Podcast Summary: UnitedHealthcare Gets Crushed

Podcast: Becker Business
Host: Scott Becker
Date: January 28, 2026

Episode Overview

In this concise, news-driven episode, Scott Becker dissects the dramatic plunge in UnitedHealthcare’s stock price and the broader implications for the health insurance sector. He offers a rapid-fire assessment of UnitedHealthcare’s earnings report, troubling indicators, and the ripple effect across the industry—distilling the saga into seven or eight brisk, punchy points.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. UnitedHealthcare’s Stock Performance

• Major Drop:
  • On Tuesday, January 27th, UnitedHealthcare’s stock fell about 20% by day’s end.
  • Over the past 52 weeks, the stock is now down roughly 48%.
  • “On Tuesday the 27th, the stock...dropped by about 20% for the day. It's also down about 48% over the last 52 weeks.” — Scott Becker [00:16]

2. Earnings Snapshot: The Good News

• Q4 Earnings and Revenue Strong:
  • Earnings per share for Q4 outperformed expectations.
  • 2025 revenues hit $448 billion, placing UnitedHealthcare as the third or fourth largest U.S. company by revenue.
  • “Earnings per share for the fourth quarter ended up above expectations... revenues for the year at 448 billion, making United about the third or fourth largest company by revenues in the United States. So that's all good news.” — Scott Becker [00:37]

3. Forecasts: The Bad and the Ugly

• First Revenue Decline in 40 Years:
  • UnitedHealthcare projects lower revenue for the coming year—a stark departure from four decades of growth.
  • “This is about the first time in about 40 years, four decades, that they've projected reduced revenues versus growth in revenues.” — Scott Becker [00:51]
• Optum Health Struggles:
  • The Optum health business underperformed.
• Membership Shrinkage:
  • Expected contraction in Medicare and Medicaid enrollment.

4. Medical Loss Ratio Concerns

• Skyrocketing MLR:
  • Medical loss ratio (MLR) hits 89%, up from historic norms (82–85%).
  • Benchmark: When MLR exceeded 85–86% in the past, insurers began showing trouble.
  • “Now when you see United Western 89.1%, those are really challenging numbers for insurers.” — Scott Becker [01:30]
• Context:
  • High MLR signals more spent on healthcare services versus administration, which is favorable for consumers and providers but challenging for insurers’ margins.
  • “As a health care consumer, as health care operator, we think medical cost ratio should be pretty high... But either way, from a health insurance perspective, these are challenging numbers.” — Scott Becker [01:43]

5. Wider Industry Shockwaves

• Not Unique to UnitedHealthcare:
  • All major insurers are experiencing similar pressures today.
  • Medicaid, Medicare, and commercial-focused companies are all “taking it on the chin.”
  • “The other big insurers are also taking it on the chin today. Both the Medicaid insurers and the Medicare insurers and the commercial insurers, everybody's taking it on the chin.” — Scott Becker [01:57]
• Humana Hit Hard:
  • Humana’s stock also dropped by 19% the same day.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Now when you see United Western 89.1%, those are really challenging numbers for insurers.”
  — Scott Becker [01:30]
• “This is about the first time in about 40 years, four decades, that they've projected reduced revenues.”
  — Scott Becker [00:51]
• “The other big insurers are also taking it on the chin today.”
  — Scott Becker [01:57]

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Stock performance & context: 00:16
• Earnings/revenue positives: 00:37
• Revenue guidance & historic perspective: 00:51
• Optum/Medicaid/Medicare concerns: 01:10
• Medical loss ratio deep dive: 01:20–01:43
• Industry-wide impact & Humana: 01:57

Conclusion

Scott Becker provides a rapid, insightful assessment of UnitedHealthcare’s brutal market day, putting it in historical and industry context. Earnings and revenues remained strong for the previous year, but reduced forecasts, surging medical costs, and shrinking enrollments have triggered alarm bells—not just for UnitedHealthcare, but across the insurance sector. The episode gives listeners a brisk, expert walkthrough of why UnitedHealthcare “got crushed” and why the pain is being felt industry-wide.