Chipotle: Is it the Economy or is it Leadership? 11-11-25

Summary

Podcast Summary

Podcast: Becker Business
Host: Scott Becker
Episode: Chipotle: Is it the Economy or is it Leadership?
Date: November 11, 2025

---

Overview

In this concise solo episode, Scott Becker examines Chipotle's significant business struggles in 2025. He analyzes whether the company’s woes stem predominantly from economic pressures or from changes and shortcomings in leadership, especially after the departure of former CEO Brian Niccol. The conversation quickly broadens to reflect on the broader fast food industry and parallels from Becker's own experiences.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Central Question: Economy vs. Leadership

• Becker opens with a pointed question: Are Chipotle’s challenges due to the broader economy, or is leadership more at fault?
• He notes the common corporate tendency to blame poor performance on external factors:
  • Quote: "Whenever a company is struggling today, they tend to find an external factor to blame it on." (Scott Becker, 00:07)
• Chipotle's situation is stark:
  • "They're down literally 50% year to date." (Scott Becker, 00:20)
  • Becker suggests this is likely more than just macroeconomic headwinds.

2. The Impact of Leadership - The Departure of Brian Niccol

• Becker emphasizes the significance of CEO Brian Niccol’s exit and paints him as a "best regarded" industry leader:
  • Quote: "Chipotle famously this last year lost its leader, Brian Nicole, one of the best regarded CEOs in, in the food business." (Scott Becker, 00:28)
• Notes Niccol’s move to Starbucks and calls attention to Starbucks’ own search for stability at the top.

3. Industry Comparisons

Becker rounds out the analysis by comparing Chipotle’s fortunes to other fast food giants:

• McDonald’s:
  • "McDonald's doing okay. They're about 5, 6% year to date." (Scott Becker, 00:48)
• Burger King:
  • "Burger King has been relevant for a long time, but now closing several hundred stores in an effort to sort of get back to profitable." (Scott Becker, 00:59)

4. The Leadership Accountability Principle

• Becker reinforces his core argument that leadership, not just the economy, is most often the deciding factor:
  • Quote: "I often think that it's more about leadership than I do about the economy." (Scott Becker, 01:07)
• He points out how current CEOs deflect blame to external forces, rather than taking responsibility:
  • Quote: "The current CEO needs to point to the economy, point to terrorists – he's going to something to sort of make it seem like it's not him that's causing the trouble." (Scott Becker, 01:19)

5. Memorable Personal Analogy

• Becker humorously ties the episode together with a golfing analogy about personal responsibility:
  • Quote: "It's almost similar when I golf. I could blame it on the conditions or I could take responsibility for myself, and it's usually myself." (Scott Becker, 01:29)

---

Notable Quotes & Timestamps

• "Whenever a company is struggling today, they tend to find an external factor to blame it on."_ — Scott Becker (00:07)
• "They're down literally 50% year to date." — Scott Becker (00:20)
• "Chipotle famously this last year lost its leader, Brian Nicole, one of the best regarded CEOs in... the food business." — Scott Becker (00:28)
• "I often think that it's more about leadership than I do about the economy." — Scott Becker (01:07)
• "The current CEO needs to point to the economy, point to terrorists – he's going to something to sort of make it seem like it's not him that's causing the trouble." — Scott Becker (01:19)
• "I could blame it on the conditions or I could take responsibility for myself, and it's usually myself." — Scott Becker (01:29)

---

Important Segments & Timestamps

• [00:00-00:26] — Framing the Chipotle dilemma: blame on economy vs. leadership
• [00:27-00:40] — The significance of Brian Niccol’s departure
• [00:41-01:07] — Industry context: McDonald’s and Burger King
• [01:07-01:22] — Leadership as the key factor, external blame
• [01:29-01:42] — Closing with the golfing analogy on accountability

---

Conclusion

Scott Becker’s short episode offers a pointed critique of the reflex to blame externalities instead of leadership when companies like Chipotle stumble. By referencing industry trends and incorporating personal insight, Becker reinforces the enduring importance of accountable and effective leadership in business success.

Transcript

[A]

This is Scott Becker with the Becker Business, the Becker Private Equity podcast. Today's discussion is Chipotle, is it the economy or is it leadership? So here's the deal. Whenever a company is struggling today, they tend to find an external factor to blame it on. In this case, Chipotle constantly points to the economy is causing trouble with their business, but they're down literally 50% year to date.

[B]

So I think it's got to be.

[A]

More than the economy. Chipotle famously this last year lost its leader, Brian Nicole, one of the best regarded CEOs in, in the food business.

[B]

In the restaurant business.

[A]

He left to go to Starbucks. Starbucks seems to be just really trying to find its stride. Imperfect, but seems to get closer.

[B]

Of course, when you look at the.

[A]

Big sort of fast food chain stuff like that, McDonald's doing okay. They're about 5, 6% year to date. But again, Chipotle getting killed. Burger King also trying to refine itself.

[B]

I don't know.

[A]

The Burger King has been relevant for a long time, but now closing several hundred stores in an effort to sort of get back to profitable.

[B]

We'll see how that goes.

[A]

But again, with companies like Chipotle, I think, I often think that it's more about leadership than I do about the economy. But the current CEO needs to point.

[B]

To the economy, point to terrorists.

[A]

He's going to something to sort of.

[B]

Make it seem like it's not him that's causing the trouble. I think it's fascinating to watch.

[A]

Thank you for listening to the Becker.

[B]

Private Equity the Becker Business podcast. It's almost similar when I golf. I could blame it in the conditions where I could take responsibility for myself, and it's usually myself. Thank you for listening to the Becker Business, the Becker Private Equity podcast. We'll be back with you shortly.

[A]

Thank you.