate to do this during the show. I've got to take a call. Hello, Joe Getty here. Yes, History. It's history calling. Oh, wow. Yes. What can we do for you? Okay, okay, okay, okay. Thank you. Thanks. Yeah, yeah. Merry Christmas. You. Yeah, History called and said the way you stop the downward spiral is your head bottom. You have a disaster. You have a cataclysm and that's the only option. Where's the eggnog?
Jack Armstrong
History kept calling me. I blocked them. They, they can no longer get through. I don't want to hear from history.
Joe Getty
Have you considered a set of history related Encycloplopedias? Encyclopedias. It's 2024.
Jack Armstrong
I'm gonna live in la la land and ignore history, which apparently we're going to do. Let's start the show officially. That'll be fun. I'm Jack, he's Joe Getty on this. It is Thursday, December 19th, the year 2024. We are Armstrong and Getty and we approve of this program.
Joe Getty
Okay, let's leap into action then. Officially, according to FCC rules and regulations, here we go at Mark.
Meta Assistant
I'm so happy to still be here and see all you wonderful people and let's have a good time. Well, how about that? You see, my family always had a lot of.
Joe Getty
We always did.
Meta Assistant
We always had a lot of fun and I never got over that.
Jack Armstrong
What was that, Michael?
Joe Getty
That's one six year old woman, Florence Hackman. And her secret is fireball whiskey.
Jack Armstrong
That's what's kept her alive. 106. Sound like you said 160, but I doubt that's the case.
Joe Getty
Yeah, 106.
Jack Armstrong
106 years old. That's, that's old. And she drinks the fireball. Good for her. Wow.
Joe Getty
Judy brought home a meme or a birthday. It might have been a birthday card actually. Happy birthday sweetheart. It's my, my darling bride's birthday today. I've certainly wished her that in person already. But she brought home a birthday card that said. Hey, they have candles. As a woman sniffing a decorative candle. Hey, they have candles that smell like fireball whiskey. And her friend replies. Or as we non alcoholic, non alcoholics call it, cinnam.
Jack Armstrong
That's pretty funny. It's amazing how many of your super ancient people, when they're asked about keys to life or what they do or ever include drinking seems to happen quite often, involved some beverage, alcoholic beverage of some sort.
Joe Getty
Well, when the world, the family, whatever is about to make you completely insane, you stop. Karen. It's probably good for you.
Jack Armstrong
I would like to know. And then we gotta take a break I guess. But I would like to know how many of the people that get to that age are people that don't pay super close attention to what's going on in the world. Because I think if you did you would go crazy.
Joe Getty
This is not good for business. I hear what you're driving at.
Jack Armstrong
Another 60 years of paying attention at this level would make me insane.
Joe Getty
All right, pass the fireball.
Jack Armstrong
How does mailbag look?
Joe Getty
Oh, it's very nice.
Jack Armstrong
Yes, that's on the way. And our text line is 415295KFTC Armstrong and Gettysburg.
Paris Hilton
You wake up, put on your Ray Ban meta glasses. Classic style, innovative tech. You're living all in. You realize you need coffee desperately.
Meta Assistant
So you say hey Meta, how do I make a latte?
Joe Getty
To make a latte, brew two shots of espresso.
Paris Hilton
After Meta AI gets you caffeinated, you start walking to work and you need a soundtrack.
Meta Assistant
Hey Meta Play hip hop music.
Paris Hilton
With the built in camera you snap a pic of a dope mural on the side of a building that you think is worth sharing.
Meta Assistant
Hey Meta Text my last photo to Eva.
Jack Armstrong
Sending message.
Paris Hilton
After work you head to meet some friends.
Joe Getty
Hey nice glasses.
Paris Hilton
Ray Ban meta glasses. The next generation of AI glasses. Just say hey Meta. To harness the power of meta AI Listen to music, make hands free calls with open air audio and built in microphones and so much more. All while staying present to the world around you. Shop Ray Ban meta glasses@meta.com smartglasses hey.
Meta Assistant
Loves, it's Paris Hilton. Are you ready? Ready to sliv your best life this holiday season? Well I've got the ultimate holiday giveaway just for you. Go to parishilton.comgiveaway to win a fabulous gift basket filled with handpicked faves from my gift guide. From my iconic cookware and chic apparel to glam goodies from my go to brands, this bundle has it all. Don't wait. Enter now@parishilton.com giveaway good luck and happy Holidays. Keep sliving. That's hot.
Jack Armstrong
If for some reason you were picturing me in my underwear, it would be Mack Weldon underwear. Oh, you weren't. Anyway, it would be Mack Weldon underwear. And also I'm wearing a Mack Weldon T shirt.
Joe Getty
Oh my gosh. The jeans, the boxer briefs in my case, the shirts, the shorts. Oh my gosh. I wear these shorts every day. Mack Weldon Great looks, great styles, great comfort, terrific value.
Jack Armstrong
The performance fabric is fantastic. Mack Weldon clothes are designed to fit your style and the demands of modern life. Looks like regular clothes but feel like the latest in modern comfort and it's.
Joe Getty
Understated good looks for understated confidence. It's not wild and flamboyant, it's good old traditional I'm a dude clothes and I love them.
Jack Armstrong
Get timeless looks with modern. Com from Mack Weldon. Just go to mack weldon.com and get 25 off your first order of $125 or more with the promo code Armstrong.
Joe Getty
That'S M A C k w e L-O-N.com Mac weldon.com use that promo code.
Steve Post
Armstrong Step into a world of unparalleled brightness and lifelike color with Vizio's Quantum Pro TV. This premium QLED TV available in 65 and 75 inch sizes is designed for those who demand the best in picture quality. Breathtaking brightness brings every scene to life while wide viewing angle delivers the perfect picture from any seat in the room. Enjoy all your favorite apps built in so you can blast your top songs through the iHeartRadio app straight out of the box. Head to Walmart to find your Vizio Quantum Pro TV today.
Todd Gordon
Hi, I'm MRN Lead Pit Reporter Steve.
Jack Armstrong
Post and I'm championship winning Crew Chief Todd Gordon.
Todd Gordon
Go behind the scenes each week with us for MRN Crew Call where we'll talk to some of the biggest names standing atop the pit box as well.
Jack Armstrong
As break down all the exciting action from the weekend in NASCAR and go into detail on the winning strategies.
Todd Gordon
Crew Call is also where you'll hear from the first time winners in the.
Jack Armstrong
Championship from the NASCAR Cup Series to the Craftsman Truck Series.
Todd Gordon
Listen today in the iHeartRadio app or on your favorite podcast platform.
Jack Armstrong
New poll just out from Marquette University. 64% support deporting illegal immigrants. So it continues to poll very, very well. And that's going to be one of the biggest stories of next year.
Joe Getty
I was at a lovely gathering last night in one of my friends who leans somewhat left, politically speaking. He agreed that anybody who thinks Trump is going to, like, root out the guy who's been in the country 20 years, has two kids in schools, he's a successful small businessman or something like that, and that has followed the law, it's not going to happen. Those nightmare scenarios are not going to happen.
Jack Armstrong
But if one of those people accidentally does get deported, that is going to be the only story in America.
Joe Getty
Correct? Yeah. So much to talk about today, including lead story in the Wall Street Journal. They are talking, they have begun talking. Biden aides saying, oh, yeah, senile as hell. Here's, here's how we dealt with it. The leaks have begun.
Jack Armstrong
Wow.
Joe Getty
But first, freedom loving quote of the day. Tim the lawyer Tim Sandifer sent this my way. It's John Adams writing in 2024, apparently put it. He's talking about how getting beyond the Constitution specifically to tax people and then redistribute money income to people is wildly outside the bounds of the Constitution, according to Adams. And he says the nature of the encroachment upon the American Constitution is such as to grow every day more and more encroaching. Like a cancer, it eats faster and faster every hour. The revenue creates pensioners and the pensioners urge for more revenue. The people grow less steady, spirited and virtuous, the seekers more numerous and more corrupt. And every day increases the circle of their dependence and expectance until virtue, integrity, public spirit, simplicity, frugality become the objects of ridicule and scorn and vanity. Luxury foppery. Too damn much foppery.
Jack Armstrong
Oh my God. Hot and cold running foppery.
Joe Getty
Selfishness meanness and downright venality swallow up the whole society.
Jack Armstrong
That is really, really good. My, my, my pushback would be. Yeah, but it's unfair that there are billionaires and poor people.
Joe Getty
John Adams for the win.
Jack Armstrong
That's really good. That is really good. They, they, they understood the long game on so many of these things. The Founding Fathers.
Joe Getty
Yeah, Human nature. Mailbag. Drop us a Note mailbag@armstrongygetti.com SoCal.
Jack Armstrong
Yes, I was driving around yesterday. Foppery everywhere.
Joe Getty
Oh, yeah, yeah, everywhere you look. Thomas SoCal with some gift ideas. Jack always says he can't wait to read books written about the Biden administration. Here are some titles I'm looking forward to reading. There is not a single thing that comes to mind. The Kamala Harris Story, an autobiography, I've Got a Busy Day. A Daily Calendar and Planner by Alejandro Mayor. Daily Calendar. Pardon Me Brother. A Guide to Plausible Deniability by Jim Biden. Tasty Recipes for San Antonio Breakfast Burritos by not a real Dr. Jill Biden. And finally, you're gonna in for a problem, A novel by Joe Biden. I recommend the audiobook version where he whispers the entire story.
Jack Armstrong
That's some good. That's some good material right there.
Joe Getty
That's some good comedy. Thomas socal. Nice job, buddy. Yeah, senile Joe Biden. Stay with us next hour.
Jack Armstrong
You're gonna in for a problem. That's one of my favorite clips.
Joe Getty
Sideshow Bob. Excuse me asking, why on earth would Jack even consider giving up baked goods? It's the only thing that truly sets us apart from the apes. That's true. Apes are almost never seen eating pie.
Jack Armstrong
God. I was talking to the kids about this at dinner. This is my most challenging New Year's resolution ever. I'm almost a little scared.
Joe Getty
Well, and JT and Livermore asks a question that I've. I've wondered myself at times. He says, primarily, I don't understand why Jack is even eating baked goods dessert style. Sugar bombs, given that he lost his sense of sweet from COVID Yeah, people.
Jack Armstrong
Ask me that all the time. I eat more because I lost my tense ability to taste sweet. I eat more sweets than I did before. It. It is. There's. Your brain wants sweet for some reason. I don't know why. And I can't get that. I don't get that. I eat it don't like. And I don't. My brain doesn't recognize that I took in sweets, so it wants more. And I. I am attracted to more sweets than ever in my life because of the COVID sweet thing. It's weird. I would have thought it had been the other way around, like most people think.
Joe Getty
Yeah, very strange. I wish we had more time. We've got some amusing emails, but we'll drop them in throughout the show. Today we got all sorts of stuff to talk about. Elon Musk and Donald Trump running the government from Mar a Lago already.
Jack Armstrong
Yes. So much today I'm. I'm going through the motions. Barely, but a lot. So stay tuned.
Paris Hilton
Armstrong and Getty, you wake up, put on your Ray Ban meta glasses. Classic style, innovative tech. You're living all in you realize you need coffee desperately so you say hey.
Meta Assistant
Meta, how do I make a latte?
Joe Getty
To make a latte, brew two shots of espresso.
Paris Hilton
After Meta AI gets you caffeinated, you start walking to work and you need a soundtrack.
Meta Assistant
Hey Meta Play hip hop music with.
Paris Hilton
The built in camera, you snap a pic of a dope mural on the side of a building that you think is worth sharing.
Meta Assistant
Hey Meta Text my last photo to Eva.
Paris Hilton
Sending message after work you head to meet some friends.
Joe Getty
Hey nice glasses.
Paris Hilton
Ray Ban Meta glasses. The next generation of AI glasses. Just say hey Meta to harness the power of meta AI. Listen to music, make hands free calls with open air audio and built in microphones and so much more. All while staying present to the world around you. Shop Ray Ban meta glasses@meta.com smartglasses hey.
Meta Assistant
Loves it's Paris Hilton. Are you ready to sliv your best life this holiday season? Well, I've got the ultimate holiday giveaway just for you. Go to parishilton.comgiveaway to win a fabulous gift basket filled with handpicked faves from my gift guide. From my iconic cookware and chic apparel to glam goodies from my go to brands, this bundle has it all. Don't wait. Enter now@parishilton.com giveaway good luck and happy Holidays. Keep sliving. That's hot.
Steve Post
Step into a world of unparalleled brightness and lifelike color with Vizio's Quantum Pro TV. This premium QLED TV available in 65 and 75 inch sizes is designed for those who demand the best in picture quality. Breathtaking brightness brings every scene to life while wide viewing angle delivers the perfect picture from any seat in the room. Enjoy all your favorite apps built in so you can blast your top songs through the iHeartRadio app straight out of the box. Head to Walmart to find your Vizio Quantum Pro tv. Today we are the voice of nascar.
Jack Armstrong
The green flag is in the air and we are underway. The Great American Race. The Motor Racing Network, NASCAR Cup, Xfinity and Craftsman Truck Series racing live on your home hometown radio station and MRN or NASCAR.com Martinsville Talladega the Chicago street course.
Steve Post
We have the side by side action.
Jack Armstrong
And last lap passes for the win. Photo finishes Ryan Blaney will win the voice of nascar, the Motor Racing Network.
Maddie
The leaves drift to the ground. The wind rises. Pull up a chair by our fire and listen to stories from the darker side of the past. I'm Maddie. And I'm Anthony and on our podcast After Dark Myths, misdeeds and the paranormal. We tell stories of villages and the death of queens, of Tudor ghosts that will not sleep, and of murder among gravestones. Listen to After Dark from history Hit wherever you get your podcasts.
Joe Getty
Starbucks announced this week it's doubled its.
Jack Armstrong
Paid parental leave policy for baristas, while Dunkin employees are still insisting they're not the father. Oh, what is that?
Joe Getty
What is that?
Jack Armstrong
That's some sort of east coast thing I don't get.
Joe Getty
Wow, what sort of odd snobbery the elite elite is. Oh, speaking of the elite, you know, I know you wanted to talk about something and we will, by God we will. But you know, I'm a big Brett Bear fan. There's an article in the Wall Street Journal. The incoming Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick just bought Bret baer's home in D.C. for $29 million.
Jack Armstrong
Brett Baer of Fox.
Joe Getty
Yes, had.
Jack Armstrong
Is selling a home for $29 million.
Joe Getty
Well, that's because he bought one in Palm Springs a couple years ago where he lives now apparently for 37 million.
Jack Armstrong
So he owned Brett doing pretty well. So he's been owning a 37 million dollar home while owning another 30 million dollar home lease for a little while.
Joe Getty
Waiting for that to clear the market. Yeah, there aren't that many buyers at that level.
Jack Armstrong
No. Yeah, wouldn't that, that's got to be something. There's got to be like five people in the entire country, maybe not even that many because you'd have to be conceivably able to afford it and then have any interest in buying a home at that moment. So it might be like two people in the nation at any given moment that could and want to buy a home at the price range.
Joe Getty
I realize if you have to ask, you can't afford it, but what the hell are the property taxes on a house like that?
Jack Armstrong
Yeah, yeah.
Joe Getty
Bear, Bear.
Jack Armstrong
Thanks for that. Michael, a couple things for you. You can't oversell. I don't think what a big deal it is. The Wall Street Journal has this big piece on Joe Biden's brain and how they've been hiding it forever. Here's an interesting thing. Just teasing it because we're going to talk about it to kick off hour two. We got to talk about it every hour, the whole show today because it's, it's a big deal. A couple of things that I've come across in terms of just teasing the story for later is Matt Welch pointing out politifact said the lie of the year is they're eating the dogs or eating the cats from Donald Trump. That's the lie of the year. And links the Wall Street Journal story saying White House meetings were frequen canceled because Joe Biden's brain didn't work. Yeah, yeah, the dogs and cats thing, bigger lie than the hiding the fact that they had to cancel meetings all the time because the president's brain didn't act. And where, where am I seeing most of the stuff, the, the little snippets of the Wall Street Journal piece from James Homan of the Washington Post who's retweeting all the most juicy stuff from the Wall Street Journal story. Probably because he didn't like being lied to all this time. He, he, his initial tweet being and again we're going to kick off our two with this blockbuster reporting this morning from and he lists all the reporters. They have 50 sources detailing various ways that Biden's inner circle was hiding his decline going back to 2019.
Joe Getty
And that's going back to the very beginning.
Jack Armstrong
But that's a Washington Post guy saying that about the Wall Street Journal article. I think that's notable. And Nate Silver also retweeting that story and saying if you said any of this before June 2024, you'd get accused of peddling misinformation like there was literally an entirely new category of misinformation invented cheap fakes concerning videos of Biden's decline that they would accuse you of. Now it's out in the open and it's interesting that all these other people are retweeting this stuff. I find that unique.
Joe Getty
Indeed. I will point out at the risk of self congratulations, if you've been listening to this show, you knew. I mean we didn't even, I didn't even take seriously the denials. I thought they were hilarious, just idiotic. And it's all been borne out. Again, you know, final punchline. Then we'll, we'll get to the story next hour in full cuz it's, it's well worth hearing. There are still those within the White House who are responding to this story and the various accusations, observations Joe Biden seriously diminished. No he's not. You need to keep meetings short and simple with him. No you don't. He's a very old man. No he's not. They're still 100% denying it.
Jack Armstrong
So again we'll kick off our two with that. And there's a lot of interesting stuff in that. I can't believe I'm talking about government shutdown, debt Ceiling stuff. But there are a couple interesting things happening, as we've already mentioned. And Trump has come out and said he wants to fully get rid of the debt ceiling, which we have said many times before Trump saying today the Democrats have said they want to get rid of it. If they want to get rid of it, I would lead the charge. It's a fake thing. There's no real value in terms of debt control. And we've been saying that for years. It doesn't actually do anything. It just puts us in this weird bickering back and forth, weird political handcuff situation every once in a while. But so far it's never accomplished anything.
Joe Getty
Right?
Jack Armstrong
Yeah, it's, it's hilarious.
Joe Getty
You could, it's Emperor's New Clothes ish.
Jack Armstrong
You could make the argument that at least once a year, twice a year, it makes you have the conversation about debt and without it, we won't, I don't know. But so far it's never, it's never helped. And it is completely made up. It's a man made thing.
Joe Getty
For what it's worth, Newt Gingrich just tweeted President Trump and Republicans should not be afraid of a government shutdown. The next election is two years away. We had two shutdowns in 1995 and became the first reelected GOP House majority since 1928. It may take shock therapy for Schumer and Democrats to learn President Trump is serious about draining the swamp. And a number of people pointed out that during that time when Bill Clinton was the president, that was our last budget surpluses as a country. They had a balanced budget multiple years.
Jack Armstrong
So in 95, I was barely following politics at all. I don't remember. I remember hearing stuff about Newt and the shutdown. I said, but I didn't think about it ever. So how much of the population would even be aware DC goes nuts over this stuff.
Joe Getty
Oh, if you didn't have the media acting like it's akin to the nationwide wildfire or something, screeching about it constantly. No, you'd never notice.
Jack Armstrong
Right. And it's always the thing of this. Many government employees will miss a check. Yeah. And then they'll get the rest of it like three days later than.
Joe Getty
Oh, no, no, no, no, no, no. They go with veterans. It'll be veterans, disabled veterans. Disabled veterans will not get their checks.
Jack Armstrong
Oh, my God.
Joe Getty
And the old, the very old, the, the, the, the soul. They can't even lift their hand to feed themselves.
Jack Armstrong
Trying to figure out what sort of thing I want to talk about today. Am I in the mood for various things. Oh, by the way, you mentioned Fox News and Brett Baer. How much money he makes.
Joe Getty
Yeah.
Jack Armstrong
Or not how much money he makes. But he's selling one 30 million dollar house since he moved into a 35 million dollars roughly.
Joe Getty
Yeah.
Jack Armstrong
Which means you have both at the same time, which is crazy. Fox News dominated 2024 so much it beat easily. CNN and MSNBC added together for the end of the year ratings. That is something.
Joe Getty
I'd like to know what News Nation and OAN and some of the other ones are, what sort of traction they're getting.
Jack Armstrong
Yeah. So that. I don't want to bring that up. I can't. I find it interesting. Maybe I'll bring it up later. I just can't make myself talk about this.
Joe Getty
Wow. All right.
Jack Armstrong
It's a downer.
Joe Getty
It's a conflicted man. We're listening to folks.
Jack Armstrong
So do you know anything about this Yoon, the president of South Korea who's now gone because he pulled that whole I'm going to become emperor thing and martial law and all that. Luckily they suck. Luckily they were able to get back in there and vote him down and open the streets back up and then impeach him. Ian Bremmer tweeted this out yesterday and I know nothing about this. Yoon's presidential campaign relied heavily on AI Deepfake version of him that was much more engaging and sociable than the real him and got him elected. The real Yoon's capability turned out to be a rude awakening to people.
Joe Getty
How did.
Jack Armstrong
How did the world miss this story? Did. Did a guy get elected in a major economic powerful country? Ian is implying through deep fake videos portraying him in a way he's not at all wow. And misled people. And then when he became president, people are like, who are you? You're a. You're a weird off putting angry. Exactly.
Joe Getty
Did that actually happen? Think if Kamala had the videos out of her gliding around the room merrily throwing out clever Bon Mo after Bon Mo making perfect sense. Not giggling like a. Yeah. It could have changed things.
Jack Armstrong
Huh?
Joe Getty
But they don't have any now Hillary. If they'd had deep fakes of Hillary seeming youthful and likable and whatever, that could have turned the tide of history.
Jack Armstrong
Yes, yes, yes. They didn't have. They don't have a media there in South Korea where there are sources that could come out and say that that never happened. Look, I was in the room that night. That is not what happened or something.
Joe Getty
I have no idea. This is. This story brand new to me. Fascinating.
Jack Armstrong
I saw it late last night. I thought I got to dig into that because if that happened, that's a major turning point in world history, I think. Sure.
Joe Getty
Yeah.
Jack Armstrong
They do have to figure out the AI Some scientist needs to figure out what percentage of perfect faces can the brain handle and still think it's real or not. Because the perfect symmetry, I feel like I can look at the AI created people and I mean, that's AI they're too perfect. Nobody looks like that. Nobody's perfectly symmetrical. Even really good looking people aren't perfectly symmetrical. But the AI people are, the chicks usually, because they got them everywhere and it's just, they're, they're obviously fake.
Joe Getty
Yeah. What's interesting is I know in digital recording, like music recording, you can fix something to a grid so it's perfectly in rhythm and then you can instruct it to insert 15% variation.
Jack Armstrong
Interesting.
Joe Getty
And I, I'll bet that sort of thing's coming to visual.
Jack Armstrong
And you would, and you would do that to what, mimic real humans?
Joe Getty
Yeah, essentially it's like you fix something and then you unfix it a little bit so it sounds more human.
Jack Armstrong
Interesting. So I was a club DJ briefly when I was younger. I didn't like that. Gladys. Huh.
Joe Getty
It was 1977.
Jack Armstrong
Disco was K many decades after that. But so I would have to mix songs together and like your, your, your rap music or hip hop music or whatever, they use what they call a click track. I mean it's a computer drum. It's perfect. And so you can mix beats together. But any rock and roll song, if you try to mix it there, like you know, Back in Black, ACDC or whatever, you can't because the tempo varies. Rolling Stones anymore, the beat varies. They get a little faster toward the end or slow down in the middle or whatever because it's human beings involved. And I always thought that was really interesting. Some of the most popular songs of all time, they didn't keep a perfectly steady beat through it. Of course you wouldn't.
Joe Getty
Right, right. And I, I kind of regret being mostly recording during the year of click tracks because when you listen to those songs and it's pointed out to you, you think that's why the last chorus sounds more exciting.
Jack Armstrong
They picked up the space, sped up a little. They got excited or they slowed down.
Joe Getty
Before it just because they were all looking at each other and yeah, there.
Jack Armstrong
Was human emotion involved.
Joe Getty
Exactly. They got excited. Now I'm excited, everybody's excited.
Jack Armstrong
That'll be the difficult thing for AI to mimic. Although they'll figure it out soon enough. Also looking at some of the Elon headlines. He is a guy who is not concerned what other people think about him. No, I don't think it ever crosses his mind. I mean, he is, he is the all time king of I have no Fs to give.
Joe Getty
Right. Ego, wealth, and autism. I think there's plenty of people positioned.
Jack Armstrong
Plenty of people with ego and wealth, but they seem to be very concerned what other people think. He's not one. I said it yesterday. You were gone somewhere that I wonder how much of his ability. Oh, it was the conversation we had about. So, Katie, you. You got the name for me? Some big business leader, gazillionaire, also who worked with Steve Jobs and Elon Musk was talking about the signal to noise ratio thing that I'm kind of fascinated with. And he was, he was talking about how Steve Jobs was 90% signal, 10% noise, as in 90% of everything he did was. Was focused on getting something accomplished with very little extraneous whatever. And he worked 20 hours a day. He said, Elon is a hundred percent signal. Wow. Just the way he is, like 20 hours a day. And I wondered how much of that is his Asperger's. Just his ability to stay focused without like, screw this, I'm gonna do something else. I'm gonna drink margaritas and flip through, you know, porn or something. I don't know what.
Joe Getty
I wish you could step on a scale or get a scan or something and they could say, well, Joe, you're 22% signal. I'd.
Meta Assistant
What?
Jack Armstrong
Yeah, no kidding. Do you remember who that was, Katie?
Steve Post
Yeah, Kevin O'Leary. Also big on Shark Tank.
Jack Armstrong
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Joe Getty
Oh, you know, it's funny on that topic, I. I've got just a minor health thing going on. Everything's fine. But they wanted to do an MRI of my brain to make sure it wasn't a brain tumor. And how do you.
Jack Armstrong
How do you say, I got a health thing? It's no big deal. They did an MRI to see if I got a brain tumor. That seems like a big deal.
Joe Getty
I just. The details of it aren't interesting and we're up against a break. It's. It's a hearing thing, but it's. It's. I think I know what it is. It's gonna be fine. But anyway, I thought it was hilarious that I got the results. I actually saw them getting ready with the show for the show today, and it said, please assure the patient that his MRI looks normal and his his brain showed nothing exceptional. And I thought, wow, that's pretty much confirmed by the trajectory of my life.
Jack Armstrong
Nothing exceptional here.
Joe Getty
The Joe Getty Story.
Jack Armstrong
Yeah, that could be the the title of your book. We see nothing exceptional. The Joe Getty Story. We've got Katie's headlines next Armstrong and Getty.
Paris Hilton
You wake up, put on your Ray Ban meta glasses. Classic style, innovative tech. You're living all in. You realize you need coffee desperately.
Jack Armstrong
So you say hey Meta, how do.
Meta Assistant
I make a latte?
Joe Getty
To make a latte, brew two shots of espresso.
Paris Hilton
After Meta AI gets you caffeinated, you start walking to work and you need a soundtrack.
Meta Assistant
Hey Meta, Play hip hop music with.
Paris Hilton
The built in camera. You snap a pic of a dope mural on the side of a building that you think is worth sharing.
Meta Assistant
Hey Meta, text my last photo to Eva.
Jack Armstrong
Sending message.
Paris Hilton
After work you head to meet some friends.
Joe Getty
Hey nice glasses.
Paris Hilton
Ray Ban Meta glasses. The next generation of AI glasses. Just say hey Meta. To harness the power of Meta AI, listen to music, make hands free calls with open air audio and built in microphones and so much more. All while staying present to the world around you. Shop Ray Ban meta glasses@meta.com smartglasses hey.
Meta Assistant
Loves it's Paris Hilton. Are you ready to sleeve your best life this holiday season? Well, I've got the ultimate holiday giveaway just for you. Go to parishilton.comgiveaway to win a fabulous gift basket filled with handpicked faves from my gift guide. From my iconic cookware and chic apparel to glam goodies from my go to brands, this bundle has it all. Don't wait. Enter now@parishilton.com giveaway good luck and happy Holidays. Keep sliving. That's hot.
Steve Post
Step into a world of unparalleled brightness and lifelike color with Vizio's Quantum Pro TV. This premium QLED TV available in 65 and 75 inch sizes is designed for those who demand the best in picture quality. Breathtaking brightness brings every scene to life while wide viewing angle delivers the perfect picture from any seat in the room. Enjoy all your favorite apps built in so you can blast your top songs through the iHeartRadio app straight out of the box. Head to Walmart to find your Vizio Quantum Pro TV today.
Todd Gordon
Hi, I'm MRN lead pit reporter Steve Post.
Jack Armstrong
And I'm championship winning crew chief Todd Gordon.
Todd Gordon
Go behind the scenes each week with us for MRN Crew will talk to some of the biggest names standing atop.
Jack Armstrong
The pit box as well as break down all the exciting action from the weekend in NASCAR and go into detail on the winning strategies.
Todd Gordon
Crew Call is also where you'll hear from the first time winners in the.
Jack Armstrong
Champions from the NASCAR Cup Series to the Craftsman Truck Series.
Todd Gordon
Listen today in the iHeartRadio app or on your favorite podcast platform.
Maddie
The leaves drift to the ground. The wind rises. Pull up a chair by our fire and listen to stories from the darker side of the past. I'm Maddie. And I'm Anthony and on our podcast After Dark Myths, Misdeeds and the Paranormal, we tell stories of villages and the death of queens, of Tudor ghosts that will not sleep, and of murder among gravestones. Listen to After Dark from history Hit wherever you get your podcasts.
Jack Armstrong
I like reading the style sections of various newspapers because I find them hilarious and they're so out of touch with my real life. Anyway, here's one. What is the hottest scent in perfumes right now? According to the Wall Street Journal, it is pistachio. Just a hint of pistachio and all the most expensive scents out there. And also their suggestion for the holidays Forego the hackneyed holiday beanie, which I wore to work today to keep my head warm. Forgot it's hackneyed, you see, in favor of the equally practical Fullard. F O U L A R D Full art.
Joe Getty
Oh yeah, I've got three of them.
Jack Armstrong
Some triangle thing you tie around your head. I hope you're not wearing a hackneyed beanie this weekend.
Joe Getty
Full hard. I wouldn't know one if you shoved it up my chimney. Anyway, hey, let's figure out who's reporting what. It's lead story with Katie Green.
Steve Post
Katie Starting with abc, the FAA temporarily bans drones in parts of New Jersey. Notice threatens, quote, deadly force for imminent security threat.
Jack Armstrong
There is, as Joe is saying, this will go away when Travis proposes to Taylor or, you know, something happens. Christmas will make this story go away, right? We'll all forget about it. We'll come back on January 6th and it will have gone away. And no, nobody will remember how it got resolved and that'll be the end of it.
Joe Getty
The latest is you got a bunch of New Jerseyites saying the thing passed over my house and now I can't stop coughing. Oh, people complaining of weird symptoms.
Jack Armstrong
Maybe you need a full art to keep your head warm.
Steve Post
From the New York Post, Luigi Mangione arrives at courthouse as hundreds of protesters.
Jack Armstrong
Gather outside to show support for Killer you freaking weirdos.
Steve Post
From the Wall. Washington Post, Amazon hit by Teamsters strikes during holiday rush.
Jack Armstrong
Yeah, it's thousands of people. And Amazon has 1.8 million employees or something like that. So it's. But. But in the locations where they're centered, like San Francisco, that's if you're expecting something, you know, overnight, last minute rush, it could have an effect.
Joe Getty
Whoops.
Steve Post
From The Associated Press. NASA's two struck as two stuck astronauts face more time in space with return delayed now until at least March.
Jack Armstrong
That'd be a heck of bad news that. Bad news to get. You think you're coming back from space after being stuck up there forever? Change it again.
Joe Getty
Yeah. Even if, if it was kind of exciting that they would be up there for an extended period, at first they'd think, well, what the hell, I get to live in space for a while. They're probably good and sick of it now.
Jack Armstrong
Unless you don't like your family and you're thinking, oh, right.
Steve Post
From cnn Humanoid robot that can do your laundry dishes and make you coffee. Could be yours as early as next year.
Jack Armstrong
Awesome.
Steve Post
And finally, the Babylon Be RFK Jr advises children to leave out eight strips of bacon and a bowl of beef tallow for Santa this year.
Jack Armstrong
Which publication had the headline about the you might have a robot next year?
Steve Post
Cnn.
Jack Armstrong
Okay, I have to look into that story. I need one.
Joe Getty
Between AI and robots, we're spending a lot of time and money on designing things that we could just do ourselves. I don't. I don't know. We're gonna make ourselves obsolete. The president is senile and now everybody's admitting it. Major Wall Street Journal story coming up next. If you can't stay around, grab it via podcast. Armstrong and Getty on demand.
Meta Assistant
Armstrong and Getty. Hey loves, it's Paris Hilton. Are you ready to sliv your best life this holiday season? Well, I've got the ultimate holiday giveaway just for you. Go to parishilton.comgiveaway to win a fabulous gift basket filled with handpicked faves from my gift guide. From my iconic cookware and chic apparel to glam goodies from my go to brands, this bundle has it all. Don't wait. Enter now@parishilton.com giveaway good luck and happy holidays days Keeps living. That's hot.
Joe Getty
At Ameca Insurance, we know it's more than just a house. It's your home. The place that's filled with memories. The early days of figuring it out. To the later years of still figuring.
Jack Armstrong
It out.
Joe Getty
For the place you've put down roots. Trust Amica Home insurance. Ameca Empathy is our best policy.
Steve Post
Ready to unleash the power of 4K Vizio's 4K TV collection has you covered with sizes ranging from 43 inches all the way up to a jaw dropping 86 inch screen. Experience stunning clarity like never before, bringing your favorite shows and movies to life. And with Watch Free plus built in, you'll enjoy free live and on tv. Demand TV right out of the box. You can even stream your favorite songs with the iHeartRadio app ready to go on every Vizio 4K TV. Upgrade your entertainment. Head to Walmart to find your Vizio 4K TV today.
Todd Gordon
Hi, I'm MRN Lead Pit Reporter Steve Post.
Jack Armstrong
And I'm Championship winning Crew chief Todd Gordon.
Todd Gordon
Go behind the scenes each week with us for MRN Crew Call, where we'll talk to some of the biggest names standing atop the pit box as well.
Jack Armstrong
As break down all the exciting action from the weekend and NASCAR and go into detail on the winning strategies.
Todd Gordon
Crew Call is also where you'll hear from the first time winners in the.
Jack Armstrong
Champions from the NASCAR Cup Series to the Craftsman Truck Series.
Todd Gordon
Listen today in the iHeartRadio app or on your favorite podcast platform.
Maddie
The leaves drift to the ground. The wind rises. Pull up a chair by our fire and listen to stories from the darker side of the path past. I'm Maddie. And I'm Anthony and on our podcast After Dark, Myths, Misdeeds and the Paranormal. We tell stories of villages and the death of queens, of Tudor ghosts that will not sleep, and of murder among gravestones. Listen to After Dark from History Hit wherever you get your podcasts.
Armstrong & Getty On Demand: "Yes! Public Weeping!" – December 19, 2024
In the December 19, 2024 episode of Armstrong & Getty On Demand, hosts Jack Armstrong and Joe Getty delve deep into the tumultuous state of American politics, exploring themes of governmental dysfunction, excessive spending, and the pervasive influence of high-profile figures like Donald Trump and Elon Musk. Titled "Yes! Public Weeping!," the episode serves as a critical examination of the current political landscape, interspersed with sharp wit and candid commentary.
The episode opens with a heated discussion on the looming government shutdown and the contentious debates surrounding the debt ceiling. Armstrong expresses profound frustration with the perpetual stalemate in Washington, stating at [03:51]:
“I just don't care. I just don't care at all. Maybe that makes me a child, I don't know.”
Getty reinforces this sentiment, highlighting the absurdity of ongoing deficit spending:
“We are spending future generations into oblivion. It's incredibly selfish and evil.” [10:14]
The hosts criticize both major political parties for their inability to achieve fiscal responsibility, portraying the debt ceiling as a "man-made thing" that offers no real control over national spending.
Armstrong and Getty scrutinize the outsized roles of Donald Trump and Elon Musk in current political affairs. Armstrong sarcastically remarks on Trump's temporary position as an "unelected co-president" at [03:24]:
“And soon Biden may wander off anyway, so Trump might as well actually sit behind the desk.”
Getty adds perspective on Musk's involvement, noting his disregard for public opinion:
“Elon is a hundred percent signal. [...] I don't know how much of that is his Asperger's.”
A major focus of the episode is the critique of unchecked government spending and the cyclical nature of fiscal irresponsibility. Armstrong laments the constant insertion of unrelated expenditures into budget bills, leading to impasses:
“Every single time there's some reason that the Republican Party or the Democratic Party explains. No, just this one. We need to get this one passed.”
Getty emphasizes the moral decay resulting from such practices, labeling the current state as “treasonous” with detrimental long-term effects on the nation's economic stability:
“It is utterly immoral. What we are doing right now is indefensible. Fiscally, morally, patriotically. It's treasonous.” [10:14]
The hosts turn their attention to a Wall Street Journal exposé alleging President Biden's declining cognitive abilities. Armstrong highlights the media's role in perpetuating misinformation:
“The lie of the year is they're eating the dogs or eating the cats from Donald Trump.” [30:13]
Getty argues that their show had dismissed such claims early on, which have now been corroborated by the exposé:
“If you've been listening to this show, you knew. We thought they were hilarious, just idiotic. And it's all been borne out.”
A significant portion of the episode explores the implications of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and deepfakes in modern politics. The hosts discuss the hypothetical scenario where AI-generated personas influence elections, referencing South Korean President Yoon's misrepresented image:
“Yoon's presidential campaign relied heavily on AI Deepfake version of him that was much more engaging and sociable than the real him and got him elected.” [34:10]
Armstrong muses on the psychological impact of flawless AI-created images versus the imperfect nature of real humans:
“Nobody looks like that. Nobody's perfectly symmetrical. But the AI people are—the chicks usually, because they got them everywhere and it's just, they're obviously fake.”
Getty adds insights into how digital manipulation can alter public perception and trust:
“It's like you fix something and then you unfix it a little bit so it sounds more human.”
Amidst the heavy political discourse, Armstrong and Getty intersperse personal stories and humor. Getty shares a personal health anecdote about undergoing an MRI, likening the results to his professional life:
“The Joe Getty Story. We've got Katie's headlines next Armstrong and Getty.” [40:47]
Their playful exchange about fashion choices and societal norms adds a relatable and entertaining layer to the conversation.
Concluding the episode, Armstrong and Getty propose public weeping—a metaphorical call for heightened public emotion and activism—as a means to break the political impasse and force meaningful change:
Armstrong: “So just blow it up. Until there is public weeping and, oh, my God, the endless government shutdown.”
Getty: “Yes, that's what we need, public weeping.”
By advocating for a collective emotional response, the hosts suggest that public dissatisfaction could disrupt the status quo and compel politicians to address the nation's financial and administrative crises more earnestly.
Notable Quotes:
Jack Armstrong [03:51]: “I just don't care. I just don't care at all. Maybe that makes me a child, I don't know.”
Joe Getty [10:14]: “We are spending future generations into oblivion. It's incredibly selfish and evil.”
Jack Armstrong [34:10]: “Nobody looks like that. Nobody's perfectly symmetrical. But the AI people are... they're obviously fake.”
Joe Getty [30:13]: “If you've been listening to this show, you knew. We thought they were hilarious, just idiotic. And it's all been borne out.”
Conclusion
This episode of Armstrong & Getty On Demand offers a passionate and unfiltered critique of contemporary American politics, emphasizing the urgent need for fiscal responsibility and genuine leadership. Through incisive analysis and engaging dialogue, Armstrong and Getty challenge listeners to reflect on the systemic issues plaguing the government and consider radical solutions to incite meaningful change.