Loading summary
Guy Swan
Three days later, as fog burned off the water, Hukoy's relatives moved upriver in narrow canoes. Faces were darkened with charcoal, not for concealment so much as resolve. They carried bows of yew, quivers of reed, arrows tipped with obsidian, and long knives at their waists. The best in Bitcoin made Audible I am Guy Swan and this is Bitcoin Audible. Nick Szabo has written his first article in like almost a decade and it
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
is short, but it is really good
Guy Swan
and there is one line in it
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
that I want to devote the commentary to after this read. Welcome back to Bitcoin Audible everybody.
Guy Swan
I am Guy Swan, your host and narrator for today. I am the guy who has read more about bitcoin than anybody else you know, the proof is in the podcast we are on read 943 today and
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
and we are getting back into a
Guy Swan
piece by Nick Szabo. We haven't read a Szabo piece in some time now and this is actually
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
posted on the Jan3 blog or website and Jan3 is with Samson Mao and their crew and they're building Aqua Wallet, which is actually a really fantastic wallet by the way. It's got liquid lightning and bitcoin basically
Guy Swan
all in one and if I'm not
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
mistaken, actually all transfers are shifted over.
Guy Swan
I think your balance is held in liquid by default.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
That could be different. I haven't used it or haven't like actively looked at it in a while. I probably have a little bit of and I think they even have USDT or some sort of dollar stablecoin on liquid, which is pretty cool. It's actually a fantastic wallet if you haven't used it. But he posted this article and there's
Guy Swan
a couple of lines in particular that
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
I really want to hit because this I just think this gets at the heart of so many ideas or concepts behind economic theory about money and I think do such a good job of just in a very short form drives the point home to understand where it
Guy Swan
is that money came from.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
And one of the most important things that I have stressed I don't know how many times on this show, but he says it very simply and very beautifully towards the end of this podcast and or excuse me, towards the end of the read and I'll hit it in the commentary after. But with that I want to go ahead and just jump right in to Nick Szabo's piece real fast. A shout out to Bitbox.
Guy Swan
They now have the Bitbox O2 Nova.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
I've always been a huge fan of the Bitbox. They really do have an elegant and simple design.
Guy Swan
And their new model, the Nova, will
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
work on all of the mobile devices. So it's iPhone, iPad, and Android. Check it out. I have a discount code and an
Guy Swan
affiliate link with right down in the show notes.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
All right, let's dive into today's article from the Jan3 blog and it's titled
Guy Swan
the Fabric of Desires by Nick Szabo Mist hung low over the Klamath river, softening the redwood shadows into wavering shapes. At first light, word passed quietly between houses. A canoe had been stolen in the night. It belonged to Hue Koi, a fisherman of standing whose family's claim to a bend in the river stretched back beyond memory. The canoe was not just wood it was access to salmon to trade to standing among men. By midday, Huay Koi's kin had named the culprits a small group from upriver led by a man named Pei Nol, who had long disputed fishing rights along that stretch. Some call it money, some call it other things. Many don't know what to call it and just ignore it as falling between
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
the cracks of today's financial categories.
Guy Swan
Whatever you call it, it's older than markets. Long before any efficient marketplace existed, people faced recurring high stakes transactions, tribute, inheritance, compensation for injury or death, reparations, bride price. Such crucial life events often arrive without warning in the form of a death, a crime, a conquest, a marriage. What is sometimes called money. What we shall, due to its oldest forms being partly alien to us, call collectibles distills and stores value, a desire shared across the vagaries of time and individuals with terse symbolism. Such objects can also communicate persistent rights and obligations. But the main function of collectibles is usually storing and on certain crucial occasions, transferring value, stitching together desires and events in space and in time. Three days later, as fog burned off the water, Hukoi's relatives moved upriver in narrow canoes. Faces were darkened with charcoal, not for concealment so much as resolve. They carried bows of yew, quivers of reed, arrows tipped with obsidian, and long knives at their waists. The problem is finding something the intended beneficiary would want. Whenever, unpredictably, the event happens, the moment arrives. That unpredictable event might be somebody else's desires, an exchange, but it often is instead a crucial event that calls for, among other responses, transfer of wealth. To stitch together the separated times and places of desires and events, an object must above all be be a good store of value. The objects best suited to perform such stitching are the most durable, divisible, and trust minimized among all objects Peoples before the ages of metal could make. Shells optimized these properties. The economist Karl Manger argued that money emerged from barter markets. He was correct to theorize that money, what we call collectibles, emerged naturally from the difficulty of matching desires to what one has available to transfer. But collectibles predate markets by tens of thousands of years. The problems they solved included the transfer of wealth during crucial life events, not just desires for goods and services, and were older and more important than the problem of inefficient trading. They landed near Panal's village at dawn. A dog barked, someone shouted. Then the air snapped with the sound of bowstrings. Arrows struck the walls of plank houses thudded into posts, shattered against stones. One man fell near the waterline, clutching his thigh. Another staggered back with a shaft through his shoulder. Painal himself emerged with a shield of elk hide, calling for his men to hold their ground. The many needs to stitch together desires and events in time and space, along with the ability to do so with durable and trust minimized objects, leads to cultures evolving something that carries value across time and space. Objects valued by some for practical or even superficial reasons can evolve into objects deeply valued by all in a culture for their stitching ability. The clash lasted less than an hour. By evening, the talking began. Elders and skilled speakers met on a gravel bar between the villages, a place neutral enough to hold anger without igniting it. The wounded were named. The canoe was discussed. Voices rose, then steadied. Each side counted its losses not only in blood but in standing. Each fact carried weight. At last Panal spoke differently. He did not yield the argument, but he shifted its ground. He offered payment, not as admission of guilt but as a way to end the matter. From a deerskin bundle, his relatives brought out strings of dentalium shells. Long, pale, carefully graded by length and perfection, they gleamed softly in the fading light. Shells and, much later, precious metals strung into necklaces for safe storage and easy division, stitched together events and desires not because any leader decreed them valuable, but because their scarcity and their durability made them perpetually ready and on hand when struck. Everybody came to find that valuable. Many other kinds of durable and trust minimized. Objects have evolved into collectibles, but shells were the most common. On a gravel bar between the two villages, shells were measured against forearm tattoos and counted aloud. Longer shells for the injury, additional strands for the insult, a final measure for the disturbance of peace. Huay Koi's family conferred in low voices the amount was not small. It acknowledged harm without surrendering pride. Finally, Wei Koy lifted the strings so all could see and nodded. The canoe was returned. The reparations had been paid. The war was over.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
Marriage is a moment of promises and
Guy Swan
transfers, of alliances, of risks, of.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
Of futures.
Guy Swan
In most traditional cultures, when two families negotiated a marriage, what changed hands was not merely property, but alliance, risk, expectation, and obligation across generations. The bride price or bride wealth was a recognition that something of irreplaceable value was moving from one kin group to another, and that this movement created obligations which needed to be embodied in something tangible, something that could not be argued away or forgotten. Collectibles served this purpose because people of a culture valued them. Everyone in Yoruk society, for example, knew what a dentalia shell of a given length and quality was worth. A death arrives, the body cools, Tools, ornaments, names, roles of authority, rights and obligations of many sorts were needed to persist in the next generation. Hopes and fears for the departed soul and grief by and for the living deprived of their loved one arrive right alongside conflict over these rights and obligations to simplify, to satisfy, to reduce the chances of conflict. The best thing to leave behind is not the tools of one's particular life, but rather what everyone wants. The collectibles valued by all the wounded were treated by their respective shamans, and their families expressed their gratitude to these holy women in Dentalia shells. In the season that followed, Penal sold his claim to the disputed fishing site outright. Denominated, as usual in Dentalia. The same shells that had ended the violence now completed the transaction the violence had been about. It is not markets that made money possible. It is collectibles, which we now call money, that make markets possible. For a good store of value, the liquidity of markets is nice to have. It is not essential. Money is instead essential for efficient markets. The most important arguments being made for bitcoin today are probably over a hundred millennia old collectibles which when used in today's markets we call money, can take many of the desires people have throughout life, along with its hardest problems and greatest opportunities, death, conflict, marriage, and make them virtually coincide, stitch them together in time and space. They transfer value across space and time from one set of events and desires to another. All right, that wraps up the piece.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
Fantastic little write up by Nick Szabo always has a way with his explanations and I love the little interspersed story to just kind of show demonstrate its purpose in a very visceral way. Anybody who's listened to the show for any amount of time knows that I just absolutely love a good hint or touch on a story like a real story, not a, not a simple explanation. I think it portrays the reality of the situation much cleaner because you know, it's one thing to explain how something is derived from a market and use a bunch of jargon. It's another thing to understand in practical reality in and occurrences that actually happened, events that actually occurred. How did these things play a role?
Guy Swan
What role did they play? And there was one line in this
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
that I have tried to hit on so many different times. And this is about as succinctly and
Guy Swan
cleanly as you can put it. Quote it is not markets that made money possible. It is collectibles, which we now call money that make markets possible.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
I cannot stress this more stringently.
Guy Swan
We've referenced back to Carl Menger and
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
the age old explanation that people give all the time that money arose from
Guy Swan
the problem of barter.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
And then there is also the idea of, you know, Mises and the regression theorem that essentially money always went back to some specific thing with some specific utility that had liquidity in the market. But this actually doesn't stand up to
Guy Swan
the test of history from actually looking
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
at how markets evolve.
Guest or Additional Commentator
And the thing is you can't have markets. They don't actually work.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
They're so barter is so inefficient that
Guest or Additional Commentator
it's not even a real market.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
It doesn't arise out of barter being really efficient.
Guest or Additional Commentator
Barter never becomes a market or a real system of any consequence at all until you have a medium and it makes perfect sense. A market is literally built on and is only possible because of inter exchange liquidity. The, the ability and the volume of exchange between different goods such that you can actually maintain, you can create a
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
price and you can create agreements that aren't just instantaneous isolated agreements, but that there's some sense of larger picture of value.
Guest or Additional Commentator
It is explicitly in the trillions of individual communications and individual exchanges that the,
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
the sense of value, intersubjective value, value that is spread out amongst everyone, like what's the average so to speak, than
Guest or Additional Commentator
it even arises in the first place. Which means it's dependent on something with enough liquidity to actually make a market take place at all. Otherwise it's not a real market. All exchanges or any exchanges are personal and isolated. They're specific to you and the person you know, or they're a debt between you and someone else in your village or tightly within your own culture. And bridges between communities and cultures are essentially non existent.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
And this is What I've said about a free market as well is the
Guest or Additional Commentator
idea of a free market is about
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
genuine market signals where there is no systemic manipulation, where the independent exchanges and independent valuations of all of the participants actually drive the direction and the valuations.
Guy Swan
And in the market itself. You cannot have a free market without
Guest or Additional Commentator
sound money, because sound money is the only thing that enables to market to
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
actually communicate those valuations.
Guest or Additional Commentator
If you don't have that, you don't actually have a market. And if you don't have actual market information, you can't possibly have a free
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
market because it just, it begs the
Guest or Additional Commentator
question as to what is the market? How do you actually maintain the rules of the market? You have to have a set of rules for exchange, for valuation, for a monetary medium, for a base. Or no market can even exist, let alone a free market, whatever that might even mean.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
In the absence of any legitimate market signal being able to spread through, it
Guest or Additional Commentator
just, it just becomes inefficient.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
It just becomes one that cannot sustain
Guy Swan
large groups of people.
Guest or Additional Commentator
And that's why millions of people usually starve. And it's just kind of a matter of time. Consequences of fiat money are not arbitrary or, you know, 50, 50, they, they are universally one. There's, there's one consequence, there's one way that the money dies. There is one direction that the money goes. If you can corrupt the money, you will destroy the society because there is no market that can be sustained on top of it. The soundness of the money comes before
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
the existence and the security and the
Guy Swan
fragility or the anti fragility of the market itself.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
And note, I think a lot of people will probably see this in the context of like, oh, store of value versus medium of exchange. And I think that's the wrong way to think about the argument that Szabo is making here. It's that store of value comes before medium of exchange makes any sense. As I've said again dozens of times, I don't even know how many times on this show. The evolution or the adoption of money
Guest or Additional Commentator
is a path dependent thing. And for something to exchange value, it
Guy Swan
must first store it.
Guest or Additional Commentator
It doesn't make any sense for the second market to ever actually evolve if the first one isn't settled.
Guy Swan
It is the liquidity of a store of value asset and the capacity to
Guest or Additional Commentator
exchange it that enables it to become
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
a medium of exchange.
Guest or Additional Commentator
But it can't be a medium of exchange and it certainly can't be a unit of account until it has enough
Guy Swan
liquidity as a store of value. This is why, despite the fact that
Guest or Additional Commentator
fees on the bitcoin network are still
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
one satoshi per V byte on a regular basis. And there has been no indicator like we've talked forever about, you know, when bitcoin's this price, fees will be this
Guest or Additional Commentator
price or whatever, whatever that I still
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
don't think that I'm still not bearish on the idea of Bitcoin being used
Guy Swan
for exchange, even though there is no
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
hard data to suggest that fees will just keep going up until, you know, the security of the network is dealt
Guest or Additional Commentator
with because we simply aren't in the
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
medium of exchange phase.
Guest or Additional Commentator
And I think there will be a
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
quote unquote phase shift in how Bitcoin is used in the, in the main Bitcoin infrastructure and what is being done with it. And I don't know when that occurs, but I think it's intuitive that that is an inevitable occurrence and it will probably screw up everything. We'll have built so much infrastructure around one type of use or one way of expectation about the network that so much of it will break or our
Guy Swan
assumptions will break about it. Like it will be insanely disruptive when it occurs.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
And this is why I think fee
Guest or Additional Commentator
spikes are actually good.
Guy Swan
Because they are stress tests to what
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
I believe will eventually be the norm, so to speak. And I could be wrong and this conversation could change drastically based on the data that occurs maybe in the next 10 year period. But I still see that there's a natural evolutionary step in the market of bitcoin that feels inevitable to me. And it doesn't seem, it doesn't counter that narrative or that mental model to me for the situation to have been the way that it has been for as long as it has been. Because the mental model doesn't really rely on any particular time frame. And I think there's always that simple reality that we overestimate what will happen in the next year and greatly underestimate what can happen in 10 years. So anyway, great piece. Fantastic little story throughout that I thought was just a really fun structure. And I'm glad to see Zabo writing again because I'm a huge fan of his work. His blog, Unenumerated. We've done many, many pieces by Nick Szabo. I've read many, many more that I don't have in audio. And honestly, which I should have in audio. Probably the best resource there is, the Nakamoto Institute, shout out to those guys. And they're actually in some really, really interesting projects right now, believe it or not, on archiving and becoming like A very explicit y' all should check out. In fact, I might. Damn, this one might actually be worth doing a show on, because I had a really interesting conversation at bitblogboom about what they are doing. And I might hit back up Carlos from Simple Proof and Goldstein and really kind of dig into what's happening over at the Nakamoto Institute because there's some really, really cool stuff and there's a fascinating little, I guess, quote, unquote play or idea about how they're extending themselves into an official archive role and what that means from a. From the context of literally archivists and librarians and historians and stuff all over. Because it's not. It's not. So it's not really the simplicity of, oh, we just. We're just becoming certified in a thing. It's actually far more expansive and far more interactive with other people in that space than I had realized something like that might be, because they essentially have the opportunity to establish an entirely new standard for what good archiving is, particularly
Guy Swan
in the digital age with.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
In the era of AI and the era of, you know, fake news everywhere and all of that stuff. There's actually. There's actually a really fascinating unlock that I think they're on to something and they've been doing things quietly that I hope they'll start being public about very soon. But it's a. It was a fascinating conversation and kind of opened up some doors and windows that I had never really considered of. Oh, there's this. You know, there's these other.
Guy Swan
There's all these little worlds that have their own standards and their own ancient
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
histories and ways of doing things that have been established for a long time. And bitcoin plays a role in so many that we just kind of dismiss. We're like, oh, well, it's a. It's finance, right? It's investment, it's savings. And we forget just how many different things Touch are touched by the bitcoin technology. And having an independent time chain like this, actually great opportunity to shout out the Time Chain Summit. Hope to see you guys in Colorado. I will be there. I will be giving a presentation. So shout out to anybody who is going. If you're not going and you're going to be in the area, definitely do. I will try to have the link to that in the show notes. If you haven't gotten tickets and you want to go, let's hang out. I'll see at the Time Chain Summit. And on that note, I have to
Guest or Additional Commentator
prepare and I have to get a
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
couple more episodes done. So we will close this one out. Thank you so much for listening. A shout out to Jan3. Another fantastic shout out to Bitbox, the Bitbox 02 and the Bitbox 02 Nova, their latest edition that works with all mobile platforms.
Guest or Additional Commentator
Natively.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
Super stoked. Fantastic little hardware wallet. And I have a discount code right down in the show notes just for you guys. And with that, I will catch you on the next episode of Bitcoin.
Guy Swan
Audible. Follow me.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
Follow Nick Szabo, follow Jan3, follow Bitbox. And until next time, I am Guy Swan. And that is my two sats.
Guy Swan
There's always a story.
Bitcoin Audible Co-host
It's all stories, really.
Guy Swan
The sun coming up every day is a story. Everything's got a story in it. Change the story, change the world. Terry Pratchett, A Hat Full of Sky.
"The Fabric of Desires" by Nick Szabo
Host: Guy Swann
Date: May 8, 2026
This episode features Guy Swann reading and analyzing Nick Szabo’s first new article in nearly a decade, “The Fabric of Desires.” The episode explores the origins of money, challenging common narratives by explaining how early collectibles — long before formal markets existed — stitched together social obligations, value, and essential events across time. Guy and his co-host emphasize the primacy of a good store of value as fundamental for the emergence of markets and unpack the deep implications of Szabo’s argument for both economic theory and the evolution of Bitcoin.
| Timestamp | Segment | |-----------|----------------------------------------------| | 01:20 | Introduction to Nick Szabo’s work and article | | 03:26 | Beginning of the read: The Fabric of Desires (Szabo’s story) | | 04:21 | Szabo on “collectibles” as the origin of money | | 06:58 | Story reaches resolution with shell payment | | 09:44 | The role of collectibles in marriage, inheritance | | 11:35 | The central thesis: collectibles make markets possible | | 13:35 | Guy’s highlight and commentary on Szabo’s line | | 14:12 | Critique of barter and classic economic theory| | 16:33 | Importance of sound money for free markets | | 18:03 | Store of value before medium of exchange logic| | 19:39 | Bitcoin’s current phase and future transition | | 22:00 | Praise for Szabo’s storytelling; Nakamoto Institute | | 24:49 | Closing and shoutouts | | 25:33 | Closing quote from Terry Pratchett |
[25:33] Guy Swan (quoting Terry Pratchett):
“The sun coming up every day is a story. Everything’s got a story in it. Change the story, change the world.”
A must-listen for anyone curious about Bitcoin’s philosophical and historical foundations, and why truly sound money is essential for a healthy market — not the other way around.