Loading summary
A
Hi everyone and welcome to Badon Paper Podcast. I'm Olivia Mentor.
B
And I'm Becca Freeman.
A
And today we're talking about 2026 publishing trends.
B
Yeah, we have two experts that we're talking to, one book agent and one bookseller. And I'm really curious to hear what they're seeing in the publishing industry. I mean, I think we have our own theories as readers and as authors, but I'm really curious to get their expert opinions.
A
Me too. And they both have such great specific taste, so I'm looking forward to it.
B
Before we get to that, tell me your high. It's been a while since we recorded. We recorded the last two episodes in advance, so there's been a lot of time for highs and lows in between.
A
A lot of time. And I will say it's been a good two weeks. I went to Charleston. I had a nice book event, I saw my parents. The weather was perfect. But I got back and the vibes have just been good. I feel really good. I got back home with this really renewed spring energy where I just started cleaning out my entire house. Donated, I can't even thousands of pieces of clothing. It felt like. Listed some stuff on Poshmark too, but mostly just got rid of stuff. We're cleaning out rooms, getting ready for the kitchen, we're planning stuff. I'm working all the time. I'm not spending a lot of time on my phone. I'm reading a ton. I just feel like the vibes are good and spring is around the corner. Even though it is not great here today, weather wise. But I believe it's close. I did my first day in the garden working. Getting the leaves out and seeing all of the little sprouts underneath the leaves was such a nice metaphor for spring is coming. So, yeah, it's just the vibes are strong. The vibes are good.
B
Love, love hearing that.
A
Tell me about your high.
B
Well, I had to narrow it down. I had about 4 highs, but I'm picking 2. So the first thing, as a follow up to a low I had a few weeks ago that I was kind of dilly dallying on getting started with book three. I'm happy to report that I've started and I'm just taking it really light and easy. I hopefully have set myself some very achievable goals and I'm just wading in like I'm only up to my knees, you know, like I'm like 6,000 words in. But the water feels good. I'm excited.
A
Good, light and easy. I like the sound of that.
B
We'll see if I can make it
A
last on your substack. You shared your post that you posted when you started your second book.
B
Yeah.
A
And you're saying light and easy. Light and easy. And then you weren't.
B
No.
A
But now. Now.
B
Third time's a charm, baby.
A
Sometimes it takes the time, you know, But I love to hear that.
B
So, yeah, that is exciting to be on the road and to be in a new project. I can already feel the obsession seeds kind of propagating. And then my other high is that started buying some things for my apartment. I have been here officially two months, and I made it just shy of two months. Hadn't bought a single thing for the apartment other than, you know, random organization, bins, et cetera. And had a great meeting with my interior designer last Friday, and we started to make some decisions. So I am really excited to start to see the apartment come together.
A
That's so exciting. I saw the rug, the runner you posted, which was so funny because I have been looking at that same site, Green Row. I have never seen random pieces here and there. Yeah. It's so cute. And I love, like, the English sort of style and sensibility with home decor. So I love that you shared it. And I loved the runner. It looked so nice.
B
Well, I think that I am doing some surgery that we're going to combine two runners together to make it long enough, so.
A
Oh, yeah. You know, weirdly, I have a similar project coming up because after we refinish the floors and the stairs, we're going to get a stair runner, which will be interesting because I doubt I can find a runner the right length. And we're doing it ourselves. I think I can't pay, like, a carpet company to do that because I, like, you just need staples, you know, a stapler.
B
Oh, I'm. I'm having a professional do this. I mean, I don't have a sewing machine, period, but I think this is the type of thing that you need some industrial tools for.
A
Yeah. I will probably grow to regret this diy, but I like the innovation happening.
B
Yeah. So things are starting to arrive. Shipping is fast right now. Nothing goes together that has arrived. Like, I have dining room chairs, but no dining room table. My office rug is coming tomorrow, but the rug pad won't be here for two weeks. So, you know.
A
Have you picked out a dining room table?
B
I have, yeah.
A
Okay. That's exciting.
C
I have.
B
It's on order.
A
I want to hear about that.
B
Things are going to start happening.
A
Is your goal to have it done by the end of summer or earlier?
B
No, I don't have any specific goal. I mean, I think, you know, depending on shipping lead times, it should definitely come together by the end of the summer. But kind of just trying to make the right choices. There's definitely some, like, logic puzzles of orders of operation. Like, I'm gonna wallpaper the bathroom, but first we need to switch out the light and the medicine cabinet. So, you know, the. There's like, some process going on, but, yeah, I'm excited.
A
Well, I can't wait to hear about it, because I'm in a similar stage with dining room kitchen stuff. We're about to order all the appliances, so I'm like, here we go. It's happening.
B
It's exciting.
A
Well, what's your low?
B
I have a very vain, stupid low that I wonder if anyone has advice
A
on, so I do too, actually.
B
Oh, good.
A
So, yes, we're in this together.
B
So do you remember a few years ago when one of my New Year's goals was to start dyeing my hair? Start dyeing my grays, which I have, but I am having this problem that the dye, and I'm just doing, like, a single process dye, it doesn't permanently stick to my grays, so it bleaches out over time, and it kind of ends up looking like a dingy blonde highlight because it's brown dye that's, like, clinging for dear life to white hair. And I don't quite have. It's not the full Stacy London white streak, but I do have this one section in. In my hair on one side, in my kind of mid layers that is pretty white. And so I'm going to the hair salon after this, and I'm gonna talk to my hairdresser about it too, but I'm like, is there. Is there a solution to this or is this just aging?
A
There must be. There must be. I would assume so, because this is something that a lot of women are doing. So there has to be a product, a solution, a treatment.
B
I feel like you're. You're lucky as a natural blonde. Your. Your whites and your grays are going to be easier to mask.
A
Natural blonde is generous at this point, but my mom's hair is, like, she says it's not really gray. It just kind of gets, like, dishwater. Ish. Which is basically the color of my hair naturally at this point, so which I love a, like, silver gray hair moment. Even, like an ashy gray, I think looks really nice. But we'll see. I haven't really found a True gray hair yet. But Jake is going very salt and pepper, which of course he looks incredible. Of course, of course. And has no interest in doing anything about it. But I just go deeper, deeper into dishwash water.
B
But yeah, if any listeners have the solution for this, please let me know.
C
What.
B
What is your vain, petty low.
A
So you may see here this mark on my neck. It's like this quarter sized red mark on my neck in the very middle of the front of my neck list.
B
It looks like a weird hickey.
A
Yes, it does. Not ideal. So I woke up one morning in Charleston towards the beginning of our trip. And I saw it and I kind of thought it was just, you know, when you sleep, you kind of wake up. You have red marks. I'm very fair and prone to redness. So I was like, whatever. Then I went about my day and it stayed. And it stayed. I woke up the next morning, it was there. It was still there. And then I had a really similar mark on my leg, which was weird, like on my knee area. And I couldn't figure it out. And then I realized what it was and it was that I had been drinking a Diet Coke with lime. That's what it was in the sun. And I remember this thing because my mom had it once. Yes. I got a Lyme burn or a margarita burn. And I guess I had touched my neck and I touched my leg and I was in the sun. And so now I have this chemical burn on my neck which truly does look like a hickey on the front of my neck. Which. Great. And it's really hard to cover with makeup. I have to wear sunscreen on it every day because apparently it can become darker. I've had this for two weeks now. Apparently it can last even longer than that. And then it can just develop into a dark spot. I'm like, can I just catch a break here? I don't need it could be anywhere else. It is truly dead center front of my neck, like middle where everyone can see it. It's just I feels, whatever, it's fine, who cares? But I don't like the idea it'll be there forever.
B
I feel like it will heal. I feel like that is the outside case that it, you know, is there forever. But, you know, I think you could really make up a story to go with it. You could tell people that you were visited by a vampire. You could tell people it was Edward Cullen. You could make it so weird for other people that they want you to stop. And I'm asking.
A
I could. I probably won't okay.
B
Well, I'm just saying that option is available to you.
A
It is available. It does really look like a hickey, though. And it's, like, this weird shape, too. I don't know. It's.
B
It doesn't look like a hickey because that would be a very weird location for a hickey.
A
It would have to be, like a vampire style. Like, you're laying there, and the other person, like, goes above you and to
B
the side, feeds from you.
A
They're eating a corn of cobalt.
B
Yeah.
A
Corn of cob. Cob of corn.
B
Oh, I didn't even. I didn't even get that. Like, that. You messed that up. To my mind, I was just like, huh. Huh?
A
Corn of cob does sound kind of right.
B
It does.
A
It is not. Anyway, so, yeah, that is my vein. If anyone has any ideas of that, there are any dermatologists in the house. I already have an appointment at the end of May, so I'm like, if it's still there the end of May, I'm going to be like, laser it off. Do something. But let's hope it's not.
B
Well, hopefully it's not, but we can work on your backstory if it.
A
If it does persist, we'll develop a narrative.
B
Yeah. Yep. Well, let's take an ad break, and let's get into these interviews.
A
Today's episode is sponsored by Cozy Earth. This year is flying, and I can hardly believe that Mother's Day is already coming up on May 10th. Maybe you're shopping for a mom in your life, or maybe you're being shopped for and you want to drop some crafty hints about a gift you'd like to receive. And I can think of no better gift than something from Cozy Earth that helps you or the mom in your life unwind.
B
So my first idea here is the Cozy Earth puffy sheep slippers. So I asked for these for Christmas, and it was such a great move. They truly feel like putting a cloud on your feet. And I had never been a slipper person before, but we were having some heating issues in my old apartment, which prompted this gift. And now I can't imagine my life without them. And the best part of a gift from Cozy Earth is that it's the kind of gift that's going to get used every single day.
A
Another great option is to consider one of their robes. And there are quite a few to choose from with Cozy Earth that are plush and quilted and waffle, just like my favorite Cozy Earth towels.
D
Or.
A
Or they have a stretch knit. There's really something for everyone and a gift from Cozy Earth is risk free with their 100 night sleep trial and 10 year warranty.
B
Let this Mother's Day be a reminder that she deserves care too. Discover how Cozy Earth turns everyday routines into moments of softness and ease. Head to cozyearth.com and use our code BOP for an exclusive 20% off. And if you see a post purchase survey, be sure to mention that you heard about Cozy Earth right here on Badon paper. Because home starts with Mom. For one of Shay's guests, we have Emily Sommer, who is the book buyer at East City bookshop in Washington, D.C. she loves literary fiction. The more devastating, the better. All manners of memoir, especially celebrity memoir and psychological thrillers. She's a native South Carolinian who has lived on Capitol Hill since 2005 and joined East City Bookshop just before it opened 10 years ago. Welcome.
D
Thank you so much for having me. Good morning.
B
Well, one of the key reasons I wanted to have you on for this episode is that you were the first person to put the Correspondent on my radar last year, probably in May or June. And then it went on to become this huge word of mouth success, which I feel like you kind of predicted when you told me about it. You were saying that it was one of those books that somebody buys in the store and then tells four people about.
D
So it felt very much like a word of mouth, under the radar success that just grew and grew.
B
Well, so now I'm curious if you can do it again. So what are you seeing right now in the store? Like, what are customers gravitating towards? What are you seeing work in the store that maybe isn't represented right now on the New York Times bestseller list yet?
D
Well, I will say, first off, the Correspondent continues to to sell. And just when we think like, surely everyone has purchased it and everyone has bought it and read it, that is not the case. And I have to remind my coworkers, you know, that things that seem obvious to us that have been, you know, for months are people are still discovering it. So the Correspondent is still selling like crazy for us. The Wedding People by Alison Ethbock is still moving and growing. And I'll see, you know, one week I'll think, oh, maybe it's finally slipped. And no, it is still selling like crazy. Oh, Heart the Lover by Lilly King continues to grow and grow and grow. And for me, that tells me that what people want are very well written stories that are very human and that are about our connection with each other. And I'm trying To think what newer ones this year are starting to pop out in that way. It's still a little bit early. Kin by Tayari Jones is doing very well and continues to grow. That one was very highly anticipated, certainly not under the radar at all because everybody loved An American Marriage so much and was so eager for her return. But I'm seeing that one steadily build. And I actually, I don't keep up with what is on the New York Times bestseller list to know how much it differs from our own. I look at the indie bestsellers list and I look at what's selling in the store, and I don't entirely know how that is different from the national lists. I will say that I know that the celebrity memoirs that I like aren't necessarily the celebrity memoirs that are on the New York Times bestseller list. So there are certainly things that'll pop and will sell millions of copies that we don't move at all.
B
So it looks like this week, look at hardcover fiction. The Abby Jimenez is number one.
D
Yes.
B
And then the Judge Stone, the Viola Davis and James Patterson is number two. And then the Correspondent is number three.
D
So the Correspondent's still up there for everybody. That's great. We have sold the Viola Davis. That's not one of our top sellers, but that one has sold for us. And we do a lot of romance sales. So we have also sold the Abby Jimenez. So that is no, that is no surprise. But that is very. That is very helpful to know.
A
Are you noticing any categories that used to be the thing or like the hottest section books of the store start to wane at all or shift?
D
I'll be interested to hear what your expert about Romanecy says, because I have seen a little bit of a drop in Romanecy sales in our store where we're not selling 4th Wing and Sarah J. Maas as much as we were a few months ago or at the end of last year. And we're not seeing new franchises rise up to take their place, I think, in the way that some publishers hoped that they would. So I would say that is waning slightly, but it's still, it is still a presence in the store in a way that it was not three years ago. So even a dip, it's still there. Becca mentioned in my bio that I like really dark, gritty psychological thrillers. I will say this might be a representation of where we are in dc, where everybody really wants an escape from heavy things. I am seeing more cozier mysteries or more pleasant mysteries, even if they're not cozy by genre. Something more like, along the lines of a Richard Osmond do better than something really, really dark and gritty. And I think that's just a function of. At least in our store, people want something to take them out of the news and how heavy things seem already.
B
Yeah, I can definitely see that. I feel that in my own taste, like, I can't handle sad the way I maybe once could. I was never one for scary, but in terms of, like, dark or sad,
D
I go either way. Sometimes I'm like, I want the darker. I feel things feel bad enough, take me somewhere even darker so I can exercise it on the page and feel catharsis. But there have been a couple of times over the last year and a half or so where I've thought, you know what, that might be too much, even for me. And that's when we know in the store that things are really bad. Because if it's too. If. If I can't even read sad, then everybody needs an escape.
B
Well, let's talk about the book buying side. So in a crowded landscape, before a book even comes out, before you have, you know, real reader input, you have potentially early reader input from ARC readers. But what inputs are you using to decide whether or not to stock a book in the first place? And, like, what signals are you looking at to say, I think this book is going to be big?
D
That is a great question. And that is what everybody always wants to know about book buying. And I always say I heard this somewhere and I wish I could remember where so I could attribute it correctly. People in the book biz say that the buying is both an art and a science, and the art side of it is just sort of instinct and gut feeling. The science of it is that luckily we live in an age of data. And so I can look at numbers and I can look at sales figures, and I can see how similar titles have performed in our store. I am better at the art than I am at the science. I am better at the gut feeling of, you know, the correspondence, going to. People are going to love this. Than I am about the numbers, although, thankfully, I have the numbers at my fingertips. So I can check one thing that I look at. This has changed over the last 10 years of being a buyer because it was not something that was on my radar when I started. I pay a lot of attention to the editor.
A
Oh, okay.
D
So I know whose list I really like. And I know if certain editors edit it, either it's going to be one of my personal favorites or it's going to be Something that is very tailored to our store. The head of Little Brown, Olivia's House, Sally Kim is one of those tastemakers for me. Like, if Sally Kim has her fingerprints on it and. Or Sally tells me that I like it, I know that that's true. But there are lots of editors like that. I know last year we talked about Karina Giterman, who had so many good hits last year. And there are a lot of editors. So that's one thing that I look at. I think, oh, if Sarah McGrath at Riverhead edited this, it's going to be an Emily favorite and it's going to be really, really good. She's Liz Moore's editor, She's Miranda July's editor. All kinds of wonderful stuff. Emma Straub, maybe. So I look a lot at the editor.
B
Is there a way for consumers to look at that data?
D
I don't know if there is a way before the book is published. The best way after a book is published is to look at the acknowledgments.
B
Right.
D
Because.
C
Right.
B
But there's no database. Like it's not on.
D
Not that I know of. I see it in through our. The publisher and Bookseller interface, Edelweiss. But that is not a consumer facing.
A
You can see it in announcements. I pay attention to it in announcements. But that's. You really have to be, I think, kind of deep in the.
D
Right.
A
Right.
D
Like if you're in the publisher's weekly news. Yeah.
B
You also have to hold on to that information for a while.
D
Right.
B
Usually those are being announced a year
D
or two before, so far in advance. So for the other things that I look at when I'm buying, I mean, I look at the author's track record, I look at sales of similar titles. I do look at blurbs. So I look at which fellow authors have already blurbed the book. I know there is some controversy about that because people debate the utility of blurbs. For me, it's useful in that it tells me where the publisher is positioning that book. So I know based on who they are getting to stand behind the book that those are similar readers. And so I know, okay, this is supposed to appeal to fellow readers, people who like, you know, Becca Freeman, Laura Hankin, Emily Henry, et cetera. So that's helpful to me. And I look at the print runs too, because that tells me I don't want to have just the things that have enormous print runs. I want, especially in an independent store, I want people to be able to find hidden gems and smaller things. But I do know that if something has an enormous print run, that that means that the publisher is backing it and I should have it represented in the store because somebody's gonna hear about it and they're gonna come in and look for it.
B
I have a follow up question to this. How much does the science part of it matter? Like, can you take a wait and see approach? Obviously you miss out on those sales of somebody coming into the store looking for something that doesn't wanna wait to order it. But how fast do books come to you if you all of a sudden say, oh my gosh, we did not go deep enough on the Viola Davis book and we've miscalculated.
D
We are lucky because where we are on the East Coast, I can get things usually the next day or in two days.
B
Oh, wow, okay.
D
I still try to. I buy seasonally, so I do buy in advance. I am hopeful that I'm not trying to chase a title. So I try to err on the side of having what we need. But in a pinch, I can usually get things really fast. That is not the case for every bookstore across the country because depending on how close they are to a publisher or a distribution warehouse, it can take some stores a lot longer than others. We get a lot of our books from Westminster, Maryland or Chambersburg, Pennsylvania. And so everything's within like a day transit. So I'm lucky. I can sort of wait and see if I have to. And I do reorder books every single day. So every morning I look at the books that still sold yesterday in the store and then I reorder accordingly. So when I buy my initial buys, I'm usually looking to see what can carry me through the first. Just the first few weeks. And we're lucky enough too that we've been around long enough now that we have a little bit of space in the store for storage and we have enough cash flow that I can kind of go. Go a little bit bigger to protect ourselves in that way. Because I don't want to lose the sale because you lose too many sales and then you lose a customer. I want to err on the side of having too many, but in a pinch I can, I can fill in unless the publisher has not printed enough. And that's the heated rivalry of it all that. The heated rivalry of it all. Goodness. Now, the good thing was that all bookstores were pretty much in the same boat, so we were all chasing those titles. But yeah, that was tricky. We could not get those in fast enough.
A
Well, looking forward to the rest of the year. We obviously both love your taste. I'd love to know what are even three books that you're excited about this year.
D
This is one I was preparing this question in the shower. I was like, what books? How do I narrow it down? I'm so excited and you can't see behind me, but I have like literally stacks of books to remind myself what to talk about. One that I wanted to mention because I feel like it has a very bad on paper vibe. I just feel like your listeners have such good taste.
B
A curated wreck.
D
A curated. These are curated wrecks. That's what we do in an independent bookstore. We give. These are personal wrecks. So one that I am very excited about is called Leave youe Mess at Home by Tolani Akinola. And it comes out April 14, if I'm not mistaken. So you don't have to wait very long for this one. I do not have my copy of it in the store. I wish I did. I mean in my house right now. So I wish I did because I would hold it up because it has one of the best covers of the season. But it is about a Nigerian American family in Chicago. Four siblings in their 20s and early 30s. It's a debut. It's from an editor that I love, as I mentioned earlier. Her name is Seema Mahanian. She is fantastic. She's got such great taste and her, her stuff is so fresh and interesting and it's coming out from Viking and Pamela Dorman Books. But I believe that Reese Witherspoon's hello Sunshine had some sort of publishing. I don't know if it's an incubator. They had some sort of publishing discovery process and it came up, if I'm not mistaken, through that process. And I think Tolania Canola was mentored in some capacity by Curtis Sittenfeld. Oh, but I read this book last year and it is just wonderful. It's got these great sibling dynamics. Four siblings in very different places in their lives and you see all of them in sort of different areas of their coming of age. It's funny. It's got great music, it's got great food, and it made me cry. It's just wonderful. So I think that it's one that, when people find it, I think it's one that people will want to recommend to their friends.
B
This one's been lingering on my list for months. So you've finally given me the shove to bump it up. I've heard Blue Sisters comps to it.
D
Yes, that's a good comp. Yes, That's a good comp.
A
That's one of my favorites.
D
I actually haven't read that one, which it feels like a miss on my part because it's so in my wheelhouse. I love a sibling story, I think, because I'm an only child and I just haven't gotten to it yet. Sometimes things get so big that they don't need me to sell them, and then they're so big that I miss them. So. Blue Sisters still on my list, but I think that's a great. I think that's a great comp and will appeal to the same readers. Another one that is coming out and this is an Olivia wreck. This is one that I feel like would be in your wheelhouse, Olivia, because I think you like kind of the mystery, like suspense, like I do. I don't know if it's on your radar yet. It's called Five by Ilona Bannister. Have you heard of this one?
A
No, I haven't.
D
It's coming from Crown in May. It's a one sitting read. Like people say that this is truly like. I read it in one sitting at a coffee shop. I read it because I was under deadline. I had told the editor that I would read it, but it was like the biggest pleasure of the big. It was such a joy to read it. It's five people on a London tube platform. You know that one of them is about to meet a terrible end. You've got literally just a few minutes and it's in real time. You're finding out what's happening with all these people, who's going to die, what's going on. It's wild, but it's excellent and very smart. There's a lot. It's propulsive and a page turner, but there's like, there's so much substance going on in the story that she's telling about each of these characters. So Five by Ilona Bannister, coming in May, I think is another really good one for somebody who likes suspense.
A
That sounds great.
B
Thank you. I hear the click clacking in the background of Olivia.
A
Like, sorry. Yeah, my.
B
Wow. Finding the book like your recommendation hit home.
D
And now I'm trying to think, where do I go with only one more? Oh, there's so many. Okay. I just finished the new Patrick Radden Keefe book, which comes out tomorrow, called London Falling. So this is my nonfiction wreck. He wrote say Nothing, Empire of Pain, the king of narrative nonfiction. That reads like a novel. I mean, just the smartest person in the room, probably. I feel Like I would read anything that he writes, but London Falling, about the death of a London teenager in 2019. He falls or jumps off of a building into the Thames. And as Patrick Raden Keefe investigates that death, he also looks at how London has changed in the last 25 years. How Finance has changed it, how the presence of Russian oligarchs has changed it, the kind of organized crime that might be happening there and what our children might be up to that we as parents have no idea about.
A
So that sounds good too.
D
That one does not need me to sell it. He will sell a gazillion copies because he is Patrick Ryden Keefe. But it is as good as everybody anticipated it would be. Now I'm looking at all the things that are right in front of me that I haven't even mentioned.
B
There's so many. Well, I have a twist on that question that will give you an opportunity to potentially recommend more books.
D
Okay.
B
So I know you are also, as I am very passionate about, Book of the Year, Book of the Summer discourse.
D
Yes.
B
Apparently the only thing we cannot bet on on polymarket, or maybe it is on there, who knows? But if you were putting your chips on like two books making it big this year, where. Where are you putting them
D
in terms of like commercial sales or award winning ness?
B
I would say commercial sales.
D
Okay, commercial sales.
B
But not like the hyper obvious like Sarah J. Maas, A Court of Thorns and Roses 6. Because that will obviously probably be the answer. But that's not very interesting if you haven't read the first five.
D
Okay. It's right in front of me and I'm gonna go with it. I think that Chloe Benjamin's book Understory is gonna do really well, and I have not read it yet. She wrote the Immortalists.
A
I read an arc.
D
Have you read it already? Did you. Did you love it?
A
It's a lot. It's intense.
D
I love intent.
A
Yeah. To me, I comped it sort of to like a weird love child of Wild Dark Shore and Project Hail Mary, but with more songs.
D
Oh, okay.
A
So, like, I can see it really hitting, but it isn't. It is intense.
D
So the reason that one just jumped out at me is because last week I saw both Stephen Rowley, who wrote the Gunkle and the Celebrants. I saw Steve talking about it and I saw Anne Napolitano talking about it, and I feel like I saw one other person. Like, it felt like it has authors from different spheres coalescing around it. I think there's a lot of reader interest in it because I think people loved the Immortalists. And so that's my answer. And I could keep going with lots of other. I think Jenny Jackson's book is going to do really well. I think that'll be a great summer seller. Emma Straub that comes out tomorrow is so fun. American Fantasy, absolutely delightful. And then there are so many literary, like very literary heavy hitters that have books coming out this year that if there's one 2026 trend, it would be every great author has a new book this year and we don't have time to read them all. So I don't know. There are lots of possible options, but the Chloe Benjamin is just jumping, jumping out at me right now.
A
Okay. Yeah. Okay. Good pick.
B
So if people would like to keep up with more of your recommendations, where can they find you on the Internet or in person if they want more?
D
You can find me in person at East City Bookshop on Capitol hill in Washington D.C. you can find me on Instagram at emilygsommer. But be warned, I do post a lot about books, but I also post my children and lots of concerts. So. So it is not a Bookstagram account. You might get more than you bargained for, but you can find me in both of those places.
A
Thank you so much. Let's take another ad break.
B
This episode is sponsored by Ritual. You know, we love a good routine here and one that we've both been working on making a habit is our vitamin routines. So for me, moving recently was a huge time of upheaval. But I felt like I had a of lot, a little peace of mind knowing that I was hitting my nutrient goals even as cooking for myself kind of went out the window for a little bit there. Ritual's team of scientists poured over thousands of studies to identify common gaps between nutritional needs and what people are actually consuming across different life stages to build a vitamin that supports foundational health.
A
I take my essential for women 18 plus multivitamin basically anytime I can remember throughout the day. And I keep it in the same cabinet that I keep my water cup. So whenever I'm going to get a cup of water, I see my little pill case and I take my vitamins. And this is great for me because I am low on vitamin D. And the essential for women 18 includes a healthy dose of vitamin D, which is helpful. Their university led clinical trial showed that these vitamins increased vitamin D levels by 43% and omega 3 DHA levels by 41% in just 12 weeks. And it's not just vitamin D. Rituals essential for women 18 contains nine key nutrients and two delayed release capsules designed for optimal absorption while still being gentle on your stomach.
B
Instead of striving for perfect health, aim for supporting foundational health. You can save 25% off on your first month of ritual@ritual.com batonpaper that's ritual.com batonpaper for 25% off your first month
A
this episode is sponsored by Caraway Home. Lately, all I think about is kitchens, kitchens, kitchens. I spend a lot of time just standing in there staring at things in preparation for our upcoming renovation. Honestly, I also spend a lot of time throwing things out and grabbing things to donate that just don't work for me or the space anymore. But one kitchen item that is sticking around, let me tell you. It is my Caraway Cook cookware set. I have used these pots and pans for pretty much at least one or two meals a day for more than five years now. I do have to say though that I have been slacking a little bit when it comes to cooking dinner every night because of being on book tour and traveling. And now that I am home and settling back into a routine, Caraway makes it so easy for me to want to get back to those habits that make me feel my best. And one of those is definitely cooking cooking meals for myself every night. I also really love their food storage sets, which I promise you are so much more substantial and just more beautiful than whatever you're using right now. They make my very boring, very basic fridge seem very elevated right now. You can save up to $230 on the 12 piece cookware set versus buying the products individually and you can find even more set savings when you shop Caraway's full kitchenware collection. Visit Carawayhome.com BoP to take an additional 10% off your next purchase. This deal is exclusive for our listeners, so visit carawayhome.com BOP or use code BOP at checkout.
B
We are so excited to have Alyssa Morris back with us. She's an agent with Trellis Literary Management representing romance and romantasy authors, which is new since the last time we talked to her in 2025. So we'll get and she also writes the Romancing the Phone newsletter where she covers Booktok trends. Melissa, welcome back.
C
Thank you so much for having me again. Delighted to be here.
B
Well, I was just telling you before we started recording that I've loved some of the pieces that you've been putting together about the direction that the romance genre is headed in and kind of what's in and what's out with readers. So I was thinking we could talk about some of that and more today. But before we get into trend, since we last talked to you, which I think was 2025, you've moved into agenting. So first of all, congratulations. But can you tell us a little bit about making that leap?
C
Sure. Thank you so much. It's interesting. It's like I was on a path my whole life that was sort of leading here, but never totally made sense until it happened, if that makes sense. I mean, I started my career in book publishing in New York. I was an editorial intern at Berkeley. Right out of college I went and I worked at Amazon on the physical books marketing team for a coup of years. But I moved to Austin in 2015 and sort of thought that my time in publishing was over just because of the way the publishing world works and how centralized it is. And I actually ended up post2020 meeting some people in Austin. Allison Hunter, who's one of the partners at Trellis, we became very good friends, and we would talk about books all the time. And with the way the romance industry has shifted, at a certain point, she was like, this is your moment to come back to romance. We're missing a voice like yours that's really connected to the readers. So I started scouting for her initially, and then it went so well. She brought me in as a full agent at Trellis, and it's been wonderful. Everyone at Trellis is amazing and so supportive, and my first internship in college was for a literary agent. So it does feel extremely full circle for me.
B
Well, it feels so natural. I can think of very few people who know more about the romance genre than you do.
C
That's so kind. Thank you.
A
So as someone who is sort of a triple threat agent newsletter writer who covers reading book trends, and then also an avid reader yourself, I feel like you probably have one of the best perspectives on the romance genre and the industry. So what are you seeing really pop up right now when it comes to romance?
C
Well, I think we've gotten to a point where romance has just exploded in at least visible popularity since 2020. Romance as a genre has always been popular, but it's really sort of taken over the conversation in the past five or six years. And I think because of that, things have gotten a little bit stagnant. Right. Like, we have romantasy. Are we tired of fairies? What's different on that side of things on the contemporary romance side? Like, what can we do that doesn't just feel like trying to recapture the Emily Henry magic Right. And so I think when I talk to readers, when I look at readers online, there's this sense of, like, dissatisfaction or this desire for something new. I feel like we're in a moment again. Like the moment we were in right before Fourth Wing sort of exploded onto the scene with very few precursors, where at that moment I could not have predicted that a Dragon Academy romance novel would be the book that took over the world. But it did feel like we were due for something like that. And so I just have this feeling that, like, something none of us are expecting is going to be a huge hit in the next couple of years. So take everything I say about trends with a grain of salt, because I do think what is going to happen next is going to be unpredictable. But I think in general, readers are looking for something that feels really different. And the thing that I see crop up over and over again on booktok is people want yearning. And I feel like the word yearning has become a stand in for a lot of things that people are missing in their romance novels. There's been such a swing towards high heat, high spice. People want to focus maybe again on, like, the Mr. Darcy hand flex of it all. And I think there's also the yearning can be an issue with point of view. Right. Like a lot of romance novels are currently in first person. And when people are going back to, say, historical romances from the late 90s, early 2000s, and rediscovering the yearning in those books and the big feelings, part of the difference is they're dual third person pov. And so what does that POV shift change in the romance novels you're reading and the way you're feeling about them?
B
So wait, are you saying you think a third person POV is yearnier?
C
I mean, I think it can be interesting.
B
I would have said, because the first person you're in somebody's head, you feel closer to the yearning. But maybe I need to. I'm not well versed in the late 90s, early 2000s romance, so maybe I have to check one out.
C
I think sometimes when you have 100% access to someone's thoughts, it's too easy.
B
Interesting. Okay, so when you talk about yearning, what books in the current marketplace or that are forthcoming this year do you think best representation the yearning trend?
C
That's a great question, because I'm not sure if I can point to any. I think what's interesting about this desire for yearning is that it's like a pervasive desire that I don't see people coalescing around, like, one book or even a set of books in particular. And this is why I feel like there is a reader desire that has not quite been met by what is currently out there. I'm not totally sure how to think about what's going to come out of that trend. But the other thing I think it ties into, if you think about heated rivalry, there is a lot of yearning and heated rivalry, and it is high spice, which is an interesting combination. But it's like it takes place over a span of years. There's so much angst. You're going through, like, an emotional crucible with these characters. And I think that that's something that readers are looking for.
B
Yeah. Yeah. Well, talk to us on the flip side. So I was so fascinated by a newsletter that you wrote recently talking about what readers are saying that they're over, which doesn't necessarily totally map to book sales. Can you talk to us a little bit about that? Like, what's out?
C
I personally and other people I have talked to are tired of romances where the hero or heroine is a writer. I think we've had a ton of those in recent years, and I think people are ready for something new. What I am looking for is, like, people who are good at their jobs, but their jobs are not email jobs. I think we have a real lack of that right now. And people really want competence porn. At least that's what I want. And when I talk to people, that's something they're looking for, too. I think a book that's coming out this summer that might fit into that neatly is the Chelsea Curto Stormy Weather, which is about rival meteorologists and storm chasers. So it's sort of like twisters if it was a romance novel. And I think we'll see a lot of interesting trends and how those are playing with people when that book comes out. But I'm very excited to read that one. The other thing I think people are looking for a lot of, and maybe they're not describing it this way, is genre mashups. I think when, like, sub genres have started to feel stale for people, the way that writers can make them feel different is by mashing two of them together. And so I think we might start seeing, like, paranormal sports romance, or we're seeing like, Small Town with Witches or things that are sort of like maximum tropey because you're putting two sub genres together.
B
That's interesting. Is there anything out in the marketplace that represents that? Or you think this is, like, on the horizon?
C
I think it's on the horizon. I think there are things bubbling. I think the interesting thing about the market right now and trends is that on the romance side, trends are coming from indie published books and fanfiction first because those markets can move so much more quickly than traditional publishing. So like the things that are sort of bubbling will come out first in indie books and those will blow up and then those will get picked up by traditional publishers and they will get to them more slowly. I do think it's harder for traditional publishers to be the ones breaking out trends in romance right now because they can't compete with the speed of indie publishing.
B
Well, that's another thing that I wanted to talk to you about is that I feel like I see so many people talking about traditional publishers being risk averse and picking up successful self published books and then repackaging them or fan fiction. So, you know, things like Alchemized from last year, which was such a huge sensation, was originally fanfiction.
C
I mean I have many I can share. They just announced today the adaptation of all the Young dudes, which is now called Wolf Boy was picked up by Del Rey. The same poet publisher is Alchemized.
B
But this isn't necessarily new. Like if I think back to like the Spanish Love Deception by Elena Armas, like Magnolia Parks, like this has been happening for a really long time. Is it picking up or are readers just more wise to this now?
C
That's a really interesting question. I think it's both. I think that they are doing this more often as there's been a proven track record of success. I mean it goes back even farther than that if you think about 50 shades of gray.
D
Really?
B
Oh yeah.
C
Like, and you know, this is sort of the second wave of indie books getting picked up by traditional publishers. There was a big wave of it in like 2012, 2013. But I do think we also just have a savvier online audience who is now constantly paying attention to what their favorite authors are doing. Indie authors have these established fan bases now. They're going to want to buy the indie edition if they know it's going away and then buy the traditional version of a book. There's just like a much more intense fan culture that I do think is focused on like every little thing that is happening. And so it is much more visible when these transitions are happening.
B
Yeah, I feel like I'm seeing so much of it on threads. Like I feel like, you know, maybe 2020, 2021 was so much about book talk and now you know, well, I'm curious to hear what you think about booktok's level of impact and relevance right now. But I do feel like now book threads, especially from the publishing business side, you know, has kind of like picked up and is a hotspot.
C
Yeah, I mean I deleted threads off my phone because the level of TikTok just was not for me. I do think TikTok is interesting right now because I think the algorithm is kind of broken. I think it is not as good as it was even six months ago. And like mine is very dialed to only serve me book content because like my TikTok is my job, right. And like if it serves me anything that is not book content, I immediately swipe away. I'm always doing searches to like keep my algorithm dialed to the kinds of content I want to see. And yesterday I got served like five or six not related to anything I'm interested in, books or otherwise TikToks and I was like, this disturbs me. So I do think that the relevance, if they can no longer like serve people the content they're interested in and be a platform for discovering new books to read, people are going to have to go to other platforms to find the new books that they're reading.
A
Do you think readers are spending much time on book threads or do you think it's really like an industry gossip?
C
It feels very author centric to me, but again, it's hard for me to tell because what my algorithm was giving me was like very industry specific and like writer focused conversations. But when I'm going to look for what readers are looking to read next or like what's going viral on that side of things, threads is not typically where I'm finding it off of booktok. It's more like Reddit.
B
I think that's interesting. I have not explored the book Reddit universe.
C
There is a huge romance reader community on Reddit. It's fascinating, it's incredible. And they're reading like slightly different books, I would say than booktok. So there's an interesting sub community over there of things that are trending. What they're looking for, what is interesting for them to read.
B
How would you classify the book talk reader versus the book Reddit reader?
C
That's a really interesting question. I think booktok is more mainstream. Reddit is people who are looking for something that feels more different, especially on the romantasy side. I think that they're really seeking out maybe like romantasy with a higher percentage of fantasy does pretty well on Reddit but also just again things that Feel different. Like some romanticies with older heroines have really blown up on Reddit.
A
Yeah. I was going to ask you if there's an example of a book that you think that's a Reddit book versus a Booktok book.
C
There's a romantasy called Priestess that I think has gotten picked up by a traditional publisher and is coming out traditionally published. That is one of the ones I found on Reddit before anywhere else. I also, I represent an author named Kira Percy who writes indie published billionaire romance that are actually like very zany, very funny rom coms. And her books were voted like, the number one and three favorite books of Reddit in 2024. And I saw them a lot on Twitter. I have not seen them as much on booktok.
B
Interesting. Well, what about going to the publishing side of things? So now in your role as an agent, you're earlier in the pipeline, so you're actually talking to editors about what they're looking for and, you know, kind of scouting the books that might inform publishing trends in 2027 and beyond. So when you are having these conversations or when you're looking for author, represent, like, outside of yearning and interesting jobs, like, what are you hearing from editors about what they're looking for?
C
Yeah. So on the romantasy side, both with readers and with editors, there's this real desire for standalone romantasy because I think there's series fatigue. Readers don't want to sign their lives away for the next five years waiting for a series to finish when they've already committed to, like, maybe, you know, 10, 15, 20 series.
B
I feel this like, I'm like, I can't. My dance card is full. I'm already in the midst of too many, like, I cannot commit to anymore.
C
Yeah. And so I think readers and editors are really in lockstep on this one where, like, the romantasy market has gotten more competitive and harder over the past few years because there's just been such a flood of it. And I think the standalone thing is really going to play a big part in the next couple of years. We've also seen it, like, duologies have gotten more popular as we've seen the genre grow. This just got announced today, so I can tell you about it. I just sold a standalone romantasy that started indie that's been a viral sensation since the end of the year called the Poison Daughter. And it's coming out in hardcover now in August with Slow Burn and Sandow. But I think that book, it's like, incredibly long. But, you know, exactly how long you're committing to this story for, and then it's done. And I think that's been a big reason why it's been so appealing.
B
I love the sound of this trend because I feel like the best time to read a series is when it's already out, because otherwise I forget too much in between. I'm reading too much and then, you know, I go back to a book and I'm like, who are you? What's this world like? I would rather just do it all in one, even if it's very long.
C
And I don't want to have to go watch one of those like, YouTube recap videos before I read the second book in a series. I don't have an hour to watch someone recap what happened in the book. Even. I've been suggesting to people that we need like a previously on where the first three pages of the second book in a series or something is a summary of what happened before. Because I would rather hear about it from the author than some random influencer on BookTok or YouTube. I second that, but I just think that there's a lot of problems with the series model right now because of that.
A
It's also for people like me who don't really consider themselves fantasy readers but are open to reading fantasy. I'm open to reading a standalone. But to me, part of the reason why I Never continue with 4th Wing or any of the Things is because it's just like I'm not that committed. I'm committed enough to really dive in and enjoy it for one book, but not beyond that. So I like the idea of a standalone, long romantasy fantasy book I can get on board with for sure.
C
I definitely think we're going to see more of those.
B
What about on the contemporary side? There's been this conversation of contemporary romance is dead or dying, or that it's so hard to break into. Like, what are editors excited about? On the contemporary romance side, it feels to me like maybe there's an appetite for something that's slightly more literary, but I don't know if this is just my own tastes that I'm extrapolating against and calling a trend.
C
I think it's just anything that feels different, honestly. I think we've seen this big wave of speculative contemporary romance, and that's been sort of an attempt to make things feel different. I just finished One and Only by Maureen Goo, which I absolutely loved. I thought that was like the perfect amount of speculative, just like a little bit.
B
I also loved that she was a 40 year old protagonist that felt really different. She had her shit together. And I really loved the way that Maurene Goo integrated fashion and food and interiors in a way that felt like very grown up. It felt like a daily life experience. It was really lush. Yeah.
C
Yeah. And I've been telling people this lately. Like I love a book with an older heroine and I like it when she is still extremely sexy and cool. My pet peeve is when you're reading a romance with an older heroine and it's all like, my joints hurt. It's hard being 40 or whatever. That's not fun to me.
B
That's not interesting. I only wear sad pants and like woe is me. Here are my 10 cats.
A
Yes.
C
My friend Lila Sayles has a book coming out from 831 stories in the fall that is a rock star romance about a 40 year old rock star. And it was so refreshing to read about a like sexy older adult woman who is still incredibly cool.
B
Oh, that sounds very fun.
C
It's fabulous.
B
So if you had to bet big on two books that have either recently come out or are coming out in 2026, what would your bets be?
C
I mean, everyone who has talked to me recently knows, including you, that I'm obsessed with games, which is coming out in June. It was Dark Lina fan fiction. It has been picked up by Avon to be, you know, turned into a standalone contemporary romance. The comps are normal people and 50 shades of gray, both of which I think are incredibly earned. And it's a really fascinating mashup of trends and style that truly could not have been written by anyone else and stands on its own. There are on page debates about Marxism and economic policy. The sex is incredibly sexual, sexy. I just found it to be very refreshing and kind of like one and only. Like the city of New York is a character. The setting details are really glamorous and escapist in that way. Sort of like we've had this trend of what I would call like beach house romance from Carly Fortune and people like that where the setting is a character. And I think moving those kind of books into more urban settings is a really interesting twist on that previous trend that feels a little bit different.
B
I will be so curious to see how this book does. I really enjoyed it. However, I did have the feeling that I have when I watch industry where I do not actually know what anyone is talking about and if I agree or disagree with them, like the economic theory in this was so dense that and you know, they were talking about specific historical economic Schools of thought or thinkers. And I was like, I'm just gonna
A
trust you on this.
B
Like, not really sure what's happening.
C
This is kind of what I'm talking about, about people being good at their jobs. Like, I don't need to know if this is, like, right or not necessarily. But I believed that they were smart and good at their job.
B
Absolutely. I was convinced. Okay, what would you say for your second?
C
I'm not sure I have a second specific book, but the other trend that I just feel is coming and that we've seen a lot of deals come through for these books that are just starting to come out is vampires. I think vampires is going to be back in a big way. And I don't know whose vampire book it's going to be, but they're all over the place.
B
I did just download an advanced copy of Die for Me, which comes out this summer, and I downloaded it not realizing that it was a vampire book. So I feel like, yeah, I definitely am seeing this surge of vampires. There's like, the My Italian Vampire, which is Betty Corleo's book that she wrote under a pen name. Like, am I right?
C
Elena Armis's next book is a vampire book.
B
Oh, I didn't know that.
C
Yeah.
B
Interesting.
C
Okay.
A
Vampires stuck around, doesn't it?
B
Olivia, we were just talking about. Olivia has a weird mark on her neck. And I was like, you should tell people it's a vampire bite.
A
Well, on trend, can you tell people again where to find you and your newsletter on the Internet? And also if you are open to queries as an agent.
C
So you can find me at romancingthephone.substack.com and I am not open to queries.
B
So she'll find you.
C
I'll find you.
B
Yeah. But definitely sign up for her newsletter. I think it's one of the best outlets for discussions on romance. So if you enjoyed this conversation, you're going to really enjoy Alyssa's newsletter. Let's take one last ad break. This episode is sponsored by Wayfair. With my recent move, I have been spending a ton of time on Wayfair recently. And in fact, I just got a set of caned back dining chairs delivered yesterday and I could not believe how fast they came with their free shipping. I ordered them on a Monday, they arrived on Wednesday. And if you're also shopping for things for your home, you should know that it is almost way day at Wayfair. From April 25th to 27th, you can get the best deals in home. I'm talking up to 80% off with free shipping on everything.
A
We are totally redoing our powder room downstairs, and we're moving it, and it's a whole thing. And Jake and I recently sat down and we went on Wayfair and we looked for the floor tile for this space because I had a very specific vision. I wanted a beautiful marble tile that looked like it had been there a hundred years ago. And in a hundred years, it would look good as well. And I found the perfect thing that was also incredibly affordable. And I used Wayfair's incredible filters to do that. Wayfair's filters make it easy to find exactly what fits your style and needs, from furniture and decor to home improvement and outdoor essentials. And it's all on sale during Wayday.
B
Wayday is the sale to shop for the best deals in home. We're talking up to 80% off with fast and free shipping on everything. Head to Wayfair.com April 25th to 27th to shop Wayday. That's W A Y-F-A-I-R.com Wayfair Every style, every home. Into some obsessions. Olivia. I have an obsession that I feel like you will care about a lot. So I found a new garlic gadget. I feel like every few years I find a new one, and I'm obsessed with it for a little bit, but I think this one has staying power. So a cooking skill that I've never mastered is doing the really finely sliced garlic. And I was reading some recipe that called for sliced garlic, and the person added in that they use this little tool. So it's. I got it on Amazon. It's called the leaf height L E I F H E I T. Some German engineering there. Comfortline gourmet slicer. And it looks like a little pepper mill almost. And you just, you put heads of garlic, peeled heads of garlic in, and you just twist it like a pepper mill. And it made the most even easy slices of garlic. It was like magic. But the best part, because I feel like the thing with some of these garlic tools, like, I have, the pressure is that they. They were, like, really hard to clean. And this one was very easy to clean.
A
Good to know. I was just actually the other day making a recipe that called for thinly sliced garlic, and I almost cut my finger off.
B
So I know my knife skills, My knife skills aren't good enough to actually do it with a knife.
A
Well, you know how I feel about garlic smells so. Well, I appreciate that.
B
I'm giving this an A plus. It's like 27. So it's not the cheapest, but I don't know. I think that's not terrible for a kitchen gadget that I can use for theoretically decades to come.
A
Definitely.
B
What are you obsessed with?
A
I'm obsessed with this notes app system I have been using.
B
Tell me everything. You know, I care about a notes app system.
A
I've been using it for four months now, so I feel like it's, like, sticking around. It's not very complicated, but essentially I have a note that I pinned to the top of my notes where I have to do list broken up by month, so usually, like three months out. So right now I have an April to do list. I have a May to do list and maybe the beginning of a June. And I can see that's an example
B
of something that's on your June to do list already.
A
Mostly house stuff.
B
Okay.
A
So, you know, or like, planning stuff for coming months or book stuff or whatever. So for the April to do list, at some point, I need to call a tree guy to take down a tree, that kind of stuff. And then I'll move it to May if I need to or whatever. So I have those lists. And then every week I have a weekly to do list where it's the. The bubbles that you can check off very satisfyingly. And I just put everything I need to do for that week from, like, workouts I want to do to, you know, poshmark sales I need to send to. Just reminders about what I'm making for dinner. Everything, basically, it all goes into the list. And as I think of things throughout the week, I add it to the list. And obviously it's on my computer, it's on my phone. And so whenever I have a free moment, I go in and I check things off and I review it. And it's been working really well for me. I mean, it's basically just a to do list on my phone. I'm making it sound really a lot more systematic than it is, I guess, but it's been working.
B
I'm so happy for you.
A
Yeah, I highly suggest. And it's free, so. Great.
B
Take me over to the reading front because it looks like from our outline, you've done a lot of reading since we last talked.
A
I have been reading a lot. So I finished the Fountain by Casey Sheschka, who is another upstate author. She lives on the other side of the river from me in the Catskills. And this book is set in the Catskills, and I think Emma Straub blurbed it and Described it as Tuck Everlasting for Adults, which immediately sold.
B
If I ever heard of a book meant for you, it's that, yes, it
A
very much was that. And I loved all of the upstate stuff so much. And essentially, it's about a woman who can't die, and she goes back to her family home from hundreds of years ago to try to undo the spell. And it's kind of like a genre mashup. It's like a little literary, a little mystery, and very atmospheric and Catskillsy. And I actually saw someone post in the Facebook group about this book and how much they absolutely loved it. So I definitely suggest checking it out if you're interested in the mood for, like, an atmospheric character forward suspense novel set in the Catskills.
B
What else do you have for us next?
A
I have In Her Defense by Philippa Malika, which I picked up, I think, the same day that Grace told us that or told me that I should read this book. This is about. Gosh, it's hard to describe this without giving stuff away. I do think it is worth going in blind. But it's this story of this woman who has a famous mother and a questionable therapist.
B
Okay.
A
Who has told her to cut off contact with her mother. And it is a lot about life coaches and wellness experts, all things I'm interested in. And when they're good, when they're not. And it's all set against the A trial. So it moves very fast. The writing is great. A lot of it is set in Rome, which was wonderful. I loved this book. I read it very fast. It was great.
B
So Grace was right. She's got your number.
A
Yes. Yes. It's a surprising read. And next, another surprising read. I read this book called Whale Fall by Elizabeth o', Connor, and I went into a bookstore in Charleston. I wanted to get a paperback because I didn't want anything too bulky. I saw this book, I seen it around. I didn't really know much about it. I read the back, and it was about this woman who lives on a remote Welsh island in the, I believe, the early 1900s. And I was already done.
B
Very Olivia Coton.
A
Yeah, I was like, done, done, done, done. And then I started reading it, and I thought, oh, I think this is going to be a little too plotless for me or a little too lyrical. The formatting is really different. And then I kept reading, and I just fell completely in love with this book. And it's all about this, as I said, this woman growing up in this remote island, very, very cut off from the World doesn't know what's going on. They don't get papers for weeks and weeks after the fact. And these two researchers land on the island and sort of expose her to more of the world. It's a really understated, very subtle novel, but it's just so beautiful. The descriptions of nature are so great. I loved this book. Like, I loved it so much. I posted about it and someone replied and they said, really? When I posted that, I loved it. And they said, really? I guess because they did.
B
So not for everyone.
A
This is not for everyone. No. It's. I don't know. It's so accessible and easy to read, but it's also literary because of the structure and because of how lyrical it is. But I just loved it. I loved everything about it so much. Yeah. One of my favorites of the year, surprisingly, I think, so far. Finally, I read the Sirens by Amelia Hart, because after Whalefall I was like. More books about oceans. This is about two sisters living in Australia. So it's set against this historical fiction past timeline of a ship of female prisoners sent from England and Ireland to Australia, a penal colony. And the two timelines kind of interweave in this very magical, fantastical way that doesn't feel like fantasy. But there is something, I guess you would call it, speculative. I had never read this author before. She also wrote Wayward, which was super popular. But yeah, I really liked this. The descriptions of the ocean, there's a mermaid aspect you can imagine. And yeah, I enjoyed it. I enjoyed it. I love Australia as a setting a lot, so it was a fun one. And also the cover's gorgeous. Love what a hot streak you're on for now. I have more coming at you next week.
B
Wow.
A
Yes. What have you read?
B
I only read two books, so I read Once and Again by Rebecca Searle, which is her newest book that just came out last month. And as with all of her books, there is, like a little bit of magical realism, but it's set in the real world. And so in this one, the premise is that all of the women in this family are born with, like, a silver ticket that allows them to have one do over to, like, redo a choice in their life or rewind time in some way. And the main character of the book is struggling with infertility. Definitely a pretty heavy trigger warning there. And her husband is out of town for work for the summer and she moves back in with her parents and ends up reconnecting with her childhood first love. So it's like a love triangle between a woman, her husband and her first love. And as with all of Rebecca Searle's books, it's like very much thematically to do with fate versus free will. I enjoyed this one. I really enjoyed the setting. It's set in Malibu at a beach house and I really enjoyed that aspect of it. And I really enjoyed the thematic exploration. Like, I think she really hit hard on like, would you, should you take a do over? And kind of the ramifications of that. I think my favorite of hers is still in five years, but I did really enjoy this one.
A
Great.
B
And then in a single Saturday, I read a book that's also set on water that maybe is not quite as historical or precarious as some of your recent reading, but I read American Fantasy by Emma Straub, which comes out, I think this week. And this is about a boy band nostalgia cruise. And so it's told from three points of view. It's told from the event producer who's, you know, making it all happen. One of the members of the boy band and then this woman who's ended up on the cruise by herself somewhat by accident. And I just love anything that it's like a really rich examination of a type of niche subculture. And oh, this delivered for me so hard in terms of, you know, getting into the idiosyncrasies of being on a boy band cruise. And I had a lot of fun with this. I think this would be a great vacation read. It's like on the lighter side, it's kind of hard to classify. Like there's a little bit of a romance plot, but it's not a romance. There's a little bit of a unlikely friendship plot, but it's not a friendship story. Like more than anything, I think it's a middle aged novel.
A
Okay, this is on my Kindle and everywhere.
B
It's definitely more than a lot of water set books you've read. But if you're, if you're looking for
A
a water set, does the cruise capsize? Because that's really all I'm curious about.
B
No, the, the cruise safely. There are no disasters. All of the disasters are event planning and interpersonal. There are no.
A
I mean, it sounds good. I love, I think cruises are interesting environments for so many reasons. So I definitely am looking forward to this one whenever I get to it.
B
Well, if none of those recs struck your fancy, we also have our April book club pick, which is Good People by Patmina Sabit, which we'll be discussing on April 29th. I have not had a chance to read this one yet, but I'm very excited to. Olivia pitched it as a mystery surrounding a tragedy that befalls an Afghan American family, told from many, many different points of view. I'm assured it's very gulpable that there are very short chapters that kind of make the pages turn themselves. I'm excited. Anything to add to that pitch?
A
No, I'm. I'm excited, too. I think more people need to be reading this book, so I can't wait.
B
Well, I'm going to be one of them.
A
Good. Well, if you want to talk to us about any of this, you can join us in the Facebook group, which is under Batonpaper podcast. We're on Instagram @batonpaper podcast. We have a BFF group under Baton Paper Podcast. I'm on Instagram and Substack and the general intranet under Olivia Mentor.
B
I'm on Instagram ecamfreeman. My newsletter is@beccafreeman substack.com and I have a new novel coming this October called Back Where We Started and I would love it if you considered pre ordering it. We'll see you next week.
A
Bye.
D
Bye.
Bad On Paper Podcast - Episode Summary
Podcast: Bad On Paper
Hosts: Becca Freeman & Olivia Muenter
Episode: 2026 Publishing Trends
Date: April 8, 2026
This episode dives into the key publishing trends of 2026, with a focus on what’s happening in fiction and romance. Becca and Olivia invite two industry insiders—Emily Sommer, book buyer for East City Bookshop, and Alyssa Morris, literary agent and romance trend expert—to discuss what’s selling, how book buying decisions are made, and what’s next in romance and fantasy genres. The episode is packed with recommendations, industry insights, and an engaging look at the future of books.
Highs:
“I just started cleaning out my entire house. Donated, I can't even, thousands of pieces of clothing. The vibes are strong. The vibes are good.” — Olivia [01:13]
“I hopefully have set myself some very achievable goals and I'm just wading in... But the water feels good. I’m excited.” — Becca [02:22]
Lows:
“Is there a solution to this or is this just aging?” — Becca [07:10]
“Now I have this chemical burn on my neck which truly does look like a hickey on the front of my neck... it is truly dead center front of my neck... Who cares? But I don’t like the idea it’ll be there forever.” — Olivia [09:03]
Where to find Emily:
“It truly could not have been written by anyone else and stands on its own.” — Alyssa [55:15]
Where to find Alyssa:
Olivia’s recent reads:
Becca’s recent reads:
Life/Organization/Obsession Chat:
Upcoming Book Club:
This episode is a must-listen (or read!) for anyone curious about what’s driving book buying, the ongoing power of BookTok, reader fatigue with series, and the rise of unexpected genres and trends. The interviews provide honest, insider perspectives, practical recommendations, and predictions that balance delight and savvy realism—all in Becca and Olivia’s trademark conversational, insightful style.
To connect further: