Podcast Summary: Blank Check with Griffin & David – "Miller's Crossing with Ari Aster"

Podcast Information:

• Title: Blank Check with Griffin & David
• Hosts: Griffin Newman and David Sims
• Guest: Ari Aster
• Episode: Miller's Crossing with Ari Aster
• Release Date: July 27, 2025
• Produced by: Ben Hosley

Introduction

In this engaging episode of Blank Check with Griffin & David, hosts Griffin Newman and David Sims welcome acclaimed filmmaker Ari Aster to discuss the Coen Brothers' cult classic, "Miller's Crossing." The episode delves deep into the film’s intricate narrative, stylistic elements, character dynamics, and its place within the Coen Brothers' illustrious filmography.

Overview of "Miller's Crossing"

Griffin Newman kicks off the conversation by referencing the film’s opening line about ethics:

"That's the opening line of the movie." ([00:31])

The hosts set the stage by explaining that "Miller's Crossing" is not just another entry in the Coens' filmography but a complex exploration of loyalty, betrayal, and moral ambiguity within a gangster framework.

Themes and Symbolism

A significant portion of the discussion centers around the film's exploration of ethics and friendship. David Sims emphasizes:

"It's about ethics and game journalism. That's what this movie's about, right?" ([01:45])

However, Ari Aster offers a nuanced take, suggesting that while ethics are a surface theme, the film delves deeper into the complexity of human relationships and the moral decisions characters must navigate.

A recurring symbol in the film is the hat, which serves as a motif for status and vulnerability. David Sims reflects:

"The hat is a symbolic representation of one's standing in the world." ([52:29])

This symbolism is further explored when Ari Aster notes:

"The hat doesn't represent anything. It's a hat blown by the wind." ([50:19])

This duality showcases the Coens' mastery in embedding layers of meaning within seemingly simple elements.

Character Analysis and Performances

Gabriel Byrne's portrayal of Tom Reagan is lauded for its stoic yet emotionally charged performance. Ari Aster praises Byrne:

"He really didn't ask for any of this... He just... he's very, very wonderful." ([63:43])

John Polito's role as a volatile and cunning enforcer is another highlight. Griffin Newman shares:

"Polito is one of the best actors to ever do it, you know?" ([67:57])

The chemistry between the characters, especially the dynamic between Tom and Leo (played by Albert Finney), underscores the film’s central themes of loyalty and betrayal. David Sims observes:

"Tom Reagan is a stoic who seems to be a brilliant improviser." ([41:08])

The guest, Ari Aster, adds depth by discussing how Finney's last-minute casting elevated the character:

"It is astonishing that he didn't get a supporting actor nomination." ([68:04])

Coen Brothers’ Stylistic Choices and Influences

The Coen Brothers' distinctive visual style and dialogue are dissected, with David Sims noting:

"Their films are immaculately made, very designed." ([78:04])

Griffin Newman compares their work to that of Alfred Hitchcock and Stanley Kubrick, emphasizing their attention to detail and rhythmic pacing:

"They feel like the true successors to Hitchcock... Their sense of humor is something between misanthropic and Jewish." ([80:33])

The influence of Dashiell Hammett and classic noir is evident in the film's narrative structure and character archetypes. The discussion highlights how "Miller's Crossing" pays homage to these genres while infusing the Coens' unique storytelling techniques.

Production Insights and Behind-the-Scenes

The episode provides a peek into the production challenges faced during the making of "Miller's Crossing." Ari Aster recounts:

"They couldn't keep up with Mink's dialogue. They started dropping every other sentence because they weren't going to attempt to do this." ([07:44])

The transition from Trey Wilson to Albert Finney is explored, showcasing the Coens' adaptability and commitment to authentic performances:

"They had to get Finney on set within a week after Wilson's untimely death." ([47:43])

Filming locations, particularly the choice of New Orleans for its classic architecture, are discussed as pivotal in establishing the film’s period-specific atmosphere.

Ari Aster’s Perspectives and Filmmaking Philosophy

Ari Aster shares his admiration for the Coens and how "Miller's Crossing" has influenced his own work. He emphasizes the importance of tone management and subtle character development:

"Miller's Crossing is an exercise in tone management... Polito is doing a different size performance than everyone else in this movie." ([108:57])

Aster reflects on his own directing style, drawing parallels between the Coens' meticulous planning and his approach to creating emotionally resonant narratives.

Symbolism and Thematic Depth

The hat motif is dissected further as a symbol of respect and power. David Sims connects it to broader societal hierarchies:

"The central tension of this movie is, can you do something that breaks the gentlemanly nature of crime?" ([54:07])

The discussion delves into how minor gestures, like the manipulation of a hat, can signify grander themes of power dynamics and ethical dilemmas within the criminal underworld.

Legacy and Critical Reception

Griffin Newman and David Sims discuss the film’s initial reception and its enduring legacy. They highlight how early criticisms have given way to widespread acclaim:

"Raising Arizona was barely 10 years later, it had gone from overwritten stuff to one of the 50 best American comedies ever made." ([34:14])

The hosts reflect on how "Miller's Crossing" serves as a bridge between the Coens' earlier, more comedic works and their later, critically acclaimed films like "Fargo." The film's craftsmanship and thematic richness are celebrated as key reasons for its lasting impact.

Key Takeaways and Conclusion

The episode wraps up with a comprehensive appreciation of "Miller's Crossing" as a testament to the Coen Brothers' ability to blend genre homage with original storytelling. Ari Aster underscores the film’s role in shaping modern cinema’s approach to complex character studies and ethical narratives.

David Sims concludes:

"Miller's Crossing is such a successful tribute that I put it with those classic gangster films. It fits into the essence of the genre while standing out as a meticulously crafted piece of art." ([58:49])

The hosts express their enthusiasm for future discussions, ensuring listeners that the deep dive into the Coens' filmography will continue with more insightful episodes.

Notable Quotes

• Griffin Newman [00:33]: “I was trying to see if there was a hi hat; it's my favorite thing in this movie.”

• Ari Aster [00:36]: “I think people need to say that more.”

• David Sims [41:08]: “He seems to be a brilliant improviser.”

• Ari Aster [50:19]: “It's an image that came to us that we like.”

• Griffin Newman [65:00]: “The sound design, the pacing, it's like it's underwater.”

• David Sims [54:07]: “The central tension of this movie is, can you do something that breaks the gentlemanly nature of crime?”

• Ari Aster [108:57]: “Polito is doing a different size performance than everyone else in this movie.”

Final Thoughts

This episode of Blank Check with Griffin & David offers a rich, multifaceted exploration of "Miller's Crossing," blending enthusiastic analysis with expert insights from Ari Aster. Whether you're a seasoned film aficionado or new to the Coen Brothers' work, this discussion provides a comprehensive understanding of the film's enduring significance in cinematic history.