The Trial: Star Witness

Summary

Bad Rap: The Case Against Diddy – Episode Summary: The Trial: Star Witness

Release Date: May 16, 2025
Host: Brian Buckmire, ABC News Legal Contributor
Guest: Tonya Simpson, Coordinating Producer for ABC's Investigative Unit

---

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "The Trial: Star Witness" from the six-part series Bad Rap: The Case Against Diddy, ABC News delves deep into the federal charges facing Sean "Diddy" Combs. These charges include sex trafficking, racketeering, conspiracy, and interstate transportation for prostitution. The episode provides an inside look at the courtroom drama, centering primarily on the testimony of Cassie Ventura, a key witness and former romantic partner of Combs.

Background of the Case

Sean Combs, a towering figure in the hip-hop industry and a successful entrepreneur, has seen his career marred by a series of serious allegations. The dissolution of his public image began in earnest when a video surfaced depicting Combs assaulting his then-girlfriend, Cassie Ventura. This episode chronicles the unfolding of a lawsuit initiated by Ventura in 2023, which was settled for $20 million without any admission of guilt from Combs. However, recent developments have escalated the situation, bringing forth a barrage of new lawsuits alleging sexual abuse and manipulation during orchestrated "freak offs" — sex parties allegedly controlled by Combs.

Cassie Ventura's Testimony

The heart of this episode is Cassie Ventura's courtroom testimony. As she sits before the jury, Ventura provides a sobering account of her experiences with Combs:

• Professional Sabotage: Ventura alleges that Combs actively hindered her career progression. "He held my career back," she testified, underscoring the manipulation she faced behind the scenes.

• Participation in "Freak Offs": Ventura recounts her involvement in these orchestrated sex performances, stating, "I participated because I wanted to please Diddy." She further reveals that her attempt to withdraw from one such event led to a violent altercation. "Leaving early led to him beating me in the hallway of the Intercontinental hotel back in 2016," she declared, referencing video evidence captured by hotel surveillance cameras.

• Emotional and Physical Abuse: The testimony paints a harrowing picture of abuse. Ventura describes how she was forcibly removed from a "freak off," resulting in physical harm. "I had a black eye and didn’t want more injuries before my movie premiere," she explained at [06:02].

Courtroom Dynamics and Observations

Brian Buckmire and Tonya Simpson provide detailed observations from their vantage point in the courtroom:

• Reactions of the Jury: During particularly graphic parts of Ventura's testimony, such as descriptions of being urinated on, jurors exhibited visible discomfort. [09:16] "Several jurors looked down at the floor and shook their heads, appearing disgusted."

• Emotional Shifts in Testimony: Initially, Ventura maintained a stoic demeanor. However, as the testimony delved into more traumatic experiences, her composure faltered. "I just need a minute," Ventura whispered to the prosecutor before visibly sobbing [11:10].

• Non-Verbal Cues: Both Buckmire and Simpson noted significant non-verbal communication. For instance, Ventura's husband, Alex Fine, displayed intense stares towards Combs and his associates, suggesting underlying tensions [06:19].

Legal Strategy and Implications

The episode also explores the strategic elements of the trial:

• Presentation of Evidence: A critical legal debate revolved around the use of explicit videos and images from the "freak offs." ABC News was part of a coalition advocating for limited media access to these materials to report responsibly without further traumatizing Ventura. However, the judge ruled against releasing these visuals to the press, allowing only jurors and witnesses to view them directly [08:11].

• Prosecution vs. Defense Arguments:

  • Prosecution: Leveraging Ventura's testimony, the prosecution builds a case around sex trafficking and racketeering, highlighting the logistics of transporting escorts across different states and even internationally. "They flew an escort to Ibiza for a freak off," Ventura testified, emphasizing the organized nature of the alleged activities [16:52].

  • Defense: Combs' legal team counters by questioning Ventura's agency and willingness, presenting text messages that suggest her eagerness to participate. They also insinuate that Ventura's reluctance stems from desires for a deeper romantic relationship rather than fear of trafficking [07:20].

Brian Buckmire provides a legal analysis, noting that while the sex trafficking charges seem to align with the presented evidence, racketeering poses a more complex challenge for the prosecution due to its multifaceted requirements [17:31].

Emotional and Psychological Impact

Ventura's testimony reveals the profound emotional and psychological toll the alleged abuse has taken on her:

• Seeking Therapy: Ventura discussed her experiences in rehab and trauma therapy, indicating long-term psychological impacts. "I feel like I have PTSD," she confessed [11:10].

• Despair and Emotional Breakdown: During the afternoon sessions, Ventura opened up about her struggles with mental health, even expressing suicidal thoughts. "I didn't want to live anymore," she revealed, illustrating the depth of her distress [11:10].

Conclusion and Upcoming Developments

As the trial unfolds, "The Trial: Star Witness" sets the stage for a prolonged legal battle that is expected to stretch over six to eight weeks. The early testimony of Cassie Ventura is pivotal, potentially setting the tone for the prosecution's case. Buckmire and Simpson anticipate that as more evidence and testimonies emerge, the alignment of facts will either solidify the charges against Combs or expose vulnerabilities in the prosecution's strategy.

The episode concludes by highlighting the human element of the trial, emphasizing the courage of survivors like Ventura in bringing their stories to light and the broader implications for accountability in the entertainment industry.

---

Notable Quotes:

• "He held my career back." – Cassie Ventura [05:25]
• "Leaving early led to him beating me in the hallway of the Intercontinental hotel back in 2016." – Cassie Ventura [06:02]
• "I have PTSD." – Cassie Ventura [11:10]
• "I didn't want to live anymore." – Cassie Ventura [11:10]
• "They flew an escort to Ibiza for a freak off." – Cassie Ventura [16:52]

Disclaimer: This summary is based on the transcript provided and aims to encapsulate the key elements of the podcast episode without introducing personal interpretations.

Transcript

[Tonya Simpson]

Pms, pregnancy, menopause, being a woman is a lot. Ollie supports you and yours with expert solutions for every age and life stage. They just launched two new products exclusively at Walmart. Period Hero Combats, Bloat, Mood swings and more during PMS and balance perimeno to support hormonal balance, mood and metabolism during perimenopause. Grab [e-mail] these statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.

[Brian Buckmire]

A warning that this episode includes discussion of violence, sexual assault and suicide. So please take care when listening this week, USA v. Sean Combs, has been mostly about one witness, singer Cassie Ventura, who was in a romantic relationship with Sean Combs for over a decade. Cassie brought the first civil lawsuit against Combs in 2023. It included allegations of sex trafficking and was settled quickly with no admission of guilt. This week we learn through her testimony the amount of that settlement. $20 million. For a long time, that lawsuit was the only look we had into her experience with Sean Combs. I remember when we were researching earlier episodes of this podcast, the lawsuit was one of the very few sources of information we had to draw from to try to understand her side of things. And now here's Cassie Ventura sitting in court, very pregnant, answering question after question, testifying to how she believes Sean Combs held her career back. How she started off participating in orchestrated sex performances called freak offs because she wanted to please Combs. How she says leaving a freak off early led to Combs beating her in the hallway of the Intercontinental hotel back in 2016. The jury saw videos of that incident captured by the hotel's surveillance cameras. Combs denies the federal charges of sex trafficking, racketeering, conspiracy and interstate transportation for prostitution. He's facing, and he's pled not guilty. Under cross examination, the defense asked Cassie to read texts she'd sent to Combs, texts they say show her willingness, eagerness and agency in the relationship. The defense also questioned whether her reluctance to participate in Combs freak offs was because she wanted their relationship to develop more and to be more than their sexual encounters. In other words, was the story more about jealousy and infidelity than the serious charges Combs is facing. One of the people keeping an extremely close eye on everything happening in the courtroom is my colleague Tonya Simpson. She's a coordinating producer for ABC's investigative unit. We're going to talk about what she heard and observed while sitting in the courtroom when Cassie was on the stand. I'm Brian Buckmire an ABC News legal contributor and practicing attorney. You're listening to Bad Rap, the case against Diddy. This episode, Star Witness. Tanya, you and I have both been in court every day. I think we've been like line buddies as well for a while. We've heard some really incredible testimony. And I say incredible not because it's like amazing, but just almost beyond belief. Most notably from Cassie Ventura, Diddy's ex. We'll get into that in a minute, but listeners might be surprised to learn we can't take any electronic devices into the court with us. So we have to take notes the old fashioned way. Pen and paper. How's your wrist holding up, by the way?

[Tonya Simpson]

You know, my wrist is doing okay. My fingers were getting a little sore on the first day. I was starting to get a dent on one of my fingers from the pen. So I actually bought cushions to put on my pens while I'm writing. And that has helped a lot.

[Brian Buckmire]

And I know you guys can't see us, but Tonya's flipping through his book. One, some of the nicest writing I've seen.

[Tonya Simpson]

Thank you.

[Brian Buckmire]

Two, very small writing. And so you're like squeezing things into the margins just to make it fit, but it's still just covering the page.

[Tonya Simpson]

Yeah, yeah. I am a very meticulous note taker. Shout out to my grade school teachers for the penmanship.

[Brian Buckmire]

Okay, so, Tanya, let's dive into these notes of yours and see what you think about this case. What have been some of the more compelling points each side has made this week or things that stood out to you? Maybe more so in Cassie's testimony?

[Tonya Simpson]

Sure. I think one of the first things that stood out for me and Cassie's testimony is when prosecutors asked her to walk through the hotel video. It was interesting to see her watching that video. I was paying very close attention to her face. I was also looking at Sean Combs face while she was washing. Cassie Ventura's husband has also been in the courtroom. I noticed him was Diddy watching Sean Combs while the video was playing. But it was interesting to hear Cassie talk about everything that led up to what we saw in the video and then everything that came after she explained that they were at the hotel, they were in la. She was getting ready for a big movie premiere. And she talked about how she didn't necessarily want to do a freak off that weekend, but she felt like she needed to because she wanted her premiere to go smoothly. She talked about the fact that that was one of the only times that she had ever actually tried to leave a freak off. And Cassave Ventura claimed that the reason she tried to leave that freak off is because at some point she was hit in the face. She had a black eye, and she knew she had this movie premiere coming up and she didn't want to get any more injuries before she had to hit that red carpet.

[Brian Buckmire]

You mentioned Cassie Ventura's husband, Alex Fine. And I know that you and I are very close. I think you're just a little off to my side and maybe one row behind. I'm curious if you saw what I saw. I saw him staring at Sean Combs as well. But did you see the side of his face and his ear turn red as if he was getting heated?

[Tonya Simpson]

He turned very, very red. And when he would look at Sean Combs and kind of look at Sean Combs family, it was a very pointed stare. It wasn't a glance. He would look at them for stretches of time, like a few seconds, maybe even a minute or so.

[Brian Buckmire]

Yeah. I was like, I've seen that glare.

[Tonya Simpson]

Absolutely. I also thought it was interesting that from the moment that Cassie came into the courtroom, she would glance at her husband Alex when she walked in. While she's being questioned, she is looking very pointedly at the prosecutor. She does not look at Diddy. She is not looking over at the defense table in between questions. I've seen her glance at the jury. I've seen her look down at her hands or at the screen in front of her, even when there's nothing on it. But it's notable that she hasn't made any eye contact with Sean Combs. So, Bryan, one of the legal issues that has come up this week is exactly what to do with these explicit videos and still images from the freakoffs that prosecutors presented as evidence in the case of how to present them, who gets to see them. ABC was actually part of a coalition of news organizations that argued that the media, or at least a small pool of journalists, should be able to see these videos so that we can describe what's in it, report on it, but not to actually publish the images or videos. The judge said no. So only the jurors, the witness Cassie, were able to look at these still images on screens in front of them. The attorneys had hard copies of of the images in a binder. I wonder what you make of that decision.

[Brian Buckmire]

I understood why the judge came to the conclusion that they did. There are competing constitutional rights in the courtroom at any given time. Privacy rights of the alleged victim, constitutional rights of the defendant, but also constitutional rights of the public and the media. And I think when all of these butt heads, the court errs on the side of the let's protect the person who has gone through these alleged acts. While they are allegations, there are documentations and photos of them as well. And I think the belief is that we as journalists can have the ability to articulate what we saw and heard in court sufficiently enough to inform the public without, as the court suggested, re traumatizing Cassie or anyone else who takes the standard. We do have the opportunity because we're in court to see how the jury and people in the courtroom react. So how did they react when they saw some of these very graphic pieces of evidence and also hear the testimony?

[Tonya Simpson]

There were definitely reactions from the jury during some of the really graphic points. At one point, when Cassie was describing being urinated on, I saw several jurors look down at the floor and shake their heads. They looked a little disgusted. During Cassie's testimony, when jurors were given the opportunity to see still images from videos of freakoffs, there were a couple of jurors I noticed would look at the screens in front of them and look away pretty quickly, like they didn't really want to look closely. Something else that I noticed during the Cassie's testimony that wasn't as graphic. The jurors are riveted. Their eyes are on her. A lot of times in court, kind of it looks like a tennis match. The jurors will look back and forth between the prosecution or the defense attorney and back to the person they're questioning. During Cassie's testimony, most of the jurors have been locked in. I've seen some of them leaning in. They're taking a lot of notes during these graphic sections of the testimony. Not a lot of note taking, not a lot of looking at Cassie. It is a lot of looking down, looking uncomfortable, like I said, looking a little disgusted and even a little sad for her.

[Brian Buckmire]

Tonya, in the morning, Cassie came across as very stoic and matter of fact, in a way, to me, that was a little jarring. I think if anyone is describing the sexual abuse and the trafficking or the allegations thereof, you would be trepidatious, you would be shocked. You would say it as a shocking thing. But she talked about it as plainly as I'm talking about. Yeah, you're wearing a green sweater. Yeah. You have headphones on. And she was just matter of fact. But in the afternoon when the testimony got very dark, things changed, right?

[Tonya Simpson]

Yeah. During the morning, it was a lot of what I would say, technical questions, the kind of the who's the what's the where. And you're right, she was soft spoken but it was very monotone where she kind of ticked through some of the names and the places that the freak offs would happen. Wednesday afternoon they asked her questions about how she was feeling and questions about her going to rehab and going to trauma therapy after her and Sean Combs relationship ended. And we saw a very different Cassie. It started with her getting choked up a little bit when she talked about feeling like she has ptsd and then she started sobbing when she recounted a story of how she didn't want to live anymore. At one point, at one point she apologized to the prosecutor and said, I'm sorry, I just need a minute. The prosecutor offered her a box of tissue and gave her a second before they continued. But you could tell that it was a really hard thing for her to talk about. And yeah, I think that was one of the most emotional moments that we saw from Cassie during her testimony.

[Brian Buckmire]

When we come back, what are the stakes for the prosecution and having their star witness testify at the very beginning of what's expected to be a a long trial? This episode is brought to you by Lifelock. Not everyone is careful with your personal information, which might explain why there's a victim of identity theft every five seconds in the U.S. fortunately, there's LifeLock. LifeLock monitors hundreds of millions of data points a second for threats to your identity. If your identity is stolen, a US based restoration specialist will fix it it guaranteed or your money back. Save up to 40% your first year by visiting lifelock.com podcast terms apply.

[Tonya Simpson]

This episode is brought to you by Greenlight. Get this, adults with financial literacy skills have 82% more wealth than those who don't. From swimming lessons to piano classes. US parents invest in so many things to enrich our kids lives. But are we investing in their future financial success? With Greenlight you can teach your kids financial literacy skills like earning, saving and investing. And this investment costs less than that. After school treat saving money Start prioritizing their financial education and future today with a risk free trial at greenlight.com Spotify greenlight.com Spotify Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile.

[Brian Buckmire]

I don't know if you knew this but anyone can get the same Premium Wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities so do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to [e-mail].

[Tonya Simpson]

Switch upfront payment of $45 for 3 month plan equivalent to $15 per intro rate. First 3 months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra. See full [e-mail].

[Brian Buckmire]

I'm back with Tanya Simpson. She's the coordinating producer for ABC's investigative unit and someone who's been in the courtroom paying very close attention to what's unfolding and we're debriefing on what we observed.

[Tonya Simpson]

So I am not a lawyer, even though I've been spending a lot of time in court these past couple months. So I'm excited to be sitting down with someone who is, because I really want to get your take on something again. Incredible testimony from Cassi Ventura, but how do you think that her testimony fits into the prosecution's charges against Sean Combs?

[Brian Buckmire]

So I think when I watch trials, I watch them a little differently than the average person, which I also think is somewhat at a bit of a disadvantage. Because at the end of the day, it's not an attorney who decides guilt or innocence. It's everyday citizens who sign up and choose to be jurors. But when I listen to the testimony and I watch the jurors, I'm thinking, here is the square hole. This is the peg that the government is trying to fit into it. And is it fitting? Is a square peg too big? Is it a circular peg? Is it a triangular peg? Whatever it is. And I would say in the first day of Cassie's testimony, it didn't feel like this peg was fitting correctly into the hole. And the reason for that is, is as a former public defender at the Legal Aid Society in Brooklyn, I've represented people who have been victims of domestic violence, victims of sex trafficking, people who have sex trafficked others. And as they listen to it, I was like, does this sound like domestic violence or does it sound like trafficking? And then the first day I was like, these sound like the elements of a crime that would be more in line with domestic violence from the facts that we were hearing. But on the second day of testimony, that's when I started to hear testimony and evidence. And also the way that Cassie was talking about Sean Combs, I was like, I've heard this tone before. I have heard this type of conversation before. I have heard these elements before. And that's when I started to piece together. I think they're getting closer to the trafficking allegations. Now. I say closer because they still need to have individuals come forward and testify to say I was part of this criminal enterprise. Sean Combs did this intentionally for the purpose of trafficking. This wasn't just a violent relationship. I think they still need a lot of pieces, but I'm starting to see the pieces align with what the government is accusing in the second day of testimony.

[Tonya Simpson]

And I also think in my non expert, non legal opinion, I think that Cassie's testimony has done a lot for the charge of transportation to engage in prostitution. She has testified about multiple escorts that they hired and how these same escorts, they would see them in different cities in different states. She talked about how they would arrange travel for some of the escorts. At one point internationally, she says they flew an escort to Ibiza for a freak off. I want to get your thoughts on that. And also what about the racketeering?

[Brian Buckmire]

So I always hate to look over a defense attorney's shoulder and be like, this argument doesn't really make sense. But when the defense made the argument that this is not transportation for the sake of prostitution because Sean Combs was paying for the time of escorts and dancers because he was just believing he was paying for their time, wasn't paying for sex, I kind of looked over at people and be like, come on now. This come on now. I think I made.

[Tonya Simpson]

Is that what you got face? Is there more coming face?

[Brian Buckmire]

I'm like, come on now. And the defense that they were making I just didn't think really worked out. And it just seems like an easy layup for the government and the way they're presenting this case. So I don't see an argument to combat what you're articulating. And I agree. The easily laid out facts that make out that charge. When it comes to the racketeering, I think that's more difficult for the government. There are a lot more moving pieces that you have to fit into place. And if one moving piece doesn't fit correctly, the whole structure can fall. And I see the defense having much more opportunities to poke holes in that case or to make that structure fall when it comes to the sex trafficking charge, when you're arguing this is simply just domestic violence and the racketeering, when you're saying there is no criminal enterprise here.

[Tonya Simpson]

So Cassie Ventura was considered, I think pretty much by everyone to be the government star witness, a key witness. She is one of the first people to testify. Are there pros and cons to having your star witness testify during the very first week of what is being estimated to be an up to eight week trial? Six to eight weeks.

[Brian Buckmire]

So the pro of having your star witness testify so early, and I don't even think they really had A choice with this. Cassie Ventura is very much pregnant to the point that I think her due date must be very soon.

[Tonya Simpson]

Eight and a half months.

[Brian Buckmire]

Yeah. And so I think for her health, the health of her child, the health of her family, I think the government's doing the right thing by getting her in and out of here as quickly as possible. So it's not really a choice in terms of strategy here. But if it was a choice and it was strategy, I think it's good in the sense of you set the tone and the tenor of the case very quickly. You understand what happened to your star witness or the alleged victim, however you want to describe them or what perspective you're looking at it. And you hopefully that carries on throughout the trial. The difficulty or the downside of that is when you get to a point where you're doing your closing argument some eight weeks later, the end of June, beginning of July, you've got to keep telling people, remember what I said two months ago. Remember this, remember that. And jogging their memory and trying to piece it all together can be difficult. And I think it might also amount to a little bit of a longer deliberation time because then the jury's gotta get in there, they gotta request testimony from two months ago.

[Tonya Simpson]

Hopefully their notes are as good as mine are.

[Brian Buckmire]

I mean, with your handwriting, we should just photocopy it and send it to the jurors. At this point, I think it would work out much better. But that's kind of the downside there. Thanks to ABC coordinating producer Tonya Simpson for joining me for this episode. Tanya, I'll be seeing you back in the courtroom. Before we go, if you or someone you know is a victim of sexual assault, please call the National Sexual assault hotline at 1-800-656-HOPE or go to rainn.org that's it for this episode of Bad the Case Against Diddy. Make sure to check out a new special from ABC News called Diddy on Trial that's now streaming on Hulu. Nightline co anchor Byron Pitts sits down with Charlucci Finney, a music producer and longtime friend of Combs, in his first network interview. Here's a clip from the special.

[Tonya Simpson]

I never received a dollar from him as a payroll.

[Brian Buckmire]

That's my brother Blood Mickey related. But loyalty make you family. You can find Diddy on Trial from Impact by Nightline, only on Hulu. If you have something you're curious about in the Diddy trial, leave a voicemail for me at 646-504-3221. You might even hear me answer it next week on the podcast. The number again is 646-504-3221. You can also find it on our show Notes. Thanks to everyone who's called in to ask your questions so far. The Case Against Diddy is a production of ABC Audio. I'm Brian Buckmire. Our podcast production team includes Vika Aronson, Nancy Rosenbaum, Audrey Mostek, Amirah Williams, Tracy Samuelson, and Sasha Aslanian. Special thanks to Stephanie Maurice, Caitlin Morris, Liz Alessi, Katie Dundas and the team at ABC News Live. Michelle Margulis is our operations manager. Josh Cohan is ABC's director of podcast programming. Laura Mayer is our executive producer. Yeah, the NBA playoffs are here and it's about to be. Ridiculous. Unbelievable, Unfair, downright nasty. Straight up, can't miss, don't blink. Grab your popcorn and strap in. Cinema.

[Tonya Simpson]

This isn't about who's next.

[Brian Buckmire]

This is about who's now. This time it's different. The NBA playoff is presented by Google. Continue on ESPN and abc.

[Tonya Simpson]

The cultural phenomenon the Secret Lies of Mormon Wives is back with an all new season now streaming on Hulu.

[Brian Buckmire]

Where is everyone at?

[Tonya Simpson]

Mom Talk has gotten to a really hostile point.

[Brian Buckmire]

Demi's willing to kick Jessie out of the group. I feel like I'm working into a lion's den. It's gonna get messy for sure. Mom Talk is turning on each other left and right. The police are here.

[Tonya Simpson]

I can't see this going any other way, but.

[Brian Buckmire]

But a pure bloodbath.

[Tonya Simpson]

This is so toxic. The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives now streaming on Hulu.