Ask NT Wright Anything: Is Abortion Ever Justified? Can Lucifer Be Forgiven? NT Wright Answers Your Questions

Released on June 1, 2025, "Ask NT Wright Anything" hosted by Mike Bird delves into some of the most profound and contentious theological questions. In this episode, listeners submit inquiries on the justification of abortion, the potential forgiveness of Lucifer, and the relationship between Romans 8 and Galatians 4. Renowned theologian Tom Wright joins Mike to provide thoughtful, scripture-based insights into these complex issues.

1. The Ethics of Abortion: A Christian Perspective

Question by Sarah Mercer (Germany) [01:27]: Sarah poses a deeply personal and challenging question: “Why should Christians defend life from the moment of conception? Why should Christians oppose abortion and stand up for the protection of unborn life?” She grapples with the moral implications of abortion, especially in cases like rape or when the mother's life is at risk, finding the traditional stance against abortion somewhat abstract and emotionally disconnected.

Tom Wright’s Response [03:49]: Tom acknowledges the sensitivity and complexity surrounding the abortion debate, emphasizing its entanglement with broader societal and ethical issues. He reflects on the historical context, noting how the sexual revolution and the subsequent rise of abortion as a political tool contributed to its stigmatization within Christian discourse.

“The reaction against abortion was partly to do with the reaction against people having sex with multiple partners whenever they wanted and not caring. [...] It became a symbol of that amoral society that was suddenly springing up, particularly in the 60s.” [03:55]

Drawing from personal experience, Tom shares a poignant story about a family member facing a potential termination due to rubella exposure, highlighting the moral and emotional turmoil such decisions entail. He underscores the importance of prioritizing the mother's health while also recognizing the inherent value of the unborn child.

“The sooner the better, because at a certain point [...] then this is a viable human being that should then be cherished.” [09:20]

Tom also critiques extreme positions that advocate for late-term abortions or infanticide, labeling them as remnants of pagan practices incompatible with Christian ethics.

“The early Judeans didn't do that. The early Christians didn't do that because they valued every human being.” [08:15]

He concludes by affirming that while the default Christian stance opposes abortion, exceptions may exist in dire circumstances, always approached with sorrow and ethical consideration.

2. The Doctrine of Reconciliation: Can Lucifer Be Forgiven?

Question by Timothy Smith (United States) [11:51]: Timothy seeks clarity on a theological conundrum: “Does God forgive Lucifer in the end? [...] Does the destruction of Satan mean the destruction of his will or the destruction of his person?” He references Colossians 3:11 and inquires about the extent of God's reconciliation.

Tom Wright’s Insight [12:56]: Tom distinguishes between the immediate context of Colossians 3:11 and the broader Pauline theology. He clarifies that Paul’s reference to Christ being "all and in all" pertains specifically to the unity of the church, transcending ethnic and social boundaries, rather than addressing cosmic reconciliation.

“Paul is talking about the Church and about the fact that we're all part of the same family, which is an outlandish, scandalous doctrine in the first century.” [13:10]

Addressing the possibility of Lucifer’s forgiveness, Tom expresses skepticism rooted in scriptural interpretations. He argues against dualistic notions that place Satan as an equal opposing force to God, emphasizing that biblical texts portray negative forces as ultimately being destroyed rather than reconciled.

“I don't think there is a being equal and opposite to God or even equal and opposite to Jesus that would then need to be reconciled.” [17:30]

Tom references historical theological debates, particularly critiquing Origen’s early Christian views on universal reconciliation. Instead, he leans on revelations from the Book of Revelation, which depict the final eradication of evil.

“The book of Revelation [...] sees all the negative forces as being thrown into this pit of fire.” [17:45]

He concludes that reconciliation, in the Pauline sense, does not extend to Lucifer or fallen angels, aligning with the eschatological vision of ultimate divine justice.

3. Exploring Paul’s Letters: Galatians 4 and Romans 8

Question by Frank O’Keefe (Sydney, Australia) [21:37]: Frank delves into Pauline theology, asking: “In your lecture on Galatians 4, you mentioned parallels between Galatians 4 and Romans 8. Could you please expand on how Romans 8 is sort of like an extrapolation of Romans 4?” He seeks to understand whether Romans 8 builds upon or diverges from Galatians 4 in its theological discourse.

Tom Wright’s Exposition [23:03]: Tom begins by addressing a common scholarly debate regarding perceived inconsistencies in Paul’s treatment of the Law between Galatians and Romans. He explains that Galatians and Romans, while seemingly opposing on the surface, are addressing different contexts and theological issues.

“Galatians is saying, watch out, don't go back to the law... Romans is saying, look, the law, the Jewish law was a good thing, now fulfilled.” [30:15]

In Galatians 4, Paul focuses on the issue of community identity, especially scrutinizing the pressures on Gentile Christians to adopt Jewish customs like circumcision to be recognized as part of Abraham’s covenant family. Tom emphasizes that Galatians advocates for freedom in Christ, moving beyond the Law to establish unity and inclusion within the Christian community.

“Galatians looks as if it's anti-law, but that is an abstract way of reading it over against the real life three-dimensional historical situation.” [28:30]

Conversely, in Romans 8, Paul delves into the relationship between the Law and Christian life, asserting that the Law is fulfilled through the Spirit. Tom elaborates that Romans integrates both covenantal and juridical (law court) language, enriching the theological framework established in Galatians.

“Romans 8 becomes really quite complicated because there is therefore now no condemnation for those in Messiah Jesus.” [31:10]

Tom highlights that Romans 8 builds upon Galatians by addressing broader theological themes such as sin, redemption, and the assurance of salvation, thereby presenting a more comprehensive view of Christian liberation through the Spirit.

“In Romans, as we know from chapters nine to eleven, Paul is faced with a community in Rome where lots of Gentiles have become Christians...” [27:50]

He advises listeners to consider the historical and cultural contexts of both letters to fully grasp their interconnected yet distinct theological messages.

Conclusion

Throughout this episode of "Ask NT Wright Anything," Tom Wright offers nuanced and contextually grounded perspectives on some of Christianity’s most challenging questions. From the ethical debates surrounding abortion to the intricate theological discussions on reconciliation and Pauline doctrine, Wright emphasizes the importance of historical context, scriptural fidelity, and compassionate reasoning. Whether grappling with personal moral dilemmas or seeking deeper theological understanding, listeners are encouraged to engage thoughtfully with these profound issues through the lens of faith and scholarship.

For more insights from Tom Wright and Mike Bird, subscribe to bonus episodes at Ask NT Wright Supporting Cast.