Transcript
A (0:00)
Should you buy a rental property now or wait until you've saved up more money? Buy now and if prices rise and interest rates drop, you'll get appreciation and beat the competition. Wait, and you could put down more and have bigger cash flow and be in a relatively stronger financial position. If we had just enough money for a down payment and we were starting from scratch, this is what we'd do right now in 2025. Hey everyone, I'm Dave Meyer, head real estate investing at Bigger Pockets. And today on the show I'm joined by my friend and on the Market co host James Dainard. James, thanks for being here.
B (0:40)
Oh, I'm excited. This is my favorite kind of show. There's so many things that get popped around. I just love digging into like the little specifics.
A (0:46)
All of the success I feel like is hidden in those specifics on these individual circumstances. And the cool thing about this is that we have great questions today that even if they don't apply perfectly to your situation, going through the thought process and hearing sort of the different criteria, the metrics, the thought process that James and I have in answering these questions I think will help you understand how to drive your own portfolio forward better. And the questions we have today are awesome and are probably applicable to almost everyone listening out there. First question we have is from an investor who's debating whether to buy a deal now or save up more cash. We're also going to talk about how much rehab is too much rehab for a first time investor. James, that's right up your your alley. We'll be talking about what's driving the insane unrealistic expectations out there for many people in the real estate game. And we have a couple more questions about flipping houses as well. James, you ready?
B (1:44)
Oh, I'm always ready.
A (1:45)
So the first question, I like this because it's from someone named James in Seattle, just like you. But this is a different James also in Seattle though, who says I'm looking to purchase my first property for a house hack. Realistically, I could save up about 25,000 by the time my current apartment lease is up next year. That sum is not enough for a conventional loan, so I'd have to take out an FHA loan with PMI and a higher rate if I decide to buy next year. The alternative is I save up for a larger down payment and use a conventional loan. Part of me just says get started faster so you stop paying rent and start paying for an asset. And then the other part of me says waiting and having a bigger down payment will give you more cash flow, both in the short term and the long term. So there's a lot of math that goes into this, and I'm having difficulty weighing the pros and cons. I guess I should explain what PMI is. If you put less than 20% down on an FHA loan, you'll have something called PMI, which is private mortgage insurance, which is basically just another fee on top of your principal and interest that you're normally paying because the lender is essentially taking on more risk on you because you're only putting 3.5 or 5% down. And so they charge you for that in monthly payment and it just adds more expense. So it does hurt your cash flow, but the benefit is that you get to put 3 and a half or 5% down to control an asset. I think this is a question almost every investor has asked themselves at one point or another. So, James Daynard, who's also in Seattle, tell us how you think through this kind of question.
