Blank Check with Griffin & David

Avatar: Fire and Ash (December 21, 2025)

Episode Overview

In this lively, several-hour episode, Griffin Newman and David Sims (plus guests Ben Mankiewicz and Marie Mareno) dissect James Cameron's latest behemoth, Avatar: Fire and Ash. Continuing their "decade of dreams" miniseries and their tradition of exhaustive auteurist filmography coverage, the hosts break down what they deem the sexiest, most chaotic, and thematically messy of the three Avatar films. The conversation weaves between detailed plot analysis, Cameron’s career, personal anecdotes, worldbuilding glee, and their recurring awe at how Cameron pulls off “the hottest creature that could ever exist” and massive, all-consuming cinematic universes.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Personal Chaos and Holiday Travels

• 00:09–09:47: The episode opens with the hosts swapping horror stories about post-Thanksgiving travel—vomiting children, peeing cats, and seeing which dad had it worse. The section showcases the team’s typical, familial banter and sets up running jokes about resilience, totems, and parenthood.
  • Quote: "Especially if you want to drive three small children to Boston on Thanksgiving weekend, be my guest. ...It was a f***ing nightmare." — David Sims (01:15)

2. James Cameron’s Career & the “Blank Check” Phenomenon

• 09:04–12:24: Transition to Cameron as the ultimate "Blank Check" director, with three films (Titanic, Avatar, Avatar: Way of Water) amongst the all-time box office top five.
  • Quote: “He is also currently the only person with three of the ten highest-grossing films of all time. ...Big Jim Cameron, the deepest director alive, has returned and graced us with another installment.” — Ben Mankiewicz (09:12)

3. Initial Reactions to 'Fire and Ash'

• 12:24–15:18: All hosts adored the new film, immediately noting how overwhelming and difficult Cameron’s Avatar sequels are to process on first viewing, despite their surface-level “simplicity.” They jokingly warn off haters and set expectations: this episode is all about celebrating the film.
  • Quote: “If you don’t like [Avatar], you should just not listen to this episode.” — Ben Mankiewicz (15:18)
• 15:18–19:05: Discussion of the Pandora setting, horny Na’vi, and the meme-ification of the franchise’s sexiness.
  • Memorable moment: General agreement that this is "the sexiest Avatar" and that the Na’vi are now officially "hotter than ever." (16:13–17:24)

4. Ponytail Sex, Avatar Lore, and Consent

• 17:24–18:49: Deep dive into the metaphysics and mechanics of Na’vi ponytail-bonding, drawing a parallel to ‘His Dark Materials’ and the intimacy/violation of the “queue.”
  • Quote: “It’s like… you’re not supposed to do that. That’s like against natural Na’vi law.” — David Sims (18:37)

5. Colonel Quaritch: From Stock Villain to Franchise Keystone

• 19:08–21:26: Huge praise for Stephen Lang’s Miles Quaritch as one of film’s “great” villains, charting his progression from straightforward bad guy to Cameron’s Darth Vader figure.
  • Quote: “And these two sequels, Way of Water and Fire and Ash, explore [the question of a human soul resurrected into a Na’vi body]… That is the thread they explore that is the most fascinating to me.” — David Sims (20:23)

6. Thematic Complexity Beneath 'Broad' Tropes

• 21:26–22:56: Pushback on criticisms that Avatar is “simple” or “broad,” arguing the worldbuilding, hybridization themes, and weirdness elevate it above surface-level readings.

7. Major Plot Developments in 'Fire and Ash'

• 24:01–27:38: The crew tries to organize the plot’s key breakthroughs:
  • Spider becomes a Na’vi/human hybrid, representing a new stage for humans on Pandora (24:17–24:50).
  • Natiri’s growing resentment of Spider, post-family tragedy.
  • The emergence of "bad Na’vi"—clans who reject Eywa (25:43–26:18).
  • Introduction of drugs in the world (27:38–28:45): Quaritch gets high in a trippy, sexy ritual.
    • Quote: “Quaritch gets stoned and [Varang] blows up his nose and then his pony braid hard.” — Ben Mankiewicz (28:09)
    • “And one assumes also his dick hard.” — David Sims (28:13)

8. Structural & Serial Nature of the Sequels

• 29:03–30:47: Fire and Ash is conceptualized as part two of a mid-saga duology, the middle chapter of a trilogy-turned-saga, with Cameron’s ambitions ballooning the story into multiple films.
  • Quote: “What was originally supposed to be the second film… got so unwieldy that it became two films.” — Ben Mankiewicz (30:03)

9. James Cameron’s Longevity and Process

• 33:09–37:14: Candid discussion of interviews with Cameron. He jokes about having 30–40 years left to make movies, his friendships (Guillermo del Toro, Elon Musk), and rational, nuanced takes on AI. Cameron’s production method—years with actors, then years in post—is dissected.
  • Memorable moment: “Best case scenario, what? I only have 30 or 40 years left in me.” — James Cameron, paraphrased by Ben Mankiewicz (33:15)

10. Avatar’s Attitude Toward AI and Digital Production

• 37:22–39:55: Hosts recall the "no AI" pre-film message, Cameron’s nuanced take on generative vs. Skynet-style AI, and his concern that audiences now assume everything is digital or synthetic.
  • Quote: “He was like, there’s generative AI… And he basically was just like, the film industry is collapsing. These movies are getting too expensive…” — Ben Mankiewicz (38:30)

11. Navigating the Plot, Big Set Pieces, and World Elements

• 40:14–47:00: Attempts to summarize the sprawling narrative:
  • How the “simple” structure belies dense character, ecological, and political subplots.
  • Jake's arc is somewhat sidelined for Lo'ak’s narration and for focus on Spider’s existential journey (44:05–46:08).
  • Multiple characters' arcs and shifting perspectives build toward an emotionally fragmented center.

12. Avatar's Political/Ecological Allegory, Worldbuilding, and Human Villains

• 55:58–63:48:
  • Anti-human stance: “One of the most incredible things about this franchise is how firmly anti-human it is.” — Ben Mankiewicz (61:21)
  • Expanded worldbuilding: the three laws of Eywa, why the Na’vi eschew stone, wheels, and metals, and how each tribal group relates to their environment (56:34–57:58).

13. Humans as Villains, Expansion Toward Earth, and Broader Context

• 63:54–67:53:
  • The reputation of Jake Sully as an “Edward Snowden” or “Benedict Arnold” figure.
  • Cameron's reflected belief that we should "save Earth" rather than colonize other planets (66:00–67:44).

14. Appeal, Worldbuilding, and the Mythic/Biblical Epic Quality

• 81:02–84:45: The hosts liken Cameron’s Avatar saga to classic biblical and epic cinema, noting his preference for simple, elemental stories bolstered by “insane,” original worldbuilding.
  • Quote: “[Cameron’s] making insane original sci fi versions of what used to be the biblical epic.” — Ben Mankiewicz (83:07)

15. Grief, Loss, and Real-World Parallels

• 84:28–86:06: The death of John Landau (longtime Cameron collaborator) and real-world tragedies (Titan sub disaster) breed a deeper meditation on grief in the film. The theme of losing a brother/family member is especially resonant.

16. Vivid Tangents and Running Jokes

• 87:00–92:00: Wild digressions about toys, parenting, Swarm/Red Hulk, and Spidey-dinosaur LEGOs serve as comedy breaks and insight into the hosts’ personal lives.

17. Varang and “Bad Na’vi”: New Franchise Icons

• 103:03–114:43: Detailed discussion of the new antagonist Varang (played by Una Chaplin), the design of the Ash people, the “Joker and Harley Quinn” dynamic of Varang and Quaritch, and the intensity of their mutual attraction.
  • Quote: “Quaritch and Varang are now officially my Joker and Harley Quinn.” — Ben Mankiewicz (110:54)
• Exploration of what makes Varang compelling: her rule-breaking, punk energy, and the cultural implications of Na’vi who fall outside Eywa’s influence.

18. Spider: The Divisive Key to the Movie

• 119:14–121:36: The trio discuss Spider’s arc and Jack Champion’s performance, with ambivalence about the character acting as both a narrative lynchpin and an audience surrogate.

19. Payakan, Whale Stuff, and the Tulkun's Role

• 124:00–126:08: The role of Payakan, the pariah Tulkun, in catalyzing Na’vi resistance and representing “outcast” strength in the face of pacifist cultural norms.

20. Narrative Choices, Character Arcs, and Open Endings

• 125:29–153:32: The hosts debate whether the lack of a definitive conclusion is a feature or flaw—seeing the middle-entry messiness as a byproduct of Cameron’s ambition. Avatars' evolving approach to serial storytelling, cut comic material, and the ongoing dilemma of Cameron’s timeline are explored.

21. Box Office Prognostication & the State of the Blockbuster

• 157:19–161:01: With a winking look at real and invented 2025 blockbusters, they predict Fire and Ash’s box office fate, its competition with other holiday films, and bemoan “holiday squeeze” scheduling.

22. Final Thoughts and Fandom Reflections

• 142:47–149:11: Despite its craziness, the hosts love the Avatar world, savoring Cameron’s “all-you-can-eat buffet” and likening the franchise to the Rainforest Café: “You’re either in, or you’re not.”

  • Quote: “I like everything they make at this restaurant. And if you don't like this restaurant...it’s your fault for going through the door.” — Ben Mankiewicz (142:03)

Notable Quotes & Moments (with Timestamps)

• On Quaritch’s Arc:
  “It’s so much weirder when people knock these movies for being broad and simplistic... that’s the foundation. And then on top of that, James Cameron does the weirdest shit in the world.”
  — Ben Mankiewicz (20:23)

• On Avatar as Anti-Human:
  “One of the most incredible things about this franchise is how firmly anti-human it is.”
  — Ben Mankiewicz (61:21)

• On Ponytail Sex, Consent, and New Lore:
  “This movie really explores new territory in terms of pony braid fucking... both consensual and non-consensual.”
  — Ben Mankiewicz (17:42)

• On Cameron’s Process and Persona:
  “Best case scenario, what? I only have 30 or 40 years left in me. That’s a good case scenario, my friend.”
  — as recalled by Ben Mankiewicz (33:15)

• On Avatar’s Serial Structure:
  “What was originally supposed to be the second film in his planned trilogy got so unwieldy that it became two films.”
  — Ben Mankiewicz (30:03)

• On Fandom and Franchise Worldbuilding:
  “People like, it’s the thing that happens every time an Avatar movie comes out where they're like, that looks dumb. Then they go see it and they're like, leaning forward in their seat, and then six months later, they're like, that sucks.”
  — Ben Mankiewicz (81:43)

Episode Segments (Selected Timestamps)

• 00:09–09:47: Banter, travel woes, and introduction.
• 09:47–12:24: James Cameron’s blank check status.
• 12:24–15:18: First reactions to Fire and Ash, warning off naysayers.
• 17:24–19:05: Ponytail sex, worldbuilding, consent.
• 20:23–22:56: Quaritch as the franchise’s Darth Vader.
• 27:38–28:45: The “drugs” sequence, Quaritch gets high.
• 29:03–30:47: Film structure and middle-chapter status.
• 33:15: Cameron’s “I have 30–40 years left” interview moment.
• 61:21: Discussion of how anti-human the series is.
• 119:14–121:36: Spider's arc and performance.
• 125:29–153:32: Serial structure, comics tie-ins, the future of the franchise.
• 157:19–161:01: Predictions for box office and 2025 movie landscape.
• 142:03: The Rainforest Cafe/Avatar restaurant metaphor.
• 166:36–167:54: Announcements of upcoming miniseries (Lynne Ramsay & Peter Weir) and sign off.

Conclusion

The episode is both an exuberant celebration and serious defense of James Cameron's deeply ambitious, weird, and unwieldy Avatar universe. The hosts underscore that, for all its bloat and wild tonal swings, Fire and Ash raises the bar for blockbuster invention, worldbuilding, and emotional throughlines, even as it loses some control. The film’s serialized structure, ecological/genealogical themes, the introduction of new villain Varang, and the increasingly transgressive, sexy, and anti-human tone are dissected with loving precision.

For fans of Blank Check, Cameron, or blockbuster cinema at large, this episode is an essential, entertaining listen—so long as you don’t mind hearing the phrase “pony braid fucking” and wrestling with the “totemic” debates (soon to be retired in 2026).

Select Closing Quotes

• "Thank you all. For riding with us. Our clan. This podcast is a fortress." — Ben Mankiewicz (167:02)
• “I think you have to admit, a pretty potent podcast.” — Ben Mankiewicz (169:44)
• "Oh, no shit. No shit." — David Sims/Ben Mankiewicz (169:50)

End of 2025. See you in 2026!