Summary of "Baking it Down with Sugar Cookie Marketing"

Episode 247: "The Alternates (Bless Their Souls)"

Date: February 11, 2026
Hosts: Heather and Corrie Miracle (intro/outro), with alternate hosts and guests Ashley (Dapple Bakery) and Donna (Peace, Love, and Sugar Cookies)
Theme: Alternates take the reins while the original Miracle twins are at Cookie College Bootcamp; honest, upbeat discussion with seasoned cottage bakers on what really brings in business, pricing, burnout prevention, and building relationships in a competitive cookie market.

Main Theme & Purpose

This episode features "the alternates" filling in for Heather and Corrie. The focus is on actionable strategies for turning baking hustle into profitability, especially how bakers can market themselves authentically, price confidently, and foster repeat customers. The tone is supportive, full of camaraderie, and punctuated with practical tips and laughter. Guests Ashley and Donna share their hard-won lessons from real world bakery business experience.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Meet the Alternates – Baker Introductions

• Ashley (Dapple Bakery, Houston) and Donna (Peace, Love & Sugar Cookies, Northeast) introduce themselves, sharing their specialties and marketing journeys.
  • Ashley: "Once I got on [Google Business Profile], I had clients constantly approaching me, not me chasing them." (07:09)
  • Donna: "A local networking group increased my business by 57% last year—best thing I’ve ever done!" (07:35)

2. Ice Breaker Rapid Fire (04:07 - 06:25)

Fun, quick questions cover platforms they’re “trauma bonded with” (Instagram), custom orders vs. classes, favorite trends (bright colors), most-ordered cookies, and favorite flavor combos.

“Strawberry and sweet cream. Strawberry cookies, cream cheese, or sweet cream. And now we’re all hungry.” —Ashley (06:07)

3. Real Marketing Strategies that Work

What actually generates orders?:

• Ashley: Google Business Profile tops the referral source; “clients seeking her out, not the other way around.” (07:09)
• Donna: Local networking groups are gold: “We share referrals and support each other's business growth weekly.” (08:05)
  • Weekly 1-hour meetings.
  • Referrals via social and word of mouth.
  • Learning business tips from diverse local entrepreneurs.

4. Strategies that Flopped

• Donna: “A year advertising in an upscale magazine for one client. Don’t waste money or time on pay-to-play print.” (10:06)
• Ashley: Tries not to sink time/money into trends or sales promotions until they’re vetted—advises staying nimble and strategic.

5. Pricing Without Guilt (12:53)

• “Know your numbers—use a spreadsheet or app, and review quarterly. Pricing is math, not emotion.” —Ashley (12:53)
• Adjust regularly for rising ingredient costs.
• Stay aware of local competitors’ pricing, but don’t underprice (“biggest mistake new bakers make”).

6. Converting Followers to Paying Clients (16:46)

• Ashley: “Show value—customers pay more for cookies that impress and delight, not just taste.”
• Donna: Personal touches: “Every order, no matter how tired I am, spreads peace and joy, one chipper at a time.” (17:17)
  • Warm, human communication from order to pickup.
  • Name, brand, and customer experience all reinforce this.

7. Naming and Branding (18:01)

• Donna’s bakery named by a former student: “Peace, Love & Sugar Cookies suited my personality—relationships matter.”
• Ashley advises: don’t get too attached to logos/mascots if they confuse your audience (“I had to change from a dog logo after people thought I made dog treats”). (18:45)

8. Repeat Customers & Retention (20:21)

• Consistent follow-up: reach out one month ahead for birthdays/annual events.
• Small, secret thank-you cookies for pickup.
• Personalizing orders and recall of customer stories builds loyalty.

9. Promos & Giveaways (22:10)

• Ashley is strategic—prefers giveaways for engagement (pre-sale design votes), not for general freebies.
• Donna offers anniversary promos ("12 years!").

10. Showing Personality on Social Without Feeling Cringe (23:16)

• “We're our own worst critics—you're less cringey than you think.” —Ashley (23:20)
• Donna uses AI-generated “messy kitchen” photos and viral memes to foster relatability and community engagement (“over 260,000 views and 1,000+ comments!”). (24:44)

11. Tackling Busy Seasons & Setting Boundaries

• “Maypocalypse”—navigating overlapping busy holidays (Teacher Appreciation, graduations, Mother’s Day, etc.).
  • Both pick and choose—don’t do every holiday or offer endless choices.
  • “Mother’s Day never sells for me, so I dropped it and focus on graduation/teachers.” —Donna (27:28)
• Best Mother’s Day gift: “Most moms just want a break!” (28:24)
• Learning to say no to last-minute requests and to let go of not being “everyone’s baker.” (34:52)

12. Content Creation & Scheduling (30:24 – 35:40)

• Both are working on more video/reel content, experimenting with trends and transitions, and keeping scheduling manageable.
• Tips:
  • Use apps like InShot for video editing.
  • Simple, process-focused reels perform well.
  • Adopt a content calendar—consistency over frequency, batch editing/photos on a set “content day,” and don't stress curation.

13. Community Over Competition (37:41 – 39:16)

• Embrace local baker groups for referrals and mutual support.
• “The grocery store is proof—there’s plenty of customers for everyone.” —Donna (38:21)
• Being too territorial is counterproductive; network so you can refer and receive referrals, especially if taking time off.

14. Listener Q&A Highlights (39:21 – 46:10)

• Dealing with local competitors? — Make friends and highlight your unique story/services; niche offerings help.
• Bouncing back after a slow season? — Update your Google Business Profile, post a “Meet the Baker” re-introduction, join more community groups, and consider a small giveaway.
• Instagram burnout? — Post as often as you reasonably can (“consistency doesn’t mean daily”), focus on behind-the-scenes, tools, customer stories, and not just pretty cookies.
• Balancing social posting with exhaustion: — Batch schedule, forgive imperfection, and ask for help if possible (VAs, AI for rough copy).
• Procrastinated marketing task? — Tackle one step at a time, enlist group accountability, don’t let tech anxiety stall you.

15. Bonus Tips & Resource Highlights

• Cookie College: Massive course library, private podcast, vibrant Facebook group. “So many business, event, teaching, and photography resources in one place. Invaluable.” (48:42–51:38)
• Marketing Power Tips:
  • Put your face out there (show the baker, not just the bakes).
  • Schedule posts using a content calendar and leverage national holidays for ideas.
  • Don’t be afraid to shout out other local businesses.

16. Notable Quotes

• “Know your numbers. Pricing is a math problem, not a feeling.” —Ashley (12:53)
• “Every order is a chance to spread peace and joy, one chipper at a time.” —Donna (17:17)
• "We're our own worst critics—you're not as cringey as you think!" —Ashley (23:20)
• “The best thing I did was join a networking group. I made the yearly fee back in weeks through referrals.” —Donna (07:35)
• “Mother’s Day? Moms want a break, a spa day, someone else to think of them!” —Ashley & Donna (28:24)

Notable Segments & Timestamps

| Timestamp | Segment | Highlights | |-----------|-------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| | 02:40 | Guest Intros | Ashley & Donna share backgrounds, business names, and specialties | | 04:07 | Icebreaker Game | Fun rapid fire gets laughs and bakery confessions | | 07:09 | Main Marketing Wins | Google Business Profile & networking groups as top lead sources | | 10:06 | Marketing Misses | Print magazine ad disaster; cautionary tales on ill-advised old school advertising methods | | 12:53 | Pricing Discussion | Hard numbers, how to calculate and adjust, avoiding emotional underpricing | | 16:46 | Turning Followers to Clients | Messaging value, authentic engagement, brand philosophy embedded in each interaction | | 18:01 | Branding Stories | Why your bakery's name/mascot matters more than you think | | 20:21 | Customer Retention | Personalized follow-up, secret thank you cookies, tracking special dates | | 23:16 | Personality in Marketing | AI memes, sharing imperfect moments, viral relatability | | 27:24 | Seasonal Strategy | Picking busy season battles, focusing on what actually sells | | 30:24 | Content Scheduling | How to stay consistent without burning out | | 35:40 | Community over Competition | Why having friendly local bakers is key—referrals and support | | 39:21 | Listener Q&A | Local competition, social media burnout, getting back after a break | | 48:42 | Cookie College & Bootcamps | Resource shoutouts, class kits, upcoming topics | | 56:01 | Life Interests | Heating pad and “Amazon box purge” for physical and home sanity |

Memorable Moments

• Donna’s viral AI photo—went “baker viral” not for sales, but because it built community solidarity and laughs. (24:44)
• Both guests agree: you don’t have to do every holiday/no to last-minute orders for your sanity.
• “There’s enough cake for everyone”—real encouragement for bakers who feel threatened by market saturation. (38:21)
• Donna's procrastinated Google Business Profile—relatable tech paralysis and group accountability. (46:26)

Practical Takeaways

• Focus your marketing efforts: Google Business Profile, networking, and authentic, regular social media presence are proven drivers.
• Underpricing leads to burnout and unsustainable business—always know your cost and price for profit.
• Build genuine relationships (with both customers and other local bakers) for referrals, support, and better mental health.
• Batch content, use tools like InShot and scheduling platforms, and forgive yourself for imperfection.
• Pick your battles during busy seasons—choose offerings that sell; quality over quantity.
• Personality and a bit of “cringe” can forge a stronger brand connection than perfect curation.

Conclusion

An upbeat, actionable episode full of real-world bakery marketing wisdom: focus on math and relationships, be open to learning and pivoting, and—above all—don’t be afraid of showing up as yourself, both online and in your bakes.

Listen for more: Community, encouragement, and strategy from real bakers who have survived many a cookie “apocalypse.”

Notable Quote:

“Know your numbers. Pricing is a math problem, not a feeling.”
—Ashley, at [12:53]

Contact for Next Episode Qs:
Text your questions to 571-556-5644 for a chance to be featured next week!

This summary includes only content-specific discussions and skips advertisements and unrelated intro/outro chatter. All timestamps are in MM:SS format for easy reference.