Ascend - The Great Books Podcast: Episode Summary
Title: Prometheus Bound by Aeschylus with Dr. Jared Zimmerer
Release Date: May 6, 2025
Hosts: Deacon Harrison Garlick and Adam Minihan
Guest: Dr. Jared Zimmerer, Content Marketing Director and Great Books Adjunct Professor at Benedictine College
Introduction
In this insightful episode of Ascend - The Great Books Podcast, hosts Deacon Harrison Garlick and Adam Minihan delve deep into Aeschylus's classic tragedy, Prometheus Bound. Joined by Dr. Jared Zimmerer, a distinguished professor from Benedictine College, the discussion explores the profound themes of tyranny, freedom, and the essence of human civilization as portrayed in the play.
Understanding Prometheus Bound
Deacon Harrison Garlick introduces the episode by highlighting the central narrative of Prometheus Bound: "It tells the story of Zeus, newly ascended to the throne over gods and men, binding Prometheus to a rock for helping mankind" (00:00). He emphasizes the play's relevance, stating, "It is a story of tyranny, freedom, and human civilization" (00:10), and invites listeners to ponder how technological progress affects human nature and society.
Dr. Jared Zimmerer echoes this sentiment, reflecting on the play's enduring impact: "It's just such an interesting celebration of what it means to be a human person, what it means to be culture, creators, civilization and builders" (107:26).
Themes Explored
Tyranny and Freedom
A significant portion of the discussion centers on Zeus's portrayal as a tyrannical ruler. Dr. Zimmerer notes, "When you think of Zeus, you think of might and violence" (24:24), contrasting this with traditional depictions where Zeus is often seen as a bringer of order. The hosts explore how Prometheus Bound subverts this perception by presenting Zeus in a harsh, authoritarian light from the outset.
Deacon Garlick adds, "It's a prison yard ethic... a tyrant making examples of people to solidify his rule" (26:19), drawing parallels to modern dictators and emphasizing the timeless nature of tyranny.
Suffering and Redemption
The hosts delve into the motif of suffering, a recurring theme in Aeschylus's works. Deacon Garlick connects Prometheus's agony to the broader Greek understanding that "in suffering, man finds wisdom" (46:59). This idea aligns with later Christian concepts of redemptive suffering, highlighting the universal struggle between enduring hardship and seeking meaning.
Dr. Zimmerer concurs, stating, "There's something redemptive about suffering, something that can be purgative" (49:08), underscoring how Prometheus's endurance ultimately serves a greater purpose.
Character Analyses
Prometheus: Hero or Anti-Hero?
A focal point of the conversation is Prometheus's complex character. Dr. Zimmerer describes him as an "anti-hero" yet the figure audiences cheer for: "he's the hero, he's the guy you're cheering on" (12:21). This duality raises questions about his motivations and the morality of his actions.
Deacon Garlick grapples with Prometheus's role, pondering whether he aligns more with Christ or Lucifer: "Is Prometheus a better analog to Christ or Lucifer?" (22:47). This ambiguity highlights the nuanced portrayal of rebellion against divine authority.
Zeus: The Embodiment of Tyranny
Zeus is depicted not as the noble deity of traditional myths but as a despotic ruler. Dr. Zimmerer asserts, "power will ultimately corrupt" (27:10), emphasizing Zeus's quick descent into tyranny. The conversation contrasts this with earlier representations where Zeus was often seen as a bringer of order and justice.
Io and Hermes: Agents of Punishment
The introduction of Io and Hermes adds depth to Zeus’s tyranny. Dr. Zimmerer explains Io's plight as a result of Zeus's lust and Hera's jealousy: "he raped a girl and then he transfigured her into something ugly" (66:14). Hermes's role as a messenger enforcing Zeus's will further illustrates the extent of divine abuse.
Analogies and Modern Implications
Prometheus as Christ and Lucifer
The hosts explore Prometheus's potential analogies to both Christ and Lucifer. Deacon Garlick observes, "Prometheus has this indomitable will... it seems like he's also pushing against divine tyranny" (78:53). This duality mirrors modern interpretations where Prometheus embodies both the suffering hero and the rebellious figure akin to Lucifer.
Dr. Zimmerer adds, "With Prometheus, there's this weird mixture of the two" (54:16), highlighting the complexity of his character and the varied ways he can be interpreted.
Technology and Fire
A significant portion of the discussion is dedicated to the symbolism of fire as technology. Deacon Garlick posits that fire represents both the arts and sciences: "fire is an analog of the arts of science" (90:00). Dr. Zimmerer agrees, noting, "fire is a perfect example... a blessing and a warning" (92:57). They discuss how fire, while essential for civilization, also holds the potential for destruction, mirroring modern technological advancements that can both uplift and harm society.
Cultural Reflections: High Culture vs. Pop Culture
The hosts lament the decline of "high culture," equating it to Prometheus's gifts being squandered: "we waste the arts and techne that Prometheus gave us" (86:28). Deacon Garlick emphasizes the importance of leisure in fostering creativity and civilization: "leisure was actually when we could produce things" (89:18). They argue that modern society's focus on superficial entertainment undermines the profound cultural and intellectual advancements that Prometheus symbolizes.
Dr. Zimmerer concurs, stating, "we have flat souls wielding atomic power and AI" (98:00), critiquing the superficial engagement with technology and culture.
Justice and Governance
Aeschylus's portrayal of justice is another critical area of exploration. Deacon Garlick compares the primitive justice of familial revenge in the Oresteia to the more structured procedural justice in Prometheus Bound: "Aeschylus is still working through that grammar" (77:00). They discuss how the tragedy lays the groundwork for understanding justice's evolution from personal vengeance to societal systems.
Dr. Zimmerer adds, "it's the nature of tyranny to distrust friends and turn against allies" (43:24), reinforcing the critique of Zeus's governance style.
Prophecy and the Cycle of Usurpation
The prophecy concerning Hercules as the one to free Prometheus introduces the theme of inevitable change and the cyclical nature of power. Deacon Garlick reflects on the mythological pattern of usurpation: "multiple variations... Aeschylus changes the myths to make a point" (102:15). This prophecy underscores the transient nature of tyranny and the enduring spirit of rebellion and renewal.
Dr. Zimmerer explains Hermes's role in enforcing Zeus's decrees and Prometheus's strategic silence: "he would rather sit here and suffer than give away that information" (74:10). This strategic patience emphasizes Prometheus's long-term vision and forethought.
Conclusion
The episode concludes with both hosts and Dr. Zimmerer acknowledging the profound insights of Prometheus Bound. Dr. Zimmerer encourages listeners to engage with the text, highlighting its rich exploration of human nature and civilization: "It's one of those works that gets skipped over, but there's so much in it" (107:26). Deacon Garlick reinforces the play's significance in understanding the divine-human relationship and the ever-relevant themes of power, suffering, and cultural integrity.
Deacon Garlick wraps up with anticipation for the next episode: "Next week we will be taking up Antigone by Sophocles" (108:03), inviting listeners to continue their journey through the Great Books.
Notable Quotes:
- Deacon Harrison Garlick: "It is a story of tyranny, freedom, and human civilization" (00:10).
- Dr. Jared Zimmerer: "It's such an interesting celebration of what it means to be a human person, what it means to be culture, creators, civilization and builders" (107:26).
- Deacon Garlick: "It's a prison yard ethic... a tyrant making examples of people to solidify his rule" (26:19).
- Dr. Zimmerer: "There's something redemptive about suffering, something that can be purgative" (49:08).
- Deacon Garlick: "Is Prometheus a better analog to Christ or Lucifer?" (22:47).
- Dr. Zimmerer: "fire is a perfect example... a blessing and a warning" (92:57).
Resources Mentioned:
- Complete Greek Tragedies Collection by David Green and Latimer.
- A Year of Homer guides available on thegreatbookspodcast.com.
Connect with Dr. Jared Zimmerer:
- Media Benedictine: media.benedictine.edu
- Social Media: Search for "Jared Zimmerer" on your preferred platform.
Upcoming Episode:
Join us next week as we explore Antigone by Sophocles, continuing our exploration of the Great Books with profound discussions and insightful analyses.
Follow Us:
Stay updated with Ascend - The Great Books Podcast by following us on X (formerly Twitter), YouTube, and support us on Patreon.